itatatenale e,
ata
Sopa
a εἴ κ᾽
ΤΟΣΟΣ
οἷ δὲ
οι δὴν
τ δ OEE (ΩΣ
ba Ca telnet 4 4S
bh ζει Satz 2 74)
οἱ
Cs
Σ
Ἢ
Seeseeht
>
iS<$
ese {4.4
esas ra Ps, >
Me Seteee) >, ipeees
>P>2> ἐξέ ςς > be ἐς
eSaseees ἐπεί τος ¢ S454
; ΤΡ:
ΤΣ kK Dpppor'
ῬΡΣΎΡΙ
aes?
>>
eseses
ἮΝ
ἽΝ
eT, xs ex o
5 SSeS ἐς
Sasesatesere
ὃ
=
Spee
“a
a
>;
x
ete
roe
ma
ated
e4ees
BD
seeeseeet ἌΡ λον»
Bo Pers bs bbe Pha Ps!
PEDSPEDEP yD See E eta coe pep.
SEES SRE os
ἐέος ἐς ἐς ες ἐν ἐφ εξεξεζε
ὌΣΣΕ are?
ἰφξεξεύς $e ες
Sets
5).
SeSese3
ἐπέ ξεςε
>
>>:
Dy >a Ps
ϑι
ΡΘΗ
ἐξέ
>:
Sess
$
es
ΕΣ
4 Sates
ἐς ἐς ἐς EoD PraPyry Pare? (SEER ES
ἱ εἰς ἐς ἐς ἐς εξ ς ἐφ ζέξεςς PS? ἐς ἐξ εἰς ἐςἐς ἐς ξές ls ες ἐς ςὸς SES
τες εἰ ς.ς( etrtstete Parse >>: q
> aPbe , ἐξέ ες ; (ἐς
>
δ ἐς ςοςς
ete
setae
ἰεέφε ἐξέ εξ Se
PErphprgpgoes ses
ἯΙ ‘ > Ἂ >? ζ >
ἣν ἐν eaereete
ae Sete.
᾿
eee
(ες
ese
ae
Ah Akad
AK
aoe
aka
Nd
SEA EEE
τ ν σ᾽
Fry
KARALA:
τ;
γ'
Vy.
,
CMe
KEES
TNS
CLL:
τς
τ
ys
4"
j Lo
3
= rae
ΝΟ Os . -»
,,.»
‘
Ss .
é
.
.
f
θές»:
᾿ ΡΕΙΝΟΕΤΟΝ. Ν. J.
ΠΥ τ ea
@ | Part of the
¢ ADDISON XANDER LIBRARY,
| which was presented by |
Ὁ ΜΈΞΕΕ. L. anp A. Stuart.
ao
A
ἃ, ὦ
24
eee
τ
«Ομ σο των α
Jos. (olcl ion ΡΣ γ΄.
ἀρ fe. Loe.
78 ἊΣ ἴα σῇ lh a { ve Cs Te 4, iB os
liens J Mion (0 4 Ping toel{ “ slie OAV
AA ͵ ᾿Ξ ; TMG Chey COU μι ab oMr cal Ἶ
-ΞΞΕ .- 9 8.
THE
DIVINE LEGATION OF MOSES
DEMONSTRATED.
BY em REVEREND
WILLIAM’ WARBURTON, D.D.,
LORD BISHOP OF GLOUCESTER.
TO WHICH IS PREFIXED,
A DISCOURSE BY WAY OF GENERAL PREFACE:
CONTAINING SOME ACCOUNT OF THE LIFE, WRITINGS, AND CHARACTER OF
THE AUTHOR.
BY RICHARD HURD, D.D.,
LORD BISHOP OF WORCESTER.
THE TENTH EDITION, CAREFULLY REVISED.
IN THREE VOLUMES.
VO ΤΣ
LONDON:
PRINTED FOR THOMAS TEGG, 73, CHEAPSIDE..
MDCCCXLVI.
-ν- ; ' a -
LONDON : " =: ι
PRINTED BY JAMES NICHOLS, *, ae *
3 Ἢ
—-- HOXTON-SQUARE. “
᾿
ba
s ,
ΕΝ,
ἫΝ 1η
7 ἐξ
Sd ἐν
tei
‘ 3
2 MEN OF AT OL
. 4 , ,
ἐεδὲ ᾿ May? ᾿
“a Ἂν» ,
¢ ἐγ ea
"
CONTENTS.
od
BOOK III. CONTINUED.
SECTION
Page.
VI.—TueE atheistical pretence of religion’s being an invention of statesmen, and
therefore false, clearly confuted, and shewn to be both impertinent and false.
For that, was the Atheist’s account of religion right, it would not follow that
religion was false, but the contrary—But the pretence false and groundless,
religion having existed before the civil magistrate was in being ....--...... 1
Appendix, showing that the omission of a future state in the Mosaic dispensation
doth not make it unworthy of the original to which believers ascribe it.,.... 50
OLEH Rute Inder OOK taraieyale/olelaisiolvieieielvielireisisis,« cleisiaicie! cloves els ciesisiersisieriaee | OU,
DEDICATION OF BOOKS ἵν. v. vI. TO LORD MANSFIELD, 1765 ..........-- 84
DEDICATION TO THE Jews, 1740........ ΕΣ sraisls @ stelevelsrerserale sfait ἘΔ;
PREFACE TO BOOKS Iv. V. VI. 1740... .....-.0.0e το Ἐπ τὴς Ghog60d0 coodc605 HIE
RELA CE MOM TIE ΒΙΠΙΤΙΟΝ, ΟἿ᾽ 178, dete s ee cieicielne isc s.< eels cise eisteiorersieleereiertst OS
BOOK IV.
PROVES THE HIGH ANTIQUITY OF THE ARTS AND EMPIRE OF EGyPt; AND
THAT SUCH HIGH ANTIQUITY ILLUSTRATES AND CONFIRMS THE TRUTH
oF THE Mosaic HIsToRy ...... few see δϑορα ὦ S090 0600 6c Ἐπ. 190
SECTION
I.—Jntroduction, shewing that the universal Pretence to Revelation, proves the
“Truth of some, and particularly of the Jewish .......... sie ΕΠ eae Lor
i1.—Enters on the third Proposition—Some general reflections on the high anti-
quity of Egypt ; and ofthe equal extravagance of both parties in their attempts
44
foradvance or depress that antiquity τὸ τον. το sence seocccscscscvencsvase ἢ
I11.—The high antiquity of Egypt proved from Scripture—And from the ancient
Greek historians, supported and confirmed by Scripture—In the course of this
inquiry the rise and progress of the art of medicine is treated of and explained 149
IV.—The high antiquity of Egypt proved from their Hieroglyphics —Their nature,
original, and various kinds, explained— Proved to be the original of the art of
Onirocritics or interpretation of Dreams, and likewise of Brute-worship— In
this inquiry is contained the history of the various modes of information by
Speech and Writing—And of the various modes of ancient idolatry, in the
order they arose from one another ......... nisretste erellereicts ποτ τ τ ττν cou
V.—Sir Isaac Newton’s chronology of the Egyptian empire confuted, and shewn to
contradict all sacred and profane antiquity, and even the nature of things—In
the course of this Dissertation the causes of that infinite confusion in the
ancient Greek history and mythology are inquired into and explained -....-
V1I.—-Proves that Moses was skilled in all the learning of Egypt, and the Israelites
violently inclined to all their superstitions—That the Ritual Law was insti-
tuted partly in opposition to those superstitions, and partly in compliance to
the People’s prejudices—That neither that Ritual nor Moses’s Learning is
any objection to the divinity of his Mission—But a high confirmation of it—In
which Herman Witsius’ arguments to the contrary are examined and con-
futed ; and the famous Prophecy in the twentieth chapter of Ezekiel explained
and vindicated against the absurd interpretation of the Rabbins and Dr.
SHWCERfORd 2. See ee ee ee πο σον ὁ ὑὸ το 5711: .1.-| τες
2
Notes on the Fourth Book... ..ccceccncccccccccccevncnsnccccccsssscscces
46
iy CONTENTS.
BOOK ΚΓ.
Page.
THE NATURE OF THE JEWISH THEOCRACY EXPLAINED: AND THE DOCTRINE
OF A FUTURE STATE PROVED NOT TO BE IN, NOR TO MAKE PART OF,
HE, MOSAIC UDISPENSATION | (rato -creleeveieteratetensioteretalatsteterapete τ --.
SECTION
1.—Little light to be got from the systems of Christian writers, or the objections
of Deists, or from the Rabbins, or from the Cabalists, concerning the true
nature of the Jewish Republic—The Hebrew People separated from the rest of
mankind not as favourites, but to preserve the knowledge of the true God
amidst an idolatrous world—Vindicated from the calumnious falshoods of the
GEE E VOIEAITE Ne ΠΕΡ τς τς τς ἘΣ aieieoieielnieleretete tate raietet iors ate /etetal ste 418
1J.—Proves the Jewish Government to be a Theocracy—This form shewn to be
necessary—There being no other, by which opinions could be justly punished
by civil Laws—-And without such Laws against idolatry, the Mosaic
Religion could not be supported——The equity of punishing opinions under a
Theocracy, explained—Bayle censured—Foster confuted—-The Theocracy
easily introduced, as founded on a prevailing notion of tutelary Deities—An
objection of Mr. Collins to the truth of Revelation examined and confuted—
The easy introduction of the Theocracy, it is shewn, occasioned as easy a
defection from the Laws of it—The inquiry into the reason of this leads to an
explanation of the nature of the Jewish idolatry—Lord Bolingbroke’s accusa-
tion of the Law of Moses examined and exposed..... one ieleicle «lg.c'= slai\e a ΡῈ 555)
11].—Treats of the Duration of the Theocracy—Shewn to have continued till the
coming of Curist—The arguments of Spencer and Le Clerc to the contrary
examined—The Prophecy of Shiloh explained—The Bishop of London’s dis-
course upon it examined and confuted .......... 4 ρει ιβοσοίδε πο ὦ 2:
1V.—The Consequences of a Theocracy considered—Shewn that it must be
administered by an extraordinary Providence, equally dispensing temporal
Rewards and Punishments, both to the Community and to Particulars—That
Scripture gives this representation of Gop’s government—And that there are
many favourable circumstances in the character of the Jewish People, to
induce an impartial Examiner to believe that representation to be true ...... 489
For the remainder of the Contents of Book V. see the Contents of the third volume.
DIRECTIONS FOR PLACING THE PLATES IN THIS VOLUME.
Page.
Platesviy Τα ΠῚ eerie ἘΝ ΠΕΣ πε τ πο ΕΣ δύο Ε seicvoteg siesiete Oeics MLV
For Plate IV. which ought to appear in page 175, see page Ὁ 308, where it is
engraved with Plate X.
Plate sve rend: Vat eee. tac ceca ΤΕ seme eee es coe tee ee Ree πος τ}
—— VII. ..cccces
eeeeeveee ee ee Fees οὸ eeoert Poaceae eceeaeege yess νυ δ **eod 374
—— VIII. ought to appear in page 202; but it is conjoined with Plate IX. in page 235
-- TK Sate sem ΡΝ ΠΕ oe ae ene cone 00 se vee τ esse es MOUS
a
ἧς
THE
DIVINE LEGATION OF MOSES
DEMONSTRATED.
BOOK III.
SECTION VI.
i HAVE now gone through the second general proposition, which
is, THAT ALL MANKIND, ESPECIALLY THE MOST WISE AND
LEARNED NATIONS OF ANTIQUITY, HAVE CONCURRED IN BELIEV-
ING, AND TEACHING, THAT THE DOCTRINE OF A FUTURE STATE
OF REWARDS AND PUNISHMENTS WAS NECESSARY TO THE WELL-
BEING OF sociETY. In doing this, I have presumed to enter the
very Penetralia of Antiquity, and expose its most venerable secrets to
open day. Some parts of which having been accidentally and
obscurely seen by the owl-light of infidelity, were imagined by such
as Toland, Blount, and Coward (as is natural for objects thus seen by
false Braves), to wear strange gigantic forms of terror: and with
these they have endeavoured to disturb the settled piety of sober
Christians.
The ridiculous use these men have made of what they did not
understand, may perhaps recal te the reader’s mind that stale atheis-
tical objection, that RrLicion 15 ONLY A CREATURE OF POLITICS,
a State-engine invented by the Legislator, to draw the knot of Civil
Society more close. And the rather, because that objection being
founded on the apparent use of Religion to Civil Policy, I may be
supposed to have added much strength to it, by shewing in this
work, in a fuller manner than, perhaps, has been done before, the
EXTENT OF THAT UTILITY ; and the large sphere of the Legislator’s
agency, in the application of it.
For thus stood the case: I was to prove Moses’s divine assistance,
from his being ABLE to leave out of his Religion, the doctrine of a
future state. This required me to shew, that this doctrine was
naturally of the utmost importance to Society. But of , a
YOL. II. B
2 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK If.
ments, by which that importance may be proved, the plainest, if not
the strongest, is the conduct of Laweivers. Hence the long detail
of circumstances in the second and third books.
But indeed it not only served to the purpose of my particular
question, but, appeared to me, to be one of the least equivocal proofs
of the truth of Reticion in general; and to deserve, in that view
only, to be carefully examined and explained. I considered this part,
therefore, and desire the reader would so consider it, as a whole and
separate work of itself, to PROVE THE TRUTH OF RELIGION IN
GENERAL, FROM ITS INFINITE SERVICE TO HUMAN SOCIETY,
though it be but the zntroduction to the truth of the mosatc.
Let us examine it: Lawgivers have unanimously concurred in pro-
pagating Religion. This could be only from a sense and experience
of its uTiniry; in which they could not be deceived: Religion
therefore has a general utility. We desire no more to establish its
truth.
For, TRUTH AND GENERAL UTILITY NECESSARILY COINCIDE ;
that is, Truth is productive of Utility ; and Utility is indicative of
Truth. That truth is productive of utility, appears from the nature
of the thing. The observing truth, is acting as things really are:
he who acts as things really are, must gain his purposed end: all
disappointment proceeding from acting as things are not: Just as in
reasoning from true or false principles, the conclusion which follows
must be necessarily right or wrong. But gaining this end is utility
or happiness; disappointment of the end, hurt or misery. If then
Truth produce utility, the other part of the proposition, that utility
indicates truth, follows of necessity. For not to follow, supposes two
different kinds of GENERAL UTILITY relative to the same creature,
one proceeding from truth, the other from falshood ; which is impos-
sible ; because the natures of those utilities must then be different,
that is, one of them must, at the same time, be, and not be,
utility.* Wherever then we find general utility, we may certainly
know it for the product of Truth, which it indicates. But the practice
of Lawgivers shews us that this utility results from Religion, The
consequence is, that Reticion, or the idea of the relation between the
creature and the Creator, is true.
However, as the unanimous concurrence of Lawgivers to support
Religion, hath furnished matter for this poor infidel pretence, I shall
take leave to examine it more thoroughly.
Our Adversaries are by no means agreed amongst themselves :
Some of them have denied the truth of Religion, because it was of no
UTILITY ; Others, because it was of SO GREAT. But commend me to
the man, who, out of pure genuine spite to Religion, can employ
: * See note II, at the end of this book.
SECT. ‘VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED 3
e
these two contrary systems together, without the expense so much as
of a blush.* However, the System most followed, is the political
envention of Religion for its use : the other being only the idle exercise
of a few dealers in paradoxes.+
I have begun these volumes with an examination of the first of
these systems ; and shall now end them with a confutation of the
other. For the Unbeliever, driven from his first hold, by our shewing
the utility of religion, preposterously retires into this, in order to
recover his ground.
Critias of Athens, one of the thirty tyrants, and the most execra-
ble of the thirty, is at the head of this division ; whose principles he
delivers in the most beautiful Iambics.~ His words are to this
purpose: ‘There was a time when man lived like a savage, without
government or Laws, the minister and executioner of violence; wher
there was neither reward annexed to virtue, nor punishment attendant
upon vice. Afterwards, it appears, that men invented civil Laws to be
a curb to evil. From hence, Justice presided over the human race ;
force became a slave to right, and punishment irremissibly pursued
the transgressor. But when now the laws had restrained an open
violation of right, men set upon contriving, how to injure others,
in secret. And then it was, as I suppose, that some CUNNING POLI-
TICIAN, well versed in the knowledge of mankind, counterplotted
this design, by the invention of a principle that would hold wicked
men in awe, even when about to say, or think, or act ill in private.
And this was by bringing in the BeLier or A Gop; whom, he
taught to be immortal, of infinite knowledge, and of a nature super-
latively excellent. This God, he told them, could hear and see every
thing said and done by mortals here below: nor could the first con-
ception of the most secret wickedness he concealed from him, of
whose nature, knowledge was the very essence. Thus did our Port-
TICIAN, by inculcating these notions, become the author of a doctrine
wonderfully taking ; while he hid truth under the embroidered veil of
fiction. But to add servile dread to this impressed reverence, the
Gods, he told them, inhabited that place, which he found was the
repository of those Mormo’s, and panic terrors, which man was so dexte-
rous at feigning, and so ready to fright himself withal, while he adds
imaginary miseries to a life already over-burthened with disasters.
That place, I mean, where the swift coruscations of enkindled meteors,
accompanied with horrid bursts of thunder, run through the starry
vaults of heaven; the beautiful fret-work of that wise old Architect,
time. Where a social troop of shining orbs perform their regular
* See BLount’s Anima Mundi, and “ Original of Idolatry.” + Such as the
Author of Du Contract Social, ch. viii. p. 129. t See note KK, at the end of this
book.
Bee
4 THE DIVINE LEGATION * BOOK 111-
and benignant courses : and from whence refreshing showers descend
to recreate the thirsty earth. Such was the habitation he assigned
for the Gods ; a place most proper for the discharge of their func-
tion: And these the terrors he applied, to circumvent secret mischief,
stifle disorder in the seeds, give his Laws fair play, and introduce
Religion, so necessary to the magistrate.—This, in my opinion, was
the TRIcK, whereby mortal man was first brought to believe that
there were immortal Natures.”
How excellent a thing is justice! said somebody or other, on
observing it to be practised in the dens of thieves and robbers. How
useful, how necessary a thing is Religion! may we say, when it
forces this confession of its power, from its two most mortal enemies,
the Tyrant and the Atheist.
The account here given of RELIGION is, that it was A STATE
INVENTION: that is, that the idea of the relation between the crea-
ture and the Creator was formed and contrived by politicians, to keep
men in awe. From whence the Infidel concludes it to be visloNARY
and GROUNDLESS. From the Macistrare’s large share in the
Establishment of ancient national Religions, two consequences are
drawn ; the one by Believers ; the other by Undelievers. The First con-
clude that therefore these national Religions were of political original :
and this the ancient Fathers of the Church spent much time and
pains to prove. The Second conclude, from the same fact, that there-
fore Religion in general, or the idea of the relation between the crea-
ture and the Creator, was a politic invention, and not founded in the
nature of things. And if, in confuting this, I strengthen and sup-
port the other conclusion, I suppose, that, in so doing, I give addi-
tional strength to the cause of Revelation ; otherwise the Futhers
were very much mistaken. And though Infidels, indeed, in their
writings, affect to dwell upon this conclusion, “ that Superstition was
a State-invention ;” it is not, I presume, on account of any service,
which they imagine it can do their cause; but because it enables
them to strike obliquely, under that cover, at Religion in general,
when they do not care to appear without their mask. But if ever
they should take it into their heads to deny, that there is any better
proof of Superstition’s being a mere politic invention than that Reli-
gion in general is so, let them take notice that I have here answered
them beforehand. On the whole, then, if I prove that Religion in
general was not a politic invention, I enervate all the force of the
Atheist’s argument against Revelation, taken from the invention of
Religion. For that Superstition was of human original, both parties
seem to agree: though not all of it the invention of Statesmen, as
we shall see presently, when we come to shew that one species of
Idolatry was in wse even before the institution of civil Society.
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 5
I shall prove, then, and in a very few words, that their fuct or
position is first, IMPERTINENT, and secondly, FALSE. For,
Ἰ.
Were it true, as it certainly is not, that Religion was invented
by Statesmen, it would not therefore follow that Religion is false. A
consequence that has been, I do not know how, allowed on all hands ;
perhaps on the mistaken force of one or other of these Proposi-
tions :
I. Either, that Religion was not found out, as a truth, by the use of
Reason.
Il. Or, that it was invented only for its Utility.
III. Or lastly, that the Inventors did not believe it.
I. ds to Religion’s not being found out, as a truth, by the use of
reason, we are to consider, that the finding out a truth by reason, neces-
sarily implies the exercise of that faculty, in proportion to the import-
ance and difficulty of the search: so that where men do not use their
reason, truths of the utmost certainty and highest use will remain
unknown. We are not accustomed to reckon it any objection to the
most useful civil truths, that divers savage nations in Africa and
America, remain yet ignorant of them.
Now the objection against the truth of Religion, is founded on this
pretended fact, that the Lawgiver taught it to the people from the
most early times. And the Infidel System is, that man from his first
appearance in thd world, even to those early times of his coming
under the hands of the Civil Magistrate, differed little from brutes in
the use of his rational faculties ; and that the improvement of them
was gradual and slow; for which, Antiquity is appealed to, in the
account it gives us concerning the late invention of the arts of life.
Thus, according to their own state of the case, Religion was taught
mankind when the generality had not begun to cultivate their
rational faculties; and, what is chiefly remarkable, it was TAUGHT
BY THOSE FEW WHO HAD.
It is true, our holy Religion gives a different account of these first
men: But then it gives a different account too of the origin of Reli-
gion. And let our Adversaries prevaricate as they will, they must take
both or neither. For that very thing which was only able to make
the first men so enlightened, as they are represented in Scripture, was
Revelation ; and, this allowed, the dispute is at an end.
If it should be said, That “supposing Religion true, it is of so
much importance to mankind, that God would never suffer us to
remain ignorant of it: I allow the force of the objection: but
then we are not to prescribe to the Almighty his way of bringing us
to the knowledge of his Will. It is sufficient to justify his goodness,
6 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK 113.
that he hath done it : and whether he chose the way of REVELATION,
or of Reason, or of the CrvIL MAGISTRATE, it equally manifests his
wisdom. And why it might not happen to this ¢rwth, as it hath
done to many others of great importance, to be first stumbled upon by
chance, and mistaken for a mere wtility; and afterwards seen and
proved to be what it is; I would beg leave to demand of these
mighty Masters of reason.
Il. ds to Religion’s being invented only for its utility: This,
though their palmary argument against it, is, of all, the most unlucky.
It proceeds on a supposed inconsistency between utility and truth.
For men perceiving much of it, between private, partial, utility and
truth, were absurdly brought to think there might be the same incon-
sistence, between general utility and some truths. This it was which
led the ancient Sages into so many errors. For neither Philosopher
nor Lawgiver apprehending THAT TRUTH AND UTILITY DID COIN-
cipE; the First, while he neglected utility, missed (as we have seen)
of the most momentous ¢ruths : and the Other, while little solicitous
about truth, missed in many instances (as we shall see hereafter) of
utility. But general utility and all truth, necessarily coincide. For
ruth is nothing but that natural or moral relation of things, whose
observance is attended with universal benefit. We may therefore as
certainly conclude that general utility is always founded on truth, as
that ¢ruth is always productive of general utility. Take then this
concession of the Atheist for granted, that Religion is productive of
public good, and the very contrary to his inference, as we have seen
above, Must follow: namely, that Religion is true.
If it should be urged, That “experience maketh against this rea-
soning ; for that it was not Religion, but Superstition, that, for
the most part, procured this public utility: and superstition, both
sides agree to be erroneous.” To this we reply, that Superstition
was so far from procuring any good in the ancient world, where it
was indeed more or less mixed with all the national Religions, that
the good which Religion procured, was allayed with evil, in propor-
tion to the quantity of Superstition found therein. And the less of
Superstition there was in any national Religion, the happier, ceteris
paribus, we always find that people; and the more there was of it,
the unhappier. It could not be otherwise, for, if we examine the
ease, it will appear, That all those advantages which result from the
worship of a superior Being, ave the consequences only of the ¢rue
principles of Religion: and that the mischiefs which result from such
worship, are the consequences only of the false; or what we call
Superstition.
The wiser Ancients (in whose times, SuPERSTITION, with it’s
malignant embraces, had twined itself round the noble trunk of
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. TE
Rexie1on, had poisoned her benignest qualities, deformed all her
comeliness, and usurped her very NAME) were so struck and affected
with what they saw and felt, that some of them thought, even
ATHEISM was to be preferred before her. PiLurarcu composed a
fine rhetorical discourse in favour of this strange paradox; which
hath since given frequent occasion to much sophistical declamation.
M. Bayxe hath supported Plutarch’s Thesis at large, in an Historical
and Philosophical Commentary: Yet, by neglecting, or rather con-
founding, a real and material pisTINCTION, neither the ancient nor
the modern Writer hath put the reader fairly into possession of the
question. So that, both the susyecr and the prepicaTe of the
Proposition are left in that convenient state of ambiguity which is
necessary to give a Paradow the air and reputation of an Oracle.
The ambiguity in the swdject ariseth from the word SupEersti-
TION’S being so laxly employed as to admit of two senses: either as a
THING ADVENTITIOUS TO RELIGION, with which it is fatally apt to
mix itself; Or as a CORRUPT SPECIES OF RELIGION. In the first
sense, Superstition is of no use at all, but of infinite mischief; and
worse than Atheism itself: In the second sense, of a corrupt Religion,
it is of great service; For, by teaching a Providence, on which man-
kind depends, it imposeth a necessary curb upon individuals, so as to
prevent the mischiefs of mutual violence and injustice. It is like-
wise, indeed, of great disservice : for, by infusing wrong notions of
the moral attributes of God, it hinders the progress of Virtue; and
sometimes sets up a false species of it. However, in the sense of a
corrupt Religion, the Reader sees, it is infinitely preferable to Athe-
ism: As in a Drug of sovereign efficacy, the application even of that
which by time or accident is become decayed or viciated, is, in despe-
rate disorders, greatly to be preferred to the rejection ; though it may
engender bad habits in the Constitution it preserves ; which, the
sound and pure species would not have done. Now one of the lead-
ing fallacies, which runs through PiuTarcn’s little Tract, keeps
under the cover of this ambiguity, in the suBJECT.
The ambiguity in the pReDICATE does as much service to sophis-
try. “Superstition” (they say) “7s worse than Atheism.” They do
not tell us, Tro wHom; but leave us to conclude, that they mean,
both to PARTICULARS and to society ; as taking it for granted, that
if worse to one, it must needs be worse to the ofher. But here they
are mistaken: and so, from this ambiguity arises a new fallacy,
which mixes itself with the other. The degree of mischief caused by
Superstition is different, as it respects its objects, Individuals or
Societies. Superstition, as it signifies only ἃ CORRUPT RITE, is
more hurtful to Socicties than to Individuals ; and, to both, worse
than Atheism. But as it signifies a CORRUPT RELIGION, it is less
8 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK 111-
hurtful to Societies than to Individuals; and, to both, detter than
Atheism. The confounding this distinction makes the ambiguity in
which Bayle principally delights to riot. And this, by the assistance
of the other from Plutarch, supports him in all his gross equivoca-
tions, and imperfect estimates: Till at length, it encourages him to
pronounce, in the most general terms, that Superstition is worse than
Atheism.*
BayLe is a great deal too diffused to come within the limits of this
examination. But as PLurarcn led the way ; and hath even dazzled
Bacon himself,t with the splendour of his discourse ; I propose to
examine his arguments, as they lie in order: Whereby it will appear
that, besides the capital fallacies above detected, it abounds with a
variety of other sophisms, poured out with a profusion which equals,
and keeps pace with, the torrent of his wit and eloquence.
This famous Tract is, as we have observed, a florid declamation,
adorned with all the forms and colouring of Rhetoric; when the
question demanded severe reasoning, and philosophical precision. At
the same time, it must be owned, that it is of a genius very different
from those luxuriant, and, at the same time, barren Dissertations of
the Sophists. It is painted all over with bright and hvely images, it
sparkles with witty allusions, it amuses with quaint and uncommon
similies ; and, in every decoration of spirit and genius, equals the
finest compositions of Antiquity: Indeed, as to the solidity and exact-
ness of the Logic, it is on a level with the meanest. His REASONING
is the only part I am concerned with: and no more of this, than lies
in one continued ComMPARISON between Atheism and Superstition :
For, as to his positive proofs, from fact, of the actual mischiefs of
Superstition, I am willing they should be allowed all the force they
pretend to.
It will be proper, in the first place, to observe, That it is hard to
say, What Plutarch intended to infer from this laboured Comparison
between Atheism and Superstition ; in which, he, all the way, gives
the preference to Atheism : For though, throughout the course of the
argument, he considers each, only as it affects Particulars, yet, in his
conclusion, he makes a general inference in favour of Atheism with
regard to Society. But, it will not follow, that, because Atheism is
less hurtful to Particulars, it is therefore less hurtful to Societies
likewise. So that, to avoid all sophistical dealing, it was necessary
these two questions should be distinguished ; and separately con-
sidered. However, let us examine his reasoning on that side where it
hath most strength, The effects of Atheism and Superstition on
PARTICULARS.
* Pensées diverses ecrites ἃ un Docteur de Sorbonne ἃ I’ Occasion de la Comete qui
partit au Mois de Decembre, 1680. Et Continuation des Pensées diverses, &c.
t See his ‘“‘ Essays ;’’ where this paradox of Plutarch is supported.
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 9
1. He sets out in this manner—‘‘ Ignorance concerning tlie nature
of the Gods, where it meets with a bold and refractory temper, as in a
rough and stubborn soil, produces ATHEISM ; where it encounters
flexible and fearful manners, as in rank and low land, there it brings
forth Superstition.” *—This is by no means an exact, or even
generally true account of the origin of these evils. There are various
causes which incline men to Atheism, besides fool-hardiness ; and, to
Superstition, besides cowardice. The affectation of singularity; the
vanity of superior knowledge ; and, what Plutarch himself, in another
place of this very Tract, assigns as a general cause, the sense of the
miseries of Superstition, have frequently inclined men to this fatal
obliquity of judgment. On the other hand, ignorance of Nature ;
impatience to pry into futurity ; the unaccountable turns in a man’s
own fortune, to good or bad ; and, above all, a certain reverence for
things established, carry them into Superstition. And as these con-
siderations are equally adapted to affect the hardy and the pusillani-
mous ; so the others, mentioned before, as soon get possession of the
fearful as of the bold. Nay, Fear itself is often the very passion
which most forcibly inclines a wicked man, who hath nothing favour-
able to expect from divine Justice, to persuade himself that there is
none to fear. Plutarch owns as much; and says expresly, that
“the end the Atheist proposes in his opinions is to exempt himself
from all fear of the Deity.” +—Again, we find, by the Histories of all
times, that Superstition seizeth, along with the weak and fearful, the
most daring and determined, the most ferocious and untractable.
Tyrants, Conquerors, Statesmen, and Great Generals, with all the
savage tribes of uncivilized Barbarians, submit tamely to this galling
Yoke.
But our Author’s account of the different births of Atheism and
Superstition was no more than was necessary to support his Thesis.
He all along estimates the two evils by the miseries they bring on
those who are under their dominion. These miseries arise from the
passions they create. But, of all the passions, FEAR is the most
tormenting. The pusillanimous mind is most subject to fear. And
it is over the fearful (he says) that Superstition gains the ascendant.
This, therefore, was to be laid down as a postulatum. ‘The rest
follows in order.
2. For now coming to his parallel,.he begins witha confession—
‘That both errors are very bad. But as Superstition is accompanied
with passion or affection, and Atheism free from all passion, Supersti-
tion must needs be the greater evil; as in a broken limb, a compound
* πῆς περὶ ϑεῶν ἀμαθίας καὶ ἀγνοίας εὐθὺς ἐξ ἀρχῆς δίχα ῥυείσης, τὸ μὲν, ὥσπερ ἐν
χωρίοις τισὶ σκληροῖς καὶ ἀντιτύποις, ἤθεσι τὴν ἀθεότητα, τὸ δὲ, ὥσπερ ἐν ὑγροῖς καὶ
ἁπαλοῖς, τὴν δεισιδαιμονίαν ἐμπεποίηκεν.-- Περὶ Δεισιδ. vol. i. p. 286, Steph. ed. 8vo.
+ Τέλος ἐστὶν αὐτῇ τοῦ μὴ νομίζειν ϑεοὺς, τὸ μὴ φοθεῖσθαι.---Ρ. 287.
10 THE DIVINE ΠΕΘΑΤΙΟΝ. woox 4m
fracture is much worse than a simple. Atheism” (he says) ‘ may
pervert the mind, but Superstition both w/cerates and perverts. A man
who believes no God hath none to fear; but he who believes God to
be a capricious or vindictive Being hath a great deal to ἔβαν." *—This
is wittily said: but Nature talks another language. We should
beware how we credit poetical similies; or even philosophical analo-
gies ; which, indeed, is but poetry, once removed. They both have
their hopes and fears. Though the Atheist has no God to fear, yet
the miserable forlorn condition of a World without a Ruler must keep
him under perpetual alarms, in the apprehension of the dismal effect
which Chance and Hazard may produce in the Material system ;
either by removing the parts of it (whose present position supports
the harmony of the whole) too far from, or else by bringing them too
near to, one another.
And now again, the rapidity of Plutarch’s invention throws him on
a Comparison, to support his reasoning, which entirely overturns it—
** He” (says our author) “ who thinks Virtue a corporeal being is only
absurd. Here we have an error without passion. But he who
thinks Virtue a mere name is miserable ; for his error is attended with
passion.” +—How so?—** Because such a one lies under the sad
reflection of having lost his ablest support.” But must not a man’s
being deprived of the Lawerver be as sensible a mortification, as his
being deprived of the Law, whose existence depends upon the
Lawgiver ? On the other side, Though Superstition hath its fears, it
hath its Aopes also: which, upon the whole, I think, to be more
eligible than that supposed freedom of the Atheist (even as our author
draws it) from all passion and affection. For though the supersti-
tious man. may think perversely concerning the means whereby the
Deity is appeased, yet he thinks him placable; and supposeth the
means to be in his own power. So that he is not under the tyranny
of that pure and unmixed fear, which Plutarch represents in such a
manner as if all Nature furnished out provision to the superstitious
man, for food and exercise to this passion. Whereas the affection of
Superstition is equal between hopes and fears: It is the proper tem-
per of the superstitious man, which more inclines him towards one
than to the other. But Plutarch had before, gratuitously, laid it
down as an axiom, ‘ That the essential temperament of the supersti-
tious man is fear and cowardice.”
3. However, all this would not have been sufficient to support the
weakness of his declamatory reasoning, without the assistance of two
commodious sophisms, to set it off. The first, indeed, is of a slender
"Ἅπασα μὲν οὖν κρίσις ψευδὴς, ἄλλως τε κἂν ἢ Wepl ταῦτα μοχθηρὸν, τῇδε Kal
τυάθος τορόσεστι μοχθηρότερον' way "γὰρ wdbos ἔοικεν ἀπάτη φλεγμαίνουσα εἶναι. Se.
— Pp. 286, 287. + Πάλιν οἴονταί τινες εἶναι σῶμα τὴν aperiv, &c.—P. 286.
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. wl
make, and hath little more in it than sound. He says “the very
name shews, the essence of superstition to be Fear: For the Greek
name of this moral mode, δεισιδαιμονία, signifies a fear of the gods.”
A Roman might with the same pretence aver, that the essence of
superstition is Love: for that the Latin word swperstitio, hath a
reference to the love we bear to our children, in the desire that they
should survive us; being formed upon the observation of certain
religious practices deemed efficacious for procuring that happy event.
The other sophism is more material; and consists in putting the
change upon us, and representing the God of the Superstitious man,
by whom he supposes the world to be governed, in false and odious
colours, as an envious Being, hurtful to man :* For it is not the good,
but the revit Demon whom the superstitious man ¢hus represents :
Not the Being which he worships ; but the Being which he avoids
and detests. The superstitious man, indeed, foolishly enough, sup-
poseth, that the God whom he acknowledgeth to be good, is capri-
cious, inconstant, and vindictive. But then, from that essential
quality of GoopNess, which belongs to him as Gop, he concludes,
that this Being may be appeased by submission, and won upon by
oblations and atonements. All this, Plutarch himself confesseth :
and in words which directly contradict the account he here gives of
the God of the superstitious man. Superstition (says he) agitated
by many contrary passions, suffereth itself to suspect that THE Goon
itself may be evil.+ Plutarch has therefore acted unfairly, and to
serve a purpose, in thrusting in the superstitious man’s evel Demon, in
the place of his God. This conduct will bear the harder upon his
ingenuity, as he held the doctrine of the Two PRINCIPLES: and,
therefore, can hardly be supposed to have changed the object inad-
vertently, or without design.
4. Having made the God of the superstitions man, a Devil, he
hath, consistently enough, represented the superstitious man’s condi-
tion to be the very state of the damned: “That his pains have not
remission ; that he carries Hell in his bosom, and finds the Furies in
his dreams.” ¢ The terms of the original are very elegant: But as
they plainly allude to the shews of the mysteries, 1 think the author
should have been so fair to recollect, that there was an ExLysruM as
well as a Tarrarvus both in the Dreams of the superstitious man and
in the shews of the Mysteries. And that as Tartarus and Elysium
* Οἰόμενόν τ᾽ εἶναι ϑεοὺς, εἶναι δὲ λυπηροὺς καὶ βλαβερούς.--Ρ. 287. t ‘H δὲ
δεισιδαιμονία ττολυπάθεια κακὸν τὸ ἀγαθὺν ὑπονοοῦσα" φοθοῦνται τοὺς ϑεοὺς, καὶ κατα-
φεύγουσιν ἐπὶ τοὺς ϑεούς.---Ῥ. 291. {Ὥσπερ ἐν ἀσεθδῶν χώρῳ, τῷ ὕπνῳ τῶν
δεισιδαιμόνων, εἴδωλα φρικώδη καὶ τεράστια φαρμακῶν, καὶ wowds τινας ἐγείρουσα καὶ
στροθοῦσα τὴν ἀθλίαν ψυχὴν, ἐκ τῶν ὕπνων ἐκδιώκει τοῖς ὀνείροις, μαστι(ζομένην καὶ
κολαζομένην αὐτὴν bp αὑτῆς. ὡς bp ἑτέρου, καὶ δεινὰ τσροστάγματα καὶ ἀλλόκοτα
λαμβάνουσαν.---Ῥ. 288.
12 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK ITF
were alike the fictions of superstition, they were alike the objects of
the superstitious Man’s dreams. His natural temperament and the
redundancy of a particular humour would determine the colour of
the Scene. The Atheist therefore, who, he says, enjoys the benefit of
repose, might have his sleep disturbed by the cries of the damned as
well as the superstitious man; whom he represents as kept in per-
petual alarms by this passion; because the habit of the body makes
the very same impressions on the fancy, in sleep, which the state of
the mind does on the imagination while awake.
5. But, “from the tyranny of Superstition,” he says, ‘‘ there is no
respite nor escape ; because, in the opinion of the superstitious man,
all things are within the jurisdiction of his God; and this God is
inexorable and implacable.” * From such a Being, indeed, there can
be no escape, nor respite from torment. But, as was said before, this
is not the superstitious man’s God, but his Devil. Besides, the attri-
bute of implacability totally removes, what our Author makes the
other half of the miseries of Superstition ; its slavish attention to the
foolish and costly business of expiations and atonements: A practice
arising from the idea of placability, and necessarily falling with it.
6. Therefore, asif conscious of this prevarication, he adds: “ That
the superstitious man fears even his best-conditioned Gods, the Bene-
ficent, the Preservers : that the Gods, from whom men seek grandeur,
affluence, peace, concord, and success, are the objects of his dread
and terror.” + Here we see the superstitious man is at length con-
fessed to have Gods very different from those before assigned unto
him: However, we must not think that even these will afford him
any solace or consolation. It is well that the whole proof of this
cruel exclusion lies in the ambiguity of the terms, φρίττων and
τρέμων : which, when they signify the fearing slavishly, do indeed
imply mesery : But when they signify fearing religiously, do as cer-
tainly imply a dlessing ; because they deter the subject, they influ-
ence, from evil. Now, when these terms are applied to the Gods
confessedly beneficent, they can signify only a religious fear ; unless
when Plutarch hath defined Superstition to be, the fearing sla-
vishly, we will be so complaisant to allow that the SuprrstTiTious
MANT cannot fear religiously. And where is the absurdity in flying
for refuge to Gods, so feared? Though Plutarch puts it among the
contradictions of Superstition.§—It is remarkable, that these good-
conditioned Gods, here described as τοὺς σωτῆρας καὶ τοὺς μειλιχίους,
"Ὁ 6é τὴν τῶν δεῶν ἀρχὴν ὡς τυραννίδα φοδούμενος σκυθρωπὴν καὶ ἀπαραίτητον,
wou μεταστῇ, woo φυγῇ, τσοίαν γῆν ἄθεον εὕρῃ, wolay δάλασσαν ;—P.2 289. +‘O
poSotmevos τοὺς τσατρῴους καὶ γενεθλίους, ὁ φρίττων τοὺς σωτῆρας καὶ τοὺς μειλιχίους,
τρέμων καὶ δεδοικὼς wap" ὧν αἰτούμεθα τυλοῦτον, εὐπορίαν, Bae μοι: εἰρήνην, ὄρθωσιν
λόγων καὶ ἔργων τῶν ἀρίστων. -ΞῈ. 289. 1 See p. 16. § Φοβοῦνται τοὺς
δεοὺς, καὶ καταφεύγουσιν ἐπὶ τοὺς ϑεούς.---Ῥ. 291.
Β5ΕΟῚ- vis OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 13
are called by our author watpoous καὶ γενεθλίους, his native and coun-
try Gods. Yet if we consider the stories of Jupiter, Mars, Mercury,
Bacchus, Diana, &c. we shall find no great reason to extol their
morals. But here lay the distress of the affair. Plutarch was a
Priest of this class of Deities; and Greece, at that time, being over-
run with strange Gods, and labourmg under Eastern superstitions, it
was proper to blacken this foreign worship, for the sake of the
national: So that Plutarch, like the fair Trader, in an ill humour
with Interlopers, reckons all Eastern Rites as even worse than Athe-
ism. Hence his famous exclamation to his Countrymen, which the
noble author of the Characteristics quotes with much exultation, and
transferred bitterness. “Ὁ wretched Greeks’’ (says Plutarch, speak-
ing to his then declining countrymen) ‘‘ who in a way of superstition
run so easily into the relish of barbarous nations, and bring into
Religion that frightful mien of sordid and vilifying devotion, ill-
favoured humiliation and contrition, abject looks and countenances,
consternations, prostrations, disfigurations, and in the act of worship
distortions, constrained and painful postures of the body, wry faces,
beggarly tones, mumpings, grimaces, cringings, and the rest of this
kind.—A shame indeed to us Grecians /—NShall we, while we are
nicely observant of other forms and decencies in the Temple, shall we
neglect this greater decency in voice, words, and manners ; and with
vile cries, fawnings, and prostitute behaviour, betray the natural dig-
nity and majesty of that divine Religion, and NATIONAL WORSHIP,
delivered down to us by our forefathers, and purged from every thing
of BARBAROUS and savage kind.’ * Such then were the circum-
stances of the time; and these, together with the personal views of
our Author, were, I suppose, the causes which gave birth to this
famous Tract, or SupeRsTiTion. ΤῸ proceed,
7. Another advantage of Atheism over Superstition, in Plutarch’s
reckoning, is, “that the Atheist is secured from the impressions of a
future state.’ + Tt is no wonder that we find this in the number of
the Atheist’s blessings, when we consider that our Author regarded a
future state as a Fable, at best, invented for the restraint of evil. Yet,
whatever pleasure the Atheist may take in his security from this
terror, it is certain, Society would suffer by taking off so useful a
curb upon the manners of the people.
8. Our Author then proves, and indeed proves it effectually, “ That
superstition is much worse tlian the true knowledge of the Deity.” 1
9. He considers next the different effects of Atheism and Supersti-
* (( Miscel. Reflections,” vol. iii. misc. ii. c. 3. + Ti de? μακρὰ λέγειν ; wepas ἐστὶ
τοῦ βίου wacw ἀνθρώποις 6 Sdvaros: τῆς δὲ δεισιδαιμονίας οὐδ᾽ οὗτος " ἀλλ᾽ ὑπερβάλλει
τοὺς ὅρους ἐπέκεινα τοῦ (ἣν, μακρότερον τοῦ βίου «ποιοῦσα τὸν φόθον, καὶ συνάπτουσα
τῷ ϑανάτῳ κακῶν ἐπίνοιαν ἀθανάτων, Sc.—Pp. 289, 290. 1 Φιλοσόφων δὲ καὶ Πολι-
τικῶν ἀνδρῶν καταφρονοῦσιν, &c.—P. 291.
14 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK 1170
tion on their subjects, in the disastrous accidents of life. And here
again, Atheism, as usual, is found to have the advantage. ‘The
Atheist indeed curses Chance, and blasphemes Providence ; but the
superstitious man complains of his Gods, and thinks himself hated or
forsaken of them.’ *—The Atheist is well come on. Hitherto Plu-
tarch had represented his Favorite as always calm and undisturbed :
Indeed, he makes one great part of the Atheist’s advantage over
Superstition to consist in his freedom from all unruly passions. Here,
they labour both alike under their tyranny. Well, but some passions
make their owner more miserable than others. It is confessed, they
do. But, is that the case here? Or if it be, Is it to the advantage
of the Atheist? By no means. The disasters of life are supposed to —
have betrayed them both into passion. But he surely is least
oppressed by the commotion, who sees a possibility of getting out of
his distresses. It is impossible the Atheist can have any such pros-
pect. There is no Fence against a Flail, nor provision against blind
Chance: The superstitious man may easily hope to appease the irri-
tated Deity : for though he fears and dreads the Gods, yet, as Plutarch
acknowledges, he flies to them for refuge. 1 might mention another
advantage which the superstitious man hath over the Atheist in the
disasters of life, namely, that he is frequently Jettered by his misfor-
tunes ; and this the Atheist never is; because the superstitious man
may suppose them sent by the Gods in punishment for his crimes ;
which the Atheist never can.
“But” (says our Author) “If the disaster in question be disease
or sickness, the Atheist referring it to the right cause, intemperance, ἡ
seeks out for the proper cure. While the superstitious man imagin-
ing it to be a yudgement from Heaven, neglects to have recourse to
medicine.” + The delusion here is evident. It is built on that false
position, which the experience of all ages hath discredited, namely,
That men always act according to their principles. In this case espe-
cially, of avoiding or freeing themselves from instant physical evil,
men of the most different Principles go all one way; and however
divided in their religious opinions, they all meet in an uniformity to
medical practice. It is an idle sophism which would persuade us,
that, because the superstitious man useth sacred Rites to remove what
he esteems a sacred disease, that, therefore, he employs no other
* Πάντας ἐπὶ τὴν τύχην καὶ τὸ αὐτόματον ἀπερειδομένου τοὺς ὀδυρμοὺς, καὶ βοῶντος
ὡς οὐδὲν κατὰ δίκην, οὐδ᾽ ἐκ wpovolas, ἀλλὰ τσάντα συγκεχυμένως καὶ ἀκρίτως φέρεται,
καὶ σπαθᾶται τὰ τῶν ἀνθρώπων---σ“ἀντων τὸν ϑεὸν αἰτιᾶται---καὶ ὡς ov δυστυχὴς ὧν,
ἀλλὰ δϑεομισής Tis ἄνθρωπος.---ῬρΡ. 291, 292, + Νόσῶν τε 6 ἄθεος ἐκλογίζεται καὶ
ἀναμιμνήσκεται τολησμονὰς αὑτοῦ καὶ οἰνώσεις, καὶ ἀταξίας wept δίαιταν, ἢ κόπους ὑπερ-
βάλλοντας, ἢ μεταβολὰς ἀέρων ἀήθεις καὶ ἀτόπους---Τῷ δὲ δεισιδαίμονι καὶ σώματος
ἀῤῥωστία waca—wrnyal ϑεοῦ καὶ τπτροσδολαὶ δαίμονος λέγονται" ὅθεν οὐδὲ τολμᾷ
βοηθεῖν, οὐδὲ διαλύειν τὸ συμδεβηκὸς, οὐδὲ ϑεραπεύειν, οὐδὲ ἀντιτάττεσθαι, μὴ δόξῃ
ϑεομαχεῖν καὶ ἀντιτείνειν κολαζόμενος.---Ρ. 292.
SECT, VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 15
means.* The early mixture of medical drugs with religious charms
and incantations in the first state of Physic, might have taught our
Author, how naturally men are wont to lend a helping hand to the
supposed efficacy of Religion. But this reasoning is utterly discre-
dited by his own instance of the Mariners ; the most superstitious of
mortals ; who, in the distresses of a storm, while they pour out their
vows to their Saviour Gods, at the same time fall lustily to their
tackle, and pump without intermission? + Indeed, he seems fully
sensible of its weakness, when he catches at an occurrence in the
Jewish Ὁ history, to support it; where, we know (though he did not)
that all things were extraordinary, and nothing to be brought to
example, any more than to imitation.
To disgrace Superstition still more, our Author urges “the misfor-
tune of Nicias the Athenian ; who, frightened by an eclipse of the
Moon, delayed his retreat till he and his army were invested, and cut
in pieces, by the enemy.’ But this kind of superstitious observance
is as well adapted to encourage as to dismay armies and bodies of
men; and hath just as often done the one as the other. So that,
under this article, Plutarch should have fairly stated, and balanced
the account.
From the miseries of life, He comes to the pleasures of it. And
here too the Atheist must have an exclusive possession. He con-
fesseth, “that the pomps and ceremonies of religious Festivals abound
with complacency and joy.” He owns “his Atheist can receive no
further amusement from such a scene than to laugh at it: But to the
superstitious man” (he says) ‘‘ they are the subject of distress and
misery.” §—Not to allow the relaxations of the superstitious man’s
mental terrors to have their effect, is hard indeed. It is much the
same as not to suffer us to feel the remissions of our bodily pains.
If the superstitious man fancies the Gods are often angry, he some-
times, at least, believes them to be appeased. And when can he hope
to find them in good humour, if not at their Festivals? To draw
him, therefore, at this season, with pale looks and trembling gestures,
is certainly over-charging the picture. The truth is, the superstitious
man hath as strong paroxysms of joy as of grief; though perhaps
neither so frequent nor so lasting. Yet to leny them to him at the
* Plutarch makes the superstitions man say, Ταῦτα πάσχεις, ὦ κακόδαιμον, er
«ρονοίας καὶ ϑεοῦ κελεύοντος" ἔῤῥιψε macu ἐλπίδα, τυροήκατο éavtoy.—P. 293.
+ Τοῦτο ἰδὼν κυβερνήτης εὔχεται. μὲν ὑπεκφυγεῖν, καὶ Seovs ἐπικαλεῖται σωτῆρας,
εὐχόμενος δὲ τὸν οἴακα προσάγει, τὴν κεραίαν ὑφίησι. -Ρ, 294. 1 ᾿Αλλὰ ᾿Ιουδαῖοι
σαββάτων ὄ ὄντων ἐν ἀγνάμπτοις καθεζόμενοι, τῶν τσολεμίων κλίμακας τυροστιθέντων, καὶ
τὰ τείχη καταλαμβξανόντων, οὐκ ἀνέστησαν, &c.—P. 294. § Ἥδιστα δὲ τοῖς
ἀνθρώποις ἑορταὶ, Se. ἐνταῦθα τοίνυν σκόπει τὸν ἄθεον, γελῶντα μὲν μανικὸν καὶ σαρ-
δώνιον γέλωτα τούτοις τοοιουμένοις -- ἄλλο δὲ οὐδὲν ἔχοντα κακόν" 6 δὲ δεισιδαίμων
βούλεται μὲν, ov δύναται δὲ χαίρειν. οὐδὲ ἥδεσθαι--- ἐστεφανωμένος ὠχριᾷ, ϑύει καὶ
φοβεῖται, δ ὁ.---ΡΡ. 294, 295.
10 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK. 111.
celebration of his religious Festivals is a contradiction to all common
sense.
Our author next attempts to shew, That “the crime of impiety is
rather to be charged upon the superstitious man than the Atheist :
for Anaxagoras,” he says, ‘‘was accused of impiety, for holding the Sux
to be only a red-hot stone: But nobody challenged the Cimmerians
of that crime for denying its existence.” * By this, our Author would
insinuate, that it is more injurious to the Gods, to hold dishonourable
notions of their Nature, than to call in question ther Beg. The
opposition of these cases is witty and ingenious: but very defective,
in the integrity of the application. Plutarch’s Philosophic atheist in
question, corresponds no more with the Cimmerians, than his Theist
does with Anaxagoras.—The Atheist, after having had a full view of
the works of God, denies the existence of the Workman. The Cim-
merians, because debarred, by their situation, the use of that sense
which alone could inform them of the Sun’s nature, had no concep-
tion of his Being. In the first case, the conclusion being derogatory
to the Nature of the Power denied, the Denier is justly charged with
impiety ; In the latter, as no such derogation is implied, no such
crime can be reasonably inferred. But this brisk sally was only to
introduce the famous declaration which follows, and hath been so
often quoted + by the modern advocates of this paradox. “ For my
own part I had rather men should say of me, That there neither is
nor ever was such a one as Plutarch; than they should say, there
was a Plutarch, an unsteady, changeable, easily-provoked, and
revengeful man.’ These, says the noble author of the Character-
istics,t are the words of honest Plutarch.
And, without doubt, did Gop stand only in that relation to the
rest of Beings in which one creature stands to another; and were his
existence no more necessary to the Universe of things than the
existence of honest Plutarch, every body would say the same. But
the KNOWLEDGE of a Creator and Governor is so necessary to the
rational system, that a merciful Lord would chuse to have it retained
and kept alive, though he might happen to be dishonoured by many
false and absurd opinions concerning his Nature and Attributes. A
private man of generous morals might rather wish to continue
unknown than to be remembered with infamy. But a supreme
"Ὅθεν ἔ ἔμοιγε καὶ ϑαυμάζειν ἔπεισι τοὺς τὴν ἀθεότητα φάσκοντας ἀσέβειαν εἶναι,
μὴ φάσκοντας. δὲ τὴν δεισιδαιμονίαν " καίτοιγε ᾿Αναξαγόρας δίκην ἔφυγεν ἀσεβείας ἐπὶ
τῷ λίθον εἰπεῖν τὸν Ἥλιον" Κιμμερίους δὲ οὐδεὶς εἶπεν ἀσεβεῖς ὅτι τὸν Ἥλιον οὐδ᾽
εἶναι τοπαράπαν νομίζουσι.---Ῥ. 295. + “10 were better” (says Bacon) ‘to have
no opinion of God at all, than such an opinion as is unworthy of him.—Plutarch saith
well to that purpose. Surely (saith he) I had rather a great deal men should say there
was no such man as Plutarch, than that they should say there was one Plutarch that
would eat his children,’ §&c.— Essays Civil and Moral,” chap. xviii. t * Charac-
teristics ;’’ Letter concerning Enthusiasm, sect. 5.
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 7
Magistrate, who loved the Community he governed, would certainly
prefer the being known to his Subjects, even at the hazard of their
mistaking him for a Tyrant: because, if the members of a Com-
munity, through ignorance of their having a Ruler, should think
themselves free from subjection, every one would consult his passions
and appetites, till he brought the whole into confusion. Whereas,
while they knew they had a Master, their actions would be so con-
formed to the general measures of obedience as to support the order
of Society: though their perverse notions of his Character might
indeed obstruct many of those blessings which Government produces
under a Ruler of acknowledged justice and-goodness.
Our author proceeds ; and observes next, “that the Atheist, it is
true, believes there is no God; but the superstitious man wishes there
were none: That the Atheist is averse to Superstition ; but the super-
stitious man, if he could, would shelter himself in Atheism.” * It is
by no means true that the superstitious man ever desires to be free of
the sense of a superior Being, to whom he may be accountable for his
actions ; as appears plainly from his abhorrence and persecution of
Atheism: All that he wisheth is, to render such a Being propitious,
and easily placable.
As to our author’s inference, concerning the better condition of
Atheism, because “the Atheist never wisheth to be superstitious,
though the superstitious man wisheth to be an Atheist,” it is a mere
sophism: The proposition, on which it standeth, amounting to no
more than this, That the Atheist doth not wish what 1s afflictive in
Superstition : And the superstitious man doth wish what is easy in
Atheism. And from those restrained premises no such general con-
clusion can be logically inferred.
But he hath found out another reason for preferring Atheism to
Superstition. ‘‘ Atheism,” he says, “was never the cause of Supersti-
tion: but, on the contrary, Superstition has very often given birth to
Atheism.” + His meaning may be, either, that an Atheist did never
change to a superstitious Religionist ; Or that an Atheist, while such,
could never become superstitious.
In either sense, fact hath shewn that the assertion is utterly false.
In the first, we have seen, that it is of the essential weakness of
humanity to run continually from one extreme to another. Modum
tenere nescia est, saith the great Philosopher{ very truly. And the
phenomenon is no mystery. The mind, as soon as ever it becomes
sensible of its excesses, striveth, from its innate abhorrence of what is
wrong, to break away from them. And the force, with which it is
* Νυνὶ δὲ τῷ μὲν ἀθέῳ δεισιδαιμονίας οὐδὲν μέτεστιν" ὁ δὲ δεισιδαίμων τῇ τσροαιρέσει
ἄθεος ὧν, ἀσθενέστερός ἐστιν ἣ τοῦ δοξάζειν wepl Sev ὃ βούλεται.---Ρ. 297. + Καὶ
μὴν 6 ἄθεος δεισιδαιμονίας οὐδαμῇ συναίτιος " ἡ δὲ δεισιδαιμονία τῇ ἀθεότητι καὶ γενέσθαι
waperxev apxiv.—P, 297. { Bacon.
VOL. 11. C
15 THE DIVINE LEGATION ROOK IIl.
then impelled, being increased by the struggle between its old preju-
dices, which would restrain it, and its new aversion, which drives it
on, rarely remits, till it arrives at the OPPOSITE EXTREME. ‘The
behaviour of all Ages supports this observation: and of none, more
than the Present. Where a contempt of Revelation having for some
time spread amongst the People, we see them now become an easy
prey to fanaticism and superstition: and the Mreruopist and the
Popisu PRIEST succeed, with great ease and silence, to the Libertine
and the Freethinker.
To say, that an Atheist, while he is such, cannot become supersti-
tious, betrays great ignorance of human nature. How many Princes
and Ministers of State hath the history of the two or three last Ages
delivered down to us as Unbelievers in all Religion, and yet strongly
devoted to the dotages of judicial Astrology! The Italians, in parti-
cular, have not been more noted for their irreligion and refined
Politics, than for their credulity in this gross Imposture. Should I
stay to enquire at large into the cause of so strange a phenomenon, it
would be seen, how much honour it does to Religion. At present ἢ
shall only observe, That these men finding (and none have so good
opportunities) how perpetually public events fall out beside their
Expectation, and contrary to their best-laid schemes of Policy, are
forced to confess that human affairs are ordered by some power
extrinsical. 'To acknowledge a God and his Providence would be the
next way to introduce a morality destructive of that public system,
which they think necessary for the government of the World. They
have recourse therefore to that absurd scheme of Power, which rules
by no other Law than Fate or Destiny.
I have now gone through our Author’s various arguments in sup-
port of his Paradox ; or, to call them by their right name, a group
of ill-combined sophisms, tricked off by his eloquence, or varnished
over with his wit.
But there is one MASTER-SOPHISM still behind, that animates the
Whole, and gives a false vigour to every Part. Let us consider the
question which Plutarch invites his reader to debate with him, Τί
is not, What the szmple qualities of Atheism and Superstition, if
found alone in man, are severally capable of producing: but what
each really doth produce, as each is, in fact, found mingled with the
rest of man’s passions and appetites. He should not, therefore, have
amused us with inferences from the abstract ideas of Atheism and
Superstition ; but should have examined their effects in the concrete,
as they are to be found in the Atheist, and in the superstitious man.
‘For, nature having sown in the human breast the seeds of various and
differing passions and appetites, the γέ passion, in each Character,
is no more in its simple, unmixed state, than the predominant colour in
SECT. VI; O¥ MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 19
a well-wrought picture: Both the passion and the colour are so
darkened or dissipated by surrounding light and shade, so changed
and varied by the reflection of neighbouring tints, as to produce very
different effects from what, in their separate and simple state, whether
real or imaginary, they were capable of affording.* Let the reader
apply this observation to any part of Plutarch’s Declamation, who
considers Atheism and Superstition not in the concrete, but in the
abstract only, and it will presently expose the inconsequence of his
reasoning. I will but just give an example, in one instance. He
prefers Atheism to Superstition, “because ¢his is attended with
passion ; that is free from all passion.” Now the only support of
this remark is the sophism in question. Consider the ideas of
Atheism and Superstition in the adstract, and there is a shew of
truth: for Superstition, simply, implying the fear of the gods, is of
the essence of passion ; and Atheism, simply, implying the denial of
their existence, includes nothing of the idea of passion. But consider
these moral modes in the concrefe, as in this question we ought to do,
and Atheism will be always found accompanied with passion or affec-
tion ; and of as uneasy a kind, perhaps, as Superstition. It is of no
moment, to this discourse, whether Plutarch hath here imposed upon
himself or his reader. It is possible, that, in the drawing his two
characters, he might imitate, or be misled by, THropHrRastts:
Whose various pourtraits have all this fundamental defect. That is,
if we understand them as given for copies of any thing really existing.
But, [ apprehend, this is not their true character. I rather think
This curious fragment of Antiquity was only the remains of a Promp-
tuary for the use of the Comic Port, from whence he might be
supplied with his materials, the simple passions ; in order to blend,
and shade, and work them into his pictures of real life and manners.
However, if Plutarch considered them under the common idea, and,
under that, would make them his model, he shewed as little judgment
as that painter would be found to do, who should apply his simple
colours just as he received them from the colourman ; without form-
ing them into those curious
—‘“ Lights and shades, whose well-accorded strife
Gives all the strength and colour of our life.”’
To proceed with our author’s Argument: It is directed, we see, to
shew the advantage of Atheism above Superstition, only as these
opinions and practices regard parTicuLARs: Though, by the turn
and management of his reasoning, he appears willing, you should
infer that the same advantage holds equally, with regard to society
also: And therefore he concludes, ‘‘ That it had been better for the
* See note LL, at the end of this book,
G2
20 : THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK III.
Gauls and Scythians to be without any Religion, than to have had
such a one as taught them to believe that the Gods delighted in the
blood of human victims: And much better for Carthage to have had
the Atheists, Critias and Diagoras, for Lawgivers, than such as those
who authorized the Sacrifices performed to Saturn.”* The sophisms
which support these assertions are fully exposed in the introductory
observation ‘to these remarks; and so, stand in need of no further
detection.
Lord Bacon’s chapter on Superstition, in his Essays civil and
moral, is no other than an epitome of this tract of Plutarch. Now
whether that great man thought his Original defective, in not attempt-
ing to shew the advantage of Atheism over Superstition, as well with
regard to Society as to Particulars; Or whether he thought, that
though his Author did attempt it, yet he was too concise and obscure ;
and therefore judged it expedient to comment on his hints: It is
remarkable, that he addresses himself very strenuously, to make out
this important point. ‘ Atheism” (saith his Lordship) ‘ did never
perturb States : for it makes men wary of themselves, as looking no
farther: And we see, the times inclined to Atheism, as the time of
Augustus Cesar, were civil times. But Superstition hath been the
confusion of many States; and bringeth in a new primum mobile,
that ravisheth all the spheres of Government. The Master of Super-
stition is the People.”
This is a paragraph totally unworthy so great a Genius. Atheism,
he says, did never perturb States. The observation might, perhaps,
pass for true, when he wrote. But, true or false, to make it to his
purpose, he must suppose, that this negative advantage ariseth from
the essential nature and intrinsic quality of Atheism, and not from
mere accident ; and so he plainly insinuates, in the reason subjoined
—For it makes men wary of themselves, &c. but falsely. It is not
from the nature of things, but by mere accident, that Atheism never
perturbed States ; it having rarely, or never, spread amongst the
People, but hath been confined to a few speculative men. If ever it~
should become thus extensive, if ever it should infect the Sovereign,
it must not only perturb States (as we have sad experience that it
does, even under its negative form of IRRELIGION) but, as we have
shewn at large,+ would certainly overturn Society. Indeed his Lord-
ship himself fairly confesseth thus much, where, charging this very
mischief on Superstition, he subjoins the cause of its malignity—
the Master of Superstition is the People, i. e. the people are they
* Οὐκ ἄμεινον οὖν ἣν Γαλάταις ἐκείνοις καὶ Σκύθαις τοπαράπαν μήτε ἔννοιαν ἔχειν
Seay, μήτε φαντασίαν, μήτε ἱστορίαν, ἢ ϑεοὺς εἶναι νομίζειν χαίροντας ἀνθρώπων σφαττο-.
μένων αἵμασι ;-- τί δὲ Καρχηδονίοις οὐκ ἐλυσιτέλει Κριτίαν λαθοῦσιν ἢ Διαγόραν νομοθέτην
ἀπ᾽ ἀρχῆς, μήτε τινὰ ϑεῶν μήτε δαιμόνων νομίζειν, ἢ τοιαῦτα ϑύειν οἷα τῷ Κρόνῳ ἔθυον ;
—P, 297. t Book i. sect. 4. /
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 9]
who are infected with this error. Atheism, he says, makes men
wary of themselves, as looking no further: This argument in favour
of Atheism seems to have been borrowed from CARDAN ; and (as
miserable as it is) hath been considered in its place.*
The times, inclined to Atheism, he says, were cwil times: 1 know of
no times inclined to Atheism ; that is, when the people had a propen-
sity to it, unless, perhaps, twé or three centuries ago in Italy; and
then the times were as miserable as civil distractions could make a
bad and wicked Government. His Lordship, indeed, refers to the
age of Augustus Cesar. But it is certain, that, at that time, no
Roman troubled his head with Grecian principles, (and Atheism was
then to be had no where else) except it were a few of the Nobility :
Then, indeed, part of their Grandees, to make themselves easy under
Servitude, espoused the principles of Errcurus: But a much larger
part followed the doctrine of the Porcu. Either served their turn.
If they could persuade themselves to believe that their miseries were
enevitable, it was just as well as if they could force themselves to think
that these miseries were no evils. The soft, the delicate, the luxu-
rious, espoused the first: The more rigid, and severe of morals, the
latter. But still we must observe that their PRINCIPLES were the
effect of their acquiescence in a state of Nervitude; not the cause ; as
his lordship would insinuate : And did then, in reality, no more con-
cern the Public, than their different tastes for wild-boar or mullets.
The time of Augustus Cesar, he says, was a civil time. And this
must be placed to the score of Atheism, although other causes be so
very obvious: The miseries of the preceding civil wars, in support of
Liberty, often renewed, with still greater violence, and still less suc-
cess, made men weary both of struggling and suffering ; and willing,
at last, to thrust their necks under the yoke of a well-established
Master. And this, together with the want of Instruments (for the
general slaughter of them had made Confusion cure itself) were the
real causes which, in the ceaseless round of human actions, produced
that still calm of real slavery, after a long tempestuous season of
nominal Freedom.
However, the general observation we made on PLuTARCH may be
well applied to Bacon: What he wants in fact and argument, he
makes up in wit, and the ornaments of fancy: as where he says,
Superstition bringeth in a new primum mobile, that ravisheth all the
spheres of government. By which pompous figure, borrowed of the
Peripatetic Philosophy, no more is meant than the Churchman’s
destructive claim of independency on the State ; which conceals a vile
ambition under the cloak of Religion: A claim, which, at that time,
those two capital enemies of the established Church, the Papist and
* See vol. i. p. 128.
59 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IIT.
the Puriran, alike pursued ; as then to the disturbance, so, wherever
they succeed, to the certain ruin of civil Government.
But to return to Plutarch, and conclude. The only sage part of
his Declamation is in his last words ; where he observes, “That, for
the reasons he hath given, we ought to shun and avoid SupERSTITION ;
but so cautiously, as not to fall into the other extreme of ATHEISM ;
like those giddy travellers, who flying’ from wild beasts and robbers,
fall down rocks and precipices, where they perish.”* But to enforce
so plain a conclusion, there was no need of all that expence of wit
and sophistry to prove (what the conclusion did not want) That
Atheism was in all things preferable to Superstition. To proceed,
III. As to the Inventors of Religion, their not believing what they
taught concerning it, which is the last pretence, This comes with an ill
grace from an Atheist, who, under cover of an unquestionable maxim,
That, in matters of speculation, reason and not authority should deter-
mine the judgment, despiseth all Authority, so as to oppose his own
singularities against the common voice of mankind. Was it true,
then, that the inventors did not believe what they taught, this would
be seen to be a very poor argument against the truth of religion.
But indeed, the supposition is absolutely false; and betrays gross
ignorance of the true character of the ancient Lawgivers. The idea,
our adversaries have formed of these Civilizers of mankind (as men
are but too apt, in their representations of others, to copy from
themselves) is of a species of sly cold-headed Cheats, whose capacity
arose only from the predominancy of their phlegm. But the History
of all times might have told them, that, amongst the infirmities of
Heroes, a deficiency of Faith is not one. Diodorus was so sensible of
their propensity to be on the believing side, that he makes it a
question, Whether those ancient Lawgivers whom he there enume-
rates, did not really believe the divine Mission they professed to
execute? ‘They did this” (says he) “either because they really
thought that the conceptions which they had formed, so productive
of public good, must needs be strictly supernatural and divine.” -—
And I may venture to affirm, That there never was a great Conqueror,
a Founder of Cwwil Policy, or the Preacher up of a new Religion, (if
he succeeded by mere human means) but who was naturally much
incined to Enrnusiasm. Not that I suppose the heat of Hxthu-
siasm is not always tempered, in Heroes, with an equal share of
crart and policy. This extraordinary composition makes their true
* Φευκτέον οὖν αὐτὴν ἀσφαλῶς τε καὶ συμφερόντως, οὐχ ὥσπερ οἱ λῃστῶν ἢ Snplov
ἔφοδον, ἢ wip ἀπερισκέπτως καὶ ἄλογίστως wepipevyovtes, ἐμπίπτουσιν εἰς ἀνοδίας
βάραθρα καὶ κρημνοὺς ἐχούσας" οὕτως γὰρ ἔνιοι φεύγοντες τὴν δεισιδαιμονίαν, ἐμπίπ-
τουσιν εἰς ἀθεότητα τραχεῖαν καὶ ἀντίτυπον, ὑπερπηδήσαντες ἐν μέσῳ κειμένην τὴν
εὐσέθειαν.---Ῥ, 298. + Εἴτε ϑαυμαστὴν καὶ delay ὅλως ἔννοιαν εἶναι κρίναντας τὴν
μέλλουσαν ὠφελήσειν ἀνθρώπων ταλῆθος. elre.—Lib. i. p. 59. Steph. edit.
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 93
character : A character so much better conceived than expressed, that
it hath embarrassed the pen even of a Livy to delineate correctly.*
But the necessity of this odd-paired union appears plainly from
the nature of things. A mere cold-headed Contriver, without any
tincture of natural enthusiasm, can never succeed in his designs ;
because such a One can never supply those surprising freaks, which a
heated imagination, working on a disordered, though, for this pur-
pose, fitly-framed temper of body, so speciously exhibits. For the
spirits of the PeopLe who are to be taken in, can never be allured
but by raising their Admiration, and keeping up their confidence, by
the aid of an inspired Leader. Besides, new doctrines and new ideas
are never so readily received as when the Teacher of them is in
earnest, and believes himself: for then there is something so natural
in his conduct, so alluring in his behaviour, as easily conciliates
wavering opinions ; and acts, on his followers; like fascination, or a
charm. This made an ingenious French writer not scruple to say ;
““Give me but half a dozen men whom I can thoroughly persuade
that it is not the Sun makes the day, and I would not despair of
seeing whole nations brought over to the same opinion.’’+
On the other hand, a mere Enthusiast, who by virtue of his fanati-
cism, hath gone so far in his purpose, as to raise the admiration, and
captivate the spirits of the Populace, must here begin to fail for want
of the other quality, of sectarian craft ; for his imagination not being
under the government of his judgment, he will want the proper
dexterity to apply the different views, tempers, and stations of the
People, now enflamed, and ready to become his instruments for the
attainment of his purpose.
But when these two talents of Fraud and Fanaticism unite to fur-
nish out a Hero, or Leader of a sect, great will be the success of his
undertakings. The sallies of enthusiasm will be so corrected by his
cunning, as to strengthen and confirm his supernatural pretences :
And the cold and slow advances of a too cautious policy, will be
warmed and pushed forward by the force of his fanaticism. His craft
will enable him to elude the enquiries and objections of the more
rational; and his visions will irrecoverably subdue all the warmer
noddles. In a word, they will mutually strengthen and enforce each
other’s power ; and cover and repair each other’s defects. St. Jerom
seems to have had some idea of this extraordinary combination, when
he said, “ Nullus potest Heeresin struere, nisi qui ARDENTIS INGENII
est, et habet pona Natur.” Which may be thus paraphrased,—
No Heretic will ever be able to raise a Sect, but he, in whose constitu-
* See note MM, at the end of this book. t ** Donnez moi une demi-dozaine de
persomnes, a qui je puisse persuader que ce n’est pas le Soleil qui fait le jour, je ne
desesperai pas que des nations entieres n’embrassent cette opinion.’’—FoONTENELLE,
Hist. des Oracles, cap. xi.
24 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK It.
tion Nature hath enabled Fraud and Fanaticism to act in concert.
And indeed, there are so many powerful and opposite interests to
overcome and reconcile, so much caprice and humour to cajole, and
artfully to-apply ; that it is not strange, if no one ever yet succeeded
in any great design, where a whole People was the instrument, who
had not reconciled in himself, by a happy union, these two qualities
seemingly incompatible.
Several things concur to facilitate this conjunction. An Enthusiast
considers himself as an instrument employed by Providence to attain
some great End, for the sake of which he was sent out. This makes
him diligent in his Work ; impatient under let or impediment, and
disposed to practise every means for removing them. Persuaded of
the necessity of the ENp, and of the reality of the divine Commission
intrusted to him, for procuring it, he begins to fancy that One 50.
employed, is dispensed with, in breaking, nay is authorized to break,
the Common-Law of Morality ; which, in the cant of that fatal time
~ when Fanaticism had its full swing amongst us, was called the BEING
ABOVE ORDINANCES. In the first application of these extraordinary
MEANS the People are the Dupes of their Leader: But the success
~ being frequently even beyond his own expectation, he becomes, in his
turn, the Dupe of his own contrivance ; and begins in good earnest
to believe that the trick which he played them was indeed not of his
own invention, but the inspired instigation of Heaven.* This may
serve to explain an obscure passage of Tacitus, where speaking of this
sort of Character, he says, in his Oracular way, FINGUNT sIMUL
CREDUNTQUE.
To confirm all this, it might be easily made appear, by an historical
deduction from ancient and modern Times, that all those successful
Disturbers or Benefactors of mankind, who have prospered in their
designs, were indebted for their good fortune to the mutual assistance
of these two Qualities. By this operation, under the management of
such as Manomet, I@narius Loroxna, and. OLivER CROMWELL,
great and powerful empires have been created out of nothing.
And again, it might be shewn, that those, who are upon the
records of History for having failed, were either mere Enthusiasts,
who knew not how to push their projects, when they had disposed
the People to support them; or else mere Politicians, who could
never advance their wise schemes so far, as to engage a fanatic Popu-
lace to second them; or lastly, which most deserves our observation,
such as had the two qualities in conjunction, but in a reverted order.
Of each of which defects, we have domestic examples in the three
great Companions of the last successful Impostor, mentioned above ;
I mean in Furetwoop, LAMBERT, and VaANE.—CroMWELL had
* See note NN, at the end of this book.
SECT. Vi. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. ¢
wo
2)
prepared the way for their succession to his power, as thoroughly as
Mahomet had done for that of Abubeker, Omar, and Othman. Yet
these various wants defeated all their efforts, and rendered all his pre-
parations fruitless. Fleetwood wasa frank enthusiast, without parts or
capacity ; Lambert a cool contriver, without fanaticism ; and Sir Harry
Vane, who had great parts, and as great enthusiasm, yet had them,
and used them, in so preposterous an order as to do him no kind of
service. For the history of those times informs us, that he began a
sober and sedate plotter: But, when now come in view of the goal, he
started out the wildest and most extravagant of Fanatics: In a word,
he ended just where his MAsTER began: so that we need not wonder
his fortune proved so different. But this was a Course as rare as it
appears to be retrograde. The affections naturally keep another
Order. And the reason is evident. Hnthusiasm is a kind of ebul-
lition, or critical ferment of the Mind; which a vigorous nature can
work through ; and, by slow degrees, be able to cast off. Hence the
most successful Impostors, as we say, have set out in all the blaze of
Fanaticism, and completed their schemes amidst the cool depth and
stillness of Politics. Though this be common to them all, yet I don’t
know any who exemplifies it so strongly as the famous Ienatrus
Loroxa. ‘This illustrious personage, who confirms the observation of
one who came after him,* and almost equalled him in his trade,
“that a man never rises so high as when he does not know whither
he is going,” began his extasies in the mire: and completed his
schemes with the direction and execution of Councils, that, even in his
own life-time, were ready to give the law to Christendom. Yea, the
same spirit of Enthusiasm so regulated and conducted is no less
serviceable to Nations and to Bodies of Men than it is to particulars.
This built up old and new Rome. Prophane history tells us, that
when the City had not six miles of dominion beyond it’s Walls, it
indulged the dream of UntversaL Monarcuy; and we learn by
the ecclesiastical, that when the jurisdiction of the Bishops of Rome
extended not beyond a small Diocese, they entertained the celestial
vision of aPorEpom. And it was this spirit, which, in defiance, and
to the destruction, of Civil Policy and Religion, made the fortune of
Both.
But these things belong rather to the History of the human Mind
than to the work I have in hand: and besides, would keep me too
long from the conclusion of the volume,t to which I am now has-
tening. I will only observe, that this high Enthusiasm was so
conspicuous in the character of ancient Heroism, and so powerful
in making easy the most difficult undertakings, that the learned
Varro scruples not to say, ‘It is of great advantage to Society, that
* CROMWELL. + The second volume of the edition in 8vo. 1766.
26 THE DIVINE LEGATION - BOOK 111,
Heroes should believe themselves the offspring of the Gods, whether -
indeed they be so or not. That by this means, the mind, confiding
in its divine original, may rise above Humanity; so as more sub-
limely to project, more boldly to execute, and more happily to estab-
lish the grand schemes it labours with, for the service of mankind.”’*
Hence it appears, that if Religion were a cheat, the LeGisLaTors
themselves were among the first who fell into the deceit.
On the whole then we see, That of all these mediums, whereby our
adversaries would infer that Religion is false, because invented by
Statesmen, the ¢Aird, which is most to their purpose, proves nothing :
While, of the other fwo, the first is a high presumption of its truth ;
and the second, a demonstration of it.
I have said, that it was (I don’t know how) taken on all hands for
granted, that the invention of Religion by Politicians inferred its fals-
hood. But, on second thoughts, I am persuaded, the too great
facility in agreeing to this conclusion arose from hence; The popular
argument of the innate idea of God, had been for many ages esteemed
a demonstration of his Being and Attributes: And the political origin
of Religion overthrowing that argument, it was too hastily concluded
that it overthrew the truth of Religion in general : For prejudice had
established this consequence, If no innate idea of God, Then no God
ai all.
BM.
But now, although (as hath been proved) the granting this infidel
pretence doth not at all affect the truth of NATURAL RELIGION ; yet
it doth by accident, and by accident only, affect the truth of Reve-
LATION : Because Holy Scripture hath given us a different account of
the origin of divine worship.
I shall shew therefore, in the next place, that the Notion is as false
and visionary, as it is vain and impertinent; first, by examining”
the circumstances from which its pretended truth is inferred ; and
secondly, by producing plain matter of fact to the contrary.
I. The first of these circumstances is, That the Lawgiver employed
his utmost pains and labour in teaching, propagating, and establishing
Religion. But what can be inferred from this but that he employed
his pains from a full conviction of its utility? And how should he
come by that conviction but from observing the effects of its influence
on the actions of men? Which must needs suppose him to have
found, and not to have invented Religion.
If this argument against Religion hath any weight, we must con-
clude the Magistrate was not only the inventor of xatural Reiicion,
* “ Utile est civitatibus, ut se viri fortes, etiamsi falsum sit, ex diis genitos esse cre- ἢ
dant, ut eo modo animus humanus, velut divine stirpis fiduciam gerens, res magnas
aggrediendas presumat audacius, agat vehementius, et ob hoc impleat ipsa securitate
felicius.””— Apud Aucust. Civ. Dei, lib. iii. cap. 4.
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 27
but of natural Jusrice likewise; for he took the same pains in
teaching, propagating, and establishing both. But will any one pre-
tend to say, that men, in a’state of nature, had no ideas of justice ?
Indeed, both one and the other had lost much of their efficacy, when
men applied to the civil Magistrate for relief: And this explains the
reason why, on their entering into Society, the Legislator was always
so intent upon RELIGION ; namely, that he might recover it from the
powerless condition, to which it was then reduced.
It will be said, perhaps, that the Atheist doth, in fact, contend,
that natural justice was an invention of Politicians, as well as
Religion. We have seen, indeed, a Countryman of our own, who
hath made this proposition the foundation of his Philosophy, ¢hat
Just and Unjust arose from the Civil Magistrate. But then, he never
supposed, that men, before Society, had no idea of these things: All
he would contend for was, that the idea (when and wherever got
before) was merely fantastic.
II. The other, and more peculiar circumstance from which our
adversaries infer their paradox, is, that the first and original idolatry
was the worship of DEAD MEN? And these being Lawgivers, Magis-
trates, and public Benefactors, Religion appears to have been a politi-
cal Institution, So among the Ancients. EunrmeErus, surnamed
the Atheist, wrote a treatise to prove that the first gods of Greece
were dead men ; which, Cicero, who saw his drift, rightly observed,
tended to overturn all religion.* And so, amongst the Moderns,
ToLAND, the pious author of the PanruetstTicon, with the same
design, wrote a pamphlet, intitled, Of the origin of Idolatry, and
reasons of Heathenism. It is not unpleasant to observe the uniform
conduct of this noble pair of writers, which one never fails to find in
authors of a like character, how distant soever in time or country.
Euhemerus pretended his design was only to expose the popular
religion of Greece; and Toland, that his great learning was only
pointed against Pagan idolatry, while the real end of both was the
destruction of Religion in general.
It must be owned, that this circumstance, of the first and original
idolatry, hath a face (but a very false one) of plausibility; being
manifestly founded on this sophism, That the first idolatry, and
the first religious worship, are one and the same thing. Whereas, it
is not only possible that the worship of the first Cause of all things
should be prior to any Idol worship; but, in the highest degree,
probable that it was: Idol worship having none of the marks of an
original practice ; and all the circumstances attending a depraved and
corrupt Institution.
But it being utterly false that the worship of dead men was the
* Nat. Deor. lib. i. cap. 42.
28 ὶ ᾿ς THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK 111].
primitive Idolatry, We shall endeavour to convince these men of a
Facr they are so unwilling to see or acknowledge.
I was pleased to find a book, like this of Toland’s, written pro-
fessedly on the subject ; being in hopes to meet with something like
argument or learning, that would justify an examination of it: For an
answer to a licentious writer arrests the attention of common readers,
better than general reasoning, though this goes more directly to the
fact, and determines the question with greater precision. But I had
the mortification to find nothing there but an indigested heap of
common-place quotations from the Ancients; and an unmeaning
collection of common-place reflexions from modern infidels ; without.
the least seasoning of logic or criticism, to justify the waste of time
to the Reader, or to make the labour supportable to one’s self. And
the authority of the man, which is nothing, could not engage me to
any farther notice of his book. But another, whose name stands _
justly highest in the learned world, and whose heart was as unlike
this writer’s as his head, seems to be of the same opinion concerning
the primitive idolatry. It is the incomparable Newron in his Chro-
nology of the Greeks. His words are these: ‘‘ lacus the son of
Aigina, who was two generations older than the Trojan war, is by
some reputed one of the first who built a temple in Greece. Oracles
came first from Egypt into Greece about the same time, as also did
the custom of forming the images of the gods with their legs bound up
in the shape of the Egyptian mummies: For 1poLaTrRy began in
Chaldeea and Egypt, and spread thence, &e.—The countries upon the
Tigris and the Nile being exceeding fertile, were first frequented by
mankind, and grew first into kingdoms, and therefore began first to
adore their dead kings and queens.’’* This great man, we see, takes
at for granted, that the worship of dead men was the First kind of
idolatry: And so only ixsinuates a reason for this supposed fact,
namely, that the worship of dead men introduced image worship : For,
the Egyptians first worshipped dead men 7” person, that is, in their
mummies ; + which when lost, consumed, or destroyed, were wor-
shipped by representation, under an image made with its legs bound
up, in likeness of the mummies. The reader now will be curious to
know how ¢his infers the other, that the worship of dead men was
the primitive idolatry? All I can say to it is, that the excellent
person seems to have put the change upon himself, in supposing
image worship inseparably attendant on idolatry in general ; when it
was but commonly attendant on Hero-worship ; and rarely upon the
Elementary. As to the elementary, Herodotus tells us that the
Persians, who worshipped the celestial bodies, had no statues of their
* “Chronology of ancient Kingdoms,” p. 160. + See book IV. plate IX.
fig. 1, 2, and 3, compared together,
ὡς
x
4
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 29
Gods at all: And as to Hero-worship, we are assured by Dionysius
Halicarnasseus, that the Romans, whose Gods were dead men deified,
worshipped them, during some ages, without statues.
But to come closer to the point: Our Adversaries overturn their
position, on the very entrance on the question. The grand symbol
of the Atheistic school is, that Fear FIRST MADE GODS:
“ Primus in orbe Deos fecit timor.”’
And yet, if we will believe them, these first gods were dead men,
‘deified for their PUBLIC BENEFITS to their country or mankind:
«Not only” (says Toland) ‘kings and queens, great generals and
legislators, the patrons of learning, promoters of curious arts, and
authors of useful inventions, partook of this honour; but also such
private persons, as by their virtuous actions had distinguished them-
selves from others.”’ *
But to pass this over. Their great principle of FEAR is every way
destructive of their System: For those very ages of the world, in
which rEAR most prevailed, and was the predominant passion of man-
kind, were the times BEFORE civil society; when every man’s hand
was against his brother. If fear then was the origin of Religion,
Religion, without question, was BEFORE civil Society.
But neither to insist upon this: Let us hear what the ancient
Theists thought of the matter. They said it was Love, and not
FEAR, which was the origin of Religion. Thus Seneca: ‘ Nee in
hune furorem omnes mortales consensissent alloquendi surda numina
et inefficaces deos ; nisi nossent ilorum BENEFICIA nunc ultro oblata,
nunc orantibus data; magna, tempestiva, ingentes minas interventu
suo solventia. Quis est autem tam miser, tam neglectus, quis tam
duro fato, et in peenam genitus, ut non tantam deorum munificentiam
senserit ? Ipsos illos complorantes sortem suam, et querulos circum-
spice, invenies non ex toto beneficiorum ccelestium expertes ; neminem
esse, ad quem non aliquid ex illo BENIGNISSIMO FONTE manaverit.”’ +
But as HOPE and FEAR, LOVE and HATRED, are the cardinal
hinges, on which all human actions and cogitations turn, I suppose it
was neither one nor other of these passions alone, but both of them
together, which opened to those early Mortals (whose uncultivated
reason had not yet gained the Anowledge, or whose degenerate man-
ners had now lost the ¢radition of the TRUE Gop) the first idea of
superior Beings. ‘
I. Such men, in a state of nature, whose subsistence was wmmedi-
ately to be supplied by the product of the earth, would be exact
observers of what facilitated or retarded those supplies: So that of
* “Letters to Serena,” Tract of the Origin of Idolatry, p. 73. + De Benef.
lib. iv. cap. 4.
90 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IIt.
course, the grand genial Power of the system, that visible God the
Sun, would be soon regarded by them as a most beneficent Deity:
And thunder and lightning, storms and tempests, which his Qualities
produced, would be considered as the effects of his anger. The rest
of the celestial Orbs would, in proportion to their use and appearance,
be regarded in the same light. That noble fragment from SancHo-
NIATHO, quoted above,* as part of the History rehearsed in the
ἀπόῤῥητα of the Mysteries, gives this very original to idolatry. It
tells us that ‘* Genos and Genea (begotten of the two first mortals,
Protogonus and Afon) in the time of great droughts, stretched out
their hands towards the sun, whom they regarded as a God, and sole
Ruler of the heavens. After two or three generations, came
Upsouranios and his brother Ousous. These consecrated two pillars
to FIRE and wIND, and then offered bloody sacrifices to them, as to
Gods.” This is a very natural account of the origine and FrrsT spe-
cies of Idolatry. That it is the true, we shall now endeavour to shew.
1. Those ancient people of the North and South, the Suevi, the
Arabs, and Africans, who lived long uncivilized, and in tribes, were all
worshippers of the celestial bodies. The same appears to have been
the case of the Chinese ; of the North Americans; and of the people
of Mexico and Peru; as may be collected from what is said above, of
their first Lawgivers pretending to be the offspring of the Sua and
Heaven :+ For we may be assured they had the sense to chuse a
well-established authority, under which to set up their own
Pretensions.
2. But all Antiquity concurs in asserting, that the first religious
adoration, paid to the Creature, was the worship of heavenly Bodies.
This was so evident, and so universally acknowledged, that Cririas
himself, as we see,t was forced to allow its truth. And this being
the entire overthrow of his system of the origin of religion, nothing
but the fullest evidence could have extorted the confession from him.
To support so manifest a point with a long heap of quotations,
would be trifling with the reader’s patience.
To cut the matter short, Eusrsrus expressly affirms, and attempts
to strengthen his position by an etymology of the word ΘΕΟΣ, that
no Beings were anciently accounted Gods or divine, neither dead men,
nor demons good or bad; but the stars of heaven only.§
* < Divine Legation,” vol. i. p. 213. 7 “1,8 Soueit est la divinité des peuples
de l’Amerique, sans en excepter aucun de ceux qui nous sont connus.”—LaFiTau,
Meurs des sauvages Ameriquains, tom, i..p. 130. t See his Iambics in note
KK, at the end of this book, p. 80. § PAAA’ ὅτι μὲν of τορῶτοι καὶ τσαλαιότατοι
τῶν ἀνθρώπων, οὔτε ναῶν οἰκοδομίαις ταροσεῖχον---ὅτι δὲ οὐδὲ τῶν μετὰ ταῦτα κατω-
νομασμένων Seay τε καὶ ἡρώων μνήμη τις τοῖς τοτε πσαρῆν, οὔτ᾽ οὖν τις ἣν αὐτοῖς
Ζεὺς, οὐ Κρόνος, 8..---ἀαἀλλὰ οὐδὲ δαίμων τις ἀγαθὸς ἢ φαῦλος ἐν ἀνθρώποις ἐθαυμάζετο"
μόνα δὲ τὰ φαινόμενα τῶν οὐρανίων ᾿Αστρῶν, τσαρὰ τὸ ϑέειν, ὅπερ ἐστὶ τρέχειν, ϑεῶντε
ταροσηγορίας, ws αὐτοί φασιν ervyxave.—Prep. Evang, lib. i. cap. 9.
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED, 21
But as Greece and Eeyrr, the two Countries where civil Policy
took deepest root, ‘and spread its largest influence, had, by the long
custom of deifying their public Benefactors, so erased the memory of
a prior idolatry, as to have this second species of it, by some moderns,
deemed the first ; I shall produce an ancient testimony or two, of the
highest credit, to shew that the adoration of the celestial “Bodies was
the first idol-worship in those two grand Nurseries of Superstition, as
well as in all other places.
1. Iv APPEARS TO ΜῈ (says PuavTo in his Cratylus) THAT THE
FIRST MEN WHO INHABITED GREECE, HELD THOSE ONLY TO BE
GODS, WHICH MANY BARBARIANS AT PRESENT WORSHIP; NAMELY,
THE SUN, MOON, EARTH, STARS, AND HEAVEN.* he barbarians
here hinted at, were both such as remained in, and such as had got
out of, the state of nature. As first, the civilized Persians, of whom
Heropores gives this account : ‘ They worship the Sun, Moon, and
Karth, Fire, Water, and the Winds: And this adoration they have all
along paid from the very beginning. Afterwards, indeed, they
learned to worship Urania,’ + &c. And so goes on to speak of their
later idolatry of dead mortals. Secondly, the savage Africans, of
whom the same Herodotus says, ‘They worship only the Sun and
Moon: The same do all the Africans.”’ 7
2. Droporus Sicuuus, speaking of the Eeyprtrans, tells us,
THAT THE FIRST MEN LOOKING UP TO THE WORLD ABOVE THEM,
AND TERRIFIED AND STRUCK WITH ADMIRATION AT THE NATURE
OF THE UNIVERSE, SUPPOSED THE SUN AND MOON TO BE THE
PRINCIPAL AND ETERNAL GODS.§ The reason which the historian
assigns, makes his assertion general; and shews he believed this
idolatry to be the first every where else, as well as in Eaypr. But
that it was so there, we have likewise good internal evidence, from a
circumstance in their hieroglyphics, the most ancient method of
recording knowledge : Where, as we are told by Horus Apollo, a srar
denoted or expressed the idea of the Drtry.||
Such was the genius and state of Idolatry in the uNcrIvILIzEeD
world. So that the Author of the book called, The Wisdom of
Solomon, said well, ““ Surely vain are all men by nature who are
ignorant of God; and could not by considering the Work, acknow-
ledge the Work-master : but deemed either Fire or Winp, or the
* Φαίνονταί μοι of wpaTo των ἀνθρώπων περὶ τὴν Ἑλλάδα τούτους μόνους ϑεοὺς
ἡγεῖσθαι, ὥσπερ νῦν πσολλοὶ τῶν βαρθάρων. Ἥλιον, καὶ Σελήνην, καὶ Γῆν, καὶ ἴΑστρα,
καὶ Οὐρανόν. t Θύουσι δὲ Ἡλίῳ τε καὶ Σελήνῃ, καὶ Γῇ, καὶ Πυρὶ, καὶ Ὕγδατι. καὶ
᾿Ανέμοισι" τούτοισι μὲν δὴ μούνοισι δύουσι ἀρχῆθεν" ἐπεμεμαθήκασι δὲ καὶ τῇ Οὐρανίῃ
Svew.— Lib. i. cap. 131. t Θύουσι δὲ Ἡλίῳ καὶ Σελήνῃ μούνοισι" τούτοισι μὲν νῦν
-ὡάντες Λίβυες ϑύουσι.---Τ 1}. iv. cap. 188. § Τοὺς ἀνθρώπους τὸ τσαλαιὸν γενομένους
ἀναδλέψαντας εἰς τὸν κόσμον, καὶ τὴν τῶν ὅλων φύσιν καταπλαγέντας καὶ ϑαυμάσαντας,
ὑπολαβεῖν εἶναι ϑεοὺς ἀϊδίους τε καὶ wpwrovs, τόν τε Ἥλιον καὶ Σελήνην.--- 1,1}. i.
|| ᾿Αστὴρ wap Αἰγυπτίοις γραφόμενος Θεὸν onuatver.—Lib. ii. cap. 1,
32 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK 111.
swift air, or the circle of the stars, or the violent water, or the
Liguts or Heaven, to be the Gops which govern the World.” ἢ
II. But when now Society had produced those mighty blessings,
which exalt our brutal nature to a life of elegance and reason; and,
in exchange for penury, distress, and danger, had established safety,
and procured all the accommodations of Civil intercourse, the RELI-
GIous system received as great, though far from so advantageous, a
change as the POLITICAL.
1. GRatTiruDE and ADMIRATION, the warmest and most active
affections of our nature, concurred to enlarge the object of Religious
worship ; and to make men regard those BENEFACTORS OF HUMAN
NATURE, the Founders of Society, as having more in them than a
common ray of the Divinity. So that, god-like benefits bespeaking,
as it were, a god-like Mind, the deceased ParENT oF A PEOPLE
easily advanced into an ImmMortaL. From hence arose, though not
till some time after, their metaphysical distribution of Souls into the
several classes of human, heroic, and demonic. A distinction which
served greatly to support this species of Idolatry.,
2. When the religious bias was in so good a train, NATURAL
AFFECTION would have its share in advancing this new mode of
Adoration. Piety τὸ Parents would easily take the lead; as it
was supported by gratitude and admiration, the ‘‘ primum mobile” of
this whole system: The natural Father of the Tribe often happening
to be the political Father of the People, and Founder of the State.
3. FonpNESS FOR THE OrrspRING would next have its turn.
And a disconsolate Father, at the head of a People, would contrive to
sooth his grief for the untimely death of a favourite child, and to
gratify his pride under the want of Succession, by paying divine
honours to its memory. “For a Father afflicted with untimely
mourning, when he had made an image of his child, soon taken
away, now honoured him as a God, which was then a dead man, and
delivered, TO THOSE THAT WERE UNDER HIM, ceremonies and
sacrifices.” +
4, Lastly, the Sussect’s REVERENCE for his Master, the Cirr-
ZEN’S VENERATION for the Law-giver, would not be far behind, to
complete this religious Farce of mistaken gratitude and affection.
This was the course of the SECOND SPECIES OF IDOLATRY; as we
may collect from ancient history both sacred and profane: And,
especially, from the famous fragment of SancuHonrarso, which
partakes so much of 60th; where these various motives for this
species of Idolatry are recounted in express words: “After many
generations came Chrysor; and he INVENTED many things useful to
civil life ; for which, after his decease, he was worshipped as a God.
* Chap. xiii. 1, 2. + “Wisdom of Solomon,” xiv, 15.
SECT, VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 33
Then flourished Ouranos and his sister Ge ; who deified and offered
sacrifices to their Farner Upsistos, when he had been torn in pieces
by wild beasts. Afterwards Cronos consecrated Muth his Son, and
was himself consecrated by his Sussects.” *
IIT. But Idolatry did not stop here. For when men, as the
Apostle says, would not retain God in their knowledge, He gave them
up to their own vain imaginations, whereby they changed the truth of
God into a lye—into an image made like to corruptible man, and to
birds, and to four-footed beasts, and to creeping things.t How this
last monstrous change was effected, I have discoursed of at large,
elsewhere.t It is sufficient to observe at present, that it was begun
in Egypt, and was propagated from thence: Where the method of
their Learned, to record the history of their Hero-gods, in improved
hieroglyphics, gave birth to Brurr-worsuip. For the characters of
this kind of writing being the figures of animals, which stood for
marks of their ELEMENTARY Gops, and principally of their
HEROES, soon made their Hieroglyphics, sacred. And this, in no
great space of time, introduced a symMBouic worship of their Gods,
under hieroglyphic Figures. But the People (how naturally, we may
see by the practice of saint-worship in the church of Rome) presently
forgot the symbol or relation; and depraved this superstition still
farther, by a direct worship: till at length, the animals themselves,
whose figures these hieroglyphic marks represented, became the object
of religious adoration. Which species of Idolatry, by the credit and
commerce of the EGypriaAns, and their Carriers and Factors the
PH@NICIANS, in course of time, spread amongst many other
nations. And this was the THIRD AND LAST ΒΡΕΟΙΕΒ of Pagan
Idolatry.
And here again, as well for the original as the order of this
Idolatry, we have the confirmation of SANCHONIATHO’S authority :
* Ouranos”’ (says he) “‘was the Inventor of the Betylia, a kind of
ANIMATED STONES framed with great art. And Taautus {the
Egyptian] formed ALLEGORIC FIGURES, CHARACTERS AND IMAGES
of the celestial Gods and Elements.” ὃ
By these animated stones (as is observed above) must needs be
meant, stones cut into a human figure. For, before this invention,
brute, unformed, or pyramidal Stones, were consecrated and adored.
The allegorie figures and characters more plainly describe Hiero-
glyphic writing: From whence, as we say, this species of Idolatry
was first derived.
This is a plain, consistent account of THE RISE AND PROGRESS OF
PaGan IpoLatrRy; supported as well by the scattered evidence of
* See vol. i. p. 213. + Rom. i. 23. 1 Book iv. sect. 4. § See
vol. i. p. 213.
VOL. II. D
94 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK III.
Antiquity, as by the more certain reason of things. I say, ‘the
scattered evidence of Antiquity:’? For I know of no writer who
hath given us a direct, or so much as consistent, account of this
matter. And it is no wonder. For a system of Religion, of which
the MorTAL Gops are so considerable a part, would appear too hard
even for the digestion of the People. An expedient therefore was
soon found, and by a very natural incident, to throw a veil over this
shocking absurdity ; and this was by pretending one while, to those
who grew inquisitive concerning the nature of the Hero-Gods, that
these Gods were only symgotic of the Celestia/: and at another, to
those who pried too closely into the ELEMENTARY worship, that this
was only syMBOLICAL of their Heroes: who were not dead men, as
might be suspected, but a species of superior Beings, which, in
affection to mankind, had once been conversant on Earth: and
whom, now, a deification had reinstated in their original Rights.
Thus the popular belief presented nothing but one uniform order of
Immortats: The secret of the human original of one part of them
being reserved for the private instruction of the MYSTERIES.
This cover for their absurd Idolatries, would naturally produce two
orthodox Parties of Symbolizers in the Pagan Church. They, who
most favoured HERo-worship, would find the Symbol in ELEMENT-
Ary: And they, who best liked the Hlementary, would find the
Symbol in the Heroic. Both parties, as usual, laid claim to primi-
tive Antiquity. For true it is, that the DEGREES and MANNER by
which the early Mortals supERINDUCED the worship of dead men on
the primary idolatrous worship of the heavenly Bodies, gave coun-
tenance to either side. This was the natural incident I spoke of
above, as favouring the expedient employed to hide the dishonours of
Paganism. The matter is worth knowing; and I shall endeavour to
explain it.
1. The first step to the AporHrosts was the complimenting their
Heroes and public Beneractors, with the Name of that Being,
which was most esteemed and worshipped. Thus a King, for his
beneficence, was called the Sun; and a Queen, for her beauty, the
Moon. Diodorus relates, that Sou FirsT REIGNED IN EGyPpT;
CALLED SO FROM THE LUMINARY OF THAT NAME IN THE
HEAVENS.* This will help us to understand an odd passage in the
fragment of Sanchoniatho, where it is said, “that Cronus had seven
sons by Rhea, the youngest of which was made a God, as soon as
born.” + The meaning, I suppose, is, that this youngest son was
* Πρῶτον μὲν Ἥλιον βασιλεῦσαι τῶν κατ᾽ Αἴγυπτον, ὁμώνυμον ὄντα τῷ κατ᾽ οὐρανὸν
ἄστρῳ.---Τὴν. i. In the language of Egypt called men, as we see in Herod. lib. ii. cap.
99. The practice of Assyrian superstition was the same ; their king Belus being named
from Baal the Sun. + Τῷ αὐτῷ [Κρόνῳ] γίνονται amd Ῥέας waides ἑπτά" ὧν ὃ
νεώτατος ἅμα τῇ γενέσει ἀφιερώθη.
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 85
called after some luminary in the Heavens, to which they paid
divine honours: and these honours came, in time, to be transferred
to the terrestrial name-sake. The same Historian had before told us,
that the sons of Guenos, mortals like their father, were called by the
names of the elements, light, fire, and flame, whose use they had
discovered.* Ἶ
2. As this adulation advanced into an Established worship, they
turned the compliment the other way: And now the Planet or
Luminary was called after the Hero; I suppose, the better to
accustom the people, even in the act of Planet-worship, to this new
adoration. Diodorus, in the passage quoted a little before, having
told us that the Sun and Moon were the first Gods of Egypt, adds,
THE FIRST OF WHICH, THEY CALLED OSIRIS, AND THE OTHER
Ists.+ But this was the general practice. So the Ammonites
called the Sun, Moloch; the Syrians, ddad; the Arabs, Dionysius ;
the Assyrians, Belus; the Persians, Mithra; the Pheenicians,
Saturn; the Carthaginians, Hercules; and the Palmyrians, 1716-
gabalus.t Again, the Moon, by the Phrygians was called Cybele, or
the mother of the Gods; by the Athenians, Minerva ; by the
Cyprians, Venus; by the Cretans, Diana; by the Sicilians, Proser-
pine; by others, Hecate, Bellona, Urania, Vesta, Lucina,§ &e.
Philo Byblius, in Eusebius, explains this practice: “It is remark-
able” (says he) “that they [the ancient idolaters] imposed on the —
ELEMENTS, and on those parts of nature which they esteemed Gods,
the NAMES OF THEIR KINGS: For the natural Gods, which they
acknowledged, were only the Sun, Moon, Planets, Elements, and the
like; they being, now, in the humour of having Gods of both classes,
the MoRTAL and the IMMORTAL.” ||
3. As a further proof that Hero-worship was thus sewperinduced
upon the planetary, let me add a very singular circumstance in the
first formation of STATUES, consecrated to the Hero-Gods ; of which
circumstance, both ancient €] and modern ** writers have been at a
loss to assign a reason. It is, that these first Statues were not of
Auman form, but CONICAL and pyRAMIDAL. Thus the Scholiast, on
the Vespe of Aristophanes, tells us, that the Statues of Apollo and
Ἑξῆς, φησὶν, ἀπὸ Γένους γενηθῆναι αὖθις waidas ϑνητοὺς, ois εἶναι ὀνόματα, Pas
καὶ Πῦρ καὶ Φλόξ' οὗτοι, φησὶν, ἐκ τσαρατριδῆς ξύλων εὗρον wip, καὶ τὴν χρῆσιν ἐδίδαξαν.
—Eusesil Prep. Evang. lib. 1. cap. 10. 1 Ὑπολαβεῖν εἶναι Seovs aidlous τε καὶ
περώτους, τόν τε Ἥλιον καὶ Σελήνην, ὧν τὸν μὲν ἼΟσιριν, τὴν δὲ Ἴσιν ὀνόμασαι. --ΤΆ}». i.
566. Μάσβοβιι Saturnal. lib. i. cap. 17, et seq. § See AvuL. Melamorph.
|| Ἐξαιρέτως δὲ καὶ ἀπὸ τῶν σφετέρων βασιλέων, τοῖς κοσμικοῖς στοιχείοις, καί τισι τῶν
νομιζομένων ϑεῶν τὰς ὀνομασίας ἐπέθεσαν, φυσικοὺς δὲ, ἥλιον καὶ σελήνην. καὶ τοὺς
λοιποὺς πλανήτας ἀστέρας, καὶ τὰ στοιχεῖα, καὶ τὰ τούτοις συναφῆ Θεοὺς μόνους
ἐγίνωσκον" ὥστ᾽ αὐτοῖς τοὺς μὲν ϑνητοὺς, τοὺς δὲ ἀθενάτους ϑεοὺς elva.—Prep, Evang.
lib. i. cap. 9. 4“ See CLEMENS ALEX. Strom. lib. i. p. 348, Par. ed. ** See
Spencer De Legibus Heb. Rit. lib. ii. cap. 28, sect. 3.
pd 2
36 THE DIVINE LEGATION : BOOK III.
Bacchus were conic pillars, or Obelisks: * and Pausanias, that the
Statue of Jupiter Meilichius represented a Pyramid: + That of the
Argive Juno did the same, as appears from a verse of Phoronis,t
quoted by Clemens, intimating, that these pyramidal columns were
the first Statues of the Gods: And this practice was universal, as
well amongst the early Barbarians as.the Greeks. Now it is well
known that the Ancients represented the rays of Light under pillars
of this form: And we find, from the fragment of Sanchoniatho, that
Usous consecrated two cotumns to the Wind and Fire: Hence, the
erecting them as representatives of their Hero-gods shews how These
succeeded to the titles, rights, and honours of the natural and
celestial Deities.
To explain this matter at large would require a volume: It is
sufficient to have given this hint: which, if pursued, might perhaps
direct us to the right end of the clew of that hitherto inexplicable
labyrinth of Pagan Myrnonocy. The Reader sees clearly, by what
has been already said, that this unheeded, but very natural way of
superinducing Hero-worship on the Planetary, easily confounded the
different specieses: and afforded a plausible pretence for the two
Parties mentioned above, to make Either, symBoLICAL of the Other.
Here matters rested : and the vulgar Faith seems to have remained
a long time undisturbed. But as the Age grew refined, and the
Greeks became inquisitive and learned, the common MyTHoLoey
began to give offence. The Speculative and more Delicate were
shocked at the absurd and immoral stories of their Gods ; and scan-
dalized, to find such things make an authentic part of their story.
It may indeed be thought matter of wonder how such tales, taken up
in a barbarous age, came not to sink into oblivion as the age grew
more knowing; from mere abhorrence of their indecencies, and
shame of their absurdities. Without doubt, this had been their
fortune, but for an unlucky circumstance: The great Ports of
Greece, who had most contributed to refine the public taste and
manners, and were now grown into a kind of sacred authority, had
sanctified these silly Legends by their writings, which Time had now
consigned to immortality.
Vulgar Paganism, therefore, in such an Age as this, lying open to
the attacks of curious and inquisitive men, would not, we may well
think, be long at rest. It is true, Frer-rTH1nK1NnG then lay under
great difficulties and discouragements. To insult the Religion of one’s
“ Πρὸ τῶν Supav ἔθος εἶχον κίονας εἰς ὀξὺ λήγοντας, ws ὀβελίσκους ἱδρύειν εἰς τιμὴν
᾿Απόλλωνος ᾿Αγυιέως--- ἰδίους δὲ φασὶν αὐτοὺς εἶναι ᾿Απόλλωνος" οἱ δὲ Διονύσου" οἱ δὲ
ἀμφοῖν.---Σφηκές, ver. 870. t In Corin. p. 132.
1 Ἥρης ᾿Αργείης, ἢ στέμμασι καὶ ϑυσάνοισι,
Πρώτη ἐκόσμιζεν weph κίονα μακρὸν ἀνάσσης.--- Strom. lib. i.
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. ΘΩ͂
Country, which is now the mark of learned distinction, was branded,
in the ancient world, with public infamy. Yet Free-thinkers there
were: Who (as is their wont) together with the public worship of
their Country, threw off all reverence for Religion in general.
Amongst these was Evuemervs, the Messenian ; and, by what we
can learn, the most distinguished of this tribe. This man, in mere
wantonness of heart, began his attacks on Religion, by divulging the
secret of the Mysteries. But as it was capital to do this directly and
professedly, he contrived to cover his perfidy and malice by the inter-
vention of a kind of Utopian Romance. He pretended, “that in a
certain City, which he came to, in his travels, he found this GRAND
SECRET, that the Gods were dead men deified, preserved in their
sacred writings ; and confirmed by monumental records, inscribed to
the Gods themselves ; who were there said to be interred.’ So far
was not amiss. But then, in the genuine spirit of his Class, who
never cultivate a truth but in order to graft a lye upon it, he pre-
tended, “that DEAD MORTALS WERE THE FIRST Gops: And that
an imaginary Divinity in these early Heroes and Conquerors created
the idea of a superior Power ; and introduced the practice of religious
worship* amongst men.’ The learned reader sees below, that our
Free-thinker is true to his cause, and endeavours to verify the funda-
mental principle of his Sect, that FEAR first made Gods, even in that
very instance where the contrary passion seems to have been at its
height, the time when men made Gods of their deceased BENEFAC-
rors. A little matter of address hides the shame of so perverse a
piece of malice. He represents those Founders of Society, and
Fathers of their Country, under the idea of destructive Conquerors,
who by mere force and fear had brought men into subjection and
slavery. On this account it was that indignant Antiquity concurred
in giving EvHEmeERvs the proper name of ArHEist: which, how-
ever, he would hardly have escaped, though he had done no more
than divalge the Secret of the Mysteries ; and had not poisoned his
discovery with this impious and foreign addition, so contrary to the
true spirit of that Secret.
This detection had been long dreaded by the orthodox Protectors
of Pagan Worship: And they were provided of a temporary defence
in their intricate, and properly perplexed, system of syMBOLIC
ADORATION. But this would do only to stop a breach for the
present, till a better could be provided ; and was too weak to stand
alone, against so violent an attack. The PuiLosornuers, therefore,
; Ξ
“ Εὐήμερος δὲ, 6 ἐπικληθεὶς ἴΑθεος, φησὶν ὅτ᾽ ἦν ἄτακτος ἀνθρώπων Bios, οἱ weprye-
νόμενοι τῶν ἄλλων ἰσχύι τε καὶ συνέσει ὥστε wpds τὰ ὑπ᾽ αὐτῶν κελευόμενα ττάἬντας
= “ a “ a
βιοῦν, σπουδάζοντες μείζονος δαυμασμοῦ καὶ σεμνότητος τυχεῖν, ἀνέπλασαν wep) αὐτοὺς
« , ᾿ ΄ , Μ᾿ “ > 7)
ὑπερθάλλουσάν τινα καὶ δείαν δύναμιν, ἔνθεν καὶ τοῖς ἄλλοις ἐνομίσθησαν ϑεοί.-- ϑεχτ.
ΕΜΡΙΒ. Adversus Mathem.
98 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Ill.
now took up the defence of Paganism, where the Priests had left
it: And, to the other’s Sympons, added their own ALLEGORIES,
for a second cover to the absurdities of the ancient Mythology. So,
Mrinvucius Freiix—‘ Zenon, interpretando Junonem Aéra, Jovem
Ceelum, Neptunum Mare, Ignem esse Vulcanum, et ceteros similiter
vulgi Deos elementa esse monstrando, publicum arguit graviter et
revincit errorem. Eadem fere CurysipPus, vim divinam, rationalem
naturam, et mundum interim, et fatalem necessitatem Deum credit:
ZyNONEMque interpretatione Physiologie in Hestop1, Homert,
OrpuHerque carminibus imitatur. Babylonio etiam DioGENi disci-
plina est exponendi et disserendi, Jovis partum et ortum Minerve et
hoe genus cetera, rerum vocabula esse non Deorum.”* For, all the
genuine Sects of Philosophy, as we have observed, were steady
patriots; LeGisLaTion making one essential part of their Philo-
sophy. And, to legislate without the foundation of a national Reli-
gion, was, in their opinion, building castles in the air. So that we
are not to wonder, they took the alarm ; and opposed these Insultors
of the public Worship with all their vigour. But, as they never lost
sight of their proper character, they so contrived, that the defence of
the national Religion should terminate in a recommendation of their
philosophic speculations. Hence, their support of the public worship,
and their evasion of Huhemerus’s charge, turned upon this proposi-
tion, “That the whole ancient MyTHOLOGY was no other than the
vehicle of PHYSICAL, MORAL, and DIviNE knowledge.” And, to this
it is that the learned Husebius refers, where he says, ‘‘ That a new
race of men refined their old gross THEOLOGY, and gave it an honester
look ; and brought it nearer to the truth of things.” +
However, this proved a troublesome work; and, after all, imef-
fectual for the security of men’s PRIVATE MORALS ; which, the
example of the licentious story according to the /efter, would not fail
to influence, how well soever the allegoric interpretation was calcu-
lated to cover the puBLic HONOUR of Religion: So that the more
ethical of the Philosophers grew peevish with what gave them so
much trouble, and answered so little to the interior of religious
practice: this made them break out, from time to time, into hasty
resentments against their capital Poets ; unsuitable, one would think,
to the dignity of the Authors of such noble recondite truths, as they
would persuade us to believe were treasured up in their Writings.
Hence it was that PLaro banished Homer from his Republic : and
that PyrHaGoras, in one of his extramundane adventures, saw both
Homer and Hestop doing penance in Hell, and hung up there, for
* Octavius, cap. xix. + Τοιαῦτα ἣν τὰ τῆς wadaids Θεολογίας, ἣν meTaba-
λόντες νέοι τινὲς, χθὲς καὶ τορώην ἐπιφυέντες, λογικώτερόν τε φιλοσοφεῖν αὐχοῦντες. τὴν
δὴ φυσικωτέραν τῆς wepl Θεῶν ἱστορίας δόξαν εἰσηγήσαντο, σεμνοτέρας εὑρεσιολογίας
τοῖς μύθοις τοροσεπινοήσαντες. Prap. Evang. lib. ii. cap. 6.
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 39
examples, to be bleached and purified from the grossness and _pollu-
tion of their ideas.
The first of these Allegorizers, as we learn from Laertius,* was
Anaxagoras ; who, with his friend Metrodorus, turned Homer’s
Mythology into a system of Ethics. Next came Heraclides Ponticus,
and, of the same fables made as good a system of Physics : which, to
shew us with what kind of spirit it was composed, he intitled
᾿Αντίῤῥησις τῶν κατ᾽ αὐτοῦ [Ὁμήρου] βλασφημησάντων. And last of
all, when the necessity became more pressing, Proclus undertook to
shew that all Homer’s Fables were no other than physical, ethical,
and moral ALLEGORIES. For we are to observe, that the Philosophers
INVENTED and REVIVED this way of interpretation, as at two differ-
ent times, so on two different occasions.
1. It was invented to encounter such men as EvaemMeERus, who
attempted to overthrow all Religion, by this pretended fact, That the
First Worship was paid to dead men deified ; which they supported
on a real one, namely, that the greater Gods of Greece were only
deified Mortals ; as appeared from Homer and the other early Greek
Poets: whose writings being become a kind of Scriprure in the
popular Religion, the Defenders of the common faith had it not in
their power to REPUDIATE their fables as only the idle visions of a
poetic fancy : Nothing was left but to sprr1ruALize the sense, by
allegorical interpretations. And this proved so lucky an expedient,
that, at the same time that it covered their fables from the attacks of
their adversaries, it added new reverence and veneration both to them
and their Authors. So TerruLuran. “Ipsa quoque vulgaris super-
stitio communis Idololatrize, eum in simulacris de nominibus et fabulis
veterum mortuorum pudet, ad interpretationem naturalium refugit, et
dedecus suum ingenio obumbrat, figurans Jovem in substantiam fervi-
dam, et Junonem ejus in aéream,” + &e.
2. What These began for the sake of their THroxocers, their
successors continued for the sake of their Turotocy. For it is to be
noted, that the first Curist1an Apo.ogists took up so much of the
argument of Evunemervs and his Fellows, as concerned the real
nature and original of the greater Gods of Greece. And as they had
disencumbered this truth, of the false consequence with which those
audacious Freethinkers had loaded it, they were enabled to urge it
with superior force. But if the Curistians added new vigour to
this attack, the PHiLosopHers became still more animated in their
defence : for they hated this new Sect as an enemy equally to the
PuiLosorny and to the Reticion of Greece. And their accidental
advantages in the application of this revived method of allegory, were
not inferior to their most studied arts of improving it: For their
* Lib. ii. 4navag. Vita. + Adversus Marc. lib. i.
Ὁ
40 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK 111.
Christian Adversaries could with no grace object to a way of interpre-
tation which they themselves had just borrowed from Paganism, to
SPIRITUALIZE, forsooth, their sacred Scriptures, which the Philoso-
phers had long used with more sense and better judgment, to make
theirs, REASONABLE.
But here we are to take notice of this difference between these
Allegorizers BEFORE, and the Allegorizers arrER the time of Christ.
The first were principally employed in giving a physical* or moral
interpretation of the Fables; the latter, a THEOLOGICAL. As we
may see in the case of Plutarch ; who was both Priest and Philoso-
pher in one. His famous tract, or Ists AND Ostrts, is directly
written to support the national Religion, which had just taken the
alarm ; and not without reason. His purpose, in it, is to shew, That
all its MULTIFORM worship was only an address to the SUPREME
BEING, under various names and covers. But then ancient history,
which acquaints us with the origin of their Gods, stood in his way.
He denies therefore, what these histories invariably attest. He calls
Euhemerus, who inforced their evidence, an Impostor :+ And hath
many other evasions to elude such circumstances as are most decisive.
Thus, when he cannot deny, that, what is recorded of their Gods
shews them to be subject to human passions, he will not yet allow the
inference for their humanity ; because the Genii and Demons are
agitated by the like passions.t Thus again, the ewailing and lament-
ing gestures, in many of their established Rites, which looked so like
mourning for the dead, signified, he assures us, no more than an
allegorical representation of corn sown and buried.§ In this manner,
the postulate having supported the allegories ; the allegories come, in
good time, to the assistance of the postulate.
Thus stood the matter in the ancient World. Let us see now what
use the Moderns have made of what they found recorded there. Our
Freethinkers, such as Toland and his school, have revived the old rank
doctrine of Euhemerus. That Panrnerstic Philosopher’s under-
standing had so strong a bias to impiety, that it seemed rather a
* So Arnosius. ‘ Vulnerari, verari, bella inter se gerere farialium memorantur
ardore discriminum: Vobis illa est descriptio voluptati, atgue ut scriptorum tantam
defendatis audaciam, ALLEGORIAS res illas, et NATURALIS SCIENTIEZ mentimint esse
doctrinas.’ ’—Adversus Gentes, lib. iv. p. 150, ed. quarto. + “Os αὐτὸς [ΕὐήμεροΞ]
ἀντίγραφα συνθεὶς ὁ ἀπίστου καὶ ἃ ἀνυπάρκτου͵ μυθολογίας, Waray ἀθεότητα κατασκεδάννυσι
τῆς οἰκουμένης, τοὺς νομιζομένους ϑεοὺς τσάντας ὁμαλῶς διαγράφων, εἰς ὄνομα Στρατηγῶν
καὶ Ναυάρχων καὶ Βασιλέων, ὡς δὴ τυάλαι γεγονότων. —P. 641. 1 Βέλτιον οὖν, ot
τὰ weph τὸν Τυφῶνα καὶ Ὄσιριν καὶ “low ἱστορούμενα, μήτε ϑεῶν τσοαθήματα, μήτε
ἀνθρώπων, ἀλλὰ Δαιμόνων μεγάλων εἶναι νομίζοντες, ὡς καὶ Πλάτων καὶ Πυθαγόρας καὶ
Ξενοκράτης καὶ Χρύσιππος, ἑπόμενοι τοῖς τυάλαι Θεολόγοις, ἐῤῥωμενεστέρους μὲν ἀνθρώ-
πων γεγονέναι λέγουσι, καὶ πολλῇ τῇ δυνάμει τὴν φύσιν ὑπερφέροντας ἡ ἡμῶν, τὸ δὲ ϑεῖον
οὖκ ἀμιγὲς, οὐδὲ ἄκρατον ἔχοντας, ἀλλὰ καὶ ψυχῆς φύσει καὶ σώματος αἰσθήσει ἐν
συνειληχὸ, ἡδονὴν δεχομένην καὶ «πόνον καὶ ὅσα ταύταις ἐγγενόμενα. ταῖς μεταβολαῖς
wan, τοὺς μὲν. μᾶλλον, τοὺς δὲ ἧττον ἐπιταράττει" γίνονται yap ὡς ἐν ἀνθρώποις, καὶ
Δαίμοσιν, ἀρετῆς διαφοραὶ καὶ κακίας. -- Ῥ- 642. § See note OO, at the end of this
book.
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 41]
natural sympathy than any thing acquired, which drew him to it at
all distances. Hear how aukwardly he represents Huhemerus’s system
to us: and yet he labours hard to set it off. The rirst Idolatry
(says he) did not proceed, as is commonly supposed, from the beauty,
or order, or influence of the Stars. But men observing Books to
perish [before there were any] by fire, worms, or rottenness ; and
Iron, Brass, and Marble, not less subject to violent hands or the
injuries of the weather, they IMPOSED ON THE Stars, as the only
everlasting monuments, the proper names of their HEROES, or of some-
thing memorable in their History.* ΑἸ] this, his Predecessors, the
Freethinkers of Antiquity, (who knew how to express themselves)
informed us of when they said, That Star-worship was only symbolical
of Hero-worship ; and, consequently, of later date: the thing they
aimed at, to induce their conclusion, that therefore Religion was a
political invention. Toland treads in their footsteps, though he treads
awry. But our Religionists in general, have not been so happy in the
choice of their arms, nor in their sagacity of knowing their friends
from their enemies. The excellent G. J. Vossius (to mention him
amongst a multitude) hath, in his very learned collection of Gentile
Theology, gone, bona fide, into the old pagan method of allegorizing
their Theology ; as if it were doing service to true Religion to shew,
that the Pagan Idolatry was, at bottom, tolerably reasonable.
It is true, a late ingenious Person seems to have understood his
subject better, and to know to what it all tends; I mean the learned
Writer of the Letters concerning Mythology. We have observed,
that the ancient defenders of Paganism had by their Symbols and
Allegories resolved the Hero-gods into the Elementary ; and these
again, into the various attributes of the first Cause. In which they
were so successful, that they not only changed their Idolatry, but
their Idols likewise. For the S1cna PanTHeEiA expressive of this
new Theology have all the marks of the later times of pagan Antiquity.
The ancient Faruers of the Church are very copious in exposing
this subterfuge. In which service they employed all that was found
in the system of EHuhemerus ; that is to say, That the Greater Gods
of Greece and Rome, the Dii majorum Gentium, were Dead men
deified. And 1 have endeavoured throughout this work to support
their Cause. There are hardly now, I believe, two opinions on this
matter, amongst knowing men. But the Author of the Inquiry into
the Life and Writings of Homer attempts, in these Letters, to bring
us back again to the old Mumpsimus. He saw, | suppose, the neces-
sary connexion between Allegories and Ideal Gods : a principle which
could produce nothing more than a sHapowy IpoLaTry at worst.
And therefore, in honour of Pagan Antiquity, hath laid it down as an
* “Of the Origin of Idolatry and Reasons of Heathenism,” p. 74.
42 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK 111.
_
axiom, That the powers producing, and parts composing the Universe,
were their GREATER Gops ;* or the Dii majorum Gentium. This He
calls, the grand Key of Mythology. And here it is worth while to
observe, (but by the way only) that these admirers of the wisdom of
prophane Antiquity, are not so favourable to that of sacred: but are
generally amongst the first to laugh at what Divines call the DoUBLE
SENSE in Scripture prophecies. And yet they make the greatest part
of pagan wisdom to consist in the use and invention of DOUBLE
SENSES: ‘ Witness” (says this writer to his friend) “the DouBLE
view you have already had of the rise of things, and government of
the world from Orpheus, in the description of Pan: and from Hesiod
in his borrowed Theogony: and still plainer in the pouBLE moral of
Prometheus, as signifying either the divine Providence in the formation
of the world, and particularly of man, or human foresight perpetually
on the rack, for the necessaries and conveniences of life.’+ The
difference is, the pagan double sense connects together two things that
are foreign to one another in the constitution of Nature: The serip-
ture double sense connects together two things that are as nearly
related, as the various parts of one moral Dispensation. But to
return :
As these Letrrers seem to be written as much in opposition to
what is here, and elsewhere throughout this work, advanced, con-
cerning the rise, progress, and various fortunes, of ancient Idolatry,
as in favour of the now exploded Myrnoxiocy ; which was, as we
say, invented, and, from time to time, improved by the early, middle,
and later Philosophers, to hide the deformities of vulgar Polytheism ;
I think proper to consider what he hath to say in support of such an
undertaking. |
Now against my various reasoning in confutation of this pagan
System, I find not so much as one argument opposed ; and in support
of the System itself, but one; and this one, borrowed from Cud-
worth.t It is put thus: “‘ Huhkemerus and his FOLLOWERS, ere we
join with them in mortalizing the first Divinities, must satisfy us,
Why the Poetical Sages, the Instructors of mankind, termed their
grand Work, the basis of their doctrine, not only a THroGony, or
an account of the birth and pedigree of the Gods, but a CosmoGony,
or an account of the birth and creation of the World? Or, plainer
still, a Cosmopor!a, a making or framing of the Universe? The
Pxatonic Philosophy had no hand in the Cosmogonies, or histories
of the Creation written by Taaut or Thoth, by Linus, by Orpheus,
&e. It was plain, therefore, the Allegory did not come too late,’ ὃ &e.
—These last are my words.
* Page 409, of the ‘* Letters concerning Mythology.” + Pp. 120, 121. { See
ἐς Intellectual System.” Contents annexed to first edition, p. 234, ὃ Pp. 211, 212.
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 43
If Huhemerus supposed, as it appears he did, that the rrrsT pagan
Divinities were mortal Men, he would have found it difficult to answer
this objection of Cudworth. But the Fotrower of ELuhemerus (for
with this title he honours the Author of the Divine Legation) who
supposes no such thing, but hath evinced the contrary, will find no
difficulty at all. For he holds,* that the first Gods of Greece were
the heavenly Bodies. And if the Makers of these Cosmogonies, such
as Thoth, Linus, and Orpheus, held the same, then their THEOGONIES,
or accounts of the birth and pedigrees of these Gods, could be no
other than CosmoGontEs, or accounts of the birth and creation of
the world ; these Gods being parts of it.
But things seem here to be confounded by our Letter-Writer.
These Cosmogonies have just as much, and no more, to do with Pla-
tonic allegories, than the elements of Speech with the ornaments of
Rhetoric.
There are two errors likewise, in this matter, which our Letter-
Writer seems to have laboured under. The one is, that Huhemerus
was the Inventor of the mortalizing system : Whereas, I had shewn,
it was taught in all the Mysteries long before Euhemerus had any
being. He, indeed, maliciously carried it much farther than the
Mysteries intended: He made planetary worship symbolical of the
Heroic: and, from thence, inferred the political origin of Religion :
for which, he passed with Antiquity, and perhaps justly, for an
Atheist. Whereas the Mysteries, as we see from the fragment of
Sanchoniatho,+ kept these two species of Idolatry distinct ; and
assigned the proper order of time to each of them.
The other error this lively Writer falls into, is in supposing, that
this Follower of Euhemerus, against whom he writes, holds all the ,γ8έ,
as well as last, Gods of Greece to have been mortal men: Whereas he
distinguishes between the Gods of civilized and uncivilized Greece :
The first, he supposes to have been heavenly bodies ; and the latter
only, dead men deified.
From censuring the Learning of Euhemerus’s Followers, the Letter-
Writer proceeds to censure their Morals. “It is not easy”’ (he says)
“to ascertain what should make some warm Ecclesiastics, for the
wiser are far above such weakness, so angry at the Allegories of
ancient Poets, now, when all danger from their Deities is over. Of
old, indeed, when Temples and Revenues belonged to them ; when
wealth, and Dignities of the Church, were annexed to the allegorical
Devotion, and vested in its Teachers, no wonder the good FATHERS
should fulminate against the wild and impious Worship. But zow,
when the struggle is long since over, when the Father of Gods and
men has not so much as a lamb offered, nor his Daughter: [1. e.
* See above. + See above, and likewise p. 212 of the first volume.
44 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK 111.
Minerva or Wispom] a single grain of incense burnt upon her altar
for near a thousand years, it is hard to tell what should awake this
preposterous zeal, or make them so eager to mortalize the EMBLEMS
of Antiquity. Is there not, as I was hinting, some infection in the
case? Has not the reading the FLAMING INVECTIvES of the
primitive Fathers, who were actually in the struggle, a little infected
their Followers with the same fiery spirit and INDECENT LAN-
GUAGE!” *
As to these flaming Invectives, the Letter-Writer seems to lie under
a small mistake. For though such invectives may perhaps be thought
characteristic of the Faruers’ zeal, the terms are not here in their
place. They reserved their cnvectives for a better occasion, to fulmi-
nate the malice of their Enemies, and the follies of their Friends.—
On this point, viz. the mortalizing the emblems of antiquity, I can
assure him, they appeared much at their ease ; and more disposed to
quibble than to rail; as he might have seen by one of the most
serious of them, and who least understood raillery when -he was
pressed, I mean St. Austin ; who, in his confutation of Varro and his
emblems, could afford to be thus jocular: “Sed, heec omnia inquit
[Varro] referuntur ad mundum ; videatne potius ad immundum.” +
As to the indecent language ; it is to be found in the third ¢ volume
of the Divine Legation ; where it is said, that the Ancients adopted
into the number of their greater Gods, Ravishers, Adulterers, Pathics,
Vagabonds, Thieves, and Murderers.§ But it is pleasant to hear this
Letter-Writer talk of decency to a set of PHanroms, EMBLEMs, and
Symsgots; for such he esteems these Greater Gods to be; and yet
observe it so little to the Ministers of the Christian Religion. For
he is at a loss, the Reader sees, to account for their warmth, where
their private interest is not concerned. And in seeking for the cause
of it, when he cannot fix it on their avarice and ambition, rather than
allow them a motive becoming their character and office, he will throw
it upon their passions and prejudices. He supposes, they catched the
infection from the Fathers, whose worldly interests, he imagines,
were much concerned in the quarrel. But if he deserves the opinion
I have of his candour, he will be pleased to find his suspicions ill
grounded : And that the Ecciestastics, who engage so warmly in
this question, do it en important reasons, becoming their character of
Ministers of the Truth.
The Bible represents ancient Idolatry, in the most odious colours ;
and the whole Gentile World as given up to its delusions. A species
of modern Mythologists, hinted at above, had, on the revival of
learning in the West, endeavoured to evade this charge, by borrowing
= Pp. ΘΟ, σ΄. + Civitas Dei, lib. vii. cap. 27. 1 In the second volume
of the present edition. § Book iv. sect. 4.
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 45
the defences of the ancient Philosophers; who allegorized the fables
of the popular Religion, to screen it from the contempt of the more
knowing Vulgar; as Learning, at one time, and Christianity, at
another, had severally shaken the Seat of Superstition.* In those
Allegories, all the national Gods were reduced to mere SyMBOLS,
expressive of the Attributes of the first Cause: and, consequently,
the Scripture-charge against the Gentiles, of worshipping the Creature
for the Creator, rendered groundless, or at least, uncandid. These
modern Mythologists, a late French Writer hath well described in the
following words,—‘‘ Au commencement du Seiziéme Siécle quelquesuns
des Savans, qui contribuérent au retablissement des lettres, etoient,
dit-on, Paiens dans le cceur, plus encore par PEDANTERIE, que par
libertinage : ensorte qu’il π᾿ οὐδ pas tenu ἃ eux de ramener le culte des
Dieux d’Homere et de Virgile—ils emploioient ce qu’ils avoient de
litérature et d’esprit, pour donner au Paganisme un tour plausible, et
en former un systéme moins insensé. [15 avoiioient que la MyrHo-
LOGIE étoit insoutenable prise a la lettre: mais, en méme tems, elle
contenoit, selon eux, sous l’EmBieme des fictions les profondeurs de
la pHysIQUE, de la MoRALE, et de la TrHEOLOGIE.’’ +—In this state
and representation of things, some Zcclesiastics have thought it of
their office to MORTALIZE these pretended emblems of Antiquity ; and
to shew, that the greater national Gods were dead men deified: and,
consequently, that their worshippers were REAL IDOLATERS ; and of
the worst sort too, as they frequently had for their objects the worst
kind of men.
But so little of this matter entered into the Letter-Writer’s views,
that he says, “ This, which was formerly a grand religious controversy,
is now turned to a point of pure speculation. What, in the days of
Polytheism, raised the indignation of the Priests, and inflamed the
rival zeal of the Fathers of the Church, now raises a little squabble
amongst the Antiquaries, as a question of mere curiosity: to wit,
whether all the Gods of Antiquity were not mortal men.” 1
Now, if the Letter-Writer will needs suppose, that where the
Cierey have no oblique and interested designs, they have no reason-
able ones, he will be often out in his reckoning: And (what to be -
sure is greatly to be lamented) unequal to the office of a Censor on
their Manners.
After all, perhaps I may understand Him as little, as he appears to
have understood Me, if I think him in earnest. The whole of his
Tetters, if one may judge by hints dropt here and there, seems to be
only the wanton exercise of a Sophist ; and just such an encomium on
the WISDOM OF THE ANCIENTS, as Erasmus’s was on the FOLLY OF
rue Moverns. It is certain, at least, that in the prosecution of his
* See pp. 38—40. + Pie de l’Emp. Julien, pp. 48, 49. { P. 208.
406 THE DIVINE LEGATION - BOOK III.
argument, his chief concern is for FicrtoN AND ITS INTERESTS,
Thus, in one page, he tells us, “That this eager zeal to MORTALIZE
these emblems of Antiquity is DESTRUCTIVE TO ALL TRUE
POETRY.” * And in another, “That this prevailing PROSAIC TASTE
has neither dignity of manners, nor strength of genius, nor extent
of fancy.’+ But he explains himself more fully, where speaking
of Sympoxs and ALLEGORIES, and the inseparable as well as acci-
dental marks by which they may be unravelled, he illustrates
his subject by Abbé Pluche’s Hypothesis: Which, however, in
several places, he treats for what it is, an idle and a groundless
fancy. ‘‘Symbols”’ (says he) ‘carry natural marks that strike a
sagacious mind, and lead it, by degrees, to their real meaning. A
hint in one author brightens the obscurities in many others; as one
single observation of Macrobius proved the clue to Abbé Pluche’s
(how justly 1 say not) to unravel the whole mystery of Egyptian,
Assyrian, and Grecian Gods.’ He had no occasion to consider how
justly, if he were in jest. Otherwise, a man might have seen, that
the justness of unravelling depended on the reality of the Clue:
Which, too, though dignified by the name of Clue, is indeed no other
than a number of odd ends, that wanted to be made consistent, rather
than to be waravelled. For the rest, as our learned Critic would
immortalize the Pagan Deities in reverence to the Cuassics, so this
Abbé Pluche (of whom he speaks with so much honour) has
attempted to draw them out of their mortal state, in order to
cover the disgraces of Popery; to which that superstition is
obnoxious, from the protestant parallels between Sait and Hero-
worship.
But as if all this had not been enough to shew us that his concern
was not for TrurH but Fiction, he gravely professes to credit all
Bacon’s visions, as the genuine Wisdom of the Ancients, which every
body else admires as the sportive effort of modern wit. As he is in
so pleasant an humour, he may not be displeased to hear the Determi-
nation of Docror RaBELAts upon this question, who thus addresses
the Allegorizers of his time, ‘‘ Croyez-vous, en vostre foy, qu’oncques
Homers, escripvant l’Iliade et lOdyssée, pensast 6s ALLEGORIES
lesquelles de luy ont calefreté Plutarche, Heraclide de Ponticq,
Eustatie, Phornute, et ce que d’iceulx Poxir1an ha descrobé? Si le
croyez, vous n’approchez ne de piedz, ne de mains ἃ mon opinion :
qui DECRETE icelles aussi peu avoir esté songées de Homere, que
d’Ovide en ses Metamorphoses, les Sacremens de |’ Evangile, lesquelz
ung Frere Lubin, vray croquelardon, s’est efforcé demonstrer si
dadventure il rencontroit gens aussi folz que luy.”’ This facetious
Satirist had here in his eye those very Mythologists of the sixteenth
“P21, + P. 214.
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 47
Century, whom the learned Author of the Life of Julian, quoted
above, so very justly censures.
And thus much for this GRAND KEY OF MYTHOLOGY, as this
Letter-Writer is pleased to call his Fancies.*
To return to the Patrons of the other extreme, that the heavenly
bodies were only SymsBots of the Hero-Gods.—Having thus shewn,
the worship of the elements to be prior to that of dead men, 1 have
not only overthrown this argument, for the proof of the atheistic notion
of the origin of Religion, but likewise the notion itse/f. For if (as
our adyersaries own) the worship of dead men were the first religious
institution after entering into civil society ; and if (as T have proved)
the worship of the heavenly bodies preceded that of dead men; the
consequence is, that Religion was in use before the Civil Magistrate
was in Being. But I need not our Adversaries’ concession for this
consequence ; having proved from ancient testimony, that planetary
worship was the only Idolatry long before Civil Society was known ;
and continued to be so, by all unpolicied nations, Jong after.
II. I come, in the next place, to direct Fact : from whence it appears,
that the Lawgiver, or Ciwil Magistrate, did not invent Religion.
Here the Atheist’s gross prevarication ought not to pass uncensured.
—From the notoriety of the Magistrate’s care of Religion, he would
conclude it to be Ais INVENTION: And yet, that very Antiquity,
which tells him this, as plainly and fully tells him ¢his other ;
namely, that Religion was not invented by him: For, look through all
Greek, Roman, and Barbarick Antiquity; or look back on what we
have extracted from thence in the second section of the foregoing
book, and it will appear, that not one single Lawgiver ever found a
People, how wild or unimproved soever, without a Religion, when he
undertook to civilize them. On the contrary, we see them all, even
to the Lawgivers of the Thracians and Americans, addressing them-
selves to the savage Tribes, with the credentials of that God who was
there professedly acknowledged and adored. But this truth will be
farther seen from hence: It appears by the history of the Lawgivers ;
by the sayings recorded of them ; and by the fragments of their writings
yet remaining, that they perceived the error and mischief of the gross
idolatries practised by those People, whom they reduced into Society ;
and yet, that they never set upon reforming them. From whence we
reasonably conclude, that they found the People in possession of a
Religion which they could not unsettle ; and so were forced to comply
with inveterate prejudices. For, that they were willing and desirous
to have reformed what they found, appears not only from the Prorms
to their Laws, mentioned above, but from the testimony of one of the
most knowing Writers of Antiquity, [ mean Plutarch ; who, in his
~ P7409:
o
48 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK 111.
Tract of Superstition, speaking of the unruly temper of the People,
says they ran headlong into all the follies which the makers of Graven
images propagated ; and in the mean time, turned a deaf ear to their
Lawgivers, who endeavoured to inform them better.* This forced
even Solon himself to establish the Temple-worship of Venus the
Prostitute.+ But the reform was seen to be so impossible, that Plato
lays it down as an axiom in his Republic, That nothing ought to be
changed in the received Religion which the Lawgiver finds already
established ; and that a man must have lost his understanding to
think of such a project. All they could do, therefore, when they
could not purify the Sout of Religion, was more firmly to constitute
the Bony of it, for the service of the state. And this they did by
NATIONAL RITES AND CEREMONIES. Nay; when the visible folly
of a superstitious Rite, would have enabled them to abolish it, they
sometimes for the sake of turning it to the civil service chose to give
it the public sanction. This, Cicero confesses where he says—
««Equidem adsentior C. Marcello—existimoque jus augurum, etsi
Divinationis opinione principio constitutum sit, tamen postea Rre1rpus-
LIC CAUSA conservatum ac retentum.” {
Indeed, in course of time, though insensibly, the genius of the
Religion, as we observed before,§ followed that of the civil Policy ;
and so grew better and purer, as it did in Rome; or more corrupt
and abominable, as it didin Syrra. But had the Legislators given
an entire NEw Re.icion, in the manner they gave Laws, we should
have found some of those, at least, nearly approaching to the purity
of natural Religion. But as we see no such, we must conclude they
FOUND Religion, and did not MAKE it.
On the whole then, I have proved, what the most judicious Hooker
was not ashamed to profess before me, That ‘‘a POLITIQUE USE of
Religion there is. Men fearing Gop are thereby a great deal more
effectually than by positive Laws restrayned, from doing evil: inas-
much as those Laws have no further power than over our outward
actions only ; whereas unto men’s inward cogitations, unto the privie
intents and motions of their hearts, Religion serveth for a bridle.
What more savage, wilde, and cruell than man, if he see himselfe
able, either by fraude to overreach, or by power to overbeare, the
Laws whereunto he should be subject? Wherefore in so great bold-
ness to offend, it behoveth that the World should be held in awe, not
by a VAINE SURMISE, but a TRUE APPREHENSION of somewhat,
which no man may think himself able to withstand. Tus 1s THE
POLITIQUE USE OF RELIGION.” ||—Thus far this great man; where
* Φιλοσόφων δὲ καὶ ΠΟΛΙΤΙΚΩ͂Ν ἀνδρῶν καταφρονοῦσιν, ἀποδεικνύντων τὴν τοῦ
Seov σεμνότητα μετὰ χρηστότητος καὶ μεγαλοφροσύνης, μετὰ βίας καὶ κηδεμονίας.
+ Πανδήμου ᾿Αφροδίτης.---ΑΤἸῊ ΕΝ Εὶ1 Deip, lib. xiii. t De Divin. lib. ii. cap. 35.
§ See vol. i. p, 174, et seq. \| ““ Ecelesiastical Polity,’ book y. sect, ii.
SECT, ΥἹ- OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 49
he takes notice how certain Atheists of his time, by observing this use
of Religion to Society, were fortified in their folly of believing that
Religion was invented by Politicians to keep the World in awe. An
absurdity, I persuade myself, now so thoroughly exposed, as to be
henceforth deemed fit only to go in rank with the tales of Nurses,
and the dreams of Free-thinkers.
I HAVE now at length gone through the two first Propositions :
1. THAT THE INCULCATING THE DOCTRINE OF A FUTURE
STATE OF REWARDS AND PUNISHMENTS, IS NECESSARY TO THE
WELL-BEING OF CiviL SOCIETY.
2. THAT ALL MANKIND, ESPECIALLY THE MOST WISE AND
LEARNED NATIONS OF ANTIQUITY, HAVE CONCURRED IN BELIEV-
ING, AND TEACHING, THAT THIS DOCTRINE WAS OF SUCH USE
To Civit Society.
The neat Book begins with the proof of the third; namely,
3. THAT THE DOCTRINE OF A FUTURE STATE OF REWARDS
AND PUNISHMENTS, IS NOT TO BE FOUND IN, NOR DID MAKE
PART OF, THE MOSAIC DISPENSATION.
Hitherto we have been forced to move slowly, to feel for our way in
the dark, through the thick confusion of many irrational RELIGIoNs,
and mad schemes of PuiLosopHy, independent of, and inconsistent
with, one another: Where the labour of the search, perhaps, has
been much greater to the Author, than the pleasure will be to the
Reader, in finding this Cuaos reduced to some kind of order ; the
Principies developed, from whence the endless diversity and contra-
diction have arisen ; and the various usr that may be made of these
Discoveries for our demonstration of the truth of revealed Religion.
We now emerge into open day :
“Ὁ Major rerum mihi nascitur ordo,
Majus opus moyeo.”
And having gotten the PROMISED LAND in view, the labour will be
much easier, as the Discoveries will be more important, and the
subject infinitely more interesting: For having now only one single
System and Dispensation to explain, consistent in all its parts, and
absolute and perfect in the Whole, which though, by reason of the
profound and sublime views of its Author, these perfections may not
be very obvious, yet, if we have but the happiness to enter rightly,
we shall go on with ease, and the prospect will gradually open and
enlarge itself, till we see it lost againin that ImmeENnsiry from
whence it first arose.
Full of these hopes, and under the auspices of these encourage-
ments, let us now shift the Scene from GENTILE to JEWwisH
Antiquity ; and prepare ourselves for the opening of a more august
and solemn Theatre.
VOL, IT, L
APPENDIX,
SHEWING THAT THE OMISSION OF A FUTURE STATE IN THE
MOSAIC DISPENSATION DOTH NOT MAKE IT UNWORTHY
OF THE ORIGINAL TO WHICH BELIEVERS ASCRIBE IT.
As both Believers and Unbelievers have, by some blind chance or other,
concurred to make this Objection to the omission ; I think it not improper,
before I enter upon the Subject of the Mosarc Law, which comes next into
consideration, to remove this common prejudice concerning it. And as 8
celebrated Writer has collected together what hath been said in support of
the Objection, and given to it all the strength that the force of his own
genius could impart, I suppose his words will be the best text to my
discourse.
“L’Evéque Warburton, auteur d’un des plus savants ouvrages qu’on
ait jamais fait, s’exprime ainsi, page 8. tome I. ‘Une Religion, une
Société qui n’est pas fondée sur la eréance dune autre vie, doit étre
soutenue par une Providence extraordinaire. Le Judaisme n’est pas fondé
sur la créance d’une autre vie; donc, le Judaisme a été soutenu par une
providence extraordinaire.’ Plusieurs Theologiens se sont élevés contre
lui, et comme on rétorque tous les arguments, on a retorqué le sien, on lui
a dit : ‘Toute Religion, qui n’est pas fondée sur le dogme de l’immortalité
de lame, et sur les peines et les recompenses eternelles, est necessairement
fausse ; Or le Judaisme ne connut point ces dogmes, done le Judaisme,
loin d’etre soutenu par la Providence, était par vos principes une Religion
fausse et barbare qui attaquait la Providence.’ Cet Evéque eut quelques
autres adversaires qui lui soutinrent que V’immortalité de Dame était
connue chez les Juifs, dans le temps méme de Moise ; mais il leur prouva
tres-évidemment que ni le Décalogue, ni le Levitique, ni le Deuteronome,
n’avaient dit un seul mot de cette creance, et qu’il est ridicule de vouloir
tordre et corrompre quelques passages des autres livres, pour en tirer une
vérité qui n’est point annoncée dans le livre de la Loi.
“ Mr. ’Evéque ayant fait quatre Volumes pour demontrer que la Loi
Judaique ne proposait ni peines ni recompenses aprés la mort, n’a jamais
pt répondre a ses adversaires d’une maniére bien satisfaisante. 115. lui
disaient : ‘Ou Moise connaissait ce Dogme, et alors il a trompé les Juifs
en ne le manifestant pas ; ou il Vignorait, et en ce cas il n’en savait pas
assez pour fonder une bonne Religion. En effet si la Religion avait été
bonne, pourquoi l’aurait-on abolie? Une Religion vraie doit étre pour
tous les temps et pour tous les liewx, elle doit étre comme la lumiere du
Soleil, qui éclaire tous les Peuples et toutes les Générations.’
APPENDIX. THE DIVINE LEGATION OF MOSES. 51
“Ce Prelate tout éclairé qu’il est, a eu beaucoup de peine a se tirer de
toutes ces difficultés ; mais quel Systéme en est exempt?” *
The trouble I have had in disengaging myself from these difficulties
will now be seen.
The Objections, as here stated by this ingenious man, respect, we see,
both the Lxcistator and the Law.
1. Hither Moses (says he) was acquainted with a future State, and in that
case he deceived the Jews in not teaching it: or he was ignorant of the
doctrine, and in this case he did not know enough to become the Author of a
good Religion. Indeed, if the religion had been good, Why was it abolished ?
a true religion should be for all times and places. Its light should be like
that of the Sun, which illumines all nations and all generations.
2. All Religion which is not founded on the doctrine of the Soul’s immor-
tality and future rewards and punishments is necessarily false: but, in
Judaism, these doctrines were not contained: therefore Judaism, so far from
being supported by an extraordinary Providence, was, on your own Princi-
ples (says he to the Bishop) ὦ religion false and barbarous, which attacked
and insulted Providence.
1. The first argument, against the integrity of Moses’s conduct from this
Omission, had been urged at large by the late Lord BotrncBroxe ; and the
Reader may find it at large confuted, in the Appendix to the Fifth Book of
the Divine Legation.
2. The second argument, against the integrity of the Law from this
Omission, has been clamoured by a large Body of Answerers, led up by
Dr. Sreppinc. But these men pretending to believe Revelation, their
reason, for want of integrity in such a Religion, was founded in a supposed
defect in it’s Essence ; so their conclusion from this reasoning was, “ That
a future State was certainly in the Mosaic Religion, how much soever it
might walk there in Masquerade.” The celebrated Frenchman, who
pretends to no such belief, founds his argument on the reality of the
Omission, and from thence concludes, “that the Mosaic Law was an
imposture.”
- I shall examine what they have to say, in their order.
I.
The English Doctor comes first. ‘ You consider” (says this candid
Divine, addressing himself to the Author of the Divine Legation) “ the
Ignorance of the Jews as to the doctrine of a future State, as one of the
most momentous truths that Religion has to boast of. I, on the other hand,
look upon it as a piscrace to Revelation; as by the very act of God
himself, it shuts out his own chosen People, for many ages, from that
single point of Knowledge, which could be the foundation of a reasonable
Worship; while, by the directions of his Providence, all the world besides
were permitted to have the benefit of it.” Ὁ
* Dictionnaire Philosophique Portatif; article (Religion, premiere question.)
+ ‘An Examination of Mr. Warburton’s second Proposition, &c. in an Epistolary
Dissertation addressed to the Author,” pp. 131, 132.
E 2
52 ' THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK 111.
Here we see the Doctor proposes to confute my representation of the
omission of a future State in the Mosaic Religion: But, for mine, he gives
us his own, and very notably confutes that. My idea of the omission I
declared to be this, that, as the Jews, to whom the Mosaic Religion was
given, were, at the time of giving, under an extraordinary Providence,
they had no absolute need of the doctrine. The Doctor’s idea of the
omission is, that when the Mosaic Religion was given to the Jews, they
were under an ordinary Providence, and therefore the doctrine was neces-
sary. That I do him no wrong in charging him with this sophistical
chicanery, appears from his own words, where he gives his reason for
saying that my (meaning his own) representation of the omission is a
disgrace to Revelation ; namely, because this single point of Knowledge
[i. e. a future state] zs the only rounpation of a reasonable Worship.
Now, it is obvious to common sense, that this can be only predicated of a
future state under an ordinary Providence: And that under an eatra-
ordinary it is no necessary FOUNDATION at all.
If it should be pretended (for it will hardly be owned that the Doctor,
with all his zeal, was an Unbeliever) that by the many ages in which the
people of God were shut up (as he expresses it) from this knowledge, he
meant, those ages in which the Jews lived under a common providence, this
subterfuge will not serve his turn, for I have shewn, that when the
extraordinary dispensation ceased, the Jews, like all the world besides, and
by the same means of information, had all the benefit which the knowledge
of this FUTURE STATE, such as it was, could afford them.
But let us take the Doctor as we find him. .
He tells us why he looks upon my representation of the Mosaic Religion
as a disgrace to Revelation.— Because (says he) by the very act of God himself
it shuts out his own chosen people from that single point of Knowledge which
could be the foundation of a reasonable Worship.
Let us examine this curious period on all sides.
By the act of God himself he must mean, (for nothing else can be meant ;
and it is only when his meaning is thus circumstanced, that I can be
certain, I do not mistake it) he must mean, I say, God’s act, by the ministry
of Moses. Now this very Doctor, in his several Pieces against The Divine
Legation, has, over and over again, told his Reader, that Moses did not
teach, NOR HAD IT IN HIS CoMMISSION TO TEACH ὦ future state to the Israclites.
For, at every step, he brings himself into these distresses (if such a trifle as
a contradiction can be supposed to distress him) by a false modesty. He
was ashamed of the absurdity of his Brethren, who all along maintained,
that Moses taught, or oveut to have taught, a future state: and therefore,
at this turn, leaves them in the lurch; and slyly steals in the better
principle of his Adversary, that Moses had no Commission to teach it: for
he must have been duller than any Doctor can be supposed to be, not to
discover that this was his Adversary’s principle, after having seen him
write a large book to prove that, Moses did not teach it. I call this
desertion of his Friends, a false modesty; For what is it else, to be
shocked at one of their absurdities, while he is defending all the rest ?
i te
APPENDIX. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. δῶ
whose only support, too, happens to be in that one which he rejects.
Indeed, good Doctor,
PUDOR TE MALUS wrget
Insanos qui inter vereare Insanus haberi.
But “God” (says he) “ by this very act, shut out his own chosen people
from the knowledge of a future state.” It is very true, God’s own chosen
people were shut out. But not, as our Doctor dreams, by the very act of
God himself: but (if he will have the Truth, who never seeks it, for
itself) by the very act of their Forefather, Anam. It was the First Man
who shut them out ; and the door of Paradise was never opened again, till
the coming of the Second Man, the Lord from Heaven. But this is the
Language of Seripture: and this language his Sums and Systems do not
teach him. But more of this secret hereafter.
A future state (says our Doctor absolutely and without exception) ἐς
that single point of knowledge which could be the foundation of a reasonable
worship. Were Doctors differ. St. Paul places the foundation of a reason-
able worship in another thing. He saith, that, He rHar comern Τὸ Gop
MUST BELIEVE THAT HE IS; AND THAT HE IS A REWARDER OF THEM THAT
DILIGENTLY SEEK HIM.*—What is Man’s purpose 7 coming to God?
Without doubt, to worship him. And what doth the great Doctor of the
Gentiles tell us is the true, the reasonable foundation of this worship ?
Why, To BELIEVE THAT HE IS A REWARDER OF THEM THAT DILIGENTLY SEEK
um. He places this foundation (we see) in a REWARD simply, and
generically ; not in that particular species of it, a FurURE sTAaTE. He
places it in the nature ; not (as our modern Doctor) in the inessential
circumstances, of Rewarp. The consequence is, that a reward giver HERE
was as solid a foundation of a reasonable Worship to the early Jews, living
under an EXTRAORDINARY Providence, as a reward given HEREAFTER, is to
us Christians, living under the orprvary one. Another consequence
(though it be but a trifle) is, that our learned Doctor is mistaken. But to
come a little closer to this formidable man, now I have got the Apostle on
my side. I will undertake to peMonsrRATE (how much soever he and his
Fellows take offence at the word) that a ruruURE sTaTE is so far from being
the only foundation of a reasonable Worship, that, as a MopE of ewistence, it
is no foundation at all. The true foundation of a reasonable Worship,
being this and this only, that God is a rewarder of them who seek him. He
may reward here, or he may reward hereafter. But, which he chuses is
indifferent, as to the solidity of the foundation; because ΡΙΕΤῪ and
MORALITY, Which constitute a REASONABLE WORSHIP, spring only from the
belief that God is, and that he is a Rewarder. The Mosaic Religion,
teaching this, enjoins that men should love God with all their hearts, with
all their soul, &c. for the excellence of his nature ; and that they should
love their neighbours as themselves, for the equality of their common nature,
which requires an equal measure for ourselves and others. Now Jesus
says, that, on the Love of God and of our Neighbour hang all the Law and
* Heb. xi. 6.
54. THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK III.
the Prophets, i.e. in the most confined sense, it is the foundation of a
reasonable Worship. Our Doctor says, No ; a future state is the only foun-
dation. In a word then, since Pirry, which constitutes a reasonable
Worship, and since Virtur, which constitutes a reasonable service, are
both raised and supported by the belief, that God 7s, and that he is a
Rewarder ; What more forceable inducement is there in our selfish nature
to cherish them, than that which the Law of Moses holds forth, when it
teaches that every work shall receive it’s full recompence of reward HERE 1—
Here or hereafter, in this life or in another, being only the modes of
receiving one and the same thing, cannot possibly affect either piety or
morality. But it hath been taken for granted, that there is in future
rewards something of a virtue to purtFy the mind, which present rewards
have not. I shall consider, before I have done with the question, on what
ground this opinion stands. In the mean time, let us hear the famous
Orobio, the Jew; who, though little to his own purpose, yet much to
ours, and to such Objectors to the purity of the Mosaic Law, as our
Doctor—“Omnes [Christiani] cultum internum predicant, quasi a Deo
internus cultus summa ‘cum perfectione in Lege non fuisset prascriptus ;
“Tota quidem interni cultus perfectio consistit in vero et constantissimo
Dei amore, et Proximi propter ipsum Deum: Hic est totus cultus
internus ex quo omnia opera externa, seu moralia, seu ritualia sint, debent
profluere : que si ex hoc principio noh emanaverint, imperfectissima sunt,
et divine Legi prorsus adversa.” *
Our Doctor proceeds—“ God’s chosen people were shut out, for many
ages, from that point of knowledge, which, by the directions of his Provi-
dence, all the world besides were PERMITTED to have the BENEFIT of.’—In
examining the predicate of this proposition, I shall first consider the PER-
MIsston, and then the BENEFIT.
All the World besides (says he) were permitted. By what instrument? I
ask ; for they had no Revelation—By the use of their Reason, says he.—
And had not the Jews the use of theirs? No, replies he, not the free use :
for their Prophet (according to you) delivering to them, from God, a new
Law and a new Religion in which the doctrine of a future state was omitted,
this would naturally lead them to conclude against it ?—What? in defiance
of all the clear deductions of Reason, which, from God’s demonstrable
attributes of justice and goodness, made the Pagan world conclude, that as
moral good and evil had not their retribution here, they would have it,
hereafter 2—Yes, for Moses promisep they should have their retribution
here-—Whiat then? other ancient Lawgivers promised their People the
samething. Yet this did not hinder their having recourse to a future state
to secure the foundation of Religion, which, St. Paul tells us, is the belief
that God is, and that he is the Rewarder of them that seek him. The matter
now begins to pinch: and the Doctor must be dumb, or confess that the
only possible reason one can assign why the Jews had not recourse to the
same expedient for securing the foundation of Religion, which the Gentiles
had recourse to, was because they felt the performance as well as heard the
ΚΡ. 110.
APPENDIX. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 55
promise: For when that was no longer felt (the extraordinary providence
being withdrawn in punishment for their crimes) the Jews, like all other
people, had their doctrine of a future state, which, by its complexion, is
seen to be of foreign, and very spurious birth.
See then, to what this PERMIssIon amounts ; so invidiously urged, not
against me, for that is nothing, but against the Scriptures of God! Just
to thus much—“ That all the world besides were permitted to find out, by
REASON as they could, what his chosen people were taught, by the practical
demonstration of an EXTRAORDINARY ProvipENcE; namely, that God
would act with justice and goodness towards man.”
Come we next to the Benerit. The benefit of the doctrine of a future
state is twofold ; to Society as such, by encouraging Virtue and suppressing
Vice, under an wnequal distribution of things; to Religion as such, by
affording a solid foundation to it, under the same distribution. But both
these aids from the doctrine of a future state were more effectually afforded
by an extraordinary Providence. We find then, the learned Doctor to be
miserably mistaken, in supposing the Gentiles enjoyed any spiritual benefit
which the Jews were deprived of. The former indeed had a future state to
support Society and Religion ; the latter had an extraordinary Providence.
Which of them was, in its nature, the most efficacious support, common
sense will not suffer us to remain in doubt. But the benefit of believing is
one thing ; the benefit of having is another. I have only yet spoken to
the first. Now, the Doctor seems to think the Jatter affected by the omts-
ston. We commonly hear it said, that seeing is believing ; but I suspect
our learned Doctor has been imposed on by another Aphorism (as absurd
in the thought as that is in the expression) that believing is having ; else
how came he to place so great a benefit in the point in question, if he did
not suppose that the Jews’ want of the Docrrine would deprive them of
the THING.
And now, in taking my final leave of this Champion in Ordinary to the
Party Orthodoxal, let me not be here again misunderstood as I have so
often been by them. I deny, indeed, that the want of a future State, in
the Mosaic Religion, at all affected the true fowndation of a reasonable Wor-
ship. Yet I am very far from denying, that the frame and constitution of
this Religion rendered it, on many accounts, partial and incomplete. In
my address to the Jews, prefixed to the second part of the Divine Legation,
Τ have shown in what particulars it was so. As first, in the whole turn of
the Ritual Law: and secondly, in that omisston, at what time the Jews
came under the ordinary and common Providence of Mankind. For I am
there placing before these mistaken People a view of the Mosaic Religion
as it appears and operates at present, in order to convince them of the
necessity of its receiving its completion from the Religion of Jesus. In ἡ
which conclusion, I suppose, all Christians are agreed. At least, they who
have escaped the thick darkness of controversy will see that these two
assertions are very distinct and different, and at the same time consistent.
1. That a Religion without a future state, wanted not, during the existence
of an extraordinary providence, a solid foundation of a reasonable worship.
δθ THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK 181.
And, 2dly, that such a Religion, if supposed to serve for all times and
places, must needs be deemed incomplete.
This Omission of a future state in the Mosaic Religion is now generally
acknowledged by all who read the Bible with the same impartiality that
they read other Histories. Should not our Doctor therefore, who pretends
to believe the divinity of the Mosaic Religion, blush at his rashness in
calling it, A piscrace Τὸ Revenation? He does it, indeed, in confidence
that the early Jews were not ignorant of this matter. But will his confi-
dence persuade impartial men against their senses? Were there but a
chance of being mistaken in this supposed Anowledge of the early Jews, a
sober Minister of God’s word would have avoided the scandal of so irre-
verend an assertion ; so unsuitable to the veneration he owes to his Maker,
when speaking of a dispensation which he professes to believe did indeed
come from him ; and not have dared to measure this Dispensation of Pro-
vidence by his scanty and obscure ideas of fit and right. The Author of
The Divine Legation demonstrated might, indeed, say, and I hope without
offence, that the ignorance of the early Jews concerning a future state was a
truth of so HIGH IMPORTANCE, that from thence might be demonstrated the
divinity of their Religion ;.because, though he should be mistaken, no
injury was done to Revelation ; He left it whole and entire, just as he took
itup. But should our Doctor be mistaken, his calling this ignorance (now
found to be real) a piscrace ΤῸ Revetatron, would be supplying the
Enemies of Religion with arms to insult it. The only excuse he can
make for himself (an excuse full as bad as the offence) is, that he had now
gone back to the common principle of his Party, which before he seemed to
have rejected, That ἐγ God did not teach his chosen People a future state, he
ought to have taught it. A species of folly, which the sage Hooxrr, to
whom their Orthodoxy may haply be disposed to pay attention, has
admirably reproved in another set of men, possessed with the same impious
and presumptuous spirit—“ As for those marvellous discourses” (says this
great man) “ whereby they [the Puritans] adventure to argue, that God
must needs have done the thing which they imagined was to be done, I must
confess, I have often wondered at their exceeding boldness herein. When
the question is, Whether God have delivered in Scripture (as they affirm
he hath) a complete particular immutable Form of Church-politie, Why
take they that other, both presumptuous and superfluous, labour to prove ;
that HE SHOULD HAVE DONE Ir, there being no way, in this case, to prove
the deed of God, saving only by producing that evidence wherein he hath
done it ; for if there be no such thing apparent upon Record, they do as if
one should demand a Legacie by foree and virtue of some written Testa-
ment, wherein there being no such thing specified, he pleadeth, that THERE
Ir MusT BE; and bringeth arguments from the love or good-will which
always the testatour bore him ; imagining that these or the like proofs
will convict a testament to have that in it, which other men can no where,
by reading, find. In matters which concern the actions of God, the most
dutiful way, on our part, is to search what God hath done ; and with
meekness to apmree that, rather than to DISPUTE What he, 2 congruity
APPENDIX. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 57
of reason, ought to do. The waies which he hath, whereby to do all things
for the greatest good of his Church, are more in number than we can
search, other in nature than we should presume to determine, which, of
many, should be the fittest for him to choose, till such time as we see he
hath chosen, of many, some one ; which one we then may boldly conclude
to be the fittest, because he hath taken it before the rest. When we do
otherwise, surely we exceed our bounds: who, and where we are, we
forget ; and therefore needful it is that our PRIDE, in such cases, be con-
troled, and our disputes beaten back with those demands of the blessed
Apostle, How unsearchable are his judgments, and his ways past finding out !
Who hath known the mind of the Lord, or who hath been his Counsellor ?” *
We have now done with the Orthodox DivineE ; and come, in good time,
to the Freethinking PurosopHeEr.
Dr. Sreppinc, who sees a future state in the Mosaic Religion by a kind
of SECOND SENSE, just as northern Highlanders see things to come by a
SECOND sicut, affirms, only hypothetically, that this Religion was a DIsGRACcE
τὸ Reticion: Our Philosopher, who can see in it nothing of futurity,
affirms positively, that it was such a DISGRACE.
The Philosophex’s Principles incur no discredit, though he should fail in
his conclusion, since he had discarded Revelation before-hand : But should
the Divine be mistaken, he exposes his Principles to the scorn and contempt
of Freethinkers, since he professes to believe Revelation.
For the rest, the Philosopher stands charged with the same Soruisrry, of
which the Divine hath been found guilty ; the taking for granted the thing
in dispute, viz. that the Jews were under an wnequal Providence. Yet
here again both his sense and his modesty triumph over the Divine’s. The
Philosopher, in the Opinion that the Jews were under an wnequal Pro-
vidence, betrays no Principles of Natural Religion, which he pretends to
follow : The Divine, in avowing the same Opinion, betrays all the Princi-
ples of Revealed Religion, which he pretends to believe.
Indeed, the Sophistry in both, is equally contemptible.’ For no princi-
ples, whether of belief or unbelief, can authorize a Disputant to take for
granted the thing in question. The Author of The Divine Legation under-
took to prove, that the early Jews were under an equal Providence, by this
Medium, the Omission of a Future State in their Law ; and from thence
concluded, that the Religion revealed by the ministry of Moses was true ;
which, reduced to a syllogism, runs thus :
Whatever Religion and Society have no future state for their support
must be supported by an extraordinary Providence :
The Jewish Religion and Society had no future state for their support :
Therefore the Jewish Religion and Society were supported by an extra-
ordinary Providence.
To deny the major, as our Philosopher should have done ; to deny the
minor, as our Divine did; was fair argument. But to leave both, as the
First hath done, without an answer, and deny only the conclusion, is,
amongst all nations and languages, a BEGGING OF THE Question, If our
* Book iii. sub fin.
58 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Ill.
Philosopher would argue to the purpose, he should either shew that the
premisses are false, and then he attacks the minor ; or that they do not
infer the conclusion, and then he attacks the major. He does neither ; but,
instead of this, having begged the question, he falls to syllogizing, in his
turn—Lvery Religion (says he) which is not founded in the Doctrine of the
immortality of the soul, and eternal rewards and punishments, is necessarily
false. But Judaism was ignorant of these doctrines. Therefore Judaism,
so far from being upheld by a providence, was even, on the Principles of the
Author of the Divine Legation, a Religion false and barbarous, which
attacked Providence itself. 'The Argument we see is inform: And, if you
will believe the Philosopher, inforced upon my Principles. But, to bring
his syllogism to bear against me, he must go upon this Postulatum, that
the Law was not administered by an extraordinary Providence: And then, I
dare appeal to his own venerable Bench of Purtosopuers (if Logic hold any
place in their school) whether the upshot of all his syllogizing be not
taking for granted the thing in dispute. And if this were all, As these men
have accustomed us to this beggarly way of reasoning, we might pass it
over in silence and contempt: But there is something more than ordinary
perverse in the conduct of this syllogism. For, not content to beg the
question, our Philosopher falsifies my Principles—On the Prixcrptss (says
he) of the Author of the Divine Legation, Judaism was a false Religion.
Now the Principles which, as a Christian, I believe, are these, “That
Moses promised an extraordinary providence, and that he omitted a future
state.”
The Principles, which, as a Logician, I have proved, are these, “ That the
promise was fulfilled, and therefore that the Omission was attended with no
hurtful consequences either to Religion or Society.”
The Principles believed, I had collected from my Bible: the Principles
proved, I had deduced from what I understood to be the conclusions of
right reason.
How then (I would fain learn) can it fairly be inferred, from these Prin-
ciples, that the Religion of Moses is FaLsE ?
In the mean time, let me acquaint the Philosophers, in what manner I
infer from these Principles, that the Religion of Moses is TRUE.
That Moses promised an extraordinary Providence, is held by all Believ-
ers ; and that he omitted a future state, is seen by all Unbelievers. Neither
of them are mistaken. These are my Principles of belief—My purpose
was to convince Unbelievers, on their own grounds, that the promise was
PERFORMED, and this I do by the meprum of the Omission. How strongly
let the Book itself declare. These are my Principles of proof.
It was amongst my more general Principles, That whatever Religion,
under @ common Providence, omits to teach a future state, is certainly
false. And it seems to be amongst our Philosopher’s logical conclusions,
that, therefore, on this Principle of mine, whatever Religion under an
extraordinary Providence omits to teach a future state is false likewise.
But the Philosopher’s syllogism seems to have been made up out of an
Objection ill understood, which certain Divines brought against my argu-
— " ἀν «δ a -.
APPENDIX. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 59
ment; (for, of objections, against an offensive truth, there is neither end
nor measure.) These Doctors of the Church objected, “That I should
first of all have proved from Scripture that the promised Providence was
actually bestowed, before I used the service of my Meprum.” Let me ask
them for what end? Should it be to convince Unbelievers? But that it
could not do; for they reject the extraordinary or supernatural part of
Scripture-History. Did they mean, that it should have been done for their
own satisfaction? But what need of that? Believers profess to hold that
all which Moses promised was performed. What was it then that brought
forth this Objection? A mere blunder in their reasoning ; in the course
of which, they had confounded two very different things, with one ano-
ther—The promise of an extraordinary providence, with the actwal admi-
nistration of it. They saw, that it was necessary previously to prove that
Scripture speaks of the Administration of an extraordinary Providence,
otherwise the mediwm, which I employ, would be vague in its aim, and
uncertain in its direction. But they did not see, that this was done by
simply producing the promises of Moses on this point: And that as Unbe-
lievers professed to allow thus much (and with Unbelievers only, I had to
do) my point was to prove to them, on their own principles, the actual per-
“formance of those promises, by the medium of the Omission. It is true,
indeed, had no extraordinary providence been promised, it had then been
incumbent on me previously to have shewn, that Scripture represented the
Israelites as living under such a providence, in order to give my medium
that certain direction, which leads to my Conclusion. But as it was pro-
mised, the Unbeliever’s confession of that promise was all I wanted.
Yet both Believers and Unbelievers have thought it of such consequence
that the Argument of The Divine Legation should be discredited, that they
have not scrupled to reverse all the Laws of Logic in this important ser-
vice. Hence the Conclusion is turned into the premisses for the use of
our Doctors ; and the premisses, into the Conclusion for the use of our
Philosophers.
The ingenious Frenchman’s second Argument against The Divine Lega-
tion is in these words—“ Either Moses was acquainted with this doctrine
La future state], and, in this case, he deceived the Jews in not communi-
cating it to them; Or he was ignorant of it, and, in this case, he did not
know enough for the Founder of a Good Religion.”
As to the first charge of his deceiving the Jews, I have answered it long
ago, in my animadversions on Lord Boxincproxe, from whom the argu-
ment is taken.
As to the second, that Moses’s ignorance made him incapable of founding
a good Religion,—it receives all its strength from an equivocation in the
term, good ; and a misrepresentation of the nature of the Mosace LHistory.
Good may signify either relative or absolute; good for some, or good
for all. Our Philosopher confounds these two meanings. A good Religion
designed for all men cannot be without’a future state: But a Religion
given toa single Tribe, singularly circumstanced, may be good, without a
future state.
00 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IIT.
Moses (says he) ignorant of a future state, knew not enough to found a
good Religion. Wad Moses, when he said nothing of a future state, been
equally silent concerning an extraordinary Providence, He might, I will
confess, be concluded by our Philosopher (who supposes him a mere civil
Lawgiver and uninspired) not to know enough to found a good religion: But
when the Philosopher himself tells us that Moses had promised this extra-
ordinary providence when he omitted a future state ; then, even on his own
Idea of the Character of Moses, he can never rationally conclude, that the
Lawgiver was not knowing enough in his office to found a good Religion,
since we find that he did indeed know the use of a future state, as he pro-
vided a succedaneum for the want of it. Now, a Religion which teaches
all that natural Religion teaches, viz. that God is, and that he is a rewarder
of them who seck him, must needs be a good Religion ; and the Founder of
it a perfect Master of his business.
Let us consider what all other Lawgivers did, whom our Philosopher
will allow to have known enough. They founded their Religions on this
common Principle, That God is, and that he is a Rewarder, &c. The doc-
trine of a future state was no more than a security for this Foundation, by
a proper sanction, under an wnequal Providence. Moses, under an egual
dispensation of things, wanted not this sanction for the security of his
Foundation, and therefore did not employ it.
But then (adds the Philosopher) ¢f the Mosaic Religion was a coop Reli-
gion, Why was it abolished? His equivocation in the use of the word
good, which may signify either.relative or absolute good, hath been already
taken notice of. Had the Mosaic Religion been absolutely good, that is,
good for all men as well as for the Jews, it had certainly never been abo-
lished. But good, in this sense, he well knows, the Religion of Moses was
never said to be, by the Author of The Divine Legation, or any other
Believer. They only contend for its relative goodness. It was relatively
good, they say, as it fully answered the design of God who gave it; which
was, to preserve a chosen people, separate from the rest of mankind, to be a
repository for the doctrine of the Unrry; and to prepare the way for the
further Revelation of a Religion absolutely good, or a Religion for the use
of all Mankind. Now, to ask, Why a Religion only relatively good was
abolished, to make way for another absolutely good, for the sake of which,
the first was given in the énterim, is a question that could be kept in coun-
tenance by nothing but the impertinence of a formal answer.
But, as our Philosopher, by his question, “If the Mosaic Religion was a
good religion, Why was it abolished?” seems to deny the justice and rea-
sonableness of such a conduct in the Deity, I shall attempt, a little more
fully,
to justify the ways of God to man.
—“TruE Religion” (says he) “should be for all times and all places.” —I
haye rarely found any other labour in solving an objection to Revelation,
than in detecting and exposing the ambiguity and equivocation of the
terms, in which such are almost always delivered. It is the case here.
APPENDIX. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 61
True Religion (as we before observed of good) may either signify a perfect
Religion, or a Religion truely coming from God. True Religion, in the
sense of a perfect Religion, hath certainly the attributes here assigned to it,
of being for all times and places; and this, we say, is amongst the attri-
butes of the Curistran. But true Religion in the sense only of a Religion
truely coming from God, like the Mosarc, doth imply no such wniversality ;
as shall be now shewn.
The assertion stands on this Principle, “That it is not agreeable to what
the best Philosophy teacheth concerning the Nature and Attributes of the
Deity, to give a rule of life to one particular people, exclusive of the rest
of Mankind :” because such a dispensation would imply partiality and an
impotent fondness for one above the rest. Now if God’s revealing himself
to one Race or Family doth imply 7m the act itself such a partiality, the
Principle is well founded. But, it is apparent to common sense, that it
doth not imply it; since various other reasons, besides partial fondness,
may be assigned for the act. To know whether a partial fondness be the
motive, we must attend to the reasons which the Divine Author hath given
for the Dispensation ; either explicitely by words in the declarations of his
Messengers, or implicitely by circumstances attending the Gift.
Now, we say, that the Jewish Religion (the Dispensation in question)
contains all these proofs, both express and implied, of its not being given
out of fondness for the Jews, or under a neglect of the Gentiles ; but, on
the contrary, for the sake of Mankind in general.
It is notorious to all acquainted with ancient History, that, at the time
Moses revealed the Law of God to the Jews, the whole Posterity of Adam,
by some disaster or other, had forgot the Lord their Creator, and were
sunk into the grossest Idolatries. It is agreeable to all the ideas we have
of God’s goodness, that he should rescue the human Race from the miser-
able condition into which they had fallen, through the abuse of their free-
will; and out of which, by their own strength, they were unable to
extricate themselves. ‘
The only remaining question, then, will be, Whether, in this charitable
work, Gop should seek the way of performing it, in our ideas, or in his
own? ‘The Philosopher says, without all doubt in owrs ; God should have
relieved his labouring Creatures all at once, and have proceeded directly to
the END, an universal Religion like the Christian ; instead of stopping so
long at the mrans, a partial Religion like the Jewish. If God had any
thing to do in the matter, we may be assured, the wniversal Religion would
be delayed no longer than to the time in which he foresaw, that the giving
of it would produce the best effects. And as Ages and Seasons are in the
hand of God, Hr only knows the proper time for the accomplishment of
his end. Indeed, were Man a machine, and to be governed only by the
Laws of matter and motion, we can conceive no reason why infinite Wis-
dom did not pursue that direct course which led immediately to the END,
instead of exercising its Providence so long in the support and continuance
of the mrans. But as, in the opinion of Religionists of all kinds, man as
not a machine, but was created an accountable Creature ; and as none can be
02 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK 1711.
accountable without the power and use of FREE-wILL ; this Creature was to
be drawn (according to God’s own expression) with the cords of a man.
‘But He only, who formed the human heart, and knows what is in man, can
tell when these cords are to be relaxed, and when drawn strait. In other
words, the best means or method of bringing all mankind to God’s truth
cannot possibly be known by any but Himself. When we have seen the
method employed, and the effects it hath produced, we have a sure way of
knowing that it was the best; because it was employed by an all-wise
Conductor.
Now the Jewish Religion was the great MEAN, employed by Providence,
of bringing αἱ men to Curist. If this can be proved, and that the Mosaic
Law was not given to the Jews out of any partial fondness for them, it will
appear that a Religion may be true, though it were not designed for all
times and places.
ABRAHAM (as appears by the history of his Race) was called by God out
of an édolatrous City, to be the Father and founder of a People, which,
sequestered from all other, was to preserve amongst them, as in a sure
Repository, the name and memory of the Creator; at this point of time,
in imminent danger of being obliterated and lost ; to preserve it, I say, till
the fulness of time should come ; that is, till an Universal Religion, founded
in the mystery of Redemption, should be revealed. In the very entrance
on this means, the END was imparted to the Father of the Faithful, viz.
that IN HIS NAME ALL THE FAMILIES UPON EARTH SHOULD BE BLESSED.
When the race of Abraham were now become numerous enough to sup-
port themselves in a National sequestration, God informs them, by the
ministry of Moses, that the immediate blessings attending this sequestration,
were bestowed upon them for the sake of their Bather, Abraham, as the
sequestration itself was ordained for the sake of all Mankind, intimated in
the promise, that in his name all the Families upon earth should be blessed.
By the ministry of his Prophets He repeats the same Lesson to them, viz.
that this distinction was not for their sakes, but for his holy name’s sake ;
that is, for the better manifestation of his gracious Dispensation to all man-
kind. And, without question, the exceeding perversity and unworthiness
of this People was recorded in sacred story, as for other uses to us
unknown, so for this, to obviate that egregious folly both of Jews and
Gentiles, in supposing that the Israelites were thus distinguished, or repre-
sented to be thus distinguished, as the peculiar Favourites of Heaven. An
absurdity which all who attended to the nature of the God of Israel could
confute : and which the Jewish History amply exposes.
But if their History informs us for what they were not selected, their
Law and their Proruers inform us, for what they were. These declare,
in their different modes of information, that this Religion was given, to
prepare men for, and to facilitate the reception of, one UNIVERSAL.
In the first place, Let us consider the RiruAL or cEREMoNIAL Law. If
what I have here assigned to be, was, in truth, the end of the Jewish Dis-
pensation, we may expect to find this Ritual declarative of such a purpose.
And on examination it will be found to be so. The whole body of the
APPENDIX. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 63
ritual Law being framed, in part, to oppose to the prevailing superstition of
the Age in which it was given ; and, in part, to prefigure that future Dis-
pensation, which was to take it away. By virtue of the first part of it’s
nature, the Jews were kept separate: and by virtue of the second, they
were prepared to receive, and enabled to understand, the Religion of their
promised Messiah. This, for the sake of mankind in general, was a neces-
sary provision, since the first Preachers of the Gospel were preordained to
be taken from amongst the Jewish People.
As to the Propuers, which from time to time were sent amongst them
for the support of the Law: These (as appears by their predictions) had it
principally in their Commission to acquaint their Countrymen occasionally,
and by slow degrees, with the approaching cHance of their Oeconomy,
and with the different narurE of the new Dispensation.
Amongst the several intimations given them of the change, I shall select
only two of the most capital; the one is concerning the punishment of
Children for the crimes of their Fathers ; the other, of the abolition of the
Temple- Worship.
I have shewn that the first was promulged in aid of the sanction of the
Jewish Law, in the absence of a futwre state ; but of no further use after
the revelation of Life and immortality. So that Jeremiah, prophesying of
this future Dispensation, says,—Jn those days, they shall say no more, The
Fathers have eaten a sowre grape, and the Children’s teeth are set on edge.
But every one shall die for his own iniquity ; every man that eateth the sowre
grape his teeth shall be set on edge.* Yet such hath been the fortune of
this illustrious evidence of the connexion between the old and new Law,
that it has been represented as a contradiction between the Law and the
Prophets.t Although Jeremiah, as if on set purpose to obviate so foolish
a calumny, immediately adds—Behold the days come, saith the Lord, that I
will make a New Covenant with the house of Israel and Judah ; Τ i. e.
** The Reason why I take away this support of the sanction is, because the
sanction itself will be abolished.”
Another intimation of the change of the Dispensation is the Prophecy
concerning the abolition of the Temple Worship. Fyrom the account given
of the nature of the Jewish Law it appears, that the principal Rites of their
Religious Worship were to be performed and celebrated in some appro-
priated and determined Place. This, the object and subject of their crrE-
MONIAL seemed equally to require: For the ideas of a tutelary God and
King implied a Loca RESIDENCE : and a national Act, created and arising
from these relations, required a fied and certain place for it’s celebrations.
This, which the nature and reason of things so evidently point out, the
institutes of the Law expresly order and enjoin. During the early and
unsettled times of the Republic, the sacrifices prescribed by the Mosaic
Ritual were directed to be offered up before the door of an ambulatory
Tabernacle: But when they had gained the establishment decreed for
them, and a magnificent Temple was now erected for the God-of Israel,
* Jer xxxi. 29) 30, { See book v. sect. 5, of this work. t Jer. xxxi.
51. 90. 99. :
64 THE DIVINE LEGATION . BOOK Itt.
from henceforth all sacrifices were to be offered at Jerusalem only. Now
sacrifices constituting the very essence of their national Worship, their
Religion could no longer subsist than while that celebration continued.
Yet the Prophets foretold, that a time would come when there should be no
longer any Trmpre-Worsuir ; which, in other words, was to foretella
change in the Dispensation. Zephaniah says, The Lord shall be terrible—
Men shall worship him every one FROM HIs PLACE, even all the Isles of the
GrnTILEs*—every one from his place ; that is, “they were not to go up to
JeRusALEM to worship.” This he expresses more precisely in another
place—Jn that day, there shall be an auranr to the Lord in the midst of the
Land of Kayer;t i. e. “the Temple-service shall be abolished.” Which
Malachi thus confirms, in a diversified expression—And IN EVERY PLACE
incense shall be offered unto thy name, and a PURE OFFERING ; 1 i. 6. “it
shall not be the less acceptable for not being offered up at the Temple of
Jerusalem.”
But the Prophets not only give information of the cuance of the οἷά,
but explain the Nature of the zew Dispensation. Isaiah, speaking of this
change, intimates its nature in these words—As the Heavens are higher than
the Earth, so are my ways higher than your ways, and my thoughts than your
thoughts.§ And explains it more clearly by the following figure ; Jnstead
of the thorn shall come up the fir-tree, and instead of the brier shall come up
the myrtle-tree ; || i.e. “the new Religion shall as far excel the old as the
fir-tree does the thorn ; or, the myrtle, the brier.””—Behold (says the same
Prophet speaking in the name of God) 7 create NEw HEAvENs and ὦ NEW
Earru ; and the former shall not be remembered or come in mind.|—Behold
the days come, saith the Lord, (by the Prophet Jeremiah) that I will
make @ NEW Covenant with the house of Israel—not according to the covenant
that I made with their Fathers—But this shall be the covenant—I will put my
Law into their iNWARD PaRts, and write it in their wEaRtTs.** What Isaiah
figuratively names, a new Heaven and a new Earth, Jeremiah, more simply
and literally, calls a new Covenant. And what kind of Covenant ?—I will
put my Law into their inward parts, &c., i. e. “this Law shall be spiritual,
as the other given to their Fathers was carnal.” But, concerning the
nature of this prophetic phraseology, and the reasons of it’s use, the
Reader may see it explained at large in the second part of this Work.tt
From all this it appears (if we may credit the clearest conclusions of
human reason) that a Religion may be true though it be not fitted for all
times and places. A proposition which (although our Philosopher takes for
granted) carries its absurdity in the very face of it.
But, says this ingenious Writer—7Zrue Religion should be like the splen-
dour of the Sun, which extends its beams to all People and to all Generations.
—When the controversy runs from reasoning to simile, it begins to smell of
the Poet rather than the Philosopher. What relation, what connexion is
there between the Sum and Religion more than in a fanciful analogy ? Light
“ Chap. ii. 11. + Isaiah xix. 19. 1 Chap. i. 11. § Chap. lv. 9.
|| Chap. lv. 13. 4“ Chap. Ixv. 17. ** Chap. xxxi. 31. +t Book vi.
sect. 6.
AP PENDIX. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 65
is a physical emanation operating on this material Globe: Revelation, a
voluntary gift bestowed upon the rational Inhabitants of it. All they hold
in common is, that they are both blessings, but of very different kinds.—Or
was it the Poet’s intention, in this simile, to insinuate the Phzlosopher’s
system of NATURALISM ?
ἘΠ:
So much for the strait-laced Divine and the loose-bodied Philosopher ;
but to the soper Rexieronist, of whatever denomination, I have something
more to say ; and I hope so much to his satisfaction, that this objection to
the Mosaic Law, from the omission of a future state, shall never hereafter
be considered in the learned world, as any other than an ignorant prejudice.
Now to understand how Revelation in general is affected by the repre-
sentation which 1 have given of the Jewish, it will be necessary to con-
sider, What the light of Nature teacheth us concerning ReEticious
SANCTIONS.
The true idea of natural Religion (defining and including the essence
wherein it consists) is no where so concisely, so fully, and so elegantly
delivered as by St. Paut in these words,—He who cometh to God must believe
that he is ; and that he is a Rewarder of them who diligently seek him: In
other words, the sum of natural Religion (he tells us) is this, “ Belief in
God, and that he rewards his Faithful Worshippers ; which implies his
punishing the unfaithful.’—While this is steadfastly believed, natural
Religion stands on a solid Basis. If any thing be seen in God’s dispensing
Providence here, which shews that God is not always a Rewarder, Sc., the
Belief is shaken, and Religion is in danger. The unequal distribution of
things here below endangers it ; and it becomes re-established by the inter-
vention of the Doctrine of a rururE state. Thus, we see, the belief of a
future state is not of the Essence of naruran Retrie1on, but one of the
accidents of it only ; for were the distribution equal, as from the Being and
Attributes of the Deity (abstractedly considered) one might be led to
expect, a future state had never come into the definition of natural Religion.
The Mosaic Religion was a repuBtication of natural Religion to the
Jews. And all it taught, concerning it’s sanction, was, that God ts, and
that he is a Rewarder, &c. The reason why a future state was omitted is
apparent : Moses assured them they were under the dispensation of an.
equal Providence here. And now let me ask, How it comes to pass that the
self-same system of Religion, which, one way (by the light of reason )
revealed to man, does honour to God, if we believe St. Paul ; yet, another
way, revealed (4y Moses) does dishonour him, if we give credit to our
modern Divines ?
When God separated a chosen People, he gave them, for their Belief, the
principles of narurat Rewiaron (republished by the Ministry of Moses) in
its orrarNAL and most perfect Form, under an equal Providence. And yet
this circumstance, which sets it far above it’s publication amongst the Gen-
tiles by natural light, is esteemed a disgrace to it ; and men rather chuse to
piece-out God’s Dispensation from what they can find in the lumber and
VOL. ITI. E
66 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK III.
rubbish of Paganism, than receive it in it’s native simplicity and genuine
grandeur: And, because natural Religion, disturbed and corrupted amongst
the Gentiles, was forced to lean on the Crutch of a future state, they will
needs find the same prop for the pure and perfect, as REPUBLISHED by Moses,
though it stands upright, under an extraordinary Providence.
The truth is, this false idea arises from an inveterate error (to be exposed
at large in the last volume of this Work) that natural Religion not only
teaches a future state, (which it does indeed, though by accident only) but
that it teaches this state to be ENDLESS, which it neither does, nor can do.
All it teaches is, that God is, and that he is a Rewarder ; whether here or
hereafter is to be collected from the mode of God’s dispensing Providence
here.
This error, which confounds all our reasoning on God’s moral Govern-
ment, arose, in part, from a later Revelation, the Christian, ill understood
(of which, more hereafter) ; and, in part, from false and visionary Meta-
physics. :
1. But say they, “ Admitting, that natural Religion taught no more than
St. Paul learned of it, yet surely a Revelation, such as the Mosaic, must
contain more, or why was it given ?””—I will answer these mén in their own
way—It was given as a republication of the Religion of Nature: For
though they were egregiously mistaken in receiving the Christian Religion
for no more; yet it is very certain, the Mosaic, with regard to Doctrine,
was, indeed, just such a Republication, and no other. Nor, does human
conception discover any thing incongruous in the moral conduct of the
Deity, when he renews those Laws, first revealed in an ordinary way, and
by the folly of men become almost erased ; to renew them, I say, in an
extraordinary. For we do not oppose the talk of Christianity’s being only
such a republication on account of any incongruity in the thing itself ; but
because, that, when applied to the Christian Religion, this defimition of it
is both false and imperfect, and averse to the whole genius and nature of
the Dispensation.
2. But, secondly, it may be said, That “ the Doctrine of future rewards
is of force to purify and spiritualize the mind; which that of temporal
rewards is not.” To this, I reply, That the snown rewards here, or the
unknown hereafter, leave the mind just in that state in which Religion
itself, or Piety towards God, hath put it. It is the rree opeprence to his
commands, not the sense of the necessary consequence of that obedience,
which rectifies the Will, and purifies the Affections.
But the mistake, here confuted, arises from men’s having confounded a
future state, as discoverable by natural light, with the future state as
announced in the Gospel. Now, Natural light discovers to us nothing of
the Nature of that State ; and therefore leaves the mind in that situation in
which an indefinite Reward puts it. The Gospel, indeed, defines a future
state so fully, as to enable the doctrine to purify and spiritualize the ἡ
Mind, above ail other modes of Religion.
But what does this concession infer? That the Mosaic Religion, which
- taught an equal Providence, but omitted to teach a future state, was unwor-
NOTES. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 67
thy of God? Surely not. For then it would follow, that natural Religion,
that other revelation of God’s will, which taught no future state, till Pro-
vidence here was found to be unequal, was likewise unworthy of Him.
What then, does it infer? This, and this only, that the Mosaic Religion
wants much of that perfection which the Christzan hath. Now, this truth
is not only acknowledged, but contended for.
The Question then may return, Could God, according to the idea we
have of his attributes, give a less perfect Religion, in order to facilitate the
reception of one more perfect? The question may return, I say, but in
order to be sent back for its confutation, to the answer already bestowed
upon it, in the examination of Mr. Voltaire’s Objections.
NOTES
ON
THE THIRD BOOK.
P. 411, vol.i. A. Ir may not be improper, on this occasion, to present the
Reader with an extract from a Letter of the late President Monrrsqureu to
the Author, who had given him some account of Lord Bolingbroke’s
Posthumous Works, just then on the point of publication—* J’ay lu quel-
ques ouvrages de My Lord Bolingbroke—Or, Monsieur, dans cet ouvrage
posthume, dont vous me donnes une idée, il me semble qu’il vous prepare
une matiere continuelle de triomphe. Celui qui attaque la Religion revelée
n’attaque que la Religion revelée; mais celui qui attaque la Religion
naturelle attaque toutes les Religions du monde. Si lon enseigne aux
hommes quwils n’ont pas ce frein ci, ils peuvent penser qu’ils en ont un
autre: Mais il est bien plus pernicieux de leur enseigner qu’ils n’en ont pas
du tout. 1] n’est pas impossible d’attaquer une Religion revelée, parce
quelle existe par des faits particuliers, et que les faits, par leur nature,
peuvent étre une matiere de dispute: mais il n’en est pas de méme de la
Religion naturelle ; elle est tirée de la nature de ’homme, dont on ne peut
pas disputer, et du sentiment interieur de ’homme, dont on ne peut pas
disputer encore. J’ajoute a ceci, Quel peut étre le motif d’attaquer la
Religion revelée en Angleterre? on l’y a tellement purgé de tout prejugé
destructeur qu’elle n’y peut faire de mal, et qu’elle y peut faire, au con-
traire, une infinité de biens. Je sais, qu'un homme en Espagne ou en
Portugal que l’on va bruler, ou qui craint d’étre brulé, parce qu’il ne croit
point de certains articles dependans ou non de la Religion revelée, a une
juste sujet de attaquer, parce qu’il peut avoir quelque esperance de pour-
voir ἃ sa defence naturelle: Mais il n’en est pas de méme en Angleterre, ou
tout homme qui attaque la Religion revelée l’attaque sans interest, et ou cet
homme quand il reussiroit, quand méme il auroit raison dans le fond, ne
feroit que detruire une infinité de biens pratiques pour ¢tablir une verité
purement speculative.
“ Jay eté ravi, &e.
A Paris, ce 26 May, 1754. “ MonrESQqUIEU.”
P. 411. B. Strabo’s words are—Kat φόξους, καὶ ἀπειλὰς, ἢ διὰ λόγων, ἢ διὰ
F 2
68 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK ITi.
τύπων ἀώρων, “Fears and threatnings either by words or dreadful forms.”
Casaubon, who corrected the last word very justly, has given us no explana-
tion of the allusion in this obscure sentence. I am persuaded, the author
had in his mind the dreadful words spoken, and the representations exhibited
in the Mysteries, for the very purpose the author here mentions: so
ἀπειλὰς refers to λόγων, and φόξους to τύπων dwpev. The reader, who
remembers what has been said in the section of the Mysteries, in the fore-
going book, concerning this matter, will be inclined to believe this to be the
true explanation.
P. 415. C. And, without doubt, this was amongst the reasons for his
declining, throughout the whole course of his life, the study and the teach-
ing of physics, or natural philosophy, which had a direct tendency to shake
and overturn one half of the national religion, namely the worship of, what
were called, the celestial Gods, or Host of Heaven. ;
P. 415. Ὁ. We have, indeed, been told, that, to his Cock he might have
added a Bull ; for that the Philosopher was now in a delirium, occasioned
by the cicuta, to which, Scribonius Largus attributes this effect. But I
apprehend, the eminent persons who then attended the last moments of the
expiring Philosopher (and must have been well apprised of the nature of a
draught, whose legal application to criminals of state had made its effects
familiar to every one) would have been the first to observe this symptom, if,
indeed, the drug had any such property. Whereas they speak of Socrates
as perfectly in his senses when he made this request ; and I think They are
rather to be relied on who understood what related both to the sacrifice and
the drug, than They who know so little of either ; especially as we find this
rite was exactly suitable to the foregoing declaration of Conrormiry, in his
defence before his judges.
P. 416. E. “ Duplex enim erat doctrine genus apud antiquas gentes,
δημῶδες καὶ ἀπόῤῥητον, doctrina vulgaris et doctrina arcana: idque non
tantum ob diversitatem materie, sed eandem sepe materiam duplici modo
tractabant, populari et philosophica.”—Archwol. Phil. 1. i. c. 8.—See this
matter explained at large by the very learned author of the Critical inquiry
into the opinions and practice of the ancient philosophers, §c. second edit.
chap. 11, 12, 13.
P. 417. Β΄. “The author of the philosophical piece commonly ascribed to
Origen, says, That he sometimes complied with the popular opinion, and declared
that the universe would be one day destroyed. Καὶ Παρμενίδης ἕν μὲν τὸ
way ὑποτίθεται, AIAION TE, καὶ ἀγέννητον, καὶ σφαιροειδὲς" οὐδ᾽ αὐτὸς EKPEY-
TON ΤῊΝ ΤΩΝ πολλῶν AOZAN, wip λέγων καὶ γῆν ΤᾺΣ ΤΟΥ ΠΑΝΤῸΣ
APXAS, τὴν μὲν γῆν, ὡς ὕλην᾽ τὸ δὲ wip, ὡς αἴτιον, καὶ τπτοιοῦν: TON KOSMON
ΕἸΠῈ ΦΘΕΙΡΕΣΘΑΙ. It appears too from this passage that he spoke
popularly, when he said that the world was made, or had a beginning ; and
that this doctrine was merely popular, may be seen too from the following
words of Themistius. Kal γὰρ ὁ Παρμενίδης ἐν τοῖς τορὸς δόξαν, τὸ Seppov
ποιεῖ καὶ τὸ ψυχρὸν ἀρχὰς, ὧν τὸ μὲν wip, τὸ δὲ γῆν τρροσαγορεύει. Itis then
evident from these passages that, in his ezoterics, he gave the world both a
beginning and an end. But then in his other writings he denied that it had
either. I need not quote Cicero, Plutarch, or Eusebius, to prove this; the
following verses of his own are sufficient for my present purpose :
Αὐτὰρ ἀκίνητον μεγάλων. ἐν welpact δεσμῶν
Ἔστιν ANAPXON, AMAYSTON, ἐπεὶ ΓΈΝΕΣΙΣ καὶ ΟΛΕΘΡΟΣ
Τῇδε mar ἐπλάγχθησαν, ἄπωσε δὲ τοίστις ἀληθής."
See the Critical enquiry into the opinions and practice of the ancient philo-
sophers, p. 225, 2d edit.
NOTES. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 69.
P. 420. G. One of the Answerers of The Divine Legation says, “ What
a noble field would have been here opened for the Faruerrs, could they have
charged the Pagan sages and philosophers with the dissimulation which
Mr. W. has here done! Could they have loaded them with the crime of
believing one thing and teaching another, with ty1NG, with imposing on the
credulity of the people ; what a display of rhetoric should we have had !
Could there have been a more fit occasion for satire or declamation ?—nut
THEY NEVER REPROACH THEM ON THAT account.”—Dr. Sykes’s Exam.
p- 88. The gravity of all this is so rarely contrasted with its profound
knowledge, that the Reader cannot find in his heart to be angry with him
for what follows, from these Faruers ; with whom the good Doctor appears
to be so well acquainted.
Arnosius, speaking of this custom of believing one thing and teaching
another, says: “ Nune vero, cum ALIUD CREDITIS et ALIUD FINGITIS, et in
eos estis contumeliosi, quibus id attribuitis, quod eos confitemini non esse :
et irreligiost esse monstramini, cum id adoratis quod fingitis, non quod in re
esse, ipsaque in veritate censetis.”—Z,. iii. p. 109. Lugd. ed.
Eusestus reproaches Plato on this very account: charges him with mean
dissimulation for teaching doctrines which he believed to be false, merely
out of reverence to the laws of his country. Καὶ τὸ wapa γνώμην δὲ ταῦτα
λέγειν τῶν νόμων ἕνεκα διαῤῥήδην παρίστησιν ὁμολογῆσας, ὅτι δέοι ἑπομένους TO
νόμῳ πιστεύειν αὐτοῖς. Prep. Evang. ¢. xiii. 1.---ὠαλλὰ γὰρ τούτων δὲ χάριν
ἀπολειπτέος ἡμῖν οὗτος, δέει ϑανάτου τὸν ᾿Αθηναίων δῆμον καθυποκρινάμενος.
6. 15.
LAcTANTIUs reproves Cicero for the same practice : “ Cum videamus etiam
doctos et prudentes viros, cum religionum intelligant vanitatem, nihilo-
minus tamen in iis ipsis, que damnant, colendis, NESCIO QUA PRAVITATE,
perstare. Intelligebat Cicero falsa esse, que homines adorarent : nam cum
multa dixisset, que ad eversionem religionum valerent : ait tamen non esse
illa vulgo disputanda, ne susceptas publice religiones disputatio talis extin-
guat : Quid ei facies, qui, cum errare se sentiat, ultro ipse in lapides im-
pingat, ut populus omnis offendat? Ipse sibi oculos eruat, ut omnes ceci
sint? Qui nec de aliis bene mereatur, quos patitur errare ; nec de seipso,
qui alienis accedit erroribus; nee utitur tandem sapientie sue bono, ut
factis impleat, quod mente percepit.” Div. Instit. 1. 11. ¢. 3.
St. Austin’s account of Seneca is not at all more favourable. “Sed iste
quem philosophi quasi Jiberum* fecerunt, tamen quia illustris populi
Romani Senator erat, colebat quod reprehendebat ; agebat, quod arguebat ;
quod culpabat, adorabat.—Eo damnabilius, quod illa que MENDACITER
agebat sic ageret, ut populus veraciter agere existimaret.” De civ. Dei,
1: yi. ὁ: 10:
But this Father concludes all the Pagan sages and philosophers under the
same condemnation, for rmpostne (as Dr. Sykes expresses it) ON THE
CREDULITY OF THE PEOPLE, and with satire and declamation enough of con-
science, if that will satisfy the Doctor.—* Quod utique non aliam ob
causam factum videtur, nisi quia homines velut prudentium et sapientium
negotium fuit, POPULUM IN RELIGIONIBUS FALLERE, et in eo ipso non solum
colere, sed imitari etiam Demones. Sicut enim Demones nisi eos quos
fallendo deceperint, possidere non possunt, sic et homines principes non sane
justi sed Demonum similes, ea que vana esse noverant, religionis nomine
populis tanquam vera suadebant, hoe modo eos civili societati velut arctius
alligantes.” De civit. Dei, 1. iv. ¢. 182.
* Alluding to the Stoical wise man.
70 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Ill.
P. 424. H. One scarce meets with any thing in antiquity concerning
Pythagoras’s knowledge in physics, hut what gives us fresh cause to admire
the wonderful sagacity of that extraordinary man. This story of his pre-
dicting earthquakes has so much the air of a fable, that I believe it has been
generally ranked (as it is by Stanley) with that heap of trash, which the
enthusiastic Pythagoreans and Platonists of the lower ages have raked
together concerning him. Yet we learn from the collections of Pliny the
Elder, which say—“ futuro terre motu, est 7 puteis turbidior aqua,” 1. ii.
c. 83, that the ancients profited of this discovery, verified by a modern
relation of Paul Dudley, Esq. in the Philosophical Transactions, No. 437.
Ῥ. 72, who, speaking of an earthquake which lately happened in New
England, gives this remarkable account of its preceding symptoms: “ A
neighbour of mine, that has a Well thirty-six feet deep, about three days
before the earthquake, was surprized to find his water, that used to be very
sweet and limpid, stink to that degree that they could make no use of it,
nor scarce bear the house when it was brought in; and thinking some
carrion was got into the Well, he searched the bottom, but found it clear
and good, though the colour of the water was turned wheyish, or pale. In
about seven days after the earthquake, his water began to mend, and in
three days more returned to its former sweetness and colour.”
P. 426. 1. “Cesar” (says Cato) “bene et composite paulo ante, in hoe
ordine, de vita et morte disseruit, credo falsa existumans ea que de inferis
MEMORANTUR.” Apud eund. Cicero’s reply is to the same purpose : “ Itaque
ut aliqua in vita formido improbis esset posita, apud inferos ejusmodi
quedam illi ant1gur supplicia impiis constituta esse voluerunt: quod vide-
licet intelligebant, his remotis, non esse mortem ipsam pertimescendam.”
Orat. iv. in Catilin. ὃ 4. I cannot conceive what the very ingenious
Mr. Moyle could mean in his Essay on the Roman Government, by saying,—
if the immortality of the soul (by which he means the doctrine of a future
state of rewards and punishments) had been an ESTABLISHED doctrine, Cesar
would not have derided it in the face of the whole senate—Do not the words
of Cicero—Antiqui supplicia impiis constituta esse voluerunt, expressly
declare it to be an established doctrine ?
When Juvenal speaks of the impiety of Rome, with regard to this
religious opinion, he exhorts the sober part of them to adhere to it, in
these words :
“ Sed tu vera puta. Curius quid sentit, et ambo
Scipiade ? quid Fabricius manesque Camilli?
quoties hine talis ad illos
Umbra venit ? cuperent lustrari, si qua darentur
-Sulphura cum tedis, et si foret humida laurus.
Illuc, heu! Miseri traducimur ”-
Those who understand these lines can never doubt whether a future State
was the established doctrine in Rome.—Yet, stranger than ail this, the very
learned Mosheim, in his De Rebus Christ. Comment. p. 15, speaking of this
licentious part of Cesar’s speech, seems to copy Mr. Moyle’s opinion
(whose works he had translated) in these words—“ Ita magni hi Homines
et Romane civitatis principes nunquam ausi fuissent loqui, in Concilio
Patrum conscriptorum δὲ Religio credere jussisset, mentes hominum per-
ennes esse.’ By his, si Religio credere jussisset, he must mean—é@f this had
been the established Doctrine—He could not mean—had the Pagan Religion
in general enjoined it to be believed—For there was no national Religion of
Paganism without it. But the reason he gives for his opinion exceeds all
belief. He says, “Cato is so far from blaming Cesar for this declaration,
NOYES. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. vil
that he rather openly applauds it ’—“ Quam orationem M. Portius Caro,
illud Stoice Familie presidium et decus, tantum abest, ut reprehendat, ut
potius publice pariter in Senatu laudat.” What are these terms of praise ?—
“Sic enim Bene et Composite,” inquit, “‘ Cesar paulo ante in hoc Ordine de
vita et morte disseruit: falsa, credo, existimans que de inferis memorantur.”
Surely this bene et composite disseruit, was so far from being intended by
the rigid Stoic as a compliment on his capital Adversary, that it was a
severe censure, implying, in every term made use of, that Csar’s opinion
was no crude or hasty sentiment, taken up, as an occasional topic, out of an
ill-judged compassion for the Criminals, but that it was the System of his
School in this matter, deliberately dressed out with all the charms of his
own eloquence, in a studied and correct dissertation.
Ῥ. 431. K. Acad. Quest. 1.iv.—The learned Mosheim has done me the
honour of abridging my reasoning on this head in the following manner—
“ὁ Academici, meliores licet et sapientiores Scepticis videri vellent, eque tamen
mali et perniciosi erant. Id ipsum enim dogma, in quo vis et ratio disci-
pline Sceptice posita erat, probabant ‘ Nihil cognosci, nihil percipi, nihil
sciri posse, et de omnibus idcirco rebus, nullo interposito judicio, disputan-
dum esse.’ Hoc unum inter utrosque intererat, quod cum Sceptici sta-
tuerent, “nulli rei ad sentiendum, sed perpetuo disputandum esse.’
Academici e contrario sciscerent ‘in illis que veri speciem haberent seu
probabilia viderentur, acquiescendum esse.’ Atguc hoc ipsum PROBABILE
cut sapientem adsentiri volebant Academici, NUNQUAM ILLI REPERIEBANT.
Quare non secus ac Sceptici infirmare omnia et incerta reddere studebant.
Id vero qui agunt, ut dubium prorsus et anceps videntur Utrum—<Animz
moriantur an supersint,”’ &c. De rebus Christ. Comment. p. 22.
P. 431. L. The reader may not be displeased to see the judgment of a
learned French writer on the account here given of the Academics—*“ L’on
fait voir que l’on doit exclure de ce nombre [des sectes dogmatistes]| les
nouveaux Academiciens, purs sceptiques, quoy qu’il y ait quelques auteurs
modernes qui pretendent le contraire, et entre autres M. Middleton, auteur
de la nouvelle Vie du Ciceron Anglois. Mais si l’on examine la source ott
il a puisé ses sentimens, on trouvera que c’est dans les apologies que les
Academiciens eux mémes ont faites pour cacher le scepticisme qui leur étcit
reproché par toutes les autres sectes; et de cette maniere on pourroit soute-
nir que les Pyrrhoniens mémes n’étoient point sceptiques. Qu’on se res-
souvienne seulement que, suivant le raport de Ciceron, Arcesilaus, fondateur
de la nouvelle Academie, nioit que Von fut certain de sa propre existence.
Apres un trait semblable, et plusieurs autres qui sont raportés—on laisse au
lecteur a décider du caractere de cette secte et du jugement qu’en porte M.
Middleton.”—M. De S. Dis. sur ? Union de la Religion, de la Morale, et de
la Politique, Pref, p. 12.
P. 432. M. Tully assures us that those of the Old Academy were Dog-
matists, Quest. Acad. lib. i. ‘ Nihil enim inter Perrpatericos et AcADE-
miAM illam vETEREM differebat ;”’ for that the Peripatetics were dogmatists
no body ever doubted. Yet the same Tully, towards the conclusion of this
book, ranks them with the sceptics, ‘“ Hanc Academiam novam appella-
bant, que mihi verus videtur ;” for such certainly was the New Academy.
The way of reconciling Cicero to himself I take. to be this: Where he
speaks of the conformity between the Peripatetics and the Old Academy, he
considers Plato as the founder of the Old Academy ; this appears from the
following words, Academ. 1. ii.c.5. “ Alter [mempe Plato] quia reliquit
perfectissimam disciplinam, Peripateticos et Academicos, nominibus differ-
entes, re congruentes :’? And where he speaks of the conformity between
79 ᾿ς THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iif,
the New Academy and the Old, he considers Socrates as the founder of the
Old Academy. For the New, as we here see, claimed the nearest relation to
their master. Thus De Wat. Deor.1. i. ¢. 5, he says, “ Ut hee in philoso-
phia ratio contra omnia disserendi, nullamque rem aperte judicandi, profecta
ἃ Socrate, repetita ab Arcesila, confirmata ἃ Carneade,” ὅς. But Tully, it
may be said, in the very place where he speaks of the agreement between
the Wew and Old Academy, understands Plato as ‘the founder of the
old; *‘ Hane Academiam novam appellant ; que mihi vetus videtur, si
quidem Platonem ex illa vetere numeramus ; cujus in libris nihil adfirma-
tur, et in utramque partem multa disseruntur ; de omnibus queritur, nihil
certi dicitur.” But it is to be observed, that Plato had a twofold cha-
racter: and is to be considered, on the one hand, as the Disciple and His-
torian of Socrates ; and on the other, as the Head of a Sect himself, and
master of Xenocrates and Aristotle. As the disciple, he affirms nothing ; as
the master, he is a Dogmatist. Under the first character, Socrates and he
are the same ; under the second, they are very different. Tully here speaks
of him under the first, as appears from what he says of him, nzhil adfirma-
tur, &c. Plato, in this place, therefore, is the same as Socrates. The not
distinguishing his double character, hath occasioned much dispute amongst
the Ancients ; as the not observing that Cicero hath, throughout his writ-
ings, made that distinction, hath much embarrassed the moderns. Diogenes
Laertius tells us, there were infinite disputes about Plato’s character ; some
holding that he did dogmatize, others that he did not. ᾿Επεὶ δὲ πολλὴ
στάσις ἐστὶ, καὶ of μέν φασιν αὐτὸν δογματίζειν, οἱ δ᾽ οὔ. Lib. ili. Seg. 51.
Sextus Empiricus says the same thing: τὸν Πλάτωνα οὖν, οἱ μὲν δογματικὸν
ἔφασαν εἶναι, οἱ δὲ ἀπορηματικόν. He then tells you, some distinguished
better: Kara δέ re δογματικόν. ἐν μὲν γὰρ Tots γυμναστικοῖς φασὶ λόγοις,
ἔνθα 6 Σωκράτης εἰσάγεται ἤτοι wailoy wpds τινας ἢ ἀγωνιζόμενος πρὸς
σοφιστὰς, γυμναστικόν τε καὶ ἀπορηματικόν φασιν ἔχειν αὐτὸν χαρακτῆρα"
δογματικὸν δὲ, ἔνθα σπουδάζων, ἀποφαίνεται ἤτοι διὰ Σωκράτους, ἢ Tepaiov,
ἢ τινος τῶν τοιούτων. That Cicero made the distinction, delivered above,
we shall now see. In the Academic Questions, he speaks of him as the
disciple and historian of Socrates’; and, under that character, “nihil adfir-
matur, et in utramque partem multa disseruntur, de omnibus queritur,
nihil certi dicitur.” In his Offices he speaks of him as different from
Socrates, and the founder of a sect: and then he is a Dogmatist, and, as he
says elsewhere, “reliquit perfectissimam disciplinam Peripateticos et Aca-
demicos nominibus differentes, re congruentes.” His words to his son are :
«ς Sed tamen nostra [nempe Academica] leges non multum a Peripateticis
dissidentia, quoniam utrique et Socratici et Platonici esse volumus ;” i. e.
He tells his son, that he would both dogmatize like Plato, and scepticize
like Socrates. But Grevius, not apprehending this double character of
Plato, would change Socratici to Stoici. For, says he, “ qui dieere potest se
utrumque esse voluisse Platonicum et Socraticum ; perinde est ac si scrip-
sisset utrumque se velle esse Peripateticum et Aristoteleam.” But there
was a vast difference between Plato, founder of the Academy, and Socrates ;
though none between Plato the disciple and historian of Socrates, and
Socrates.—The fortune of this note has been very singular ; and will afford
us a pleasant picture of the temper and genius of Answerers and their ways.
One man writing something about Plato and the ancients ; and reading
what is here said of Plato’s dogmatizing, abuses the author for making
him a dogmatist: And another who had to do, Ido not know how,
with Socrates and the moderns, and reading what relates to Plato’s scepticiz-
ing, is as plentiful, in his ribaldry and ill language, for making him a
NOTES. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 73
sceptic: while the author was, all the time, giving an historical relation of
what others made him; and only endeavoured to reconcile their various
accounts.
P. 435. N. Tusc. Disp. 1. i. 6. 16.—Honore refers to his philosophic
character ; and auctoritate to his legislative. The common reading is,
“cum honore et disciplina, tum etiam auctoritate.”’ Dr. B. in his emen-
dations on the Zusc. Quest. saw this was faulty ; but not reflecting on the
complicated character of Pythagoras, and perhaps not attending to Cicero’s
purpose (which was, not to speak of the natwre of his philosophy, but of
the reputation he had in Magna Grecia) he seems not to have hit upon the
true reading. He objects to honore, because the particles cwm and tum
require a greater difference in the things spoken of, than is to be found
in honos and auctoritas: which reasoning would have been just, had only a
philosophic character, or only a legislative, been the subject. But it was
Cicero’s plain meaning, to present Pythagoras under both these views. So
that honos, which is the proper consequence of succeeding in the first ; and
auctoritas, of succeeding in the latter ; have all the real difference that cum
and twm require ; at least Plutarch thought so, when he applied words of
the very same import to the Egyptian so/diery and the priesthood; to
whom, like the legislator and philosopher, the one having power and the
other wisdom, auctoritas and honos distinctly belong :—rod μὲν de ἀνδρίαν,
τοῦ δὲ διὰ σοφίαν, μένους AZIQMA καὶ TIMHN: ἔχοντος, De Isid. et
Osir, Another objection, the learned critic brings against the common
reading, has more weight ; which is, that in honore et disciplina, two words
are joined together as very similar in sense, which have scarce any affinity
or relation to one another: on which account he would read Mors ef disci-
plina. But this, as appears from what has been said above, renders the
whole sentence lame and imperfect: I would venture therefore to read,
(only changing a single letter) “tenuit Magnam illam Greciam cum honore
EX disciplina, tum etiam auctoritate :”? and then all will be right, dése¢plina
referring equally to honore and auctoritate, as implying both his philosophic
and civil institutions.*
P. 438. O. Demonstratio Evangelica ; which, because the World would
not accept for demonstration, and because he had no better to give, after a
long and vain search for certainty throughout all the Regions of Erudition,
he attempted, by the help of Sextus Empiricus, in order to keep himself in
credit, to shew that no such thing was to be had. And so composed his
book of the Weakness of human understanding. Malebranch has laid open
his ridiculous case with great force and skill—“TII est vrai qwil y en a
quelques-uns qui reconnoissent aprés vingt ou trente années de temps
perdu, qu’ils n’ont rien appris dans leurs lectures ; mais il ne leur plait pas
de nous le dire avec sincerité. Π faut auparavant qu’ils ayent prouve, a
leur mode, gwon ne peut rien scavoir ; et puis apres ils le confessent ;
parce qwalors ils croyent le pouvoir faire, sans qu’on se mocque de leur
ignorance.”
Ῥ. 448. P. Geddes, or his Glasgow editors, (to mention them for once)
in the essay on the composition of the ancients, are here very angry at the
author for charging Plato with making a monstrous mis-alliance, merely (as
they say) because he added the study of physics to that of morals > and
employ six pages in defending Plato’s conduct. As these insolent scribblers
could not see then, so possibly they will not be ready to learn now, that the
term of monstrous mis-alliance, which I gave to Plato’s project, of incorpo-
[“ In the references to the notes N and O in pages 435 and 438, the edition of 1811
has been followed, which by mistake quotes them az M and P.]
74 ‘THE DIVINE LEGATION ROOK 111.
rating the Pythagorie and Socratic Schools, referred to the opposite and
contrary geniuses of those Schools in their manner of treating their Sub-
jects, not to any difference which there is in their Subjects themselves.
The mis-alliance was not in joining Physics to Morals ; but in joining a
Fanatic Mysticism to the cool logic of common sense.
P. 454. Q. The unfairness of readers when their passions have made
them become writers, is hardly to be conceived : some of these have repre-
sented the three last testimonies as given to prove that Plato believed no
future state at all: though the author had plainly and expresly declared,
but a page or two before, p. 452, as well as at p. 414, that there was a sort
of future state which Plato did believe ; he refers to it again at p. 455,
and, what is more, observes here, on this last passage, that Celsua slludes to
this very future state of Plato.’ And what was it but this,—that future
happiness and misery were the natural and necessary consequences of
Virtue and Vice ; Vice being supposed to produce that imbecility and slug-
gishness which clogged and retarded the Soul, and hindered it from pene-
trating into the higher regions.
P. 456. R. This will explain the cause of a fact which Cicero observes
concerning them, where he speaks of the liberty which the Greek Philoso-
phers had taken, in inventing new Words—“ ex omnibus Philosophis Srorcr
plurima novaverunt.” de Fin. 1. ii. c. 2. For the more a Teacher deviates
from common notions, and the discipline of Nature, the less able he will be
to express himself by Words already in use.
P. 457. 5. This strange Stoical fancy, that the same Scenes of men and
things should revive and re-appear, can be only well accounted for by the
credit they gave to the dotages of Judicial Astrology, to which their doc-
trine of Fate much disposed them. This renovation was to happen in the
GREAT Piarontc YEAR, when all the heavenly Bodies were supposed to
begin their courses anew, from the same points from which they first set
out at their Creation. So Ausonius,
- “* Consumpto Magnus qui dicitur anno
Rursus in antiquum venient vaga sidera cursum,
Qualia dispositi steterant ab Origine Mundi.”
P. 459. T. Cicero makes the famous orator, M. Antonius, give this as
the reason why he hid his knowledge of the Greek Philosophy from
the People-—“ Sic decrevi [inquit Antonius] philosophari potius, ut Neopto-
lemus apud Ennium, paucis : nam omnino haud placet. Sed tamen hee est
mea sententia, quam videbar exposuisse. Ego ista studia non improbo,
moderata modo sint : opinionem istorum studiorum, et suspicionem artificii
apud eos, qui res judicent, oratori adversariam esse arbitror. Imminuit
enim et oratoris auctoritatem et orationis fidem.” De Ογαΐ. 1.11. ο. 17.
P. 459. U. Orat. pro Murena. It must be owned, that these words, at
first sight, seem to have a different meaning. And the disputandi causa
looks as if the observation was confined to Stoicism. For this Sect had so
entirely engrossed the Dialectics, that the followers of Zeno were more
frequently called Dialectici than Stoic?. Notwithstanding this, it plainly
appears, I think, from the context, that the other sense is the true. Tully
introduces his observation on Cato’s singularity in these words: et guoniam
non est nobis hee oratio habenda aut cum imperita multitudine, aut in aliquo
conventu agrestium, audacius paulo de studiis humanitatis, gue et mihi et
vobis nota et jucunda sunt, disputabo. Tere he declares, his design is not to
give his thoughts of the Stoics in particular (though they furnished the occa-
sion) but of the Greek philosophy in general, de studiis humanitatis. We
NOTES. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED, 15
then runs through the Stoical paradozes, and concludes—Hee homo inge-
niosissimus M. C. arripuit, Sc. But had it been his intention to confine the
observation to the Stoics, on account of their great name in Logic, he must
have said hance, not hee: it being their Logic, not their Paradowxes, which
was of use in disputation.
P. 461. X. Lucullus had been declaiming very tragically against the
Academy, when Tully entered on its defence ; in which he thought it pro-
per to premise something concerning himself. “ Aggrediar igitur,” (says he)
“ὁ 51 pauca ante, quasi de rama Mua, dixero.” He then declares, that, had he
embraced the Academy out of vanity, or love of contradiction, it had not
only reflected on his sense, but on his honour: “ Itaque nisi ineptum puta-
rem in tali disputatione id facere, quod cum de republica disceptatur fieri
interdum solet: jurarem per Jovem,” &c. From hence, I gather that
though the question here be of the Academic philosophy, and of Cicero as
an Academic ; yet, as he tells us, he is now to vindicate himself in a point
in which his honour was concered ; the protestation is general, and con-
cerns his constant turn of mind ; which always inclined him, he says, to
speak his sentiments.
P. 465. Y. The learned Author of the exact and elegant History of
Cicero, hath since turned this cirewmstance to the support of the contrary
opinion, with regard to his Hero’s sentiments :—“ But some”? (says he)
“have been apt to consider them [4, 6. the passages in Tully’s philosophic
writings in favour of a future state | as the flourishes rather of his eloquence
than the conclusions of his reason. Since in other parts of his works he
seems to intimate, not only a diffidence, but a disbelief of the immortality
of the soul, and a future state of rewards and punishments, and especially
in his letters, where he is supposed to declare his mind with the greatest
frankness. But—in a melancholy hour, when the spirits are depressed, the
same argument would not appear to him with the same force, but doubts
and difficulties get the ascendant, and what humoured his present chagrin
find the readiest admission. The passages alleged [7. 6. in this place of the
Divine Legation | were all of this kind, written in the season of his dejec-
tion, when all things were going wrong with him, and in the height of
Cesar’s power,” &c. Vol. ii. p. 561. ed. 4, Thus, every thing hath two
Academical handles. But still, my candid friend will allow me to say, they
cannot both be right. It is confessed, that a desponding temper, like that
of Cicero, will, ina melancholy hour, be always inclined to fear the worst.
But to what are its fears confined? Without doubt to the issue of that
very affair, for which we are distressed. A melancholy hour would have
just the contrary influence on our other cogitations. And this by the
wise and gracious disposition of Nature ; that the mind may endeavour to
make up by an abundance of hope in one quarter, what through the persua-
sion of its fears, it hath suffered itself to part from, in another. So that
unless Cicero were made differently from all other men, one might venture
to say, his hopes of future good (had Philosophy permitted him to entertain
any hopes at all) would have risen in proportion to his fears of the present.
And this is seen every day in fact. For it is nothing but this natural dis-
position that makes men of the world so generally fly even to Superstition
for the solace of their misfortunes. But the excellent author of the Crétécal
Inquiry into the Opinions of the Ancient Philosophers goes further. “ Cicero”
(says he) “ very frankly declares in his Tuwsculans themselves that this [the
mortality or the no separate existence of the soul] was the most real and effec-
tual,the most solid and substantial comfort that could be administered against
the fear of death. In his first Tusculan, he undertakes to prove, that death
70 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Itt.
was not an evil; and this, 1st, Because it was not attended with any actual
punishment, or positive and real misery. 2d/y, He rises higher, and
labours to prove, that men ought to look upon death as a blessing rather
than an evil, as the soul, after its departure from the body, might be happy
in another life. In the first part he supposes the mortality and extinction
of the soul at death ; in the second he plainly supposes, that it will survive
the body. Now the question is, on which doctrine does he lay most stress ;
or, which of these two notions, in the opinion of Cicero, would serve best to
fortify and prepare men against the fear of death? And luckily Cicero
himself has long since determined this point for us ; having in the first Tus-
culan brought several reasons to prove the immortality of the soul, he after
all very frankly declares, that they had no great validity and force ; that
the most solid and substantial argument, which could be urged against the
fear of death, was the very consideration advanced in his letters, or the doc-
trine which makes it the utter period of our being: And in the remaining
part of the book he proceeds to argue chiefly on this supposition, as being
the best calculated to support men against the fear and terror of death. The
arguments which he urged to prove the immortality of the soul, seem some-
times to have had great weight with the person to whom they were
immediately addressed; he declares himself fond of the opinion, and
resolves not to part with it. ‘Nemo me de émmortalitate depellet.’? To this
Cicero replies, ‘laudo id quidem ; etsi nihil nimis oportet confidere: move-
mur enim sepe aliquo acute concluso ; labamus mutamusque sententiain
clarioribus etiam in rebus ; in his est enim aliqua obscuritas. Id igitur si
acciderit, simus armati,’ ¢.32. He does not seem to lay any great stress on
the notion of a future state ; ‘nihil oportet nimis confidere.’ He owns that
the arguments, alleged in support of it, were rather specious than solid:
‘movemur enim sepe aliquo acute concluso.” That they were not plain
and clear enough to make any strong and lasting impression : ‘ Labamus mu-
tamusque sententiam clarioribus etiam in his rebus ; in his est enim aliqua
obscuritas..—That therefore the best remedy at all events, would be the
notion that the soul dies with the body; ‘id igitur si acciderit, simus
armati. Having then explained what he had to say on the immortality of
the soul, he proceeds to shew, that death could not be considered as an evil,
on the supposition that the soul was to perish with the body.
“When therefore he would teach men to contemn the terrors of death,
he grounds his main argument on the mortality of the soul. As to the
notion of a future state, it was maintained by arguments too subtile to
work a real and lasting conviction ; it was not thought clear enough to
make any deep and strong impression. He has therefore recourse to the
extinction of the soul, as the most comfortable consideration that could be
employed against the fear of death. This was not then a topic that was
peculiar to the season of dejection and distress ; it was not thrown out only
accidentally, when he was not considering the subject, but was used in the
works that were deliberately and professedly written on this very point.
It could not therefore be occasional only, and suited to the present cireum-
stances, as Dr. Middleton in his reasoning all along supposes.”
P. 475. Z. Dion Cassius tells us, that in the year of Rome 689 the
Government consulted, what the Historian calls, the Awgury of safety; a
sort of divination to learn, if the Gods received in good part the Prayers
for the Safety of the People. This ceremony. was only to be performed in
that year, during the course of which, no Allies of Rome had defected
from her, no Armies had appeared in the field, and no Battle had been
fought, A ceremony which plainly arose from the ancient notion of an
NOTES, OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. rid
envious Demon, then most to be dreaded when the felicity of States or of
private men was at its height.
P. 480. AA. Tuse. Disp. l.v.c.18. The words, si hoe fas est dictu,
had been omitted by accident, in my quotation.—But Answerers saw a
mystery in this omission, which could be nothing but my consciousness
that the omitted words made against me. They are now inserted to show
that they make entirely for me; and that Cicero used the word decerptus
in the Jiteral sense ; for, if only in a figurative, he had no occasion to soften
it with a salva reverentia.
P. 480. ΒΒ. It properly signifies what hath neither beginning nor end ;
though frequently used in the improper sense of having no end. And
indeed, we may observe in most of the Latin writers, an unphilosophic
licence in the use of mized modes by substituting one for another: The
providing against the ill effects of this abuse, to which these sort of words
are chiefly liable, gave the ancient Roman lawyers great trouble ; as appears
from what one of them observes, “ Jurisconsultorum summus circa verbo-
rum PROPRIETATEM labor est.” Hence the Composers of the Justinian
Digest found a necessity of having one whole book of their Pandects
employed de verborum significatione. The abuse arose, in a good measure,
from their not being early broken and inured to abstract reasoning: It is
certain at least, that the Greeks, who were eminent for speculation, are
infinitely more exact in their use of mixed modes; not but something
must be allowed for the superior abundance of the Greek language.
P. 482. CC. It hath been objected to me, that this doctrine of the refu-
sion of the soul was very consistent with the belief of a future state of
rewards and punishments, in the zmtermediate space between death and the
resolution of the soul into the τὸ ἕν. But these Objectors forgot that it
had been shown, that those Philosophers who held the refusion not to be
immediate, believed the soul to be confined to a successive course of trans-
migrations entirely physical. So that there was no more room for a moral
state of reward and punishment hereafter, than if the resolution had been
immediate.
Pp. 489, 500. DD. Avera: ἑκάστη δύναμις AAOTOS εἰς τὴν ὅλην ζωὴν τοῦ
παντός. But the elder Platonists talked another language: if Virgil may
be allowed to know what they said :
“ Esse apibus partem divinze mentis, et haustus
AMtherios dixere. Deum namque ire per omnes.”
P. 489. EE. But they were not content to speak a language different
from their Master. They would, sometimes, make him speak theirs. So
Hierocles tells us, Plato said, that “* When God made the visible world, he
had no occasion for pre-existent matter to work upon. His will was suffi-
cient to bring all creatures into being.” ᾿Αρχεῖν yap αὐτῷ εἰς ὑπόστασιν τῶν
ὄντων τὸ οἰκεῖον βούλημα. De fato et prov. ap. Puot. But where Plato said
this we are yet to learn.
ἐς Terrasque, tractusque maris, ceelumque profundum,
Hine pecudes, armenta, VIROS, genus omne ferarum,
Quemque sibi tenues nascentem arcessere vitas.
Scilicet hue reddi deinde, ac RESOLUTA referri
Omnia :”’— Georg. iv. 222.
But now what temptation could the Jater Platonists have to make this
alteration in favour of Paganism, if their master and his first followers
called the human soul a part of God only in a loose metaphorical sense ?
for such a sense could have reflected no disgrace upon their systems.
A passage of Plutarch will shew us the whole change and alteration of
78 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK 11.
this system in one view ; where, speaking of the opinions of the philoso-
phers, he says, “ Pyrmacoras and Prato held the Soul to be immortal ; for
that launching out into the Soul of the universe, it returns to its Parent
and original. The Stoics say, that on its leaving the body, the more infirm
(that is, the Soul of the ignorant) suffers the lot of the body: But the
more vigorous (that is, the Soul of the wise) endures to the conflagration.
Democritus and Epicurus say, the Soul is mortal, and perishes with the
body: Pyrnacoras and Prato, that the reasonable Soul is immortal (for
that the Soul is not God, but the workmanship of the eternal God) and
that the irrational is mortal.” Πυθαγόρας, Πλάτων, ἄφθαρτον εἶναι τὴν
ψυχήν ἐξιοῦσαν γὰρ eis τὸ τοῦ παντὸς Ψυχὴν ἀναχωρεῖν πρὸς τὸ ὁμογενές.
Οἱ Στωϊκοὶ ἐξιοῦσαν τῶν σωμάτων ὑποφέρεσθαι τὴν μὲν ἀσθενεστέραν ἅμα τοῖς
συγκρίμασι γενέσθαι (ταύτην δὲ εἶναι τῶν ἀπαιδεύτων) τὴν δὲ ἰσχυροτέραν, οἵα
ἐστὶ wepl τοὺς σοφοὺς, καὶ μέχρι τῆς ἐκπυρώσεως. Δημόκριτος, ᾿ΕἘπίκουρος
φθαρτὴν, τῷ σώματι συνδιαφθειρομένην. Πυθαγόρας καὶ Πλάτων τὸ μὲν λογι-
κὸν, ἄφθαρτον (καὶ γὰρ τὴν ψυχὴν, οὐ ϑεὸν, GAN ἔργον τοῦ ἀϊδίου Seod ὑπάρχειν)
τὸ δὲ ἄλογον, φθαρτόν.---Περὶ τῶν ᾽Ἄρεσ. τοῖς Pir. βιέλ. δ΄. κ. ζ΄.
There is something very observable in this passage. _He gives the opi-
nions of the several Philosophers concerning the Soul. He begins with
Pythagoras and Plato; goes on to the Stoics, Democritus and Epicurus ;
and then returns back to Pythagoras and Plato again. This seems to be
irregular enough ; but this is not the worst. His account of the Pythago-
rean and Platonic doctrine concerning the Soul, with which he sets out,
contradicts that with which he concludes. For, the launching out into the
soul of the universe, which is his first account, implies, and is, the language
of those who say, that the Soul was part of the substance of God; whereas
his second account expressly declares that the Soul was not God, that is,
part of Ged, but only his workmanship. Let me observe too, that what he
says further, in this second account, of the rational Soul’s being immortal,
and the irrational, mortal, contradicts what he in another place of the same
tract, quoted above, tells us, was the doctrine of Pythagoras and Plato
concerning the soul; namely, that the human and brutal, the rational and
irrational, were of the same nature, Πυθαγόρας, Πλάτων λογικὰς μὲν εἶναι καὶ
τῶν ἀλόγων ζώων καλουμένων Tas ψυχὰς, ov μὴν λογικῶς ἐνεργούσας παρὰ τὴν
δυσκρασίαν τῶν σωμάτων. How is all: this to be accounted for? Very
easily. This tract of the placits of the Philosophers was an extract from
the author’s common-place: in which, doubtless, were large collections
from the Pythagoreans and Platonists, both before and after Christ. It is
plain then, that in the passage in question he begins with those who went
before ; and ends with those who came after.. And it was the language of
those after, to call the human soul, not (like their predecessors) a part of
God, but his workmanship: so Plotinus, who came still later, tells us, that
the soul is from God, and yet has a different existence: It was in their lan-
guage, to call the brutal soul, mortal: and so afterwards Porphyry, we find,
says, every irrational power ts resolved into the life 07 the whole: for, this
resolution or λύσις was qualified with the title of ἀφθαρσία, or POdpya
indifferently, as they were disposed to hide or to reveal its real nature.
While they held all souls subject to this resolution, they would, of course,
keep it amongst their srcrers, and call it immortality. When they began
to make a distinction, and only subjected the ¢rrational soul to this resolu-
tion, as in the passage of Porphyry, then they would call it mortality, as in
the passage of Plutarch ; a passage though hitherto esteemed an indigested
heap of absurdity and contradiction, is now, we presume, reasonably well
explained and reconciled to itself.
NOTES. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 79
P, 492. FF, It is remarkable that Democritus the Master of Epicurus
gave but two qualities to MaTTER, figure and bulk, i. 6. extension. His dis-
ciple gave three, by adding Gravity. This quality was as sensible as the
other two. What shall we say? That Democritus penetrated so far into
MATTER, as to see that Gravity did not essentially belong unto it, but was a
quality superinduced upon it. Certain it is, what Dr. Clarke conjectures,
in his dispute with Leibnitz, that Kpicurus’s Philosophy was a corrupt and
atheistical perversion of some more ancient, and perhaps better Philosophy.
P. 499. GG. But this has been the humour of the zealous Partizans of
a favourite Cause, in all Ages. Honest Antony Woop, recommending a
MS. of a brother Antiquary, one Henry Lyte, intitled, Conjectural Notes
touching the Original of the University of Oxon and also of Britain,
observes with great complacency—“ In this are many pretty fancies, which
may he of soME USE, as occasion shall serve, by way of reply for Oxon,
against the far-fetched antiquities of Cambridge.’—A dispute had arisen
between these two famous Universities, not concerning the superior Excel-
lence of the one or other Institution ; but of the superior Antiquity only.
In a contention of the first kind, the disputants would have had some need
of Truth; all that was wanted in the latter, was well-invented Fable.
Wisely therefore did our reverend Antiquary recommend to the Managers
of this important question, the prerry Fancres of this Oxford Champion ;
to oppose to the pretty fancies of the far-feiched Antiquities of the Cam-
bridge Athlet.
P. 509. HH. As what is here said relates entirely to the revolutions in
the state of Religion here at home, strangers will not be able to see the
force of it, without some further account of this matter.—Jusrirication
BY FAITH ALONE, built upon the doctrine of the Redemption of Mankind by
the death and sacrifice of Christ, was the great Gospel-Principle on which
Protestantism was founded, when the Churches of the North-West of
Europe first shook off the Yoke of Romz: By some perhaps pushed too
far, in their abhorrence of the Popish doctrine of merit; the Puritan
schism amongst us being made on the panic fancy that the Church of
England had not receded far enough from Rome. However, Justification
by Faith alone being a Gospel-Doctrine, it was received as the badge of true
Protestantism, by all; when the Purrrans (first driven by persecution from
religious into civil Faction, and thoroughly heated into Enthusiasm by
each Faction, in its turn) carried the Doctrine to a dangerous and impure
Antinomianism. This fanatic notion soon after produced the practical
virtues of these modern Saints. The mischiefs which ensued are well
known. And no small share of them has been ascribed, to this impious
abuse of the doctrine of Justification by faith alone ; first by depreciating
Moratrry, and then by dispensing with it.
When the Constitution was restored, and had brought into credit those
few learned Divines whom the madness of the preceding times had driven
into obscurity, the Church of England, still smarting with the wounds it
had received from the abuse of the great Gospel-principle of Farrn, very
wisely laboured to restore Moraxiry, the other essential part of the Chris-
tian System, to its Rights, in the joint direction of the Faithful. Hence,
the encouragement the Church gave to those noble discourses which did
such credit to Religion, in the licentious times of Charles the Second,
composed by these learned and pious men, abused by the Zealots with the
nickname Latrruprnartan Divines. The reputation they acquired by so
thoroughly weeding out these rank remains of Fanaticism, made their
Successors fond of sharing ‘with them in the same labours. <A laudable
80 THE DIVINE LEGATIGN BOOK 111.
ambition! but, too often mixed with a vain passion for improving upon
those who have gone, successfully, before. The Church was now triumph-
ant. The Sectaries were humbled ; sometimes oppressed ; always regarded
with an eye of jealousy and aversion ; till at length this Gospel-principle
of Faith came to be esteemed by those who should have known better, as
wild and fanatical. While they who owned its divine Original found so
much difficulty in adjusting the distinct Rights and Prerogatives of Farru
and Moratiry, that by the time thisCentury was ready to commence, things
were come to such a pass (Morality was advanced so high, and Faith so
depressed and encumbered with trifling or unintelligible explanations) that
a new definition of our holy Religion, in opposition to what its Founder
taught, and unknown to its early Followers, was all in fashion ; under the
title of a Republication of the Religion of Nature: natural Religion, it
seems, (as well as Christianity) teaching the doctrine of life and immor-
tality. So says a very enfinent prelate.* And the Gospret, which till now
had been understood as but coeval with REepEmprion, was henceforth to be
acknowledged, as old as the Creation.
P. 2, vol. ii. II. How expedient it was to give this detailed proof of the
coincidence of truth and general utility, may be seen by the strange em-
barras which perplexes that ingenious Sceptic, Rousseau of Geneva, when
he treats of this subject. ‘“‘ Je vois,’” (says he, in his letter to the Arch-
bishop of Paris,) “deux manieres d’examiner et comparer les Religions
diverses, ’une selon le vrai et le faux, qui s’y trouvent—l’autre selon leurs
effets temporels et moraux sur la terre, selon le bien ou le mal qu’elles peuvent
faire a la Societé et au genre humain. II ne faut pas, pour empécher ce
double examen, commencer par decider que ces deux choses vont toujours
ensemble, et que la Religion la plus vraye est ausi la plus sociable.”—But
then again he says,—“‘ ΠῚ paroit pourtant certain, je l’avoue, que si ’homme
est fait pour la Societé, la Religion la plus vraye est ausi la plus sociale et
la plus humaine.”—Yet for all this he concludes—“ Mais ce sentiment,
tout probable qu’il est, est sujet ἃ de grandes difficultés par historique et
les faits qui le contrarient.”—Pp. 71, 72. But Antiquity, which had
intangled itself in this question, apparently drew him, in. The Sages of old
saw clearly that U*télty and Virtue perfectly coincided. They thought
Utility and Truth did not : as conceiving the constitution of things to be so
framed, that falsehood (as it was cireumstanced) might at one time be of
general benefit, just as Truth is at another.
Ρ. 8, νο}]. 11. Kk,
“Ἣν χρόνος ὅτ᾽ ἦν ἄτακτος ἀνθρώπων βίος,
Καὶ ϑηριώδης, ἰσχύος δ᾽ ὑπηρέτης"
“Or οὐδὲν ἄθλον οὔτε τοῖς ἐσθλοῖσιν ἦν,
Οὔτ᾽ αὖ κόλασμα τοῖς κακοῖς ἐγίνετο.
Κᾷἄᾷπειτά μοι δοκοῦσιν ἄνθρωποι νόμους
Θέσθαι κολαστὰς, ἵνα Δίκη τύραννος ἢ
Γένους βροτείου, τὴν δ᾽ “ὕθριν δούλην ἔχῃ"
᾿Ἐῤημιοῦτο, δ᾽ εἴ τις ἐξαμαρτάνοι.
Ἔπειτ᾽ ἐπειδὴ, τἀμφανῇ μὲν οἱ νόμοι
᾿Απῆγον αὐτοῖς ἔργα μὴ τυράσσειν βίᾳ,
Λάθρα δ᾽ ἔπρασσον, τηνικαῦτά μοι δοκεῖ
Πυκνός τις ἄλλος καὶ σοφὸς γνώμην ἀνὴρ
Teyovévat, 0s ὥνητοῖσιν ἐξευρὼν, ὕπως
Εἴη τι δεῖμα τοῖς κακοῖσι, κἂν λάθρα
Πράσσωσιν, ἢ λέγωσιν, ἢ φρονῶσί τι.
Ἐντεῦθεν οὖν τὸ ϑεῖον εἰσηγήσατο"
‘Qs ἐστὶ -Δαίμων ᾿ἀφθίτῳ ϑάλλων βίῳ,
* SHERLOCK’s “ Sermons,” vol. i. serm. 6.
NOTES. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 51
Νόῳ τ᾽ ἀκούων, καὶ βλέπων, φρονῶν τε, καὶ
Προσέχων τε ταῦτα. καὶ φύσιν δείαν φορῶν.
(Ad οὗ) wav μὲν τὸ λεχθὲν ἐν βροτοῖς ἀκούεται.
‘Os δρώμενον δὲ way ἰδεῖν δυνήσεται.
Ἐάν τε σὺν σιγῇ τι βουλεύῃς κακὸν,
Τοῦτ᾽ οὐχὶ λήσει τοὺς ϑεούς: τὸ γὰρ φρονοῦν
Ἔνεστι. Τούσδε τοὺς λόγους αὐτοῖς λέγων
Διδαγμάτων ἥδιστον εἰσηγήσατο
Ψευδεῖ καλύψας τὴν ἀλήθειαν λόγῳ"
Εἶναι δ᾽ ἔφασκε τοὺς ϑεοὺς ἐνταῦθ᾽. ἵνα
Μάλιστά γ᾽ ἐκπλήξειεν ἀνθρώπους ἄγων,
“Odev wep ἔγνω τοὺς φόβους εἶναι βρύτοις,
Καὶ τὰς τυονήσεις τῷ ταλαιπώρῳ βίῳ,
Ἔκ τῆς ὕπερθε wepupopas, ἵν᾽ ἀστραπὰς
Κατεῖδεν οὔσας, δεινά τε κτυπήματα
Bpovtijs, τύ, τ᾽ ἀστερωπὺὸν οὐρανοῦ δέμας,
Κρόνου καλὸν τσοίκιλμα, τέκτονος σοφοῦ"
Ὅθεν τε λαμπρὸς ἀστέρων στείχει χορὸς,
Ὁ, δ᾽ ὑγρὸς εἰς γὴν ὄμβρος εἰσπορεύεται.
Τοιούσδε τσεριέστησεν ἀνθρώποις φόθους.
AC ods καλῶς τε τῷ λόγῳ κατῴκισε
Τοὺς δαίμονας καὶ ἐν τορέποντι χωρίῳ,
Τὴν ἀνομίαν τε τοῖς νόμοις κατέσθδεσεν.
Οὕτω δὲ wperoy οἴομαι τοεῖσαί τινα
Θνητοὺς νομίζειν δαιμόνων εἶναι γένος.
There are many variations in the reading of this fragment ; and I have
every where chosen that which appeared to me the right. That Critias
was the author, how much soever the critics seem inclined to favour the
claim of Euripides, I make no scruple to assert. The difficulty lies here :
Sextus Empiricus expressly gives it to Critias; and yet Plutarch is still
more express for Euripides ; names the play it belonged to ; and adds this
farther circumstance, that the poet chose to broach his impiety under the
character of Sisyphus, in order to keep clear of the Laws. Thus two of
the most knowing writers of Antiquity are supposed irreconcilable in a
plain matter of fact. M. Petit, who has @xamined the matter at large
LObserv. Miscell. lib. i. cap. 1.], declares for the authority of Plutarch.
And M. Bayle has fully shewn the weakness of his reasoning in support of
Plutarch’s claim. [Crit. Dict. Art. Cririas, Rem. H.] Petit’s System is
to this effect, that there is an Azatus in the text of Sextus: That a Copyist,
from whom all the existent MSS. are derived, when he came to Critias,
unwarily jumped over the passage quoted from him, together with Sextus’s
observation of Euripides’s being in the same sentiments, and so joined the
name of Critias and the Zambics of Euripides together. But this is such a
liberty of conjecturing, as would unsettle all the monuments of Antiquity.
I take the true solution of the difficulty to be this: Critias, a man, as the
Ancients deliver him to us, of atheistic principles, and a fine poetic genius,
composed these Zambics for the private solace of his Fraternity ; which
were not kept so close but that they got air, and came to the knowledge of
Euripides ; to whom the general stream of antiquity concurs in giving a
very virtuous and religious character, notwithstanding the iniquitous
insinuations of Plutarch to the contrary. And the Tragic Poet, being to
draw the Atheist, Sisyphus, artfully projected to put these Zambics into his
mouth : for by this means the sentiments would be sure to be natural, as
taken from real life; and the poet safe from the danger of being called
to account for them. And supposing this to be the case, Plutarch’s account
becomes very reasonable ; who tells us, the Poet delivered this atheistic
doctrine by a dramatic character, to evade the justice of the Areopagus ;
3
but, without this, it can by no means be admitted: For, thinly to screen
VOL. II. G
92 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IiIl.
=
impiety by the mere interposition of the Drama, which was an important
part in their festivals, and under the constant eye of the Magistrate, was a
poor way of evading the penetration and severity of that formidable judi-
cature, how good a shift soever it might prove against modern penal Laws.
But the giving the known verses of Critias to his Atheist, was a safe way of
keeping under cover. For all resentment must needs fall on the real
author ; especially when, it was seen, they were only produced for con-
demnation, as will now be shown. Without doubt, the chief motive
Euripides had in his contrivance, was the satisfaction of exposing a very
wicked man ; in which he had nothing from his adversary’s power to deter
him, for Critias was then a private man ; the Sisyphus being acted in the
91st Olymp. and the tyranny of the Thirty not beginning till the latter
end of the 93d. But what is above all, the genius and cast of that particu-
lar Drama wonderfully favoured his design: for the Sisyphus was the last
of a tetralogy (rerpadoyia τραγικῶν δραμάτων) or a satiric tragedy, in which
species of poetry, a licence something resembling that of the o/d comedy, of ἡ
branding evil citizens, was indulged ; and where the same custom of paro-
dying the verses of rival poets was in use. And we may be sure that
Euripides, who was wont to satirize his fellow-writers in his serious trage-
dies (as where in his Electra he ridicules the discovery in the Choéphoroi of
Aischylus,) would be little disposed to spare them in this ludicrous kind of
composition. Admitting this to be the case ; it could not but be, that, for
a good while after, these Zambics would be quoted by some as Critias’s,
whose property they were ; and by others, as Euripides’s, who had got the
use, and in whose Tragedy they were found; and by both with reason.
But in after-times this matter was forgotten or not attended to ; and then
some took them for Euripides’s, exclusive of the right of Critias ; and
others, on the contrary : And as a Copyist fancied this or that man the
author, so they read the text. Of this, we have a remarkable instance
in the 35th verse, where the transcriber, imagining the fragment to be the
Tragic Poet’s, chose to read, τ
“Obey τε λαμπρὸς ἀστέρος στείχει μύδρος.
Because this expresses the peculiar Physiology of Anaxagoras, the pre-
ceptor of Euripides ; which Mr. Barnes thought a convincing proof of the
fragment’s being really his: whereas that reading makes a sense defective
and impertinent ; the trwe being evidently this of Grotius:
Λαμπρὸς ἀστέρων στείχει χορός.
And thus, I suppose, Plutarch and Sextus may be well reconciled.
P.19. LL. The exquisitely learned Author of the English Commen-
tary and Notes on Horace’s Art of Poetry, has with admirable acumen
detected and exposed the same kind of mistake in the dramatic Poets.
Who when, as he observes, they were become sensible of the preference of
Plays of character to Plays of intrigue, never rested till they ran into this
other extreme. But hear this fine writer in his own words :—
“ The view of the comic scene being to delineate characters, this end,
I suppose, will be attained most perfectly by making those characters as
universal as possible. For thus the person shown in the drama being the
representative of all characters of the same kind, furnishes, in the highest
degree, the entertainment of dwmour. But then this universality must be
such as agrees not to our idea of the possible effects of the character, as
conceived in the abstract ; but to the actwal exertion of its powers which
experience justifies, and common life allows. Mottere, and before him,
Piautus, had offended in this; that, for a picture of the avaricious man
NOTES. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 83
*
they presented us with the fantastic unpleasing draught of the passion of
avarice.—This is not to copy Nature, which affords no specimen of a
man turned all into a single passion. No metamorphosis could be more
strange or incredible. Yet portraits of this vicious taste are the admiration
of common starers.—But if the reader would see the extravagance of build-
ing dramatic manners on abstract ideas in its full light, he need only turn
to Ben Jonson’s Every Man out of his Humour ; which, under the name of
a play of character, is, in fact, unnatural, wholly chimerical, and unlike
any thing we observe in real life. Yet this comedy has always had its
admirers. And Randolph, in particular, was so taken with the design, that
he seems to have formed his Muse's Looking-glass in express imitation
of it.” Dissertation on the several provinces of the Drama, p. 239.
When Pliny therefore compliments Silarion for giving one of his statues
the expression not of an angry man, but of anger itself, either it is a mere
flight of rhetoric, to show the just force of the artist’s expression : or, if,
indeed, the ferocious air did exceed the traces of humanity, the Philoso-
pher’s praise was misapplied, and the Statuary’s figure was a caricature.
P. 23. MM. His picture of Scipio Africanus is, however, so very curious,
that the learned reader will not be displeased to find it in this place :—
“ Quam ubi ab re tanto impetu acta solicitudinem curamque hominum
animadyertit, advocata concione, ita de etate sua imperioque mandato, et
bello quod gerendum esset, magno elatoque animo disseruit, ut impleret
homines certioris spei, quam quantam. fides promissi humani, aut ratio ex
fiducia rerum subjicere solet. Fuit enim Scrpro, non veris tantum virtuti-
bus mirabilis, sed arte quoque quadam ab juventa in ostentationem earum
compositus : pleraque apud multitudinem, aut per nocturnas visa species,
aut velut divinitus, mente monita, agens: sive ut ipse capti quadam super-
stitione animi, sive ut imperia consiliaque, velut sorte oraculi missa, sine
cunctatione assequeretur. Ad hee jam inde ab initio preparans animos, ex
quo togam virilem sumpsit, nullo die prius ullam publicam privatamque
rem egit, quam in Capitolium iret, ingressusque edem consideret, et ple-
rumque tempus solus in secreto ibi tereret. Hic mos, qui per omnem vitam
servabatur, sew consulto, sew temere, vulgate opinioni fidem apud quosdam
fecit, stirpis eum divine virum esse, retulitque famam, in Alexandro Magno
prius vulgatam, et vanitate et fabula parem, anguis immanis concubitu con-
ceptum, et in cubiculo matris ejus persepe visam prodigii ejus speciem,
interventuque hominum eyolutam repente, atque ex oculis elapsam. His
miraculis numquam ab ipso elusa fides est ; quin potius aucta arte quadam,
nec abnuendi tale quicquam, nec palam affrmandi.”—Hist. lib. xxvi.
Hence we see with what judgment Cicero in his Republics makes the
dream sent from Jove, concerning a future state, to be communicated to his
Scrpro.
P. 24. NN. That great observer of Nature, Cervantes, having made
Sancho (to save himself from the vexation of a sleeveless errand) palm
upon his Master a supposititious Dulcinea, when the Squire comes to relate
this adventure to the Duchess, she extols his ingenuity so highly, that he
begins to suspect himself tricked by the Enchanter into his own con-
trivance; who had presented him with a true Dulcinea in Masquerade,
while he thought he was barefacedly imposing on his Master a false one.
P. 40. OO. This ingenious conceit of Srepcorn did not escape the
Abbé Pluche, who in his Histoire du Ciel, hath judiciously employed it for
the foundation of a reformed system on this matter; which, however,
brings us to the same place, by a back way ; and ends in this, that the Gods
were not dead men deified.
DEDICATION
OF THE FOURTH EDITION OF BOOKS IV. V. AND VI. OF
THE DIVINE LEGATION OF MOSES,
MDCCLXV.
TO THE RIGHT HON. WILLIAM LORD MANSFIELD,
LORD CHIEF JUSTICE OF ENGLAND.
My Lorp,
Tue purpose of this Address is not to make a return for the
favours I have received from you, for they are many and great ; but
to add one more security to myself, from the malice of the present
and the forgetfulness of future times. A purpose, which though it
may be thought less sober than the other, is certainly not more ἡ
selfish. In plain terms, I would willingly contrive to live, and go
down to posterity under the protection of your Name and Character :
from which, that Posterity, in the administration of public justice,
must receive their instruction ; and in the duties of private life, if
they have any virtuous ambition, will take their example.—But let
not this alarm you. I intend not to be your Panegyrist. To praise
you for Eloquence, would be to praise you for a thing below your
Character, unless it were for that species of Eloquence which Mitton
describes, and You have long practised. ‘“ TRuE ELOQUENCE,” says
he, “1 find to be none, but the serious and hearty love of Truth:
And that, whose mind soever is fully possessed with a fervent desire
to know good things, and with the dearest Charity to infuse the
knowledge of them into Others, wHEN SUCH A MAN WOULD SPEAK,
his words, like so many nimble and airy Servitors, trip about him at
command, and in well-ordered Files, as he would wish, fall aptly into
their own places.”
To live in the voice and memory of Men is the flattering dream of
every adventurer in Letters: and for me who boast the rare felicity of
being honoured with the friendship of two or three superior Charac-
ters, Men endowed with virtue to atone for a bad age, and of abilities
to make a bad age a good one, for me not to aspire to the best mode
of this ideal existence, the being carried down to remote ages along
with those who will never die, would be a strange insensibility to
human glory.
DEDICATION TO LORD MANSFIELD. 85
But as the protection I seek from your Lordship is not like those
blind Asylums founded by Superstition to skreen iniquity from civil
vengeance, but of the nature of a TempLe or JusTICcE, to vindicate
and support the Innocent, You will expect to know the claim I have
to it; and how, on being seized with that epidemic malady of idle,
visionary men, the projecting to instruct and reform the Public, 1
came to stand in need of it.
I had lived to see—it is a plain and artless tale I have to’ tell—I
had lived to see what Law-givers have always seemed to dread, as the
certain prognostic of public ruin, that fatal Crisis when RELIGION
HATH LOST IT’S HOLD ON THE MINDS OF A PEOPLE.
I had observed, almost the rise and origin, but surely very much of
the progress of this evil: for it was neither so rapid to elude a dis-
tinct view, nor yet so slow as to endanger one’s forgetting or not
observing the relation which its several parts bore to one another :
And to trace the steps of this evil may not be altogether useless to
those, whoever they may be, who, as the Instruments of Providence,
are destined to counter-work its bad effects.
The most painful circumstance in this relation is, (as your Lordship
will feel) that the mischief began amongst our friends; by men who
loved their Country ; but were too eagerly intent on one part only of
their Object, the security of its CIVIL LIBERTY.
To trace up this matter to its source, we need go no further back
than to the happy Accession of that illustrious House to whom we
owe all which is in the power of grateful Monarchs, at the head of a
free People, to bestow ; I mean, the full enjoyment of the common
rights of Subjects.
It fortuned that at this time, some warm friends of the Accession,
newly gotten into power, had too hastily perhaps suspected that the
Cuurca (or at least that party of CourcuMEN which had usurped
the name) was become inauspicious to the sacred Aira from whence
we were to date the establishment of our civil happiness ; and there-
fore deemed it good policy to lessen the credit of a body of men, who
had been long in high reverence with the People, and who had so
lately and so scandalously abused their influence in the opprobrious
affair of Sacheverell. To this end they invited some learned men,
who in the preceding reign had served the common cause, to take up
the pen once more against these its most pestilent enemies, the
JacospireE CLerGy. They readily assumed the task, and did it so
effectually, that under the professed design of confuting and decrying
the usurpations of a popish Hierarchy, they virtually deprived the
Cuurcu of every power and privilege, which, as a simple Society, she
had a claim to; and, on the matter, delivered her up gagged and
bound, as the rebel-Creature of the State. Their success (with the
80 DEDICATION ΤῸ LORD MANSFIELD.
prejudice of Power, and what is still stronger, the power of Prejudice,
on their side) became yet the easier, as the Tory Clergy, who opposed
these Erastian notions, so destructive to the very being of a Church,
reasoned and disputed against the Innovators on the principles com-
monly received, but indeed supported on no sounder a bottom than
the authority of Papal or (if they like it better) of Puritanical usurpa-
tions: principles, to speak without reserve, ill founded in them-
selves, and totally inconsistent with the free administration of Civil
government.
In this then, that is, in humbling disaffected Churchmen, the
friends of Liberty and the Accession carried their point. But in con-
ducting a purpose so laudable at any time, and so necessary at that
time, They had, as we observe, gone much too far; for instead of
reducing the Church within its native bounds, and thereby preserving
it from its two greatest dishonours, the becoming factious, or the
being made the tool of Faction, which was all that true Politics
required, and all perhaps that these Politicians then thought of ;
their Instruments, by discrediting every right it had, and even strip-
ping it of some of them, in a little time brought it into general
contempt.
But this was not the worst. These Enemies of obnoxious Church-
men found much assistance in the forward carriage of the Enemies of
Religion itself; who, at this time, under pretence of seconding the
views of good Patriots, and serving the State against the encroach-
ments of Church-power, took all occasions to vent their malice against
Revelation itself: And Passion, inflamed by opposition, mixing with
Politics throughout the course of this affair, these Lay-writers were
connived at; and, to mortify rebellious Churchmen still more, even
cried up for their free reasonings against Religion, just as the Clergy-
writers had been, for their exploits against Church-government. And
one man in particular, the Author of a well-known book called the
Independent Whig, early a favourite, and to the last a Pensioner,
carried on, in the most audacious and insulting manner, these two
several attacks, together: A measure supported perhaps in the execu-
tion, by its coinciding with some Statesmen’s private opinions ;
though the most trite maxims of Government might have taught such
to separate their private from their public Character. However,
certain it is, that the attack never ceased operating till all these
various kinds of Free-writing were gotten into the hands of the
PEOPLE.
And now the business was done: and the sober Friends of the
Government were become, before they were aware, the Dupes of their
own policy. In their endeavours to take off the influence of a
Church, or rather of a party of Churchmen inauspicious to a free
DEDICATION TO LORD MANSFIELD. 87
State, they had occasioned at least, the loosning all the ties which till
then Religion had on the minds of the Populace : and which till then,
Statesmen had ever thought were the best security the Magistrate had
for their obedience. For though a rule of right may direct the Philo-
sopher to a principle of action; and the point of honour may keep
up the thing called Manners amongst Gentlemen ; yet nothing but
Religion can ever fix a sober standard of behaviour amongst the
common People.
But those bad effects not immediately appearing, our Politicians
were so little apprehensive that the matter had already gone too far,
that they thought of nothing but how to improve some COLLATERAL
advantages they had procured by the bargain ; which, amongst other
uses, they saw likewise, would be sure to keep things in the condition
to which they were reduced. For now Religion having lost its hold
on the People ; the Ministers of Religion were of no further conse-
quence to the State ; nor were Statesmen any longer under the hard
necessity of seeking out the most eminent, for the honours of their
Profession: And without necessity, how few would submit to such a
drudgery! For Statesmen of a certain pitch are naturally appre-
hensive of a little sense, and not easily brought, whether from experi-
ence or conviction, to form ideas of a great deal of gratitude, in those
they have to deal with. All went now according to their wishes.
They could now employ Church-honours more directly to the use of
Government, that is, of their own, by conferring them on such sub-
jects as most gratified their taste or humour, or served best to
strengthen their connexions with the Great. This would of course
give the finishing stroke to their System. For though stripping the
Church of all power and authority, and exposing it naked and
defenceless to its enemies, had abated men’s reverence for it ; and the
detecting Revelation of imposture, serving only for a State-engine,
had destroyed all love for Religion ; yet they were the INTRIGUES OF
CuurcuH-promotTion which would make the People despise the
whole Ordinance.
Nor did the hopes of a better generation give much relief to good
men’s present fears or feelings. The People had been reasoned out
of their religion, by such Logic as it was: and if ever they were to be
brought back to a sober sense of their condition, it was evident they
must be reasoned into it again. Little thought and less learning
were sufficient to persuade men of what their vices inclined them to
believe ; but it must be no common share of both, which, in opposi-
tion to those vices, shall be able to bring them to themselves. And
where is that to be expected, or likely to be found? In the course
of forty or fifty years (for I am not speaking of present transactions)
a new Generation or two are sprung up: And those, whom their Pro-
88 DEDICATION TO LORD MANSFIELD.
fession has dedicated to this service, Experience has taught, that the
talents requisite for pushing their fortune, lie very remote from such
as enable men to figure in a rational defence of Religion. And it is
very natural to think that, in general, they will be chiefly disposed to
cultivate those qualities on which they see their Patrons lay the
greatest weight.
I have, my Lord, been the longer and the plainer in deducing the
causes of a recent evil, for the sake of doing justice to the ENGLIsH
CriercGy ; who in this imstance, as in many others, have been forced
to bear the blame of their Betters. How common is it to hear the
irreligion of the times ascribed to the vices or the indiscretions of
Churchmen! Yet how provoking is such an insult! when every
child knows that this accusation is only an Echo from the lewd
clamours of those very Scribblers whose flagicious writings have been
the principal cause of these disorders.
In this disastrous state of things, it was my evil stars inclined me
to write. I began, as these Politicians had done, with the Cuurcn.
My purpose, I am not ashamed to own, was to repel the cruel inroads
made upon its Rights and Privileges ; but, I thank God, on honester
principles than those which have been employed to prop up, with
Gothic buttresses, a Jacobite or High-Church Hierarchy. The
success was what I might expect. I was read; and by a few indif-
ferent and intelligent Judges, perhaps, approved. But as I made the
CHurcnH neither a Slave nor a Tyrant (and under one or other of
these ideas of it, almost all men had now taken party) The Alliance
between Church and State, though formed upon a Model actually
existing before our eyes, was considered as an Utopian refinement.
It is true, that so far as my own private satisfaction went, I had no
great reasoh to complain. I had the honour to be told by the heads
of one Party, that they allowed my principles ; * and by the heads of
the other, that they espoused my conclusion ;+ which however
amounted only to this, that the One was for Linerty, however they
would chuse to employ it; and the Other for powrr, however they
could come at it.
I had another important view in writing this book.—Though
vobody had been so shameless to deny the use of Religion to civil
Government, yet certain friends of Liberty, under the terror of the
mischiefs done to Society by Fanaticism, or Religion run mad, had,
by a strange preposterous policy, encouraged a clamour against
ESTABLISHMENTS: the only mode of Religion which can prevent
what they pretended to fear; that is, its degenerating into Fana-
ticism. It is true, had these Clamourers not found more enemies to
the Hstablishment than they had made, (enemies on solider grounds,
* Bishop Ho. + Bishop Sh.
DEDICATION TO LORD MANSFIELD. 89
to wit, the sense of their exclusion from the emoluments of a national
Chureh) an Establishment had hardly given umbrage to the appointed
Protectors of it. But these had the Sectaries to caress: and a
private and pressing interest will often get the better of the most
indispensible maxims of good policy.
It was for this reason, my Lord, that so much of the book is
employed in the defence of a national or an established Religion ;
since, under such a Form, FANATICISM can never greatly spread :
and that little there will always be of this critical eruption of our
diseased Nature, may have the same good effect on the Ustablished
Religion which weak Factions are observed to have on the administra-
tion of Government; it may keep men more decent, alert, and
attentive to the duties of their Charge.
Where then was the wonder, that a subject so managed, and at
such a juncture, should be violently opposed, or to speak more truely,
be grossly misrepresented. Those in the new system accused me of
making the State a slave to the Church; those in the old, of making
the Church a slave to the State: and one passionate Declaimer, as |
remember, who cared equally for Church and State, was pleased to
say, that, the better to banter mankind, I had done both.*
Having thus, in the foolish confidence of youth, cast in my Goose-
quill, to stem a torrent that in a little time was to bear down all
before it; I proceeded, with the same good faith, in another romantic
effort, The support of ReLier1on itself.
You, my Lord, who feel so humanely for the Injured, on whomso-
ever POPULAR INJUSTICE may chance to fall, have hardly forgotten
the strange reception with which this my fair endeavour was enter-
tained; and principally by Those whose interests I was defending.
It awaked a thousand black passions and idiot prejudices. The
Zealots inflamed the Bigots.
’T was the time's plague,
When madmen led the blind.
For, the noble prosecution of real Impiety was now over; or, at
least, no longer serious. What remained, to belye a zeal for Religion,
was a ridiculous Tartuffism ; ridiculous because without the power to
persecute: otherwise, sufficiently serious, as it was encouraged by
men, at that time, in eminence of place.t For false Zeal and unbe-
lieving Politics always concur, and often find their account in sup-
pressing NOVELTIES.
But things, unnaturally kept up in a state of violence, in a little
time subside: And though the first Writers, let loose against me,
came on as if they would devour; yet the design of those who, at
spring and fall, have ever since annually succeeded them, has been, ἢ
* Lord B. + Archbishop Ῥ,
90 DEDICATION TO LORD MANSFIELD.
think, only to eat. The imputation that yet sticks to my notions,
amongst many well-meaning men, is, that they are PARADOXICAL.
And though this be now made the characteristic of my Writings, yet,
whether from the amusement which Paradozes afford, or from whatever
other cause of malice or curiosity, the Public seem still sufficiently
eager to see what, in spite of the Argument, and perhaps in spite to
it, they are pleased to call my conctusion. And as in your Lord-
ship’s progress through your high Stations (for I will not take my
comparison lower while my subject is public favour) men no sooner
found you in one than they saw you necessary for a higher ; so every
preceding Volume seemed to excite a stronger appetite for the
following ; till, as I am told, it came to a kind of impatience for the
last : which must have been strangely obstinate if in all this time it
has not subsided. And yet it is very possible it may not: For the
good-natured pleasure of seeing an Author fill up the measure of his
Paradoxes is worth waiting for. Of all men, I would not appear vain
before your Lordship ; since, of all men, You best know how ill it
would become my pride. Nor am I indeed in much danger to have
my head turned by this flattering circumstance, while I remember
that Rasexais tells us, and I dare say he tells us truth, that the
Public of his times were full as impatient for the conclusion of the
unfinished story of the giant Gargantua and his son Pantagruel.
I have now, both leisure and inclination to gratify this Public
fancy, after having put my last hand to these two Volumes: A work
of reasoning ; and though fairly pursued, and, as I thought, brought
home to its ConcLusion, yet interspersed with variety of Philologic
dissertations: For I had to do with a sort of Readers not less delicate
than that fastidious Frenchman, who tells us in so many words, that
—La ΚΈΑΒΟΝ a tort des qwelle ENNUYE. As my purpose therefore
was to bring Reason into good Company, I saw it proper now and
then, to make her wait without, lest by her constant presence she
should happen to be thought tiresome. Yet still I was careful not to
betray her rights: and the Dissertations brought in to relieve the
oppressed attention of the Reader, was not more for his sake than for
hers. If I was large in my discourse concerning the nature and end
of the Grecian Mysterixs, it was to shew the sense the ancient
Lawgivers had of the use of Religion to Society : and if I expatiated
on the origine and use of the Egyptian HizroGiypuics, it was to
vindicate the logical propriety of the Prophetic language and senti-
ment. For I should have been ashamed to waste so much time in
classical amusements, and at last to join them to your Lordship’s
Name, had they not had an intimate relation to the things most con-
nected with Man and his interests.
J have detained your Lordship with a tedious Story; and still I
DEDICATION TO LORD MANSFIELD. 01
must beg your patience ἃ little longer. We are not yet got to the
end of a bad prospect—While I, and others of my Order, have been
thus vainly contending pro Aris with the unequal arms of Reason, we
had the further displeasure to find, that our Rulers (who, as 1
observed above, had needlessly suffered those ties of Religion to be
unloosed, by which, till of late, the passions of the People had been
restrained) were struggling, almost as unsuccessfully, pro Focis with
a corrupt and debauched Community.
General History, in its Records of the rise and decay of States,
hath delivered down to us, amongst the more important of its lessons,
a faithful detail of every symptom, which is wont to forerun and to
prognosticate their approaching ruin. It might be justly deemed the
extravagance of folly to believe, that those very Signs, which have
constantly preceded the fall of other States, should srgnify nothing
fatal or alarming to our own. On the other hand, 1 would not
totally condemn, in such a dearth of Religious provision, even that
species of piety, which arises from a national pride, and flatters us
with being the peculiar attention of Heaven; who will avert those
evils from his favoured People, which the natural course of things
would otherwise make inevitable: For, indeed, we have seen (and,
what is as strange as the blessing itself, the little attention which is
paid to it) something very like such an extraordinary protection
already exerted; which resists, and, till now, hath arrested, the
torrent just ready to overwhelm us. The circumstance, I mean, is
this :—That while every other part of the Community seems to le
in fece Romuli, the administration of Public Justice in England, runs
as pure as where nearest to its ccelestial Source ; purer than Plato
dared venture to conceive it, even in his feigned Republic.
Now, whether we are not to call this, the interposing hand of Pro-
vidence ; for sure I am, all History doth not afford another instance of
so much purity and integrity in one part, coexisting with so much
decay and so many infirmities in the rest: Or whether, profounder
Politicians may not be able to discover some hidden force, some
peculiar virtue in the essential parts, or in the well-adapted frame, of
our excellent Constitution :—In either case, this singular and shining
Phenomenon, hath afforded a chearful consolation to thinking men,
amidst all this dark aspect from our disorders and distresses.
But the evil Genius of England would not suffer us to enjoy it
long; for as if envious of this last support of Government, he hath
now instigated his blackest Agents to the very extent of their malig-
nity ; who, after the most villainous insults on all other Orders and
Ranks in Society, have at length proceeded to calumniate even the
King’s Supreme Court of Justice, under its ablest and most unble-
mished Administration.
92 DEDICATION TO LORD MANSFIELD.
After this, who will not be tempted to despair of his Country, and
say, with the good old man in the Scene,
“Tpsa si cupiat SALUS
Servare, prorsus non potest, hanc FAMILIAM.”
ATHENS, indeed, fell by degenerate manners like our own: but she
fell the later, and with the less dishonour, for having always kept
inviolable that reverence which she, and indeed all Greece, had been
long accustomed to pay to her August Court of Arropacus. Of
this modest reserve, amidst a general disorder, we have a striking
instance in the conduct of one of the principal Instruments of her
run. The witty ARISTOPHANES began, as all such Instruments do
(whether with wit or without) by deriding Virtue and Religion ; and
this, in the brightest exemplar of both, the godlike Socrates. The
Libeller went on to attack all conditions of Men. He calumniated
the Magistrates ; he turned the Public Assemblies into ridicule ; and,
with the most deastly and blasphemous abuse, outraged their Priests,
their Altars, nay, the very established Gods themselves.—But here he
stopped ; and, unawed by all besides, whether of divine or human, he
did not dare to cast so much as one licentious trait against that
venerable Judicature. A circumstance, which the Readers of his
witty ribauldry, cannot but observe with surprize and admiration ;—
not at the Poet’s modesty, for he had none, but at the remaining
virtue of a debauched and ruined People ; who yet would not bear to
see that clear Fountain of Justice defiled by the odious Spawn of
Buffoons and Libellers.
Nor was this the only consolation which ATHENs had in its calami-
ties. Its pride was flattered in falling by apostate Wits of the first
Order: while the Agents of public mischief amongst us, with the
hoarse notes and blunt pens of Ballad-makers, not only accelerate our
ruin, but accumulate our disgraces : Wretches the most contemptible
for their parts, the most infernal for their manners.
To conclude. Great Men, my Lord, are sent for the Times ; the
Times are fitted for the rest, of common make. Erasmus and the
present Cuier Justice or ENGLAND (whatever he may think) were
sent by Providence, for the sake of humanity, to adorn two periods,
when REeL1e1on at one time, and Society at another, most needed
their support; I do not say, of their great talents, but of that
HEROIC MODERATION so necessary to allay the violence of public
disorders : for to be MODERATE amidst party-extremes, requires no
common degree of patriotic courage.
Such characters rarely fail to perform much of the task for which
they were sent ; but never without finding their labour ill repaid, even
by those in whose service it was employed. That glory of the Priest-
hood left the World, he had so nobly benefited, with this tender com-
DEDICATION TO THE JEWS. 93
plaint,—‘“‘ Hoe tempore nihil scribi aut AGr potest quod non pateat
CALUMNI#; nec raro fit, ut dum agis CIRCUMSPECTISSIME utram-
que Partem offendas, quum in utraque sint qui PARITER INSANIANT.”
A complaint, fated, alas! to be the motto of every Man who greatly
serves his Country.
I have the honour to be,
My Lorp,
Your Lordship’s most obliged, most obedient and faithful Servant,
W. GLOUCESTER.
February 2, 1765.
DEDICATION
OF THE FIRST EDITION OF BOOKS IV. V. AND VI. OF
THE DIVINE LEGATION OF MOSES,
MDCCXL.
TO THE JEWS.
-SIRS,
THE purpose of this Work being to prove the Divine LeGatTion
oF Mosss, it will, I hope, have so much merit with you, as to engage
your serious attention to the following Address ; which, from the
divinity of Moses’s Law, as in this work demonstrated, attempts to
shew you, how, by necessary consequence, it follows, that the religion
of Jesus is also divine.
But, while I am laying my conclusions before you, let me beseech
you not to suffer yourselves to be prejudiced against the evidence, by
such kind of fallacies as these ;- Both Jews and Christians confess that
the religion of Moses came from Gov: but one only, of these two
Sects, believe the divinity of that of Jesus: the safest way, therefore,
is to adhere to what both sides own to be true. An argument, which
however like, hath not, in all its parts, even so much force as what
the idolatrous. Romanists are wont to urge against the Reformed—
That as both parties hold salvation may be had in the church of Rome,
and only one party holds it may be had in the churches of the
Reformed, it is safest to adhere to Popery: which I dare say you
laugh at for its impertinence, how much soever you may have deluded
04 DEDICATION TO THE JEWS.
others by the same kind of sophistry.* For if the Roman catholics,
or you, will not take our word for Christianity or Reformation, why
do you build any thing upon it, in favour of Popery or Judaism ?
Both of you will say, perhaps, “because we are prejudiced in the
former conclusion ; but that the mere force of evidence extorts the
latter from us even against ourselves.” This is easily said ; and may,
perhaps, be easily believed, by those who taking their Religion from
their ancestors, are apt to measure Truth only by its antiquity. But
genuine Christianity offering itself only to the private judgments of
men, every sincere enquirer believes as he finds cause. So that if
either you or they would give yourselves the trouble to examine our
motives, it would appear, that the very same reasons which force us
to conclude that Christianity in general, and the Reformed religion in
particular, are true, force us at the same time to conclude that the
Jewish was from God; and that salvation may be obtained, though
with much difficulty, in the church of Rome. Either, therefore, the
whole of our conclusion is prejudice, or no part of it is so.
As I would not have you harden your habitual obstinacy in favour
of your own Religion, by bad arguments ; so neither will I use any
such to draw you over to ours.
I shall not therefore attempt that way to bring you to the truth,
which some amongst us, little acquainted, as should seem, either with
your Dispensation, or the Christian, imagine they have discovered :
Who, taking it for granted that the Mosaic Law can be defended only
by the Gospel of Jesus, pretend you must first acknowledge our Reli-
gion, before you can support your own: and so, which is very hard,
will not allow you to have any reasonable assurance of the truth of
your Religion till you have forsaken it.t But I would not urge you
with such kind of reasoning, if it were only for this, that I suspect
you may not be such utter strangers to the New Testament as not to
know, that it lays the foundation of Christianity in Judaism.
Besides, right reason, as well as St. Paul (which with us, at present,
are still the same thing) would teach you to reply to such Convertists :
Boast not against the branches of the native olive-tree : but if thou
boast, thou bearest not the root, but the root thee.” t
Much less would I employ, in this Address, the quainter project of
* This, the miserable Uriel Acosta tells us, was one of the principal arguments that
induced him to embrace Jwdaism.—< Preterea veteri fwederi fidem dabant tam Judi
quam Christiani; novo autem feederi soli Christiani.”—Hwxemplar humane Vite, p. 346,
in fin. dmica Collat. Poin. a LimBorcH. t “ Dr. Rogers has declared as I
remember in one of his sermons, that he could not believe the truth of Moszs’s preten-
sions, were it not for the confirmation given to them by the Gospel. This 1 take to be
a dangerous assertion, that saps the very foundation of Christianity ; and supersedes at
once the whole purpose of your intended work, by denying any original intrinsic cha-
racter of divinity to the institution of Mosxes.”—Dr. MippLeton’s Leiter to Mr. W.
Nov. 30, 1736. Vol. v. of his Works. 1 Rom. xi. 18.
DEDICATION TO THE JEWS. 95
our common Adversary, the FREE-THINKER. For you are to know,
that as those I spoke of before, make Christianity too recent, so these
make it as much too old; even as old as the Creation. Those fall
short of the support of Judaism ; these overleap it; and assure us,
that the only way to bring you to believe in Jesus is to prove Moses
an impostor. So, says a late writer: who, by the singular happiness
of a good choice, having learnt his morality of our Tyndal, and his
philosophy of your Spinoza, calls himself, by the courtesy of England,
a MORAL PHILOSOPHER.*
The road I have taken is indeed very different: and the principles
I go upon for your conversion, will equally serve, to their confutation.
For I have shewn that the Law of Moses was from Gon; and, at the
same time, that it is only PREPARATORY to the more perfect Religion
of Jesus.
The limits of this Address will not allow me to point out to you
any other arguments than what arise immediately from those import-
ant circumstances of the Law, discoursed of in this Work. Much
less shall I have room to urge you with a repetition of those reason-
ings, which Christian writers have already used with so superior a
force against you.
Let us see then what it is that keeps you still enslaved to a galling
Discipline, so long after the free offers of Redemption. The two
principal reasons, I suppose, are these :
I. First, a presumption that the Religion of Moses is perfect ; so
full and complete in all its members as to be abundantly capable of
supplying the spiritual wants of men, by preparing and fitting human
nature for the enjoyment of the supreme Good, and by proposing and
procuring the possession of that Good. Hence you conclude, and
were your presumption well grounded, not unreasonably, that the Law
was given as a perpetual ordinance, to be observed throughout all
your generations for ever.
II. The second is a persuasion that the Prophecies (a necessary
credential of the Messiah) which, we say, relate to Jesus, relate not
to him in a primary sense; and that a secondary sense is a fanatic
vision raised by deluded Christians to uphold a groundless claim.
For thus one of our common enemies, who hath inforced your
arguments against us, tells the world, you are accustomed to speak.
All the books written by Jews against the Christian Religion (says he)
some of which are printed, and others go about Europe in manuscript,
chiefly attack the New Testament for the allegorical interpretations
of the Old Testament therein, and with the greatest insolence and con-
tempt imaginable on that account ; and oppose to them a single and
literal interpretation as the true sense of the Old Testament. And
* MORGAN.
96 DEDICATION TO THE JEWS.
accordingly the allegorical interpretations given by Christian expositors
of the Prophecies are now the grand obstacle and stumbling-block in
the way of the conversion of the Jews to Christianity.*
These, it seems, are the two great impediments to your conversion.
Give me leave then to shew you how the reasoning of this book
removes them.
I. As to the perfection of your Religion, it is here proved, that,
though it indeed had that specific perfection, which no Religion
coming from Gop can want,t+ that is, a full capacity of attaining its
end, which was the separation of the race of Abraham from an idola-
trous world ; yet that it was perfect only in this restrained and rela-
tive sense. As to absolute independent perfection, the Law had it not.
1. That it had no perfection with regard to the improvement
of human nature for the enjoyment of the supreme Good, I have
shewn from the genius of your whole religious Worship ; and its
general direction against the various idolatries of those early ages.
And in this I have a Doctor of your own, the famous MAIMoNIDEs,
for my warrant: who indeed little thought, while he was proving this
truth in so invincible a manner, that he was preparing the more rea-
sonable part of his Brethren for the reception of the Gospel. It is
true, some of your later writers have seen better into this conse-
quence: and Orodio, in his dispute with Limborch, hath part of a
chapter{ to disprove, or, rather, to deny the fact. But if your reli-
gious Worship consist only of a multifarious burdensome Ritual,
relative to the Superstitions of those early times, it must needs be
altogether unable to perfect human nature in such a manner, as you
do and must allow to be God’s design, in a revealed Religion,
universal and perpetual.
2. Again, as to the second branch of this perfection, the proposing
and procuring the possession of the supreme Good: \ have shewn that
the Law of Moses revealed No FUTURE STATE of rewards and punish-
ments, but studiously declined the mention of any doctrine pre-
paratory to it: that no Mosaical Tradition supplied this omission :
and that it did not become a national doctrine amongst you till the
later times of your republic; when it arose from various and dis-
cordant sources ; and was brought in on foreign occasions. But it is
certain, that That Religion must fall very short of absolute perfection,
which wants a doctrine so essential to Religion in general.§ And
* Grounds and Reasons of the Christian Religion, pp. 82, 83. t See this
proved against Lord Bolingbroke, book v. sect. 2. t The title of the chap-
ter is: “ Quod ritualia non erant precisé ut Israél ab aliis populis separaretur; neque
lex neque populus propter Messiam, sed hic propter populum, ut ei inserviret.”—P. 86,
ed. Goud. § Here Dr. Stebbing charges me with contradiction ; [Kxam. p. 9.]
first in asserting, that a future state made no part of the Religion of Moses; and then
that a future state was essential to Religion in general. Now this which he is pleased
to call a contradiction, 1 brought as an argument for the divinity of the Law; and sup-
DEDICATION TO THE JEWS. O7
this, you yourselves at length seem to have been aware of: for
though, during the existence of your Republic, the deniers of a future
state, such as the Sadducees, were not cut off from the nights of the
Synagogue ; yet since that time, it hath been generally held by your
Doctors for a prime cause of excommunication :—One of them says,
that it is the very fundamental of fundamentals ; *—-Another, that to
deny this is the same thing as to deny Gov himself, and the Divinity
of his Law ;+ and a third, that even to believe it, and yet not believe
that it was revealed by the Law, is the same thing as not to believe it
at all.t
But you will do well, when you have considered the force of those
reasonings by which I prove a future state not to be revealed by the
Law of Moses, to go on with me, (for the free thoughts of many
amongst you, concerning Revelation in general, give scandal to the
posed it to be conclusive by its consistency.— Where I speak of Religion in general, I
explain my meaning to be, a Religion universal and perpetual, such as Natural Reli-
gion and the Christian ; and from thence 1 argue, that if a future state be essential to a
Religion universal and perpetual; and a future state be not found in the Religion of
Moses, that then the Religion of Moses was not wniversal and perpetual, but local and
temporary ; the point I was inforcing, in order to bring over the Jews to the Gospel of ©
Jesus. If the Doctor supposes, that what is essential in one species of Religion must
be essential in the other, this is supposing them not to be of different species, but one
and the same; that is, it supposes, that they are and that they are not of the same
species. -But, continues our Doctor, “If you should say, that your argument is levelled
against the Jews, considered only in their present state, in which they are not under an
equal Providence, this answer will not serve you. For as in their present state they are
not under any extraordinary Providence, so neither do they want the doctrine of a
future state, of which yon tell us they have been in possession long ago,” p. 11. What
pains does this learned Doctor take to make my application to the Jews, in favour of
Christianity, ineffectual! Your Religion (say 1 to them) teaches no future state. You
are at present under the common unequal Providence of Heaven. How disconsolate is
your condition! Not so bad neither, replies their Advocate, Doctor Stebbing. They
Now have a future state. How came they by it? By the Law? No matter, says he,
they have it, and that is enough to destroy all the force of your persuasion to embrace
the Gospel. Not altogether enough, good Doctor: for if they have not the future state
by the Law, (and that truth I take for granted in this address to them,.as I think I
reasonably might, after 1 had proved it at large) their future state, even by their own
confession, is a Phantom; and to gain the Substance there is no way left but to embrace
the Gospel. They themselves own this truth: for in the words quoted below, they con-
fess that to believe a future state, and yet that it was not revealed by the Law, is the
same thing as not to believe tt at all.—lt is a sad thing when Polemics or blacker pas-
sions have gotten so entire possession of a man’s heart, that he cares not what harm he
does to a common cause, or even to common sense, so he can but ANSWER the man or
the opinion he happens to dislike.
* “Sceripsit Rab. (Maimon.) p. m. Articulus fundamentalis decimus tertius agit de
resurrectione, cujus rationem (quomodo se habeat) et fundamenta jam exposuimus.
Quod si homo crediderit fundamenta illa omnia, seque illa credere declaraverit, ingre-
ditur Ecclesiam Israelis, et jubemur diligere illum, et misericordiam illi exhibere, et
conyersari cum illo juxta omnia, que precepit Deus benedictus cuilibet erga proxi-
mum facienda.—Si quis autem vilipenderit hoe fundamentum excellentium fundamento-
rum, ecce exit ille ex Ecclesia, quippe qui abnegat articulum fidei, et vocatur impius
ac Epicureus, amputatque plantas, quem odio habere et perdere jubemur.’”—Evw beth
Elohim. Vid. Dassovium De Resurrectione, ed, 1693. + ‘* Hee fides [de
Resurrectione mortuorum]—numeretur inter articulos Legis et fundamenta ejus, quam
qui negat, perinde facit acsi negaret esse Deum, legem esse a celo, et quod in aliis
istis articulis tractatur.”—R. SaLtomo apud Dassovium De Resurrect. t “ Opor-
tet te scire articulum fidei de resurrectione mortuorum ex lege esse. Quod si quis fide
firma crediderit resurrectionem mortuorum, non autem crediderit esse illam ex lege,
ecce ille reputatur acsi hoc omnia negaret.”—R. JEHUD. ZABARA apud Dassov.
VOL. 11, H
98 DEDICATION TO THE JEWS.
professors of more than one Religion) while I prove, from thence, by
necessary consequence, that this Law came from Gop: And, in con-
clusion, join with me in adoring the infinite Wisdom of the Gop of
your Fathers, here so wonderfully displayed, in making one and the
same circumstance a standing evidence of the divinity of the Mosaic
Religion, and, at the same time, an irrefragable proof that it was pre-
paratory only to the Christian ; The logical result of all our reasoning
being the confirmation of this sacred truth, long since enounced by a
great Adept in your Law, That roe Law MADE NOTHING ὁ PERFECT,
BUT THE BRINGING IN OF A BETTER Hore Ὁ10. ἢ
Permit me to observe farther, that this rabbinical notion of a future
state of rewards and punishments in the Mosaic Dispensation, which
still encourages the remnant of your Nation to persist in rejecting the
Gospel of Jesus, was the very prejudice which, in the first ages of
Christianity, so superstitiously attached the Converts from Judaism,
to the whole observance of the Law.
As a Corollary to all this, I have shewn, that the punishment
of Children for the crimes of their Parents, which hath given a handle
to the enemies of your Law to blaspheme, can be only well explained
and vindicated on the Principle of no future state in the religion
of Moses: And farther, that, on this Principle, all the inextricable
embarras of your Rabbins, in their endeavours to reconcile the
different accounts of Moses and the Prophets concerning that method
of punishment, is intirely removed, and a perfect harmony and con-
cord is seen to reign amongst them. But at the same time that the
Principle does this, take notice, it disables you from accounting for
the length of your present dispersion. For the only reason your best
defender, Orobio, had to assign for it was, that you now suffer not for
your own sins, but for the sins of your Forefathers. But the Princi-
ple which reconciles Moses and the Prophets, shews that this mode of
punishment hath long since ceased.
II. In answer to the second part, your prejudices against the cre-
dentials of Jesus’s Messiahship, for the want of rational evidence in
a secondary sense of Prophecy ; I have proved those prejudices to be
altogether vain and groundless, 1. By tracing up the nature of human
converse in speech and writing, from its early original; and from
thence evincing, that a secondary sense of Prophecies is proper,
rational, and conformable to the justest rules of grammar and logic.
2. By shewing that this method of information was so exactly suited
to the occasion, that if ever you were to have a Messiah to compleat
your Law, the body of the Prophecies, relating to him, must needs be
given in the very manner which those in dispute are actually given :
For that, had these Prophecies recorded the nature of the Messiah’s
* Heb. vii. 19.
DEDICATION TO THE JEWS. 99
Kingdom in plain and direct terms, it would-have defeated the very
end and purpose of the Law. And this, on reflexion, you will find a
sufficient answer to those FouR Queries into which your ablest
Defender * has collected the whole strength of your cause.
As a Corollary, likewise, to this part, I shew, in order to reconcile
you still farther to the Messiahship of Jesus, that the history of
Gop’s Dispensations to your Fathers, even before his giving the Law,
can never be rightly understood, or fuily cleared from the objections
of Unbelievers, but on the supposition of the redemption of mankind
by the death and sufferings of Jesus. And of this I have given a
convincing proof in the famous history of the Command to Abraham
to offer up his Son. Which I prove to be no other than a Revena-
TION of that Redemption, delivered in action instead of words. This
strongly corroborates the Mission of Jesus, and should incline you
seriously to consider its force.—Here Gop reveals to your father
Abraham the Redemption of Mankind by the death and passion of his
Son. Why then, I ask you, should you not conclude with our
learned Apostle, that to Abraham and his seed the Promises being
made, the Covenant that was confirmed before of Gov in Curist, the
Law which was four hundred and thirty years after, cannot desannul ;
that it should make the Promise of none effect ? +
Having thus shewn your Religion to be partial, imperfect, and pre-
paratory ; and consequently shewn the necessity of its completion by
the teaching of a Messiah; to whose character in the person of
Jesus, I have endeavoured to reconcile you, by removing your only
plausible objection, the mistaken nature of the Prophecies concerning
him; As a Corollary to the whole, I have proved, in order to remove
your prejudices for a worldly Prince, and a restoration to a carnal
Dominion in Judea, that your race was not at first chosen by Gon,
and settled in the land of Canaan as his ravouriTes, for whom he
had a greater fondness than for other of the sons of Adam; but only
to serve the general ends of Providence, in its Dispensations to the
whole Species; which required the temporary separation of one
People from the rest of Mankind, to preserve, amidst an idolatrous
world, the great doctrine of the Uniry, as the foundation of that
* <Oropio. 1. Ut assignetur locus aliquis in quo Deus mandaverit, aut dixerit
expressé, quod fides in Messiam est absolute necessaria ad salutem generis humani ;
adeo ut qui non crediderit damnandus esset. 2, Ut assignetur locus, in ‘quo Deus
dixerit, quod unicum medium ad salutem Israelis, et restitutionis in divinam gratiam,
est fides in Messiam jam adyentum. 3. Ut assignetur locus, in quo Deus dixerit,
quod Israel propter infidelitatem in Messiam erat deperdendus, et abjiciendus in natio-
nibus, ut non sit amplius Populus Dei, sed in «ternum damnandus donec Messiam adven-
tum non crediderif. 4. Tandem assignetur locus, in quo dixit Deus, omnia Legalia
preter moralia, fuisse umbram, seu figuram futurorum in adventu Messi, et quod fere
omnia que et in divina Lege et in Prophetis fuere revelata, MYSTICE et TROPOLOGICE
explicare liceat, quantumvis sensus literalis omnino despiciatur.”— dmica Collatio Lim -
BORCH. pp. 1, 2. + Gal. iii. 16, 17.
H 2
100 DEDICATION TO THE JEWS.
universal Religion to be dispensed by Jesus, when the fulness of
time should come. Which time being now come, and the end
obtained, you cannot but confess there is no further use or purpose of
a national separation.
Let me add the following observation, which ought to have some
weight with you. Whoever reads your history, and believes you, on
your own word, to be still tied to the Religion of Moszs, and to have
nothing to expect from that of Jesus, must needs regard you as a
People long since abandoned of God. And those who neither read
nor believe, will pretend at least to think you forsaken of all REASON.
Our Scriptures alone give us better hopes of your condition: and
excited by the Charity they inspire, I am moved to hazard this
address unto you. Fora time, as they assure us, will come, when
this veil shall be taken from your hearts. And who knows how near
at hand the day of visitation may be? At least, who would not be
zealous of contributing, though in the lowest degree, to so glorious a
work? For if the fall of you be the riches of the World, and the
diminishing of you, the riches of the Gentiles, how much more your
Julness !* says the Apostle Paul. Who at the same time assures us,
that blindness in part is happened to Israel, until the fulness of the
Gentiles be come in. And so all Israel shall be saved.t+
I know you will be ready to say, “that much of this sort of
Charity hath been preached to your People even amidst the horrors of
the Inquisition ; and that it has always made a suitable impression :
that indeed, in a land of liberty like Britain, you should have thought
much more favourably of our good-will, had not a late transaction, in
which your natural rights came in question, amply convinced you that
Christian Charity is every where the same.”
Sufferers, even imaginary ones, may be excused a little hard lan-
guage; especially when they only repeat the clamours of those
amongst ourselves ; who, on the defeat of your Naturalization project,
affected to feel most sensibly for the interests of Liberty and Com-
merce. And yet I think it no difficulty to convince unprejudiced
men, that the Sanctity of Government was, in the first instance, sur-
prised ; and that the Legislature did justly as well as politicly in
acting conformably to their second thoughts.
A People like this of Great Britain, the genius of whose Religion
and Government equally concur to make them tender and jealous of
the rights of mankind, were naturally led by their first motions to
think they might extend those privileges to your Nation, which they
saw plainly were the due even of the followers of Mahomet: And yet
for all this they were mistaken.
As much a paradox as this may seem, it is easy to shew that in this
* Rom. πὶ, 19. t+ Verses 25, 26.
DEDICATION TO THE JEWS. 101
point, You stand distinguished to your disadvantage from all the
Nations upon earth: there being in your case, a peculiar circumstance
which must eternally exclude your claim to the general right of
Naturalization, in every free Government in Christendom, while men
act, not to say with common integrity, but even with common
decency, according to their profession. ;
Let us then consider your case as it is understood by Christian
Communities; for men must always act, would they act honestly,
according to their own conceptions of the case, not according to the
conceptions of other men.
Now it is a common principle of Christianity, that God, in punish-
ing your Nation for the rejection of their promised Messiah, hath sen-
tenced it to the irremissible infamy of an unsettled vagabond condi-
tion, without Country or Civil policy, till the fulness of the Gentiles be
come in: and then, as we observed before, our St. Paul declares, that
your Nation, converted to the faith in Jesus, shall be received again
into favour, and intitled to the privilege of Sons. The sentence
denounced upon you was not only the loss of your own Community,
but the being debarred an entrance into any other, For you are
condemned to be aliens and strangers in every land where you abide
and sojourn. A punishment which can only respect Particulars, and
not the Community ; for one People can be no other than aliens and
strangers to another People, by the constitution of Nature. So that
the sentence against you imports, that the Particulars of your race
shall not be received by Naturalization, to the rights and privileges of
the free-born Subjects of those civil States amongst which you shall
happen to be dispersed. And we have seen this sentence wonderfully
confirmed by the actual infliction of it for the space of seventeen hun-
dred years; which must be confessed to give great credit to the truth
of our interpretation of your Prophecies.
But to understand more clearly what share a Christian Community
ought to take in PREVENTING ANY INSULT on those Prophecies
which it holds to be divine, it will be necessary to consider what will
be the worldly condition of your Nation when reinstated in God’s
favour ; which both you and we are equally instructed to expect.
If it shall be, as you imagine, a recovery of your Civil-policy, a
revival of the Temple-service, and a repossession of the land of Judea ;
if this be the merey promised to your Nation, then indeed the inter-
mediate punishment, between the abolition and the restoration of your
divine Policy, can be only the temporary want of it; and conse-
quently the facilitating your entry at present into the several civil
Communities of christian men, might well be thought to have no more
tendency to insult the general Economy of revealed Religion than the
naturalizing of Turks and Tartars.
102 DEDICATION TO THE JEWS
But the genius of Christianity and the tenor of those Prophecies, as
interpreted by Christ and bis Apostles, declare such a restoration to
the land of Judea and a revival of the Temple-service, to be manifestly
absurd, and altogether inconsistent with the nature of the whole of
God’s religious Dispensation : for by this it appears, that the Mosaic
Law or Religion (as distinguished from its foundation, natural Reli-
gion, on which it was erected) was only PREPARATORY to, and
TYPICAL of the Gospel. Consequently, on the establishment of
Christianity, the Political part of your institution became abolished ;
and the Ritual part entirely ceased ; just as a scaffold is taken down
when the building is erected; or as a shadow is cast behind when the
substance is brought forward into day. Nor were you, after this pro-
mised conversion, to expect ANY oTHER Civil policy or religious
Ritual peculiar to yourselves, or separate from those in use amongst
men who profess the name of Christ: because the Gospel, of which
you are now supposed to be professors, disclaims all concern with
political or civil matters ; and because au its professors compose but
ONE religious Body, under one head which is Christ.
All therefore that remains for us to conceive of your civil condition,
when the fulness of the Gentiles shall be come in, and Israel be
received into grace, is this, That, on your conversion, you shall be
NATURALIZED and incorporated, as your convenience or inclination
may lead you, into the various civil Communities of the Faithful.
This is the only idea we Christians can entertain of your future
eondition : and this may and must regulate our conduct whenever an
alteration of your present condition comes in question.
And now to justify the Councils of our Lawgivers in their last and
perhaps final determination concerning you.
If the DECLARED punishment of heaven on your Nation, while you
continue in unbelief, be pispERsion through the world, wirHouT A
ΟἿ, poLicy of your own as a People, and wiTHouT A COUNTRY,
as Particulars; and that your restoration to favour, on your em-
bracing the Gospel, is the being received into the Church of Christ,
and (as you can be received therein only as Particulars, and not as a
Nation) the being INCORPORATED into the several civil Communities
of Christians ; then, any arrempPT to incorporate you by Naturalza-
tion into such civil Communities, before the time predicted and while
you adhere to your old Religion, as directly opposes the Prophecies,
or the declared will of Heaven, as the attempt of Julian to rebuild
your Temple, after the sentence of its final destruction had been put
in execution: because it aims to procure for you a CIVIL CONDITION
while Jews, which it is foretold you shall not enjoy till you are
become Christians. Nor is it of any avail to those Politicians who
were concerned of late in your favour, to pretend that Julian’s
DEDICATION TO THE JEWS, 103
attempt was with malice, and their’s with much integrity of heart ;
since this difference makes no change in the nature of the action, as
it respects God’s Dispensations, whatever it may be supposed to do,
in the quality of it, as it respects the Actors. In either case the
declared will of Heaven is opposed. When it is done with kpowledge
of the Prophecy, and with intention to discredit it, the attempt is
wicked and impious: when with a forgetfulness of it, with a disre-
gard to Religion, and a neglect of its interests, the attempt (even in
this best way of considering it) is indecent and dishonourable. Not
that He who thus conceives of things, hath the least apprehension
that Propnecy can be dishonoured, or have its predictions defeated
by Civil Power: But this He thinks, that a Christian State while it
enacts Laws, though unwarily, whose operation combats the truth of
those Predictions, may very easily dishonour itself.
A Nation professing Christianity, though principally busied in the
office of protecting liberty and commerce, ceases not to be a nation of
Christians, amidst all their cares to discharge the duties of good
Citizens. They have the interests and honour of their Religion to
support as well as the common-rights of Mankind. For though Civil
society be totally and essentially different from the Ecclesiastical, yet
as the same Individuals compose the members of both; and as there
is the closest Coalition between both, for their mutual support and
benefit ; such Civil society can never decently or honourably act with
a total disregard to that co-allied Religion, which they profess to
believe, and of which, under another consideration, they compose the
body.
Perhaps You may tell me, it appears from the manner in which
this late affair was conducted, that none of these considerations ever
entered into the heads, either of your Friends, or those you will call,
your Enemies, when, at length, they both agreed to leave you as they
found you. It may be so. Yet this does not hinder but that the
result of a Council, may be justified on principles which never influ-
enced it. And as for the credit of Revelation, that generally becomes
more conspicuous when, through the ignorance and perverseness of
foolish men, the predictions of Heaven are supported by Instruments
which knew not what they were about. Had they acted with more
knowledge of the case, the enemies of Religion would be apt to say,
No wonder that the honour of Prophecy is supported, when the Power
which could discredit it, held it an impiety to make the attempt.
Thus you see the British Legislature is justified in its last deter-
mination concerning you, on all the general principles of piety,
honesty, and decency. I speak of men, and [ speak to men, who
believe the Religion they profess. As for those profligates, whether
amongst yourselves or us, who are ready to profess any Religion, but
104 PREFACE TO THE FIRST EDITION
much better disposed to believe zone, to them, this reasoning is not
addressed. Have a fairer opinicn therefore of our Charity, and
believe us to be sincere when we profess ourselves,
Your &c.
PREFACE
TO THE FIRST EDITION OF BOOKS IV. V. AND VI. OF
THE DIVINE LEGATION OF MOSES:
.
MDCCXL.
Tue Author of The Divine Legation of Moses, a private clergyman,
had no sooner given his first volume * to the Public, than he was fallen
upon in so outrageous and brutal a manner as had been scarce pardon-
able had it been The Divine Legation of Mahomet. And what was
most extraordinary, by those very men whose Cause he was sup-
porting, and whose Honours and Dignities he had been defending.
But what grotesque instruments of vengeance had BigoTRy set on
foot! If he was to be run down, it had been some kind of conso-
lation to him to fall by savages, of whom it was no discredit to be
devoured.
Optat aprum, aut fuluum descendere monte Leonem.
However, to do them justice, it must be owned, that, what they
wanted in teeth, they had in venom; and they knew, as all Brutes do,
where their strength Jay. For reasons best known to Bigotry, he
was, in spite of all his professions, to be pushed over to the Enemy,
by every kind of provocation. ΤῸ support this pious purpose, pas-
sages were distorted, propositions invented,t conversation betrayed,
and forged letters written.t
The attack was opened by one who bore the respectable name of a
Country Clergyman, but was in reality a Town-Writer of a Weekly
Newspaper ; § and with such excess of insolence and malice, as the
Public had never yet seen on any occasion whatsoever.
Amidst all this unprovoked clamour, the Author had his reasons for
sparing these wretched tools of impotence and envy. His friends
thought it beneath him to commit himself with such writers; and he
* Books i. ii. iii. + See the Author’s Letter to Smallbrooke, Bishop of Lich-
field and Coventry, in which he accuses the Bishop of this crime; To which accusation,
the public never yet saw either defence or excuse. 1 By one Romaine and one
Julius Bate in conjunction. § Dr. Webster by name. Who soon after, by a cir-
cular letter to the bench of Bishops, claimed a reward for this exploit.
OF BOOKS IV. V. VI. 195
himself supposed it no good policy to irritate a crew of Zealots, who
had, at their first opening, called loudly upon the secular arm. Our
Author indeed could talk big to the FREE-THINKERS ; for alas, poor
men! he knew their weapons: All their arms were arguments, and
those none of the sharpest ; and wit, and that none of the brightest.
But he had here to do with men in Authority ; appointed, if you will
believe them, Inspectors-General over clerical Faith. And they went
forth in all the pomp and terror of Inquisitors ; with Suspicion before,
Condemnation behind, and their two assessors, Ignorance and Inso-
lence, on each side. We must suspect his faith (say they)\—We must
condemn his book—We do not understand his argument.*
—But it may perhaps be of use to Posterity at least, if ever these
slight sheets should happen to come down to it, to explain the provo-
cation which our Author had given for so much unlimited abuse and
calumny. The Reader then may be pleased to know, that the Author’s
first Volume of The Divine Legation of Moses was as well a sequel
and suppart of The Alliance between Church and State (a book written
in behalf of our Constitution and Established Clergy) as it was an
introduction to a projected Defence of Revelation. It might likewise
be regarded as an entire work of itself, to shew the usefulness of
Religion to Society. This, and the large bulk of the Volume, disposed
him to publish it apart; while the present state of Religion amongst
us seemed to give it a peculiar expediency, ‘‘an open and professed
disregard to religion”’ (as an excellent pastor of our church observes)
‘being become the distinguishing character of the present age. An
evil grown to a great height in the Metropolis of the Nation, and
daily spreading through every part of it; which hath already brought
in such dissoluteness and contempt of principle in the higher part of
the world, and such profligate intemperance and fearlessness of com-
mitting crimes in the lower, as must, if this torrent of impiety stop
not, become absolutely fatal.’ + Our Author therefore thought, that
as this evi/, which is now spread through the populace, began in the
higher part of the world, it must be first checked there, if ever it
were checked at all. And he knew no better way to do this, than by
shewing those People of Condition (who, amidst all their contempt of
religious Principle, yet professed the greatest zeal for their country and
mankind) that Religion is absolutely necessary for the support of civil
Government. He thought too, this no ill device to get the advocate of
Revelation a fair hearing. For he supposed, that unless they could be
made to see the usefulness of Christianity to Society (which their
contempt of Principle shewed they yet did not see) they would never
be brought to believe its Truth or Divinity.
* Webster, Venn, Stebbing, Waterland, and others. + BisHop oF OXFORD’S
“Charge,” London, 1738, 4to. p: 4.
Se, ἢ ; Pp
106 PREFACE TO THE FIRST EDITION
These were his endeavours and designs. What he got for his
pains, I have already told the Reader.—
In vain had he endeavoured to deserve well of Religion at large, and
of the Church of England in particular :—by fixing the true grounds
of morality ;—by confuting the atheistic arguments of Bayle, and the
flagitious Principle of Mandeville ;—by explaining the natures, settling
the bounds, and adjusting the distinct rights of the two Societies ;—
and by exposing the impious tenet, of Religion’s being the contrivance
of Politicians.
All this went for nothing with the Bigots. He had departed from
the old posture of defence, and had projected a new plan for the
support of Revelation. His Demonstration (says one of them) if he
could make one of it, could never make us amends for changing our
posture of defence, and deserting our strong holds.* For though they
will talk, indeed, of the love of truth, and the invincible evidence of
our Faith, yet I know not how, even amidst all their Zeal and Fury,
they betray the most woful apprehensions of Christianity, and are
frighted to death at every foolish Book new written against Religion,
though it come but from the Mint or Bedlam. And what do our
directing Engineers advise you to, in this exigence? Do they bid you
act offensively, and turn the enemies’ artillery upon them? By no
means. Keep within your strong holds. Watch where they direct
their battery, and there to your old mud walls clap a buttress ; and so
it be done with speed, no matter of what materials. If, in the mean
time, one more bold than the rest, offer to dig away the rubbish that
hides its beauty, or kick down an aukward prop that discredits its
strength, he is sure to be called by these men, perhaps to be thought
by those who set them on work, a secret enemy, or an indiscreet
Sriend.+ He is sure to be assaulted with all the rude clamours and
opprobrious names that Bigotry is ever ready to bestow on those it
fears and hates.
But this was the fortune of all his betters. It was the fortune of
Hooker, Hales, Stillingfleet, Cudworth, Bp. Taylor. They were called
Politiques, Scepties, Erastians, Deists, and Atheists. But Cun-
WORTH’S case was so particular, that it will excuse a little enlarge-
ment.
The Philosopher of Malmesbury was the terror of the last age, as
Tindal and Collins have been of this. The press sweat with contro-
versy: and every young Churchman militant would needs try his arms
in thundering upon Hobbes’s steel cap. The mischief his writings
had done to Religion set Cudworth upon projecting its defence. Of
this he published one immortal volume ; with a boldness uncommon
indeed, but very becoming a man conscious of his own integrity and
* WEBSTER’s * Country Clergyman’s second Letter.” + WATERLAND.
- OF BOOKS IV. V. VI. 107
strength. For instead of amusing himself with Hobbes’s peculiar
whimsies, which in a little time were to vanish of themselves, and
their answers with them; which are all now forgotten, from the
Curate’s to the Archbishop’s ; * he launched out into the immensity
of the Intellectual System ; and, at his first essay, penetrated the very
darkest recesses of Antiquity, to strip ATHEISM of its disguises, and
drag up the lurking Monster into day. Where, though few readers
could follow him, yet the very slowest were able to overtake his
purpose. And there wanted not Country Clergymen to lead the cry,
and tell the world,—That, under pretence of defending Revelation, he
wrote in the very manner that an artful Infidel might naturally be
supposed to use in writing against it ; that he had given us all the
filthy stuff that he could scrape together out of the sink of Atheism, as
a natural introduction to a demonstration of the truth of Revelation ;
that with incredible industry and reading he had rummaged all anti-
quity for atheistical arguments, which he neither knew, nor intended
to answer. In a word, that he was an Atheist in his heart, and an
Arian in his book.+ But the worst is behind. These silly calumnies
were believed. The much injured Author grew disgusted. His
ardour slackened ; and the rest, and far greatest part of the Defence,
never appeared ; a Defence, that would have left nothing to do for
such as our Author, but to read it; and for such as our Author’s
Adversaries, but to rail at it.
Thus spiritual Hate, like carnal Love, levels all distinctions. And
thus our Author came to be honoured with the same treatment which
it had bestowed upon a Cupwortnu. But as this hate is for the most
part, only envy, under the name of zeal, the Bigots, for their own ease,
should be more cautious in conferring their favours. They have given
our Author cause enough to be proud : who, as inconsiderable as he is,
has, it seems, his : as well as a Locke his Edwards, or a
CuritiinewortH his Cheynel. But alas! the Publie, I am afraid,
distinguish better. They see, though these men cannot, that the
Edwardses and Cheynels increase upon us, while the Lockers and
CHILLINGWORTHS are become exceeding rare. Turn then, good
Creatures! while you have time, turn your envy on their few remain-
ing successors: and leave our Author in peace. He has parts (had
he but suitable morals) even to be of your party. But no time is to
be lost. We have a sad prospect before us. The CHI1LLINGWORTHS
of the present age will, in a little time, be no more; while the race of
Cheynels threatens to be immortal. But this is the fate of human
things. The Geese of the Capitol, we know, remained for ages, after
* Tenison. + See WeBSTER’s ‘‘ Country Clergyman’s first Letter against The
Divine Legation ;” and one Mr. Joun Turner’s “ Discourse ” (a Clergyman likewise}
‘against The Intellectual System.”
108 PREFACE TO FIRST EDITION OF BOOKS IV. V. VI.
those true defenders of it, the Manui, the CAm1uut, the AFRICANI,
were extinct and forgotten. __ .
And alas! how ominous are the fears of friendship! I had but
just written this, when the death of Dr. Francis Hares, late bishop
of Chichester, gave me cause to lament my Divination. In him the
Public has lost one of the best patrons and supports of letters and
religion. How steadily and successfully he employed his great talents
of reason and literature, in opposing the violence of each religious
party in their turns, when court-favour was betraying them into
hurtful extremes, the unjust reproaches of Libertines and Bigots will
never suffer us to forget. How generously he encouraged and
rewarded Letters, let them tell who have largely shared in his bene-
ficence: for his character may be trusted with his enemies, or even
with his most obliged friends. In him our Author has lost, what he
could but ill spare, one of the most candid of his Readers and ablest
of his Critics. What he can never lose, is the honour of his esteem
and friendship.
But whatever advantage our Author may have received from the
outrage of his enemies, the Public is a real sufferer. He had indeed
the honour to be known to those few, who could have corrected his
errors, reformed his course, and shewn him safely through the wide
and trackless waste of ancient times. But the calumnies of the
Bigots obliged him to a kind of quarantine, as coming lately from
suspected places, from the cabinet-council of Old Lawgivers, and the
schools of Heathen Philosophers ; whose infection was supposed to be
yet sticking on him. And under such circumstances it is held ill-
breeding to come near our Superiors.
This disadvantage was the more sensible to him, as few writers have
been under greater obligations to consult the satisfaction of capable
readers ; who gave his first Volume so kind a reception ; and waited
with a favourable expectation for the following. And if he has made
these readers wait too long, he has only this to say, that he would
not follow the example of paradoxical writers, who only aim to strike
by a novelty. For as his point was truth, he was content his notions
should become stale and common, and forego all advantages but their
native evidence, before he submitted the prosecution of them to the
judgment of the Public.
PREFACE
TO THE EDITION OF
THE DIVINE LEGATION OF MOSES,
MDCCLVIII.
eee
THE subject of these Volumes had occasionally led me to say many
things of the genius and constitution of PaAGan Religion, in order to
illustrate the divinity of the Jew1su and the CuristTiaNn : Amongst the
rest, I attempted to explain the true origin of that opprobrium of our
common nature, PERSECUTION FOR OvINIoNS:* And I flattered
myself, I had done REVELATION good service, in showing that this
evil owed its birth to the absurdities of Pagan Religion, and to the
iniquities of Pagan Politics: for that the persecutions of the later
Jews, and afterwards, of the first Christians, arose from the reasonable
constitution of these two Religions, which, by avoiding idolatry,
opposed that universal principle of Paganism, INTERCOMMUNITY OF
WORSHIP; or, in other words, That the Jews and Christians were
persecuted as the enemies of mankind, for not having Gods in common
with the rest of the World.
But a learned Critic and Divine hath lately undertaken to expose
my mistake ; He hath endeavoured to prove, that the first persecution
for opinion was of Christian original; and that the Pagans persecuted
the primitive Church, not, as I had represented the matter, for the
unsociable genius of its Religion, which forbad all intercourse with
idolaters, but for its NOCTURNAL and CLANDESTINE ASSEMBLIES.
From whence it follows, as will be seen by and by, that the first
Christians were fanatics, libertines, or impostors; and that the per-
secuting Emperors, provident for the public safety, legally pursued a
bigotted or immoral sect, for a CRIME OF STATE, and not for matter
of opinion.
If it be asked, How a Doctor of Laws, a Minister of the Gospel,
and a Judge ecclesiastical, would venture to amuse us with so strange
a fancy; all I can say for it is, he had the pleasure, in common with
many other witty men, of writing against The Divine Legation ; and
he had the pleasure too, in common with many wise men, of thinking
he might indulge himself in any liberties against a writer whom he
* See “ Divine Legation,” book ii. sect. 6.
110 PREFACE TO THE EDITION OF 1758.
had the precaution not to name.—But he says, he never read the
Divine Legation. I can easily believe him: and will do him this
further justice, that, when many have written against it without read-—
ing it, he is the first who has had the ingenuity to own it.
His system or hypothesis, as we find it in a late quarto volume,
called Elements of the Civil Law,* is, in substance, this,—‘‘ That the
same principle, which set the Roman Senate upon prosecuting the
abominable r1tres or Baccuus, excited the Roman Emperors to
persecute the PRIMITIVE CHURCH.”
But it is fit, this marvellous discovery should be revealed in his own
words.—It may be asked (says he) in that almost universal licence and
toleration, which the ancients, the Romans particularly, extended to
the professors of all religions whatsoever, why the Christian profession
alone, which might have expected a favourable treatment, seems to
stand exempted, and frequently felt the severity of the bitterest per-
secution.t—If the learned Critic be serious in asking a question,
which had been answered, and as would seem, to the general satis-
faction, near twenty years ago, I suppose it is, to intimate that no
other answer will content him but one from the persecutors themselves.
This then he shall have; though it be of sixteen hundred years’ standing.
Puiny the younger, when proconsul of Bithynia, acquaints his
master with the reasons why HE persecuted; and the satisfaction he
had in so doing :—‘‘ Neque dubitabam, qualecumque esset quod fate-
rentur, certe PERTINACIAM, ET INFLEXIBILEM OBSTINATIONEM
debere puniri.”’ { What was this froward and inflexible obstinacy ?
He tells us, it was refusing all intercommunity with Paganism ; it was
refusing to throw a single grain of incense on their altars.
Tacitus, speaking of the persecution which followed the burning
of Rome by Nero (the impiety of which action that mad tyrant had
charged upon the Christians) says, ‘‘ Haud perinde in crimine incendii,
quam ODIO HUMANI GENERIS conyicti sunt.” § By which, I under-
stand him to mean,—That though the emperor falsely charged them
with the burning of Rome, yet the people acquiesced in the persecu-
tion, on account of the enormous crime of which they were convicted,
[ἡ3 e. judged guilty in the opinion of all men;] their hatred to the
whole race of mankind ; || for nothing but such an unnatural aversion,
* By the Rev. Dr. Taytor, Chancellor of Lincoln. + Page 579. ΜῈ ΕΠ} τ» τὸ
ep. 97. § πηαίζιεηι lib. xv. cap. 44. || Tacitus, speaking of the Jews,
observes that the end of their peculiar Rites was to separate them from all other people.
From their separation he inferred their aversion. In this sense we are to understand
him and other Pagan writers, when they exclaim against the Jews for their peculiar
Rites. Each Nation had its own: so that peculiarity was a circumstance common to all.
What differenced the Jewish Rites from all others was their end; which was to keep
the people from all intercommunity with the several religions of Paganism; each of
which, how different soever in their Rites, held fellowship with one another.—But here
a famous French Critic, who writes ‘‘ de omni scibili,” comes in support of our English
Critic’s system of the PszuDO-mMARTYRS of the primitive Church, and says, we all mis-
take Tacitus’s Latin. His words are these—‘‘ J’oserais dire que ces mots odio humani
PREFACE TO THE EDITION OF 1758. 111
they thought, could induce men to persevere in rejecting so universal
a principle, as ixtercommunity of worship.
The good emperor AURELIUS was himself a persecutor. It is not
to be doubted, when he speaks in condemnation of the Christian sect,
but that he would tell the worst he conceived of them: and it must
certainly have been that worst, which made him a Persecutor, so much
against the mildness of his nature, and the equity of his philosophic
manners. Now this sage magistrate, in his book of Meditations,
speaking of the wise man’s readiness to give up life, expresses himself
in this manner,—‘‘ He should be so prepared that his readiness may
be seen to be the issue of a well-weighed judgment, not the effect of
MERE oBSTINACY, like that of the Christians.’ * For intercom-
munity being in the number of first principles, to deny these, could be
owing to nothing but to mere obstinacy, or downright stupidity.
Here, the mistaken duty of the magistrate, overcame the lenity of the
man, and the justice of the philosopher: at other times, his specula-
tions happily got the better of his practice. In his constitution to the
community of Asia, recorded by Eusebius, he says,—‘‘I know the
Gods are watchful to discover such sort of men. And it is much
fitter that they themselves should punish those who REFUSE TO
WORSHIP THEM, than that we should interfere in their quarrel.” +
The emperor, at length, speaks out: and what we could only infer
from Pliny, from Tacitus, and from the passage in the Meditations,
he now declares in so many words; viz. that THe CHRISTIANS WERE
PERSECUTED FOR REFUSING TO WORSHIP THE GODS OF THE
GENTILES.
Lastly, the imperial Sophist, who, of all the idolaters, was most
learned in this mystery of iniquity, as having employed all his politics
and his pedantry to varnish over the deformities of persecution,
frankly owns, that “the Jews and Christians brought the execration
of the world upon them, by their AavERSION TO THE GODS OF THE
GENTILES.” 1 :
generis convicti peuvent bien signifier, dans le stile de Tacite, convaincus d’étre hais du
genre-humain, autant que convaincus de hair le genre-humain.” [Traité sur la Toler-
ance, 1763, p. 60.] He tells us, He dare say,—what not one of
“Ὁ Westminster’s bold race
dare say,—that these words, odio humani generis convicti, may well signify, in the style
of Tacitus, convicted of being hated by the human race, as well as convicted of hating
the human race.” And now Tacitus, so long famed for his political sagacity, will be
made to pronounce this galimatias from his oracular Tripod, ‘ The Jews were not con-
victed so properly for the CRIME of Setting fire to Rome, as for the CRIME OF BEING
HATED by all mankind.”
n 4 aA \ A , ε
* πὸ δὲ ἕτοιμον τοῦτο, ἵνα ἀπὸ ἰδικῆς κρίσεως ἔρχηται, μὴ κατὰ ψιλὴν τσαράταξιν, ws
οἱ Χριστιανοί.--Τὴν. xi. sect. 3. + Ἐγὼ μὲν oid’, ὅτι καὶ τοῖς Seois ἐπιμελές ἐστι,
΄ ~ \ A ΄
μὴ λανθάνειν τοὺς τοιούτους" πσολὺ γὰρ μᾶλλον ἐκεῖνοι κολάσαιεν ἂν τοὺς μὴ βουλομέ-
~ ΄ . . : \ A 2
vous αὐτοὺς τοροσκυνεῖν ἢ tuets.—Eccles. Hist. lib. iv. cap. 13. 1 ᾿Αλλὰ τὸ, Οὐ
τυροσκυνήσεις ϑεοῖς ἑτέροις" ὃ δὴ μέγα τῆς wepl τὸν ϑεόν φησι διαδολῆς. “Θεὸς γὰρ
(ηλωτής φησι--Αφετε τοῦτον τὸν λῆρον, καὶ μὴ τηλικαύτην ἐφ᾽ ὑμᾶς αὐτοὺς ἕλκετε
Braopnulay.JuLIAN. apud ΟΥ̓ 11. Contra Jul. lib. v.
112 PREFACE TO THE EDITION OF 1758.
We have seen, from the Macisrratr’s own testimony, what it was
for which he persecuted. We shall now see, from the PEOPLE's
demand, that they required the exertion of his power, on no other
account. It was usual in their sanguinary shews, when criminals and
offending slaves were exposed to the beasts, to call out for and demand
execution on the Christians, by the formula of AIPE ΤΟΥΣ
A@EOYS. This was their early language, when they required Poly-
carp for the slaughter. The name ATHEIST was only one of their more
odious terms, for a rejector of their Gods. And it was but too
natural, when they wanted to have their rage and cruelty thus
gratified, to use expressions, which, at the same time that the terms.
were most calumniating, implied the very crime for which the magis-
trate was wont to persecute.
What says our learned Civilian to this evidence? He allows Anti-
quity to have proved the Fact, that the pagan emperors did persecute.
But for what, is a question (says he) that may still be asked. And
the true answer, with your leave, he thinks himself better able to give
than the Persecutors themselves. My reader (these are his words)
will grant the fact ; and | comE Now TO Account FoR IT. The
account, we find, had been settled long ago. What of that? It had
never passed through his philologie Office ; and therefore lay still open
till our master-critic was at leisure to examine it.
It is not true (says this redresser of wrongs) that the primitive
Christians held their assemblies in the night-time to avoid the interrup-
tions of the civil power. But the converse of that proposition is true
IN THE UTMOST LATITUDE, viz. that they met with molestations from
that quarter, because their assemblies were nocturnal.”
He says, it is not true: The Christian church says, i is. Who
shall decide? A bundle of Grammarians ; or the college of Apostles ?
I know Ais mind: and I guess at my reader’s: and of the two, being
at present more disposed to gratify the latter, I shall, for once,
venture to bring our Civilian before a foreign Judicatory, that is to
say, HOLY SCRIPTURE.
From Scripture we learn, that the first Christian assembly, held in
the night-time, was the very night after the RESURRECTION ; when
the disciples met in a clandestine manner, with the doors made fast
upon them: and this, we are assured, was to avoid the interruptions
of the civil power; or, in the plainer words of St. John, FOR FEAR
OF THE sEWs:+ for the Soldiers’ story of the resurrection began
now to make a noise; and the Jewish rulers were much startled and
enraged at it. But when the fright of the disciples was a little over,
and things had subsided into a calm, the next assembly, we hear of,
was in the day-time ; without any marks of the former wary cixcum-
“ἐς Klements of the Civil Law,” p. 579. + John xx. 19.
PREFACE TO THE EDITION OF 1758. 113
spection.* These open meetings were repeated as often as the returns
of public worship required: sometimes shifting from house to house ;
sometimes more stationary in the Temple.t
But when now the miractes, worked by the apostles in confirma-
tion of the soldiers’ story, had alarmed the rulers afresh ; and Peter
and John, whom they had put into prison, were, on their releasement,
enjoined silence, the Church, assembled in this exigence to implore the
Divine direction touching the extent of their obedience to the civil
power, was answered by sensible signs from heaven, as at the day of
Pentecost— And when they had prayed (says the historian) the place
was shaken where they were assembled together ; and they were all
filled with the Holy Ghost, and they spake the word of God witu
BOLDNESS.{
Here we see, that this second persecution had a different effect
upon the Church from the former. At first, they assembled in a
clandestine manner for fear of the Jews; now, they continued openly
in the Temple to speak the word of God with boldness. This conduct
seemed good to the Holy Ghost: and the reason is not difficult to
comprehend. The Church was now, for the first time, solemnly
enjoined silence by Authority. It was fit it should be as solemnly
decided, who was to be obeyed ; Gon, or the civil Magistrate. But
this was not all: the decision served another very great purpose ; it
served, to disseminate the Faith: for the natural consequence of the
disciples’ persisting to discharge their ministry, after they had been
formally forbidden, was their being scattered abroad throughout the
regions of Judea and Samaria.§ Wad the Church taken its usual
remedy against civil violence, namely, secret assemblies (which, in
ordinary cases, modesty and a sober regard to authority prescribe),
the faithful had not been dispersed ; and the purpose of Divine Pro-
vidence, in the speedy propagation of the Gospel, had not been pro-
perly effected.
This being the case, in the interval between the dispersion, and St.
Paul’s miraculous conversion, we hear of no nocturnal assemblies ;
unless you reckon in the number that between the Disciples and their
illustrious Convert, on the town-wall of Damascus, when they Jet him
down in a basket, to escape his persecutors.|| In this condition,
things remained till Paul’s return to Jerusalem: and then, says my
text, the Churches had rest throughout all Judea and Galilee and
Samaria.4
From this time, till Herod’s persecution,** we have not one word of
any nocturnal assembly of the Faithful: but no sooner did that perse-
cution commence, than those meetings were again re-assumed. The
Se Actsie 14: 11. 1 } Acts ii. 46. 1 Acts iv. 31. § Acts viii. 1.
|} Acts ix. 25. q Acts ix. 31. SSS ACts) xile Le
VOL. 11. I
114 PREFACE TO THE EDITION OF 1758.
Church assembled at midnight, to pray for Peter’s deliverance’ out of
prison: and he, when he was delivered by their prayers, found more
diffculty to get to his secreted friends than to escape from his
gaolers.*
In a word, from this history of the first propagation of the Faith,
we learn, that, in times of persecution, the Church assembled by
stealth, and in the night: but whenever they had a breathing-time,
and were at liberty to worship God according to their conscience, they
always met together openly, and in the face of day. Thus when Paul
came first to Rome (where this sect shared in the general toleration of
foreign worship, till the magistrate understood that it condemned the
great principle of intercommunity) we learn, that he freely discharged
the office of his ministry from morning to night.t And the sacred
writer, as if on purpose to insinuate, that, when the Church had rest
from persecution, it never crept into holes and corners, ends his narra-
tive in this manner :— And Paul dwelt two whole years in his own hired
house, and RECEIVED ALL that came in unto him; preaching the
kingdom of God, and teaching those things which concern the Lord
Jesus Christ, with all confidence, NO MAN FORBIDDING HIM.{
It may be objected, perhaps, “that the question is, of the perse-
cuting Pagans ; and all that has been here said, concerns the perse-
cuting Jews only.” It does so: but who can help it? The Jews
happened to persecute, first. As to the question, that which is
essential in it is only this, Whether the primitive Christians held their
clandestine assemblies to avoid persecution; or, whether they were
persecuted for holding clandestine assemblies?—Who persecuted,
whether Jews or Pagans, is merely incidental to the question, and
wholly indifferent to the decision of it. But it may still be said,
“That the Christians having thus gotten the habit of clandestine
assemblies in Judea; by that time Churches became formed in the
midst of Paganism, they continued the same mode of worship, though
the occasion of its introduction was now over; so that the learned
Doctor’s position may yet be true, that the Pagans persecuted for
those clandestine meetings, which had been first begun in Judea, to
avoid persecution, and were now continued in contempt of authority.”
To this I answer, that the fact, on the Doctor’s own principles, is
impossible. According to his principles, clandestine meetings must
be prosecuted as soon as observed; and they are of a nature to be
observed as soon as practised. Now all Antiquity, both profane and
sacred, assures us, that the Christian Church was not persecuted on
its first appearance amongst the Pagans: who were not easily brought,
even when excited by the Jews, to second their malice, or to support
their impotence.
* Acts xii, 18. + Acts xxviii. 23. t Acts xxviii. 30, 31.
PREFACE TO THE EDITION OF 1758. 115
But the fact is, in the highest degree, improbable on any principles.
Had our learned Critic consulted what Philosophers, and not what Philo-
logists, call HUMANITY, that is, the workings of our common nature, he
had never fallen into so absurd a conceit, as that the inspired propa-
gators of a Revelation from heaven should, without any reasonable
cause, and only in imitation of pagan worship, affect clandestine and
nocturnal meetings. For he might have seen, that so strange a
conduct had not only been in contempt of their divine Master’s
example, who, at his arraignment before the high priest, said, 7 spake
OPENLY fo the world ; and IN SECRET have I said nothing ; * but
likewise in defiance of his injunction, when he sent them to propagate
the faith— What I tell you in DARKNESS, that shall you speak 1N
THE LIGHT: and what ye hear IN THE EAR, that preach ye UPON
THE HOUSE-ToPs.t Had our Critic (I say) paid that attention to
human nature and to the course of the moral world, which he has
misapplied upon an old mouldy brass, and a set of strolling Baccha-
nals,t he might have understood, that the first Christians, under the
habitual guidance of the Holy Spirit, could never have recourse to
nocturnal or clandestine conveuticles, till driven to them by the
violence of persecution: he might have understood, that the free
choice of such assemblies must needs be an after-practice, when
churchmen had debased the truth and purity of Religion by human
inventions and sordid superstitions ; when, an emulous affectation of
MYSTERY, and a mistaken zeal for the tombs of the Martyrs, had
made a Hierarchy of that, which at first was only a Gospel-ministry.
On the whole therefore, we need not, I think, ask leave of this
learned man to continue in our opinion, that the primitive Christians
held their assemblies in the night-time to avoid the interruptions of
the civil power; and to esteem his CONVERSE proposition, as he
affects to call it (of their meeting with molestation from that quarter,
BECAUSE their assemblies were nocturnal) as a mere dream or vision.
But to hide nothing which may concern a matter of such import-
ance as our Critic’s Discoveries ; I will ingenuously confess, how much
soever it may make against me, that there are instances in sacred
story of meetings at midnight and before dawn of day, to which xo
interruption of the civil Power had driven the disciples of Christ ; but
which were evidently done in contempt and defiance of that Power:
such, for example, was the clandestine meeting between Mary and the
two Angels at the sepulchre: § that between the Apostles and the
Angel of the Lord in the common prison: || and that, again, between
* Jobn xviii. 20. + Matt. x. 27. t All these refined speculations con-
cerning persecution, are at the end of the said book of Elements; in a dissertation on a
curious ancient tablet, containing the senatorial decree against a crew of wicked Bac-
chanais, of the size and dignity of our modern Gypsies. § John xx. 11, 12.
{| Acts v. 18, 19.
12
110 PREFACE TO THE EDITION OF 1758.
Peter and the.same Angel: * not to speak of another famous midnight
assembly between Paul, Silas, the Gaoler, and an Earthquake.t
We come now to the learned person’s second proposition, called by
way of eminence, the CONVERSE ; which affirms, That the primitive
Christians met with molestations from the civil power, because their
assemblies were nocturnal. And this he assures us is true IN THE
UTMOST LATITUDE; which in his language, I suppose, signifies, true
in the EXACTEST SENSE; for his argument requires some such mean-
ing. Now in common English—true in the utmost latitude, signifies
true, in the LOWEST SENSE; for the greater latitude you give to any
thing, the looser you make it. This most eloquent editor of Demos-
thenes, therefore, by uémost latitude may be allowed to mean, what
makes most to his purpose; though it be what an Englishman would
least suspect,—wutmost strictness. And now for his reasoning.—By the
molestations the Christians met with, we rust needs understand the
FIRST molestations ; all other being nothing to the purpose: for when
persecution was once on foot, I make no doubt but the nocturnal
assemblies, to which persecution had driven them, gave fresh umbrage
to the Civil power ; it being of the nature of a persecuting spirit to
take offence at the very endeavours to evade its tyranny. The ques-
tion between the learned Civilian and me is, What gave birth to the
Jirst, and continued to be the general, cause of persecution? He says
it arose from nocturnal and clandestine assemblies : 1 suppose it to be
occasioned by the Atheistic renunciation of the Gods of Paganism.
Now it seems to be a viclent prejudice against the learned Critic’s
system, that no one of those persecutors ever assigned nocturnal
assemblies as the first or general cause of persecution; and equally
favourable for my opinion, that they all concur in giving another cause 3
namely, the unhospitable temper of the Christians, in refusing to have
Gods in common with the rest of mankind.
Purny, in doubt how to\act with the Christians of his district,
writes to his master for instructions. His embarras, he tells the
emperor, was occasioned by his never having been present at their
examinations ; which made him incapable of judging what, or how he
was to prosecute. ‘‘Cognitionibus de Christianis interfui nunquam :
ideo nescio guid et quatenus aut puniri soleat aut queeri.” He wanted
to know, whether the very NAME was not criminal; either for itself,
or for some mischief hid under it—‘* Nomen ipsum etiam si flagitiis
careat, an flagitia cohzrentia nomini puniantur.’’ But could a
Roman Magistrate, when at a loss for a pretence to persecute, over-
look so fair a one as voluntary, unforced clandestine assemblies, and
hunt after a mormo hid in the combination of four syllables? Not
that he wanted a Precedent for proceeding on these visionary
grounds ; but the very Precedent shows that the Persecutors wanted
* Acts xii. 7, 8. 1 Acts xvi. 25.
PREFACE TO THE EDITION OF 1758. 117
better. TeERTULLIAN assures us, that the Christians had been
actually persecuted for the Name only: ‘Non scelus aliquod in
causa, sed NOMEN ; Christianus, si nullius criminis reus, nomen valde
infestum, si solius nominis crimen est—si nominis odium est, quis
nominum reatus: quee accusatio vocabulorum? nisi si aut barbarum
sonat aliqua vox nominis, aut infaustum, aut maledicum, aut impudi-
cum,” &c. From whence, by the way, allow me to conclude, that
when a harmless NAME becomes so odious as to occasion the Sect
which bears it, to be persecuted, the aversion must arise from some
essential principle of that Sect, and not from a casual circumstance
attending their religious practice.—But to return to Pliny ; at last he
discovers something worthy of animadversion. It was their FRo-
WARD AND INFLEXIBLE OBSTINACY :—‘‘neque dubitabam, quale-
cumque esset quod faterentur, pervicaciam certe et ¢nflexibilem obsti-
nationem debere puniri.” Now is it possible, if the Christians were
first persecuted, and continued to be persecuted, for holding their
assemblies in the night-time, that Pliny, after so much experience of
it, should not know the crime, nor how to proceed against the
offenders? What is still more unaccountable, TRAJAN, in answer to
this application, is unable to deliver any general rule for the direction
of his Minister :—‘ Neque enim in universum aliquid, quod quasi cer-
tam formam habeat, constitui potest.” But the assembling in a elan-
destine manner by night, if this was the Crime which gave offence, is
an action that admits of few modifications in a Court of Justice; and
so might be commodiously submitted to a general rule. On the other
hand, if what the author of The Divine Legation says, be true, that
they were persecuted for opposing the principle of INrTERCOMMU-
NiTy, we see plainly why no general rule could be delivered. They
expressed this opposition in various ways and manners ; some more,
some less, offensive :—by simply refusing to worship with the Pagans,
when called upon ; by running to their tribunals uncalled ; by making
a profession of their faith, unasked; or by affronting the national
religion, unprovoked. Now, so just and clement a prince as Trajan
might well think, these different modes of expressing their abhor-
rence of intercommunity deserved different degrees of animadversion.
When Nero, in a mad frolic, set Rome on fire, and then threw that
atrocious act upon the Christians, it is highly probable that the noc-
‘turnal assemblies of the Faithful (which, by this time, persecution had
introduced amongst them) first started the happy thought, and encou-
raged him to pursue it. Now, if this, which is very probable, and
our Critic’s hypothesis, which is very improbable, be both truth, I
cannot see how it was possible for Tacrrus, when he acquits them of
this calumny, and at the same time expresses the utmost virulence
against them, to omit the mention of their nocturnal assemblies, had
118 PREFACE TO THE EDITION OF 1758.
they been begun without necessity, and obstinately continued after
the civil magistrate had forbidden them. Instead of this, all he had
to object to the Christians, was their odium humani generis : of which,
indeed, he says, they were convicted; convicti sunt : an expression,
without either propriety or truth, unless we suppose he understood
their refusal ‘of intercommunity to be a conviction: other proof there
was none: for when examined on the rack concerning this hatred of
mankind,* they constantly denied the charge; and appealed as well
to their principles as their practice; both of which declared their
universal love and benevolence to all the creatures of God. But to
reprobate the Gods of Rome, the Ordis Romanus, (of which our Critic
can tell us wonders) was proclaiming hatred and aversion to all the
world. Hence it is that Quintilian, speaking of the topics of dispraise,
says that the Author of the Jewish Religion (equally reprobating, with
the Author of the Christian, the universal principle of zxtercommunity)
was deservedly hated and held ignominious as the founder of a super-
stition which was the BANE of all other Religions— Et parentes malo-
rum odimus : Et est conditoribus urbium infamize, contraxisse aliquam
PERNICIOSAM ceteris gentem, qualis est primus Judaicz supersti-
tionis Auctor.” But why pernicious and baleful to the rest, if not by
accusing and condemning all other institutions of error and imposture ?
Marcus Avre.ius and ὅταν were vigilant and active; well
instructed in the rights of Society; and not a little jealous of the
interests of the Magistrate. Yet neither of these princes ever accuse
the Christians of running to nocturnal assemblies unprovoked, or of
persisting in the practice against imperial edicts. What a field was
here for Aurelius, who despised them, to urge his charge of drutal
obstinacy ; and for Julian, who feared them, to cry aloud of danger to
the state; their two favourite topics against these enemies of their
Religion and Philosophy !
But sacred story may help us out where the civil fails: let us see then
how this matter stands represented in Scripture : for I make our Critic’s
cause my own, as supposing we are both in the pursuit of Truth.
I have already given a brief account of the Assemblies of the infant-
church, as they are occasionally mentioned in the history of the Acts
of the Apostles.
Our Critie’s converse proposition, which we are now upon, only
requires us to shew in what light the persecutors of the Apostles con-
sidered this matter ; and whether nocturnal assemblies, when any such
were held, either gave advantage to their Jewish accusers, or umbrage
to the pagan Magistrate, before whom the propagators of the Gospel
were convened.
“ἦν e. Concerning their principles and their practice, from whence the Pagans
inferred their hatred of mankind.
PREFACE TO THE EDITION OF 1758. 119
The persecutions recorded in the history of the dets were almost all
of them raised, or at least, fomented, by the Jews. Their several
accusations against those they called apostate brethren are minutely
recorded : and yet the crime of assembling by night is never brought
into account. In the mean time, their point was to make the unwill-
ing Magistrate the instrument of their malice: for this reason, they
omitted nothing which might tend to alarm the jealousy of the State ;
as when they accused the Christians of setting up another king,
against Cesar. Had their nocturnal assemblies therefore been held
out of choice, they would not have neglected this advantage, since
nothing could more alarm the civil Magistrate than such assemblies.
The truth is, the Jews could not be ignorant of the advantage this
would afford them. But conscience and humanity are not to be
overcome at once. To accuse those they hated, of what they them-
selves had occasioned, required a hardiness in vice which comes only
by degrees ; and after a long habit of abusing civil justice and the
common rights of mankind.
Our Critic, perhaps, may be ready to say, ‘‘ That it is probable the
Jews did accuse the Christian Church of this misdemeanor, though
the historian, in his succinct history of the Acts, hath omitted to
record it.”
But this subterfuge will never pass with those who consider how
unwilling the Roman Magistrate always was to interfere in their con-
tests, as clearly apprehending, the subject of them to be of certain
matters concerning their law : so that, under this disposition, nothing
could be more effectual to quicken his jealousy and resentment, than
the charge of clandestine assemblies ; of which, doubtless, the Romans
were very jealous, as contrary to their fundamental Laws, though not
so extravagantly umbragious as our Critic’s hypothesis obliges him to
suppose.
But it will be said, “‘ Were clandestine meetings never objected to
the primitive Christians?” Yes, very often. Cxxsus objected such
meetings to them, as things contrary to law.* But OricEen’s reply
will set matters to right. He says, the Church was driven upon this
obnoxious measure to avoid the unjust persecution of its enemies.t
Nay Celsus, in a more ingenuous humour, confesses, they had reason
for what they did: there being no other way to escape the severest
punishments.t At least then, I have the honour of finding this reve-
rend Epicurean on my side, against our Civilian and his converse
proposition.
These meetings, therefore, it is confessed, subjected the Church to
“Ὅσαι κατὰ νόμους yiyvovTat.—ORIGENES Contra Cels. + ᾿Απὸ τοῦ κοινοῦ
, > / “ ~ a , Ἁ > / > ΄“
κινδύνου. 1 Οὐ μάτην τοῦτο πσοιοῦσιν, ἅτε διωθούμενοι τὴν ἐπηρτημένην αὐτοῖς
δίκην τοῦ ϑανάτου.
120 PREFACE TO THE EDITION OF 1758.
much censure; but that was all. Tertullian, vindicating the Chris-
tians on this head, says—‘‘ Hee coitio Christianorum merito sane
illicita, si illicitis par; merito damnanda, si quis de ea queritur eo
titulo quod de factionibus querela est.””* The passage is remarkable ;
and shews, not only that the Christians were never brought imto con-
demnation for nocturnal meetings; but, why they were not ; namely,
because nothing bad or even suspicious could be proved against
them. The law of the twelve tables says, “δὶ qui in urbe ecetus noc-
turnos agitassit, capital esto;”’ meaning, if celebrated without the
licence of the magistrate.t The Christians applied for this licence :
it was denied them. They assembled: and such assemblies are only
liable to animadversion, if any thing criminal or immoral be com-
mitted in them. Crimes were indeed pretended; but on enquiry, as
we find by Pliny, they could not be proved. This I take to be the
true explanation of Tertullian’s argument: by which we understand
that the Christians were not persecuted, but only calumniated, for
their nocturnal assemblies.
Maximus, a pagan Philosopher of Madaura, desires to know
of Austin why the Christians so much affected mystery. To which
the answer is, ‘“‘ That, without doubt, this idolater did not mean, the
meetings in caverns and sepulchres, in which the faithful were wont
to assemble during the heat of persecution—but their mysteries of
Baptism and the Lord’s Supper.” ΖΦ St. Austin supposes Maximus
did not intend to object to their clandestine meetings: however, if he
did, he is ready to justify them on the plea of necessity, and to avoid
persecution. Another sad discredit to the converse proposition.
But since our Civil Judge is so eager to have the primitive Chris-
tians found guilty of a crime of state, at his tribunal; I will, out of
tenderness to his credit, and deference to his authority, consent to
give them up; and fairly confess, they were not only accused, but
even punished for high treason, the erimen lese majestatis. The pro-
cess was thus carried on. Christians refused to worship the Gods of
Rome. Sacrificing for the safety of the empire, and for the life of the
emperor, made part of that worship. If the Christians could not
_ worship, they could not sacrifice: But this sacrifice was esteemed a
necessary part of civil obedience. The omission of it, therefore, was
a crime of state, and amounted to high treason. ‘Tertullian sums up
* Apologia, cap. xxxviii. + This appears to be the true sense of the Law, from
a passage in Cicero’s dialogue De Legibus. Atticus thought him too severe upon noc-
turnal assemblies: he vindicates himself by observing, that, even in the midst of
Greece, Diagondas, the Theban, totally abolished them.—‘ Ne nos duriores forte videa-
mur, in media Grecia, Diagondas Thebanus lege perpetua sustulit.” From hence J
infer these two things; That, were not the Law of the twelve iables to be understood in
the sense here given to it, Cicero needed not have gone so far as Thebes for his justifi-
cation: and secondly, that his laying so much stress upon the abolition’s being made in
the midst of Greece, shews how strongly, in his opinion, that country was attached te
noclurnal assemblies. t Ep. xliv,
PREFACE TO THE EDITION OF 1758. 121
~
the charge, and pleads guilty to it. ‘‘ Deos inquitis”’ (says he, repeat-
ing the pagan accusation) “ non colitis, et pro imperatoribus sacrificia
non impenditis :—sacrilegii et majestatis rei convenimur. SumMMaA
HC CAUSA, IMO TOTA EST.” Here again we see, Antiquity gives
the exclusion to the cenverse proposition: for if this was the only
cause of persecution, certainly nocturnal assemblies was not one. I
could wish therefore, by this crime of state, to save the learned Doc-
tor’s credit and authority. But I am afraid, on examination, it will
prove no more than their refusal to communicate in pagan worship.
Tertullian himself, in the passage quoted above, makes it amount to
no more. However, it was esteemed to be the crimen lese majesta-
tis : and this we are not to wonder at; for one of the greatest orna-
ments of Paganism, long before the moving this question, had
declared, that even the exclusive worship of one God came pretty near
the matter. MasesTATEM IMPERII NON DECUISSE UT UNUS TAN-
tum Devs coLatur, says Cicero, in his oration for Flaccus.
You see then, at length, to what our Critic’s discovery amounts.
No marvel he triumphs in it. ‘And now” (says he) ‘‘can any one
doubt that the considerations I have mentioned, were those which
GAVE AN EDGE to the Roman persecutions? The professors of
Christianity had No rEAsoN to be apprehensive of any severities
upon the score of religion, any more than the professors of ANY
OTHER RELIGION besides. Antiquity, in its public capacity, was
generally very indulgent to all who dissented from the established
worship: persecution for DIFFERENCE OF BELIEF ALONE owes its
nativity to more modern ages, and Spain was its country ; where
Priscillian, by some, is held to be the first sufferer for mere opinion.”
—Pp. 579, 580.
—And now can any one doubt that the considerations I have men-
tioned were those which GAVE AN EDGE to the Roman persecutions ?
—For a trusty Guide, allow me to recommend him to the reader ;
whom he is ready to mislead, the very first step he makes. The ques-
tion is, and so he himself has stated it, What occASIONED the Roman
persecutions? Here, he changes it to—What GAVE AN EDGE to
them ?—Nocturnal assemblies might give an edge to the persecutions,
and yet all be true that his Adversary affirms, and the persecutions be
occasioned by a very different thing.—But our Critic is so highly
figurative, and often so sublime, as to transcend the common liberties
of speech. Thus he speaks of Antiquity in its public capacity, mean-
ing, I suppose, the civil states of Greece and Rome; though in the
mode of ordinary language it would be no inelegant periphrasis for
the NEW INCORPORATED SOCIETY OF ANTIQUARIES: again he talks
of the nativity of persecution, and of its being a native of Spain ; and
yet he seems not to mean, as you would fancy, its darth, but its edu-
122 PREFACE TO THE EDITION OF 1758.
cation. For he tells us (p. 583) it was born long before, in Egypt ;
where it occasioned, what he calls, their holy wars ; which, by his
own account, were persecutions for difference of belief alone. How-
ever, as this Egyptian intrigue was but a miscarriage, and a kind of
coming before it’s time, he forces it to enter again into the womb of
Fate, and to be born, we sce, a second time for the honour of Christi-
anity. Since, then, our Critic’s figures are so new, and of so transcend-
ent a kind, why may we not suppose that, the giving an edge to perse-
cution, may signify the giving a sword to it, and then all will be right.
—The professors of Christianity (says he) had no reason to be
apprehensive of any severities upon the score of Religion.—The more
fools they ; when their Master had pointed out so many. If they
had no reason, it must be because xo reason would make an impres-
sion. For they were frequently reminded by him, of what they were
to suffer, not indeed for assembling in the night-time, but for his
NAME’S SAKE, and because of the worv.* St. Paul too had
expressly assured the churches, that all who live godly in Jesus Christ
shall suffer persecution.t But where was the wonder, that they, who
paid so little attention to their Master, should pay still less to their
Fellow-servant ?
—Hear me out, however, cries our learned Critic: I affirm that the
professors of Christianity had no reason to be apprehensive of any
severities upon the score of Religion, ANY MORE than the professors
of any other sect or religion besides. On my word, he has mended
matters greatly! What, had the professors of other sects or religions any
PROPHECIES OF REVELATIONS of severities upon the score of religion ?
But, from this essential difference in the external circumstances of
these two sets of Professors, the Pagan and the Christian, we will
turn to the internal: and, under this head, let me ask another ques-
tion. The Professors of the faith held it to be unlawful, and a deadly
sin, to have communion or fellowship with the Gods of the Heathen.
But had the Professors of Idolatry any of these scruples, or did they
hold any thing analogous to them? On the contrary, did,not the
Professors of Gaul, of Greece, of Asia, and of Egypt, join heartily
with the Professors of Rome, to pay all due honours to the established
religion? while those masters of the world as heartily joined commu-
nion with these strangers: nay, were ready to do the same honours
to the Gospel, had they found the same disposition towards mutual
civilities among its followers.
And was this so trifling a difference as to deserve no notice either
of the Critic or the Civilian? Had the Christians, who damned
Paganism in the lump, and reprobated the established religion of
Rome, as the work of evil demons and evil men, xo more reason to be
Matt. xxiv. 9; xiii, 21. ἡ 2 Tim. iii. 12.
PREFACE TO THE EDITION OF 1758. 123
apprehensive of any severities from this antiquity in its public eapa-
city, than the professors of any other religion besides, all of which not
only acknowledged the Gods of Rome, but, to make a good weight,
added Rome itself to the number of her Divinities? This pudlic
capacitied antiquity must have been of an odd paste, and strangely
composed, to use those, who attempted the destruction of its Gods, in
the same gentle way it treated those who revered and honoured them.
But, as this public capacitied antiquity is, after all, no more than
a fantom, and owes its nativity to our Critic’s brain, it is no wonder, it
should have something of the perversity of its parent; who, searching
for the caAusE of Persecution, could not find it in a circumstance in
which idolatry and Christianity differed, namely, exclusive worship, a
principle most abhorred by paganism ; and yet can see it in 4 circum-
stance where both agreed, namely, nocturnal worship, a practice most
venerated by paganism.
But antiquity (says he) in its public capacity was generally very
indulgent to all who dissented from the established worship. This, he
had many ways of learning: but the cause of the indulgence, if it be
yet unknown to him, he will owe to the author of The Divine Lega-
tion, who hath shewn that it was entirely owing to the absurdity of
its religious systems, just as the want of this indulgence, under Chris-
tianity, was occasioned by the reasonableness of its system, unreason-
ably indeed enforced upon the mistaken principles of Judaism. So
that the indulgence of Paganism had continued to this day, had not
Christianity come boisterously in, and broken the peace. Then arose
an exception, unfavourable to the new Comer: For why was the
established religion so indulgent to every strange sect, but because
every strange sect was as indulgent to the established? So that, in
this commerce of mutual civilities, while the national worship enjoyed
the civil rights of an Establishment, it was content, the stranger
should still possess the natural rights of a Toleration. But all this
good harmony, the Christian faith disturbed and violated. It con-
demned paganism in the gross, whether established or tolerated : and,
under pain of damnation, required all men, both Greeks and Barba-
rians, to forsake their ancient absurdities, and profess thew faith in a
crucified Saviour. A circumstance, sufficient, one would think, with-
out nocturnal assemblies, to sour this sweet-tempered Antiquity in its
public capacity.
But he goes on—FPersecution for DIFFERENCE OF BELIEF ALONE
owes its nativity to more modern ages; and Spain was its country, where
Priscillian, by some, is held to be the first sufferer for mere opinion.
Here we have another cast of his office. The question between us
is, “Whether the Christians were first persecuted for their faith in
general, or for their nocturnal assemblies,’ J hold the former: he
124 PREFACE TO THE EDITION OF 1758.
contends for the latter: and to confute my opinion, observes “ that
persecution for DIFFERENCE of belief alone, was of later date, and
began with Priscillian :” that is, persecution for MODES OF FAITH
began at that time. Well, and if it did, what then? What is this to
the dispute between us? I never held, because Jesus and his Apos-
tles never foretold, that the first Christians should be persecuted by
the Pagans for modes of Faith; but on the contrary, for the very
genius of that Faith, so opposite to the idolatrous world.
Paganism had no dogmatic theology, or, what we call Religion :
and not having the thing, it was no wonder they had not the word :
neither the Greeks nor Romans, with all their abundance, had a word
for that moral mode; the Latin word Religio, when it comes nearest
to it, signifies only a se¢ of ceremonies. However, though they were
without a dogmatic theology, yet they had their general principles ;
but these principles regarded utility rather than truth ; the chief of
which was that of intercommunity ; which the principle of Christianity
directly opposing, they rose against this principle, and so began a per-
secution. Pagans therefore, having zo modes of faith, could not
persecute for any: but Christians, who had, might and did persecute
for them.
Again, when the persecution is for modes of faith, their truth or
falshood comes in question: when for the common genius of a reli-
gion, its harmlessness or malignity isthe only matter of inquiry. Now
the pagan persecutors were so far from regarding Christianity as a
false religion, that they were ready,* according to their general indul-
yence to all who dissented from the established worship, to put the
professors of the Faith on a footing with other foreign sects: but this
would not serve their turn. The Christians believed their Religion to
be the only true; and therefore, that it should be the only one pro-
fessed. This PARADOX brought on persecution. But for what? not
for the profession of a falsehood ; but for a practised hatred to the
whole race of mankind.
Here then, we find, the learned Critic has shuffled in one question
for another ; and again put the change upon his reader ; and perhaps,
upon himself.
But to let his reasoning pass, and come to his fact: which, as a
Critic, he is much more concerned, in honour, to support.—Priscillian
(it seems) was the first sufferer for mere opinion. But how shall we
reconcile him to himself in this matter? for as he goes on to display
* Cecilius, the Pagan, in Minucius Felix, draws the following extraordinary charac-
ter of the genius of the Roman Religion—‘‘ Dum obsessi, et citra solum capitolium
capti, colunt deos, quos alius jam sprevisset iratos—dum captis hostilibus menibus,
adhuce ferociente victoria, numina victa venerantur: dum undique hospites deos querunt,
et suos faciunt: dum aras extruunt etiam ignolis numinibus et manibus, Sic dum
universarum gentium sacra suscipiunt, etiam regna meruerunt.”
PREFACE TO THE EDITION OF 1758. 125
his learning, he unluckily discovers a much earlier original of persecu-
tion for mere opinion than that of the first sufferer, Priscillian : This
was in the holy wars (as he calls them) of the idolatrous Egyptians
(p. 583) : which, according to his own account, were persecutions for
difference of belief alone. Here then we stick, between the first, and
the first of all ;—but not long. He has a fetch to bring us off.
This holy war was indeed persecution in the Egyptians, who dealt
and felt the blows; but it was still ¢oleration, and civil policy in
those, who set them together by the ears: for it was a standing
maxim with the Romans, to support and encourage in the subdued
Provinces, a variety in religious worship ; which occasioning holy wars,
the parties concerned to carry them on with proper decency and zeal
had work enough cut out for them, without forming plots and con-
spiracies against their Masters.” Thus, although, in these fools the
Egyptians, the holy war might be persecution for opinions, yet in the
workmen, who put it to use, it was an engine of state. The Eyyptian
superstition (says our learned Civilian) was rather an engine of state.
Rather than what ?—than persecution. How so, when superstition
made them persecute? No matter for that. It was under the direc-
tion of their Masters: and in their hands it was an engine of state.
It is pity that so great a politician as our Chancellor had not still,
like his predecessors the Chancellors of old, a patent for making these
engines. We know of One who has long lived upon this trade: and
an example of his management may set our Chancellor’s political
refinement in a true light. The Roman Conclave succeeded to the
Roman Senate in this engineering work ; and the later holy wars in
Egypt carried on by their sainted Kings and their imperious Saints,
were contrived and fomented by the Roman Church, as before by the
Roman State, to divert the subject nations from quarrelling with the
sacred See.—But what then? If a spirit of Policy projected it, was
it not a spirit of Superstition that put it in hand? And the point
our learned Civilian is debating, though only with himself, is the
spirit of Pagan Religion, not the spirit of Roman Policy. Now
surely it is a terrible breach in the general indulgence of paganism,
even as he states it, to find holy wars amongst them for difference of
belief alone ; a species of persecution which, in another place, he
expressly tells us, owed its nativity to modern ages.
To say the truth, Persecution is one of the wickedest imps of Hell,
and capable of any mischief: but who would have suspected it of this
trick, played as it were, in its mother’s belly; so long before its
NATIVITY ; and while yet it had scarce got a human being? But the
adventure was, in all respects, extraordinary ; and well deserving the
pen of our illustrious Historian.
Seriously, He seems much: better fitted, whether as Critic or Civi-
126 PREFACE TO THE EDITION OF 1758.
lian, to manage the intrigues of the Greek and Roman Alphabets,
(whose Revolutions make so shining a figure in this splendid Disserta-
tion on the Bacchanals) than to develope the policy of Empires, or to
adjust the rights of civil and religious Societies.
But it is now time to shew, that his hypothesis has as little sup-
port from reason as from fact: and that nocturnal assemblies neither
DID, nor, on our Critic’s own principles, possibly coup, give birth
to Persecution, even though these assemblies had preceded all inter-
ruptions of the civil power.
While the common opinion remained undisputed, that. nocturnal
assemblies were held to avoid persecution, all men saw a sufficient
reason for their practice. But since we have been told, that they
preceded persecution, and were the cause of it, we are utterly at a loss
to account for so extraordinary a mode of worship in the immediate
followers of Christ. For the original of nocturnal assemblies being
now, CHOICE, not NECEssITy, they must be resolved into one or other
of these causes—
1. Hither because true Christianity hath mysterious rites, proper to
be celebrated in the night-time, like the pagan Orgies :
2. Or that the first propagators of the Faith affected to imitate the
dark and enigmatic genius of Paganism :
3. Or that their followers were a set of gloomy Fanatics, who de-
lighted in the horrors of a midnight season :
4. Or lastly, that, like the BaccHANALS (whose story gave birth to
this new hypothesis) they had some very debauched and licentious
practices to conceal, whose celebration was only adapted to the obsce-
nities of night and darkness.
Now, of all these causes, our learned Critic, as a Dispenser of the
doctrine, and a Minister of the discipline of the church, can admit only
the second. He is too well instructed in the nature of the Christian
Religion to allow the first; and hé has too great a regard for the
honour of its early Professors, to suppose it possible to be the ¢hird or
fourth.
He must needs conclude, therefore, that the primitive Christians
went voluntarily into this practice, in imitation of the mysterious rites
of Paganism. On a presumption of the truth of this fact, he must
build his hypothesis—J¢ may be asked (says he) in that almost uni-
versal licence or toleration, which the Ancients, the Romans particu-
larly, extended to the professors of all Religions whatsoever, why the
Christian profession alone, which might have expected a favourable
treatment, seems to stand exempted, and frequently felt the severity
of the bitterest persecution ?—Having asked this, he very magisterially
solves the riddle: They met (says he) with molestations Srom that
quarter, BECAUSE their assemblies were nocturnal.
PREFACE TO THE EDITION OF 1758. 127
What, now, would be the first reflection of a reader, unacquainted
with Greece and Rome? Would he not conclude, that nocturnal
assemblies for religious worship were, till now, unknown in paganism,
and regarded as a prodigy, to be expiated only by capital punishments ?
He would never conceive that mysterious and nocturnal Rites were the
most venerable and sacred part of their worship. But when he is
told that these Christian Assemblies were in imitation of the most
favourite practices of Gentilism, and to conciliate the world’s good
will, he will be lost in wonder, that a modern Critic should pretend to
know better what would appease or irritate the Pagans than the pri-
mitive Church did, which had the best opportunities of distinguishing
in these matters, and was most concerned not to be mistaken. He
will tell our Critic, that if he really aims at the solution of what he
calls a difficulty, he should seek for a cause as uncommon and singular
as the effect. The errect, religious persecution, our Critic himself
tells us, was a thing almost unknown to the pagan world: but the
CAUSE, nocturnal assemblies, was as common and as extensive as
idolatry itself.
—All the various Religions of Paganism, were ever attended with
mysterious rites, which (to keep up a veneration for the worship, and
to create a sacred horror in the Participant) were generally celebrated
in the night. But as this afforded opportunities of private enormi-
ties, as well as ‘of danger to the State, the laws of the best governed
countries, such as Greece, required that foreign Religions, which cele-
brated such rites, should have the previous licence of the magistrate.
Hence we find, that, by a Law of the twelve tables, (an institute com-
posed chiefly from the Grecian laws,) clandestine assemblies held in
the night were punished with death. In course of time, as supersti-
tion abounded, this law was but little observed : for, in the 566th year
of Rome, some spurious rites of Bacchus had crept out of Greece, and
insinuated themselves into the city ; where being celebrated by night,
_ without the knowledge or licence of the Magistrate, they presently
suffered an abominable corruption.* On discovery, they were abo-
lished ; and fresh vigour given to the law of the twelve tables, by a
new regulation for celebrating of nocturnal worship. So cautious
and tender was the Magistrate, (even under this horrid provocation)
of violating the rights of Religion in this capital point of mysterious
worship : nor did the heat of reformation carry him to impinge upon
any other of the nocturnal Rites, then celebrated in Rome ; such as
the Mysteries of the Bona Dea.
Greece and Asia had been long famous for the celebration of this
kind of rites: which, Rome, now masters of the east, brought home
with them ; together with the other arts of Greece, of which, Cicero +
* See “ Divine Legation,” book ii. sect. 6. + De Legibus.
128 PREFACE TO THE EDITION OF 1758.
reckons these of the MysTERIEs in the first class. And thus things
continued in respect to these rites, throughout the whole Roman
Empire, down even to the time of Valentinian ; who, out of zeal for
Christianity, published an edict to abolish the most famous of them
all, the Exeusrn1aAn. But he was diverted from his purpose by his
prudent minister, Preetextatus ; who assured him, that it would drive
Greece and Asia to despair, and endanger the peace of the Empire.*
Such was the state and condition of nocturnal assemblies in the
pagan world: They were of the earliest original ; of the most venera-
ble use; and practised with the fondest attachment. In the very
centre, and during the full celebrity, of these Rites, the Christian
church arose: which, if you will believe our Critic, went into them
with as much spirit and attention as any Gentile Community of them
all. When, strange to tell! the Genius of Paganism, so indulgent to
new forms of Religion, (every one of which had their Mysteries, and
most of them their nocturnal assemblies) all of a sudden turned tail,
and fell foul upon this rising Sect, for a circumstance common to all,
and in a time of full peace and security.
What could occasion so unexpected a reception? Was it any dis-
gust the propLe had entertained to this Christian rite? (for, indeed,
on their passions, the Magistrate is generally obliged to square his
administration.) This could not be ; for the People, (every where the
same) are rarely offended, in religious matters, but with novelties.
What is of common use they receive with indifference ; often with a
favourable prejudice. Our Critic confounds the nature and order of
things, to make Paganism passive and unprovoked at a Principle
which subverted the whole system of their religion, namely, the uNso-
CIABILITY of the Christian Faith ; and yet mortally offended with a
practice the most sacred and universal in Paganism, namely, mysTr-
_RIOUS AND NOCTURNAL RITES.
But it will be said, ‘‘ Some jealousy entertained of this way of wor-
ship, by the MaGisTRATE, might occasion that fiery inquisition: Noc-
turnal assemblies had been abused, and therefore it became him to be
very attentive to every new institution of the like kind.” JHere our
Critic will appeal to his Bacchanalian rites : and, indeed, it seems to
have been this detestable Mummery which first put the fancy into his
head. But this abuse was a single, temporary thing, and had been
long forgotten. Nocturnal assemblies had since that time been prac-
tised, for many ages, without jealousy. Cicero, indeed, in an ideal
Utopia,t had declared against them; but he brings them in, appa-
rently for no other purpose than to stigmatize his mortal enemy
Clodius. And, what is remarkable, he gives not the least intimation
that the abuses of nocturnal assemblies had ever been so general as to
* ZOSIMUS, lib. iv. + De Legibus.
PREFACE TO THE EDITION OF 1758. 129
keep alive the attention or jealousy of the Magistrate: Particulars had
now and then perverted them to the gratification of their lusts ; and
for this, (for want of better evidence) he appeals to the comic poets of
Greece, where indeed some of the Mysteries appear to have undergone
a shameful corruption.
However, let us suppose the state of Rome to be as delicate on this
point as our Critic’s hypothesis requires it to be: Their cireumspec-
tion could never go further than to regulate or to reform these Assem-
blies : it could never proceed to the suppression or abolition of them,
because nocturnal meetings made an essential part of their own
worship.
It is probable, mdeed, that those ridiculous calumnies of the Vul-
gar, concerning the immoralities committed in the nocturnal assem-
blies of the Christians, might reach the ears of the Magistrate : But if
he attended to them, would he not begin his inquiry by examining
into the truth of them, as he had done in the case of the Bacchana-
fian rites? and when he found them as innocent as Pliny the
Younger, on a like examination, reports them to have been, would not
the search have ended here ; and a share of that universal toleration,
which he afforded to others, been imparted to them likewise ?
Our Critic may perhaps say, that these Christians were such lovers
of a secret, that they would not reveal the nature of their rites to the
Pagan Magistrate, though it were to entitle them to his protection.
Should he say this, he would forget the principles I have now forced
him to go upon, which will allow no other reason of the first Chris-
tians’ falling into this practice, than to conciliate the good will of
their Pagan neighbours.
Well, but “there might be some idolatrous Test required to qualify
the Church for its share in this toleration of nocturnal worship ; and,
for non-compliance with the condition” (he may tell us) ‘the persecu-
tion began.” It is, indeed, likely enough that such a Test was
required ; and most probably it consisted in their approbation of the
principle of intercommunity ; if not in words, yet at least in deeds ;
such as throwing a grain or two of incense on the Pagan altars. But
then the mischief of this evasion is, that it brings us round again to
the place from whence the learned Critic set out, when he turned his
back upon the reason given in The Divine Legation for toleration,
and would needs seek a better in nocturnal assemblies.
Hitherto we cannot conceive how a persecution could so much as
begin, from the cause our Critic has assigned. But let us, for argu-
ment’s sake, suppose, that the Magistrate, out of mere caprice (for we
have shewn he could have no reason) and in the plenitude of his
power, would forbid the Christians their nocturnal assemblies, while he
allowed the privilege to all besides: even in this case, his persecution
VOL. 11. K
150 PREFACE TO THE EDITION OF 1758.
must end almost as soon as it was begun: it is impossible, on our
Critic’s own principles, that it should have any continuance : for, as
the choice of nocturnal assemblies was only to reconcile Paganism to
Christianity, when they found their neighbours receive these advances
so ungraciously, they would soon remove the occasion of offence ; in
which they would be quickened by their knowledge of the rights of
the Sovereign, to whom, in things indifferent, they had been told,
all obedience was due.
Thus the matter being turned on all sides, we find that No persecu-
tion whatever could follow from that cause, which our learned Civilian
has assigned for the whole TEN.
But it being certain, that persecuted they were; and as certain,
that our Civilian will admit of no other cause than what he himself
has given, namely, their nocturnal assemblies: Let us for once sup-
pose him to be in the right; and then consider the consequences
which will arise from it. When we have done this, we shall have
done his System full justice ; and the reader, with sufficient know-
ledge of the case, may take or reject it as he finds himself inclined.
HyporuHeses are often very plausible, and much oftener very
flattering things. You shall have of these, so fair and promising,
that an honest reader shall be tempted to wish them, and, from wish-
ing, to think them, true. But this, before us, is by no means in the
number of those specious visions.
I seriously believe it would be doing our Chancellor great injustice,
to suppose he had any other view in this notable discovery than to do
honour to the Christian name: much less should we suspect that he
had any formed design of traducing it. Yet it is very certain, that
neither Couuins nor ΤΊΝΘΑΙ, could have formed a project more inju-
rious to the reputation of primitive Christianity, than to prove, what
is the aim of this learned Critic, that THE FIRST CHRISTIANS WERE
PERSECUTED FOR HOLDING THEIR ASSEMBLIES IN THE NIGHT-
TIME. For it inevitably follows, that these early professors of .the
Faith were either wild Fanatics or abandoned Lispertines: and
consequently, that the Pagan Magistrate did but his duty in inforcing,
what the Church has been so long accustomed to call, a cruel and
unjust persecution.
Before the conception of this new fancy, it was universally sup-
posed, that the primitive Christians assembled in the night-time to
avoid the interruptions of the civil power. This our Critic assures us
is a mistake. It is NoT TRUE (says he); but the converse of the
proposition is true IN THE UTMOST LATITUDE, viz. that they met with
molestation from the civil power BECAUSE their assemblies were
nocturnal, :
While the common opinion prevailed, these nocturnal Assemblies,
PREFACE TO THE EDITION OF 1758. 131
recorded in ancient church-history, gave as little scandal to the
Pagans of our times, as indeed they did to the Pagans of their own.
But when this opinion is given up for the sake of its CONVERSE, we
shall be utterly at a loss to account, to our irreligious Inquisitors, for
so extraordinary a CHOICE in the immediate followers of Christ.
It hath been shewn above, that these veluntary Assemblies could be
wccasioned only by one or other of these causes—either that the
Christian religion hath Mysteries, like the Pagan, which required
nocturnal celebrations—-or that the first preachers of Christianity
affected to imitate the practices of Paganism—or that they were
Fanatics, and delighted in the horrors of a midnight season—or
lastly, that, like the debauched Bacchanals, they had some very licen-
tious Rites to be performed only in the dark.
Our Critic’s religious principles will net allow him to admit of any
ef these causes but the second. And I have shewn that, from the
second, no persecution could arise, or, at least, ceuld continue. This,
on a supposition that the Christians affected to imitate pagan observ-
ances. But it is a supposition which contradicts fact, and violates
the nature of things. The history ef the infant-church informs us,
that the first Propagators of the Faith were most averse to every
thing which bore a shew of conformity to Paganism. They could
not but be so, for their Religion rose out of Judaism, which breathes
nothing but opposition to Idolatry.
In course of time, indeed, when pious zeal, by growing overheated,
became less pure ; when love of pomp and shew (which is natural to
men busied in the external offices of Religion), and the affectation of
importance (which is as natural to those who preside in them), had
spread their leprosy through the Church, the Ministers of the Gospel
would be fatally tempted to rival the magnificence, and to ape the
mysterious air of Paganism. And the obliquities, which led them
into these follies, they would strive to palliate or disguise by a pre-
tended impatience for the speedier extension of the Faith. I have shewn,
from Casaubon, how this corrupt conduct mfected all the language
of Theology.* But this was some ages after the times in question.
Our Critic may perhaps tell us, it was accident or whim which
drew together the first Christians into dark corners; and as_ the
evening and the morning made the first day of the old Creation, so it
was to make the first day of the new: and thus Might, by her proper
Usher, Chance, became once again reinstated in her ancient honours.
But this will stand him in small stead. He has not only to account
for the first threatenings of Persecution, but for the στ; and, what
is still more, for the continuance of it. Now, what the Christians
fell into with so little reason, they would certainly forsake on the
* “Divine Legation,” vol. i. pp. 230, 390.
K 2
132 PREFACE TO THE EDITION OF 1758.
appearance of so great, as the displeasure of the Magistrate, and the
crime and danger of disobeying lawful Authority. It is possible,
indeed, that, in the heat of Persecution, some over zealous men might
mistake their noncompliance with such commands as a necessary
mark of their open profession of the Faith. But this was not gene-
rally the case; Their common practice was to give to Cesar the things
which were Cesar’s ; and to God, the things which were Gods: Of
this, we have sufficient evidence in the famous letter of Pliny the
younger, before quoted. Trajan had forbidden the assemblies called
Heterie, which succeeded those of public worship, and were used by
the Christians of Bithynia, to confirm and bind them to one another
in the practice of virtue, by the external badge or ceremony of dreck-
ing bread ; and we are assured by this vigilant Magistrate, that the
Christians, under his jurisdiction, obeyed the imperial Edict.*
From all this Letter it appears, that the only causes, which, on our
Critic’s principles, could possibly bring on and continue persecution
(if persecution arose from nocturnal or clandestine assemblies), must
be either FANATICISM OR DEBAUCHED PRACTICES: in the first case,
their obstinacy would make them persist; in the other, their lber-
tinage. To these agreeable conclusions, have our learned Civilian’s
principles reduced us for a solution of our difficulties: and such is the
flattering picture he has exhibited of primitive Christianity. Could
its most inveterate enemies desire more! or, if its friends should give
credit to these fancies, would its enemies be content with less? Such
are the disgraces which this converse proposition is ready to. bring
upon Christianity ; disgraces of so complicated a stain, as not simply
to dishonour our holy Faith, but even to justify the powers of Paganism
in all the violences they offered to it. For the Magistrate had a right
to suppress the clandestine meetings of Fanaticism and Debauchery.
But our Enemies will have no need to fly to consequences for the
discharge of the pagan Magistrates; our Christian Chancellor himself
proceeds directly to their acquittal. He frankly tells us, that their
duty, as Magistrates, required them to animadvert on nocturnal assem-
blies, where they bound themselves to one another, and employed the
word SACRAMENTUM for a kind of tessera of union; the very appear-
ance of guilt which had occasioned the decree against the infamous
rites of Bacchus.
You will say, this is horrid, to make the Magistrate prosecute the
primitive Christians by the same provision which obliged him to exter-
minate those monsters of society! But who can help it? Our
Chancellor had but this one precedent for the prosecution of nocturnal
* “ Quod essent soliti stato die ante lucem convenire, carmenque Christo, quasi Deo,
dicere,” &c,_*‘ quibus peractis morem sibi discedendi fuisse, rursusque coé€undi ad capi-
endum cibum, promiscuum tamen et innoxium: quod ipsum facere desiisse post edictum
meum, quo secundum mandata tua heterias esse vetueram.”—Lib. x. ep. 97.
PREFACE TO THE EDITION OF 1758. 133
assemblies ; and if it be not the most honourable support of his
hypothesis, it is not his fault.
But there was no proof (you will say) against the Christian, as
there was against those Bacchanalian assemblies. What of that? -
Our Chancellor opines, that mere suspicion, in so delicate an affair,
was sufficient to acquit the Magistrate of blame: nay, to make his
conduct, in his care and jealousy for the State, very commendable.
You shall have his own words. A jealous Governor, therefore, and a
stranger to the true principles of Christianity, was naturally open to
such impressions ; and COULD NoT BUT exert that caution and atten-
tion which the practice of their Country so warmly recommended.*
Could Cicero himself have been more warm, not to say more elo-
quent, in defending the Decree which dispersed the profligate crew of
Bacchanals ?
And now a very capital point of Ecclesiastical history is cleared up
and settled. ‘The Ten Persecutions were begun and carried on, not,
as had been hitherto supposed, upon the score of Religion, or mere
opinion, but against bad Subjects, or, at least against those who were
reasonably suspected of being such.” And this is given to us by the
learned Critic as the true defence of free and generous Antiquity,
IN ITS PUBLIC CAPACITY: just as in free Britain (where, indeed,
we now find small difference, as to freedom, between its pudlic and its
private capacity, except to the advantage of the latter), when Papists
complain of the penal laws, we reply, They are not enforced against
erroneous Religionists, but against refractory Subjects, for refusing
the Magistrate the common security for obedience.—There is indeed a
difference ; our answer to the Papists is a serious truth ; and our Cri-
tic’s apology for the pagan Persecutors, an idle and ridiculous fiction.
But as if he had not yet done enough for his beloved Antiquity, in
thus blanching its TEN PpERSECUTIONS; he goes on to clear it from
the opprobrium of persecution in general; by charging the original of
this diabolic practice on the Christian Church ; where, indeed, the
Freethinkers had very confidently placed it, till the author of The
Divine Legation restored it to its right owner, the Pagan Magistrate.
—PERSECUTION FOR DIFFERENCE OF BELIEF ALONE, says our
learned Civilian, OWES ITS NATIVITY TO MORE MODERN AGES;
and Spain was its country ; where Priscillian, by some, is held to be
the first sufferer for MERE OPINION.
Thus the whole blame of preRsEcuTION for Religion is thrown
from the Gentile Persecutors, upon the suffering Church : And Chris-
tianity, either for its follies or its crimes (as either insulting civil
Society by its obstinacy, or polluting it by its vices), stands covered
with confusion. So happy an advocate has our learned Civilian
SRO:
154 PREFACE TO THE EDITION OF 1758.
approved himself for the Cause to which, by a double tye, he had
devoted and engaged his ministry.—
The length of these animadversions hindered them from finding a
place in the body of this volume, amongst other things of the like
sort. Except for this, he had no claim to be distinguished from [5
fellows. I had a large choice before me: for who has not signalized
himself against the Divine Lecation? Bigots, Hutchinsonians,
Methodists, Answerers, Freethinkers, and Fanatics, have in their turns
been all up in arms against it. ‘‘ Quid dicam?” (to use the words of
an honest man in the same circumstances.) “Commune fere hoe
eorum fatum est, quorum opera supremum Numen uti vult in Ecclesia,
ut MATURE insidiis, accusationibus et criminationibus appetantur.”
The scene was opened by a false Zealot, and at present seems likely to
be closed by a true Behmenist.* A natural and easy progress, from
knavery to madness, where the imposture fails: as the progress is
from madness to knavery, where it succeeds. It was now time to
settle my accounts with them. ΤῸ this end I applied to a learned
person, who, in consideration of our friendship, hath been prevailed
upon to undergo the drudgery of turning over this dirty heap, and
marking what he imagined would in the least deserve, or could justify
any notice: for I would not have the reader conceive so miserably of
me as to think I was ever disposed to look into them myself. He will
find, as he goes along, both in the text and the notes, what was
thought least unworthy of an answer. Nor let it give him too much
scandal that, in a work which I have now put into as good a condition
for him as 1 was able, I have revived the memory of the numerous
and gross absurdities of these writers, part of whom are dead, and
the rest forgotten: For he will consider, that it may prove an useful
barrier to the return of the like follies, in after-times, against more
successful Inquirers into Truth. The seeds of Folly, as well as Wit,
are connate with the mind: and when, at any time, the teeming
intellect gives promise of an unexpected harvest, the trash starts up
with it, and is ever forward to wind itself about rising Truth, and
hinder its progress to maturity. Were it not for this, I should refer
the candid reader to what I take to be the best defence and support
of the ARGUMENT OF THE Divine ΠΈΘΑΤΙΟΝ, the succinct view of
the whole and all its parts, which he will find at the conclusion of the
last of these volumes.t For, as Lord Verulam says excellently well :
THE HARMONY OF A SCIENCE, SUPPORTING EACH PART THE
OTHER, IS, AND OUGHT TO BE, THE TRUE AND BRIEF CONFU-
TATION AND SUPPRESSION OF ALL THE SMALLER SORTS OF
OBJECTIONS.
* Rey. Mr. William Law. + Vol, iti. of this edition.
THE DIVINE LEGATION OF MOSES
DEMONSTRATED.
BOOKS IV. V. VI.
AMOKAATYON TOTS OPOAAMOTS MOY KAI
KATANOH32 TA ΘΑΥΜΑΣΙΑ EK TOT NOMOY SOY.—PSAL.
THE
DIVINE LEGATION OF MOSES
DEMONSTRATED.
BOOK IV.
SECTION I.
Tue foregoing Volume* hath occasionally, and in the course of my
main argument, shewn the reader, that it was always the practice of
mankind to listen to, and embrace some pretended RevELATION ; in
neglect of what is called, in contradistinction to it, the RELIGION OF
Nature ; that, I mean, which is only founded on our relation to the
first Cause ; and deducible from the eternal reason of things.t
If ever a general propensity might be called a dictate of Nature,
this surely may. That such a propensity there is, the Deist, or
pretended follower of natural Religion, freely confesseth, nay, is
forward to insist upon, as a circumstance of discredit to those Revela-
tions, which we receive for true. Yet surely, of all his visionary advan-
tages, none ever afforded him less cause of triumph; a consequence
flowing from it, which is entirely subversive of his whole scheme.
For let me ask such a one, What could be the cause of so universal
a propensity in all ages, places, and people? But before he answer,
let him see that he be able to distinguish between the causes which
the Few had in giving, and the Many in receiving, pretended Revela-
tions. The causes for projecting and giving are explained at large in
the former volume ; where it is shewn, that all the pretended Revela-
tions, but real corruptions of religion, came from Princes and Law-
givers. It is true, he hath been taught otherwise. His instructors,
the Tolands and Tindals of the time, assure him, that all came from
* Books i, ii. iii, t+ Σὺ δὲ τὸν λόγον ἐξ ἀρχῆς ἀναλαβὼν τῆς δεισιδαίμονος
παλάνης, ἐπίσκεψαι τὴν διάπτωσιν" φύσει μὲν οὖν καὶ αὐτοδιδάκτοις ἐννοίαις, μᾶλλον δὲ
Νεοδιδάκτοις, καλόν τι καὶ ὠφέλιμον τυγχάνειν, τὸ σημαῖνον τὴς τοῦ ϑεοῦ wpoonyopiay
τε καὶ οὐσίαν. waytes γὰρ ἄνθρωποι κοινοῖς λογισμοῖς ποροειλήφεσαν, τοῦ τῶν ὅλων
Δημιουργοῦ, τοῦτο τσάσῃ λογικῇ καὶ νοερᾷ ψυχῇ, φυσικαῖς ἐννοίαις ὑποσπείραντος" οὐ μὴν
καὶ τῇ Wpoopéser τῇ κατὰ λόγον ἐκέχρηντο.--- ΕὐδΕΒιι Prap. Evang. lib. ii. cap. 6,
edit. Steph. pp. 45, 46,
138 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
the priests ; and I suppose they spoke what they believed: It might
be so, for any thing they knew.
My question then is, What could induce Mankind to embrace these
offered Revelations, unless it were,
1. Either a Consciousness, that they wanted a revealed Will for
the rule of their actions ; or,
2. An old TrapiTi0Nn, that God had vouchsafed it to their fore-
fathers ?
One can hardly conceive any thing else; for a general effect must
have as general a cause: which, in this case, is only to be found in
the nature of man; or in a fradition preserved in the whole race.
Prince-craft or priest-craft might indeed offer them, for their own
private ends: but nothing short of a common inducement could
dispose mankind to accept them.
1. As to the consciousness of the want of a Revelation, that may
fairly be inferred from the miserable blindness of our condition: And
he who wants to be informed of this, should consult Antiquity ; or,
what may be more for his ease, those modern writers, who, for no
very good ends, but yet to a very good issue, have drawn such lively
pictures of it, from thence. But without going even so far, he may
find, in the very disposition to receive such absurd schemes of religion
as Revelations from heaven, more than a thousand other arguments to
prove men ignorant of the first principles of natural religion ; a very
moderate knowledge of which would have certainly detected the
imposture of those pretences. But now, men so totally at a loss for
a rule of life, would greedily embrace any direction that came with
pretended credentials from heaven.
If we turn to the Few, the wise and learned amongst them, we
shall find the case still more desperate. In religious matters, these
were blinder even than the People; and in proportion too, as they
were less conscious of their ignorance. The most advanced in the
knowledge of human nature and its dependencies, were, without ques-
tion, the ancient Sages of Greece. Of these, the wisest, and far the
wisest, was Socrates ; for he saw and confessed his ignorance, and
deplored the want of a superior direction. For the rest, who thought
themselves wise, and appeared not so sensibly to feel their wants, we
have shewn at large,* how they became Fools; and, debauched by
false science, affected the language of Gods before they had well
emancipated themselves from the condition of brutes.t The two
great supports of natural religion, in the world at large, are the belief
of a FUTURE STATE, and the knowledge of MORAL OBLIGATION.
The first was rejected by all; and the true ground of the second was
* Book iii. sections 2—5. + The Stoics, who thought the soul mortal, yet
reckoned their wise man equal, or superior, to the gods.
λ
SEC.) dor OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 139
understood by none: The honour of this discovery was reserved for
Revelation, which teacheth us, in spite of unwilling hearers, that the
real ground of moral obligation is the will of God.
2. There only remains that other possible cause, the general tradi-
tion of God’s early revelation of his will to mankind, as delivered in
Scripture. I, for my part, suppose both concerned im the effect ; and
that that state of mind which disposed men to so ready and general a
reception of these numerous impostures, was the result of the con-
sciousness of their wants, joined to the prejudice of Tradition. If the
Deist allow Tradition, he gives up the question ; if he acknowledge
our wants, he affords a strong presumption, in favour of Revelation.
For if man (let the cause proceed from what it will) be so irre-
coverably blind and helpless, it is highly reasonable to think that
Infinite Goodness would lead and enlighten him by an extraordinary
revelation of his will.
But here, Tindal objects, ‘“‘ That this blindness is men’s own fault,
who, instead of improving their reason, and following its dictates,
which would lead them into all truth (our own Scriptures assuring
us, that that which may be known of God is manifest in them; for
God hath shewed it unto them),* go on like beasts, and follow one
another as they are led or driven.”
To this I answer, that what had been the lot of man from the
beginning of the world to the birth of Curist, was like to continue
so to the end of it. A deviation springing from no partial cause of
climate, government, or age; but the sad effect of human weakness
in the circumstance of our earthly situation.—By the fault of man, it
is true; but such a fault as, it is seen by long experience, man could
never remedy. He therefore flies to Heaven for relief ; and seems to
have reason for his confidence.
But to this, our man of morals has a reply at hand ; ““ That if such
be our condition, it may indeed want redress ; but then, a Revelation
will not render the cure lasting.’ And for this he appeals to the
corrupt state of the Christian world ; which, in his opinion, seems to
demand a new Revelation, to restore the virtue and efficacy of the old.
But let me tell this vain Rationalist, There is an extreme difference
between the corruption of the Pagan and the Christian world. In the
Pagan, where false Revelations had given men wrong ideas of the
attributes of the Deity, they must of course, and did in fact, act
viciously UPON PRINCIPLE ΣΤ a condition of blindness which seemed
* Rom. i. 19, 20. + See “ Divine Legation,” book ii. sect. 5.—Thv φύσιν Svnrovs
καὶ ἀνθρωπίναις κεχρημένους συμφοραῖς, ὡς ἀγαθῶν χορηγοὺς, σωτῆρας Kal Seovs avaryo-
ρεύειν, τὴν σεδάσμιον ἔννοιαν φυσικῶς αὐτοῖς ἐνυπάρχουσαν, ep ods ἐνόμιζον εὐεργέτας
μετατεθεικότες. Τοσαύτη δ᾽ ἄρα συνεῖχεν αὐτοὺς φρενῶν ἀποπληξία, ὡς μηδὲν τῶν τσλημ-
μελουμένων τοῖς ϑεολογουμένοις ὑπολογίζεσθαι" μηδ᾽ ἐρυθριᾷν ἐπὶ τοῖς αἰσχρῶς wept
αὐτῶν φημιζομένοις, τὰ τυάντα δὲ τοὺς ἄνδρας διὰ τὰς Wap αὐτῶν ττωαρεχομένας ὠφε-
140 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
to call out on God’s goodness for a remedy: but in the Christian
world, for the very contrary reason, all wicked men act ill AGAINST
PRINCIPLE ; a condition of perverseness which seems to call out for
nothing but his justice: God, according to the state of the case,
having done every thing that man, with all his presumption, can
pretend to expect from the goodness of his Maker.
So far on the Deist’s own principles ; on his own false notion that
God’s Revelation is represented in Scripture to be merely a republica-
tion of the religion of nature. For, as such he has presumed to
comment on it; and as such, in excess of complaisance, we believers
have generally thought fit to receive it. But I shall, ere long, shew
it to be a very different thing: and, from its true nature, prove not
only (as here) the use of Revelation, but likewise the absolute necessity
of it, to mankind. I shall shew that what our adversaries suppose
the only, was but the secondary end of the two Revelations; that
what was primary and peculiar to them, as Revelations, was of such a
nature as the utmost perversity of man could not, in any degree,
defeat ; of such a nature as manifests there must needs be these
Revelations ; and that to expect more, or further, would not only be
unreasonable, but absurd.*
At present, to go on with the Deist in his own way. From what
hath been said, we see a strong presumption, that God hath indeed
communicated his will to mankind in that extraordinary way we call
REVELATION,
And now, that amazing number of false religions, under paganism,
begins to appear less formidable and injurious to the ¢rue. It was on
a presumption they would prove so, that, in a foregoing volume, they
were drawn out in review, with each its false Prophet at its head.+
And here at last they are employed, wicked instruments as they were,
and wickedly as they have been abused in dishonouring truth, to
evince the high probability of God’s having actually given a revelation
of his will to mankind.
If, therefore, there be such a thing as true revelation, our highest
interests will engage us in the search of it: and we shall want no
encouragement to proceed, because it must needs have some charac-
teristic mark to distinguish it from the false. And this mark must be
our guide.
λείας, ἢ kal διὰ Tas τότε τυρῶτον συνισταμένας δυναστείας τε καὶ τυραννίδας ἀποθαυ-
μάζειν' νόμων γοῦν, ὥσπερ ἔφην, ἤδη wpdrepoy μηδέπω τότε ἐν ἀνθρώποις τσολιτευομένων,
μηδ᾽ ἐπὶ τοῖς ἁμαρτανομένοις ἁμαρτίας [τιμωρία5] ἀπῃωρημένης, μοιχείας καὶ ἀῤῥένων
φθορὰς, ἐκθέσμους τε καὶ wapayduous γάμους, μιαιφονίας τε καὶ τσατροκτονίας, τίκνων τε
καὶ ἀδελφῶν σφαγὰς, καὶ μὴν καὶ ττολέμους καὶ στάσεις τσεπραγμένας ὄντως τοῖς οἰκείοις
ποροστάταις, ods ϑεοὺς ἡγοῦντό τε καὶ ἀπεκάλουν, ὥσπερ ἐν μέρει κατορθωμάτων καὶ
ἀνδραγαθίας ἀπεμνημόνευον, τὴν τούτων μνήμην ὡς σεμνῶν καὶ ἀνδρείων τοῖς ὀψιγόνοις
ἀπολιπόντες.-- ἘΒΕΒΙΙ Prap. Evang. lib. ii. cap. 6, edit. Steph. p. 46.
* See book ix. and, in the mean time, “(Sermons on the Principles of Natural and
Revealed Religion,” serm, y. yol. ix. + See book ii, sect. 2.
SECT. 1. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 141
Now if we look round the ancient world, and take a view of the
numerous religions of paganism, we shall find (notwithstanding all
pretended to be original, and all were actually independent) so perfect
a harmony in their genius, and conformity in their ministrations, as
to the object, subject, and end of religious worship,* that we must
needs conclude them to be all false, or all true. All true they could
not be, because they contradicted one another, in matters of practice
and speculation, professed to be revealed.
But amongst this prodigious number of pretended revelations, we
find oN, in an obscure corner of the globe, inhabited by a single
family, so fundamentally opposite to all the other institutions of man-
kind, as would tempt us to conclude we have here found what we
search after.
The many particulars in which this religion differed from all others,
will be occasionally explained as we go along. For, as our subject
forced us, in the former volume, to draw into view those marks of
agreement which the false had with true revelation; so the same
subject brings us now to the more pleasing task of shewing wherein
the true differed from the false. To our present purpose it will be
sufficient to take notice only of that primary and capital mark of
distinction, which differenced Jupatsm from all the rest; and this
was its pretending TO COME FROM THE FIRST CAUSE OF ALL
THINGS ; AND ITS CONDEMNING EVERY OTHER RELIGION FOR AN
IMPOSTURE.
I. Not one of all that numerous rabble of revelations, ever pre-
tended to come from the rirst CAuse,+ or taught the worship of the
one God in their pusiic ministrations.t So true is that which
Eusebius observes from Scripture, that “for the Hebrew people alone
was reserved the honour of being initiated into the knowledge of God
the Creator of all things, and of being instructed in the practice of
true piety towards him.”§ I said, in their public ministrations, for
we have seen it was taught in their mysteries to a few ; and to their
mysteries, it is remarkable, the learned Father alludes ; who opposeth
the case of the Hebrews, to the Pagans ;|| where a small and select
number only was initiated into the knowledge of the Creator; but in
Judea, a whole people.
II. That the Hebrews were as singular, in condemning all other
religions .of imposture, as in publicly worshipping one God, the
Creator, hath been shewn in the former volume.
There is nothing more surprising in all Pagan Antiquity, than that,
amidst their endless Revelations, not one of them should ever pretend
* See “ Divine Legation,” book ii. sect. 1, 2, 5, 6, and book iii. sect. 4. ¢ Ibid.
book ii. sect. 2. t See note A, at the end of this book. § See note B, at
the end of this book. || See ““ Divine Legation,’’ vol. i. pp. 211 and 386.
142 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Ive
to come from the rirst Cause of all things ; or should condemn the
rest of falshood: And yet there is nothing which modern writers are
more accustomed to pass over without reflection. But the ancient
Fathers, who were more intimately acquainted with the state of
paganism, seem to have regarded it with the attention that so extra-
ordinary a circumstance deserves : and I apprehend, it was no other
than the difficulty of accounting for it, which made them recur so
generally, as they do, to the agency of the prvii: for I must beg
leave to assure certain modern rectifiers of prejudices, that the Fathers
are not commonly led away by a vain superstition ; as they affect to
represent them: so that when these venerable writers unanimously
concurred in thinking, that the devil had a great share in the intro-
duction and support of pagan revelation, I imagine they were led to
this conclusion from such like considerations as these,—That had
these impostures been the sole agency of men, it is inconceivable that
no one false prophet, no one speculative philosopher, of all those who
regulated states, were well acquainted with the first Cause, and
affected singularities and refinement, should ever have pretended to
receive his Revelations from the only true God; or have accused the
rest of falshood: A thing so very natural for some or other of them
to have done, were it but to advance their own religion, in point of
truth or origin, above the rest. On the contrary, so averse were they
to any thing of this management, that those who pretended to inspi-
rations even from JUPITER, never considered him, as he was often
considered by particulars, in the sense of the Creator of all things ;
but as the local tutelar Jupiter, of Crete, for instance, or Libya.
Again, those who pretended to the best system of religion, meant not
the best simply; but the best for their own peculiar community.”
This, if a supernatural agency be excluded, seemed utterly unaccount-
able. But admitting the Devil to his share, a very good reason
might be assigned: for it is certain, the suffermg his agents to
pretend inspiration from the first Cause would have greatly endan-
gered idolatry ; and the suffering any of them to condemn the rest of
falshood, would (by setting men upon enquiry and examination)
have soon put a stop to the unbounded progress of it.
Thus, I suppose, the Fathers reasoned: and I believe our Free-
thinkers, with all their logic, would find it somewhat difficult to shew
that they reasoned ill.
But as we have made it our business, all along, to enquire into the
NATURAL causes of paganism, in all its amazing appearances, we shall
go on, in the same way, to see what may be assigned for this most
amazing of all.
1. First then, the FALSE PROPHET and POLITICIAN, who formerly
* See ‘* Divine Legation,” book ii. sect. 6.
SECT. I. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 143
cheated under one and the same person,* found it necessary, in his
character of Prophet, to pretend inspiration from the God most
reverenced by the people; and this God was generally one of their
dead ancestors, or citizens, whose services to the community had
procured him divine honours ;+ and who was, of course, a local
tutelary Deity. In his character of Politician, he thought it of
importance to have the national worship paid to the Founder of the
Society, or to the father of the Tribe: for a God, who had them in
peculiar, suited the gross conceptions of the people much better than
a common Deity at large. But this practice gave birth to two princi-
ples, which prevented any opening for a pretended intercourse with
the one God, the Creator. 1. The first was, an opinion of their
DIVINES, that the supreme God did not immediately concern himself
with the government of the world, but left it to local tutelary deities,
his vicegerents.t 2. The second, an opinion of their LAWGIVERS,
that it would be of fatal consequence to Society, to discover the first
Cause of all things to the people.§
2. But secondly, that which one would imagine should have
brought the one God, the Creator, to the knowledge of the world, in
some public Institution of religion, namely, his being taught to so
many in the Mysteries, and particularly to all who pretended to reve-
lation and lawgiving,\| was the very thing that kept him unknown ;
because all who came to the knowledge of him this way, had it com-
municated to them under the most religious seal of secrecy.
3. Now, while the first Cause of all things was rejected or
unknown, and nothing professed in the public worship but local
tutelary Deities, each of which had his own appointment, and little
concerned himself in that of another’s, no one religion could accuse
the other of falshood, because they all stood upon the same founda-
tion.
How far this may account, in a natural way, for the matter in
question, is submitted to the judgment of the learned.
Here then we rest. An essential difference between the JEwisH
and all other religions is now found: the very mark we wanted, to
discriminate the true from the false.
As for any marks of resemblance in matters circumstantial, this
will give us no manner of concern. The shame of this allegation
must lie with the Deist, who can, in conscience, bring it into account,
for the equal falshood of them both ; seeing, were the Jewish (as we
pretend) true, and the Pagan false, that very resemblance must still
remain. For what, I pray, is a false religion, but the counterfeit of a
true? And what is it to counterfeit, but to assume the likeness of
* “Divine Legation,’ book ii. sect. 2. { Ibid. sect. 1. t 1014. $ Ibid
sect. 4. \| Ibid. Ε
144 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
the thing usurped? In good earnest, an Impostor, without one single
feature of truth, would be a rarity even amongst monsters.
SECTION II.
Bor the business of this Work is not probability but DEMONSTRA-
TION. ‘This, therefore, only by the way, and to lead us the more
easily into the main road of our enquiry: for the reader now sees we
are pursuing no desperate adventure, while we endeavour to deduce
the divinity of Mosrs’s Law, from the circumstances of the Law
itself.
I go on with my proposed demonstration.
Having proved in the foregoing volume the first and second propo-
sitions—That the inculcating the doctrine of a future state of rewards
and punishments is necessary to the well-being of civil Society ;—and,
That all mankind, especially the most wise and learned nations of
antiquity, have concurred in believing and teaching that this doctrine
was of such use to civil Society :—I come, in this, to the third,
THAT THE DOCTRINE OF A FUTURE STATE OF REWARDS AND
PUNISHMENTS 15 NOT TO BE FOUND IN, NOR DID MAKE
PART OF, THE MOSAIC DISPENSATION.
Now as, in support of the two first Propositions, I was forced to
make my way through the long chicane of Atheism and Freethinking ;
so in defence of the third, I shall have the much harder fortune of
finding Adversaries in the quarter of our Friends: for it hath hap-
pened unluckily, that mistaken conceptions of the JewisH and of the
CurisTIAN Dispensations, have made some advocates of Revelation
always unwilling to confess the truth which I here endeavour to
establish ; and a late revived despicable whimsy concerning the
sadducism of the Hebrews, hath now violently inclined them to
oppose it.
A man less fond of ταύτη, and equally attached to RELIGION,
would have here stopt short, and ventured no further in a road where
he must so frequently suffer the displeasure of forsaking those he
most agrees with ; and the much greater mortification of appearing to
go along with those he most differs from. I have often asked myself,
What I had to do, to invent new arguments for Religion, when the
old ones had outlived so many generations of this mortal race of
infidels and freethinkers? Why I did not rather chuse the high road
of literary honours, and pick out some poor critic or small philoso-
pher of this school, to offer up at the shrine of violated sense and
virtue? Things that might be exposed to their deserved contempt on
any principles ; or indeed without any: I might then have flourished
in the favour of my superiors, and the good-will of all my brethren.
But the love of ταύτη breaks all my measures : Imperiosa trahit
SECTS iil, OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 145
veritas ; and Iam once more borne away in the deep and troubled
torrent of Antiquity.
These various prejudices above mentioned oblige me therefore to
prove the third Proposition, in the same circumstantial manner |
proved the first and second: and this will require a previous explana-
tion of the MOSAIC POLICY.
But to form a right idea of that Institution, it will be necessary to
know the genius and manners of the HEBREW PEOPLE; though it
be, as we conceive, of divine appointment: and still more necessary
to understand the character and abilities of their LAWGIVER, if it be,
as our adversaries pretend, only of human.
Now as the Hebrews, on receiving their LAw, were but just come
from a strange country, the land of Eayrr; where the people had
been held in slavery and oppression ; and their Leader bred at court,
and instructed in all the learning of their colieges ; it could not but
be, that the genius and manners of both would receive a high tincture
from these with whom they had so long, and in such different sta-
tions, conversed: And in fact, holy Scripture assures us, that Moses
was conversant in all the wisdom, and the IsraELites besotted with
ail the whoredoms or idolatries, of Egypt.
It will be of importance therefore to know the state of suprRsTI-
TION and LEARNING in Egypt during these early ages.
This, as it is a necessary, so one would think, should be no difficult
enquiry ; for it is natural to suppose, that the same Scripture which
tells us, that the Lawgiver and his people brought their wisdom and
superstitions from Egypt, would tell us also what that wisdom and
what those superstitions were. And so indeed it does; as will be
seen in due time: Yet, by ill fortune, the fact stands, at present, so
precarious, as to need much pains, and many words, to make it
owned. Divines, it is confessed, seem to allow the testimony of
Stephen and Ezekiel, who, under the very impulse of inspiration, say
that Mosxs was learned in ail the wisdom, and the people devoted to
all the superstitions of Egypt ; yet, when they come to explain that
learning, they make it to consist in such fopperies, as a wise and
honest man, like Mosxs, would never practise: when they come to
particularize those superstitions, they will not allow even the Golden
Calf, the ὁ MOSXOS οὗτος 6 "ATIIS καλεόμενος, Ἐ to be of their
number. For by an odd chance, though not uncommon in blind
βου 165, the infidels and we have changed weapons: Our enemies
attack us with the Bible, te prove the Egyptians very learned and
very superstitious in the time of Meses; and we defend ourselves
with the new Chronology of Sir Isaac Newton, to prove them very
barbarous and very imnocent.
* Heroporvus, lib. iii. cap, 28,
VOL. Il. L
146 THE DIVINE LEGATION Saeed
Would the reader know how this came about ; it was in this wise:
The infidels had observed (as who that ever looked into sacred and
profane Antiquity hath not?) that in the Jewish Law there were
many ordinances respective of the institutions of Egypt. This cir-
cumstance they seized; and, according to their custom, envenomed ;
by drawing from thence a conclusion against The Divine Legation of
Moses. The defenders of Revelation, surprised with the novelty of
the argument, did that, in a fright and in excess of caution, which
one may observe unprepared disputants generally do, to support their
opinions ; that is, they chose rather to deny the premisses than the
concLusion. For such, not knowing to what their adversary’s prin-
ciples may lead, think it a point of prudence to stop him in his first
advance : whereas the skilful disputant well knows, that he never has
his enemy at more advantage, than when, by allowing the premisses,
he shews him arguing wrong from his own principles ; for the ques-
tion being then to be decided by the certain rules of logic, his confu-
tation exposes the weakness of the advocate as well as of the cause.
When this is over, he may turn with a good grace upon the pre-
misses ; to expose them, if false ; to rectify them, if misrepresented ;
or to employ them in the service of Religion, if truly and faithfully
delivered: and this service they will never refuse him ; as I shall
shew in the previous question of the high antiquity of Egypt, and m
the main question of the omission of a future state in the institution
of the Hebrews.
And I am well persuaded that, had those excellent advocates of
Religion (whose labours have set the truth in a light not to be
resisted) but duly weighed the character of those with whom they had
to do, they would have been less startled at any consequences the
power of their logic could have deduced. The Tolands, the Blounts,
the Tindals, are, in truth, of a temper and complexion, in which
one finds more of that quality which subjects men to draw wrong
Conclusions, than of that which enables them to invent false Principles.
The excellent Spencer, indeed, endeavoured to dissipate this
panic, by shewing these premisses to be the true key to the REASON
oF THE LAW; for the want of a sufficient reason in the ceremonial
and positive part of it, was the greatest objection, which thinking
men had, to the divinity of its original.
But all this did not yet reconcile men to those premisses. It
would seem as if they had another quarrel with them, besides the
poor unlearned fear of their leading to the infidel’s conclusion ;
namely, for their being an adversary’s principle simply ; and, on that
score alone to be disputed. This is a perverse, though common
prejudice, which infects our whole communication ; and hath hurt
unity in the chureh, and humanity in civil life, as well as peace in
SECT. 1. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 147
the schools. For who knows not that the same impotent aversion to
things abused by an enemy, hath made one sort of sectaries divide
from the national church, and another reprobate the most indifferent
manners of their country ? *
And it is te be observed, that till that unlucky time when the
infidels first blundered upon truth, this principle met with a very
general reception: the ancient Fathers, and modern Divines of all
denominations, concurring in their use of it, to illustrate the wisdom
of God’s Laws, and the truth of his Son’s interpretation of them,
where he assureth us that they were given to the Hebrews for the
hardness of their hearts ; no sort of men sticking out, but a few
visionary Jews, who, besotted with the nonsense of their cabbala,
obstinately shut their eyes against all the light which the excellent
Maimonrpss had first poured into this palpable obscure.
Not that I would be understood as admitting the premisses in the
jatitude in which our adversaries deliver them ;
fiacos intra muros peccatur et extra.
The human mind, miserably weak and instable, and distracted with
a great variety of objects, is naturally inclined to repose itself in
SYSTEM ; nothing being more uneasy to us than a state of doubt ; or
a view too large for our comprehension. Hence we see, that, of every
imaginary fact, some or other have made an hypothesis; of every
cloud, a castle: And the common vice of these castle-builders is te
draw every thing within its precincts, which they faney may contri-
bute to its defence or embellishment. We have given an instance, in
the foregoing beok, of the folly of those who have run into the con-
trary extreme, and are for deriving ail arts, laws and religions, from
the People of God: an extravagance at length come to such a height,
that, if you will believe certain writers,t the poor heathen had neither
the grace to kneel to prayers, nor the wit to put their Gods under
cover, till the Israelites taught them the way. But our wise adver-
saries are even with them; and will bate no believer an inch, in
driving en an hypothesis: for had not the Egyptians, by great good
tuck, as they give us to understand,t enjoined honowr fo parents, and
restrained theft by punishment, the Jews had been in a sad blind
condition when they came to take possession of the promised land.
Are these men more sober in their accounts of the religious Insti-
tutions of the Hebrews? J think not; when they pretend to prove
circumeision of Egyptian original from the testimony of late writers,
who neither speak to the point, nor in this point are in reason to be
regarded, if they did.§
* Puritans, Quakers, &c. t+ See note C, at the end of this book. - Ϊ See
Manrspam’s Canon Chron. ed. Franeq. pp. 177, 188. § See note D, at the end
of this book.
Te
148 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
But why all this strife for or against the one or other hypothesis ?
for assuredly it would no more follow, from this of our adversaries,
that the Jewish Religion was false, than from a lately revived one of
our friends, which supposes all the Gods of Egypt to have come out
of Abraham’s family,* that the Egyptian was true.
It must indeed be of use to true religion, where or whatever it be,,
to trace up things to their original: and for that .reason alone, with-
out any views to party, I shall endeavour to prove the four following
propositions.
1. That the Egyptian learning, celebrated in Scripture, and the
Egyptian superstition there condemned, were the very learning and
superstition represented by the Greek writers, as the honour and
opprobrium of that Kingdom.
2. That the Jewish people were extremely fond of Egyptian
manners, and did frequently fall into Egyptian superstitions: and
that many of the laws given to them by the ministry of Moses, were
instituted, partly in compliance to their prejudices, and partly in
opposition to those superstitions.
3. That Moses’s Egyptian learning, and the laws he instituted in
compliance to the people’s prejudices, and in opposition to Egyptian
superstitions, are no reasonable objection to the divinity of his
mission. And,
4. That those very circumstances are a strong confirmation of the
truth of his pretensions.
The inquiry, into which the proof of these points will lead us, is,
as we said, very necessary to the gaining a true idea of the nature of
the Jewish Dispensation : as that idea will enable the reader to form a
right judgment of the force of those arguments, I am preparing for
the support of my THIRD ΡΕΟΡΟΒΊΤΙΟΝ, That the doctrine of a
Suture state is not to be found in, nor did make part of, the Jewish
Dispensation. But the enquiry has still a further use. I shall
employ the result of it to strengthen that general conclusion, THAT
Moses HAD REALLY A DIVINE Mission, which I have promised to
deduce through the medium of this third proposition: so that the
reader must not think me in the humour to trifle with him, if this
enquiry should prove longer than he expected.
And here, on the entrance, it will be no improper place to explain
my meaning, when, in my first setting out, I promised to demon-
strate the truth of the Jewish revelation, ON THE PRINCIPLES OF A
RELIGIOUS DEIST. Had I meant no more by this, than that I would
argue with him on common principles, I had only insulted the
reader’s understanding by an affected expression, while I pretended
to make that peculiar to my defence, which is, or ought to be, a cir-
* Voyez Refevions Critiques sur les Histo!res des Anciens Peuples.
SECT. III. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 149
cumstanee common to all: or had I meant so much by it, as to
imply, that I would argue with the Deist on his own false principles,
I had then unreasonably bespoke the reader’s long attention to a
mere argument ad hominem, which, at best, had only proved the
free-thinker a bad reasoner; and who wants to be convinced of that ?
but my point was not so much to shew that the Infidel was in the
wrong, as that the Believer was in the right. The only remaining
sense then of the Deist’s own principles is this, Those true principles
of his, which because they are generally held by the enemies of Reli-
gion, and almost as generally rejected by the friends of it, have got
the title of deistical principles. Such, for instance, as this 1 am
going upon, the high antiquity of the Egyptian wisdom ; and such as
that, for the sake of which I go upon it, the omission of the doc-
trine of a future state in the Mosaic dispensation. And these are
the principles by which I promise, in good time, to overturn all his
conclusions.
SECTION III.
Tue first proposition is,—That the Egyptian learning, celebrated
in Scripture, and the Egyptian superstition there condemned, were the
very learning and superstition represented by the Greek writers as the
honour and opprobrium of that kingdom.
To prove this, I shall in the first place shew (both by external and
internal evidence) the just pretensions which Egypt had to a supe-
rior antiquity: and then examine the new hypothesis of Sir Isaac
NEwTON against that antiquity.
It is confessed on all hands, that the Greek writers concur in
representing Egypt as one of the most ancient and powerful monar-
chies in the world. In support of what they deliver, we may observe,
that they have given a very particular account of the civil and reli-
gious customs in use from the most early times of memory : customs
of such a kind, as shew the followers of them to have been most
polite and powerful.—Thus stands the Grecian evidence.
But to this it may be replied, that the Greeks are, in all respects,
incompetent witnesses, and carry with them such imperfections as are
sufficient to discredit any evidence ; being, indeed, very ignorant, and
very prejudiced. As this made them lable to imposition ; so falling,
as we shall see, into ill hands, they actually were imposed on.
Their ignorance may be fairly collected from their age ; and from
the authors of their intelligence. They all lived long after the times
in question ; and, though they received indeed their information from
Egypt itself; yet, for the most part, it was not till after the entire
destruction of that ancient empire, and when it was now become a
province, in succession, to Asiatic and European conquerors: when
150 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv,
their ancient and public records were destroyed; and their very
learning and genius changed to a conformity with their Grecian
masters, who would needs, at this time of day, seek wisdom from
Egypt, which could but furnish them with their own; though,
because they would have it so, disguised under the stately obscurity
of an Eastern cover.*
Nor were their prejudices less notorious. They thought themselves
Autocthones, the original inhabitants of the earth, and indebted to
none for their advantages. But when knowledge and acquaintance
with foreign nations had convinced them of their mistake ; and that,
so far from owing nothing to others, they owed almost every thing
to Egypt ; their writers, still true to their natural vanity, now gave
the post of honour to these, which they could no longer keep to
themselves ; and complimented their new instructors with the most
extravagant antiquity. What the Greeks conceived out of vain-glory,
the Egyptians cherished to promote a trade. This country was long
the mart of knowledge for the Eastern and Western world: and as
nothing so much recommends this kind of commodity as its age, they
set it off by forged records, which extended their history to a most
unreasonable length of time: accounts ef these have been conveyed
to us by ancient authors, and fully confuted by the modern. Thus
stands the objection to the Grecian evidence. And, though I have no
business to determine in this question, as the use I make of the
Greek authority is not at all affected by it; yet I must needs confess
that, were there no writings of higher antiquity to confirm the
Grecian, their testimony would be very doubtful: but, could writings
of much higher antiquity be found to contradict it, they would
deserve to have no credit at all.
Whatever therefore they say of the high antiquity of Egypt,
unsupported by the reason of the thing, or the testimony of holy
Scripture, shall never be employed in this enquiry; but whatever
Reason and Scripture seem to contradict, whether it serve the one or
other purpose, I shall always totally reject.
The unanimous. agreement of the Greek writers in representing
Egypt as the most ancient and best policied empire in the world, is,
as we say, generally known and acknowledged.
I. Let us see then, in the first place, what REASON says concern-
ing this matter.
There is, if 1 be not much mistaken, one circumstance in the
situation of Egypt, which seems to assert its claim to a priority
amongst the civilized Nations ; and consequently to its eldership in
Arts and Arms,
There is no soil on the face of the globe so fertile but what, in a
* See “ Divine Legation,” book iii, sect. 4.
SECT. III. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 151
little time, becomes naturally effete by pasturage and tillage. This,
in the early ages of the world, forced the unsettled tribes of men to
be perpetually shifting their abode. For the world lying all before
them, they saw a speedier and easier relief in removing to fresh
ground, than in turning their thoughts to the recovery * of the
fertility of that already spent by occupation : for it is necessity alone,
to which we are indebted for all the artificial methods of supplying
our wants.
Now the plain of Egypt having it’s fertility annually restored by
the periodic overflowings of the Nile, they, whom chance or choice
had once directed to sit down upon it’s banks, had never after an
occasion to remove their tents. And when men have been so long
settled in a place, that the majority of the inhabitants are become
natives of the soil, the inborn love of a Country has, by that time,
struck such deep roots into it, that nothing but extreme violence can
draw them out. Hence, civil policy arises ; which, while the unsettled
tribes of mankind keep shifting from place to place, remains stifled in
its seeds.
This, I apprehend, if rightly considered, will induce us to conclude,
that Egypt was very likely to have been one of the first civilized
countries on the globe.
II. Let us see next what scriprure has recorded in support of
the same truth.
1. So early as the time of Abraham we find a king in Egypt of
the common name of Pharaoh :+ which would induce one to believe,
that the civil policy was much the same as in the times of Joseph
and Moses: and how perfect it then was, will be seen presently.
This kingdom is represented as abounding in corn, and capable of
relieving others in a time of famine:{ which no kingdom can do,
where agriculture has not been improved by art, and regulated by a
civil policy. We see the splendor of a luxurious court, in the princes
who resided in the monarch’s houshold: amongst whom, we find
some (as the most thriving trade for royal favour) to have been prc-
curers to his pleasures :§ nor were the presents made by Pharaoh to
Abraham, at all unworthy of a great king.|| An adventure of the
same sort as this of Abraham’s with Pharaoh, happened to his son
Isaac with Abimelech; which will instruct us in the difference
between an Egyptian monarch, and a petty roitelet of the Philistines.
Abimelech is described as little different from a simple particular, ]
without his guards, or great princes: so jealous and afraid of Isaac’s
growing power, that he obliged him to depart out of his dominions ;**
* See note E, at the end of this book. + Genesis xii. 15. t Verse 10.
§ The princes also of Pharaoh saw her, and COMMENDED HER BEFORE PHARAOH:
and the woman was taken into Pharaoh’s house. (Gen. xii. 15.) || Gen. xii, 16.
J Chap. xxvi. 7, 8. ** Verse 16.
Se Se
152 ‘THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
and, not satisfied with that, went afterwards to beg a pete of him,
and would swear him to the observance of it.*
2. The caravan of Ishmaeclite merchants, going from Gilead to
Egypt,+ brings us to the second scripture period of this ancient
monarchy. And here their camel-loads of spicery, balm, and myrrh,
and their traffic in young slaves,t commodities only for a rich and
luxurious people, sufficiently declare the established power and wealth
of Egypt. We find a captain of Pharaoh’s guard ; a chief butler, and
a baker.§ We see in the vestures of fine linen, in the gold chains,
and state-chariots given to Joseph,|| all the marks of luxury and
politeness : and in the cities for laying up of stores and provisions, {J
the effects of wise government and opulence. Nor is the policy of a
distinct PRIESTHOOD, which is so circumstantially described in the his-
tory of this period, one of the least marks of the high antiquity of this
flourishing kingdom. It is agreed, on all hands, that there was such
an Institution in Egypt, long before it was known in any other parts
of the East. And if what Diodorus Siculus intimates to be the
original of a distinct priesthood, be true, namely the growing multi-
tude of religious rites, we see the whole force of this observation.
For multiplicity of religious rites is generally in proportion to the
advances in civil life.
3. The redemption of the Hebrews from their sles is the third
period of the Egyptian monarchy, recorded in Scripture. Here, the
building of treasure cities,** and the continual employment of so vast
a multitude, in only preparing materials ++ for public edifices, shew
the vast power and luxury of the State. Here too, we find a fixed
and standing militia 17 of chariots ; and, what is more extraordinary,
of cavalry:§§ in which kind of military address the Greeks were
unskilled till long after the times of the Trojan war. And indeed, if
we may believe St. Paul, this kingdom was chosen by God to be the
scene of all his wonders, in support of his elect people, for this very
reason, that through the celebrity of so famed an empire, the power
of the true God might be spread abroad, and strike the observation of
the whole habitable world.—For the Seripture saith unto Pharaoh,
Even for this same purpose have I raised thee up, that I might shew
my power in thee ; and that my name might be declared throughout all.
the earth.|\\|
To this let me add, that Scripture every where, throughout these
three periods, represents Egypt as an entire kingdom under one
monarch ; 4/4] which is a certain mark of great advances in civil policy
and power: all countries, on their first egression out of barbarity,
* Gen. xxvi. 26, et seq. + Chap. xxxvii. 25. t Verse 28. § Chap.
ἘΣ παῖς, τς \| Chap. xli, 42, 43. “ Chap. xli. Dslr ICE ti Chap.
v. 14. It Chap. xiv. 7. §§ Verse 9. lll] Rom, ix. 17. 77 See
Gen. xli. 41, 43, 45, 46, 55; xlyii. 20; and Exod. passim.
SECT. 111. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 153
being divided into many little States and principalities; which, as
those arts improved, were naturally brought, either by power or policy,
to unite and coalesce.
But here let me observe, such is the ceaseless revolution of human
affairs, that that power which reduced Egypt into a monarchy, was
the very thing which, when it came to it’s height, occasioned it’s fall-
ing back again under it’s Reguli. Sesostris, as Diodorus Siculus
informs us, divided the lower Egypt to his soldiery, by a kind of feu-
dal Law, into large patrimonial tenures. The successors of this
militia, as Marsham reasonably conjectures,* growing powerful and
factious, set up, each leader for himself, in his own patrimonial
Nome. The powerful empire of the Franks, here in the West, from
the same causes, underwent the same fate, from the debility of which
it did not recover till these latter ages.
Thus invincibly do the Hebrew records + support the Grecian evi-
dence for the high antiquity of Egypt. And it is further remark-
able, that the later inspired writers of the sacred canon confirm this
concurrent testimony, in the constant attributes of antiquity and wis-
dom, which, upon all occasions, they bestow upon the Egyptian
nation. Thus the prophet Isaiah, in denouncing God’s judgments
against this people :—‘ Surely the princes of Zoan are fools, the coun-
sel of the wise counsellors of Pharaoh is become brutish: How say
ye unto Pharaoh, I am the son of the wise, the son of ANCIENT
Kines? Where are they? where are thy wise MEN? and let them
tell thee now, and -let them know what the Lord of hosts hath pur-
posed upon Egypt.” Τ
But the Greek writers do not content themselves to tell us, in a
vague and general manner, of the high antiquity and power of Egypt,
which in that case was little to be regarded; but they support the
fact, of which their books are so full, by a minute and circumstantial
account of INSTITUTIONS, civil and religious, said to be observed by
that people from the most early times, which, in their very nature,
speak a great and powerful people ; and belong only to such as are so.
Now this account sacred Scripture remarkably confirms and verifies.
I. The prRiEstHOOoD being the primum mobile of the Egyptian
policy, we shall begin with that. Diodorus Siculus thus describes its
state and establishment :—‘‘ The whole country being divided into
three parts ; the first belongs to the body of Priests; an order in the
highest reverence amongst their countrymen, for their piety to the
Gods, and their consummate wisdom, acquired by the best education,
and the closest application to the improvement of the mind. With
their revenues they supply all Egypt with public sacrifices ; they sup-
“ Can. Chron. p. 446. + See note F, at the end of this book. t Isaiah
xix. 11,12. See note G, at the end of this book.
154 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
port a number of inferior officers, and maintain their own families :
for the Egyptians think it utterly unlawful to make any change in
their public worship; but hold that every thing should be adminis-
tered by their priests, in the same constant invariable manner. Nor
do they deem it at all fitting that those, to whose care the public is
so much indebted, should want the common necessaries of life: for
the priests are constantly attached to the person of the King, as his
coadjutors, counsellors, and instructors, in the most weighty matters.
—For it is not amongst them as with the Greeks, where one single
man or woman exercises the office of the priesthood, Here a Body
or Society is employed, in sacrificing and other rites of public wor-
ship ; who transmit their profession to their children. This Order,
likewise, is exempt from all charges and imposts, and holds the
second honours, under the King, in the public administration.”’ *
Of all the colleges of the priesthood, Herodotus tells us, that of
HrLiopouis was most famed for wisdom and learning : Ὁ and Strabo
says that, in his time, very spacious buildings yet remained in that
place; where, as the report ran, was formerly the chief residence of
the Priests, who cultivated the studies of philosophy and astronomy.{
Thus these three celebrated historians; whose account, in every
particular, is fully confirmed by Moses; who tells us, that the Egyp-
tian Priests were a distinct order in the state, and had an established
landed revenue; that when the famine raged so severely that the
people were compelled to sell their lands to the crown for bread, the
Priests still kept theirs, unalienated, and were supplied gratis.§
Diodorus’s account, which gives us the reason of this indulgence, con-
firms the scripture-history, and is fully supported by it: for there we
see, not only the reverence in which the Order was held, but the pub-
lic uses of religion, to which two thirds of their revenues were
applied, kept Pharaoh from attempting on their property. Again,
Moses supports what Diodorus says of the public and high employ-
* Τῆς δὲ χώρας ἁπάσης εἰς τρία μέρη διῃρημένης, Thy μὲν wpeTny ἔχει μερίδα Td
σύστημα τῶν ἱερέων, μεγίστης ἐντροπῆς τυγχάνον wapa τοῖς ἐγχωρίοις, διά τε τὴν εἰς
τοὺς δεοὺς εὐσέδειαν, καὶ διὰ τὸ τυλείστην σύνεσιν τοὺς ἄνδρας τούτους ex watdelas
εἰσφέρεσθαι. ἐκ δὲ τούτων τῶν wpocddwv τάς τε ϑυσίας ἁπάσας τὰς κατ᾽ Αἴγυπτον
συντελοῦσι, καὶ τοὺς ὑπηρέτας τρέφουσι, καὶ ταῖς ἰδίαις χρείαις χορηγοῦσιν. οὔτε γὰρ
τὰς τῶν δεῶν τιμὰς ᾧοντο δεῖν ἀλλάττειν, GAN’ ὑπὸ τῶν αὐτῶν Gel καὶ τσαραπλησίως
συντελεῖσθαι" οὔτε τοὺς τσάντων τσροβουλευυμένους, ἐνδεεῖς εἶναι τῶν ἀναγκαίων. Καθό-
Aov yap wepl τῶν μεγίστων οὗτοι τοροβουλευόμενοι συνδιατρίβδουσι τῷ βασιλεῖ, τῶν μὲν
συνεργοὶ, τῶν δὲ εἰσηγηταὶ καὶ διδάσκαλοι γινόμενοι"---οὗ γὰρ ὥσπερ τσαρὰ τοῖς Ἕλλησιν,
εἷς ἀνὴρ ἢ μία γυνὴ τὴν ἱερωσύνην τσαρείληφεν, ἀλλὰ τσολλοὶ wep) τὰς τῶν ϑεῶν ϑυσίας
καὶ τιμὰς διατρίθουσι, καὶ τοῖς ἐγγόνοις τὴν ὁμοίαν τοῦ βίου wpoalpeow τσαραδιδόασιν.
> “- a a
Εἰσὶ δὲ οὗτοι ττάντων τε ἀτελεῖς, καὶ δευτερεύοντες μετὰ τὸν βασιλέα ταῖς Te δόξαις, Kad
ταῖς ἐξουσίαι5.---- Biblioth. Hist. p. 46, Steph. ed. + Of yap Ἡλιουπολῖται λέγονται
Αἰγυπτίων εἶναι Noyirato1.—Lib. ii. cap. 3. 1 Ἐν δὲ τῇ Ἡλιουπόλει καὶ οἴκους
εἴδομεν μεγάλους, ἐν οἷς διέτριβον of ἱερεῖς" μάλιστα γὰρ δὴ ταύτην κατοικίαν ἱερέων
γεγονέναι φασὶ τὸ πτσαλαιὸν, φιλοσόφων ἀνδρῶν καὶ ἀστρονομικῶν.---- Οὐοσν. lib. xvii.
§ Only the land of the priests bought he not: for the priests had a portion assigned
them of Pharaoh, and did eat their portion which Pharaoh gave them; wherefore they
sold not their lands. (Gen. xlvii. 22.)
SECT, III. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 155
ment of the Priests (who were privy counsellors and ministers of
state), where speaking of the priest of On,* he calls him Chohen,
which, as J. Cocceius shews in his lexicon,+ signifies as well the
friend and privy counsellor of the King, as a Priest ; and accordingly,
the Chald. Paraphr. calls him Princeps On. The word often occurs ;
and, I imagine, was borrowed from the Egyptian language ; the
Hebrews having no order of priesthood before that instituted by
Moses. This further appears from the name Coes,{ given to the
priests of the Samothracian Mysteries, plainly a corruption of Coen
or Chohen. The Mysteries in general, we have shewn,§ were derived
from Egypt, and particularly those of Ceres or Isis, at Eleusis: Now,
in Samothrace, the Mysteries were of Ceres and Proserpine, as at
Eleusis.|| Lastly, Moses confirms Herodotus’s and Strabo’s account
of the superior learning and dignity of the Heliopolitan college.
When Joseph was exalted to the prime ministry, he tells us, that
Pharaoh married him to a daughter of the priest of On ; 4 which the
Septuagint and vulgar Latin rightly interpret Hexiopoxis: that the
king was then in a disposition to do Joseph the highest honours, is
plain from the circumstances of the story ; and that he principally
consulted his establishment in this alliance, appears from the account
given us by these Greek historians. We see the public administration
was in the hands of the priesthood; who would unwillingly bear a
stranger at the head of affairs. The bringing Joseph therefore into
their family, and Order** which was hereditary, was the best expe-
dient to allay their prejudices and envy. And this Pharaoh did most
effectually, by marrying him into that Cast which was then of greatest
name and credit amongst them.
I will only observe, that this superior nobility of the Priests of On
seems to have been chiefly owing to their higher antiquity. Heliopo-
lis, or the city of the Sun, was the place where that luminary was
principally worshipped; and certainly, from the most early times:
for Diodorus tells us, that the first gods of Egypt were the sun and
moon ; ++ the truth of which, all this, laid together, remarkably con-
firms. Now if we suppose, as is very reasonable, that the first
established Priests in Egypt were those dedicated to the Sun at On,
* Gen. xlvi. 20. + “« Chohen, proprie et ex vi vocis, gui accedit ad Regem, et
eum, qui summus est. Ideo explicationis erg6 adjungitur tanquam etymologize evolutio,
Exod. xix. 22. ‘Sacerdotes gui accedunt ad Jehovam.’—Non, quod vox Chohen notet
primatum, ut vult Kimchius, sed quod notet primos accedentium—Certe in Aigypto
fuerunt tales, et his alimonia a rege debebatur.” t Κοΐης, ἱερεὺς KaSetpwv.—
HeEsycu. § “ Divine Legation,” book ii. sect. 4. || Μυοῦνται δὲ ἐν τῇ Ξαμο-
θράκῃ τοῖς Καθείροις, ὧν Μνασέας φησὶ καὶ τὰ ὀνόματα. Τέσσαρες δ᾽ εἰσὶ τὸν ἀριθμὸν.
᾿Αξίερος, ᾿Αξιόκερσα, ᾿Αξιόκερσος. ᾿Δξίερος μὲν οὖν ἐστιν ἣ Δημήτηρ" ᾿Αξιόκερσα ὃ ὲ ἣ
Περσεφόνη" ᾿Αξιόκερσος δὲ ὁ “Αἰδης" 6 δὲ πορροστιθέμενος τέταρτος Κάσμιλος ὁ Ἑρμῆς
ἐστιν, ὡς ἱστορεῖ Διονυσόδωρος.-- Θ0Π01,. in APOLL. Argon. lib. 1. 917. q Gen.
xlvi. 20. ** See note H, at the end of this book. tt See ‘‘ Divine Lega-
tion,’’ book ii.
156 THE DIVINE LEGATION © BOOK IV.
we shail not be at a loss to account for their titles of nobility. Strabo
says, they were much given to astronomy ; and this too we can easily
believe : for what more likely than that they should be fond* of the study
of that system, over which their God presided, not only in his moral,
but in his natural capacity? For whether they received the doctrine
from original tradition, or whether they invented it at hazard, which
is more likely, in order to exalt this their visible God, by giving him
the post of honour, it is certain they taught that the sun was in the
centre of its system, and that all the other bodies moved round it, in
perpetual revolutions. This noble theory came, with the rest of the
Egyptian learning, into Greece (being brought thither by Pythagoras ;
who, it is remarkable, received it from Cinuphis, a priest of Helio-
polis ;) 7 and, after having given the most distinguished lustre to his
school, it sunk into obscurity, and suffered a total eclipse throughout
a long succession of learned and unlearned ages; till these times
relumed its ancient splendor, and immovably fixed it on the most
unerring principles of science.
If. Another observable circumstance of conformity between the
Greek historians and Mosss, is in their accounts of the RELIGIOUS
RITES of Egypt. Herodotus expresly tells us, that the Egyptians
esteemed it a prophanation, to sacrifice any kind of cattle, except
swine, bulls, clean calves, and geese; ὃ and, in another place, that
heifers, rams, and goats were held sacred,|| either in one province or
in another: though not from any adoration paid in these early times
to the living animal. I shall shew hereafter that the Egyptians at
first only worshipped their figures or images. However picture wor-
ship must needs make the animals themselves sacred, and unfit
for sacrifice. Now here again, in confirmation of this account, we are
told by Scripture, that when Pharaoh would have had Mossrs sacrifice
to God, in the land of Egypt, according to his own family-rites,
the prophet objected,—I¢ ts not meet so to do; for we shall sacrifice
the abomination of the Egyptians to the Lord our God: Lo shall we
sacrifice the abomination of the Egyptians before their eyes, and will
they not stone us? 4 And if Herodotus came any thing near the
truth in his account of the early superstition of Egypt, the Israelites,
we see, could not avoid sacrificing the abomination, 7. 6. the Gods of
the Egyptians. And with what deadly hatred and revenge they
* See note I, at the end of this book. t See “πὸ Divine Legation of Moses
Demonstrated, ”? book i. Tt See note K, at the end of this book. § Τοῖσι yep | οὐδὲ
κτήνεα ὁσίη ϑύειν ἐστὶ, χωρὶς ὑῶν, καὶ ἐρσένων βοῶν, καὶ μόσχων, ὕσοι ἂν καθαροὶ ἔ ἔωσι,
καὶ χηνέων, κῶς ἂν οὗτοι ἀνθρώπους ϑύοιεν j—Lib. ii. cap. 48. || Τὰς βοῦς τὰς
ϑηλέας Αἰγύπτιοι ταάντες ὁμοίως σέθδονται τυροθάτων ταάντων μάλιστα μακρῷ. —Cap. xli.
“Ooo μὲν δὴ Διὸς Θηδαίου ἵδρυνται ἱρὸν, ἢ νομοῦ τοῦ Θηβαίου εἰσὶ, οὗτοι μὲν wayTes
ὀΐων ἀπεχόμενοι, αἰγὰς ϑύουσι. Θεοὺς γὰρ δὴ οὐ τοὺς αὐτοὺς ἅπαντες ὁμοίως Αἰγύπτιοι
σέβονται, ταλὴν “lows τε καὶ ᾽Οσίριδος. τὸν δὴ Διόνυσον εἶναι λέγουσι. τούτου» δὲ
ὁμοίως ἅπαντες σέβονται. ὕσοι δὲ τοῦ Μένδητος ἔκτηνται ἱρὸν, ἢ ἢ νομοῦ τοῦ Mevdyatou
εἰσὶ, οὗτοι δὲ αἰγῶν ἀπεχόμενοι, ὄϊς ϑύουσι.-- (ἀρ. xlii. q Exod. viii. 26.
SECT. III. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 15.
pursued such imaginary impieties, the same Herodotus informs us, in
another place.*
III. To come next to the c1viz arts of Egypt.—Concerning their
practice of physic, Herodotus says, that it was divided amongst the
faculty in this manner: “ Every distinct distemper hath its own
physician, who confines himself to the study and cure of that alone,
and meddles with no other: so that all places are crouded with
physicians: for one class hath the care of the eyes, another of the
head, another of the teeth, another of the region of the belly, and
another of occult distempers.” + After this, we shall not think it
strange that Joseph’s physicians are represented as a number—dnd
Joseph commanded his servants, the physicians, to embalm his father :
and the physicians embalmed Israel.t A body of these domestics
would now appear an extravagant piece of state, even in the first
minister. But then, we see, it could not be otherwise, where each
distemper had its proper physician: so that every great family, as
well as city, must needs, as Herodotus expresses it, swarm with the
Faculty: and a more convincing instance, of the grandeur, luxury,
and politeness of a people, cannot, I think, be well given. But
indeed it was this circumstance for which the Egyptian nation was
peculiarly distinguished, not only by the earliest Greek writers (as we
shall see hereafter), but likewise by the holy prophets. There is a
remarkable passage in Jeremiah, where, foretelling the overthrow of
Pharaoh’s army at the Euphrates, he describes Egypt by this charac-
teristic, her skill in medicine. Go up into Gilead, and take balm, O
virgin the daughter of Egypt: in vain shalt thou USE MANY MEDI-
cines ; for thou shalt not be cured.§ The Prophet delights in this
kind of imagery, which marks out a people by its singularities, or
pre-eminence. So again, in this very chapter: Eaypr, says he, ts
like a@ FAIR HEIFER, but destruction cometh: it cometh from the
north. Also her hired men are in the midst of her lke ἙΑΥΤΕΡ
BULLOCKS, for they also are turned back and are fled away together.||
For the worship of Isis and Osiris, under the figure of a cow and a
bull, and afterwards by the animals themselves, was the most cele-
brated in all the Egyptian Ritual.
But a learned writer, frightened by the common panic of the high
antiquity of Egypt, will needs shew, the art of medicine to be of
much later original.{ And to make room for his hypothesis, he
contrives to explain away, this direct testimony of Herodotus, by a
very uncommon piece of criticism. This is the substance of his
* Lib. ii. cap. 65. + Ἡ δὲ ἰητρικὴ κατὰ τάδε ode δέδασται" μιῆς νούσου ἕκαστος
ἰητρός ἐστι, καὶ ov τολεόνων. τσάντα δ᾽ ἰητρῶν ἐστι «πλέα. οἱ μὲν γὰρ, ὀφθαλμῶν ἰητροὶ
κατεστέασι" of δὲ, κεφαλῇς᾽ οἱ δὲ, ὀδόντων" οἱ δὲ, κατὰ νηδύν" οἱ δὲ, τῶν ἀφανέων
νούσων.--- Lib. ii. cap. 84. T Gen. 1. 2. § Jer. xlvi, 11. \| Verses
20, 2]. q See note L, at the end of this book.
158 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
reasoning, and in his own words :—“ We read of the Egyptian physi-
cians in the days of Joseph; and Diodorus represents them as an
order of men not only very ancient in Egypt, but as having a full
employment in continually giving physic to the people, not to cure,
but to prevent their falling into distempers. Herodotus says much
the same thing, and represents the ancient Egyptians as living under
a continual course of physic, undergoing so rough a regimen for three
days together, every month, that I cannot but suspect some mistake,
both in him, and Diodorus’s account of them in this particular. He-
rodotus allows them to have lived in a favourable climate, and to have
been a healthy people, which seems hardly consistent with so much
medicinal discipline as he imagined them to go through, almost
without interruption. The first mention we have of physicians in the
sacred pages shews indeed that there was such a profession in Egypt
in Joseph’s time, and Jacob was their patient ; but their employment
was to embalm him after he was dead; we do not read that any care
was taken to give him physic whilst alive; which inclines me to
suspect that the Egyptians had no practice for the cure of the diseases
of a sick bed in these days: we read of no sick persons in the early
ages. The diseases of Egypt, which the Israelites had been afraid of,
were such as they had no cure for; and any other sicknesses were
then so little known, that they had no names for them.—An early
death was so unusual, that it was generally remarked to be a punish-
ment for some extraordinary wickedness. Moses informs us, that the
physicians embalmed Jacob; many of them were employed in the.
office, and many days time was necessary for the performance, and
different persons performed different parts of it, some being concerned
in the care of one part of the body, and some of the other: and I
imagine this manner of practice occasioned Herodotus to hint, that
the Egyptians had a different physician for every distemper, or rather,
as his subsequent words express, for each different part of the body :
for so indeed they had, not to cure the diseases of it, but to embalm
it when dead. These, I imagine, were the offices of the Egyptian
physicians in the early days. They were an order of the ministers of
religion. The art of curing distempers or diseases was not yet
attempted.—We may be sure the physicians practised only surgery
until after Homer’s time ;—for we read in him, that their whole art
consisted in extracting arrows, healing wounds, and preparing ano-
dynes.—In the days of Pythagoras the learned began to form rules of
diet for the preservation of health, and to prescribe in this point to
sick persons, in order to assist towards their recovery. And in this,
Strabo tells us, consisted the practice of the ancient Indian physicians.
They endeavoured to cure distempers by a diet regimen, but they gave
no physic. Hippocrates—began the practice of visiting sick-bed
SECT} Tix. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 159
patients, and prescribed medicines with success for their distempers.
This, I think, was the progress of physic.—dnd it must evidently
appear from it, that the Egyptians could have no such physicians in
the days of Moses as Diodorus and Herodotus stem to suppose.” *—
So far this writer. But if it be made appear, that the very contrary
of every thing here advanced be the truth; I shall hope, that what
Tlerodotus and Diodorus, conformable to Scripture, do not seem to
suppose, but directly and cireumstantially to affirm, may be admitted
for certain.
He tells us, first, ‘« that Diodorus represents the Egyptian physicians
as administering physic to the people in the early times, not to cure, but
to prevent their falling into distempers.’ One would conclude, from
his manner of expression, that the historian had said they did not
administer to the infirm, but to the healthy only ; which gives us the
idea of a superstitious kind of practice, by charms and amulets: and
so indeed the writer is willing we should think of it. I should ima-
gine, says he, that their ancient prescriptions, which Diodorus and
flerodotus suppose them so punctual in observing, were not medicinal,
but religious purifications.t Let Diodorus then speak for himself :
«“They prevent distempers,”’ says he, “and keep the body in health by
refrigerating and laxative medicines; by abstinence and emeticks ;
sometimes in a daily regimen, sometimes with an intermission every
three or four days: for they hold a superfluity in all food, as usually
taken ; and that it is the origimal of distempers: so that the above-
mentioned regimen removes the cause, and greatly contributes to pre-
serve the body in a state of health.” ¢ Here we have a very rational
theory, and expert and able practice; this prescribing to prevent
distempers, being, as amongst us, the result of the physician’s long
experience in his art: for the regimen, we see, was intermitted or
continued according to the habit and constitution of the patient.
But the Egyptians being a healthy people, and living under a
Favourable climate, could not have occasion (says the learned writer)
for so much physic ; therefore he will suspect their accounts. I have
observed, that these accounts are a proof of that grandeur, luxury,
and politeness, which sacred and prophane history ascribe to this
people, and which so many other circumstances concur to make
credible. Now a too great repletion, the effect of a luxurious diet,
would certainly find employment for the whole tribe of evacuants (as
we may see by the various experience of our own times), notwith-
* «The sacred and profane History of the World connected,” vol. ii. ed. 2, pp. 359—
361, 364—367. abe Olle I Tas δὲ- νόσους ττροκαταλαμθανόμενοι Sepa-
πεύουσι τὰ σώματα κλυσμοῖς, καὶ πσοτίμοις τισὶ καθαρτηρίοις, καὶ νηστείαις, καὶ ἐμέτοις,
ἐνίοτε μὲν Kad’ ἑκάστην ἡμέραν, ἐνίοτε δὲ τρεῖς ἢ τέτταρας ἡμέρας διαλείποντες. Φασὶ
γὰρ, warns τροφῆς. ἀναδοθείσης, τὸ ττλέον εἶναι περιττόν" ἀφ᾽ οὗ γεννᾶσθαι τὰς νόσους"
ὥστε τὴν τοροειρημένην ϑεραπείαν ἀναιροῦσαν τὰς ἀρχὰς τῆς νόσου, μάλιστ᾽ ἂν τσαρα-
σκεύασαι τὴν ὑγίειαν. --- Biblioth. lib. i. p. 52.
160 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK lV.
standing all the advantages of climate and constitution. And let me
observe, and it seems to be decisive, that the very establishment of
this principle of the Egyptian physic, that all distempers arose from a
too great repletion, fully evinces them to be a very luxurious people:
for a nation accustomed to a simple and frugal diet, could never
have afforded sufficient observations for the invention of such a
theory.
Tt is true, (he owns) we hear of physicians in Joseph's family, who
embalmed his father Jacob; but we do not read they gave him any
physic while alive-—Nor do we read that Jacob had any other dis-
temper than old age; and, I suppose, Hippocrates himself would
scarce have prescribed to that—But we read of no sick persons in the
early ages. A plain man would have thought this a good reason why
we read of no medicines administered. Though no man, who
considers the nature of Scripture history, will think this any
proof that there were no sick persons in those early ages.—But
further, the diseases of Egypt which the Israelites had been afraid
of, were such as they had no cure for, Devt. xxvii. 27. and from
hence is inferred the low estate of medicine in these early times.
One would reasonably suppose the authority here quoted, to
support this observation, had informed us that these were natural
diseases, which submitted not to the rude practice of that time.
But we are surprised to find that they are supernatural punishments
which the Prophet is here denouncing in case of disobedience: And
Providence would have defeated its own purpose, in suffering these
to be treatable by the common rules of art :—‘‘ But it shall come
to pass, if thou wilt not hearken to the voice of the Lord thy God,—
The Lord will smite thee with the botch of Egypt, &c. whereof thou
canst not be healed.” * That very Boéch or Boyl, which God had,
in their behalf, miraculously inflicted on the Egyptians, by the
ministry of this Prophet ; as appears by the following words of God
himself: ‘If thou wilt” (says he) ‘‘ diligently hearken to the voice of
the Lord thy God, &c. I will put none of these diseases upon thee
which I have brought upon the Egyptians: for 1 am the Lord that
healeth thee.” -—And. all other sicknesses, this learned writer says,:
were then so little known, that they had no.name for them. For
which we are referred to the following words of the same denuncia-
tion, ‘‘ Also every sickness and every plague which is not written in
the book of this law, them will the Lord bring upon thee ’till thou
be destroyed.” { This seems as if the writer considered the law of
Moses in the light of Salmon’s Dispensatory, in which we reasonably
suppose every disease and remedy without name or mention, to be
unknown.—And still further, An early death (says he) was so unusual,
* Deut. xxviii. 15, 27. + Exod. xv. 26. 1 Deut. xxviii. 61,
SECT, III. QF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 161
that ἐξ was generally remarked to be a punishment for some wicked-
vess : and for this we are sent to the xxxvilith chapter of Genesis.—It
seems then it was the rarity of the fact, which made men believe the
evil to be a punishment. Till now I imagined, it was the sense
of their being under an extraordinary Providence: it is certain at
least, that the book of Genesis as plainly represents the patriarchs,
as the book of Deuteronemy represents their posterity to be under
that dispensation: and I hope, ere long, to prove these representations
true. If then we hear in Scripture of little sickness but what is
delivered as the effect of divine vengeance, no believer, I persuade
myself, will ascribe this opinion to ignorance, superstition, or an
unusual appearance, though pagan writers be never so much accus-
tomed to talk in that strain,* but will own it to be the necessary con-
sequence of an extraordinary providence. The truth is, diseases were
then, as now, common in the world at large; but the infliction of
them, or an exemption from them, amongst the people of God, made
part of the sanction ef that ceconomy under which they lived :-—* Ye
shall serve the Lord your God,” says Moses, ‘and he shall bless thy
bread and thy water, and I will take Sickness away from the midst
of thee.’ + And again, ‘‘Thou shalt be blessed above all people,—
and the Lord will take away from thee all Sickness.” ¢ But there
are of these Divines who read their Bible, and readily talk of the
extraordinary Previdence there represented, yet argue in all questions
arising from sacred history as if there were indeed no such thing.
The learned writer goes on: The physicians embalmed Jacob, many
of them were employed in the office, and many days time was necessary
Sor the performance, ard different persons performed different parts
of it, some being concerned in the care of one part of the body, and
some of the other.—This account is pretended to be taken from -
Diodorus : how the latter part came in, or how it can be true, unless
the body were cut in pieces to be embalmed, is not easy to conceive :
but we know it was embalmed intire ; and Diodorus says nothing of
some being concerned in the eare of one part of the body, and some
of the other. Nis plain, intelligible account is this: That different
persons performed different parts of the operation ; one marked the
place for incision ; another cut; a third drew out the entrails; a
fourth salted the body; a fifth washed; and a sixth embalmed it.—
But the learned Writer’s addition to the account seems for the sake of
introducing the extraordinary criticism which follows.
Ard I imagine, says he, this manner of practice occasioned
Herodotus to Hint that the Egyptians had a different physician for
* “ Kodem auctore [Homero] disci potest, morbos tum ad iram Deorum immortalium
relatos esse; et ab iisdem opem posci solitam.’-—CeLsus De Medicina, lib. i. Pref.
+ Exod. xxiii. 25. 1 Deut. vii. 14, 15.
YOL. 11. M
162 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK iv.
every distemper, or rather, as the subsequent words express, for each
different part of the body: for so indeed they had, not to cure the
diseases of it, but to embalm it when dead.—What he means by
Herodotus’s hinting I can hardly tell: for had the historian been to
give his evidence in a court of justice, it is impossible he should have
delivered himself with more precision. Let us hear him over again:
“Every distinct prsremprr [NOYSO%] hath its own physician,
who confines himself to the study and cure of that, and meddles with
no other; so that all places are crouded with physicians: for one
class hath the care of the eyes, another of the head, another of the
teeth, another of the region of the belly, and another of OCCULT 918-
TEMPERS [APANEQN NOYSOQN].” Notwithstanding all this, by
every distemper, is meant, it seems, each part of a dead body : Death,
indeed, has been often called a remedy, but never, I believe, a disease,
before.—But the subsequent words, he says, lead us to this sense.
The reader will suspect by this, that I have not given him the whole
of the account : But the subsequent words, whereby our author would
support his interpretation, are the beginning of a new chapter about
funeral rites :—As to their mournings for the dead, and funeral rites,
they are of this kind,* §c. Now because Herodotus speaks next of
their obsequies, which, methinks, was methodical enough, after his
account of their physicians, this writer would have the foregoing
chapter an anticipation of the following ; and the historian to treat of
his subject before he comes to it.—He goes on :—For so indeed they
had [ἴ. 6. a different physician for each different part of the body] not
to cure the diseases of it, but to embalm it when dead. How comes
he to know this? Doth Scripture inform him that they had a differ-
ent physician for every different part of a dead body? No. They
are only the Greek writers (in his opinion) misunderstood who are
supposed to say it. But why will he depend so much upon them in
their account of funeral rites, and so little in their account of phy-
sicians? Seripture, which says they used embalming, and had many
physicians, is equally favourable to both accounts : But it may be, one
s, in itself, more credible than the other. It is so; but surely it is
that which tells us they had a different physician to every different
distemper ; for we see great use in this; it being the best, nay per-
haps the only expedient of advancing medicine into a science. On
the other hand, what is said of the several parts assigned to several
men, in the operation of embalming, appears, at first view, much
more wonderful. ΤΊ true, it may be rendered credible ; but then it
is only by admitting the other account of the Egyptian practice of
physic, which the learned writer hath rejected: for when each dis-
order of the body had a several physician, it was natural, it was expe-
* Θρῆνοι δὲ καὶ ταφαὶ σφέων, εἰσὶ alS_e.—Lib. ii. cap. 85.
SECT. III. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 163
dient, that each of These who were the embalmers likewise should
inspect that part of the dead corpse to which his practice was con-
fined ; partly to render the operation on the dead body more com-
pleat, but principally, by an anatomical inspection, to benefit the
Living. On this account every interment required a number, as their
work was to be divided in that manner which best suited the ends of
their inspection. It is true, subsequent superstitions might introduce
various practices in the divisions of this task amongst the operators,
which had no relation to the primitive designs.
These, I imagine, concludes our writer, were the offices of the Egyp-
tian physicians, in the early days ; they were an order of the minis-
ters of religion.—He then employs some pages* to prove that the
Egyptian physicians were an order of Religious; and the whole
amount comes to this, that their practice was intermixed with super-
stitions ; a circumstance which hath attended medicine through all
its stages ; and shall be accounted for in the progress of this enquiry.
—But their office of embalming is likewise much insisted on; for this
being part of the Egyptian funeral rites, and funeral rites being part
of their religion ; the consequence is, that these were religious minis-
ters. The physicians had indeed the care of embalming; and it was,
as we have hinted above, a wise designation, if ever there was any:
For, first, it enabled the physicians, as we have observed, to discover
something of the causes of the ἀφανέων νούσων, the unknown diseases,
which was the district of one class ; and, secondly, to improve their
skill by anatomical enquiries into the cause of the known, which was
the business of the rest. Pliny expresly says, it was the custom of
their kings to cause dead bodies to be dissected, to find out the origin
and nature of diseases; of which he gives a particular instance : +
and Syncellus, from Manetho, relates, that books of anatomy were
written in the reign of the second king of the Thinites.—But to make
their employment, in a sacred rite, an argument of their being an
order of Religious, would be just as wise as to make the priests of the
church of Rome, on account of their administering extreme unction, an
order of physicians. But though the learned writer’s arguments to
support his fanciful opinions be thus defective, yet what he imagined
in this case is very true; these physicians were properly an order of
the ministers of religion; which (though it make nothing for his
point, for they were still as properly physicians) I shall now shew by
better arguments than those of system-makers, the testimonies of
antiquity.—In the most early times of the Egyptian monarchy there
* Pp. 361—364. + **Crudos [raphanos] Medici suadent ad colligenda acria
yiscerum dandes cum sale jejunis esse, atque ita vomitionibus preparant meatum.
Tradunt et priecordiis necessarium hune succum: quando phthisim cordi intus inhe-
rentem, non alio potuisse depelli compertum sit in ANGYPTO, REGIBUS CORPORA MORTU-
ORUM AD SCRUTANDOS MORBOS INSECANTIBUS.’—Nat. Hist. lib. xix. cap. 5.
M 2
164 THE DIVINE LEGATION Ὁ BOOK IV.
was no accurate separation of science * into its distinct branches.
The scholiast on Ptolemy’s Tetrabiblus expresly tells us, that their
ancient writings did not treat separately of medicine, astrology, and
religion, but of all these together: + and Clemens Alexandrinus says,
that of forty-two books of Mercury, which were the Bible of the
Egyptians, six and thirty contained all their philosophy ; and were
to be well studied by the several orders of the priesthood, which he
before mentions; the other six, which related entirely to medicine,
belonged to the πταστοφόροι, i. 6. such as wore the cloak; { and
these, as in another place he tells us, were an order of ministers of
religion : § and even in Greece, the art of medicine being brought
thither from Egypt, went in partnership, during the first ages, with
philosophy ; though the separation was made long before the time
which Celsus assigns to it,|| as we shall see presently. Thus it
appears that these artists were properly both priests and physicians,
not very unlike the monk and friar physicians of the late ages of
barbarism.
Our author now proceeds to the general history of physic. Let us
see if he be more happy in his zmaginations here. We may be sure,
says he, the physicians practised only surgery till after Homer's time.
—wWhat must we say then to the story of Melampus,{[ who learnt
the art of physic and divination in Egypt ;** and cured Prcetus’s
daughters of an Atrabilaire disorder, with hellebore, a hundred and
fifty years before the argonautic expedition? But why not ’¢il after
the time of Homer, who wrote not of his own time, but of the Trojan,
near three hundred years before ; and this, in a kind of work which
requires decorum, and will not suffer a mixture of later or foreign
manners to be brought into the scene? ‘The writer, therefore, at
least should have said, ’till after the Trojan times. But how is even
this supported? Why we read in Homer, that their wHOLE art con-
sisted in extracting arrows, healing wounds, and preparing anodynes ;
and again, where Idomeneus says to Nestor, That one physician is
worth a many other men, for extracting arrows, and applying lenitives
to the wound ;
᾿ἸἸητρὸς γὰρ ἀνὴρ wodd@y ἀντάξιος ἄλλων,
᾿Ιούς τ᾿ ἐκτάμνειν, ἐπί τ᾽ ἤπια φάρμακα waocew.tt
* See “ Divine Legation,” vol i. book i. + Of Αἰγύπτιοι οὐκ ἰδίᾳ μὲν τὰ ᾿Ιατρικὰ,
ιδίᾳ δὲ τὰ ᾿Αστρολογικὰ. καὶ τὰ Τελεστικὰ, ἀλλὰ ἅμα ττάντα συνέγραψαν. 1 Δύο
μὲν οὖν καὶ τεσσαράκοντα αἱ τσάνυ ἀναγκαῖαι τῷ ἙἭ ρμῇ γεγόνασι βίβλοι" ὧν τὰς μὲν
As’, τὴν τσᾶσαν Αἰγυπτίων τσεριεχούσας φιλοσοφίαν, οἱ wpoeipnucvor ἐκμανθάνουσι"
τὰς δὲ λοιπὰς ἐξ, of ΠΑΣΤΟΦΟΡΟΙ, ἰατρικὰς οὔσας, &c.—Lib. vi. Strom. § ΠΑΣ-
ΤΌΦΟΡΟΣ δὲ, ἤ τις ἄλλος τῶν ἱεροποιούντων wepl τὸ τέμενος, σεμνὸν δεδορκὼς, δο.---
Padagog. lib. iii. Gap. 2. From this passage we understand, that it was an inferior
order of the priesthood which practised physic ; for such were those who sacrificed.
|| “‘ Hippocrates Cous, primus quidem ex omnibus memoria dignis, ab studio sapienti ἡ
disciplinam hance separavit.”--_De Med. lib. i. Pref. He adds, we see, to save his cre-
dit, ex omnibus memoria dignis ; taking it for granted, that those who were not remem-
bered, were not worth remembering. 4“ See “ Divine Legation,’ vol. i, book i.
** See note M, at the end of this book. tt Ilias, lib. xi. 514, 515.
SECT. ITI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 165
Homer’s speakers rarely talk impertinently. Idomeneus is: shewing
the use of a physician in an army: now, surely, his use on these occa-
sions consists in healing wounds. ‘The poet therefore chose his topic
of recommendation with good judgment ; and we may be certain, had
he spoken of the use of a physician in a peaceable city, he had placed
it in the art of curing distempers: and this is no imagination: we
shall see presently that he hath in fact done so. In the mean time
let me ask, what there is in this passage, which in the least intimates
that the wHOLE art consisted in extracting arrows, and applying
anodynes? But Pliny says so,* who understands Homer to inti-
mate thus much. What then? Is not Homer’s poem still remain-
ing; and cannot we see, without Pliny, what inference the rules of
good sense authorise us to draw from the poet’s words? The general
humour of Antiquity, which was strangely superstitious with regard
to this Father of the poets,t may be some excuse for Pliny in con-
cluding so much from his silence ; for Homer was their bible; and
whatsoever was not read therein, nor could be expresly proved
thereby, passed with them for apocryphal. But let us, whose venera-
tion for Homer rises not quite so high, fairly examine the nature of
his first great work: This, which is an intire scene of war and
slaughter, gave him frequent occasion to take notice of outward appli-
cations, but none of internal remedies; except in the history of the
pestilence ; which being believed to come in punishment from the
Gods, was supposed to submit to nothing but religious atonements :
not to say, that it was the chirurgical part of healing only that could
be mentioned with sufficient dignity. The Greeks were large feeders,
and bitter railers; for which excesses, I suppose, Machaon, during
the ten years siege, administered many a sound emetic and cathartic :
but these were no proper ornaments for an epic poem. I said, his
subject. did not give him occasion to mention inward applications ;
nor was this said evasively, as shall now be shewn from his second
poem, of a more peaceable turn; which admitting the mention of
that other part of the art of medicine, the use of internal remedies, he
has therefore spoken in its praise: Helen is brought in, giving
Telemachus a preparation of opium ; which, the poet tells us, she had
from Polydamna, the wife of Thon the Egyptian, whose country
abounded with medicinal drugs, many of which were salubrious, and
* “ Medicina—Trojanis temporibus clara—vulnerum tamen duntaxat remediis.’’—
Nat. Hist, lib. xxix. cap. 1. Celsus too talks in the same strain: “ΚΞ Quos tamen Home-
rus non in pestilentia, neque in variis generibus morborum aliquid attulisse auxilii, sed
vulneribus tantummodo ferro et medicamentis mederi solitos esse proposuit. Ex quo
apparet has partes medicine so/as ab bis esse tentatas, easque esse vetustissimas.”’—De
Medicina, lib. i. Pref. + ‘‘Homerum poetam multiscium, vel potius cunctarum
rerum adprime peritum.’ And again: ‘ Ut omnis vetustatis certissimus auctor Home -
rus docet.’’ This was said by Apuleius, a very celebrated platonic philosopher, in a
juridical defence of himself before a proconsul of Africa.
166 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
many baneful; whence the physicians of that land were more skilful
than the rest of mankind.
Tota Διὸς ϑυγάτηρ ἔχε φάρμακα μητιόεντα,
Ἐσσθλὰ, τὰ οἱ Πολύδαμνα τσόρεν Θῶνος τσαράκοιτις
ΑἸΓΎΠΤΙΗ, τῇ τυλεῖστα φέρει ζείδωρος ἄρουρα
Φάρμακα, WOAAG μὲν ἐσθλὰ μεμιγμένα, WOAAG δὲ λυγρά.
Ἰητρὺς δὲ ἕκαστος ἐπιστάμενος wept τσάντων
᾿Ανθρώπων" ἢ γὰρ Παιήονός εἰσι γενέθλης."
Here then is an express testimony much earlier than the time of
Homer, for the Egyptian physicians practising more than surgery ;
which was the thing to be proved.
Our author goes on: In the days of Pythagoras the learned
began to form rules of diet for the preservation of health, and to pre-
scribe in this point to sick persons. This is founded on the rules of
diet observed in the Pythagoric school. There seems to be something
strangely perverse in this writer’s way of arguing ;—In the case of
the Egyptian regimen, though it be expresly delivered by the Greek
writers as a medicinal one, yet by reason of some superstitions in it,
our author will have it to be a religious observance ; on the contrary, this
Pythagorie regimen, though it be generally represented, and even by
Jamblichus himself, as a superstitious practice, yet by reason of its
healthfulness, he will have to be ἃ course of physic.
He proceeds :—Hrperocrates began the practice of visiting sick-bed
patients, and prescribed medicines with success for their distempers.
For which, Pliny is again quoted; who does indeed say he was the
founder of the clinic sect: but it is strange he should say so;
since Hippocrates himself, in numerous places of his writings, has
informed us that it was founded long before. His tract De dieta
in acutis, begins in this manner: ‘ Those who have collected what we
call the CNIDIAN SENTENCES, have accurately enough registered the
various symptoms or affections in the several distempers, with the
causes of some of them: thus far might be well performed by a
writer who was no physician, if so it were, that he carefully examined
each patient about his several affections. But what a physician
should previously be well instructed in, and what he cannot learn
from his patient, that, for the most part, is omitted in this work ;
some things in this place, others in that; several of which are very
useful to be known in the art of judging by signs. As to what is
said of judging by signs, or how the cure should be attempted, I
think very differently from them. And it is not in this particular
only that they have not my approbation: I as little like their practice
in using so small a number of medicines ; for the greatest part they
mention, except in acute distempers, are purgatives, and whey, and
_ * Odyss. lib. iv. 227, et seq. Clarke on this place of Homer observes that Pliny,
lib. xxv. cap. 1, quotes this passage as ascribing a knowledge of medicinal herbs to the
Egyptians hefore Lower Egypt was inhabited.
SECT, 111. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 167
milk for the time: indeed, were these medicines proper for the
distempers to which they direct them to be applied, I should think
them worthy of double praise for being able to attain their purpose so
easily. But this I do not apprehend to be the case : however, those
who have since revised and new-modelled these sentences, have shewn
much more of the physician in their prescriptions.” * From this
long passage we may fairly draw these conclusions: 1. That there
was a physic-school at Cnidus: this appears from the sentences col-
lected under its name. 2. That the Cnidian school was derived from
the Egyptian: this appears from their sole use of evacuants, in all
but acute distempers. 3. That it was now of considerable standing ;
having had a reform in the teaching of more able practitioners.
4. And lastly, which is most to the point, that the physicians of this
school were of the clinic sect ; it being impossible they should com-
pose such a work as Hippocrates here criticizes, without a constant
attendance on the sick-bed: and therefore Hippocrates was not the
‘founder of this sect, as Pliny, and our author after him, supposed.—
But, for the established state of physic, its study as an art, and its
practice as a profession, when Hippocrates made so superior a figure,
we have the full evidence of Herodotus, his contemporary ; who tells
us, that in the time of Darius Hystaspis the physic school at Crotona
was esteemed by the Greeks first in reputation ; and that, at Cyrene,
second ;+ which both implies, that these were of considerable stand-
ing, and that there were many others: andif GALEN may be believed,
who, though a late writer, was yet a very competent judge, there were
many others:{ so that Hippocrates was so far from being the first
that visited sick-beds, and prescribed with success in distempers,
that he was not even the first amongst the Greeks. The truth of the
matter is this, the divine old man (as his disciples have been wont to
call him) so greatly eclipsed all that went before him, that, as poste-
rity esteemed his works the canon, so they esteemed him the father
of medicine: And this was the humour of antiquity. The same
eminence in poetry made them regard Homer as the founder of his
* Of ξυγγράψαντες Tas KNIAIAS καλεομένας TNOMAS, déxoia μὲν wacxovow oi
κάμνοντες ἐν ἑκάστοισι τῶν νουσημάτων, ὀρθῶς ἔγραψαν, καὶ dKolws ἔνια ἀπέβαινεν
αὐτέων" καὶ ἄχρι μὲν τουτέων καὶ μὴ ἰητρὺς ἂν δύναιτο ὀρθῶς ξυγγράψαι. εἰ εὖ Wapa τῶν
καμνόντων ἑκάστου τουθοίατο, ὁκοῖα wdoxovow: ὁκόσα δὲ τοροκαταμαθεῖν δεῖ τὸν ἰητρὸν,
μὴ λέγοντος τοῦ κάμνοντος, τουτέων τὰ πσολλὰ τπτιάρειται- ἄλλα ἐν ἄλλοισι, καὶ ἐπίκαιρα
ἔνια ἐόντα ἐς τέκμαρσιν. Ὁκόταν δὲ ἐς τέκμαρσιν λέγηται ws χρὴ ἕκαστα ἰητρεύειν, ἐν
τουτέοισι τοολλὰ ἑτεροίως γινώσκω, ἢ ὡς ἐκεῖνοι ἐπεξίεσαν" καὶ οὐ μόνον διὰ τοῦτο οὐκ
ἐπαινέω, GAA ὅτι καὶ ὀλίγοισι τὸν ἀριθμὸν τοῖσιν ἀκέεσιν ἐχρέοντο' τὰ γὰρ τὸλΛεῖστα
αὐτέοισιν εἰρέαται, πλὴν τῶν ὀξειῶν νούσων, φάρμακα ἐλατήρια διδόναι, καὶ oppor, καὶ
γάλα, ἐς τὴν ὥρην τοιπίσκειν" ἣν μὲν οὖν ταῦτα ἀγαθὰ ἦν, καὶ ἁρμόζοντα τοῖσι νουσή-
μασιν, ἐφ᾽ οἷσι πσαρήνεον διδόναι, word ἂν ἀξιώτερα ἐπαίνου ἦν, ὅτι ὀλίγα ἐόντα αὐταρκεά
ἐστι νῦν δὲ οὐχ οὕτως ἔχει: οἱ μέν τοι ὕστερον ἐπιδιασκευάσαντες., ἰητρικώτερον δή τι
ἐπῆλθον περὶ τῶν τπροσοιστέων ἑκάστοισιν. + Ἐγένετο γὰρ ὧν τοῦτο ὅτε τυρῶτοι
μὲν Κροτωνιῆται ἰητροὶ ἐλέγοντο ἀνὰ τὴν Ἑλλάδα εἶναι, δεύτεροι δὲ, Κυρηναῖοι.---1ὴ}. iii.
eap. 15], { Meth. Medendi, lib. i.
168 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
art, though they who penetrate into the perfection of his composi-
tions, understand that nothing is more unlikely. But what is strange
in this matter is, that the writer should think it evidence enough to
bring in Pliny speaking of Hippocrates as the first amongst the
Greeks who prescribed to sick-beds with success, for the confutation
of Herodotus (contemporary with Hippocrates) in what he says of
the pharmaceutic part of medicine, as an ancient practice m Egypt.
But all the writer’s errors in this discourse seem to proceed from ἃ
wrong assumption, that the dizetetic medicine was, in order of time,
before the pharmaceutic: and the greater simplicity of the first
method seems to have led him into this mistake :—Jn the days of
Pythagoras, says he, the learned began to form rules of diet for the
preservation of health ; and in this consisted the practice of the ancient
Indian physicians ; they endeavoured to cure distempers by a diet
regimen, but they gave no physic. Hippocrates began the practice of
visiting sick-bed patients, and prescribed medicines with success for
their distempers. This, I think, was the progress of physic.—t hold
the matter to be just otherwise; and that, of the three parts of medi-
cine, the CHIRURGIC, the PHARMACEUTIC, and the DIZTETIC, the
dietetic was the last in use; as the chirurgic was, in all likelihood,
the first. In the early ages of long life and temperance, men were
~ still subject to the common accidents of wounds, bruises, and disloca-
tions ; this would soon raise surgery into an art: agreeably to this
supposition, we may observe, that Sextus Empiricus derives ἰατρὸς, a
physician, from ids, a dart or arrow; the first attack upon the human
species being of this more violent sort. Nor was pharmacy so far
behind as some may imagine; nature itself often eases a too great
repletion by an extraordinary evacuation ; this natural remedy (whose
good effects as they are immediately felt, are easily understood) would
teach men to seek an artificial one, when nature was not at hand to
relieve. But the very early invention of pharmacy is further seen
from that superstition of antiquity, which made medicine the gift of
the Gods. For, what medicine do they mean? It could not be
setting a fracture, or closing the lips cf a wound; much less a regular
diet. It could be nothing then but pharmacy ; and this, both in the
invention and operation, had all the advantages for making its for-
tune: First, it was not the issue of study, but of chance; the cause
of which ‘is out of sight: but what men understand not, they gene-
rally ascribe to superior agency. It was believed, even so late as the
time of Alexander,* that the Gods continued to enrich the physical
dispensatory. Secondly, there was something as extraordinary in the
operation as in the invention. Pharmacy is divided into the two
general classes of evacuants and alteratives ; the most efficacious of
* Cicero De Divin. lib. ii. cap. 66.
SECT. It. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 169
these latter, commonly called Specifics, not working by any visible
effects of evacuation, do their business like a charm. ‘Thus, as the
general notion of the divine original of medicine made the patient
very superstitious,* so the secret operation of alteratives inclined the
practiser to the same imbecility. Hence it is that so much of this
folly hath overrun the art of medicine in all ages. Now the bestow-
ing the origin of pharmacy in this manner, is abundantly sufficient to
prove its high antiquity ; for the Ancients gave ngthing to the Gods
of whose original they had any records: but where the memory of
the invention was lost, as of seed-corn, wine, writing, civil society,
&c. there, the Gods seized the property, by that kind of right, which
gives strays to the lord of the manor.t
But now the dietetic medicine had a very low original, and a well-
known man for its author; a man worth a whole dozen of heathen
gods, even the great Hippocrates himself: and this we learn from
the surest evidence, his own writings. In his tract de Vetert Medi-
cina, he expresly says, that MEDICINE was established from the most.
early times ;t meaning, as the context shews, Pharmacy: but where
he speaks soon after in the same tract of the dietetic medicine (which
he calls τέχνη 4 intpixy, as the pharmaceutic above intpixy sub-
stantively) he says, the ART OF MEDICINE was neither found out in —
the most early times, nor sought after.§ And in his de dieta in
acutis, he tells us, That the ancients (meaning all who had _ preceded
him) wrote nothing of diet worthy notice; and that, notwithstanding
it was a matter of vast moment, they had intirely omitted it, although
they were not ignorant of the numerous subdivisions into the species of
distempers, nor of the various shapes and appearances of each.||
Hence it appears, that, before the time of Hippocrates, the visiting of
sick-beds and prescribing medicines were in practice ; but that the
dieetetic medicine, as an art, was intirely unknown: so that had
Pliny called Hippocrates the author of this, instead of the founder of
the clinic sect, he had come much nearer to the truth.
But without this evidence we might reasonably conclude, even from
the nature of the thing, that the dietetic was the latest effort of the
art of medicine. For, 1. The cure it performs is slow and tedious,
and consequently it would not be thought of, at least not employed,
* <‘ Diis primum inventores suos assignavit, et celo dicavit ; necnon et hodie multifa-
riam ab oraculis medicina petitur.”— ΡΝ τ Nat. Hist. lib. xxix. Prowm. t+ The
Rabbins, amongst their other pagan conceits, adopted this; and taught that God him-
self instructed Adam in the art of medicine ;—‘‘ Et ductus Adam per omnes Paradisi
semitas vidit omne lignum, arbores, plantas, et lapides, et docuit eum Dominus omnem
naturam eorum, ad sanandum omnem dolorem et infirmitatem.”’—R. EBENEZRA.
Which, however, shews their opinion of the high antiquity of the art. 1 Ἰητρικῇ
δὲ wdyra τσάλαι ὑπάρχει.--- (ἀρ. 8. § Τὴν γὰρ ἀρχὴν οὔτ᾽ ἂν εὑρέθη τέχνη ἡ
intpikh, οὔτ᾽ ἂν ἐζητήθη.--- Οδρ. 5. \| ᾿Ατὰρ οὐδὲ πσερὶ διαίτης οἱ ἀρχαῖοι ξυνέγραψαν
οὐδὲν ἄξιον λόγου, καί τοι μέγα τοῦτο τυαρῆκαν' τὰς μέν τοι τσολυτροπίας τὰς ἐν ἑκάα-
τῇσι τῶν νούσων, καὶ τὴν ττολυσχιδὲην αὐτέων οὐκ ἠγνόουν.--- Οαρ. 2. '
170 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
till the quick and powerful operation of the pharmaceutic (which is
therefore most obvious to use) had been found to be ineffectual.
2. To apply the diztetic medicine, with any degree of safety or suc-
cess, there is need of a thorough knowledge of the animal ceconomy,
and of its many various complexions; with long experience in the
nature and qualities of aliments, and their different effects on differ-
ent habits and constitutions.* But the art of medicine must have
made some considerable progress before these acquirements were to
be expected in its professors,
If I have been longer than ordinary on this subject, it should be
considered, that the clearing up the state of the Egyptian medicine
is a matter of importance; for if the practice, in the time of Joseph,
was what the Greek writers represent it, as I think I have shewn it
was, then this topic seems absolutely decisive for the high antiquity
of Egypt ; and the learned person’s hypothesis lying in my way, it
was incumbent on me to remove it.
IV. We come, in the last place, to the FUNERAL RITES of Egypt ;
which Herodotus describes in this manner: “Their mournings and
rites of sepulture are of this kind: When any considerable person
in the family dies, all the females of that family besmear their heads
or faces with loam and mire; and so, leaving the dead body in the
hands of the domestics, march in procession through the city, with
their garments close girt about them, their breasts laid open, beating
themselves ; and all their Relations attending. In an opposite pro-
cession appear the males, close girt likewise, and undergoing the
same discipline. When this is over, they carry the body to be salted :
there are men appointed for this business, who make it their trade
and employment :—They first of all draw out the brain, with a
hooked iron, through the nostrils, &c.—after this they hide it in
nitre for the space of SEVENTY Days, and longer it is not lawful to
keep it salted.”’+ Diodorus agrees with Herodotus in all the essen-
tial circumstances of mourning and embalming. In this last he
* Φημὶ δὲ δεῖν τὸν μέλλοντα ὀρθῶς ξυγγράφειν wepl διαίτης ἀνθρωπίνης, τορῶτον μὲν
πααντὺς φύσιν ἀνθρώπου γνῶναι καὶ διαγνῶναι" γνῶναι μὲν, ἀπὸ τίνων ξυνέστηκεν ἐξ
ἀρχῆς" διαγνῶναι δὲ, ὑπὸ τίνων μερῶν κεκράτηται" εἰ μὴ γὰρ τὴν ἐξ ἀρχῆς ξύστασιν
ἐπιγνώσεται, καὶ τὸ ἐπικρατέον ἐν τῷ σώματι, οὐχ οἷός T ἂν εἴη τὰ ξυμφέροντα τῷ
ἀνθρώπῳ «τροσενεγκεῖν" ταῦτα μὲν οὖν χρὴ γινώσκειν τὸν ξυγγράφοντα" μετὰ δὲ ταῦτα,
σίτων καὶ ττοτῶν ἁπάντων, οἷσι διαιτώμεθα, δύναμιν ἥν τινα ἕκαστα ἔχει, καὶ τὴν κατὰ
φύσιν, καὶ τὴν BC ἀνάγκην καὶ τέχνην ἀνθρωπηΐην" δεῖ yap ἐπίστασθαι τῶν τε ἰσχυρῶν
φύσει ὡς χρὴ τὴν δύναμιν ἀφαιρέεσθαι" τοῖσι δὲ ἀσθενέσιν, ὅκως χρὴ ἰσχὺν τυροστιθέναι
διὰ τέχνης, ὅκου ἂν ὁ καιρὸς ἑκάστων τσαραγένηται.---ΗἸΡΡΟΘΒΑΤΕΒ De Dieta, lib. i.
cap. 1. 1 Θρῆνοι δὲ καὶ ταφαὶ σφέων, εἰσὶ αἵδε" τοῖσι ἂν ἀπογένηται ἐκ τῶν οἰκηΐων
ἄνθρωπος, τοῦ τις καὶ λόγος 7, τὸ ϑῆλυ γένος way τὸ ἐκ τῶν οἰκηΐων τούτων κατ᾽ ὧν
ἐπλάσατο τὴν κεφαλὴν τσηλῷ ἢ καὶ τὸ τσρόσωπον' κᾷπειτα ἐν τοῖσι οἰκηΐοισι λιποῦσαι
τὸν νεκρὸν, αὗται ἀνὰ τὴν σόλιν στροφώμεναι, τύπτονται ἐπεζωσμέναι, καὶ φαίνουσαι
τοὺς μαζούς: σὺν δέ σφι αἱ τοροσήκουσαι τσᾶσαι' ἑτέρωθεν δὲ οἱ ἄνδρες τύπτονται, ἐπε-
ζωσμένοι καὶ οὗτοι" ἐπεὰν δὲ ταῦτα τυοιήσωσι, οὕτω ἐς τὴν ταρίχευσιν κομίζουσι. Εἰσὶ
δὲ οἱ ἐπ᾿ αὐτῷ τούτῳ κατέαται, καὶ τέχνην ἔχουσι ταύτην.---Πρῶτα μὲν σκολιῷ σιδηρῳ
SECT. III. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 17:
seems to vary<in one particular: “They then anoint the whole body
with the gum or resin of cedar, and of other plants, with great cost
and care, for ABOVE THIRTY DAYS; and afterwards seasoning it with
myrrh, cinnamon, and other spices, not only proper to preserve the
body for a long time, but to give it a grateful odour, they deliver it
to the relations,” &c.* All this operose circumstance of embalming,
scripture history confirms and explains ; and not only so, but recon-
ciles the seemingly different accounts of the two Greek writers, con-
cerning the number of days, during which the body remained with
the embalmers: ‘And the physicians,” says Moses, ‘ embalmed
Israel ; and Forty pays were fulfilled for him (for so are fulfilled
the days of those which are embalmed) and the Egyptians mourned
for him THREESCORE AND TEN DAys.’’+ Now we learn from the
_ two Greek historians, that the time of mourning was while the body
remained with the embalmers, which Herodotus tells us was seventy
days: this explains why the Egyptians mourned for Israel threescore
and ten days. During this time the body lay in nitre; the use of
which was to dry up all its superfluous and noxious moisture Φ and —
when, in the compass of thirty days, this was reasonably well effected,
the remaining forty, the ἐφ᾽ ἡμέρας πλείους τῶν τριάκοντα of Diodo-
rus, were employed in anointing it with gums and spices to preserve
it, which was the proper embalming. And this explains the meaning
of the forty days which were fulfilled for Israel, being the days of
those that are embalmed. Thus the two Greek writers are recon-
ciled ; and they and Scripture mutually explained and supported by
one another.
But if it should be said, that though Moses here mentions
embalming, yet the practice was not so common as the Greek histo-
rians represent it, till many ages after; I reply, that the company
of Ishmaelitish merchants with their camels bearing spicery, balm,
and myrrh, to carry down into Egypt,§ clearly shews, that embalm-
ing was at this time become a general practice.
On the whole, what stronger evidence can any one require of a
rich and powerful monarchy, than what hath been here given ?—
Seripture describes Egypt under that condition, in the times of the
Patriarchs, and the egression of their posterity: the Greek writers
not only subscribe to this high antiquity, but support their testimony
by a minute detail of customs and manners then in use, which
διὰ τῶν μυξωτήρων ἐξάγουσι Tov ἐγκέφαλον, &c.—tadta δὲ worjoayTes, ταριχεύουσι
νίτρῳ κρύψαντες ἡμέρας ἑδδομήκοντα' τὐλεῦνας δὲ τουτέων οὐκ ἔξεστι Tapixevew.—
Lib. ii. cap. 85, 86.
* Καθόλου δὲ way τὸ σῶμα τὸ μὲν ττρῶτον Kedpla καί τισιν ἄλλοις ἐπιμελείας ἀξιοῦσιν
ἐφ᾽ ἡμέρας wAclous τῶν τριάκοντα, ἔπειτα σμύρνῃ καὶ κιναμώμῳ, καὶ τοῖς δυναμένοις μὴ
μόνον wodww χρόνον τηρεῖν, ἀλλὰ καὶ τὴν εὐωδίαν τσαρέχεσθαι ϑεραπέυοντες, τσαραδι-
δόασι τοῖς συγγενέσι.--- Biblioth. lib. i. p. 58. + Gen. 1. 2, 3: t Tas δὲ
σάρκας τὸ νίτρον κατατήκει.---ΠΕΒΟΡΟΥ, p. 119. § Gen. xxxvii. 25.
172... . THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
could belong only to a large and well policied kingdom; and these
again are distinctly confirmed by the circumstantial history of
Moses.
But it is not only in what they agree, but likewise in what they
differ, that sacred and profane accounts are mutually supported, and
the high antiquity of Egypt established. To give one instance:
Diodorus expresly tells us, that the lands were divided between the
king, the priests, and the soldiery ;* and Moses (speaking of the
Egyptian famine and its effects) as expresly says that they were
divided between the king, the priests, and the people.t Now as con-
trary as these two accounts look, it will be found, upon comparing
them, that Diodorus fully supports all that Moses hath delivered
concerning this matter. Moszs tells us, that before the famine, all
the lands of Egypt were in the hands of the king, the priests, and
the people ; but that this national calamity made a great revolution in
property, and brought the whole possessions of the people into the
king’s hands; which must needs make a prodigious accession of
power to the crown. But Joseph, in whom the offices of minister
and patriot supported each other, and jointly concurred to the public
service, t prevented for some time the ill effects of this accession, by
his farming out the new domain to the old proprietors, on very easy
conditions. We may well suppose this wise disposition to continue
till that new king arose, who knew not Joseph ;§ that is, would obli-
terate his memory, as averse to his system of policy.|| He, as
appears from Scripture, greatly affected a despotic government ; to
support which, he first established, as I collect, a standing militia ;
and endowed it with the lands formerly the people’s; who now
became a kind of Villains to this order, which resembled the Zaims
and Timariots of the Turkish empire ; and were obliged to personal
service: this, and the priesthood, being the orders of nobility in this
powerful empire; and so considerable they were, that out of either
of them, indifferently, as we observed before,{] their kings were taken
and elected. Thus the property of Egypt became at length divided
in the manner, the Sicilian relates: and it is remarkable, that from
this time, and not till now, we hear in Scripture of a standing
militia,** and of the king’s six hundred chosen chariots, ὅσο.
SECTION. IV.
Havine thus proved the high antiquity of Egypt from the concur-
rent testimony of sacred and profane history ; I go on, as I proposed,
* Biblioth. lib. i. + Gen. xlvii. 1 See note N, at the end of this book.
§ Exod. i. 8. || In this sense is the phrase frequently used in Scripture, as
Judges ii. 10.—‘ And there arose another generation after them, which Anew not the
_ Lord, nor yet the works which he had done for Israel.” Here, knew not, can only sig-
nify despised, set at nought. 4 See the first volume, p. 421. e* Exod, xiv. 8, 9.
_SECT. IV. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 173
to evince the same from internal evidence; taken from the original
use of their so much celebrated HiEROGLYPHICS.
But to gwe this argument its due force, it will be necessary to
trace up hieroglyphic writing to its original; which a general mis-
take concerning its primeval use hath rendered extremely difficult.
The mistake I mean, is that which makes the hieroglyphics to be
invented by the Egyptian priests, in order to hide and secrete their
wisdom from the knowledge of the vulgar: * a mistake which hath
involved this part of ancient learning in much obscurity and con-
fusion.
Ι.
Men soon found out two ways of communicating their thoughts
to one another; the first by sounps, and the second by riGuREsS:
for there being frequent occasion to lave their conceptions either
perpetuated, or communicated at a distance, the way of figures or
characters was next thought upon, after sounds (which were
momentary and confined), to make their conceptions lasting and
extensive.
The first and most natural way of communicating our thoughts
by marks or figures, is by tracing out the images of things. So the
early people, to express the idea of a man or horse, delineated the
form of those animals. Thus the first essay towards writing was a
mere picture.
I. We see an example of this amongst the Mexicans, whose only
method of recording their laws and history, was by a picture-writ-
ing.t Joseph Acosta tells us, that, when the inhabitants of the
sea shore sent expresses to Montezuma with news of the first appear-
ance of the Spanish navy on their coasts, the advices were delineated
in large paintings, upon cloth.t The same writer gives us, in another
place, a more particular account of this sort of painting: ‘“ One of
our company of Jesus” (says he) “(a man of much experience and
discernment, assembled in the province of Mexico the Ancients of
Tuscuco, Tulla, and Mexico; who, in a long conference held with
him, shewed him their records, histories, and calendars ; things very
* See note O, at the end of this book. + “In diffetto di lettere usarono gl’
ingegnosi Mexicani figure, e Geroglifici, per significar le cose corporee, che han figura ;
e per lo rimanente, altri caratteri propri: e in tal modo segnavano, a pro della posterita,
tutte le cose accadute. Per ragion d’ esemplo per significare l’ entrata degli Spagnuoli
dipinsero un’ uomo col cappello, e colla veste rossa, nel segno di Canna ch’ era proprio
di quell’ anno.”—Giro del Mondo del Dorror D. Gio Fr. GEMELLI CARERI, tom.
sesto. Αὐὸ, Nuova Spagna, cap. vi. p. 37. t * Quando era caso de importancia
Ileuauana a los Senores de Mexico pintado el negocio de que les querian informar ;
como lo hizieron quando aparecieron los primeros navios de Espanoles, y quando fueron
a tomar a Toponchan.”—Acosta’s ‘* History of the Indies,’ Madr. 1608, 4to. lib. vi.
cap. 10.—“ Con este recado fueron a Mexico los de la costa ileuando pintado en unos
panos todo quanto auian visto, y los navios, y hombres, y su figura, y juntamente las
piedras que les auien dado,’’—Lib. vii. cap. 24.
174 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
worthy notice, as containing their figures and hieroglyphics, by which
they painted their conceptions in the following manner: things that
‘have a bodily shape were represented by their proper, figures; and
those which have none, by other significative characters: and thus
they writ or painted every thing they had occasion to express.—For
my own satisfaction I had the curiosity to inspect a paternoster, an
ave-maria, the creed, and a general confession,* written in this man-
ner by the Indians :—To signify these words, I a sinner confess
myself, they painted an Indian on his knees before a religious in the
act of one confessing: and then for this, Zo God almighty, they
painted three faces adorned with crowns, representing the Trinity ;
and, To the glorious virgin Mary, they delineated the visage of our
Lady, with half a body, and the infant in her arms; 70 δέ. Peter
and St. Paul, two heads irradiated, together with the keys and sword,
&c.—In Peru I have seen an Indian bring to the confessional a con-
fession of all his sins written in the same way, by picture and charac-
ters ; portraying every one of the ten commandments after a certain
manner.’ +
There is yet extant a very curious specimen of this American
picture-writing, made by a Mexican author: and deciphered by him
in that language, after the Spaniards had taught him letters; the
explanation was afterwards translated into Spanish, and, from thence,
into English. Purchas has given us this work engraved, and the
explanations annexed. The manner of its coming into his hands is
curious.t It is in three parts; the first is a history of the Mexican
_ * Acosta’s words are, Y symbolo y la confession general ; which Purchas has trans-
lated,— 4nd symbol or general confession of our faith. This is wrong: by la confes~
sion general is meant a general confession of sins, a formulary very different from the
creed, + “Una de los de nuestra Compaiiia de Jesus, hombre muy platico y
diestro, junto en la provincia de Mexico a los Ancianos de Tuscuco, y de Tulla, y de
Mexico, y confirio mucho con ellos, y le monstraron sus Librerias, y sus Historias, y
Kulendarios, cosa mucho de Ver. Porque tenian sus figuras, y Hieroglyficas con que
pintauam los cosas en esta forma, que los cosas que tenian figuras, las ponian con sus
proprias Ymagines, y para las cosas que no auia Ymagen propria tenian otros caracteres
significatiuos de acquello, y con este modo figuranam quanto queriam—e yo he visto
para satisfazerme en esta parte, las Oraciones del Pater Noster, y Ave Maria, y Sym-
bolo, y la Confession general, en el modo dicho de Indios.—Para significar Aquella
palabra, Yo pecador me confiesso, pintan un Indio hincado de rodillas a los pies de un
Religioso ; como que se confiessa ; y luego para aquella, 4 Dios todo poderoso, pintan
tres caras con sus coronas, al modo de la Trinidad; y ὦ la gloriosa Virgen Maria,
pintan un rostro de nuestra Sefora, y medio cuerpo con un Niio; y a San Pedro ya
San Pablo, dos cabecas con coronas, y unas llaues, y una espada.—Por la misma forma
de pinturas y caracteres vi en el Piru escrite la confession que de todos sus pecados un
Indio traya para confessarse. Pintando cada uno de los diez mandamientos por cierto
modo,”—Lib. vi. cap. 7. t “Reader, I here present thee with the choicest of my
jewels, &c.—a politic, ethic, ecclesiastic, oeconomic history, with just distinction of
time.—The Spanish governor having, with some difficulty, obtained the book of the
Indians, with Mexican interpretations of the pictures (but ten days before the departure
of the ships) committed the same to one skilful in the Mexican language, to be inter-
preted; who in a very plain style, and verbatim, performed the same. This history
thus written, sent to Charles V. emperor, was, together with the ship that carried it,
taken by French men of war; from whom Andrew Thevet the French king’s geographer
obtained the same. After whose death master Hakluyt (then chaplaine to the English
να
Ψ +
'
‘
» y
Aan Sess αν bE > wold) τον ae,
C0 et Oe ΚΗ es re ee ne -
πὰ
any
- "ΣΕ
5 “
ee -
- τ
ΕΝ ᾿
᾿ς
Ο
[9]
Οο
| (72
SAF
00000
i)
fe)
fefeTeYeTo)
Z
‘le | (Hil
ae: [olor οο
ce
9000}
© .29
--Θ
a)
ΘΘ
[AAA
X
Ἃ i
ζ ) ),
Ἢ ᾿, ΡΈΕΙ Ἑ Lh ler ε Hester, go, he χε You φῶς ΩΣ
ΩΣ 5 ΩΣ P ΩΣ ΩΣ
“ἈΦ
Vier
po απο,
a
“ay
Y
ἣν
gig
Bary ὦν
:
sect. liv. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 175
empire: the second, a tribute roll of the several tributes which each
conquered town or province paid into the royal treasury; and the
third, a digest of their civil law, the largest branch of which was, de
jure patrio. ;
This was the first, and most simple way of recording their concep-
tions ;* obvious to every one, and common not only to the North as
well as South Americans, but to all mankind.t+
1:
But the inconveniencies attending the too great bulk of the volume
in writings of this kind would soon set the more ingenious and better
civilized people upon contriving methods to abridge their characters :
and of all the improvements of this kind, that which was invented
by the Egyptians, and called HreroGtiypnics, was by far the most
celebrated. By this contrivance, that writing, which amongst the
Mexicans was only a simple painting, became in Egypt a pictured
character.{
This abridgment was of three kinds; and, as appears from the
more or less art employed in the contrivance of each, made by due
degrees ; and at three different periods.
1. The first way was, To make the principal circumstance in the
subject stand for the whole. ‘Thus when they would describe a battle,
or two armies in array, they painted (as we learn from that admirable
fragment of antiquity, the hieroglyphics of Horapollo) two hands, one
holding a shield, and the other a bow ;§ when a tumult, or popular
imsurrection,—an armed man casting arrows ; || when a siege,—a
scaling ladder.4{ This was of the utmost simplicity ; and, conse-
quently, we must suppose it the earliest way of turning painting into
an hieroglyphic ; that is, making it a picture-character. And this is
embassadour in France) bought the same for twenty French crowns; and procured
master Michael Locke, in Sir Walter Raleigh’s name, to translate it. It seems that
none were willing to be at the cost of cutting the pictures, and so it remained amongst
his papers till his death: whereby (according to his last will in that kind) I became
possessour thereof, and have obtained, with much earnestness, the cutting thereof for
the press.’’—Purcuas’s “ἢ Pilgrimage,’’ 3d part, pp. 1065, 1066. See plate I.
* < Quant aux caracteres, ils n’en avoient point: et ils y suppleoient par des especes
dhieroglyphes.’”,—CHARLEVOIX, of the Northern Americans, vol. v. p. 292. Lafitau ἡ
gives us a specimen of these hieroglyphics. See plate II. + The same kind of
characters Stahlenberg found upon rocks in Siberia in the province of Permia, and near
the river Jenesei. Of which he has given a drawing. See plate III]. The author De
vet. Lit. Hunn. Scyth. p. 15, seems to admire this natural expression of things, as
some uncommon stretch of invention. ‘ Miratus ego sepe fui caupones idiotas (nempe
in Hungaria) istis, quibus aliquid credere hujusmodi ficto charactere inter debitores non
adscribere tantum, sed longioris etiam temporis intervallo post, non secus, quam si
alphabethario scribendi genere adnotati fuissent, promere, debitamque summam et
rationes indicare potuisse; ita si debitor miles est, rudi quadam linea frameam aut
pugionem pingebant; si faber, malleum aut securim: si auriga, flagrum, atque sic
porro.” 1 See plate IV. ἃ Horapoun. Hierogl. lib. ii. cap. 5, ed. Corn.
De Pauw, Traj. ad Rhen. 1727, 4to. || Idem, lib. ii. cap. 12. q Idem,
lib. ii. cap. 28. .
176 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
what we shall hereafter distinguish by the name of the cuRIoLOGIC
HIEROGLYPHIC.
2. The second, and more artful method of contraction, was by
putting the instrument of the thing, whether real or metaphorical,
for the thing itself. Thus an eye, eminently placed, was designed to
represent God’s omniscience ;* an eye and sceptre, to represent a
monarch ;+ a sword, their cruel tyrant Ochus :{ and a ship and pilot,
the governor of the universe.§ And this is what we shall call the
TROPICAL HIEROGLYPHIC.
3. Their third, and still more artificial method of abridging pic-
ture writing, was, by making one thing to stand for, or represent
another, where any quaint resemblance or analogy, in the representa-
tive, could be collected from their observations of nature, or their
traditional superstitions. And this was their syMBOLIC HIERO-
GLYPHIC.
Sometimes it was founded in their observations on the form, or on
the real or imaginary natures and qualities, of Beings. Thus the
universe was designed by a serpent in a circle, whose variegated spots
signified the stars ; || and the sun-rise by the two eyes of the crocodile,
because they seem to emerge from its head; a widow who never
admits a second mate, by a black pigeon ; ** one dead of a fever, con-
tracted by the over great solar heat, by a blind scarabeus ; ++ a client fly-
ing for relief to his patron, and finding none, by a sparrow and owl ; tf
a king inexorable, and estranged from his people, by an eagle ; §§
a man who exposes his children through poverty, by an hawk ;|||| a
wife who hates her husband, or children who injure their mother, by
a viper ; YJ one initiated into the mysteries, and so under the obliga-
tion of secrecy, by a grashopper,*** which was thought to have no
mouth.
Sometimes again, this kind of hieroglyphic was derived from the
popular superstition. Thus he who had borne his misfortunes with
courage, and had at length surmounted them, was signified by the
hyaena,+++ because the skin of that animal, used as a defence in battle,
was supposed to make the wearer fearless and invulnerable.
But it is not from analogy alone (the force of which will be seen
more fully as we proceed), nor yet from the nature of the thing
only (which in these enquiries is indeed the safest guide), that we
conclude the hieroglyphics now described to be an improvement of an
earlier picture-writing used by the Egyptians, and resembling that of
the Americans. Ancient history records the fact. We are told, in
* CLEMENS ALEXAND. Strom. lib. v. + PLurarcu, Js. et Osir. 1 Idem,
ibid. § JAMBLICHUS. See note P, at the end of this book. || Horapoun.
Hierogl. lib. i. cap, 2. 4“ Lib. i. cap. 68. ** Lib. ii. cap. 32. +t Lib.
ii. cap. 41. tt Lib. ii. cap. 51. §§ Lib. ii. cap. 56. Π|| Lib. ii. cap. 99.
«ΜΠ Lib. ii. cap. 59 et 60. *** Lib. ii, cap. 55. ttt Lib. ii. cap. 72.
SECT. Iv. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. R/T
hat exquisite fragment of Sanchoniatho, preserved by Eusebius, that
“the God Taautus, having imitated Ouranus’s art of picture-writ-
ing,* drew the portraits of the Gods Cronus, Dagon, and the rest,
and delineated the sacred characters which formed the elements
of this kind of writing: + for Cronus, particularly, he imagined
these symbols of royalty, four eyes, two before, and two behind; of
which, two were closed in slumber; and on his shoulders four wings,
two stretched out, as in the act of flight, and two contracted, as in
repose. ‘The first symbol signified that Cronus watched though he
reposed, and reposed though he watched ; the second symbol of the
wings signified, in like manner, that even when stationed he flew
about, and when flying, he yet remained stationed. To each of the
other gods he gave two wings on their shoulders,t as the Satellites of
Cronus in his excursions; who had likewise two wings on his head,
to denote the two principles of the mind, reason and passion.” §
Here we see that Ouranus practised a kind of picture-writing, which
Taautus afterwards improved: Taautus, or Thoth, was the Egyptian
Mercury ; on which name and family all the inventions of the various
kinds of writing were very liberally bestowed : this, here mentioned,
as the improvement of Taautus, being the very hieroglyphics above
described : and that,.as before practised by Ouranus, the same with
the simple American paintings.
Such then was the ancient Egyptian hieroglyphic ;|| and this the
second mode of invention for recording men’s actions and concep-
tions; not, as hath been hitherto thought, a device of choice for
secrecy, but an expedient of necessity, for popular use.
Π|.
But the obscurity which attended the scantiness of hieroglyphic
characters, joined to the enormous bulk of picture volumes, set men
upon contriving a third change in this kind of writing: of which the
CHINESE have given us a famous example.
* The original is, Πρὸ δὲ τούτων Θεὸς Τάαυτος μιμησάμενος τὸν Οὐρανὸν, which
Vigerus thus translates, Taautus vero Deus cum jam ante ceti imaginem effinaisset ;
and Cumberland, ‘‘ But before these things the god Taautus having formerly imitated
or represented Ouranus :”—This is wronz, μιμησάμενος τὸν Οὐρανὸν signifies here, imi-
tating the art, or practice, or example of Ouranus; not painting his figure. So
PLuTARCH. De Fort. Aler. ἫἩ ρακλέα MIMOYMAT καὶ Περσέα ζηλῶ. 7 See
note Q, at the end of this book. } Conformably to this account, the Etruscans
and Greeks occasionally gave wings to the Images of all their Deities. § Πρὸ δὲ
τούτων δεὸς Τάαυτος μιμησᾶμενος τὸν Οὐρανὸν, τῶν ϑεῶν ὄψεις, Κρόνου τε καὶ Δαγῶνος,
καὶ τῶν λοιπῶν διετύπωσεν τοὺς ἱεροὺς τῶν στοιχείων XapaxTipas’ ἐπενόησε δὲ καὶ TH
Κρόνῳ wapdonua βασιλείας, ὄμματα τέσσαρα ἐκ τῶν ἐμπροσθίων καὶ τῶν ὀπισθίων μερῶν"
δύο δὲ ἡσυχῆ μύοντα, καὶ ἐπὶ τῶν ὥμων wrepa τέσσαρα: δύο μὲν ὡς ἱπτάμενα, δύο δὲ ὡς
ὑφειμένα: τὸ δὲ σύμδολον ἦν, ἐπειδὴ Κρόνος κοιμώμενος ἔθλεπε, καὶ ἔγρηγορὼς ἐκοιμῶτο:
καὶ ἐπὶ τῶν wrepay ὁμοίως, ὅτι ἀναπαυόμενος ἵπτατο, καὶ ἱπτάμενος ἀνεπαύετο" τοῖς δὲ
λοιποῖς Θεοῖς, δύο ἑκάστῳ τυτερώματα ἐπὶ τῶν ὥμων, ὡς ὅτι δὴ συνίπταντο τῷ Κρόνῳ.
καὶ αὐτῷ δὲ τσάλιν ἐπὶ τῆς κεφαλῆς, ττερὰ δύο: ev ἐπὶ τοῦ ἡγεμονικωτάτου νοῦ, καὶ ἕν
ἐπὶ τῆς aicOjcews.—Prep. Evang: lib. i. cap. 10. || See note R, at the end sf
this book.
VOL. II. N
178 THE DIVINE LEGATION . BOOK IV.
We have just observed, that the ancient Egyptian hieroglyphic was
an improvement on a yet more ancient manner, resembling the rude
picture-writing of the Mexicans; and that it jomed contracted and
arbitrarily instituted marks to images. The CHINESE writing at
length went still further ; it threw out the images, and retained only
the marks; which they increased to a prodigious number. In this
writing, every distinct idea has its proper mark; and is, like every
real character, whether formed by analogy or institution, common to
divers neighbouring nations, of different languages.* The shapes and
figures of several of these marks, however now disguised, do yet
betray their original to be from pictures and images; as the reader
may perceive, by casting his eye on the specimen given us by
Kircher : + for, that it is only a more contracted and refined hierogly-
phic, we have the concurrent testimony of the best writers on the arts
and manners of this famous people; who inform us how their present
writing was deduced, through an’ earlier hieroglyphic, from the first
simple way of painting the human conceptions.{
* << Pero Io que se escrive en elia, en todas las lenguas se entiende, porque aunque
las Provincias no se entienden de palabra unaes a otras, mas por escrito si, porque las
letras o figuras son unas mismas para todos, y significan lo mismo, mas no tinen el
mismo nombre ui prolacion, porque como he dicho son para denotar cosas y no palabras,
assi como en el exemplo de los numeros de guarismo que puse, se puede facilmente
entender. De aqui tambien procede, que fiendo los Japones y Chinas, Naciones y
lenguas tam differentes leen y entendien los unos las escrituras de los otros; y si hablas
sen lo que leen, 0 escriven, poco ni mucho no se entenderian. Estas pues son las letras
y libros que usan los Chinos tan afamados en el mundo,’’ &,—AcosTa, lib. vi. cap. 5..
“¢ Les Caracteres de la Cochinchine, du Tongking, du Japon sont les mémes que ceux
de la Chine, et signifient les mémes choses, sans toutefois que ces Peuples en parlant,
s’expriment de la méme sorte. Ainsi quoique les langues soint trés-differentes, et
qwils ne puissent pas s’entendre les uns les autres en parlant}; ils s’entendent fort bien
en s’ecrivant, et tous leurs Livres sont communs. Ces Caracteres sont en cela comme
des Chiffres d’ arithmetique: plusieurs Nations s’en servent: on leur donne differens
noms; mais ils signifient par tout la méme chose—l’on compte jusqu’a quatre vingt
mille de ces Caracteres.”—Du Hatups, Descr. de ἢ Empire de la Chine, tom. ii. p. 226.
fol. ed. + China Illustrata, p. 227, et Edipi AZgyptiaci Theatrum Hieroglyphi-.
cum, Ὁ. 12. See plate V. t “ Primd siquidem ex omnibus rebus mundialibus
primos Sinas characteres suos construxisse, tum ex Chronicis ipsorum patet, tum ipsa
characterum forma sat superque demonstrat; siquidem non secus ac Avgyptit ex
animalibus, volucribus, reptilibus, piscibus, herbis, arborumque ramis, funiculis, filis,
punetis, circulis, similibusque characteres suos, alid tamen et alia ratione dispositos
formabant. Posteriores verd Sine rerum experientia doctiores, cum magnam in tanta
animalium plantarumque congerie confusionem viderent, characteres hujusmodi varie
figuratos, certis punctorum linearumque ductibus cemulati, in breviorem methodum con-
cinnarunt, qua et in hune usque diem utuntur.—Porro litteras Sime nulla ratione in
Alphabeti morem, uti ceteris nationibus consuetum est, dispositas, neque voces ex
literis et syllabis compositas habent, sed singuli characteres singulis vocibus et nomini-
bus respondent; adeoque tot characteribus opus habent, quos res sunt, quas per concep-
tum mentis exponere volunt.”—KiRcHERI China Illustrata, p. 226, “ Au lieu d’Al-
phabet ils se sont servis au commencement de leur Monarchie, de Hieroglyphes. Us en
peint au lieu d’ecrire; et par les images naturelles des choses qu’ils formoient sur le
papier ils tachoient d’exprimer et de communiquer aux autres leurs idees. Ainsi pour
écrire un oiseau, ils en peignoient la figure; et pour signifier un forest, ils represen-
toient plusieurs arbres ; un cercle vouloit dire le Soleil, et un croissant la Lune. Cette
maniere d’ecrire estoit non seulement imparfaite, mais encore trés incommode.—Ainsi
les Chinois changerent peu ἃ peu leur ecriture, et composerent des figures plus simples,
quoique moins naturelles,’ &e.—Le ComTe, Nouv. Memoires sur l’ Etat Present de la
Chine, Tome prem. p. 256, Amst. 1698, 12mo. ‘Des le commencement de leur
SECT. IV. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 179
But it may be worth our while te consider more particularly, the
origine and introduction of these ARBITRARY MARKS; the last advance
of hieroglyphics towards alphabetic writing. We may observe that
substances, and all visible objects, were at first very naturally
expressed by the images of the things themselves; as moral modes
and other ideal conceptions of the mind were more aptly represented
by marks of arbitrary institution: for it required variety of know-
ledge, and quickness of fancy, to design these latter ideas by analogic
or symbolic figures ; which therefore can be supposed no other than
an after-theught of a people more than ordinary ingenious, as the
Egyptians, and who, aiming to set a price upon their ingenuity, made
their meaning mysterious and profound.
We shall see presently, that as all nations, in their ruder state, had
hieroglyphic images or analogic or symbolic figures for marking
things; so had they likewise simple characters or notes of arbitrary
institution, for mental conceptions. But, commonly, that sort only
which they most cultivated, or fer which they were principally
famous, happened to be transmitted to posterity. Thus the Mexicans
are remembered for their hieroglyphic paintings only; and the
Peruvians for their knotted cords. But we are πού therefore to con-
clude that the Mexican writing had no arbitrary marks,* or that the
Peruvians had no hieroglyphic paintings.+ Real characters of both
kinds had, at different periods, been cultivated in China, if we may
eredit the concurrent relations of the Missionaries. In ancient Egypt
Monarchie, ils communiquoient leurs idees, en formant sur le papier les images natu-
relles des choses qu’ils vouloient exprimer: ils peignoient, par exemple, un oiseau, des
montagnes, des arbres, des lignes ondoyantes, pour exprimer des oiseaux, des mon-
tagnes, un forét, et des rivieres. Cette maniere d’expliquer sa pensée étoit fort impar-
faite, et demandoit plusieurs volumes pour exprimer assez peu des choses. D/ailleurs
al y avoit une infinite d’objets, qui ne pouvoiert étre representez par la peinture.—C’est
pourquoi insensiblement ils changerent leur ancienne maniere d’ecrire: ils composerent
des figures plus simples, et en inventerent plusieurs autres, pour exprimer les objets,
qui ne tombent point sous les sens. Mais ces caracteres plus modernes ne laissent pas
détre encore de vrais Hieroglifes. Premierement parce quils sont composez de lettres
simples, qui retiennent la méme signification des caracteres primitifs: Autrefois, par
exemple, ils representoient ainsi le Soleil par un cercle © et Vappelloient Gé ; ils le
representent maintenant, par cette figure | , qu’ils nomment pareillement Gé. Seconde-
ment, parce que Vinstitution des hommes a attaché a ces figures la méme idée, que ces
premiers Symboles presentoient naturellement, et qu’il n’y a aucune lettre Chinoise qui
a’ait sa propre signification, lorsqu’on la joint avec d’autres. Tsai, par exemple, qui
veut dire, malneur, calamité, est composé de la lettre mien, qui signifie maison, et de la
lettre ho, qui signifie few, parce que le plus grand malheur est de voir sa maison en feu.
On peut juger par ce seul exemple, que les caracteres Chinois n’étant pas des lettres
simples, comme les nodtres, qui separement ne signifient rien, et n’ont de sens que quand
elles sont jointes ensemble ; ce sont autant de Hieroglifes, qui forment des images, et
qui expriment les pensées.’”—-Du HaLpe, tom. ii. p. 227.
* Joseph Acosta (as we see above) expressly says, that ‘‘the Mexicans represented
those things, which had bodily shape, by their proper figures, and those which had none,
. by other significative characters :’’—‘‘las cosas que tenian figuras las ponian con sus
proprias ymagines ; y para las cosas que no avia ymagen propria tenian otros caracteres
significativos de aquello.” + The same Acosta says expressly, that, besides their
quippos or ‘strings ”’ variously knotted and coloured, they had paintings like the Mexi-
cans.—Lib. vi. cap, 8.
N 2
180 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK 1Ve
indeed, where hieroglyphic figures were so successfully cultivated as to
give that general name to real characters, the use of marks by institu-
tion is more obscurely noticed. And for this, a reason will be
assigned. Martinus Martinius, in his history of China, tells us,* they
had two sorts of characters; the one, marks by institution, which had
been substituted instead of knotted cords, once in use amongst them
(as in Peru), but much more intricate than the Peruvian knots: their
other characters were figures resembling the Egyptian hieroglyphics,
and representing the ¢hings they were designed to express. Now as
the Chinese improved in arts and empire, it is natural to suppose they
would much increase their marks by institution. The growing num-
ber of these characters, the sciences to which they were applied, and
their commodious and expeditious use, would tempt them even to
change their analogic figures into marks by institution, till their
whole writing became of this sort. It is now such: and that the
ehange was produced in the manner here represented, we may collect
from the words and scheme of Martinius on the other side.+
But to all this it may be said, How then came it to pass, that
Egypt, which had the same imperial fortune in a long flourishing
dominion, should be so far from changing their analogic figures into
arbitrary marks, that their arbitrary marks were almost lost and
absorbed in analogic figures? For such arbitrary marks they had, as
we may collect from their monuments, where we find them intermixed
with proper hieroglyphics ; and from Apuleius, where we see them
described in his account of the sacred book or ritual of the mysteries
of Isis.‘ De opertis adyti profert quosdam libros, litteris ignorabi-
libus preenotatos: partim FIGURIS CUJUSCEMODI ANIMALIUM, con-
cepti sermonis compendiosa verba suggerentes ; partim NODOSIS, ET
IN MODUM ROT TORTUOSIS, capreolatimque condensis apicibus, a
curiositate profanorum lectione munita:’’ the very same species of
writing with that of the Chinese, described by Martinius, and almost
in the same words: ‘‘ Fohius characteres reperit, quos loco nodorum
adhibuit ; séd ipsis nodis intricatiores.”’
Now this opposite progress in the issue of hieroglyphic writing, in
Egypt and China, may, I think, be easily accounted for by the differ-
ent genius of the two people. The Egyptians were extremely
inventive ; and, what is often a consequence of that humour (though
here other things contributed to promote it), much given to secrecy
and mysterious conveyance : while the Chinese are known to be the
least inventive people upon earth; and not much given to mystery.
This difference in the genius of the two nations would make all the
difference in the progress of hieroglyphic writing amongst them. I
* “Tdem imperator [Fo-hi] Sinicos characteres reperit, quos loco nodorum adhibuit,
sed ipsis nodis intricatiores.”— Sin. Hist. lib i. t See plate VI.
WTAE Oe
Strom Martinus Martincius.
Hec Litera, 1.gua 272 Ζε γ72 frgnifical,
clam 7a, 2. pingcbatur. ee Jolem
co modo exprem cbant, Guo Eee
Zeiss hoe cerciule meentogiue puncto,
3.defirebilursnune esta forma Affingunt
Draconis hee. 5.clim figura crathode
072,0. formals: Le CGS hitera fet “772 72
fecpir time cum ocUlo, 7. σε) batnune ti,
Spingune. Volucrem, gallina, vel
gallium, fut, AOC ft native fpecte9 MN.
reprafentabant, reunc sets duclibus 1012
explican tur Habco PCTS THLE Lebrume Cele\’
σι Stree Ces ad ex diverfos moA0s CON=
ΓΟ ἤζεέγ)ε, Opus “272 ἐέγαε, 7.772 22 77γ2 cari
rare, Stes ob veleflatem rarelilerngue
magno femper 272 pretto habetlum. Ln 60
ε, >
Libro ANG A Litercc pormuim eclouregue
rep erund C07 ¢b/72, GUOas hore C72 cbelifers
supe P20 γεγο. γε, 7ζξ.
PLATE. 3
/ ; Cc ζ
εξ Spece PLC. of thee WLOUE Woden Othe WCE αι: ὩΣ: ἢ φέροι
2. me she. morte Unters . Vhe fe tah Mow 2 “ζω ΕΣ
> 7 2; = SG AE 3
Unticr/ Cervespondend to he fo wl rome Strichews eS WA.
ἀράν
Ἄν,
SECT. LV. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 181
have observed that the easiest, and most natural expression of the
abstract conceptions of the mind, was by arbitrary marks: but yet
the most ingenious way of representing them was by analogic or sym-
bolic figures ; as omniscience, by an eye; ingratitude, by a viper;
impudence, by the river-horse. Now the Egyptians, who were of a
lively imagination, and studious of natural knowledge, though at first,
like the Chinese, they expressed mental ideas by arbitrary marks,
yet, as they improved their inventive faculties by use, they fell natu-
rally into this method of expressing them by analogic or symbolic
figures ; and their love of mystery disposed them to cultivate it: for
these figures necessarily make the Character mysterious, as implying
in the Inventor, and requiring in the User, a knowledge of physics ;
whereas arbitrary marks lie open to all, as requiring no knowledge
but that of the institution. Hence we have a plain reason how it
happened, that the Egyptian Hieroglyphics, from very early times,
consisted principally of symbolic and analogic marks, and that those
Chinese Hieroglyphics were turned altogether into marks by institu-
tion. For as the Egyptians had soon learnt to express abstract ideas
by analogic signs, so the Chinese were at last drawn to express even
material things by arbitrary marks.
In a word, the Chinese method of thus conducting hieroglyphic
writing through all its changes and improvements, from a picture to
a simple mark, was the occasion that the Missionaries, who con-
sidered the history of their writing only by parts, have given us such
different accounts of it. Sometimes they represent it like the
Mexican pictures ; sometimes like the knotted cords of the Peru-
vians ; sometimes as approaching to the characters found upon the
Egyptian obelisques ; and sometimes again as of the nature of the
Arabic marks for numbers. But each man speaks only of the monu-
ments of which he himself had got information ; and these differed
according to their age and place. He, whose attention was taken up
with the most ancient only of the Chinese monuments, did not hesi-
tate to pronounce them hieroglyphies, like the Egyptian ; because he
saw them to be analogic or symbolic signs, like the Egyptian: he
who considered only the characters of later use denied them to be
like the Egyptian, because he found them to be only marks by
institution.
These imperfect accounts have misled the learned into several mis-
takes concerning the general nature and use of Hieroglyphics them-
selves. Some supposing it of their nature to be obvious marks of
institution ; and others, that it required a very comprehensive know-
ledge of physics to be able to compose them.
Mr. Freret, speaking of the Chinese characters, says, ‘“ Selon eux
{les Chinois] ces anciens caractéres etoient. tous fondés sur des raisons
182 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK I¥-
philosophiques. Tls exprimoient la nature des. choses qu’ils signifi-
cient : ou du moins la determinoient en désignant les rapports de ces
mémes choses avec d’autres mieux connues.”* But he doubts
whether entire credit is to be given to their accounts ; for he observes
that “La construction d’une pareille langue demande une parfaite
connoissance de la nature et de Yordre des idées qu’il faut exprimer,
e’est-a-dire, une bonne metaphysique, et, peut-étre meme un systeme
eomplet de philosophie.—Les Chinois n’ont jamais eu rien de pareil.”
He concludes therefore, that the Chinese hieroglyphics “n’ont jamais
eu qu’en rapport d’1nsTITUTION avec les choses qu’elles signifient.”
This is strange reasoning. ΤῸ know whether the ancient Chinese
characters were founded on philosophic relations, does not depend on
their haying a true system of physics and metaphysics, but on their
having a system simply, whether true or false, to which to adapt
those Characters: Thus, that part of the Egyptian physics which
taught, that the viper tore its way through its mother’s entrails, and
that the skin of the hyzena preserved the wearer invulnerable, served
full as well for hieroglyphical uses, as the soundest part of their
astronomy, which placed the sun in the center of its system.
Again, others have denied the Chinese characters to be properly
Hieroglyphics, because they are arbitrary marks and not analogical.
P. Parennin says, ‘‘ Les caractéres Chinois ne sont hieroglyphes qu’im-
proprement.—Ce sont des signes arbditraires qui nous donnent lidée
dune chose, non par aucun rapport qu ils aient avec la chose signi-
fiée, mais parce qu’on a voulu par tel signe signifier telle chose.—En
est-il de méme des hieroglyphes Egyptiens?”’? P. Gaubil says,—
‘On voit Vimportance d’une histoire critique sur lorigine et les
changemens arrivés & plusieurs caractéres Chinois qui sont certaine-
ment hieroglyphes. D’un autre cété, il y a des caractéres Chinois,
qui certainement ne sont pas hieroglyphes. Une histoire de ceux-ci
seroit aussi importante.” These Fathers, we see, suppose it essential
to hieroglyphic characters, that they be analogic or symbolic signs ;
and finding the more modern Chinese writing to be chiefly composed
of arbitrary marks, or signs by institution, they concluded that the
Chinese characters were not properly Hieroglyphics. Whereas, what
truly denotes a writmg to be hieroglyphical is, that its marks are
signs for THINGS; what denotes a writing not to be hieroglyphical, is
that its marks are signs for worps. Whether the marks be formed
by analogy or institution makes -no alteration in the nature of the
writing. If they be signs for things, they can be nothing but
hieroglyphics ; if they be signs for words, they may be, and I sup-
pose always are, alphabetical characters; but never can be hiero-
glyphics. However, it is but justice to these learned Fathers to
* Mem, de Acad. tom. vi. p. 609.
SECT. Iv. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 183
observe, that one of them, from whom the others might have profited,
‘appears to have a much clearer conception of this matter.—‘ La
nature des hieroglyphes’’ (says he) “‘n’est pas d’étre des figures
naturelles des choses qu’ils signifient, mais seulement de les repre-
senter ou naturellement, ou par Vinstitution des hommes. Or tous
les lettres Chinoises, ou sont des figures naturelles, comme les an-
ciennes, du soleil, de la lune, ou autres semblables, ou sont des figures
destinées pour signifier quelque chose, comme sont toutes celles qui
signifient des choses qui n’ont aucune figure ; comme l’ame, la beauté,
les vertus, les vices, et toutes les actions des hommes et des animaux.” *
On the whole, therefore, we see that, before the institution of
letters to express souNnDs, all characters denoted only THINGs ;
1. By representation. 2. By analogy or symbols. 3. By arbitrary
institution. Amongst the Mexicans, the first method was principally
in use: The Egyptians chiefly cultivated the second: And the
Chinese, in course of time, reduced almost all their characters to the
third. But the empires of China and Egypt long flourishing in their
different periods, had time and inclination to cultivate all the three
species of hieroglyphic writing: only with this difference ; the Egyp-
tians beginning, like the Mexicans, with a picture, and being ingeni-
ous and much given to mystery, cultivated a species of hieroglyphics
most abounding in signs by analogy, or symbols; whereas the
Chinese, who set out like the Peruvians with a knotted cord,t and
were less inventive, and without a secret worship, cultivated that
species which most abounds in marks of arbitrary institution.t
In a word, all the barbarous nations upon earth, before the inven-
tion or introduction of letters, made use of Hieroglyphics, or signs for
things, to record their meaning: the more gross, by representation ;
the more subtile and civilized, by analogy and institution.
Tuus we have brought down the general history of writing, by a
gradual and easy descent, from a PICTURE to a LETTER ; for Chinese
marks which participate of Egyptian hieroglyphics on the one hand,
and of alphabetic letters on the other (just as those hieroglyphics par-
took equally of Mexican pictures and Chinese characters) are on the
very border of letters; an ALPHABET invented to express sounds
instead of things being only a compendium of that large volume of
arbitrary marks.
Some alphabets, as the Ethiopic and Coptic,§ have taken in hiero-
glyphic figures to compose their letters ; which appears both from
their shapes and names. The ancient Egyptian did the same, as
* P. MaGalILuans, Relat. de la Chine. + “Les premiers inventeurs de I’écri-
ture Chinoise, en s’attachant 4 des signes, qui n’ont qu’un rapport d’institution avec les
choses signifiées, ont suivi le génie de la nation Chinoise; qui méme avant Fo-hi, c’est
a dire, dans la plus prefonde antiquité, se servoit de cordelettes nouées en guise d’écri-
ture.”— Mem. de I’ Acad. tom. vi. FRERET. 1 See note S, at the end of this book.
§ See note T, at the end of this book.
184 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOR I¥-
a learned French writer hath shewn in a very ingenious and convine-
ing manner.* But this is seen even from the names which express
letters and literary-writing in the ancient languages: thus the Greek
words ΣΗΜΕΙ͂Α and ΣΉΜΑΤΑ signify as well the images of
natural things as artificial marks or characters ; and TPA®® is both
to paint and to write. The not attending to this natural and easy
progress of hieroglyphic images from pictures to alphabetic letters,
made some amongst the ancients, as Plato and Tully, when struck
with the wonderful artifice of an ALPHABET, conclude that it was no
human invention, but the gift of the immortal Gods.
Here then we see the first beginnings of Hieroglyphics amongst the
Mexicans, and the end of them amongst the Chinese; yet we never
find them employed in either of these places for mystery or conceal-
ment: what there was of this practice, therefore, in the middle stage
of their cultivation amongst the Egyptians, we must needs conclude
had some private or peculiar cause, unrelated to their, general nature.
But the course of the Mexican empire was too short to improve
picture into an hieroglyphic ; and the Chinese, which, in its long
duration, hath brought this picture down, through hieroglyphics, to a
simple mark, or character, hath not yet (from the poverty of its
inventive genius,} and its aversion to foreign commerce) been able to
find out an abridgment of those marks, by letters ; it was the old and
well established monarchy of Egypt, so propitious to arts and eivil
policy, which carried the picrure, through all the stages of its
improvement, quite down to LETTERS, the invention of this ingenious
people.t
Now such a general concurrence in the method of recording the
thoughts, can never be supposed the effect of chance, imitation, or
partial purposes; but must needs be esteemed the uniform voice of
nature, speaking to the first rude conceptions of mankind: for the
reader may be pleased to observe, that not only the Chinese of the
East, the Mexicans of the West, and the Egyptians of the South, but
the Scythians likewise of the North (not to speak of those interme-
diate inhabitants of the earth, the Indians, Phcenicians, Ethiopians,
Etruscans, &c.) all used the same way of writing by picture and
hieroglyphic. ὃ
But to shew still clearer, that it was nature and necessity, not
choice and artifice, which gave birth and continuance to these several
specieses of hieroglyphic writing, we shall now take a view of the
* See note U, at the end of this book. + See note X, at the end of this book.
1 “Primi per figuras animalium ASGyPTIi sensus mentis efingebant; et antiquissima
monumenta memorize humane impressa saxis cernuntur, et /itterarwm semet inventores
perhibent; inde Pheenicas, quia mari prepollebant, intulisse Grecie, gloriamque
adeptos, tanquam repererint, que acceperant.”—Tacit! Annales, lib. xi. cap. 14.
§ See note Y, at the end of this book.
SECT. IV. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 185
rise and progress of its sister-art, the art of sprEcH; and having set
them together and compared them, we shall see with pleasure, how
great a lustre they mutually reflect upon one another; for, as St.
Austin elegantly expresses it, Signa sint VERBA VISIBILIA ; verba,
SIGNA AUDIBILIA,. "
I. LaneuaGe, as appears from the nature of the thing, from the
records of history, and from the remains of the most ancient. lan-
guages yet remaining, was at first extremely rude, narrow, and
equivocal: * so that men would be perpetually at a loss, on any new
conception, or uncommon accident, to explain themselves intelligibly
to one another ; the art of inlarging language by a scientific analogy
being a late invention: this would necessarily set them upon supply-
ing the deficiencies of speech by apt and significant stens.¢ Accord-
ingly, in the first ages of the world, mutual converse was upheld by
a mixed discourse of words and actTiGNs; hence came the eastern
phrase of the voice of the sign; t and use and custom, as in most
other affairs of life, improving what had arisen out of necessity, into
ornament, this practice subsisted long after the necessity was over;
especially amongst the eastern people, whose natural temperament
inclined them to a mode of conversation, which so well exercised their
vivacity, by motion; and so much gratified it, by a perpetual repre-
sentation of material images. Of this we have innumerable instances
in holy Scripture: as where the false prophet pushed with horns of
iron, to denote the entire overthrow of the Syrians ; § where Jeremiah,
by God’s direction, hides the linen girdle in a hole of the rock near
Euphrates ; || where he breaks a potter’s vessel in sight of the peo-
ple, 4 puts on bonds and yokes, ** and casts a book into Euphra-
tes ; ++ where Ezekiel, by the same appointment, delineates the siege
of Jerusalem ona tile ; ΤΤ weighs the hair of his beard in balances ; ὁ ὃ
carries out his houshold-stuff; |||| and jos together the two sticks
for Judah and Israel.4[/4{ By these actions the prophets instructed
the people in the will of God, and conversed with them in signs : but
where God teaches the prophet, and, in compliance to the custom of
that time, condescends to the same mode of instruction, then the
significative action is generally changed into a vision, either natural
or extraordinary: as where the prophet Jeremiah is bid to regard the
rod of the almond-tree, and the seething pot; *** the work on the
potter’s wheel, +++ and the baskets of good and bad figs; t{t and
* See note Z, at the end of this book. + If this be true, it must be the case at
all times, and in all places, where language remains within those narrow bounds. Thus
Lafitau, speaking of the savages of North America, observes, ‘‘ Ils parlent antant du
GESTE que de la voix.”—Mewurs des Sauvages, vol. i. p. 482, 4to edit. 1 Exod.
iv. 8. And not for the reason given by Le Clerc on the place: ‘ Ideoque vow iis [pro-
digiis] tribuitur, cum eorum opera Deus, non minus ac voce, suum hunce prophetam esse
significaret.”’ § 1 Kings xxii. 11. || Jer. xiii. | Chap. xix.
** Chap. xxvii. tt Chap. li. tt Ezek. iv. §§ Chap. v. ||| Chap. xii.
19 Chap. xxxvii. 16. ΝΕ Jer. i, ttt Chap. xviii. ΠῚ Chap. xxiv.
186 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
the prophet Ezekiel, the ideal scene of the resurrection of dry
bones.* The significative action, I say, was, in this case, generally
changed into a vision; but not always. For as sometimes, where the
instruction was for the people, the significative action was, perhaps,
in vision : so, sometimes again, though the information was only for
the prophet, God would set him upon a real expressive action, whose
obyious meaning conveyed the intelligence proposed or sought. Of
this, we shall give, at the expence of infidelity, a very illustrious
instance.t The excellent Maimonides, not attending to this primitive
mode of information, is much scandalized at several of these actions,
unbecoming, as he supposed, the dignity of the prophetic office ; and
is therefore for resolving them in general into supernatural visions,
-impressed on the imagination of the prophet; 1 and this, because
some few of them may, perhaps, admit of such an interpretation.
In which he is followed by Christian writers,§ much to the discredit,
as I conceive, of Revelation ; and to the triumph of libertinism and
infidelity ; || the actions of the prophets being delivered as realities ;
and these writers representing them as mean, absurd, and fanatical,
and exposing the prophet to contempt.4{ - But what is it they gain by
this expedient? The charge of absurdity and fanaticism will follow
the prophet in his visions, when they have removed it from his
waking actions: for if these actions were absurd and fanatical in the
real representation, they must needs be so in the imaginary ; the same
turn of mind operating both asleep and awake.** The judicious
reader therefore cannot but observe that the reasonable and true
defence of the prophetic writings is what is here offered: where we
shew, that information by action was, at this time, and place, a very
familiar mode of conversation. This once seen, all charge of absur-
dity, and suspicion of fanaticism, vanish of themselves: the absurdity
of an action consists in its being extravagant and insignificative ; but
use and a fixed application made these in question both sober and perti-
* Ezek. xxxvii. 2. + See the case of Abraham, book vi. sect. 5. t More
Nevochim, p. ii. cap. xlvi. which chapter he thus intitles, Quéd opera ea, que prophete
dicunt se fecisse, non fuerint facta revera et externe, sed tantum in visione prophetie 5
‘and then goes on :—“ Scias ergo, quemadmodum in somnio accidit, ut homini videatur,
ac si in hance vel illam regionem profectus esset, uxorem in ea duxisset, ac ad tempus
aliquod ibi habitasset, filium, quem N, appellarit, et qui talis aut talis fuerit, ex ea sus-
cepisset ; ita se quoque rem habere in illis parabolis prophetarum, quas vident aut
faciunt in visione prophetiz. Quicquid enim docent parabol ill de actione aliqua et
rebus, quas propheta facit, de mensura et spatio temporis inter unam et alteram
actionem, de profectione ex uno loco in alium: illud omne non est nisi in visione pro-
phetica, nequaquam verd sunt actiones vere et in sensus incurrentes, licet quedam
partes precisé et absoluté commemorentur in libris prophétarum.” § Vide Joannis
SmitH, Theol. Cantah., Dissertutionem de Prophetia et Prophetis ex transl. Jounnis
Clerici, cap. vi. and his late followers. || See note AA, at the end of this book.
Ἵ See note BB, at the end of this book. ** << Prophetic dreams and visions were 50
very lively” (says a learned writer) “ and affected the imagination with such force, that the
prophet himself could rot at the time distinguish such visions From realities. Something
of ὍΝ kind we experience in our dreams and reveries.”’ —See ἐς Dissertation on Balaam,”
p- 193.
SECT. ἂν. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 187
nent : the fanaticism of an action consists in a fondness for unusual
actions and foreign modes of speech; but those in question were
idiomatic and familiar. To illustrate this last observation by a
domestic example: when the sacred writers talk of being born after
the spirit, of being fed with the sincere milk of the word, of putting
their tears into a bottle, of bearing testimony against lying vanities, of
taking the veil from men’s hearts, and of building up one another ;
they speak the common, yet proper aud pertinent phraseology of their
country ; and not the least imputation of fanaticism can stick upon
these original expressions. But when we see our own countrymen
reprobate their native idiom, and affect to employ only scripture
phrases in their whole conversation, as if some imherent sanctity
resided in the Hastern modes of expression, we cannot chuse but sus-
pect such men far gone in the delusions of a heated imagination. The
same may be said of significative actions.*
But it is not only in sacred story that we meet with the mode of
speaking by action. Profane antiquity is full of these examples ; and
it is not unlikely but, in the course of our enquiry, we shall have
occasion to produce some of them: the early Oracles in particular
frequently employed it, as we learn from an old saying of Heraclitus :
That the king whose Oracle is at Delphi, neither speaks nor keeps
-silent, but reveals by 5ταν 5.7
Now this way of expressing the thoughts by acrion perfectly
coincided with that, of recording them by picture. ‘There is a
remarkable case in ancient story, which shews the relation between
speaking by action and writing by picture, so strongly, that we shall
need no other proof of the similar nature of these two forms. It is
told by Clemens Alexandrinus: They say, that Idanthura, a king of
the Scythians (as Pherecydes Syrius relates the story), when ready to
oppose Darius, who had passed the Ister, sent the Persian a symbol
instead of letters, namely, a mouse, a frog, a bird, a dart, and a
plow.t Thus this message being to supply both speech and writing,
the purport of it was, we see, expressed by a composition of action
and picture.
II. As speech became more cultivated, this rude manner of speaking
by action was smoothed and polished into an aroLoGuE or fable ;
where the speaker, to inforce his purpose, by a suitable impression,
* See Clem. Walker’s story of the fanatic soldier with his five lights. ‘‘ Hist. Indep.”
part ii. p. 152. + Οὔτε λέγει, οὔτε κρύπτει, ἀλλὰ onmalver.—PLUTARCHUS Περὲ
τοῦ μὴ χρᾷν ἔμμετρα, p. 992, which being a less precise and more equivocal mode
of information excellently well fitted the trade of oracles. The Lacedemonians [see
Herodotus in Thalia] preferred it to speech for another reason, viz. to hinder their being
misled by the illusions of oratory. t Φασὶ γοῦν καὶ ᾿Ιδάνθουραν τῶν Σκυθῶν βασιλέα,
ὡς ἱστορεῖ Φερεκύδης ὃ Σύριος, Δαρείῳ διαβάντι τὸν Ἴστρον πόλεμον ἀπειλοῦντα τσέμψαι
ce ἀντὶ τῶν γραμμάτων, μῦν, βάτραχον, ὄρνιθα, ὀϊστὸν, apoTtpoy.—Strom. lib. v.
Ρ. 567,
188 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IY.
told a familiar tale of his own invention, accompanied with such
circumstances as made his design evident and persuasive: for language
was yet too narrow, and the minds of men too. undisciplined, to
support only abstract reasoning and a direct address. We have a
noble example of this form of instruction in the speech of Jotham to
the men of Shechem; in which he upbraids their folly, and foretells
their ruin, in chusing Abimelech for their king. As this is not only
the oldest, but the most beautifyl * apologue of antiquity, I shall need
po excuse for transcribing it: “The trees went forth on a time to
anoint a king over them, and they said unto the olive-tree, Reign thou
over us. But the olive-tree said unto them, Should I leave my fat-
ness, wherewith, by me, they honour God and man, and go to be
promoted over the trees? And the trees said to the fig-tree, Come
thou, and reign over us. But the fig-tree said unto them, Should I
forsake my sweetness, and my good fruit, and go to be promoted
over the trees? Then said the trees unto the vine, Come thou, and
reign over us. And the vine said unto them, Should I leave my wine,
which cheareth God and man, and go to be promoted over the trees?
Then said all the trees unto the bramble, Come thou, and reign over
us. And the bramble said unto the trees, If in truth ye anoint me
king over you, then come and put your trust in my shadow: and if
not, let fire come out of the bramble, and devour the cedars of
Lebanon.” +
How nearly the apologue and instruction by action are related, may
be seen in the account of Jeremiah’s adventure with the Rechab-
ites; { an instruction partaking of the joint nature of action and
apologue.
This was the birth of the raBLe; a kind of speech which corre-
sponds, in all respects, to writing by hieroglyphics, each being the
symbol of something else understood. And, as it sometimes hap-
pened, when au Hieroglyphic became famous, it lost its particular
signification, and assumed a general one; as the Caduceus, for instance,
which was, at first, painted only to denote the pacific office of Hermes,
became, in time, to be the common symbol of league and amity: so
it was with the Apologue ; of which, when any one became celebrated
for the art and beauty of its composition, or for some extraordinary
efficacy in its application, it was soon converted and worn into a
PROVERB. We have a fine instance of this in the message of Jehoash
to Amaziah, “Saying, The thistle that was in Lebanon, sent to the
cedar that was in Lebanon, saying, Give thy daughter to my son to
wife: and there passed by a wild beast that was in Lebanon, and
trode down the thistle. Thou hast indeed smitten Edom, and thine
* See note CC, at the end of this book. + See note DD, at the end of this
book. + Jer, xxxv.
SECT, Iv. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. ὁ "189
heart hath lifted thee up: glory of this, and tarry at home: for why
shouldest thou meddle to thy hurt, that thou shouldest fall, even thou
and Judah with thee?” * Where we see plainly that this satyric
apologue of the thistle and cedar was now become a proverb: of a
like kind is that of the prophet; Howl, fir tree, for the cedar is
fallen ; + to denote the danger of the lower people, when their
superiors cannot withstand the civil tempest. .
III. But as speech improved into an art, the Apologue was con-
tracted into a SIMILE, in which men consulted closeness as well as
brevity ; for here the subject itself being still kept in sight, there was
no need, as in the Apologue, of a formal application : and how easily
the Apologue slid into the Stmilitude, we may see by the following
passage of Jeremiah, which, being something between both these
forms of speech, communicates of either’s nature: The Lord called
thy name a green olive-tree, fair and of goodly fruit: with the noise
of a great tumult he hath kindled fire upon it, and the branches of it
are broken, Sc.t This way of speaking by Simile, we may conceive
to answer to the Chinese marks or characters in writing.
Again, as from such marks proceeded the abbreviated method of
alphabetic letters, so from the Simile, to make language still more
expedite and elegant, came the METAPHOR; which is indeed but a
Simile in little: for men so conversant in matter still wanted sensible
images to convey abstract ideas. The steps by which the Simle was
contracted into the Metaphor, may be easily traced by a careful perusal
of the prophetic writings; there being no mode of speech more
common than that compounded of both; where the Sunzle is just
about to be forsaken, and the Metaphor to be received. In this
manner are God’s judgments denounced against the king of Assyria :
** Therefore thus saith the Lord God, because thou hast lifted up thy-
self in height, and he hath shot up his top amongst the thick boughs,
and his heart is lifted up in his height; I have therefore delivered
him into the hand of the mighty one of the heathen :—and strangers,
the terrible of the nations, have cut him off, and have left him: upon
the mountains and in all the valleys his branches are fallen, and his
boughs are broken by all the rivers of the land, and all the people of
the earth are gone down from his shadow, and have left him. Upon
his ruin shall all the fowls of heaven remain, and all the beasts of the
field shall be upon his branches. To the end that none of all the
trees by the waters exalt themselves for their height, neither shoot up
their top amongst the thick boughs.”’§ Quintilian considering this
matter in an inverted order, yet makes an observation, where he
speaks of metaphors, much to our purpose.—“ Continuus [usus] vero
* 2 Kings xiv. 9, 10. + Zech. xi, 2. t Jer. xi. 16. § Ezek. xxxi.
10, et seq.
190 - THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV;
in allegoriam et senigmata exit.” * That is, As the allegory may, by
degrees, be contracted into a Metaphor, so the Metaphor, by beating
long upon it, may be drawn back again into an allegory.
As the Simile slid into a Metaphor, so the metaphor often softened
into a simple rprrHet, which soon discharged all the colouring of
the figure. This is observable in the words decrepit,+ capricious, and.
a great many others, when applied either to the body or mind.
Which being first used in simile, then in metaphor, at length, by fre-
quent use in epithet, lost the very memory of their original.t
Thus we see the common foundation of all these various modes of
WRITING and SPEAKING, WaS ἃ PICTURE Or IMAGE, presented to the
imagination through the eyes and ears ; which being the simplest and
most universal of all kinds of information (the first reaching those
who could not decypher the arbitrary characters of an alphabet ;
and the latter instructing those who were yet strangers to abstract
terms), we must needs conclude to be the natural inventions of rude
necessity.
And here it may not be amiss to repeat an observation made before,
that the primitive and more simple way of expression, whether in
writing or speaking, did not always straight grow into disuse on the
invention of a more improved manner. Thus we see in Scripture,
the way of speaking by action was still used after the introduction of
the Apologue ; and the Apologue, after that of the Simile and Meta-
phor. And so again in writing; the first and simplest hieroglyphics
continued to be used in Egypt (as we shall see) long after the refine-
ment of them into those more artful ones called symbolical; and
these, after that further improvement into characters or marks resem-
bling the Chinese, and even after the invention of Jetéers.
But how, as in these several modes of speech, so in the several
forms of writing, men made a virtue of necessity, and turned that
into ornament and mystery, which had its birth in poverty, and was
Drought up in simplicity and plainness, is to be our next enquiry.
II.
It is now, I suppose, apparent, that the hitherto received opinion,
that the Egyptians invented hieroglyphics to conceal their knowledge,
and render it mysterious, is altogether without foundation. However,
as it is very certain they did, at length, employ hieroglyphic writing to
such a purpose, it will be proper to examine how this came about ;
How one of the simplest and plainest means of instruction came to be
converted into one of the most artificial and abstruse.
* Lib, viii. cap. 6. + ©Decrepirus. Comparatio vite nostre cum lucerna
nota fuit Latinis, ut patet ex decrepitorum senum nuncupatione.”—Prima Scaligerana,
p: 48. 1 See note EE, at the end of this book.
SECT. IV. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 191
To support what we have to say on this head with proper authority,
it will be necessary to produce two important passages from Porphyry
and Clemens Alexandrinus, concerning the several natures and kinds
of Egyptian writing. On these, we shall regulate our discourse ;
which will, in its turn, contribute to illustrate these passages, hitherto,
as we conceive, very imperfectly understood.
But it will be proper first of all to give the reader a general idea of
the several natures and kinds of Egyptian writing, according to the
order of time in which each was. invented and improved; and for the
truth, as well as perfect intelligence of the account, refer him to the
whole of the discourse.
Egyptian writing was of four kinds: the first, HTEROGLYPHIC, and
this twofold: the more rude, called ewriologie ; and the more artificial,
called tropical: the second, symMBoxic ; and this likewise was two-
fold; the more simple, and the more mysterious ; that ¢ropical, this
allegorical. These two kinds of writing, namely the hieroglyphic and
symbolic (which went under the generic term of hieroglyphics, dis-
tinguished into proper, and symbolic hieroglyphics), were not composed
of the letters of an alphabet, but of marks or characters which stood
for THINGS, not words. The third ΠΡΙΒΤΟΙΙΟ, so called, as we shall
see, from its being first applied to civil matters: and the fourth and
last, HIEROGRAMMATIC, from its being used only in religious. These
two last kinds of writing, namely, the epistolic and hierogrammatic,
expressed worps, and were formed by the letters of an alphabet.
We come now to the passages in question. Porphyry, speaking of
Pythagoras, tells us: That he sojourned with the priests in Egypt, and
learnt the wisdom and the language of the country, together with their
three sorts of letters, the episroLic, the HIEROGLYPHIC, and the
SYMBOLIC; of which the HIEROGLYPHIC expressed the meaning of the
writer, by an imitation or picture of the thing intended to be expressed ;
and the sympBoutc, by allegorical enigmas,* Clemens is larger and
more explicit :—Now those who are instructed in the Egyptian wisdom,
learn first of all the method of their several sorts of letters ; the first
of which is called EPistouic ; the second SACERDOTAL, us being used
by the sacred scribes ; the last, with which they conclude their instruc-
tions, HIEROGLYPHICAL. Of these different methods, the one is in
the plain and common way of writing by the first elements of words,
or letters of an alphabet ; the other by symBous. Of the symbolic .
way of writing, which is of three kinds ; the first is that plain and?
common one of imitating the figure of the thing represented; the
second is by tropical marks; and the third, in a contrary way, of
allegorizing by Enigmas. Of the first sort, namely, by a plain and
direct imitation of the figure, let this stand for an instance :—to
* See note FF, at the end of this book.
02 . THE DIVINE LEGATION ᾿ BOOK Iv.
signify the sun, they made a circle; the moon; a half circle. The
second, or tropical way of writing, is by changing and transferring the
ryject with justness and propriety: * this they do, sometimes by a
simple change, sometimes by a complex multifarious transformation ;
‘hus they leave engraven + on stones and pillars the praises of their
vengs, under the cover of theologic fables. Of the third sort, by
nigmas, take this example: the oblique course of the stars occasioned
heir representing them by the bodies of serpents ; but the sun they
ikened to a scarabeus, because this insect makes a round ball of
east’s dung, and rolls it circularly, with its face opposed.to that
uminary.t
Thus these two ancient Greeks: but both of them being in the
general mistake concerning the original of the Egyptian hierogly-
phics, it is no wonder their accounts should be inaccurate and con-
fused. The first mistake common to both, and the natural conse-
quence of that false principle, is making the EpisroLaRyY writing
first, mm order of time,§ which was indeed the last. For that this
was their sentiment appears from Clemens’s calling hieroglyphic
writing ὑστάτην καὶ τελευταίαν, the last and most perfect kind. The
second common mistake is their counting but three sorts of writing,
when, indeed, there were four; as is discoverable even from their own
reckoning: Porphyry naming epistolic, hieroglyphic, and symbolic ;
Clemens, epistolic, sacerdotal, and hieroglyphical ; the First leaving
out sacerdotal, which the Second supplies; and the Second symbolic,
which the first supplies. Their other mistakes are peculiar to each :
Clemens errs most in enumerating the several sorts ; and Porphyry in
explaining their several natures. .
This latter writer names the three sorts, epistolic, hieroglyphic, and
symbolic ; and this was not much amiss, because the fourth, the
jierogrammatic, or sacerdotal, not differing from the epistolic in its
nature, but only in its use, he comprised it, we may suppose, under
the generic term of epistolic: but when he comes to explain the
nature of the symbolic, which is performed two ways, tropically and
allegorically, he quite omits the first, and insists only on the latter.
Clemens, on the other hand, gives us these three kinds, the epis-
folie, the sacerdotal or hierogrammatical, and the hieroglyphical.
Here epistolic is used as a specific term, and hieroglyphical as a generic ;
just contrary to Porphyry, who, in his enumeration, employs them the
ther way: but then, as to their nature, Clemens says, the epistolic
and sacerdotal were by letters of an alphabet, and the hieroglyphic by
symbols : the first part of the explanation is exact. We have observed
“ See note GG, at the end of this book. + See note HH, at the end of this
book. 1 See note II, at the end of this book. § See note KK, at the end
of this book. ©
SECT. Iv. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 193
that Porphyry judiciously omits to explain epistolary writing, as
supposing it to be well known: but Clemens, who adds. to epistolary,
sacerdotal, a way of writing, though like the epistolary, by an alpha-
bet, yet being confined to the use of the priests, not so well known,
he with equal judgment explains their nature: but the latter part of
his account, where he says hieroglyphic writing was by symbols,
making symbolic, which is a specific term, to be equivalent to hiero-
glyphical, which he uses generically, is an unlucky blunder ; of which
this is the consequence, that proceeding to divide symbolic, as a
generic term, into three sorts, curiologic, tropical, and allegorical ;
he falls into a direct contradiction: τῆς δὲ Ξυμθολικῆς, says he, 7 μὲν
κυριολογεῖται κατὰ μίμησιν, the first kind of symbolic writing is by
a plain and simple imitation of the figure of the thing intended to be
represented ; which is directly contrary to the very nature of a sym-
bol; a symbol being the representation of one thing by the figure of
another. For instance, it was the bull Apis, and not the picture or
image of Osiris, that was the symbol of Osiris : Clemens therefore, we
conceive, should have said—hieroglyphics were written curiologically
and symbolically ; that the curiologic hieroglyphics were by imitation ;
the symbolic, by conversion ; and that, of this conversion, there were
two kinds, the fropical and allegorical ; and then all had answered
to his foregoing division. For the rest, He explains the nature of
euriologic and symbolic hieroglyphics with sufficient exactness ; save
that the first instance he gives of allegoric symbols seems to belong
to the tropical.
Thus we see how these writers contribute to the correcting one
another’s mistakes. What is necessary for the further clearing up
their accounts, which, obscure as they are, are the best that antiquity
will afford us, shall be occasionally considered as we go along.
Let us next enquire how HIEROGLYPHICS came to be employed for
the vehicle of mystery.
I. The Egyptians, in the beginnings of their monarchy, wrote like
all other infant nations, in a kind of universal character by picture ;
of which rude original essays, we have yet some traces remaining
amongst the hieroglyphics of Horapollo; who tells us, that the
ancient Egyptians painted ἃ man’s two feet in water to signify a
fuller,* and smoke ascending upwards to aenote fire.t But to render
this rude invention less incommodious, they soon devised the more
artful way of putting one single figure for the mark or repre-
sentative of several things; and thus made their picture an HIERO-
GLYPHIC.
This was the first improvement of that rude and barbarous way of
recording men’s ideas ; and was practised in a twofold manner ; the
* Horap. lib. i. cap, 65. + Lib. ii. cap. 16,
YOL. II. ο
104 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
one more simple, by putting the principal part for the whole; the
other more artificial, by putting one thing, of resembling qualities, for
another. The first species was the CURIOLOGIC HIEROGLYPHIC ;
the second, the TROPICAL HIEROGLYPHIC; the latter of which was
a gradual improvement on the former; as appears both from the
nature of the thing, and from the records of antiquity. Thus the
moon was sometimes represented by a half circle, sometimes by a
cynocephalus :* The overflowings of the Nile, sometimes by a spread-
ing water in heaven and earth, sometimes by a lion s+ (a hieroglyphic,
we may suppose, invented after they had learnt a little astronomy) :
a judge, sometimes by a man without hands, holding down his eyes,t
to denote the duty of being unmoved by interest or pity : sometimes
by a dog near a royal robe ; ὃ for they had a superstition that a dog,
of all animals, was only privileged to see the gods ; and it was an old
custom for their judges to behold and examine their kings naked :
Now in all these instances we see the first hieroglyphic is euriological ;
the second, tropical.
The Egyptians therefore, employed, as we say, the proper hiero- -
glyphics to record, openly and plainly, their laws, policies, public
morals, and history ; and in a word, all kinds of civil matters.
1. This is seen from those remaining monuments of old Egyptian
wisdom, the OBELISKS. || That very ancient one of Ramesses, now
standing before the pontific palace in Rome, and first erected to
adorn the city of Heliopolis, is full of hieroglyphic characters ; these
Hermapion translated into Greek ; and part of his translation is pre-
served in Ammianus Marcellinus. By which it appears, that the
writings on this obelisk contained only a panegyric on Ramesses, and
a history of his conquests. But this was not the subject of one only,
but of all the obelisks in general. We have seen already, and shall
see further, what Clemens Alexandrinus hath observed to this purpose.
Diodorus saith, that Sesostris erected two obelisks of very durable
stone, each twenty cubits high; on which he engraved the number
of his forces, the particulars of his revenue, and a catalogue of the
nations he had conquered.** At Thebes, Strabo telleth us, there were
certain obelisks with inscriptions recording the riches and power of
their kings, and the extensiveness of their dominion, stretching into
Scythia, Bactria, India, and the country now called Ionia ; together
with the multitude of their tributes, and the number of the soldiery,
* Horap. lib. i. cap. 14. + Lib. i. cap. 21. t PLurarcn. Is et Ostr.—
Diop. Sic. lib. i. § Horap. lib. i. cap. 40. || See note LL, at the end of
this book. Ἵ “0 Aigypte, Augypte, Religionum tuarum sole supererunt fabule, et
wque incredibiles Posteris suis ; solaque supererunt verba LAPIDIBUS incisa, TUA FACTA
NARRANTIBUS.”—APULEIUS, Elmenh. ed. p. 90. ** Avo δὲ λιθίνους "O6eAtoKous ἐκ
τοῦ σκληροῦ λίθου, wnxa@v τὸ ὕψος εἴκοσι wpds τοῖς ἑκατὸν, ἐφ᾽ Gv ἐπέγραψε τότε
μέγεθος τῆς δυνάμεως καὶ τὸ τολῆθος τῶν «σροσόδων. καὶ τὸν ἀριθμὸν τῶν καταπολε-
μηθέντων ἐθνῶν.-- Τὰν». i, p. 37, Stephani ed.
SECT. IV. OF-MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 195
which consisted of a million of men:* And Proclus assureth us,
That the Egyptians recorded all singular events, memorable actions
and new inventions on columns, or stone pillars.t Tacitus is more
particular than the rest: for speaking of Germanicus’s voyage into
Egypt, and his curiosity in examining its antiquities, he saith: Mow
visit veterum Thebarum magna vestigia ; et manebant structis molibus
littere Lgyptie, priorum opulentiam complexe : jussusque ὃ senioribus
sacerdotum patrium sermonem interpretari, referebat habitasse quon-
dam septingenta millia etate militari: atque eo cum ewxercitu regem
Rhamsen Libya, Aithiopia, Medisque et Persis, et Bactriano, ac
Scythia potitum; quasque terras Syri Armeniique et contigui Cap-
padoces colunt, inde Bythynum, hine Lycium ad mare imperio tenuisse.
Legebantur et indicta gentibus tributa, pondus argenti et auri, numerus
armorum equorumque, et dona templis, ebur atque odores, quasque
copias frumenti et omnium utensilium queque natio penderet, haud
minus magnifica, quam nunc, vi Parthorum, aut potentia Romana,
jubentur.t But to obviate at once all the cavils of Kircher against
this concurrent testimony, I observe, in the last place, that it receives
the fullest confirmation from that excellent treatise of Horapollo,
which consists chiefly of the ancient and proper hieroglyphics ; all of
them relating to civil life, and altogether unfit for the abstruse specu-
lations of philosophy and theology.
2. This is further seen from that celebrated inscription on the
temple of Minerva at Sais, so much spoken of by the Ancients ;
where an infant, an old man, a hawk, a fish, and a river-horse, ex-
pressed this moral sentence, 4// you who come into the world, and go
out of it, know this, that the Gods hate impudence. The excellent
Stillingfleet, who was in the common opinion that the Egyptians
invented hieroglyphics to secrete their profound wisdom, and that
this inscription at Sais was part of that wisdom, pronounces sentence
from hence, on all their mystic learning in general :—< Certainly ”’
(says he) “this kind of learning deserves the highest form amongst
the diffciles nuge ; and all these hieroglyphics put together will
make but one good one, and should be for—labour lost.’ § But
there might be much knowledge in their mystic learning, whatever
becomes of the hieroglyphical inscription at Sais ; which was indeed
no part of that learning, but a plain and public admonition in the
proper hieroglyphic ; so far from being a difficult trifle, to be secreted,
* (Ey δὲ ταῖς ϑήκαις ἐπί τινων ὀδελίσκων ἀναγραφαὶ δηλοῦσαι τὸν WAOUTOY τῶν
τότε βασιλέων, καὶ τὴν ἐπικράτειαν, ws μέχρι Σκυθῶν, καὶ Βακτρίων, καὶ Ινδῶν, καὶ
τῆς νῦν ᾿Ιωνίας διατείνασαν " καὶ φόρων τυλῆθος, καὶ στρατιᾶς wep) ἑκατὸν pupiddas.—
Lib. xvii. + Αἰγυπτίοις δὲ ἔτι καὶ τὰ γεγονότα διὰ τῆς μνήμης" ἀεὶ νέα πσάρεστιν"
ἡ δὲ μνήμη, διὰ τῆς ἱστορίας" αὕτη δὲ ἀπὸ τῶν στυλῶν, ἐν αἷς ἀπεγράφοντο τὰ τσαρά-
δοξα, καὶ τὰ ϑαύματος ἄξια τῶν wpayudtwv, εἴτε ἐν wpdicow, εἴτε ἐν εὑρέσεσιν.---ΡΕ
cLus in Timeum, lib. i. p. 31, f. {t Annal. lib. ii. § Grig. Sacr. lib. ii.
cap. ii. p. 79.
o 2
106 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
that it was a very plain and important truth to be read and under-—
stood by the people; as appears from the place where it was engraved,
the vestibule of a public temple.
And here Kircuer’s visionary labours on this subject might have
been pitied, had he discovered in any of his voluminous writings on
the Hieroglyphics, the least regard to truth or probability. This
learned person had collected a fact from Antiquity, which the noto-
riety of it will not suffer us to call in question, namely, that the old
Egyptians committed their profound and secret wisdom to the seal
of hieroglyphics. Egyptian wisdom was a matter of moment. But
the learned Jesuit did not duly consider, whether any of the vehicles
of that wisdom were yet in being; much less did he reflect that the
same Antiquity which tells us they had much profound wisdom, tells
us likewise, that it was all collected in their sacerdotal books,*
books long since lost ; and that the ancient monuments of stone still
remaining, were records of another nature. However, inflamed with
the glory of a Discoverer, he lanches out in search of this unknown
World; guided by some of the latest Greek writings, in conjunction
with the earliest Egyptian hieroglyphics. The Greek writings indeed
pretended (though very impudently +) to ancient Egyptian wisdom ;
but these hieroglyphics constantly disclaimed it: { By this direction
he steered at large: and it is pleasant to see him labouring through
half a dozen folios with the writings of late Greek Platonists, and the
forged books of Hermes, which contain a philosophy, not Egyptian,
to explain and illustrate old monuments, not philosophical. While
Hermapion, Diodorus, Strabo, Proclus, Tacitus, and Pliny, are care-
fully avoided as false lights, which would drive him upon rocks and
shallows.—But to proceed. i
II. Thus far went the two species, of the proper Hieroglyphic ;
which, in its last stage of the tropical, touched upon SYMBOLS
(of which we are now to speak) they having this in common, that
each represented one thing by another; in this they differed, that the
tropical Hieroglyphic was employed to divulge ; the tropical Symbol,
to secrete: for all the several modes of writing by THINGS having
had their progressive state, from less to more perfection, they easily
fell into one another; so that there was but little difference between
the proper Hieroglyphic in its last state, and the symbolic in its first.
For this method of contriving tropical hieroglyphics, by similar pro-
perties, would of itself produce refinement and nice enquiry into the
more hidden and abstruse qualities of things ; which meeting at the
“ See CLEMENS ALEXAND, Strom. lib. vi. t+ Vol. i. b. iii. § 4. t Thus
in one place he expresses himself :—‘ Plerique feré Herodotum, Diodorum, Plinium
secuti, Obeliscos non nisi historicas regum veterum commemorationes continere opinati
sunt; quod tamen falsum esse, ex dictis /uwce meridiana clarius patet.”’—Pp. 269, 270,
of his dip. i gypt. tom. 111.
SECT. IV, OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 197
same time with a temper now much turned to speculation* on
matters of theology and philosophy, would as naturally introduce a
new species of zoographic writing, called by the ancients syMBOLIC,
and employed for secrecy ; + which the high speculations, conveyed
in it, required; and for which it was well fitted by the enigmatic
quaintness of its representations.
As the proper Hieroglyphics were of two kinds, curiological and
tropical, so were SYMBOLS; the moré natural, simply TROPICAL; the
more artificial, ENIGMATICAL.
1. TropicaL symbols were made by employing the less known
properties of things. The quality was sometimes used for the sake
of a fanciful resemblance ; as a ca¢ stood for the moon, because they
observed the pupil of her eye to be filled and enlarged at the full
moon, and to be contracted and diminished during its decrease : ὦ
sometimes it was founded on the natural history of an animal; as a
serpené represented the divine nature, on account of its great vigour
and spirit, its long age and reviresence.§ How easily the ¢ropical
hieroglyphic fell into the tropical symbol, we may see by the following
instances : eternity was sometimes expressed by the sun and moon,
sometimes by the basilisk ; || Hyypt, sometimes by the crocodile,
sometimes by a burning censer with a heart upon it: where the
simplicity of the first representation and the abstruseness of the
latter, in each instance, shew, that the one was a tropical hieroglyphic
employed for communication ; the other a tropical symbol contrived
for secrecy.
2. EN1GMATIC symbols were formed by the mysterious assemblage
of different things, as in the Caduceus; or of the parts of different
animals, as in a serpent with a hawk’s head ;** or of things and
animals together, as in a serpent with a hawk’s head in a circle : ++
the change of the tropical into the enigmatic symbol is seen in this,
To signify the sun, they sometimes {{ painted a hawk, and this was
tropical ; sometimes a scarabeus with a round ball in its claws, and
this, as we see in Clemens, was of the enigmatic kind. Thus at
length, though by imsensible degrees, these characters, called enig-
matic symbols, became immensely distant from those called curiologie
hieroglyphics : to conceive this, the reader need only cast his eye
on two the most celebrated of the Egyptian hieroglyphics employed
to denote the universal Nature ; namely, the Diana Multimammia ; §§
* Tdavros, ὃν Αἰγύπτιοι Θὼθ τσροσαγορεύουσι, σοφίᾳ διενεγκὼν wapa τοῖς Φοίνιξι,
παρῶτος τὰ κατὰ τὴν ϑεοσέβειαν ἐκ τῆς τῶν χυδαίων ἀπειρίας, εἰς ἐπιστημονικὴν ἐμπειρίαν
διέταξεν.---ϑ΄ΑΝΟΗ. apud Eusesil Prepar. Evang. lib. i. cap. 10. t+ See note MM, at
the end of this book. 1 Αἱ δὲ ἐν τοῖς ὄμμασιν αὐτοῦ κόραι τοληροῦσθαι μὲν καὶ τολατύ-
νεσθαι δοκοῦσιν ἐν ττανσελήνῳ, λεπτύνεσθαι δὲ καὶ μαραυγεῖν ἐν ταῖς μειώσεσι τοῦ ἄστρου.
—Puurarcnus De Is. et Os. § Eusesu Prep. Evang. lib. i. cap. 10. || Horap.
lib. i. cap. 1. Ἵ Lib. i. cap. 22. “* EuseBll Prep. Evang. lib. i. cap. 10.
{1 Ibid. tt Horap, lib. i. cap. 6. §§ See note NN, at the end of this book.
198 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
and the winged globe with a serpent issuing from it ;* the first is in
the very simplest style, of a curiologic hieroglyphic ; the other myste-
rious assemblage, is an enigmatic symbol: but, under the first figure,
we must observe that the wniversal Nature was considered physically ;
under the latter, metaphysically ; agreeably to the different genius of
the times in which each was invented.
But this was not all: the Egyptian Hieroglyphic, in passing from
an instrument of open communication, to a vehicle of secrecy, suffered
another and more remarkable change. We have observed before, that
the early Egyptian hieroglyphics resembled, in this, the Mexican, that
what things had bodily form were generally represented by figures; what
had not, by marks or characters. Which we find verified in the most
ancient of the Egyptian Obelisks yet remaining. The reader need but
cast his eye into Kircher, to see how exactly their hieroglyphics in this
point resembled the American, published by Purchas, not only in their
use, which as Purchas Ὁ and Diodorus Τ say, were to record the num-
ber of their troops, the particulars of their revenue, and the names
of their conquered towns and provinces ; but likewise in their forms
and figures. But when now every thing was directed to secrecy and
mystery, modes as well as substances were paiuted by images.§ Thus
openness was expressed by a hare,|| destruction by a mouse,4]| unclean-
ness by a wild goat,** impudence by a fly,t+ knowledge by an ant,tt
aversion by a wolf,§§ anger by a cynocephalus,|||| fe. And to make
the matter still more mysterious, one animal was made to represent
many and very contrary moral modes; thus the hawk signified
sublimity, humility, victory, excellence, &c. On the contrary, and
for the same reason, one thing was represented by many and various
hieroglyphics ; sometimes for an addition, out of choice, to confound
the vulgar ; sometimes for a change, out of necessity, when a hiero-.
glyphic by long or frequent use was become vulgar or common.
Now the ancient Greeks, though they saw this to be a different
species of writing from the proper hieroglyphic, and accordingly, as
we find by Porphyry, distinguished them into two kinds, Aierogly-
phical and symbolical, yet confounding their original, in supposing
both invented out of choice, have not accurately distinguished either
their different natures or uses: they took it for granted that the
hieroglyphic, as well as symbol, was a mysterious representation ; and,
what was worse, a representation of speculative notions in philosophy
and theology ; whereas it was used only in public and open writings,
to register their civil policy and history :—These mistakes involved the
whole history of hieroglyphic writing in infinite confusion.
. See the Bembine Table. t+ See p. 174. t See p. 194. § See
pp- 178, 179. || Horar. lib. i. cap. 26. q Cap. 50. ** Cap. 49.
tt Cap. 51. tt Cap. 52. §§ Lib. ii. cap. 22. lill Lib. i. cap. 14.
«ΜΠ Lib. i. cap. 6.
SECT. Iv. OF MOSES’ DEMONSTRATED. 199
But it is now time to speak of an alteration, which this change
of the subject and manner of expression made in the DELINEATION
of hieroglyphic figures. Hitherto the animal or thing representing
was drawn out graphically ; but when the study of philosophy (which
had occasioned .symbolic writing) had inclined their learned to write
much, and variously; that exact manner of delineation would be as
well too tedious as too voluminous: by degrees, therefore, they per-
fected another character, which we may call the running-hand of
hieroglyphics, resembling the Chinese writing, which being at first
formed only by the outlines of each figure,* became at length a kind
of marks. One natural effect which this running-hand would, in
time, produce, we must not omit to mention; it was, that the use
would take off the attention from the symbol, and fix it on the thing
signified ; by which means the study of symbolic writing would be
much abbreviated, the reader or decypherer having then little to do,
but to remember the power of the symbolic mark; whereas before,
the properties of the thing or animal employed as a symbol were to
be learnt: in a word, this, together with their other marks by istv-
tution, to design mental ideas, would reduce the characters to the
present state of the Chinese. And these were properly what the
ancients call HIEROGRAPHICAL Ὁ used afterwards on subjects which
had employed the ancient hieroglyphic, as we may see by what
follows: Dr. Robert Huntington, in his dAecount of the porphyry
pillars in Egypt,t tells us, there are yet some ancient monuments
remaining of this kind of writing :—‘‘The Franks”. (says he) “call
these pillars Aguglia’s, and the English, in particular, Cleopatra’s
needles ; but the inhabitants content themselves with the general
name of pillars. They have no bases or pedestals above ground ; and
if they ever had any, they must needs be very deep in the earth.
The hieroglyphic characters, wherewith they are engraven, are pro-
bably the aboriginal Egyptian letters, long become obsolete, and they
resemble the Chinese characters, each whereof represents a word, or
rather an entire sentence; besides, they seem to be written the same
way, namely, from top to bottom.” Apuleius,§ speaking of his
initiation into the mysteries of Isis, describes the sacred book or
ritual (which we find was written partly in symbolic, and partly in
these hierographie characters of arbitrary institution, resembling the
Chinese) in this manner: “He [the Hierophant] drew out certain
books from the secret repositories of the Sanctuary, written in
unknown characters, which contained the words of the sacred
Formula, compendiously expressed, partly by rrcureEs of animals,
and partly by certain MARKS or notes, intricately knotted, revolving
* See note OO, at the end of this book. + See note PP, at the end of this
book. t ‘* Philos. Trans.” No. clxi. p. 624. § Metamorphosis, lib. ii.
200 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
in the manner of a wheel, and crouded together and curled imward
like the tendrils of a vine,* so as to hide the meaning from the
curiosity of the prophane.”+ The characters here described may be
seen in almost every compartment of the Bembine-table, between the
larger human figures; and likewise on several of the obelisks, where
they are disposed in the same manner. As we find these characters
mixed with the syméolic, in the ritual of Apuleius; so in the Bembine-
table we find them mixed both with the proper hieroglyphic and the
symbolic.
III. And now this contracted manner of hieroglyphic writing,
called hierographical, will lead us, by an easy step, to the third spe-
cies, called by Porphyry and Clemens the ἘΡΙΒΤΟΙΙΟ: For now we
are come to one of those links of the chain which served to connect
hieroglyphic marks and alphabetic letters; the first of which con-
tained curiologic or symbolic signs of things; the other comprised
signs of words by arbitrary ‘institution. For those hieroglyphic
marks which were SIGNS OF THINGS BY ARBITRARY INSTITUTION,
partook of the proper hieroglyphics in being signs for things, and of
alphabetic letters in being signs by institution. And the contrivance
of employing these arbitrary marks to design all the primitive sounds
of the human voice was inventing an alphabet. This was what the
Egyptians called their Episroxic writing. And, this, let me observe,
the ancients agree, was invented by the SssCRETARY OF AN EGYPTIAN
KING. A circumstance which will much conduce to the discovery of
the cause of its original.
Now, as it is evident that every kind of hieroglyphic writing, when
employed in public business to convey the royal commands to leaders
of armies and distant governors, must be unavoidably attended with
the inconveniencies of imperfect and obscure information, it was
natural for our Secretary to set himself upon contriving a remedy:
and this he found in the invention of the letters of an alphabet ;
serving to express words, not things ; whereby all the inconyeniencies
of imperfect information, so fatal in nice conjunctures, were avoided,
and the writer’s mind delivered with the utmost clearness and pre-
cision : which too had this further advantage, that as the Government
would endeavour to keep their invention to themselves, LETTERS OF
STATE were, for some time, conveyed with the security of our modern
cyphers: and thus, being at first appropriated to the use of the
* For a specimen of the marks thus described, see plate IX. fig. 1. + De
opertis adyti profert quosdam libros, litteris ignorabilibus prenotatos : partim figuris
cujuscemodi animalium, concepti sermonis compendiosa verba suggerentes ; PARTIM
NODC SIS, ET IN MODUM ROTH TORTUOSIS, CAPREOLATIMQUE CONDENSIS APICIBUS, ὦ
curt. sitate profanorum lectione munita. 1 It was an ancient custom, as DiopoRus
tells us, for the kings of Egypt to read all the letters of state, themselves :-“Ἕωθεν μὲν
γὰρ ἐγερθέντα λαθεῖν αὐτὸν ἔδει τορῶτον τὰς τυανταχόθεν ἀπεσταλμένας ἐπιστολὰς, ἵνα
δύνηται “πάντα κατὰ τρόπον χρηματίζειν καὶ ταράττειν, εἰδὼς ἀκριδῶς ἕκαστα τῶν κατὰ
τὴν βασιλείαν συντελουμένων.- -Ῥ. 44.
SECT. IV. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 201
cabinet, literary writing naturally acquired the name of EPISTOLARY ; *
which if you will not allow, no reasonable account, I think, can be
given of its title.
That this was, indeed, the fact, appears from Plato’s account of
Theuth’s inventions. He tells us that when Theuth came to con-
sult his master, king Thamus, about communicating his discoveries to
the people, aupa τοῦτον ἐλθὼν ὁ Θεὺθ τὰς τέχνας ἐπέδειξε, καὶ ἔφη
δεῖν διαδοθῆναι τοῖς ἄλλοις Αἰγυπτίοις, the king declared particularly
against communicating the invention of LeTrers. But the reason
he gives for the prohibition, we see, was not the principal and more
immediate (as it rarely is amongst Politicians), but only a secondary,
and more remote ; namely, a regard to the interests of hieroglyphic
learning: for the King tells his Secretary, that, if this secret should
be divulged, men’s attention would be called away from THINGS, to
which hieroglyphics, and the manner of explaining them, necessarily
attached it, and be placed in exterior and arbitrary siGNs, which
would prove the greatest hindrance to the progress of knowledge.
What is still more pleasant, and in the true genius of politics, even
the reason given was thought fit to be disguised: for though there
might be some truth in this; yet, without doubt, the chief concern of
the Egyptian Priests was to continue themselves useful ; which they
would be, while science lay concealed in Aieroglyphics.
Thus the reader finds, that the very contrary to the common
opinion is the true; that it was the first literary writing, not the first
hieroglyphical, which was invented for secrecy. In the course of time,
indeed, they naturally changed their use ; letters became common, and
hieroglyphics hidden and mysterious.
But now it may be said, that though the progress from a Picture
to a simple Mark hath been traced out, step by step, and may be
easily followed, till we come to that untried ground where ArT takes
the lead of nature, the point where veal characters end, and the
literary begin; yet here, art seeing a precipice before her, which
seems to divide the two characters to as great a distance as at first
setting out, she takes so immense a leap as hath been thought to
exceed all human efforts : which made Tully say, “‘ Summee sapientize
fuisse sonos vocis,{ qui infiniti videbantur, paucis literarum notis
terminare ; ὁ ὃ and many of the ancients to believe that LITERARY
WRITING was an invention of the Gods.
However, if we would but reflect a little on the nature of sound,
and its unheeded connexion with the objects of sight, we should be
* See note QQ, at the end of this book. + Τοῦτο yap τῶν μαθόντων λήθην μὲν
ἐν ψυχαῖς πσαρέξει, μνήμης ἀμελετησίᾳ, ἅτε διὰ wlorw “γραφῆς ἔξωθεν ὑπ᾽ ἀλλοτρίων
τύπων, οὐκ ἔνδοθεν αὐτοὺς ὑφ᾽ αὑτῶν ἀναμιμνησκομένου-" οὔκουν μνήμης. ἀλλ᾽ ὑπομνήσεως
φάρμακον eupes* σοφίας δὲ τοῖς μαθηταῖς δόξαν, οὐκ ἀλήθειαν wodpiCers.— Phedrus.
1 See note RR, at the end of this book. § Tusc. Disput. i. 25.
202 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
able to conceive how the chasm closed, and how the passage from a
real to a literary character was begun and smoothed out.
While the picture, or image of the thing represented, continued to
be objected to the sight of the reader, it could raise no idea but of the
thing itself. But when the picture lost its form, by being contracted
into a mark or note, the view of this mark or note would, in course
of time, as naturally raise, in the mind, the sound expressing the idea
of the thing, as the idea itself. How this extension, from the idea to
the sound, in the use of the real character first arose, will be easily
conceived by those who reflect on the numerous tribe of words in all
languages, which is formed on the sound emitted by the thing or
animal.*
Yet the use to which this new connexion might be applied, would
never be thought of till the nature of human sounds had been well
studied.
But when men had once observed (and this they could not but
observe early and easily, by the brute and inarticulate sounds which
they were perpetually hearing emitted) how small the number is of
primitive sounds, and how infinite the words are which may be
formed by varied combinations of those simple sounds, it would
naturally and easily occur to them, that a very few of those marks,
which had before casually excited the sensation of those simple
sounds, might be selected and formed into what has been since called
an alphabet, to express them all: And then, their old accustomed way
of combining primitive sounds into words, would as naturally and
easily direct them to a like combination of what were now become the
simple marks of sound ; from whence would arise LITERARY WRITING.
In the early language of men, the simple, primitive sounds would
be used, whether out of choice or necessity, as significative words or
terms, to denote the most obvious of those things with which they
perpetually conversed. These sounds, without arbitrary institution,
would incite the idea of the thing, sometimes, as its audible image,
sometimes, as its natural representative. Therefore the old marks for
things, to which words of this original belonged, would certainly be
first thought of for the figures of those alphabetic letters by the
ingenious inventer of this wonderful contrivance. And, in fact, this
which appears so natural has been found to be actually the case: the
most early alphabets being framed from the outlines of those figures
in the real characters, which, by use, in their hieroglyphic state, had
arrived at the facility of exciting, in the mind, the sounp as well as
THING.+
* For example, (to use the words of St. Austin) when we say in Latin, “ Airis tinni-
twm, equorum hinnitum, ovium balatum, tubarum clangorem, stridorem catenarum,
perspicis hee verba ita sonare, ut res que his verbis significantur.” This class of words
the Greeks designed by the name of ὀνοματοποιΐα. + Plate VIII.
SECT. IV. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 203
IV. But this political alphabet, as at first it was, soon occasioned
the invention of another called sacrep: for the priests having a
share in the Government, must have an early communication of the
secret; and being now immerged in deep philosophy, they would
naturally employ, in their hidden doctrines, a method so well adapted
to convey abstract speculations with exactness and precision. But
the various uses of an Alphabet in civil business not permitting it to
continue long a secret, when it ceased to be so, they would as naturally
invent another alphabetic character for their sacred use: which from
that appropriation was called HIEROGRAMMATICAL.
That the Egyptian priests had such a sacred alphabetic character,
we are informed by Herodotus :—‘ The Greeks” (says he) ‘“ write
their letters, and make their computations with counters, from the
left to the right ; the Egyptians, on the contrary, from the right to
the left.’”,—“‘ They use two sorts of letters, one of which they called
sacred, the other popular.’* Diodorus is yet more express ; ‘‘ the
PRIESTS” (says he) ‘‘ taught their sons two sorts of letters, the one
called sacred, the other, the common and popular.’+ Clemens
Alexandrinus goes still farther, and describes the very books in which
this sacred alphabet was principally employed: And as the place,
where he explains this matter, is very curious, and contributes to the
farther illustration of the subject, I shall consider it more at large.
It hath been shewn that Clemens, in the passage quoted above, under-
stood what he called the sacerdotal, IEPATIKHN, to be an alpha-
betic character. Now the same writer speaking in another placet of
the forty-two books of Hermes, which contained all the civil and
religious science of the Egyptians, informs us, that ten of these books
were called sacerdotal, and were the particular study of the chief priest,
—oapoorarns τοῦ ἱεροῦ τὰ IEPATIKA καλούμενα κ΄ βιθλία ἐκμανθάνει.
These ten, therefore, were written in a sacred alphabetic character ;
though, as we learn from him in the same place, all the various kinds
of sacred characters were employed in the composition of these forty-two
books ; for some were written in hieroglyphies ; as he tells us, where he
speaks of the sacred scribe, whose business it was to study those called
hieroglyphical,—rodrov τά τε TEPOTAY®IKA καλούμενα: And, what
is very remarkable, we find the subject of these to be of a popular and
civil nature, such as cosmography, geography, the simple elements of
astronomy, the chorography of Egypt, the description of the Nile,§
* Τράμματα γράφουσι καὶ λογίζονται ψήφοισι, Ἕλληνες μὲν, ἀπὸ τῶν ἀριστερῶν ἐπὶ τὰ
δεξιὰ φέροντες τὴν χεῖρα, Αἰγύπτιοι δὲ, ἀπὸ τῶν δεξιῶν ἐπὶ τὰ ἀριστερά.---διφασίοισι δὲ
γράμμασι χρέωνται: καὶ τὰ μὲν αὐτῶν, ἱρὰ, τὰ δὲ, δημοτικὰ καλεεταί.---Τ 1}. ii. cap. 36.
+ Παιδεύουσι δὲ τοὺς υἱούς of μὲν Ἱερεῖς γράμματα διττὰ, τά τε ἱερὰ καλούμενα, καὶ τὰ
κοινοτέραν ἔχοντα τὴν μάθησιν.---Ῥ. 51. 1 Strom. lib, vi. pp. 633, 634, edit.
Colon. 1688. § Περί τε τῆς κοσμογραφίας, καὶ γεωγραφίας, τῆς τάξεως τοῦ ἡλίου
καὶ τῆς σελήνης. καὶ τσερὶ τῶν ε΄ τολανωμένων" χωρογραφίαν τε τῆς Αἰγύπτου, καὶ τῆς
τοῦ Νείλου diaypapjs.— Ibid.
204 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
&c. conformable to what has been laid down concerning the use and
application of the most early hieroglyphics. Others again of these
books were written in syméols, particularly those two which the
. ς > “ ~ -“ -“ /
chanter had in care :—é ὠδὸς ἕν τι τῶν τῆς μουσικῆς ἐπιφερόμενος
SYMBOAQN: τοῦτον φασὶ δύο βίδλους ἀνειληφέναι δεῖν ἐκ τοῦ
Ἑρμοῦ. Here then we have all the three species of sacred writing,
the hieroglyphic, the symbolic, and the hierogrammatic or sacerdotal ;
the last of which, as we hold, was by letters of an alphaéet.
But an ALPHABET for secrecy, and consequently different from
the vulgar, was a thing in use amongst the priesthood of almost all
nations. Philo Biblius, in Eusebius, speaking of Sanchoniatho’s
history, tells us, that the author composed it by the assistance of
certain records which he found in the temples written in AMMONEAN
LETTERS,* not understood by the people: these Ammonean letters
Bochart explains to be such as the priests used in sacred matters.
Diogenes Laertius informs us, from Thrasyllus, that Democritus wrote
two books, the one of the sacred letters of the Babylonians, the
other of the sacred letters of the city Meroé:{ and concerning
these last, Heliodorus saith, that the Ethiopians had two sorts of
letters, the one called regal, theother vulgar ; and that the regal
resembled the sacerdotal characters of the Egyptians.§ Theodoret,
speaking of the Grecian temples in general, says that they had certain
forms of letters for their own use, called sacerdotal ; || and Fourmont,
and others, suppose that this general custom prevailed among the
Hebrews also.4{ Which opinion, a passage in Ireneeus seems to
support.**
And now we shall know how to deal with a strange passage++ of
Manetho in Eusebius. This historian assures his reader, ‘‘ that he
took his information from pillars in the land of Seriad, inscribed by
Thoyth the first Hermes, with Aierographic letters in the sacred dialect ;
and translated, after the flood, out of the sacred dialect, into the
* ‘O δὲ συμβαλὼν τοῖς ἀπὸ τῶν ἀδύτων εὑρεθεῖσιν ἀποκρύφοις ᾿Αμμουνέων γράμμασι
συγκειμένοις, ἃ δὲ οὐκ ἣν τοᾶσι γνώριμα.--- γώ». Evang. lib. i. cap 9. + “ Ammo-
neorum, i. e. Ammanim—Abenezra in Levit. xxvi. 30. Templa facta ad cultum Solis.
Quod verissimum ; Sol enim Hebrezis est amma, unde amman templum Solis, quem
solum Celi Dominum crediderunt prisci Phenices. Sanchoniathon, τοῦτον yap (τὸν
ἥλιον) ϑεὸν ἐνόμιζον μόνον οὐρανοῦ κύριον. Itaque hic preeipue cultus. Tamen, cres-
cente superstitione, crediderim nomen Ammanim etiam ad alia delubra pertinuisse.
Itaque Litere Ammoneorum seu Ammanim sunt literee templorum, literze in sacris
recepte.”— Geogr. Sacr. pars ii. lib. ii. cap. 17. 1 See note SS, at the end of
this book. § ᾿Ἐπελεγόμην τὴν ταινίαν γράμμασιν Αἰθιοπικοῖς, ov δημοτικοῖς, ἀλλὰ
βασιλικοῖς ἐστιγμένην, & δὴ τοῖς Αἰγυπτίων ἹΕΡΑΤΊΚΟΙΣ ΚΑΛΟΥΜΕΝΟΙΣ
ὁμοιοῦνται.---Τ ν. iv. || Ἐν τοῖς Ἑλληνικοῖς ναοῖς ἴδιοι τινὲς ἦσαν χαρακτῆρες
γραμμάτων, ods IEPATIKOYS wpoonydpevov.—In Genes. Qu. 61. 4 “ Cette
coltume de la plipart des nations Orientales, d’avoir des Characteres Sacres, et des
Characteres Profanes ou d’un usage plus vulgaire, étoit aussi chez les HEBREUX.’—
Reflex. Crit. vol. i. p. 36. «* © Antiquz et prime Hebrzorum litere, que SACER-
DOTALES nuncupate, decem quidem fuere numero.”—Adversus Heret. lib. ii. cap. 41.
tt See STILLINGFLEET’s Origines Sacre, book i. chap. ii. § 11, and MR. SHUCKFORD’s
“* Connections,” vol. i. ed. 2, p. 247.
SECT. IV. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 205
Greek tongue, with HrrRoGLYPHIC letters, and deposited in volumes
by Agathodzemon, the second Hermes, father of Tat, in the Adyta of
the Egyptian temples.” The original is in these words: “Ex τῶν
Μανεθῶ τοῦ ἹΞεξδεννύτου, ὃς ἐπὶ Πτολεμαίου τοῦ Φιλαδέλφου ἀρχι-
ερεὺς τῶν ἐν Αἰγύπτῳ εἰδώλων, χρηματίσας ἐκ τῶν τῇ Σηριαδικῇ
γῇ κειμένων στηλῶν ἱερᾷ, φησὶ, διαλέκτῳ καὶ ἱερογραφικοῖς γράμμασι
κεχαροικτηρισμένων ὑπὸ Θωὺθ τοῦ πρώτου Ἑρμοῦ, καὶ ἑρμηνευθεισῶν
μετὰ τὸν κατακλυσμὸν ἐκ τῆς ἱερᾶς διαλέκτου εἰς τὴν ἑλληνίδα
φωνὴν γράμμασιν ΤΕΡΟΓΛΥΦΙΚΟΙΣ, καὶ ἀποτεθεισῶν ἐν βίδλοις
ὑπὸ τοῦ ᾿Αγαθοδαίμονος τοῦ δευτέρου Ἑρμοῦ, πατρὸς δὲ τοῦ Tar
ἐν τοῖς ἀδύτοις τῶν ἱερῶν Αἰγυπτίων." Stillingfleet objects, with
reason, to the absurdity of translating into the Greek tongue with
hieroglyphic characters: and the author of the Connections well
seeing that by γράμμασιν ἱερογλυφικοῖς must be understood an
alphabetic character, says the words should not be translated hiero-
glyphics, but sacred letters :+ he might as well have said Gothic
letters, ἱερογλυφικὰ being always used by the Ancients to denote
characters for things, in opposition to alphabetic letters, or characters,
composing words. It is certain the text is corrupt; as may be seen,
1, From the word γράμμασιν (which in strict propriety signifies the
letters of an alphabet) its being joined to ἱερογλυφικοῖς, which
denotes a species of marks for things. 2. From the mention of a
sacred dialect, ἱερὰ διάλεκτος (of which more hereafter) ; for if these
records were written in a sacred dialect, it is plain the character
employed must be alphabetic ; and so indeed it is expressed to be in
the words ἱερογραφικοῖς γράμμασι, which immediately follow; and
if, out of this dialect, it were translated into another, must not alpha-
betic characters be still employed? And now we see not only that
the present reading is wrong, but are led, by this last observation, to
the right ; the passage being without all question to be read thus :—
μετὰ τὸν κατακλυσμὸν ἐκ τῆς ἱερᾶς διαλέκτου εἰς τὴν ἑλληνίδα
φωνὴν γράμμασιν IEPOTPA®IKOIS, καὶ ἀποτεθεισῶν ἐν βίθλοις,
§-c.—ypaypacv ΤΕΡΟΓΡΑΦΙΚΟΙ͂Σ, in speaking of the translation,
being the very words just before employed in speaking of the
original ; and with great propriety : for lepoypagix2 was used by the
ancients as a generic term, to signify as well sacred letters composing
words, as sacred marks standing for things ; ἱερογλυφικὰ not so, but
denoting only marks for things : so that the plain and sensible mean-
ing of the passage is, that a work, written by the first Hermes, in
the sacred dialect, and sacred letters, was translated, by the second
Hermes, into the Greek dialect ; the original sacred letters being still
employed. And the reason is evident ; the Greek translation was for
* Eusesil Chron. ed. Seal. Amst, 1658, p. 6. + ‘Connection of the Sacred
and Profane History,” vol. i. p. 274, and vol. ii. p. 294.
206 -THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
the use of the Egyptians: but such would be soonest invited to the
study of a foreign dialect when written in their own letters : a com-
mon inducement for translators into a foreign language, to preserve
the original character. Besides, this version was not for the Egyp-
tians in general, but for the priests only ; and therefore their peculiar
character was preserved.
We now begin to see that the whole extravagance in this account,
which made it rejected by the Critics with so much contempt, is only
in the high antiquity given to the fact; and this, the very circum-
stance of the fact refutes: for it not only tells us of sacred alphabetic
letters, which we have shewn to be of late use amongst the Egyptians,
but likewise of a sacred dialect, which certainly was still later: And,
if I be not much mistaken, a passage in Herodotus will lead us to
the time when this translation was made. The historian tells us, that
when Psammitichus, by the assistance of the Ionians and Carians,
had subdued all Egypt, he placed these Greek adventurers on both
sides the Nile; where he assigned them lands and habitations, and
sent among them Egyptian youths to be instructed in the Greek lan-
guage ; from whence sprung the State-interpreters for that tongue :*
Thus far the historian; from whose account of Psammitichus’s
project it appears, that his purpose was to establish a constant inter-
course with the Grecian nations. The youth picked out for inter-
preters were, without question, of the priesthood, all letters and learn-
ing residing in that order ; which had likewise a great share in the
public administration. And now the priesthood having the Greek
tongue amongst them, which its use in public affairs would make them
diligently cultivate ; Where was the wonder that, about this time,
some of these interpreters, ‘Epuyyéec, should employ themselves in
translating the sacred Egyptian records into the Grecian language ?
But then as to the precise time of the invention of Ecypr1ran
LetTERS, it can never be so much as guessed at; because hierogly-
phics continued to be in use long after that time; particularly on
their public Monuments, where we find no appearance of alphabetic
characters. However, that letters were very early, we have shewn
above, as well from other circumstances, as from this, the giving the
invention of them to the Gods.+
Those who are for deriving all civil improvements from the line of
Abraham, of course, bestow upon it the invention of an ALPHABET.
* Τοῖσι δὲ Ἴωσι καὶ τοῖσι Καρσὶ, τοῖσι συγκατεργασαμένοισι αὐτῷ, 6 Ψαμμίτιχος
δίδωσι χώρους ἐνοικῆσαι avtiovs ἀλλήλων, τοῦ Νείλου τὸ μέσον ExovTos'—kal δὴ τσαῖδας
παρέβαλε αὐτοῖσι Αἰγυπτίους, τὴν Ἑλλάδα γλῶσσαν ἐκδιδάσκεσθα. ἀπὸ δὲ τούτων
ἐκμαθόντων τὴν Ἑλλάδα γλῶσσαν, of νῦν Ἑ ρμηνέες ἐν Αἰγύπτῳ yeydvact.—Euterpe,
lib. ii. cap. 154. Hence it appears that the learned Dr. Prideaux was mistaken when
he said—But the worst of it is, the ancient Egyptians did not speak Greek; the
Ptolemys first brought that language amongst then— Connection,” part ii. lib. i. p. 12.
t See p. 184 of this volume.
SECT. Iv. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 207
But as this fancy is only amongst the loose ends of an hypothesis,
without any foundation in Scripture, these critics differ much about
the time. Some suppose Jetters to have been in use amongst the
Patriarchs ; and, by them, transmitted to the Egyptians ; but there
are such strong objections to this opinion (to mention no ‘other than
the Patriarchs’ sending verbal messages where it was more natural as
well as more expedient to send them written), that others have
thought proper to bring down the time to that of Moses: * When
Gop, they say, taught him the use of alphabetic letters, in the
exemplar of the two tables written, as the text assures us, with the
Finger of GOD. But how, from words, which at most only imply
that the Ten Commandments were miraculously engraved as well as
dictated, it can be concluded that letters were then first invented,
I have not logic enough to find out. A common reader would be apt
to infer from it, that letters were now well known to the Israelites, as
Gop had thought fit to deliver the first elements of their religion in
that kind of writing; I say, he would be thus apt to infer, though
Moses had never spoken of them on other occasions (which he hath
done) as of things in familiar use: + But if Gop was indeed the
revealer of the artifice, how happened it that the history of so import-
ant a circumstance was not recorded? for, as we shall see presently,
the Memory of it would have been one of the strongest barriers to
idolatry.
However, though I think it next to certain that Moszs brought
letters, with the rest of his learning, from Egypt, yet I could be
easily persuaded to believe that he both enlarged the alphabet, and
altered the shapes of the letters.t 1. The Hebrew alphabet, which
he employed in the composition of the Pentateuch, is considerably
fuller than that which Cadmus brought into Greece. Cadmus was of
Thebes in Egypt ; he sojourned in Syria, and went from thence into
Greece : His country shews that his letters were Egyptian ; and this,
their difference in number from the Hebrew, sufliciently confirms ;
Cadmus having only sixteen, and the Hebrews two and twenty.
2. That Moses likewise altered the shape of the Egyptian letters I
think probable; all hieroglyphic writing was absolutely forbidden by
the second commandment, and with a view worthy the divine wis-
dom ; hieroglyphiecs being, as we shall see hereafter, the great source
of their idolatries and superstitions. But now alphabetic letters
(which henceforth could be only used amongst the Hebrews) being
taken by the Egyptians § from their hieroglyphic figures, retained, as
was natural, much of the shapes of those characters: to cut off there-
fore all occasion of danger from symbolic images, Mosss, as I sup-
* See note TT, at the end of this book. + See note UU, at the end of this book,
Τ See note XX, at the end of this book. § See p. 177, of this volume.
208 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv,
pose, altered the shapes of the Egyptian letters, and reduced them
into something like those simple forms in which we now find them.
Those who in much later ages converted the northern Pagans to the
Christian Faith observed the same caution. For the characters of the
northern alphabet, called Runic, having been abused to magical super-
stition, were then changed to the Roman.—* Tantas in his Runis”
(says Sheringham) ‘‘latere virtutes Gothi ante fidem susceptam rati
sunt, ut sive hostium caput diris sacrandum, sive pestis morbique
amoliendi, sive aliud opus suscipiendum se incantationibus Runisque
muniebant—Post fidem vero susceptam Rune, qui incantationibus
preestiglisque magicis in tantum adhibitee fuerint, adeo fastidiri ccepe-
runt, ut multi libri, multaque antiqua monumenta exinde preepostero
zelo dejecta atque deleta sunt: unde historia Getica magnum detri-
mentum clademque accepit. Tandem vero, teste Loccenio, Sigfridi
episcopi Britannici opera (Papa etiam Romano suam operam pre-
stante) ed res devenit ut Rune in Suecid A. D.M.t. penitus abolerentur ;
et characteres Latini substituerentur.” *
This account will reconcile the differing systems of Marsham and
Renaudot ; one of whom contends,+ that the letters which Cadmus
brought into Greece were Egyptian: the other, that they were
Phenician ; and both of them appeal to the authority of Herodotus ;
who says plainly, “that the alphabet brought by Cadmus into Greece
was Egyptian ; and yet, speaking of the three most ancient inscrip-
tions in Greece, he says, they were in Phenician characters, which very
much resembled-the Ionic:”’ for if what has been here supposed be
allowed, then the alphabet which Cadmus carried with him was
doubtless of Moses’s invention, as to the form, but Egyptian, as to
the power. It may be just worth observing, that Renaudot’s dis-
course is full of paralogisms, which this solution detects.
3. To this let me add another consideration. The vowel-points (as
seems now to be generally agreed on) were added since the Jews
ceased to be a nation. The Hebrew language was originally, and so
continued to be for a long time, written without them. Now if God
first taught Moses an alphabet, can we believe that the vowels would
have been thus generally omitted? But suppose Moses learnt his
alphabet of the Egyptians, and only made it fuller, and altered the
form of the letters, we may easily give a good account of the omis-
sion. The Egyptian alphabet, as we observed, was invented for pre-
cision, and used for secrecy. Both ends were answered by an alpha-
bet with hardly any vowels.
Thus we see that the form of alphabetic characters was a matter of
much importance to the Hebrews, as to the integrity of their religion.
* De Anglic. Gent. Orig. pp. 292, 293. t+ Can. Chron. 1 Sur U Origine
des Lettres Grecques.
SECT. IV. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 209
If therefore Gop was the immediate author of them, it is difficult to
suppose that Moses could omit to record the history of their inven-
tion; such a history being the best sanction to recommend their use ;
and the best security against a return to the idolatrous practice of
hieroglyphic-writing ; to which this people, so fond of Egyptian
manners, were violently inclined.
But we have not yet done with Manetho; The last circumstance
opening the way to another discovery of great importance in the
Egyptian antiquities: for by this passage we find they had not only
sacred characters and letters, but a sacred DIALECT or language also ;
for what he here calls ἱερὰ διάλεκτος, in another place (where he
interprets a certain Word in this language) he calls ἱερὰ γλῶσσα.
It might perhaps be imagined that this sacred dialect was only the
more ancient Egyptian language ; which being now grown into disuse,
was preserved amongst the priesthood: But if we consider the small
and slow change to which the Eastern languages were subject ; espe-
cially that of a people who admitted so little of foreign manners, we
ean scarce believe this to have been the case. Besides, the sacred
dialect was used for secrecy (being known only to the priests) which
could never be the condition of a national language, how obsolete
soever we may suppose it to be grown. ΑἹ] this considered, I take
the sacred dialect to have been a language of their own framing: and
one of their latest expedients for keeping their science to themselves.
We have shewn how, for the sake of exactness, as they grew more
speculative, they invented an alphabet to express their conceptions by
marks for words, instead of marks for things : But the simple mystery
of a peculiar alphabet, employed in a common tongue, would be soon
detected ; they therefore, as now it appears, invented a pecuhar lan-
guage for the use of their alphabet ; and thus, under a double cover,
effectually secured. their hidden science. The way of framing the
sacred dialect, 1 suppose, to be this: They called things by the names
of their hieroglyphical representatives: Thus Yx in the Egyptian
tongue signifying a serpent; and a serpent, in their hieroglyphics,
denoting a king,t Yk, as Manetho informs us above, signified a king
in the sacred dialect : And in this manner, their hieroglyphics became
a sufficient fund for a new language.
On the whole then it appears that the Egyptian priests had these
three methods of secreting their recorded knowledge ; by ute fociy-
PHIC SYMBOLS, by a SACERDOTAL ALPHABET, and by a SACRED
DIALECT. In explaining their several natures, and distinguishing
* Ἐκαλεῖτο δὲ τὸ σύμπαν αὐτῶν ἔθνος TKSQS, τοῦτο δέ ἐστι βασιλεῖς τσοιμένες" Td
γὰρ TK καθ᾿ IEPAN ΓΛΩΣΣΑΝ βασιλέα σημαίνει, τὸ δὲ ΣΩΣ τοοιμήν ἐστι, καὶ
womeves κατὰ τὴν KOINHN ΔΙΑΛΕΚΤΟΝ, καὶ οὕτω συντιθέμενον γίνεται ὙΚΠΩ Σ.
—Apud JosepHuM Contra Apion, lib. i. cap. 14. + HORAPOLLO, lib. i. cap.
59 —64.
VOL. Il. Ve
210 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
them from the proper hieroglyphic, 1 have endeavoured to disembroil a
subject which seems to have perplexed even the Ancients themselves ;
who, in their accounts of the Egyptian literature, perpetually con-
found the several species of sacred writing with one another. What
greatly contributed to this confusion, I presume, was the sacerdotal
practice of promiscuously using, in one and the same book or literary
monument, the several various species of sacred writing ; that is to
say, the proper hieroglyphic, the symbolic, and the hierogrammatie ; as
was done in composing the Bembine table, and the mystic ritual
described by Apuleius.
Thus we find how it happened that that which had its origin in
necessity, came, in time, to be employed for secrecy, and was at
length improved into an ornament. But now, in the incessant revolu-
tions of things, this imagery, which was at first invented for open
communication, and was from thence converted into mystery, at
length resumed its primitive use; and, in the flourishing ages of
Greece and Rome, was employed in their monuments and medals as
the shortest and plainest method of conveying men’s conceits ; and a
SYMBOL, which, in Egypt, was pregnant with profound wisdom, was
in those places the vocabulary of the people.
To illustrate these several changes and revolutions, we shall once
again take up our instance from LANGUAGE (which still, in all its
minuter alterations and improvements, ran parallel with wriTiNe) ;
and shew, how the original expedient, to communicate our thoughts
in converse, the rude effort of necessity, came in time, like the first
hieroglyphics, to be turned into mystery, and afterwards improved
into the arts of eloquence and persuasion.
I. It hath been already shewn, in the fable of Jotham, how the
Apologue corresponded to the proper Egyptian hieroglyphic ; and was,
invented only to present a sensible image to the unimproved concep-
tion of the hearer.
As the change of the object, which the fable introduced, made it
exactly answer to the ¢ropical hieroglyphic ; so that sort of PRoso-
PoPOE!IA, which the fable much employed, representing a multitude
under the image of one, made it equally correspond with the cwriolo-
gical hieroglyphic.
II. But, now, in after-times, either when men began to affect
mystely, or their subject to require secrecy, they gradually changed
the Apologue or fable, by quaint and far-fetched allusions, into a
PARABLE, ou set purpose to throw obscurity over the information ;
just as the ¢ropical hieroglyphic was turned into the tropical symbol.
We find innumerable instances of this mode of speech in Scripture :
Thus Gop by the prophet Ezekiel :—*‘ Son of man, utter a PARABLE
unto the rebellious house, and say unto them, Thus saith the Lorp
SECT. IV. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 911
Gop, Set on a pot, set it on, and also pour water into it: gather the
pieces thereof into it, even every good piece, the thigh and the
shoulder, fill it with the choice bones. Take the choice of the flock,
and burn also the bones under it, and make it boil well, and let them
seeth the bones of it therein.”’ *
And in this manner was the Parable employed both amongst the
Orientalists and Greeks :, and thus the Jews understood it, as appears
by the complaint of the prophet - «Ah, Lorp! they say of me, Doth
he not speak PARABLES?” + and by this denunciation of our Lorp
himself ; “ Unto you it is given to know the mysteries of the king-
dom of Gop; but to others in PARABLES; that seeing they might
not see, and hearing they might not understand.” { And thus that
great master of Grecian eloquence, Demetrius Phalereus, explains it :
“The allegory is used” (says he) ‘as a covering and disguise to the
discourse.” ὃ
III. We have observed, that the Symbol, the more it receded from
the proper Hieroglyphic, the more it became obscure ; till it divided
itself, at length, into two sorts, the ¢ropical and the enigmatical :
Just so again it was with the Parable, which (answering to the
tropical symbol) grew more and more mysterious, till it became a
RIDDLE; and this again exactly corresponded to the eniymatical
Theroglyphic.
This, in sacred Scripture, is called a DARK SAYING κατ᾽ ἐξοχήν.
For the nature of God’s dispensation required enigmas; and the
genius of those times made them natural. The prophet Ezekiel will
furnish us with an example :—‘ And the word of the Lorp” (says
he) “came unto me, saying, Son of man, put forth a RIDDLE, and
speak a Parable unto the house of Israel; and say, Thus saith the
Lorp Gop, A great eagle with great wings, long winged, full of
feathers, which had divers colours, came unto Lebanon, and took the
highest branch of the cedar; he cropt off the top of his young twigs,
and carried it into a land of traffic,” &c.|| In the interpretation of
these Riddles consisted much of the old Eastern Wisdom, according
to the observation of the Wise-man: “A man of understanding”
(says he) ‘shall attain unto wise counsels ; to understand a Proverb
and the interpretation ; the words of the Wise and their DARK sAy-
inGs.”’ J It was the custom too, as we learn from Scripture ** (and
it lasted long, as we learn from Josephus),t+ for the Sages of those
* Ezek. xxiv. 3, et seq. + Ezek. xx. 49. t Luke viii. 10. § “Ὥσπερ
συγκαλύμματι τοῦ λόγου, TH ἀλληγορίᾳ Kéexpntat.—De Eloc. sect. 100. || Ezek.
xvii. 2, et seq. q Prov. i. 5, 6. ** Judges xiv. 12—14. tt Kat
Σοφίσματα δὲ καὶ λόγους AINITMATQAEIS διεπέμψατο wpds τὸν Zodrouava ὃ τῶν
Τυρίων βασιλεὺς, τταρακαλῶν ὅπως αὐτῷ τούτους σαφηνίσῃ. καὶ τῆς ἀπορίας τῶν ἐν
αὐτοῖς ζητουμένων ἀπαλλάξῃ τὸν δὲ, δεινὸν ὄντα καὶ συνετὸν οὐδὲν τούτων τααρῆλθεν,
ἀλλὰ τιάντα νικήσας τῷ λογισμῷ, καὶ μαθὼν αὐτῶν τὴν διάνοιαν epaotice.—Antig. Jud.
lib, viii. cap. ὃ.
eh We
.
212 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
times to send or offer RippLxEs to each other, for a trial of sagacity,
to the exposition of which, rewards and penalties were annexed ; * so
that the present of a riddle was sometimes only a stratagem for a
booty: hence, the understanding dark sentences became proverbial
amongst the Hebrews to signify the arts of fraud and deceit ; as may
be collected from the character given by Daniel of Antiochus
Epiphanes : ‘And in the latter time of their kingdom, when the
transgressors are come to the full, a king of fierce countenance and
UNDERSTANDING DARK SENTENCES shall stand up.” Ὁ
The mysterious cover to this kind of wisdom made it (as always
such a cover will) the most high-prised accomplishment: so when
the Psalmist would raise and engage the attention of his audience,
he begins his song in this manner: “ Hear, all ye people ; give ear,
all ye inhabitants of the world: both low and high, rich and poor
together. My mouth shall speak of wisdom, and the meditation of
my heart shall be of understanding. I wiLL INCLINE MINE EAR
TO A PARABLE; I WILL OPEN MY DARK SAYING UPON THE
HARP. { For as a great Critic in sacred and profane learning
rightly observes upon the place: Psalmi hujus auctor, quo auditores
attentos reddat, his promittit se de rebus maximis, et in quibus summa
sapientia posita sit, dicturum ; et in carmine hoe componendo artem
quam potmt maximam adhibuit, ut materia dignum redderet.§
And as, in the improved art of writinc by Symbols, the Egyp-
tians (as. well to give it the air of learning and elegance, as to cloud
it with a variegated obscurity) studied all the singular properties of
beings, and their relations, in order to fit them for representatives of
other things; so in the art of spEAKING, men soon began to adorn
those modes of information just now mentioned with tropes and
Jigures ; till at length posterity began to doubt about the original of
Jigurative expression ; even as they had doubted about the original of
hieroglyphic painting ; whereas, in truth, the first, like the latter,
owed its birth to mere want and rusticity ; that is, a want of words,
and rusticity of conception. ΤῸ give an instance of the first want, in
the pLEONASM ; of the latter, in the METAPHOR: for Eastern speech
abounds with these figures; they constitute its pride and beauty ;
and to excel in them, consists the art of their orators and poets.
1. The Pleonasm evidently arose from the narrowness of a simple
language: the Hebrew, in which this figure abounds, is the scantiest
of all the learned languages of thé East : Amant (says Grotius) He-
brei verborum copiam ; itaque rem eandem multis verbis exprimunt.||
“ Διὸς---τὸν δὲ τυραννοῦντα Ἱεροσολύμων Σολομῶνα πσέμψαι, φησὶ, wpds τὸν Εἴραμον
ΑἸΝΊΓΜΑΤΑ, καὶ wap’ αὐτοῦ λαβεῖν ἀξιοῦντα" τὸν δὲ, μὴ δυνηθέντα διακρῖναι, τῷ
λύσαντι χρήματα amotive.—!dem, ibid. { Daniel viii. 23. 1 Psalm xlix. 4.
§ Psalmorum Liber-in Versiculos metrice divisus, &c. Ev. Hare, Ερίβο, Cicest. p. 265,
|| In Hab. ii. 1.
SECT. Iv. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 213
He does not tell us the reason; but it is seen above, and appears to
be the true: for when the speaker’s phrase comes not up to his ideas
(as in a scanty language it often will not), he naturally endeavours to
explain himself by a repetition of the thought in other words; as he
whose body is straitened in room is never relieved but by a continual
change of posture. We may observe this to happen frequently in
common conversation; where the conception of the speaker is
stronger than his expression. The most scanty language therefore
will be always fullest of repetitions, which is the only copia in that
which Grotius speaks of.
2. The Metaphor arose as evidently from rusticity of conception,
as the pleonasm from the want of words. The first simple ages,
uncultivated, and immerged in sense, could express their rude con-
ceptions of abstract Ideas, and the reflex operations of the mind,
only by material images; which, so applied, became metaphors.
This, and not the warmth of a florid and improved fancy, as is com-
monly supposed, was the true original of figurative expression. We
see it even at this day in the style of the American savages, though
of the coldest and most phlegmatic complexions, such as the Iroquois
of the Northern continent ; of whom a learned missionary says:
«« They affect a lively close expression, like the Lacedemonians ; yet
for all that their style 1s figurative, and wholly metaphorical.”*
Their phlegm could only make their style concise, not take away the
figures ; and the conjunction of these different characters in it, shews
plainly that metaphors were from necessity, not choice. The very
same character, in other words, Diodorus gives of the style of the
ancient Gauls: In conversation, says he, they use the utmost brevity,
attended with a highly figurative obscurity : their speech abounds with
a licentious kind of Synecdoche, which leaves much to the hearer to
unriddle and divine; and also with hyperboles.+
But we need not these far-fetched examples. He who will only
reflect on what is so common as generally to escape reflection, may
observe, that the common people are always most given to speak in
figures. Cicero observed this long ago, where encouraging the use
of metaphors, even in the simpler style, he says,—‘‘ Translatione for-
tasse crebrior, qua frequentissime sermo omnis utitur non modo
urbanorum, sed etiam rusticorum. Siquidem est eorum, gemmare
vites, sitire agros, letas esse segetes, luxuriosa frumenta. Nihil
horum parum audacter, sed aut simile est illi, unde transferas: aut,
si res suum nullum habet nomen, docendi causa sumptum, aut ludendi
videtur.’t Hence too, the people’s delight in that other figure of
speech, PROVERBS, a passion not stronger in our own times than in
* See note YY, at the end of this book. + See note ZZ, at the end of this
book. t Orator. cap. 24,
214 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
those of Aristotle; who observes of ATPOIKOI μάλιστα TNQMO-
ΤΥΠΟΙῚ εἰσί. And the gross images under which proverbial truths
in all languages are conveyed, shew they only delighted in their own
inventions: for, to the People, it is certain, we are altogether
indebted for this species of instruction.
It is true, when gross conception met with a warm imagination
which delighted in painting strong and lively images, and was
improved by exercise and use, figurative expression would be soon
adorned with all the flourishes of wit. For wir consists in using
strong metaphoric images in uncommon yet apt allusions: just as
ancient Egyptian wispom did in hieroglyphic symbols fancifully ana-
logized. Plato perhaps had something of this in his thoughts (if
he had not, he had hardly any thing so good) when he observed to
Alcibiades, that the People was an excellent master of language.*
Thus we see it has ever been the way of men, both in Speech and
Writing, as well as in Clothes and Habitations, to turn their wants
and necessities into parade and ornament.t
IV. In the first parallel between Speech and Writing, we have
compared metaphors to the letters of an.alphabet ; and how well the
parallel runs may be further seen from hence: The Egyptians had,
as has been shewn, two sorts of alphabetic letters, the one popular,
the other sacerdotal ; so had the ancients in general two sorts of
metaphors ; one open and intelligible, another hidden and mysterious.
The prophetic writings are full of this latter sort. To instance only
in the famous prediction of Balaam: There shall come a star out of
Jacob, and a sceptre shall rise out of Israel.t This prophecy may
possibly in some sense relate to David; but, without question, it
belongs principally to Jesus: the metaphor of a sceptre was common
and popular, to denote a ruler, like David; but the star, though it
also signified, in the prophetic writings,§ a temporal prince or ruler,
yet had a secret and hidden meaning likewise: a star in the Egyp-
tian hieroglyphics denoted 600 :}} and how much hieroglyphic writ-
ing influenced the eastern languages we shall see presently. Thus
Gop, in the prophet Amos, reproving the Israelites for their idolatry
on their first coming out of Egypt, says: “Ye have born the taber-
nacle of your Moloch, and Chiun your images, THE STAR OF YOUR
GoD, which ye made to yourselves.” 1 The star of your Gop is a
sublime figure to signify the image of your Gop; for a star being
employed in hieroglyphics to signify Gop, it is used here with great
elegance, to signify the material image of a Gop: the words, the star
of your Gon, being only a repetition, so usual in the Hebrew tongue,
* See note AAA, at the end of this book. + See note BBB, at the end of this
book. t Num. xxiv. 17. § Dan. viii. 10. || ᾿Αστὴρ wap Αἰγυπτίοις
γραφόμενος ΘΕΟΝ σημαίνει.--- HORAPOL. Hierog. lib. ii. cap. 1, q Amos v. 25, 26.
SECT, Iv. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED, 215
of the preceding, Chiun your images. ence we conclude that the
metaphor here used by Balaam of ἃ star was of that abstruse myste-
rious kind; and is so to be understood ; and consequently that it
related only in the mysterious sense to CuristT, the eternal son of
Gop.
We have observed how Symbols, which came from open MHiero-
glyphies, lost their mysterious nature, and recovered again their pri-
mitive use in the flourishing ages of Greece and Rome. Just so again
it was with the Parable ; which coming from the simple .4pologue,
often returned to its first clearness, and became a proverb plain and
intelligible to all. ‘In that day” (says the prophet Micah) “ shall
one take up a Parable against you,” &c.* Shall not all these pa
(says Habakkuk) “take up a Parable against him, and a taunting
proverb against him, and say,” &c.+
Thus WRITING and LANGUAGE, throughout all their various modes,
ran exactly the same fortune: invented out of necessity, to commu-
nicate men’s thoughts to one another; they were continued out of
choice, for mystery and ornament; and they ended at last as they
began, in the way of popular information.
Hitherto we have considered the relation only as they stand in an
independent parallel; but as they are only two different ways of
communicating the same conceptions, they must needs have a mighty
influence upon one another. To explain this in the manner it
deserves would require a just volume; and as a properer place may
be found for it, when we come to consider the objections to the style
of Scripture, it will be sufficient just to touch upon it at present.
1. The influence Language would have on the first kind of writing,
which was hieroglyphical, is easy to conceive. Language, we have
shewn, was, out of mere necessity, highly figurative, and full of
material images ; so that when men first thought of recording’ their
conceptions, the writing would be, of course, that very picture which
was before painted in the fancy, and from thence, delineated in
words: Even long after, when figurative speech was continued out
of choice, and adorned with all the invention of wit, as amongst the
Greeks and Romans, and that the genius of the simpler Aieroglyphic-
writing was again revived for ornament, in EMBLEMS and DEVICES, the
poetic habit of personalizing every thing, filled their coins, their arches,
their altars, &c. with all kinds of imaginary Beings. All the qualities
of the mind, all the affections of the body, all the properties of coun-
tries, cities, rivers, mountains, became the seeds of living things: for,
-ἐς 85 IMAGINATION bodied forth
The forms of things unknown, the artist’s hand
Turn’d them to shape, and gave to airy nothing
A local habitation and a name.’’}
* Micah ii. 4. + Habak. ii. 6. { Shakespear.
216 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
2. The reciprocal influence hieroglyphic writing would have on
language is as evident. The Chinese, we have seen, used this kind of
writing, as well as the Egyptians ; and the character given of their
language is entirely correspondent: ‘‘ The style of the Chinese, in
their compositions,” (says Du Halde,) ‘is MYSTERIOUS, concise,
ALLEGORIC, and sometimes obscure. They say much in few words.
Their expressions are lively, animated, and thick sown with bold com-
parisons, and noble metaphors.’ * Their style, we see, was concise
and figurative ; the very character, as we have seen, of all the barba-
“rous nations upon earth, both ancient and modern; for Nature is ever
uniform. The cold phlegmatic temper of the Chinese made their
style short and Jaconic ; the use of hieroglyphics made it figurative ;
and from this mixture it became obscure: but had those remote inha-
bitants of the East and West possessed the warm imagination of the
proper Asiatics, then had their language, like that of the people
spoken of above, abounded with pleonasms instead of laconisms. The
old Asiatic style, so highly figurative, seems likewise, by what we find
of its remains, in the prophetic language of the sacred writers, to have
been evidently fashioned to the mode of ancient Hieroglyphics, both
curiologie and tropical, Of the first kind are the figurative expres-
sions of spotted garments, to denote iniquity ; an intoxicating draught,
to signify error and misery ; the sword and bow, a warrior ; a gigantic
stature, a mighty leader; balance, weights and measures, a judge or
magistrate ; arms, a powerful nation, like the Roman. Of tlie
second kind, which answers to the tropical hieroglyphic, is the call-
ing empires, kings, and nobles, by the names of the heavenly lumina-
ries, the sun, moon, and stars; their temporary disasters or entire
overthrow, denoted by eclipses and extinctions ; the destruction of
the Nobility, by stars falling from the firmament; hostile invasions,
by thunder and tempestuous winds ; and leaders of armies, conquerors,
and founders of empire, by lions, bears, leopards, goats, or high
trees. In a word, the prophetic style seems to be a SPEAKING
HIEROGLYPHIC.
These observations will not only assist us in the intelligence of the
Old and New Testament, but likewise vindicate their character from
the illiterate cavils of modern libertines, who have foolishly mistaken
that colouring for the peculiar workmanship of the speaker’s heated
imagination, which was the sober established language of their times ;
a language which Gop and his Son condescended to employ, as the
properest vehicle of the high mysterious ways of Providence, in the
revelation of themselves to mankind.
* “Te Stile des Chinois dans leurs compositions est mysteriewx, concis, allegorique,
et quelquefois obscur. 118 disent beaucoup de choses en peu de paroles. Leurs expres-
sions sont vives, animées et semées de comparaisons hardies, et de metaphores nobles.’*
—Descr. de 0 Empire de la Chine, tom. ii. p. 227, Paris, 1735.
SECT. Iv. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. ΟἹ
But to come to a conclusion. We must observe in the last place,
that, besides the many changes which the ancient Egyptian hierogly-
phics underwent, they at length suffered a very perverse corruption.
It hath been already seen, how the mysreries, that other grand
vehicle of Egyptian wisdom, degenerated into magic: just so it hap-
pened with the HrrRoGLypuHics; for their characters being become,
in a proper sense, sacred (as will be explained hereafter), it disposed
the more superstitious to engrave them upon gems, and wear them as
amulets or charms. But this abuse seems not to have been much
earlier than the established worship of the God Serapis: which hap-
pened under the Ptolemys; and was first brought to the general
knowledge of the world by certain Christian heretics,* and natives of
Egypt, who had mingled a number of Pagan superstitions with their
Christianity. These gems, called aBRAxas, frequently to be met
with in the cabinets of the curious, are engraven with all kinds of
hieroglyphic characters. For this abusive original, we have the testi-
mony of Rufinus, the ecclesiastical historian, contemporary with
St. Jerome: Who can reckon up, says he, the horrid superstitions
practised at Canopus? where under pretence of interpreting the
SACERDOTAL LETTERS, for so they call the ancient Egyptian charac-
ters, a public school may be almost said to be opened for the teaching
magical arts.t Hence these characters came to be called Chaldaic,
the Chaldeans being particularly addicted to magic. So Cassiodorus,
speaking of the obelisks in the Roman circus, which were brought
from Egypt, calls the inscriptions on them Chaldaica signa: t To
the Abraxas afterwards succeeded TatisMANs: § which (mixed, like
the other, with the dotages of judicial astrology) are held in high
reverence to this day, in all Mahometan countries. And here let me
observe, that from the low date of these kinds of charms may be seen
the impertinence of what Sir John Marsham brings from late Greek ἡ
and Roman writers, to confront and discredit the mysterious eleva-
tion of the brazen serpent in the wilderness. ||
But what must we think of Kircuer, who hath mistaken these
superstitions for the ancient Egyptian wisdom ; and setting up with
this magic, and that other of the mysteries, which the later Platonists
aud Pythagoreans had jumbled together, in the production of their
fanatic-philosophy, soon ingrossed, in imagination, all the treasures of
Antiquity 74 However, to be just, it must be owned that he was
* See note CCC, at the end of this book. + Canopi quis enumeret superstitiosa
flagitia? Ubi pretewtw SaceRDOTALIUM LITERARUM, ita enim appellant antiquas
Aigyptiorum literas, Magice artis erat pene publica schola.—Kccles, Hist. lib. ii. cap.
ΧΧΥ͂Ϊ. 1 Ubi sacra priscorum Chaldaicis signis, quasi literis, indicantur.—Lib,
iii. ep. 51, et lib. iii. ep. 2. § See note DDD, at the end of this book. || See
note KEE, at the end of this book. 4 The following are three of his six Postulata
on which he founds his whole interpretation of the Egyptian hieroglyphics :—1. Hiero-
glyphica Algyptiorum doctrina nihil aliud est quam arcana de Deo, divinisque Ideis,
218 ._ THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
misled by the Ancients themselves ; some of whom imagined that the
very first Aieroglyphics were tainted with this magical pollution, just
as some Moderns would have the first Mysteries to be corrupted by
debauched practices. So Lucan, speaking of the times before alpha-
betic writing, says,
“* Nondum flumineas Memphis contexere Biblos
Noverat, et σαφὴς tantum volucresque fereque
Sculptaque servabant MAGICAS animalia LINGUAS,”
Tlere, we see, the abuse and the invention are made coeval. An
extravagant error, which the least attention to the history of the
human mind and the progress of its operations might have prevented,
To conclude, I have here presumed to dispute an unquestioned pro-
position, That the Egyptians invented hieroglyphics for the sake
of secrecy. It will be well if the evidence of the reasoning may
excuse the singularity of the paradox. This is certain, the subject
hath long remained in obscurity; and as certain, that I have, some
how or other, been able to throw a little scattered light into the
darkest corners of it. Whether the common opinion occasioned the
obscurity, and the notion here advanced has contributed to remove it,
is left for the candid reader to determine.*
III.
And now to apply this matter to the proof of our Proposition ; for
this long discourse on Hieroglyphic writing is particularly given to
deduce from its nature, origin, and* use, an internal argument for the
high antiquity of Lyyptian learning.
Let us see then how the evidence stands: The true Egyptian
learning, which the early Greek Sages brought from thence to adorn
their own country, was, by the concurrent testimony of these writers,
all contained in Hieroglyphics. They record a simple fact; and, in a
fact of this nature, they could not be deceived ; though in the causes
of it they well might; and, as we have shewn, indeed were.—But
hieroglyphic-writing thus invented, was improved into a contrivance
to record their secret wisdom, long before an Alphabet was found
out; and yet an alphabet was of so high and almost immemorial
antiquity as to pass for an invention of the Gods; and consequently
Angelis, Demonibus, caterisque mundanarum potestatum classibus ordinibusque scien-
tia, saxis potissimim insculpta. 5. Hieroglyphica Symbolu non tantim sublimiuwm
erant significativa sacramentorum ; sed et naturalem quandam efficaciam habere crede-
bantur, tum ad Genios bonos quibuscum occultam, et in abdita nature abysso latentem
sympathiam habere putabantur, attrahendos ; tum ad contrarios et antitechnos Genios,
ob eorundem cum iis antipathiam, coércendos profligandosque. 6. Hieroglyphica Sym-
bola nihil aliud quam prophylactica quaedam signa, omnium malorum averruncativa, ob
Ἢ mirificum catenarum mundialium consensum connewionemque, esse existimabantur.—
dip. Af2gypt. tom. iii. p- 4.
* See note FFF, at the end of this book.
SECT, 1V. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 219
to deceive some men into an opinion that Letters were prior in time
to Hieroglyphics.*
«- To this it may be objected, “That, as I pretend Hieroglyphics were
not invented for secrecy, but afterwards turned to that use, and even
employed in it, long after the invention of alphabetic letters, it might
very well be, that this profound learning, which all agree to have been
recorded in Hieroglyphics, was the product of ages much below the
antiquity enquired after.”
Now, not to insist upon the Grecian testimony, which makes the
learned hieroglyphics coeval with the first race of kings ; I reply, and
might well rest the matter on this single argument,—That if at the
invention of e¢ters, much high-prized learning had not been contained
in Hieroglyphics, but only plain memorials of civil matters, no plausi-
ble reason can be given why the Egyptians did not then discontinue a
way of writing so troublesome and imperfect. It hath been shewn,
that in the very early ages of the world, all nations, as well as the
Egyptian, used to record the succession of time and revolutions of
State in hieroglyphic characters: but, of these, none, besides the
Egyptians, continued to write by marks for things, after the invention
of letters. All others immediately dropt their hieroglyphics on the
discovery of that more commodious method. The reason of which is
plain ; all others were totally unlearned in those periods of their
existence preceding the knowledge of letters ; consequently, as their
hieroglyphics were employed in nothing but to record the rude annals
of their history, they had no inducement to continue them: but at
this remarkable «ra, Egypt was very learned: and_hieroglyphics
being the repositories of its learning, these monuments would be in
high veneration, and that veneration would perpetuate their use.
There is but one example perhaps in the world, besides the Egyptian,
where a people’s learning was firsé recorded in hieroglyphic charac-
ters ; and this one example will support our argument: the people I
mean are the CHINESE; who, as the Missionaries assure us, bear
such esteem and reverence for their ancient character, that, when
they find it curiously written, they prefer it to the most elegant
painting, and purchase the least scrap at an excessive price: they
will not (we are told) apply the paper even of any common book, on
which these characters are written, to a profane or vulgar use ;
and their joiners and masons do not dare to tear a printed leaf which
they find pasted to the wall or wainscot.t Now if at length, these
“ See note GGG, at the end of this book. + “Ils preferent méme un beau
caractere ἃ la plus admirable peinture, et lon en voit souvent qui achetent bien cher
une page de vieux caracteres, quand ils sont bien formez. [15 honorent leurs caracteres
jusques dans les livres les plus ordinaires, et si par hasard quelques fetilles etoient tom-
bées, ils les ramassent avec respect: ce seroit, selon eux, une grossiereté et une impoli-
tesse, d’en faire un usage profane, de les fouler aux pieds en marchant, de les jetter
220 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK lV.
people should be prevailed on to use the more excellent’ way of
writing with the letters of an alphabet, can any one doubt but that
their Mandarins would still continue these venerable hieroglyphic.
characters in their works of Science and Religion? Thus, what we see
would be the case here was without all question the case of the Egyp-
tians : Characters become the vehicle of such treasures of learning
must be in the highest reverence: and, indeed, the name of Hiero-
glyphics, under which they were delivered to the Greeks, shews they
were in fact thus reverenced.* But that learning which was con-
tained in hieroglyphics, and was, of itself, sufficient to perpetuate
their use, gave birth to a tradition which would effectually secure it ;
and this was, that the Gops themselves invented hieroglyphic writing.
On the whole, The argument drawn from their CONTINUED USE
seems so sure a proof of the high antiquity of Egyptian learning in
general, that one might safely rest the whole upon it: But to remove
all cavil, I shall proceed to other, and, as I think, incontestable
proofs of the antiquity of that learning, and particularly the theologic :
the one taken from the true original of the art of On1RO-cRITIC, or
interpretation of dreams ; and the other from the true original of
ANIMAL worsHiP: both of these fantastic superstitions being the
genuine and peculiar growth of Eeyrr.
I. The art of On1rocriTIC, from whose original I deduce my first
proof, made a very considerable part of ancient Pagan religion.
Artemidorus, who lived about the beginning of the second century,
and wrote a treatise on Dreams, collected from much earlier writers,
divides dreams_into two kinds, the speculative and the allegorical ; +
the first kind is that which presents a plain and direct picture of the
matter about which the Dream gives information; the second is an
oblique intimation of it, by a tropical or symbolic image: This latter,
which makes up the large farrago of dreams, is the only kind that
needs an Interpreter; on which account Macrobius defines_a Dream
to be the notice of something hid in allegory which wants to be
explained.t
So that the question will be, on what grounds or rules of inter-
pretation the Onirocritics proceeded, when, if a man dreamt of a
dragon, the Interpreter assured him it signified majesty ; if of a ser-
pent, a disease ; a viper, money ; frogs, impostors ; pigeons and stock-
méme avec indifference ; souvent il arrive, que les menuisiers et les macons n’osent pas
dechirer une feiiille imprimée, qui se trouve collée sur le mur, ou sur le bois. Ils
craignent de faire une faute.’’—Du Haupe, Descr. de l’ Empire de la Chine, tom. ii.
p- 228.
* See p. 1753 and see note HHH, at the end of this book. + Ἔτι τῶν ὀνείρων,
οἱ μὲν εἰσὶ ϑεωρηματικοί" of δὲ ἀλληγορικοί. Καὶ ϑεωρηματικοὶ μὲν, οἱ τῇ ἑαυτῶν ϑέᾳ
-προσεοικότες ---᾿Αλληγορικοὶ δὲ, οἱ δι’ ἄλλων ἄλλα onualvovres.—ARTEMIDORI Oneir.
lib. i. cap. 2. { “*Somnium proprie vocatur, quod tegit figuris et velut ambagibus,
non nisi interpretatione intelligendam, significationem rei que demonstratur.’’—Jn
Somnium Scipionis, lib. i. cap. 8.
SECT. Iv. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 99]
doves, women : partridges, impious persons ; a swallow, sorrow, death,
and disaster ; cats, adultery ; the ichneumon, deceitful and mischiev-
ous men, δ᾽. ἢ for the whole art of ancient onirocritic was concerned
in these remote and. mysterious relations. Now the early Interpreters
of dreams were not juggling impostors ; but, like the early judicial
Astrologers, more superstitious than their neighbours; and so the
first who fell into their own delusions. However, suppose them to
have been as arrant cheats as any of their successors, yet at their first
setting up they must have had materials proper for their trade ; which
could never be the wild workings of each man’s private fancy. Their
Customers would look to find a known analogy, become venerable by
long application to mysterious wisdom, for the grow&d-work of their
deciphering ; and the Decipherers themselves would as naturally fly to
some confessed authority, to support their pretended Science. But
what ground or authority could this be, if not the mysterious learning
of symbolic characters? Were we seem to have got a solution of the
difficulty. The Hgyptian priests, the first interpreters of dreams,
took their rules for this species of DIVINATION, from their symbolic
riddling, in which they were so deeply read: A ground of interpreta-
tion which would give the strongest credit to the Art; and equally
satisfy the Diviner and the Consulter: for by this time it was gene-
rally believed that their Gods had given them hieroglyphic writing.
So that nothing was more natural than to imagine that these Gods,
who in their opinion gave dreams likewise, had employed the same
mode of expression in both revelations. This, I suppose, was the
true original+ of onirocritic, or the interpretation of those dreams
called allegorical ; that is, of dreams in general =) for the wildness of
an unbridled fancy will make almost all natural dreams to be of that
kind. It is true, the Art being now well established, every age
adorned it with additional superstitions ; so that at length the old
foundation became quite lost in these new incrustations.
If this account of its original stood in need of farther evidence, I
might urge the rules of interpretation here given from Artemidorus,
and a great many more which might have been given; all of them
conformable to the symbolic hieroglyphics in Horapollo.
Herodotus, in Clio, tells us, how Cyrus, dreaming that young
Darius had wines on his shoulders, which, when spread out, shaded
Asia and Europe, understood this dream by the assistance of his
Interpreters, to signify (as we must needs conclude) a conspiracy
formed against him by that young man. Now Sanchoniatho tells
ust that in the most ancient hieroglyphic writing, a supreme governor
was designed by a man with four wines, and his lieutenants or
* Vide AKTEMIDORUM. + See note IIT, at the end of this book. t See
above, p. 177.
992 THE DIVINE LEGATION ROOK IV:
princes under him by a man with two: and that their being oué-
stretched signified action or design.* au
But there is one remarkable circumstance which puts the matter
out of all doubt. The technical term used by the Onirocritics for
the phantasms seen in dreams, was =TOIXEIA,+ elements. It
would be hard to give a good account of the use of so odd a term on
any other supposition than the derivation of onirocritic from symbolic
writing. On that supposition it is easy and evident; for symbolic
marks} were called ΣΤΟΙΧΕΙ͂Α. Now when they used symbols to
decipher dreams, nothing was more natural than to give the same
significative images, on the stone and in the fancy, the same
appellation. ᾿
The reason why the Egyptian priests (who, we have seen, used the
Greek tongue very early) called their hieroglyphic and symbolic
marks Sroiysia, was because, in this way of writing, they employed
all kinds of natural entities, to denote their mental conceptions ; the
proper signification of Sroiyeia being the first elements and princi-
ples of things, out of which all beings arise, and, of which, they are
compounded.§ Hence it came that alphabetic letters, which were an
improvement on hieroglyphics and received their first shapes from
hieroglyphic images, were called Sroiyeia.
So much for the original of onirocritic. To bring it to the point,
we are next to consider its antiquity. Now Scripture leads us to the
practice of this art as high up as the age of Joseph.
Pharaoh had two Jasna ; || one of seven kine, the other εἰν seven
ears of corn. We see both these phantasms [Sroiei«] were symbols
of Egypt : The ears denoting its- distinguished fertility ; the /ine, its
great tutelary patroness, Isis. “ Pharaoh knew thus much without an
Interpreter ; and hence arose his solicitude and anxiety to understand
the rest, as a matter that concerned the Public: Accordingly, when
Joseph 4 comes to decipher these dreams, he does not tell the king
that the two sevens denoted seven years in Egypt, but simply seven
years : The scene of the famine needed no deciphering. Unlike, in
this, to the interpretation of Daniel, when Nebuchadnezzar saw in a
dream a fair and high tree; which being the symbol of majesty in
general, the prophet explains its particular meaning, “ The tree that
thou sawest—it is THov, O king.” **
The argument therefore stands thus: the Onirocritics borrowed
their art of deciphering from symbolic hieroglyphics.—But this could
not be till hieroglyphics were become sacred, by being made the
cloudy vehicle of their Theology ; because, till then, hieroglyphics
* See note KKK, at the end of this book. + See note LLL, at the end of this
book. t See note MMM, at the end of this book. § See p. 177, and notes LLL
and MMM. || Gen. xli. 4] See note NNN, at the end of this book.
** Dan. iy. 19—21,
SECT. IV. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 223
had neither authority enough to support the credit of those inter-
pretations, nor a perplexity sufficiently copious to support the mystery
of this application.—But by the time hieroglyphics were become
sacred, Egypt was very learned.—Now they were sacred in the days
of Joseph, as appears from the use of interpreting dreams according
to those symbols.—Therefore learned Egypt of very high antiquity.
II. My second argument for this antiquity is deduced from the
true original of ANIMAL-worsHIP; and stands thus: We have
observed, that in those improved hieroglyphics, called Symbols (in
which, it is confessed, the ancient Egyptian learning was contained)
the less obvious properties of animals occasioned their becoming
marks, by analogical adaption, for very different ideas, whether of
substances or modes; which plainly intimates that physical know-
ledge had been long cultivated. Now these symbols I hold to be the
true original of aANIMAL-worsHtIP in Egypt.» But animal-worship
was the established worship in the time of Moses, as is evident from
the book of Hwodus: Therefore the Egyptian learning was of this
high antiquity.* The only proposition, in this argument, that needs
any proof, is the first. The reasons therefore which induce me to
think symbolic writing to be the sole origin of Animal-worship are these :
1. This kind of idolatry was peculiar to the Zyyptian superstition ;
and almost unknown to all the Casts of paganism, but such as were
evidently copied from that original: + Moses treats it as their distin-
guishing superstition: | The Greeks and Romans, though at a loss
for its original, yet speak of it as the peculiar extravagance of
Egypt : And the most intelligent of the moderns consider it in the
very same light.§
2. The Egyptians not only worshipped Animals, but PLANTS ;
and, in a word, every kind of being that had qualities remarkably sin-
gular or efficacious ; because all these had found their place in sym-
bolic writing: For, as hath been shewn, when Hieroglyphics came to
be employed for mystery, no sooner was one symbol grown common
and vulgar, than another was invented of a more recondite meaning :
so that the animal, vegetable, and mineral kingdoms would be all
explored to paint the histories of their Gods.
* See note OOO, at the end of this book. + Such as the several Gentile nations
of Palestine and India. 1 Deut. iv. 14—21. § The learned Fourmont thus
expresses himself:—Mais pour parler simplement et sans fard, il faudra bon gré
mal gré en revenir ἃ ceci, que les Egyptiens etoient, et, s’ils pensoien tun peu, devoient
se croire eux mémes un peuple fort extravagant ; on n’apotheose point sans folie les
Oignons et les Asperges: que pensez encore des Dieux Oiseaux, Poissons, Serpens,
Crocodiles 2 mais non-seulement ils avoient deifié les animaux ; ce qui est plus etrange
encore, infatuez de la Metempsycose, ils s’etoient enthousiasmez la dessus de Mysta-
gogies incomprehensibles. Leurs pretres, par un zele qu'on ne connoit pas trop,
s’etoient rendus les Predicateurs de ces mémes folies ; et ils en avoient dans leurs con-
quétes, ow par des missions, infecté tout l’ Inde, toute la Chine, tout le Japon.—Heflew.
Crit. sur les Hist. des Anc. Peuples, tom. i. p. 227.
294 THE DIVINE LEGATION : ROOK Iv.
3. Besides the adoration of almost every thing existing, the Eyyp-
trans worshipped a thousand Chimeras of their own creation: Some
with human bodies, and the head or feet of brutes; others with
brutal bodies, and the heads or feet of men; while others again were
a fantastic compound of the several parts of beasts, birds, and reptiles,
terrestrial and aquatic: for besides the simpler method, in hierogly-
phic writing, of expressing their hero-gods by an intire plant or
animal, there were two others which the more circumstantial history
of those deities brought in use. Thus when the subject was only one
single quality of a god or hero, the human shape was only partially
deformed ; * as with the head of a dog, hawk, or ram, to denote
fidelity, vigilance, or strength ; with the feet and thighs of a goat, to
represent rusticity, agility, or lust; and this gave Being to their
Anubis, Pan, and Jupiter Ammon: But where the subject required a
fuller catalogue of the hero’s virtues or useful qualities, there they
employed an assemblage of the several parts of various animals: each
of which, in hieroglyphic writing, was significative of a distinet pro-
perty : in which assemblage, that animal, more peculiarly representa-
tive of the God, was most conspicuous. This will explain the verse
. of Anticlides in his hymn to the sun,
Ἡέλιος δὲ Νότοιο “Avak IEPAZ ΠΟΛΥΜΟΡΦΕ.
The sun was generally expressed by a hawk ; but this symbolic hawk,
under various considerations, had the various parts of other animals
added to it.
4. That animal which was worshipped in one city was sacrificed in
another. Thus, though at Memphis they adored the ox, at Mendes
the goat, and at Thebes the ram; yet, in one place or other, each of
these animals was used in sacrifice: but bulls and clean calves were
offered up in all places. The reason of this can only be that at
Memphis the ox was, in hieroglyphic learning, the symbol of some
deity ; at Mendes the goat; and at Thebes the ram; but the bull and
calf no where : For what else can be said for the original of so fantas-
tical a diversity in representative deities within a kingdom of one
national religion ’—But farther: the same animal was feasted in one
place, with divine honours; in another it was pursued with the direst
execrations. Thus, at Arsinoé, the crocodile was adored ; because
having no tongue it was made in hieroglyphic writing the symbol of
the divinity ; + elsewhere it was had in horror, as being made in the
* Elkacta: wap αὐτοῖς Tis μέχρι τραχήλου ἀνθρωποειδὴς, τὸ δὲ wpdcwrov ὀρνέου, ἢ
λέοντος. ἢ ἄλλου τινὸς ζώου κεκτημένος" καὶ wdAw αὖ κεφαλὴ ἀνθρωπείος, καὶ ἄλλων
τινῶν ζώων μέρη wh μὲν ὑποκείμενα, wh δὲ emixelweva.—PoRPHYRIUS De Abst. lib. iv.
+ Plutarch, in general, tells us, that the Egyptians thus considered the crocodile ; but
this author, for private ends, delivering a false original of Animal-worship, it was not to
his purpose to tell us it was so considered in symbolic writing :—ov μὴν οὐδὲ ὁ Κροκό-
δειλος αἰτίας τοιθανῆς ἀμοιροῦσαν ἔσχηκε τιμὴν. ἀλλὰ ov μίμημα ϑεοῦ λέγεται γεγονέναι;
μόνος μὲν ἄγλωσσος tv: φωνῆς γὰρ 6 ϑεῖος λόγος ἀπροσδεής ἐστι.--- 1)6 Is. et Osir.
SECT. IV. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 995
same writing the symbol of Typhon;* that is, it was used as a
sacred character in the history both of their natural and civil
Theology.
5. Brute-worship was, at first, altogether objective to their hero-
gods; of whom animals were but the representatives. This is seen
from the rank they hold on ancient monuments ; from the unvaried
worship of some few of them, as the Apis, which still continued to be
adored as the representative of Osiris :—and from the express testi-
mony of Herodotus ; who says, that, when the Egyptians addressed
the sacred Animal, their devotions were paid to that God to whom
the beast belonged.+
6. But to make the matter still plainer, it may be observed, that
the most early brute-worship in Egypt was not an adoration of the
living animal, but only of its picture or image. This truth Herodotus
seems to hint at in Euterpe, where he says, the Egyptians erected the
first altars, images, and temples to the gods, and carved the rigurES
OF ANIMALS on stones.t Now, were the original of brute-worship
any other than what is here supposed, the living animal must have
been first worshipped, and the image of it would have been only an
attendant superstition. From the sECOND COMMANDMENT, and
Moses’s exhortation to obedience, it appears that the Egyptians at the
time of the Exodus, worshipped no living animal, but the picture or
image only; “Thou shalt have no other Gods before me. Thou
shalt not make unto thee any graven image, or any likeness of any
thing that is in heaven above or that is in the earth beneath, or that
is in the water under the earth. Thou shalt not bow down thyself
to them, nor serve them.” § Thus speaks the law of the first table ;
by which we not only see that brute-worship was under an image, but
that such image was symbolical of Gods different from the animal
pictured, and alluded to in the words, Thou shalt have no other Gods
before me. Another thing observable in the law is, that not only the
making pictures and images for adoration was forbidden, but the
simple making of them at all, And thus the Jews understood it.
The consequence was, that /ieroglyphics were forbidden: a strong
proof of their being the source of the idolatry in question. Moses,
in his exhortation to the people, paraphrases and explains this law :
«Take ye, therefore, good heed unto yourselves (for ye saw no man-
ner of similitude on the day that the LORD spake to you in Horeb,
out of the midst of the fire) lest ye corrupt yourselves and make you
* The subsequent doctrine of the Metempsychosis soon made this the foundation of a
fable, that the soul of Typhon had passed into a crocodile,—that Typhon had assumed
that figure, ὥς. See ALLIAN’s ‘‘ Hist. of Animals,” lib. x. cap. 21. t Οἱ δὲ ἐν
TOL «σόλισι ἕκαστοι εὐχὰς τὰς δέ σφι ἀποτελέουσι" εὐχόμενοι τῷ DEG τοῦ ἂν ἢ τὸ
Snplov.— Lib. ii. cap. 65. t Βωμούς τε καὶ ἀγάλματα Kal νηοὺς ϑεοῖσι ἀπονεῖμαι
σφέας wpwrous, καὶ ζῶα ἐν λίθοισι ἐγγλύψαι.----Οδρ. 4. § Exod. xx. 3—6,
VOL. II. Q
226 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
a graven image, the similitude of any figure, the likeness of male
or female, the likeness of any beast that is on the earth, the likeness
of any winged fowl that flieth in the air, the likeness of any thing
that creepeth on the ground, the likeness of any fish that is in the
waters beneath the earth.” * There are two important conclusions
to be drawn from the reason of this exhortation, for you saw no man-
ner of similitude, §e. The first is, that the Egyptian brute-worship
was symbolical ; the other, that Mosrs’s prime intention was to warn
the people against representing the Gop of Israel under the shape of
men or animals, in the guise of the greater Gods of Egypt. This
observation will open our way to another circumstance, which shews
that the worship of the living animal was not yet in use amongst the
Egyptians ; and that is, the idolatrous erection of the golden calf.+
The people now suspecting they had lost Mosrs, whom they were
taught to consider as the vicegerent, or representative of thei Gon,
grew impatient for another; and, besotted with Egyptian supersti-
tions, chose for his representative the same which the Egyptians used
for the symbol of their great God, Osiris. Interpreters seem to run
into two different extremes concerning this matter, some conceiving
that the Israelites worshipped an Egyptian God under the golden calf;
though the worshippers themselves expresly declare the contrary :
“These” (say they) “06 thy Gods, O Israel, which brought thee up
out of the land of Egypt.” ¢ Others suppose the ca/f was not made
im imitation of any Egyptian symbol whatsoever, because it was the
living Apis that represented Osiris ; but we see the worship of the
living animal was not yet introduced. However, in time, and in no
long time neither, for it was as early as the Prophets, the Egyptians
began to worship the animal itself ; which worship, as might be well
expected, prevailed at length over that of its image. Colunt effigies
multorum animalium, atque ipsa MAGIS animalia, says Pomponius
Mela§ of the Egyptians; and this naturally gave birth to new super-
stitions ; for, as he goes on, Apis populorum omnium numen est. Bos
niger, certis maculis insignis—raro nascitur, nec coitu pecoris (ut
aiunt) sed divinitus et ccelesti igne conceptus.
These considerations are sufficient to shew that hieroglyphics were
indeed the original of brute-worship: And how easy it was for the
Egyptians to fall into it from the use of this kind of writing, appears
from hence. In these hieroglyphics was recorded the history of their
greater, and tutelary deities, their kings and lawgivers ; represented
by animals and other creatures. The symbol of each God was well
known and familiar to his worshippers, by means of the popular
paintings and engravings on their temples and other sacred monu-
* Dent. iv. 15—18, + See note PPP, at the end of this book. 1 Exod.
Xxxii. 4, § De Situ Orb. lib. i, cap. 6.
SECT. Iv. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED, 997
~~
ments : * so that the symbol presenting the idea of the God, and that
idea exciting sentiments of religion, it was natural for them, in their
addresses to any particular deity, to turn towards his representative,
mark or symbol. This will be easily granted if we reflect, that when
the Egyptian priests began to speculate, and grow mysterious, they
feigned a divine original for hieroglyphic characters, in order to render
them still more august and venerable. This would, of course, bring
on a relative devotion to these symbolic figures ; which, when it came
to be paid to the living animal, would soon terminate in an ultimate
worship.
But the occasional propensity to this superstition was, without
question, forwarded and encouraged by the Priesthood ; for it greatly
supported the worship of the hero-deities, by making their theology
more intricate; and by keeping out of sight, what could not but
weaken religious veneration in remote posterity, the naked truth, that
they were only DEAD MEN DEIFIED. And these advantages they
afterwards improved with notable address ; by making those Symbols
as well relative to new conceived imaginary qualities and influences of
their first natural gods, the host of heaven, as to what they properly
respected, in hieroglyphic writing, their later heroes and tutelary
deities ; Which trick, invented to keep the Egyptians in their super-
stition, spread so impenetrable an obscurity over paganism, as hin-
dered the most sagacious Philosophers and knowing Antiquaries of
Greece from ever getting a right view of the rise and progress of their
own idolatry.
And, if I be not much mistaken, it was the design of these Egyp-
tian priests to commemorate the advantages of this contrivance in the
celebrated fable-+ of TypHON’S WAR WITH THE Gops; who, dis-
tressed and terrified by this earth-born giant, fled from his persecu-
tion into Eaypt; and there hid themselves each under the form of a
several ANIMAL. This adventure is related by Ovid in a very agree-
able and artful manner, where he makes one of the impious Pierides
sing it, in their contest with the Muses :
Bella canit supertim: Falsoque in honore gigantes
Ponit, et extenuat magnorum facta deorum ;
Enmissumque ima de sede Typhoéa terre
Celitibus fecisse metum ; cunctosque dedisse-
Terga fuga : donec fessos JAGYPTIA tellus
Ceperit, et septem discretus in ostia Nilus.
Hue quoque terrigenam venisse Typhoéa narrat,
Et se MENTITIS superos celasse FIGURIS:
“ This account is supported by Herodotus, where saying that the Egyptians first of
all raised altars, statues, and temples to the gods, he immediately adds, and engraved
animals on stone : βωμούς τε καὶ ἀγάλματα καὶ νηοὺς ϑεοῖσι ἀπονεῖμαι σφέας wpHTovs,
καὶ ΖΏΑ ΕΝ AIOOISI EFLAYTVAI.—Lib. ii. cap. 4. + Diop. Sicut. lib. i.
p- 54, Steph. ed. informs us, that this was an Egyptian fable: as does Lucian, in his
tract De Sacrifictis,
Qn
228 THE DIVINE LEGATION | BOOK IV.
Duxque gregis, divit, fit Jupiter ; UNDE recurvis
Nunc quogue formatus Libys est cum cornibus Ammon.
Delius in corvo, proles Semeléia capro,
Fele soror Phebi, nivea Saturnia vacca,
Pisce Venus latuit, Cyllenius Ibidis alis.*
Typhon, amongst the Egyptians, was the exemplar of impiety : so
that under that name we are to understand the inquisitive, which the
priests always surnamed ¢he impious (such who in after-times followed
the celebrated Euhemerus of Greece); these, in a malicious search
into the genealogies of their Gods, had so near detected their original,
and consequently endangered their worship, that the priests had
nothing left but to perplex and embroil the enquiry, by encouraging
the symBoxic worship as explained above. WHence this fable (in
which they celebrated the subtilty of their expedient) that Egypt
afforded a place of refuge for the Gods; who there lay hid under the
forms of beasts. Where we must observe, that the shape each God
was said to have assumed was that of his symbolic mark in hieroglyphic
writing.t Indeed Antonius Liberalis 1 differs from Ovid in the parti-
cular transformations ; and Lucian,§ from them both ; but this rather
confirms than weakens our interpretation ; since each God, as we
have seen, was denoted by divers hieroglyphics. We must not sup-
pose, however, that the whole of their distress came from the quarter
of their enemies. More favourable enquirers would be a little
troublesome. And the same expedient would keep them at a distance
likewise. The Priests seem to have hinted at this case likewise, in
the similar story they told Herodotus, “that Hercules was very
desirous to see Jupiter, who was by no means consenting to this
interview ; at last overcome by the hero’s importunity, he eluded his
curiosity, by this expedient: he flay’d the carcase of a ram; and
investing himself with the skin separated with the head from the
body, he presented himself under that appearance to the inquirer.’’|j
Herodotus himself seems to hint at something like the explanation of
the fable of Typhon given above, where speaking of Pan soon after,
and on the same occasion, he says, “ The Egyptians represent Pan as
the Grecians paint him, with the face and legs of a goat. Not that
they imagine this to be his real form, which is the same with that of
the other Gods. But I take no satisfaction in recording the reason
they give for representing him in this manner.” From these two
different ways of relating the circumstance of Jupiter’s and Pan’s
* Metam. lib. v. fab. 5. + See note QQQ, at the end of this book. t Cap.
xxviii. § De Sacrif. || Θηβαῖοι μέν νυν, καὶ ὅσοι διὰ τούτους ὀίων ἀπέχονται,
διὰ τάδε λέγουσι τὸν νόμον τόνδέ σφι τεθῆναι. Ἡρακλέα ϑελῆσαι wavtTws ἰδέσθαι τὸν
Δία, καὶ τὸν οὐκ ἐθέλειν ὀφθῆναι ὑπ᾽ αὐτοῦ" τέλος δὲ, ἐπεί τε λιπαρέειν τὸν Ἡρακλέα,
τὸν Δία μηχανήσασθαι, κριὸν ἐκδείραντα τοροεχέσθαί τε τὴν κεφαλὴν ἀποόταμόντα τοῦ
κριοῦ καὶ ἐνδύντα τὸ νάκος, οὕτω οἱ EwdTdy ἐπιδείξαι.---- 110. ii, cap, 8. 4 Τοῦ Πανὸς
τὥγαλμα, κατάπερ Ἕλληνες, αἰγοπρόσωπον καὶ τραγοσκελέα" οὔτι τοιοῦτον νομίζοντες
εἶναί μιν, ἀλλ᾽ ὅμοιον τοῖσι ἄλλοισι ϑεοῖσι. ὅτευ δὲ εἵνεκα τοιοῦτον γράφουσι αὐτὸν, οὔ
μοι ἥδιόν ἐστι A€yew.—Lib. ii. cap. 46.
SECT. Iv. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 229
disguises under a brutal form, it appears that the Egyptian priests had
two accounts concerning it, the exoteric and the esoteric. Herodotus,
in the story of Jupiter, makes no scruple to record the first ; but the
other, which concerns Pan’s transformation, he did not care to touch
upon.
If this explanation of the famous fable of Typhon needed any
further support, we might find it in what the Egyptian Theologers
continued to deliver down concerning it. Diodorus Siculus, speaking
of the difficulty in discovering the true original of Egyptian brute-
worship, says, that the priests had a profound secret concerning it :*
A strong presumption that this here delivered was the secret ; it
being the only one which the Priests were much concerned to keep to
themselves ; as we shall see when we come to speak of the causes
assigned by the Ancients for brute-worship. What the Priests
thought fit to imtrust to the people concerning this matter, the
Sicilian tells us, was this; That the Gods of the early times being
few im number, and so forced to yield to the multitude and injustice
of earth-born men, assumed the forms of divers Animals, and by that
means escaped the cruelty and violence of their enemies ; but that, at
length, gaining the empire of the world, they consecrated the species of
those Animals whose forms they had assumed, in gratitude for that
relief which they had received from them in their distresses.- The
moral of the fable lies too open to need an Interpreter: it can hardly,
indeed, be any other than that we have here given. But Diodorus
aids us in the discovery of that secret, which he himself appears not
to have penetrated, where he says that Melampus, who brought the
Mysteries of Proserpine from Egypt into Greece, taught them the
story of TypHon, and the whole history of the disasters and sufferings
of the Gods.t Now we have shewn§ that one part of the office of
the Hierophant of the Mysteries was to reveal the true original of
Polytheism : which instruction could not be conveyed more appositely,
than in the history of T'yphon, as here explained. From the whole
then, we conclude, that this was indeed the profound secret, which the
Egyptian priests had concerning it. So that the passage of Diodorus,
last quoted, not only supports our interpretation of the Ne of
Typhon, but of the secret of the Mysteries likewise.
Only one thing is worth our notice, that the Priests should think
fit to give the people this curious origin of brute-worship : We have
observed, that they promoted and encouraged this Brutal-idolatry in
* Of μὲν Ἱερεῖς αὐτῶν ἀπόῤῥητόν τι δόγμα wep) τούτων ἔχουσιν.-- Τὴν. i. p. 54.
+ Φασὶ γὰρ τοὺς ἐξ ἀρχῆς γενομένους Seovs, ὀλίγους ὄντας καὶ κατισχυομένους ὑπὸ τοῦ
ττὉλήθους καὶ τῆς ἀνομίας τῶν γηγενῶν ἀνθρώπων, ὁμοιωθῆναι τισὶ τῶν ζώων, καὶ διὰ τοῦ
τοιούτου τρόπου διαφυγεῖν τὴν ὠμότητα καὶ βίαν αὐτῶν" ὕστερον δὲ τῶν κατὰ τὸν κόσμον
-τπάντων κρατήσαντας καὶ τοῖς αἰτίοις τῆς €& ἃ ἀρχῆς σωτηρίας χάριν ἀποδιδόντας, ἀφιερῶσαι
τὰς φύσεις αὐτῶν οἷς ἀφωμοιώθησαν. —Lib. i. p. 54. t Τὸ σύνολον τὴν wep) τὰ
ταάθη τῶν ϑεῶν irropiav.—Lib. i. § “Divine Legation,” vol. i. pp. 299, &c.
230 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK ιν.
order to hide the weakness of their Hero-worship ; but then some
reason was to be given for that more extravagant superstition : so, by
a fine contrivance, they made the circumstances of the fable, by which
they would commemorate their address in introducing a new supersti-
tion to support the old, a reason for that introduced support. This
was a fetch of policy worthy of an Egyptian priesthood.
But let us hear what the Ancients in general have to say concern-
ing the beginning of Jdrute-worship. Now the Ancients having
generally mistaken the origin of Hieroglyphics, it is no wonder they
should be mistaken in this likewise: and how much they were
mistaken, their diversity and inconstancy of opinion plainly shew us :
And yet, amidst this diversity, the cause here assigned hath escaped
them ; which had otherwise, ’tis probable, put an end to all farther
conjecture. But as they chanced to fall into variety of wrong
opinions, it will be incumbent on me to examine and confute them.
What I can at present recollect as any way deserving notice, are the
following :
They suppose brute-worship to have arisen,
. From the denefits men receive of animals.
From the doctrine of the metempsychosis.
. From the use of asterisms.
From the notion of Gon’s pervading ali things.
From the use of Animals as Symbols of the divine nature.
6. From the invention of a certain Egyptian king for his private
ends of policy.
These, I think, are all the opinions of moment. And of these, we
may observe in general, that the fourth and fifth are least wide of the
truth, as making brute-worship symbolical : But the defect, common
to them all, is that the reason assigned by each concludes for the
universality of this worship throughout paganism ; whereas it was in
fact peculiar to Egypt ; and seen and owned to be so by these very
Ancients themselves.
I. The first opinion is that we find in CicERro,* who supposes the
original to be a grateful sense of benefits received from animals.
1. This labours under all the defects of an inadequate cause, as
concluding ‘both too much, and too little: Too much ; because, on
this ground, brute-worship would have been common to all nations ;
but it was peculiar to the Egyptian and its colonies: Too little ;
1. because on this ground none but useful animals should have been
worshipped ; whereas several of the most useless and noxious + were
held sacred. 2. Plant-worship must then, in the nature of things,
have been prior to, or at least coeval with, that of drutes. But it
σε a τῷ κα
"See note RRR, at the end of this book. + See note SSS, at the end of this book.
SECT. Iv. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 231
was much later; and, on our theory, we see how this came to pass ;
the vegetable world would not be explored, to find out hieroglyphical
analogies, ’till the animal had been exhausted.
II. Neither could the doctrine of the metempsychosis, mentioned by
Dioporvs,* be the origin of brute-worship: 1. Because that opinion
was common to all nations; but brute-worship peculiar to Egypt.
The doctrine of the metempsychosis flourisheth, at this day, with
greater vigour in India, than, perhaps, it ever did in any place or age
of the world; yet it occasions no worship, or religious veneration to
those animals which are supposed the receptacles of departed souls.
A very excessive charity towards them it does indeed afford. And
this is the more remarkable, not only as this people are sunk into the
most sordid superstitions, but because, having learnt animal-worship
of Egypt,t if the doctrine of the metempsychosis had any natural
tendency to inflame that superstition, they had by this time been
totally devoted to it. 2. Because the hypothesis which makes ¢rans-
migration the origin of brute-worship, must suppose brutes to be
venerated as the receptacle of human souls become deified: but the
ancient Egyptians deified none but heroic and demonic souls: and
souls of this order were not supposed subject to the common law of
the metempsychosis.~ 3. The intrusion of those souls into brutal
bodies, according to the law of transmigration, was understood to be a
punishment for crimes. Their prison-house therefore could never
become the object of adoration; but rather of aversion and abhor-
rence ; as all subferraneous fire was amongst the ancient Romans, and
as that of purgatory is amongst the modern. 4. Lastly, the doctrine
of the metempsychosis was much later than the first practice of brute-
worship ; and evidently invented to remove objections against Provi-
dence,§ when men began to speculate and philosophise. What seems
to have given birth to this opinion of the origin of brute-worship, was
the fancy of the later Egyptians, that the soul of Osiris resided in the
Apis. Diodorus himself supports the conjecture: For, reckoning up
the several opinions concerning the origin of brute-worship, when he
comes to that of the metempsychosis, he delivers it in a popular
relation of the soul of Osiris residing in the Apis.
III. The third opinion we find to be favoured by Lucran : || which
* Diodorus delivers this original, in his account of the superstitious worship of the
Apis: Τῆς δὲ τοῦ Bods τούτου τιμῆς αἰτίαν ἔνιοι φέρουσι, λέγοντες ὅτι τελευτήσαντος
᾿᾽Οσίριδος, εἰς τοῦτον ἣ ψυχὴ αὐτοῦ μετέστη, καὶ διὰ ταῦτα διατελεῖ μέχρι τοῦ νῦν del
κατὰ τὰς ἀναδείξεις αὐτοῦ μεθισταμένη wpds τοὺς peTayeveoTepovs.—Lib. i. p. δ4.
+ As appears from hence, that those few animals, which are the objects of their reli-
gious worship, are such as were formerly most reverenced in Egypt; and into such, no
souls are doomed by the law of transmigration ; the reason of which we shall see pre-
sently. t The difference between heroic, demonic, and human souls, as it was
conceived by the most early pagans, will be explained hereafter. § See vol. i. p. 439.
\| Οἱ δὲ [Αὐγύπτιοι] καὶ ἄλλα ἐμήσαντο WOAAG μείζω τουτέων" ἐκ γὰρ δὴ τοῦ τσαντὸς ἠέρος,
«αὶ ἀστέρων τῶν ἄλλων, ἀπλανέων τε καὶ εὐσταθέων, καὶ οὐδ᾽ ἅμα κινεομένων, δυώδεκα
232 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
is, that the Egyptian invention of distinguishing the Constellations,
and marking each of them with the name of some animal, gave the first
occasion to brute-worship. But, 1. the same objection lies against
this solution as against the two preceding: for this way of distin-
guishing the Asterisms was in use in all nations ; but brute-worship
was confined to Egypt and its colonies. 2. This way of solving the
difficulty creates a greater : for then nothing will be left in antiquity,*
to account for so extraordinary a custom as the giving to one Constel-
lation the form of a ram, to another the form of a scorpion, &c.
when, in the apparent disposition of those stars, there was not so
much resemblance to any one part of any one animal as was sufficient
to set the fancy on work to make out the rest. But if, for distinc-
tion sake, those things were to have a name which had no shape,t
why then, as being of such regard from their supposed influences,
were they not rather honoured with the titles of their heroes than of
their brutes? Would the polite Egyptian priests, who first animal-
ized the Asterisms, do like Tom Otter in the comedy, bring their Bulls
and Bears to court? would they exalt them into heaven before they
had made any considerable figure upon earth? The fact is, indeed,
just otherwise. It was brute-worship which gave birth to the Aster-
isms. That the constellations were first named and distinguished by
the Egyptians, is agreed on all hands: that they were much later than
the beginning of brute-worship, is as evident ; the confused multitude
of stars not being thus sorted into bands, till the Egyptian priests
had made some considerable progress in astronomy: But brute-
worship, we know from Scripture, was prior to the time of Mosgs.
When they began to collect the stars into Constellations, a name was
necessary to keep up the combination ; and animals, now become the
religious symbols of their Gods, afforded the aptest means for that
purpose: For, 1. It did honour to their heroes: 2. It supported their
astrology (which always went along, and was often confounded with,
their astronomy,) it being understood to imply that their country
Gods had now taken up their residence in Constellations of benignant
influence.
TV. Nor is there any better foundation for the fourth opinion ;
μοίρας ἐτάμοντο ἐν τοῖσι κινεομένοισι, καὶ οἰκεῖα ζῶα ἐόντα, ἕκαστον αὐτῶν és ἄλλην
μορφὴν μεμιμέαται---ἀπὸ τέων δὴ καὶ ἱερὰ τὰ Αἰγύπτια wodveidéa «τσοιέεται: οὐ yap
ταάντες Αἰγύπτιοι ἐκ τῶν δυώδεκα μοιρέων τσασέων ἐμαντεύοντο, ἄλλοι δὲ, ἀλλοίῃσι
μοίρῃσιν ἐχρέοντο" καὶ κριὸν μὲν σέβουσιν, ὁκόσοι ἐς κριὸν ἀπέθλεπον" ἰχθύας δὲ οὐ
σιτέονται, ὁκόσοι ἰχθύας ἐπεσημήναντο" οὐδὲ τράγον κτείνουσιν, ὅσοι αἴγόκερων ἤδεσαν —
ναὶ μὴν καὶ Ταῦρον ἐς τιμὴν τοῦ ἢερίου Ταύρου σεθίζονται.---1)6 Astrologia, tom. ii.
p- 363, edit. Reitzii, Amst. 4to. 1743.
* Tsay, in Antiquity: for as to the solution of this point by the liberty of imagin-
ing, nothing is more easy. The French author of “the History of the Heavens” has,
by the mere force of imagination, removed all these difficulties; not only without any
support from Antiquity, but even in defiance of it.
+ Εἴδεα σημαίνοιεν ἄφαρ δ᾽ ὀνόμαστα γένοιντο
ἔλστρα.-- ΑΒΑΤΟΒ in Φαινομ.
SECT. Iv. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 293
which is that of Porpuyry;* who supposes that the doctrine of
Gon’s pervading all things was the original of brute-worship. But, 1.
it proves too much: for according to this notion, every thing would
have been the object of divine worship amongst the early Egyptians ;
but we know many were not. 2. According to this notion, nothing
could have been the object of their execration; but we know many
were. 3. This notion was never an opinion of the people, but of a few
of the learned only: 4. And those, not of the learned of Egypt, but
of Greece.+ In a word, this pretended original of brute-worship was
only an invention of their late Philosophers, to hide the deformities,
and to support the credit of decliing Paganism.t
Y. Akin to this, and invented for the same end, is what we find
in JAMBLICHUS; § namely, That brutes were deified only as the sym-
bols of the first Cause, considered in all his attributes and relations.
Groundless as this fancy is, yet as it is embraced by our best philolo-
gists, such as Cudworth, Vossius, and Kircher, on the faith of those
fanatic and inveterate enemies to Christianity, Porphyry and Jambli-
chus, I shall endeavour to expose it as it deserves. This will be the
best done by considering the rise and order of the three great species
of idolatry. The first, in time, was, as we have shewn, the worship
of the heavenly bodies ; and this continued unmixed till the institu-
tion of political Society : Then, another species arose, the deification
of dead kings and lawgivers. Such was the course of idolatry in all
places as well as in Egypt: but there, the method of recording the
history of their hero Gods, in improved Hieroglyphics, gave birth to
the third species of idolatry, drute-worship ; and this was peculiar to
Egypt aud its colonies. Now as the method used by all nations, of
ingrafting hero-worship on star-worship, occasioned the Philologists to
mistake || the former as symbolical of the latter ; so the method, used
by the Egyptians (mentioned a little before) of supporting brute-
worship, which was really symbolical of their hero Gods, made the
same writers think it to be originally symbolical of star-Gods, and
even of the first Cause. Thus the very learned Vossius fell into two mis-
takes: 1. That hero-worship was symbolical of star-worship : 2. That
brute-worship was symbolical of it likewise. The consequence of
* ᾿Απὸ δὲ ταύτης ὁρμώμενοι τῆς ἀσκήσεως, καὶ τῆς Wpds TO ϑεῖον οἰκειώσεως, ἔγνωσαν,
ὡς οὐ δι ἀνθρώπου μόνου τὸ ϑεῖον διῆλθεν, οὔτε ψυχὴ ἐν μόνῳ ἀνθρώπῳ ἐπὶ γῆς κατε-
σκήνωσεν, ἀλλὰ σχεδὸν ἣ αὐτὴ διὰ τσάντων διῆλθεν τῶν ζώων: διὸ εἰς τὴν ϑεοποιίαν
τσαρέλαθον wav ζῶον .--- De Abstinen.lib.iv. + See book iii. βθοῦ. 6, ». 33. 1866 vol. 1.
§ Πρότερον δή σοι βούλομαι τῶν Αἰγυπτίων τὸν τρόπον τῆς ϑεολογίας διερμηνεῦσαι: οὗτοι
γὰρ τὴν φύσιν τοῦ wavtds, καὶ τὴν δημιουργίαν τῶν ϑεῶν μιμούμενοι, καὶ αὐτοὶ τῶν
μυστικῶν καὶ ἀποκεκρυμμένων καὶ ἀφανῶν νοήσεων εἰκόνας τινὰς διὰ συμβόλων ἐκφαίνου-
σιν, ὥσπερ καὶ ἢ φύσις τοῖς ἐμφανέσιν εἴδεσι τοὺς ἀφανεῖς λόγους διὰ συμβόλων, τρόπον
τινὰ, ἀπετυπώσατο" ἣ δὲ τῶν ϑεῶν δημιουργία, τὴν ἀλήθειαν τῶν εἰδῶν διὰ τῶν φανερῶν
εἰκόνων ὑπεγράψατο" εἰδότες οὖν χαίροντα wdyTa τὰ κρείττονα ὁμοιώσει τῶν ὕποδε-
εστέρων, καὶ βουλόμενοι αὐτὰ ἀγαθῶν οὕτω ττληροῦν διὰ τῆς κατὰ τὸ δυνατὸν μιμήσεως,
εἰκότως καὶ αὐτοὶ τὸν τορόσφορον αὐτοῖς τρόπον τῆς κεκρυμμένης ἐν τοῖς συμβόλοις μυστα-
γωγίας τοροφέρουσιν.---1)6 Mysteriis ΠΕ ψυρί. sect. vii.cap.i, ἢ See bookiii. sect. 6, p. 31.
234 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
which was, that the system of physical-theology, which was, indeed,
one of the last sciences of the Egyptian school, was supposed to be
the first ; and hero-worship, which was indeed the first religion of the
Egyptian church, was supposed to be the last. This is no more than
saying, that (for reasons given before) the Magistrate would very
early institute the worship of their dead benefactors, and that the
Philosopher could have no occasion, till many ages afterwards (when
men grew inquisitive or licentious), to hide the’ ignominy of it, by
making those hero Gods only shadowy Beings, and no more than
emblems of the several parts of nature.*
Now though the doctrine of this early physical Theology, as
explained by the Greeks, makes very much for the high antiquity of
Egyptian learning, the poit I am concerned to prove; yet as my
only end is truth, in all these enquiries, I can, with the same pleasure,
confute an error which supports my system, that I have in detecting
those which made against it.
The common notion of these Philologists, we see, brings Hero-
worship, by consequence, very low; and as some of their followers
have pursued that consequence, I shall beg leave to examine their
reasonings. ‘The learned author of the Connections pushes the matter
very far :—‘ It does not appear from this table [the Bemdine] that
the Egyptians worshipped any idols of human shape; at the time
when this table was composed; but rather, onthe contrary, all the
images herein represented, before which any persons are described in
postures of adoration, being the figures of birds, beasts, or fishes ;
this table seems to have been delineated BEFoRE the Egyptians wor-
shipped the images of men and women; WHICH WAS THE LAST AND
LOWEST STEP OF THEIR IDOLATRY.” + Now the whole of this
observation will, I am afraid, only amount to an illogical consequence
drawn from a false fact ; let the reader judge. All the images (he
says) herein represented, before which any persons are described, in
postures of adoration, are the figures of birds, beasts, and fishes. 1
was some time in doubt whether the learned writer and I had seen
the same table: for in that given us by Kircher, the whole body of
the picture is filled up with the greater Egyptian Gods in HUMAN
SHAPE ; before several of which, are other human figures in postures
of adoration ; unless the learned writer will confine that posture to
kneeling ; which yet he brings no higher than the time of Solomon. t
Some of these worshippers are represented sacrificing ; § others in
the act of offering; and offering to Gods inthroned.|| One of which
oD?
figures I have caused to be engraved, 4 where a mummy from Kir-
$ See note TTT, at the end of this book. + “Sacred and Profane History of
the World connected,” vol. ii. p. 320. 1 Ibid. p. 317. § As at [S. V.]
| As at [T. Φ.] [O. 3.] and [S. X.] 4] See plate ix. fig. 1.
͵ a Ἢ a
> 2 gee Μὰ
(oa —s z : eo ~~ “ph
ον SOL eS tru ὦ
ἥν: \ ἜΜ ΕΟΑΞ, ὩΣ ἢ aA VO
| NRE ES 3 08 Poa seet
5
SSS
(ofelleilel-s olf folic
SS, = SS =
= ΞΖ, ἘΞ
- ΕΞ ZZ, ESS
Be Sis Das ORGS
as aX
>
ay
7,
Ὁ
rh δ ὦ
SAN
ὩΣ
“2
ν
“4
4
KN
UV,
poy
Le Ξ 8
24
᾿
»“, Wiss Ugg
SRL EGE
yD SS we. Se ν᾽
SSS ἜΣ
SSS >
Z 7772
Ὁ
δ
4
o>
y BS
Ld
ELD
IRS
ἦ
Ϊ (ἃς,
RS
RES
=
S
Som the Bembine Table, ᾿
γ iam rik; Y fe 272... Fiz chen ee A
am 7775 lig Z sheetitg “had Aer, 4. ol vt “2 Wt DCC worshipped. Figl. i I
lhe Bectoval Cloth “γ᾽ heim my Lig 2 on which “hid ΤΟ foe. 1 MAW, }
and PAPAL f OM adming fuom Kickers ἌΣ "ὡς pe
Libleshed by Thom as Lzgg & Son, 73, Che LPSULE ΄ὖ τὰ
skcT. ας ‘(OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 235
cher’s Oedipus * will shew us what sort of idol it is which we see
worshipped by offerings.t With regard to the kneeling postures of
adoration, to birds, beasts, and fishes, these are in a narrow border of
the table, which runs round the principal compartments. The learned
writer indeed seems to make a matter of it, “that all the images that
kneel are represented as paying their worship to some animal figure ;
there not being one instance or representation of this worship paid to
an image of human form, either on the border or in the table.” Τ
But surely there is no mystery in this. The table was apparently
made for the devotees of Isis in Rome.§ Now, amongst the Romans,
brute-worship was so uncommon, that the artist thought proper to
mark it out by the most distinguished posture of adoration; while
the worship of the greater Hero-Gods, a worship like their own, was
sufficiently designed by the sole acts of offering and sacrifice.
But supposing the fact to have been as the writer of these Connec-
tions represents it; how, I ask, would his consequence follow, That
the table was made BEFORE the Egyptians worshipped the images of
men and women? It depends altogether on this supposition, that
Brute-worship was not symbolical of Hero-worship ; but the contrary
hath been shewn. The learned author himself must own that Apis,
at least, was the symbol of the Hero-God Osiris. But can any one
believe, he was not worshipped in his own figure before he was deli-
neated under that of an ox? To say the truth, had this author’s fact
been right, it had been a much juster consequence, That the table was
made ArTER the Egyptians had generally left off worshipping the
images of men and women ; for it is certain, the symbolic worship of
brutes brought human images into disuse. Who can doubt but
human images of Hero-Gods were used in Egypt long before the time
of Strabo ? yet he tells us,|| that in their temples (of which he gives
a general description) they either have no images, or none of human
form, but of some beast. He could not mean in those temples dedi-
cated to animals; for where had been the wonder of that? nor will
this disuse of human images appear strange to those who reflect on
what hath been said of these Symbols, which being supposed given by
the Gods themselves, their use in religious worship would be thought
most pleasing to the givers.
This conclusion is further strengthened by these considerations :
1. That the age of the ¢aéle is so far from being of the antiquity
conceived by the learned writer, that it is the very latest of all the
* Fig. 2. plate ix. + Fig. 1. 1 “Sacred and Profane History of the
World connected,” vol, ii. p. 318. § See note UUU, at the end of this book.
|| Τῆς δὲ κατασκευῆς τῶν ἱερῶν 7 διάθεσις τοιαύτη. Κατὰ τὴν εἰσβολὴν τὴν εἰς τὸ
τέμενος, δο---μετὰ δὲ τὰ τοροπύλαια, ὃ νεὼς wpdvaoy ἔχων μέγαν, καὶ ἀξιόλογον" τὸν δὲ
σηκὸν σύμμετρον, ξόανον δὲ οὐδὲν, ἢ οὐκ ἀνθρωπόμορφον, ἀλλὰ τῶν ἀλόγων ζώων τινός.
— Geogr. lib. xvii. pp. 1158, 1159, Amst. ed.
236 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
old Egyptian monuments ; as appears from the mixture of all kinds
of hieroglyphic characters init. 2. That on almost all the obelisks *
in Kircher’s Theatrum Hieroglyphicum, which are undoubtedly very
ancient, we see adoration given to ideals in human form; and like-
wise in that very way the learned author so much insists upon,
namely Genuflexion.
Thus, though from the Bembine-table nothing can be concluded
for the high date of heroic image-worship, yet nothing can be con-
cluded for the low. However the learned writer will still suppose
(what every one is so apt to do) that he is in the right; and there-
fore tries to maintain his ground by fact and reason.
His argument from fact stands thus :—‘‘ The Egyptians relate a
very remarkable fable of the birth of these five Gods. They say
that Rhea lay privately with Saturn, and was with child by him ;
that the Sun, upon finding out her baseness, laid a curse upon her,
that she should not be delivered in any month or year: That Mer-
cury being in love with the goddess lay with her also; and then
played at dice with the Moon, and won from her the seventy-second
part of each day, and made up of these winnings five days, which
he added to the year, making the year to consist of three hundred
sixty-five days, which before consisted of three hundred sixty days
only ; and that in these days Rhea brought forth five children, Osiris,
Orus, Typho, Isis, and Nephthe. We need not inquire into the
mythology of this fable; what I remark from it is this, that the
fable could not be invented before the Egyptians had found out that
the year consisted of three hundred and sixty-five days, and conse-
quently that by their own accounts the five deities said to be born on
the five ἐπαγόμεναι, or additional days, were not deified before they
knew that the year had these five days added to it; and this addi-
tion to the year was made about—4.M. 2665, a little after the death
of Joshua.” + .
I agree with this learned author, that the fable could not be invented
before the Egyptians had found out that the year consisted of three
hundred and sixty-five days ; 1 agree with him, that the addition of
the five days might be made about A.M. 2665; but I deny the conse-
quence, that the five Gods were not deified before this addition to the
year ; nay, I deny that it will follow from the fable, that the makers
and venders of it so thought. What hath misled the learned writer
seems to be his supposing that the fable was made to commemorate
the deification of the five Gods, whereas it was made to commemorate
the insertion of the five days; as appears from its being told in that
figurative and allegoric manner in which the Egyptians usually con-
* Namely, the Lateran of Ramesses, the Flaminian of Psammitichus, the Sallustian,
and the Constantinopolitan. t ““ Connection,”’ vol. ii. pp. 283, 284.
SECT. IV. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 237
veyed the history of their science: and it was ever the way of Anti-
quity, to make the Gods a party, in order to give the greater
reverence to the inventions of men. A design to commemorate the
time of deification was so absurd a thing in the politics of a Pagan
priest, that we can never believe he had any thing of that kind in
view: it was his business to throw the Godhead back before all time ;
or at least to place it from time immemorial. But admitting the
maker of this fable intended to celebrate in general the history of
these five gods, can we think that he, who was hunting after the
marvelous, would confine his invention within the inclosure of dates ?
a matter too of so dangerous a nature to be insisted on. We know
(and we now, partly, see the reason of it) that the ancient mytholo-
gists affected to confound all chronology ; a mischief which hath so
shaken the crazy edifice of ancient times, that the best chronologists
have rather buried themselves in its ruins, than been able to lead
others through it; besides, it is evident that new lies were every year
told of their old Gods. Let him who doubts of this consider what
additions following poets and theologers have made to the fables
which Homer and Hesiod had recorded of the Gods ; additions, seen,
by their very circumstances, not to have been invented when those
ancient bards sung of their intrigues. In these later fables we fre-
quently find the Gods of Greece and Egypt concerned in adventures,
whose dates, if measured by determined synchronisms, would bring
down their births to ages even lower than their long established wor-
ship. The not attending to this has, as will be seen hereafter, egre-
giously misled the incomparable Sir Isaac Newton in his ancient
Chronology. Thus the same author,* Plutarch, tells us, in the same
place, of another Egyptian fable, which makes Typhon beget Hieroso-
lymus and Judeus.¢ But what then? must we believe, that Typhon
was no earlier than the name of Judzus? must we not rather con-
clude, that this was a late story invented of him out of hatred and
contempt of the Hebrews ?
In a word, this practice of adding new mythology to their old
divinity was so notorious, that the learned Connector of sacred and
prophane history could not himself forbear taking notice of it: ‘‘ The
Egyptians” (says he) “ having first called their heroes by the names
of their stderial and elementary deities, ADDED IN TIME TO THE
HISTORY OF THE LIFE AND ACTIONS OF SUCH HEROES, A MY-
THOLOGICAL account of their philosophical opinions concerning the
Gods whose names had been given to such heroes.t
“But,” says this writer, “had Osiris, Orus, Typho, Isis, and
* Tsis et Osir. + Tacitus seems to allude to this paltry fable: Quidam, regnante
Tside, exundantem per AZgyptum multitudinem, ducibus Hierosolyma et Juda, prowimas
in terras exoneratam.— Historia, lib, vy. cap. 2. 1 ““ Connection,” vol. ii. pp. 300,
301,
298 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
Nephthe, been esteemed deities before this additional length of the
year was apprehended, we should not have had this, but some other
fabulous account of their birth transmitted to us.’* Mere the pre-
misses and conclusion are severally propped up by two false suppo-
sitions; the premisses, by this, that the fable was invented to
commemorate the origin of these gods; and the conclusion, by this,
that we have no other fabulous account of their birth.
From fact, the learned writer comes to reason; and speaking of
the Egyptian Hero-Gods, who, he supposes, were ante-diluvian mor-
tals, he says :— But I do not imagine they were deified until about
this time of correcting the year; for when this humour first began,
it is not likely that they made Gods of men but just dead, of whose
infirmities and imperfections many persons might be living witnesses :
but they took the names of their first ancestors, whom they had been
taught to honour for ages, and whose fame had been growing by the
increase of tradition, and all whose imperfections had been long
buried, that it might be thought they never had any.—It is hard to
be conceived that a set of men could ever be chosen by their contem-
poraries to have divine honours paid them, whilst numerous persons
were alive, who knew their imperfections, or who themselves or their
immediate ancestors might have as fair a pretence, and come in com-
petition with them. Alexander the Great had but ill success in his
attempt to make the world believe him the son of Jupiter Ammon;
nor could Numa Pompilius, the second king of Rome, make Romu-
lus’s translation to heaven so firmly believed, as not to leave room for
subsequent historians to report him killed by his subjects. Nor can
I conceive that Julius Ceesar’s canonization, though it was contrived
more politicly, would ever have stood long indisputable, if the light
of Christianity had not appeared so soon after this time as it did,
and impaired the credit of the heathen superstitions. The fame of
deceased persons must have ages to grow up to heaven, and divine
honours cannot be given with any shew of DECENCy, but by a late
posterity.” +
He says, ἐέ is not likely they made Gods of men but just dead, of
whose infirmities and imperfections many persons might be living wit-
nesses. How likely shall be considered presently ; but that they did
in fact do so, is too plain, methinks, to be denied. The learned
Eusebius, a competent judge (if ever there was any) of ancient fact,
delivers it as a notorious truth, that in the early ages, those who
excelled in wisdom, strength, or valour, who had eminently contri-
buted to the common safety, or had greatly advanced the arts of life,
were either deified during life, or immediately on their decease :t
* “Connection,” vol. ii. p. 284. + Idem, vol. ii. pp. 286, 287. 1 Τρίτοι δὲ
ἄλλοι, σφᾶς αὐτοὺς ἐπὶ γῆς ῥίψαντες" τοὺς ἐπὶ συνέσει τῶν κατ᾽ αὐτοὺς τσροφέρειν νενο-
SECT. 1V. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 239
. This he had reason to believe, for he had good authority, the vene-
rable history of Sanchoniathon the Phenician ; which gives a very
particular account of the origin of Hero-worship, and expresly says
the deification was immediate: And surely, when men were become
so foolish as to make Gods of their fellow-creatures, the likeliest, as
well as most excusable season was, while the heat of gratitude, for
new-invented blessings, kept glowing in their hearts; or, at least,
while the sense of those blessings was yet fresh and recent in their
memories ; in a word, while they were warmed with that enthusiastic
lore and admiration which our great poet so sublimely describes :
«<’T was virtue only (or in Arts or Arms,
Diffusing blessings, or averting harms)
The same, which in a sire the sons obey’d,
A prince, the father of a people made.
On him their second providence they hung,
Their law his eye, their oracle his tongue.
He from the wond’ring furrow call’d the food ;
Taught to command the fire, controul the flood,
Draw forth the monsters of th’ abyss profound,
And fetch th’ aerial eagle to the ground.’’*
Was there any wonder in this, that*he who taught mankind to sub-
ject all the elements to their use, should, by wrude admiring multi-
tude, be adjudged a Being of a superior order ?
But they took the names of their first ancestors, whose fame had
been growing up by the increase of tradition. Without doubt, the
ancestors, men deified, and which, as being extreme early, may be
called the first, had a very large and spreading reputation. But how
was this procured but by an early apotheosis? which, by making
them the continual subject of hymns and panegyrics, preserved them
from the oblivion of those unletter’d ages: And in fact, the fame of
all, but those so deified, was very soon extinct and forgotten.
—And all whose imperfections had been long buried, that it might
be thought they never had any. By this, one would be apt to think
that the Hero-Gods of Greece and Egypt, whose deification the
learned writer would bring thus low, had nothing unseemly told of
them in their Legends: Which, were it true, the argument would
have some weight. But what school-boy has not read of the
rogueries which the Pagan worshippers have every where recorded
of their Gods? Are not these a convincing proof of their deifica-
tion by that very age which saw both their virtues and their vices ;
but, with the fondness of times newly obliged, saw nothing but in an
honourable light ;+ and so unhappily canonized both the good and
μισμένους, ἢ καὶ ῥώμη σώματος, καὶ δυναστείας ἰσχύι τῶν “«σλειόνων ἐπικρατήσαντας,
γίγαντάς τινας, ἢ τυράννους, ἢ καὶ γόητας, καὶ φαρμακέας ἄνδρας, ἔις Twos TOV δειοτέρων
ἀποπτώσεως, τὰς κακοτέχνους γοητείας συνεσκευασμένους" ἢ καὶ τοὺς ἄλλους κοινῆς τέ
τινος καὶ βιωφελοῦς εὐεργεσίας ττροάρξαντας, ζῶντάς τε ἔτι καὶ μετὰ τελευτὴν Θεοὺς
ἐπεφήμισαν.--- Prep. Evang. lib. ii. cap. 5.
“ἐς Essay on Man,” ep. iii. + “ Que ista justitia est, nobis suecensere, quod
talia dicimus de diis eorum; et sibi non succensere, qui hee in Theatris libentissimé
240 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
the bad together, and, in that condition, delivered them all down to
posterity? Not that I suppose (for I have just shewn the contrary)
that late poets and mythologists did not add to the tales of their
forefathers. I can hardly believe Jupiter to have been guilty of all
the adulteries told of him in Ovid: But this one may safely say,
that unless he had been a famed Adulterer in early tradition, his later
worshippers had never dared to invent so many odious stories of the
Sire of gods and men.
But, ἐέ is hard to be conceived that they should have divine honours
immediately paid them, because their contemporaries might have as fair
a pretence, and come in competition with them. 1 understood that
none were deified but those whose benefits to their fellow-citizens, or
to mankind at large, were very eminent; and that a// with these
pretensions were deified ; so that I scarce know what to make of this
observation.
—But Alexander and Cesar’s apotheoses were scorned and laughed
at.* Andso they deserved. For if they, or their flatterers for them,
would needs affect deification in a learned and enlightened age and
place, no other could be expected from so absurd an attempt. But
then those, who knew better how to lay a religious project, found no
impediment from their nearness to its execution. Thus Odin,t about
this very Czesar’s time, aspired to immediate worship amongst a rude
and barbarous people (the only scene for playing the farce with suc-
cess), and had as good fortune in it, as either Osiris, Jupiter, or
Belus.
—Nor could Numa Pompilius make Romulus’s translation to heaven
so firmly believed, as not to leave room for subsequent historians to
report him killed by his subjects. Here the writer conscious that
Antiquity opposed his hypothesis of the date deification of their early
heroes, with many glaring examples to the contrary, has thought fit
to produce one t which he fancied he could deal with. Romulus’s
translation was never so firmly believed but that SUBSEQUENT HIs-
TORIANS, §c. As if at all times speculative men did not see the
origin of their best established Hero-Gods: As if we could forget,
what the learned writer himself takes care to tell us in this very
place, that Huhemerus Messenius wrote a book to prove the ancient
spectant crimina deorum suorum? et quod esset incredibile, nisi contestatissime proba-
retur, hc ipsa theatrica crimina deorum suorum IN HONOREM INSTITUTA SUNT eorun-
dem deorum.”—AuGusTINUS De Civitate Dei, lib. iv. cap. 10.
* Plutarch uses this very argument against Euhemerus, to prove that their country
gods never were mortal Men. Περὶ 13. καὶ ΟΣ. p. 641, + Odinus supremus
est et antiquissimus Asarum, qui omnes res gubernat ; atque etiamsi cateri Dii potentes
sint, omnes tamen ipsi inserviunt, ut patri liberi.—Cum Pompeius duxw quidam Roma-
norum Orientem bellis infestaret, Odinus ea Asia huc in septentrionem fuyiebat.—Edda
Snorronis apud ΤΉΟΜ. BarTHOLIN. De Antig. Danic. pp. 648, 652. t See note
XXX, at the end of this book. °
SECT. Iv. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. DA]
gods of the heathen world to have been only their ancient kings and
commanders.*
The fame of deceased persons (says he) must have ages to grow up
fo heaven.—Must! that is, in spite of a barbarous multitude, who
would make Gods of them out of hand: in spite of ancient Story,
which tells us plainly, they had their wicked wills.
—And divine honours cannot be given with any shew of decency but
by a late posterity. It must be confessed, the Ancients observed
much decency when, in the number of their greater Gods, they
admitted ravishers, adulterers, pathics, vagabonds, thieves, and
murderers.
But now the learned writer, in toiling to bring hero-worship thus
low, draws a heavier labour on himself; to invent some probable
cause of the apotheosis : that warmth of gratitude for god-like benefits
received, which ancient history had so satisfactorily assigned for the
cause, being now quite out of date. For when gratitude is suffered
to cool for many ages, there will want some very strong machine to
draw these mortals up to heaven. However, our author has supplied
them with a most splendid vehicle. ‘ Some ages after” (says he)
“*they descended to worship heroes or dead men.—The most cele-
brated deities they had of this sort were Cronus, Rhea, Osiris, Orus,
Typhon, Isis, and Nephthe ; and these persons were said to be deified
upon an opinion that, at their deaths, their souls migrated into some
star, and became the animating spirit of some luminous and hea-
venly body: This the Egyptian priests expressly asserted.—Let us
now see when the Egyptians first consecrated these hero-gods, or
deified mortals. To this I answer, Not before they took notice of the
appearances of the particular stars which they appropriated to them.
Julius Cesar was not canonized until the appearance of the Julium
Sidus, nor could the Phenicians have any notion of the divinity of
Cronus until they made some observations of the star which they
imagined he was removed into.”’+
He says, the Egyptian priests EXPRESLY ASSERTED that these
persons were said to be deified upon an opinion that at their death
their souls migrated into some star. And for this he quotes a passage
out of Plutarch’s tract of Isis and Osiris ; which I shall give the
reader in Plutarch’s own words, that he may judge for himself.
Speaking of the tombs of the Gods, he says: But the priests affirm
not only of these, but of all the other Gods, of that tribe which were
not unbegotten nor immortal, that their dead bodies are deposited
amongst them and preserved with great care, but that their souls illu-
* P. 288. See the first volume of ‘‘the Divine Legation,” pp, 205, 207—209.
+ “Connection,” vol. ii. pp. 281—283.
VOL. II. R
242 THE DIVINE LEGATION | BOOK IVs
minate the stars in heaven.* All here asserted is that the Egyptians
thought the souls of their hero-gods had migrated into some star ;
but not the least intimation that they were deified upon this opinion
of their migration. These are two very different things. The opinion
of their migration might, for any thing said by Plutarch, be an after
superstition ; nay we shall make it very probable that it was so: for
the Connector not resting on this authority, as indeed he had small
reason, casts about for some plausible occasion, how men come to be
deified upon so strange an opinion ; and this he makes to be their
FIRST notice of the appearance of a particular star. But how the
new appearance of a star should make men suppose the soul of a
dead ancestor was got into it, and so become a God, is as hard to
conceive as how Tenterden steeple should be the cause of Goodwin-
Sands. Indeed, it was natural enough to imagine such an ἐπιφάνεια,
when the cultivation of judicial astrology had aided a growing super-
stition to believe that their tutelary God had chosen the convenient resi-
dence of a culminating star, in order to shed his best influence on his
own race or people. This seems to be the truth of the case: and
this, I believe, was all the Egyptian priests, in Plutarch, meant to
say.
But from a sufficient cause, this new appearance is become (before
the conclusion of the paragraph) the only cause of deification : Julius
Cesar was not canonized until the appearance of the Julium Sidus :
nor COULD the Phenicians have any notion of the divinity of Cronus
until they made some observations of the star which they imagined he
was removed into. As to Ceesar’s apotheosis it was a vile imitation of
those viler flatteries of Alexander’s successors in Greece and Egypt ;
and the Julium Sidus an incident of no other consequence than to
save his sycophants from blushing. But abandoned Courtiers and
prostitute Senates never wait for the declaration of Heaven: and
when the slaves of Rome sent a second tribe of Monsters to replenish
the Constellations, we find that Augustus, Tiberius, Claudius, ‘ec.
who rose into Gods as they sunk below humanity, had no more Stars
in their favour than Teague in the Committee. But of all cases, the
Phenicians’ seems the hardest: who with their infinite superstitions
could yet have no notion of Cronus’s divinity, ’till they had read his
fortune in his Star. Iam so utterly at a loss to know what this can
mean, that I will only say, if the reader cannot see how they might
come by this notion another way, then, either he has read, or I have
written, a great deal to very little purpose.
VI. We come now to the last cause assigned by the Ancients for
* Οὐ μόνον δὲ τούτων οἱ ἱερεῖς λέγουσιν, ἀλλὰ καὶ τῶν ἄλλων Seay, ὅσοι μὴ ἀγέν-
nro. μηδὲ ἄφθαρτοι, τὰ μὲν σώματα wap’ αὐτοῖς κεῖσθαι καμόντα καὶ ϑεραπεύεσθαι,
τὰς δὲ ψυχὰς ἐν οὐρανῷ λάμπειν Uorpa.—Page 640, edit. Steph. 8vo.
SECT. IV. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 943,
brute-worship, as we find it in Eusenrus;* namely, That it was
the invention of a certain king, for his private ends of policy, to
establish in each city the exclusive worship of a different animal, in
order to prevent confederacies and combinations against his Govern- ᾿
ment. That an Egyptian king did in fact contrive such a political
institution one may safely allow, because, on this very supposition, it
will appear that brute-worship had another and prior original. For
it is not the way of Politicians to invent new Religions, but to turn
those to advantage which they find already in use. The cunning,
therefore, of this Egyptian monarch consisted in founding a new
institution of intolerance, upon an old established practice in each
city of different animal-worship. But supposing this king of so pecu-
liar a strain of policy that he would needs invent a new Religion ; How
happened it that he did not employ /ere-worship to this purpose (so
natural a superstition that it became universal) rather than the whim-
sical and monstrous practice of drute-worship, not symbolical, when
direct hero-worship would have served his purpose so much better ;
religious zeal for the exclusive honour of a dead citizen being likely to
rise much higher than reverence to a compatriot animal? The only
solution of the difficulty is this, Brute-worship being then the favour-
ite superstition of the people, the politic monarch chose that for the
foundation of his contrivance. So that we must needs conclude, this
pretended cause to be as defective as the rest.
These were the reasons the Greek writers gave for brute-worship in
general. But besides these, they invented a thousand fanciful causes
of the worship of this or that animal in particular; which it would
be to no purpose to recount.
On the whole, so little satisfaction did these writers afford to the
learned Fourmont (who yet is for making something or other out of
every rag of Antiquity, which he can pick up and new-line with an
Etymology), that he frankly owns the true original of brute-worship
is the most difficult thing imaginable to find out: Δὲ on nous deman-
doit (says he) de quel droit, tel ou -tel dieu, avoit sous lui tel ou tel
animal, pour certain, rien de plus difficile ἃ deviner.t
However, amidst this confusion, the Greeks, we see, were modest.
They fairly gave us their opinions, but forged no histories to support
them. The Arabian writers were of another cast: it was their way
to free themselves from these perplexities by telling a story: Thus
Abennephi, being at a loss to account for the Egyptian worship of a
fly, invents this formal tale, That the Egyptians being greatly infested
with these insects, consulted the oracle, and were answered, that they
* See “ Divine Legation,” vol. i. p. 364. + Refl. Crit. sur les Histotres des
anciens Peuples, liv. ii. § 4.
R 2
244 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
must pay them divine honours. See then, says this dextrous writer,
the reason of our finding so many on the obelisks and pyramids.
But of all the liberties taken with remote Antiquity, sure nothing
ever equalled that of a late French writer, whose book, intituled,
Histoire pv Cret, accidentally fell into my hands as this sheet was
going to the press. Kircher, bewildered as he was, had yet some
ground for his rambles. He fairly followed Antiquity: unluckily
indeed, for him, it proved the ignis fatuus of Antiquity ; so he was
ridiculously misled. However he had enough of that fantastic light
to secure his credit as a fair writer. But here is a man who regards
Antiquity no more than if he thought it all imaginary, like his coun-
tryman, Hardouin. At least, he tells us in express words, that the
study of the tedious and senseless writings of Herodotus, Plato,
Diodorus, Plutarch, Porphyry, and such like, is all labour lost. The
truth is, these volatile writers can neither rest in fact nor fable; but
are in letters what Tacitus’s Romans were in civil government, who
could neither bear a perfect freedom, nor a thorough slavery.* Only
with this additional perversity, that when the inquiry is after Truth
they betray a strange propensity to Fable; and when Fable is their
professed subject, they have as untimely an appetite for Truth; thus,
in that philosophical Romance called La vie de Sethos, we find a much
juster account of old Egyptian wisdom than in all the pretended Histoire
du Ciel. This Historian’s System is, that all the civil and religious
customs of Antiquity sprung up from AGRICULTURE ; nay that the
very Gods and Goddesses themselves were but a part of this all-
bounteous harvest :+
Nec ulla interea est inarate gratia terre.
Now the two most certain facts in Antiquity are these, “That the
idolatrous worship of the HEAVENLY BODIES arose from the visible
influence they have on sublunary things ;”’ and ‘‘ That the country-
gods of all the civilized nations were DEAD MEN deified, whose bene-
fits to their fellow-citizens, or to mankind at large, had procured
them divine honours.’’ Could the reader think either of these were
likely to be denied by one who ever: looked into an ancient book ;
much less by one who pretended to interpret Antiquity? But neither
Gods nor Men can stand before a system. ‘This great adveuturer
assures us that the whole is a delusion; that Antiquity knew nothing
of the matter; that the heavenly bodies were not worshipped for
their influences ; that Osiris, Isis, Jupiter, Pluto, Neptune, Mercury,
nay their very hero-gods, such as Hercules and Minos, were not
* This shews why Locke is no favourite of our historian: “ J’ai 1d le TRES-ENNUIEUX
traité de Locke sur Ventendement humain,” &c.—Vol. i. pp. 387, 388. + See
pp: 99, 315, et passim, vol. i. ed. Par. 1739, 8vo.
SECT. 1V. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 245
mortal men nor women; nor indeed any thing but the letters of an
ancient alphabet; the mere figures which composed the symbolic
directions to the Egyptian husbandmen.* And yet, after all this, he
has the modesty to talk of Systemes Bizarres ; f and to place the
Newtonian system in that number. It would be impertinent to ask
this writer, where was his regard to Antiquity or to Truth, when we
see he has so little for the public, as to be wanting even in that mere
respect due to every reader of common apprehension? and yet this
System, begot by a delirious imagination on the dream of a lethargic
pedant, is to be called enterpreting Antiquity.t However, as it is a
work of entertainment, where AGRICULTURE has the top part in the
piece, and Antiquity is brought in only to decorate the scene, it
should, methinks, be made as perfect as possible. Would it not
therefore be a considerable improvement to it, if, instead of saying
the Egyptian husbandmen found their gods in the symbolic directions
for their labour, the ingenious author would suppose that they turned
them up alive as they ploughed their furrows, just as the Etruscans
found their god Tages:§ This would give his piece the marvelous,
so necessary in works of this nature, corrected too by the probable,
that is, some kind of support from Antiquity, which it now totally
wants. Besides, the moist glebe of Egypt, we know, when impreg-
nated with a warm Sun, was of old famed for hatching men || and
monsters.
To return. From what hath been last said, we conclude, That the
true original of brute-worship was the use of symbolic writing: and,
consequently, that Symbols were extreme ancient; for brute-worship
was national in the days of Mosres. But Symbols were invented for
the repository of Egyptian wisdom; therefore the Egyptians were
very learned even from those early times: The point to be proved.
And now, had this long discourse on the Egyptian Hieroglyphics
done nothing but afford me this auxiliary proof, which my argument
does not want, I should certainly have made it shorter. But it is of
much use besides, for attaining a true idea of the EASTERN ELOCU-
TION (whose genius is greatly influenced by this kind of writing), and
is therefore, I presume, no improper introduction to the present
volume, whose subject is the religion and civil policy of the Hebrews.
* See note YYY, at the end of this book. t See p. 122, of his Revision de
ὦ Histoire du Ciel. 1 “S’ily a méme quelque chose de solide et de suivi dans
Vhistoire, que je vais donner de l’origine du ciel poetique, j’avoue que j’en suis redevable
a Vexplication ingénieuse, mais simple, par laquelle l’auteur des saturnelles [Macros.
Saturn. lib. i. cap. 17.] nous a éclairci Yorigine du nom de ces deux signes.”—Hist. du
Ciel, vol. i. cap. 1. § “ Tages quidam dicitur in agro Tarquiniensi, cum terra
araretur et sulcus altius esset impressus, extitisse repente, et eum adfatus esse, qui
arabat. Is autem Tages, ut in libris est Etruscorum, puerili specie dicitur visus, sed
senili fuisse prudentia,” &c.—CicERO De Div. lib. ii. cap. 23.
|| Δῆμον ’Epex Ojos μεγαλήτορος. ὅν wor ᾿Αθήνη
Θρέψε, Διὸς ϑυγάτηρ, ΤῈ ΚΕ δὲ Cetdwpos APOYPA.— Ilias, ii. ver. 547.
246 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
The excellent Mr. Mede pointed to this use: and the learned Mr.
Daubuz endeavoured to prosecute his hint, at large; but falling into |
the visions of Kircher, he frustrated much of that service, which the
application of hieroglyphic learning to scripture language would
otherwise have afforded.
A farther advantage may be derived from this long discourse: it
may open our way to the true Egyptian Wisdom ; which by reason of
the general mistakes concerning the origin, use, and distinct species
of Hieroglyphic writing, hath been hitherto stopped up. The subject
now lies ready for any diligent enquirer ; and to such an one, whose
greater advantages of situation, learning, and abilities, may make him
more deserving of the public regard, I leave it to be pursued.
But whatever help this may afford us towards a better acquaintance
with the ancient Hyyptian Wisdom, yet, what is a greater advantage,
it will very much assist us in the study of the Grecian; and, after so
many instances given of this use, one might almost venture to recom-
mend these two grand vehicles of Egyptian learning and religion, the
MYSTERIES treated of in the former volume, and the HIEROGLYPHICS
in the present, as the cardinal points on which the interpretation of
GREEK ANTIQUITY should from henceforth turn.
SECTION V.
THE course of my argument now brings me to examine a new
hypothesis against the high antiquity of Egypt, which hath the
incomparable Sir Isaac Newron for its Patron; a man, for whose
fame Science and Virtue seemed to be at strife. The prodigious dis-
coveries he had made in the natural world, and especially that supe-
riority of genius which opened the way to those discoveries, hath
induced some of his countrymen to think him as intimate with the
moral ; and even to believe with a late ingenious commentator on his
Optics, that as every thing which Midas touched turned to gold, so
all that Newton handled turned to demonstration.
But the sublimest understanding has its bounds, and, what is more
to be lamented, the strongest mind has its foible. And this miracle
of science, who disclosed all nature to our view, when he came to
correct old Time, in the chronology of Egypt, suffered himself to be
seduced, by little lying Greek mythologists and story-tellers, from the
Goshen of Mosss, into the thickest of the Egyptian darkness. So
pestilent a mischief in the road to Truth is a favourite hypothesis :
an evil, we have frequent occasion to lament, as it retards the pro-
gress of our enquiry at almost every step. For it is to be observed,
that Sir Isaae’s Hyyptian chronology was fashioned only to support
his Grecian ; which he crected on one of those sublime conceptions
peculiar to his amazing genius.
SECT. V. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. DAT
But it is not for the sake of any private System that I take upon
me to consider the arguments of this illustrious man. ‘The truth is,
his discourse of the empire of Egypt contradicts every thing which
Moses and the Proruers have delivered concerning these ancient
people. Though some therefore of his admirers may seem to think
that no more harm can derive to religion by his contradicting the
History, than by his overturning the Astronomy, of the Bible, yet 1
am of a different opinion ; because, though the end of the sacred
history was certainly not to instruct us in Astronomy, yet it was,
without question, written to inform us of the various fortunes of the
People of God; with whom, the history of Egypt was closely con-
nected. I suspect therefore, that the espousing this hypothesis may
be attended with very bad consequences in our disputes with Infide-
lity. The present turn, indeed, of Free-thinking is to extol the high
antiquity of Egypt, as an advantage to their cause; and consequently
to urge Scripture, which bears full evidence to that antiquity, as a
faithful relater of ancient facts; yet these advantages being chimeri-
cal, as soon as they are understood to be so, we shall see the contrary
notion, of the low antiquity of Egypt, become the fashionable doc-
trine ; and, what all good men will be sorry to find, the great name
of NewrTon set against the Brsie.
It is therefore, as I say, for the sake of Scripture, and from no
foolish fondness for any private opinion, that I take upon me to
examine the system of this incomparable person.
His whole argument for the low antiquity of Egypt may be sum-
med up in this syllogism :
Osiris advanced Egypt from a state of barbarity to civil policy.
Ostris and SesosTris were the same.
Therefore Eaypt was advanced from a state of barbarity to civil
policy in the time of Szsosrris.
And to fix the time of Sesostris with precision, he endeavours to
prove him to be the same with Szsac. But this latter identity not
at all affecting the present question, I shall have no occasion to con-
sider it. ‘
Now the minor in this syllogism being the questionable term, he
has employed his whole discourse in its support. All then I have to
do, is to shew that Ostris and Srsosrris were not one, but two
persons, living in very distant ages.
And that none of the favourers of this system may have any pre-
tence to say, that the great Author’s reasonings are not fairly drawn
out and enforced, I shall transcribe them just as I find them collected,
methodized, and presented under one view by his learned and inge-
nious Apologist :—‘‘ He [Sir Isaac Newton] has found it more easy
to lower the pretensions of the Ancients than to conquer the pre-
248 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
judices of the Moderns. Many of his opinions, that are in truth
well founded, pass for dreams, and in particular his arguments for
settling the time of Sesostris, which the Greeks never knew, have
been answered with scurrility—I shall lay together here the evi-
dences that have convinced me of the truth of his conclusion, because
he has not any where collected all of them.
«1. That Osiris and Bacchus were the same, was generally agreed
by the Greeks and Egyptians, and is therefore out of question ; and
that the great actions related of Sesostris are true of Sesac, and the
difference between them is only nominal, is affirmed by Josephus.
“Ὡς, Osiris and Sesostris were both Egyptian kings who conquered
Ethiopia ; and yet there never was but one Egyptian king that was
master of Ethiopia.
«3. Both were Egyptian kings, that with a prodigious army and
fleet invaded and subdued all Asia northward as far as Tanais, and
eastward as far as the Indian ocean.
“4 Both set up pillars in all their conquests, signifying what sort
of resistance the inhabitants had made. Palestine, in particular,
appears to have made little or none, to them.
“δι, Both passed over the Hellespont into Europe, met with strong
opposition in Thrace, and were there in great hazard of losing their
army. ᾿
“6, Both had with them in their expeditions a great number of
foster brothers, who had been all born on the same day, and bred up
with them.
“7. Both built or exceedingly embellished Thebes in Upper Egypt.
“8. Both changed the face of all Egypt, and from an open country
made it impracticable for cavalry, by cutting navigable canals from the
Nile to all the cities.
“9. Both were in the utmost danger by the conspiracy of a bro-
ther.
“10. Both made triumphant entries in chariots, of which Osiris’s
is poetically represented to be drawn by tigers ; Sesostris’s historically
said to be drawn by captive kings.
“11. Both reigned about twenty-eight or thirty years.
“12, Both had but one successor of their own blood.
“18. Bacchus or Osiris was two generations before the Trojan war :
Sesostris was two reigns before it. Again, Sesac’s invasion of Judeea
in an. P. J. 3743, was about two hundred sixty years before the in-
vasion of Egypt in his successor Sethon’s time by Sennacherib ; and
from Sesostris to Sethon inclusively there are ten reigns, according to
Herodotus, which, if twenty-six years be allowed to a reign, make
likewise two hundred and sixty years.
‘In so distant ages and countries it is not possible that any king,
SECT, V. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 249
with many names, can be more clearly demonstrated to be one and
the same person, than all these circumstances and actions together do
prove that Osiris and Bacchus, Sesostris and Sesac, are but so many
appellations of the same man: which being established, it will evi-
dently follow, that the Argonautic expedition, the destruction of Troy,
the revolution in Peloponnesus made by the Heraclidze, &e. were in
or very near the times in which Sir Isaac has ranged them.” *
I. Before I proceed to an examination of these reasonings, it will
be proper to premise something concerning the nature of the system,
and the quality of the evidence.
1. We are to observe then, that this system is so far from serving
for a support or illustration of the ancient story of these two heroes,
that it contradicts and subverts all that is clear and certain in Anti-
quity: and adds new confusion to all that was obscure. The annals
of Egypt, as may be seen by Herodotus, Diodorus Siculus, Strabo,
Plutarch, and others, who all copied from those annals, were as ex-
press and unvariable for the real diversity, the distinct personality of
Osiris and Sesosrris, as the history of England is for that of any
two of its own country Monarchs. For they were not vague names,
of uncertain or adjoining times ; one was the most illustrious of their
Demi-cops, and the other of their Krnes; both fixed in their proper
zeras; and those vastly distant from one another. So that, I make
no question, it had appeared as great a paradox, to an old Egyptian,
to hear it affirmed that Osiris and Sesostris were but one, as it would
be now to an Englishman to be told that Bonduca and the Empress
Matilda were the same. All Antiquity acquiesced in their diversity ;
nor did the most paradoxical writer, with which latter Greece was
well stored, ever venture to contradict so well established a truth.
And what wonder? The history of Egypt was not, like that of
ancient Greece or Suevia, only to be picked up out of the traditional
tales of Bards and Mythologists: nor yet, like that of early Britain,
the invention of sedentary monks: It consisted of the written and
authentic records of a learned and active Priesthood. In which, the
only transgression, yet discovered, against truth, is that natural
partiality common to all national historiographers, of extending back
their annals to an unreasonable length of time. Let me add, that the
distinct personality of these two men is so far from contradicting any
other ancient history, that it entirely coincides with them. Nay,
what is the surest mark of historic truth, there is, as perhaps we may
take occasion to shew, very strong collateral evidence to evince the
real diversity of these two ancient chiefs.—So far, as to the nature
of the system,
* Mr. Mann’s dedication to his tract of the true Years of the Birth and Death of
CHRIST.
250 THE DIVINE LEGATION ROOK IV.
2. The quality of the evidence is another legitimate prejudice
against this new chronology. It is chiefly the fabulous history of
Greece, as delivered by their Poets and Mythologists. This hath
afforded a plausible support to Sir Isaac’s hypothesis ; by supplying
him, in its genealogies of the Gods and Heroes, with a number of
synchronisms to ascertain the identity in question. And yet, who
has not heard of the desperate confusion in which the chronology of
ancient Greece lies involved? Of all the prodigies of falshood in its
mythologic story, nothing being so monstrous as its dismembered and
ill-joined parts of Time. Notwithstanding this confusion, his proofs
from their story, consisting only of scraps, picked up promiscuously
from Mythologists, Poets, Scholiasts, ὅσο. are argued from with so
little hesitation, that a stranger would be apt to think the Fabulous
ages were as well distinguished as those_marked by the Olympiads.
But the slender force of this evidence is still more weakened by this
other circumstance, that almost all the passages brought from mytho-
logy to evince the identity, are contradicted (though the excellent
person has not thought fit to take notice of it) by a vast number of
other passages in the same mythology ; nay even in the same authors ;
and entirely overthrown by writers of greater credit; the HISTORIANS
of Greece and Egypt: which, however, are the other part of Sir Isaac’s
evidence ; of weight indeed to be attentively heard. But this he will
not do: but, from their having given to Osiris and Sesostris the like
actions, concludes the Actors to be one and the same, against all that
those Historians themselves can say to the contrary: Yet what they
might and what they could not mistake in, was methinks easy enough
to be distinguished. For as Fable unnaturally joins together later
and former times ; and ancient fable had increased that confusion, for
reasons to be hereafter given: so History must needs abound with
similar characters of men in public stations ; and ancient history had
greatly improved that likeness, through mistakes hereafter likewise to
be accounted for. Indeed, were there no more remaining of Antiquity
concerning Bacchus, Osiris, and Sesostris, than what we find in Sir
Isaac’s book, we might perhaps be induced to believe them the Same ;
but as things stand in History, this can never be supposed.
What I would infer therefore, from these observations, is this :—
We have, in the distinct personality of Osiris and Sesostris, an histo-.
rical circumstance, delivered in the most authentic and unvariable
manner, and by annalists of the best authority. All succeeding ages
agreed in their diversity ; and it is supported by very strong collateral
evidence. At length a modern writer, of great name, thinks fit to
bring the whole in question. And how does he proceed? Not by
accounting for the rise and progress of what he must needs esteem
the most inveterate error that ever was; but by laying together a
SECT. V. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 25]
number of circumstances, from ancient story, to prove the actions of
Osiris and Sesostris to be greatly alike; and a number of circum-
stances from ancient fable, to prove that the Gods, whom he supposes
to be the same with Osiris, were about the age of Sesostris. So that
all the evidence brought by this illustrious writer amounting, at most,
but to difficulties against the best established fact of history ; if we
can, consistently with the distinct personality and different ages of
these two heroes, fairly account for the similar actions recorded of
them ; and for the low age, as delivered by the mythologists, of those
Grecian Gods which are supposed to be the Egyptian Osiris ; if, I say,
this can be done, the reader is desired to observe, that all is done that
can reasonably be required for the confutation of Sir Isaac Newton’s
hypothesis, and for reinstating the ancient history of their distinct
personality in its former credit.
But I shall do more; 1. I shall shew from the religious consti-
tutions of Greece and Egypt, that the incidental errors which the
Ancients fell into, concerning these two heroes, (of which errors our
author has taken the advantage, to run them into one) were such as
hardly any circumspection could avoid.
2. And still further, that the identity of Osiris and Sesostris, in its
necessary consequences, contradicts ScRipTuR#, and the NATURE OF
THINGS.
II. I proceed then to a particular examination of this famous proof
of the identity, as it is collected and digested by the learned Master
of the Charter-house.
The first observation I shall make upon it is, that, by the same
way of arguing, one might incorporate almost any two HEROES, one
meets with, in early and remote history. For as our great English
poet well observes,
‘¢ HEROES ARE MUCH THE SAME, the point’s agreed,
From Macedonia’s madman to the Swede 5
The whole strange purpose of their lives, to find,
Or make an enemy of all mankind.”
To shew the reader how easily this feat may be performed, I will
take any two of our own Monarchs, that come first into my thoughts,
—Kine Artsur, for instance, and WiLL1AM THE CONQUEROR.
And now let him only imagine, when arts and empire have learnt to
travel further West, and have left Great Britain in the present con-
dition of Egypt, some future Chronologer of America, labouring to
prove these Heroes one and the same, only under two different names,
by such kind of Arguments as this :
1, ArrHuR and Witu1AM were both great warriors.
2. Both were of spurious or uncertain birth.
3. Both were in the management of public affairs in their early
youth,
ΘΠ THE DIVINE LEGATION ROOK rv.
4. Both came from France to recover Britain from the Saxons.
5. Both proved victorious in their expedition.
6. Both got the crown of Britain by election, and not by descent.
7. Both had other dominions, besides Britain, to which they suc-
ceeded by right hereditary.
8. Both went frequently on military expeditions into France.
9. Both warred there with various success.
10. Both had half-brothers, by the mother, who, being made very
powerful, and proving guilty of manifold extortions and acts of injus-
tice, were punished by them, in an exemplary manner.
11. Both had rebellious sons or nephews, whom they met in the
field, fought with in person, and subdued.
12. Both reigned upwards of fifty years.
13. And both died in War.
When our Chronologer had been thus successful with his argument
from similar circumstances, (as in the case of Osiris and Sesostris), it
is odds but he would go on; and to settle a chronology which made
for some other hypothesis he had in view, he would next attempt to
prove, from similitude of names, as before from similitude of actions,
that W1LL1AM THE CONQUEROR and WILLIAM THE THIRD, another
Conqueror, were but one and the same, (as in the case of Sesostris
and Sesac).
Here the number of similar circumstances, in the lives of Arthur
and William, are, evidently, more characteristic of oNE, than those in
the history of Osiris and Sesostris. Yet we know that Arthur and
William were really two different men of two very distant ages.
This will shew the critics the true value of this kind of evidence ;
and should reasonably dispose them to much caution in building
upon it.
i:
But it will be said, that the nature of the conformity between
Osiris and Sesostris is, in some respects, very different from that
between Arthur and William. I grant it is so; and, from those
respects, shall now shew, how the mistaken identity of Osiris and
Sesostris may be certainly detected. For I go on, and say, though
from this instance it be seen, that a greater agreement might well
happen in the lives of two ancient Heroes, than can be found in those
of Osiris and Sesostris, while their distinct personality was acknow-
ledged to be very certain and real; yet, in their case, it must be
owned, that there are peculiar and specific circumstances of simili-
tude, which could not arise from that general conformity between the
actions of two men of the same quality and character ; but must be
allowed to have had their birth from some fancied identity. For
several of the actions, given to both, agree only to the time of one: I
SECT. V. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 253
mean as Antiquity hath fixed their times. Thus, the vast conquests
over Asia agree well with the time of Sesostris, but very ill with the
time of Osiris: and, again, the invention of the most common arts of
life agrees very well with the time of Osiris, but very ill with that of
Sesostris. However, from this conformity in their story, Sir Isaac
concludes Osiris and Sesostris to be the same. And so far we must
needs confess, that it seems to have arisen from some kind of iden-
tity ; a sameness of person, or a sameness of name. This great writer
contends for the first; but as the first contradicts and subverts all
Antiquity, if the ascribed conformity of actions can be well accounted
for from their identity of name, and that identity be proved very pro-
bable from ancient story, the reader will conclude that the fabulous
conformity had its rise from thence ; and, consequently, that all Sir
Isaac’s arguments for their identity of person make directly against
him. For if the conformity arose from identity of name, they were two
persons. I shall endeavour to shew all this in as few words as I am able.
It was an old Egyptian custom, as we learn from Diodorus Siculus,
to call their later Heroes by the name of their earlier Gods. This
historian having spoken of the CELESTIAL Gods, according to the
Egyptians, adds, They held, that besides these, there were other
EARTHLY Gods, born mortal ; who through their wisdom, and common
benefits to mankind, had acquired immortality ; that some of these had
been kings of Egypt ; and that part got New NAmeEs, being called
after those of the celestial Gods; and part kept their own.* But
this custom of calling the later Heroes after the names of their earlier
Gods, was not peculiar to Egypt. Scripture informs us, that the
Assyrians did the same. And the practice must needs have been
general. For, as we have shewn, the original use of it was to support
nascent hero-worship.t But there was another cause, more peculiar
to early Egypt; and that was the doctrine of transmigration. For
it being thought that the same 800] passed successively into many
human bodies ; when they saw an eminent Character strongly resem-
bling some ancient Hero, they were inclined to fancy it the old busy
soul, which had taken up its residence in a new habitation: and
therefore very equitably honoured the present Hero with the name of
the past. This reason, Tacitus tells us, the Egyptians gave for
the great number of HERcuLes’s— Quem [Herculem] indigene
| Aigyptii] ortum apud se et antiquissimum perhibent, eosque qui postea
pari virtute fuerint, in cognomentum gus adscitos.” { This was so
5 Ἄλλους δ᾽ ἐκ τούτων ἐπιγείους γενέσθαι φασὶν, ὑπάρξαντας μὲν ϑνητοὺς, διὰ δὲ
σύνεσιν καὶ κοινὴν ἀνθρώπων εὐεργεσίαν τετυχηκότας τῆς ἀθανασίας. ὧν ἐνίους καὶ
βασιλεῖς γεγονέναι κατὰ τὴν Αἴγυπτον, μεθερμηνευομένων δ᾽ αὐτῶν, τινὰς μὲν ὁμωνύμους
ὑπάρχειν τοῖς οὐρανίοις, τινὰς δ᾽ ἰδίαν ἐσχηκέναι wpoonyoplay—Lib. i. p. 8, Steph. ed.
+ See ‘‘ Divine Legation,” vol. i. book iii. sect. 6. 1 Annales, lib. ii. cap. 60.
‘© Omnes, qui fecerant fortiter, HERCULES vocabantur,”’ says VARRO likewise (as quoted
by Servius).
254 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
notorious that Sir Isaac could not help owning, it was their way to
give one common name to several men. Nay even the least corporeal
resemblance was sometimes sufficient to set this superstition on work,
and produce the effect in question ; as we find from the same Diodo-
rus’s account of the Grecian Bacchus. He tells us, that when
Cadmus the Egyptian was come into Greece, and his daughter Semele
had a spurious son dying in his infancy, whose person resembled the
images of Osiris, the grandfather, after having consulted the Oracle
(whose approbation was contained in the advice, to observe the cus-
toms of his fathers), called him Bacchus, one of the names of Osiris ;
paid divine honours to the embalmed carcase ; and proclaimed abroad,
that Osrris had chosen to come once more amongst men under this
infantine appearance.* From this custom of giving the names of
celebrated personages of high antiquity to later men, who resembled
them in qualities either of mind or body, it was, that they not only,
out of honour to Sesostris, called him Osiris, but, out of contempt
and hatred, gave Moss the name of ΤΎΡΗΟΝ, as appears from some
later accounts of this Typhon, when they had now jumbled Moses
and him into one ; as they had done their Bacchus’s, Hercules’s, and
Minos’s ; and as they were very near doing, by Osiris and Sesostris.
The accounts, I mean, are those which we find in Plutarch, of
Typhon’s flying seven days, and begetting, after his escape, two sons,.
JERUSALEM and Jupaus.t+ And further that this Typhon was the
son of Isaac, and of the race of Hercules.
Causes like these could not fail to make this custom very durable,
amongst a people not at all given to change. And in fact, we find it
continued even to the time of Cleopatra, who affected to be called the
NEw Isis,$ as her brother was called the New Baccuus.|| At
length it became so general as to have no measure but the fancy
of every particular. For Lucian, defending the excessive compli-
ments he had given to one Panthea, whose form he had compared to
the images of the Goddesses, justifies himself by examples; and
amongst the rest, by that of Egypt; 1 shall not insist (says he) upon
the practice of the Egyptians, who, though they be the most religious
of all people, yet employ the names of their Gods even to satiety and
disgust .4
* Κάδμον ex Θηθῶν ὄντα τῶν Αἰγυπτίων, γεννῆσαι σὺν ἄλλοις τέκνοις καὶ Σεμέλην"
ταύτην δὲ ὑπὸ τοῦ δήποτε φθαρείσαν, ἔγκυον γενέσθαι, καὶ τεκεῖν ἑπτὰ μηνῶν διελθόντων
βρέφος τὴν ὄψιν οἷόν wep of κατ᾽ Αἴγυπτον τὸν [Ὄσιριν γεγονέναι νομίζουσι" ζωογονεῖσθαι
δ᾽ οὐκ εἰωθέναι τὸ τοιοῦτον, εἴτε τῶν Sedv μὴ βουλομένων, εἴτε τῆς φύσεως μὴ συγχω-
ρούσης. Κάδμον δὲ αἰσθόμενον τὸ γεγονὸς, καὶ χρησμὸν ἔχοντα διατηρεῖν τὰ τῶν
-πατέρων νόμιμα χρυσώσασθαί τε τὸ βρέφος καὶ τὰς καθηκούσας αὐτῷ «σοιήσασθαι Svolas,
ὥς ἐπιφανείας τινὸς κατ᾽ ἀνθρώπους ᾿Οσίριδος γεγενημένη»5.--- Lib. i. p. 14. + Ἐπὶ
ὄνου τῷ Τυφῶνι τὴν φυγὴν ἑπτὰ ἡμέρας γενέσθαι, καὶ σωθέντα γεννῆσαι waidas Ἱεροσό-
λυμον καὶ *lovdatov.—Isis et Osiris. 1 Ἰσαιακοῦ Tod Ἡρακλέους ὃ Tupav. § PLu-
TARCH. in Anton. || Diovorus Sicuuus, lib. i. 4 ᾿Εῶ yap τοὺς Αἰγυπτίους,
οἵπερ καὶ δεισιδαιμονέστατοί" εἰσι τσάντων, ὅμως τοῖς ϑείοις ὀνόμασιν εἰς κόρον ἐπιχρω-
μένους. --- Pro Imaginibus, in fin.
SECT. V. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 255
To apply this practice to the case of the Heroes in question.
Osiris was the great Lawgiver of the Egyptians ; and the Founder of
their Monarchy. Sesostris vastly extended and ennobled their
Empire ; and was, at the same time, author of many beneficial insti-
tutions. Now if ever an occasion greater than ordinary presented
itself, of putting in practice the custom of honouring later Heroes
with the name of the more early, it was here, where the resemblance
was so remarkably strong. And if what Clemens Alexandrinus says
be true, that Sesostris sprung from Osiris,* there was still a farther
occasion of giving the later Hero the name of his first progenitor.
However, that it was given him, is highly reasonable to suppose. And
this supposition will clearly account for all that ingrafted likeness
from which Sir Isaac hath inferred their identity.
For when now they had given to both, the same name; not distin-
guished, as were their Thoths or Hermes’s,} (another famous instance
of this general custom) by the addition of first and second, Posterity
would frequently confound them with one another ; and, in this con-
fusion, inadvertently give the actions of Osiris to Sesostris, and of
Sesostris to Osiris. But taking nothing from either, both their his-
tories would soon become the same. And as, in this mutual trans-
ferring of one another’s actions, several were given to both, entirely
discordant to either’s age, we are enabled to discover the true cause
of this conformity ; and thereby to prove, that that, which it is plainly
seen might be, really was, the cause.
J. Thus Osiris (because Sesostris was so) is made a great con-
queror, at a time when Egypt.was but just emerging from a state of
barbarism, into civil policy ; and long before several of those nations,
he was said to conquer, had a being. But this seems to be one of
the latest corruptions in their history. Herodotus giving none of
these conquests to Osiris, but to Sesostris only: whence I collect, it
was the product of some age between him and Diodorus Siculus, who
gives them to Osiris with all their circumstances, and supported by
the evidence of pretended ancient monuments.{ It appears too, to
have been a Grecian addition, and at a time when it was the fashion
to make their fables, systematical.§ For we are told,|| (and the tale
* τὸν οὖν Ὄσιριν, τὸν τοροπάτορα τὸν αὑτοῦ, δαιδαλθῆναι ἐκέλευσεν αὐτὸς [Ξέσωσ-
τρι5] wodvTeA@s.-—Admon. adversus Gentes, p. 31, edit. Colon. 1688, fo]. + The
histories of the first and second Hermes are as much confounded with one another
as those of Osiris and Sesostris, and from the same cause; yet, I imagine, the
distinction of first and second will hinder any one from supposing them to be the same.
1 The columns at Nysa in Arabia. § Of δὲ Ἕλληνες, εὐφυΐᾳ τσάντας ὑπερβαλ-
λόμενοι, τὰ μὲν τορῶτα τ-σλεῖστα ἐξιδιώσαντο, καὶ τοῖς τοροκοσμήμασι WolKiAws ἐξετρα-
γῴῷδησαν, ταῖς τῶν μύθων ἡδοναῖς, ϑέλγειν ἐπινοοῦντες τσαντοίως emolkiAAov.— PHILO
Bim. apud Euses. Prep. Evang. lib. i. cap. 10. || Tov δ᾽ οὖν “Ooipw φασὶ τὰ
κατὰ τὴν Αἴγυπτον καταστήσαντα, καὶ τὴν τῶν ὅλων ἡγεμονίαν Ἴσιδι τῇ γυναικὶ
wapaddvTa, ταύτῃ μὲν πσαρακαταστῆσαι σύμβουλον τὸν ἙἭ ρμῆν;--- καὶ στρατηγὸν μὲν
ἀπολιπεῖν ἁπάσης τῆς bp αὑτὸν χώρας Ἡρακλέα-- ἐπιμελητὰς δὲ τάξαι τῶν μὲν wpds
Φοινίκη κεκλιμένων μερῶν καὶ τῶν ἐπὶ ϑαλάττῃ τόπων Βούσιριν.--- εἶναι γὰρ τὸν Οσιριν
256 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK 1V.
was apparently framed for no other end than to connect this God
with the rest of the College) that, when Osiris made this expedition,
he took Silenus with him as his Governor; that he appointed Isis,
Queen-regent in his absence; and Hermes her Privy-counsellor ;
Hercules he made General of his army, and Neptune, admiral of his
fleet. And, that nothing might be wanting to compleat the cortege,
he took with him a company of dancers and singers ; amongst which
were nine lively girls more particularly eminent; with the king’s
brother, as master of the maids, at their head ; and these truly were
to pass for Apollo and the nine Muses. This quaint improvement on
an Egyptian blunder, by some driveling Greek mythologist,* as rank
as it is, is one of the chief circumstances on which our ilustrious
author hath thought fit to support his Chronology. And that which
is the mere representation of an old raree-shew of the Court of king
Osiris, brought by some stroler out of Egypt into Greece, is made an
authentic record to ascertain the true age of all their Heroes. I am
fully supported in the conjecture, that the tale of Osiris’s conquests
was invented in some age between Herodotus and Diodorus Siculus,
by the testimony of two of the soberest and most accurate of the
Greek writers, Strabo and Arrian; who expresly tell us, that the
stories of Bacchus’s and Hercules’s exploits in the Indies were invented
by the Macedonians to aggrandize the glory of Alexander.t The
Egyptians had prepared the materials and made them fit for use, by
confounding Osiris and Sesostris, under the common name of Bacchus.
2. On the other hand, Sesostris (because Osiris was so) is made the
inventor of arts, and the civilizer of a rude and barbarous people, to
whom he delivered the first rudiments of Policy and Religion, many
ages after they had erected a flourishing and powerful Empire. An
inconsistence so glaring, that the ancient critics seeing these things
recorded of Sesostris, reasonably understood Osiris to be meant.
This doubtless made Aristotle say { that Sesostris was many ages
before Minos : yet Eusebius places Minos in the times of the Judges.
And in the twelfth dynasty of Africanus, Sesostris is made to reign,
according to the calculation of Scaliger,§ in the 1392d year of the
Julian period; that very point of time on which the extravagant
φιλογέλωτα, καὶ χαίροντα μουσικῇ καὶ χοροῖς. διὸ καὶ τσεριάγεσθαι τολῆθος μουσουργῶν,
ἐν οἷς τσαρθένους ἐννέα δυναμένας ἄδειν, καὶ κατὰ τὰ ἄλλα wemaidevuévas, τὰς τσαρὰ
τοῖς Ἕλλησιν ὀνομαζομένας Μούσας, τούτων δ᾽ ἡγεῖσθαι τὸν ᾿Απόλλωνα λέγουσιν, ἀφ᾽
οὗ καὶ Μουσηγέτην αὐτὸν ὀνομάσθαι.---Τ ν. i. pp. 10, 11.
* The very learned Casaubon, speaking of the fables, which concern Bacchus with
the Nymphs and Muses, says, Est enim Grecanice vanitatis hoc quoque inventum,
Bacchicas in majus semper attollentium.— De Satyrica Poesi, p. 41. + ARRIAN,
lib. v. cap. 3; STRARBO, lib. ii. p. 771, and lib. xv. pp. 1006, 1007, Casaub. ed. Ka) τὰ
wept Ἡρακλέους δὲ καὶ Διονύσου, Μεγασθένης μὲν μετ᾽ ὀλίγων τοιστὰ ἡγεῖται, τῶν δ᾽
ἄλλων οἱ τσλείους, ὧν ἐστι καὶ ᾿Ερατοσθένης, ἄπιστα καὶ μυθώδη, καθάπερ καὶ τὰ wapd
τοῖς “EAAnotv.—STRABO, lib. xv. 1 Πολὺ yap ὑπερτείνει τοῖς χρόνοις Thy Μίνω
βασίλειαν ἣ Secdorpios.—Polit. lib. vii. cap. 10. § Vide MarsHam Can. Chron.
Secul. x. tit. Nilus Rex.
SECT. ν΄. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 957
chronology of Egypt had thrown Osiris. But there is a passage in
4flian which proves still more expresly that the Ancients sometimes
understood Osiris by Sesostris. The Egyptians (says this historian)
affirm that Mercury taught Sesostris his laws : * and that Mercury the
contemporary of Osiris was here meant, is seen by another passage of
this historian, where the same thing is said of all the Egyptians in
general. The Egyptians boast that Mercury taught them their laws.+
But though mistake gave birth to this corruption in the Egyptian
history, yet, without doubt, it was a- national vanity which supported
it. For we are told by Diodorus,t who made collections from their
history, that the reason, assigned by the Egyptians for that famous
military expedition, which they had transferred from Sesostris to
Osiris, was the Hero’s beneficent purpose of carrying the new inyen-
tions of corn and wine to all the savage inhabitants of the earth ;
whom it was his purpose to reduce from a state of Nature, to Political
society. The intelligent reader sees plainly, that the design of this
story was to do honour to Egypt, “as the common benefactress of
mankind. Though I will not deny, that the extravagance of the
conceit, at the same time, shews how much they were at a loss fora
reasonable cause of so early an expedition. The difficulty of all this
did not escape the Sicilian. He frankly owns, there is a vast discord-
ancy and confusion in the accounts of Isis and Osiris.§ What
seems strange to me is, that this did not lead him to the cause here
explained, when he had so weil unraveled the hke confusion in the
parallel case of Hercules and Alczeus. Their Ἔν had been disordered,
like this of Osiris and Sesostris, from Alezeus’s taking the name of
Hercules. But Diodorus, by the same kind of reasoning || I have here
employed to ascertain the diversity of Osiris and Sesosiris, shews that
* Φασὶν Αἰγύπτιοι ΞΣέσωστριν wap Ἑρμοῦ τὰ νόμιμα ἐκμουσωθῆναι --- ΤΓαρὶα Historie,
lib, xii. cap. 4. t Αἰγύπτιοί pace wap Ἑρμοῦ τὰ νόμιμα ἐκμουσωθῆναι. —Lib. xiv.
cap. 34. 1 Τὸν δὲ “Oop λέγουσιν, ὥσπερ εὐεργετικὸν ὄντα καὶ φιλύδος ον,
στρατόπεδον “μέγα συστήσασθαι, διανοούμενον ἐπελθεῖν ἅπασαν τὴν οἰκουμένην, καὶ
διδάξαι τὸ γένος τῶν ἀνθρώπων τήν τε τῆς ἀμπέλου φυτείαν καὶ τὸν σπόρον τοῦ τε
τουρίνου καὶ κριθίνου kaprod.—Lib. i. p. 10. § Καθόλου δὲ πολλή τις ἐστὶ δια-
φωνία περὶ τούτων τῶν seav.—Lib. i. p. 15. Ι ὋὉμολογουμένου γὰρ ὄντος -ταρὰ
τσᾶσιν ὅτι τοίς ᾿Ολυμπίοις ϑεοῖς Ἡρακλῆς συνηγωνίσατο τὸν wpos τοὺς γίγαντας τοόλε-
pov, φασὶ τῇ yn μηδαμῶς ἁρμόττειν γεγεννηκέναι τοὺς γίγαντας κατὰ τὴν ἡλικίαν, ἣν of
Ἕλληνές φασιν Ἡρακλέα γενέσθαι, γενεᾷ πρότερον τῶν Τρωϊκῶν᾽ ἀλλὰ “μᾶλλον, ὡς
αὐτοὶ λέγουσι, κατὰ τὴν ἐξ ἀρχῆς γένεσιν τῶν ἀνθρώπων, ar ἐκείνης μὲν γὰρ wap’
Αἰγυπτίοις ἔτη καταριθμεῖσθαι πλείω τῶν μυρίων, ἀπὸ δὲ τῶν Τρωϊκῶν ἐλάττω τῶν
χιλίων καὶ διακοσίων. ὁμοίως δὲ τό, τε ῥόπαλον καὶ τὴν λεοντῆν τῷ παλαιῷ πρέπειν
Ἡρακλεῖ, διὰ τὸ κατ᾽ ἐκείνους τοὺς χρόνους μήπω τῶν ὕπλων εὑρημένων, τοὺς ἀνθρώπους
τοῖς μὲν ξύλοις ἀμύνεσθαι τοὺς ἀντιταττομένους, ταῖς δὲ δοραῖς τῶν Snplov σκεπαστηρίοις
χρῆσθαι--- συμφωνεῖν δὲ τοῖς ὑπ᾽ αὐτῶν λεγομένοις καὶ τὴν πσαρὰ τοῖς Ἕλλησιν ἐκ πολλῶν
χρόνων τσαραδεδομένην. φήμην, ὅτι καθαρὰν τὴν γῆν τῶν ϑηρίων ἐποίησεν Ἡρακλῆς. ὅπερ
μηδαμῶς ἁρμόττειν τῷ γεγονότι σχεδὸν κατὰ τοὺς Τρωϊκοὺς χρόνους, ὅτε τὰ πλεῖστα
μέρη THS οἰκουμένης ἐξημέρωτο γεωργίαις καὶ τπὸόλεσι, καὶ τυλήθει τῶν κατοικούντων τὴν
χώραν τσανταχοῦ. μᾶλλον οὖν πρέπειν τῷ γεγονότι κατὰ τοὺς ἀρχαίους Χρόνους τὴν
ἡμέρωσιν τῆς χώρας, κατισχυομένων ἔτι τῶν ἀνθρώπων ὑπὸ τοῦ τσολήθους τῶν ϑηρίων καὶ
μάλιστα κατὰ τὴν Αἴγυπτον εἰς τὴν ὑπερκειμένην χώραν μέχρι τοῦ νῦν ἔρημον οὖσαν καὶ
ϑηριώδη. -- 10. i. pp. 14, 15.
VOL. 11. 5
258 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV
Alczeus and Hercules were different men; namely, from actions, given
to Alczeus, which could not belong to his age. But these being of
different nations, the one a Greek, the other an Egyptian; this
circumstance afforded him an opening which he wanted in the case of
Osiris and Sesostris, who were both Egyptians.
And here let me observe, that this ancient practice of calling later
heroes by the name of earlier, whether of their own or of foreign
countries, brought still greater confusion into some other of their
histories ; making the Ancients themselves imagine an identity where
none was ; as in Bacchus, Neptune, Hercules, Mars, Venus, Minos,
&c. which popular mistakes Sir Isaac employs to support another
imaginary identity that they never dreamt of.
From this state of Antiquity I would infer these two things. First,
that, notwithstanding the conformity in the histories of Osiris and
Sesostris, there is great reason to suppose the reality of their distinct
personalities, because the same kind of similitude, arising from the
same mistake, is found in the histories of many other ancient heroes
confessedly distinct. Secondly, that there must have been, in Anti-
quity, some very convincing proofs of the real diversity of Osiris and
Sesostris, to keep them, as it did, perpetually separate, notwithstanding
the sameness in their histories ; when the like kind of conformity had
melted two or more Bacchus’s, Hercules’s, Minos’s, into one.
On the whole then, I have shewn, that a sameness of name is suffi-
cient to account for the original of the conformity in the history of
Osiris and Sesostris; and, having done this, I have done all that is
needful to ascertain their diversity of person: there being nothing to
oppose to the full testimony of ancient history, which declares for
their diversity, besides this conformity of actions.
But I have done more: I have shewn, that a sameness of name
was, in fact, the only cause of that conformity ; and, consequently,
that their persons were really different. That it could be only a
sameness of name, I think, appears evidently from the giving to each
hero, actions unsuitable to his age; as great conquests to Osiris, and
civil inventions to Sesostris. For I persuade myself, (though Sir
Isaac be obliged, for the sake of his hypothesis, partly to support,
and partly to palliate, this convincing circumstance) no one can, in
good earnest, believe that Egypt was indeed emerging from a state of
barbarism at the time in which he places Sesostris. ’Tis true, if men
will yet suppose so, I have no better argument against it than
the Bisie: and how far the credit of that will go in this enlightened
age is not very easy to guess. In a word, such unsuitable actions
ascribed to each, nothing can account for, but a mistaken identity,
arising from the sameness of name; for when this had advanced, or
brought down, the real antiquity of either, the historian was to suit
SECT. V. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 959
their actions to the imaginary time. Besides, we know they are not
at all scrupulous about property, when they find an atchievement in
their way, capable of doing honour to a favourite Hero. There is, as
might be expected, a pregnant instance of this, in the history of this
very Sesostris; of whom it was recorded, that he divided the lands of
Egypt amongst the People, reserving an annual rent to the Crown.*
Now we are very certain that this was done, long before his time,
under the ministry of the Patriarch Joseph. Here the theft lies
open. While these Heroes were only made to pilfer from one ano-
ther, there was some difficulty to get them convicted ; as where two
cheats are taught to convey their stolen goods into one another’s
hands, to evade a pursuit: but here an honest man steps in to make
good his claim, and proves it beyond all exception.
But it is our business only to shew that the conformity, in the
histories of Osiris and Sesostris, may be well accounted for, from a
sameness of name. Otherwise, if the case required it, we should not
want positive arguments, supported by the soundest part of Antiquity,
to prove their difference of person. To mention one or two only by
the way; it has been observed before,f that, in substituting [ero,
to Planet-worship, the Egyptian rulers, in order to bring the people
more easily into this later species of idolatry, called the Hero by the
name of a Celestial God. So Diodorus says, that Sol first reigned in
Egypt; called so from the Luminary of that name in the heavens.
This was the easier brought about, because the first Civilizers, to gain
the greater authority, pretended, as was very natural, to be the
Offspring of the Sun, that universal God of all the uncivilized people
upon the earth. For the same end likewise, namely to accustom the
people, even while in the practice of Planet-worship, to the new
adoration, they turned the compliment the other way; and called the
Luminary by the name of the Hero; the same historian telling us,
that they called the Sun, Osiris, and the Moon, Isis. Now the end of
this mutual transferring of names being only to strengthen their new
idolatry by giving it a support from the o/d, it must needs be invented
on the first introduction of hero-worship. But hero-worship was as
early as the first institution of civil policy. Therefore the using the
name of Osiris to this purpose, is a demonstration that he was as
early as sober Antiquity supposed. Again, Herodotus tells us, and
of his own knowledge, that no Gods, besides Isis and Osiris, were
worshipped by all the Egyptians in the same unvariable manner.t
* Κατανείμαι δὲ τὴν χώραν Αἰγυπτίοισι ἅπασι τοῦτον ἔλεγον Thy βασιλέα [Zéoworpw’]
κλῆρον ἴσον ἑκάστῳ τετράγωνον διδόντα: καὶ ἀπὸ τούτου τὰς wpooddovs «ποιήσασθαι,
ἐπιτάξαντα ἀποφορὴν ἀποτελέειν κατ᾽ eviavtdv.—HEROD. lib. ii. cap. 109. + See
“« Divine Legation,” vol. ii. pp. 30—32. 1 Θεοὺς γὰρ δὴ ov τοὺς αὐτοὺς ἅπαντες ὁμοίως
Αἰγύπτιοι σέξονται, τσολὴν Ἴσιός τε καὶ ᾿Οσίριδος. τὸν δὴ Διόνυσον εἶναι λέγουσι. τούτους
δὲ ὁμοίως ἅπαντες σέθονται.---Τ 1}. ii. cap. 42.
s 2
200 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
This I think a plain proof of their being the common benefactors of
all Egypt, in the invention of corn, wine, and civil policy, as the
Egyptian annals deliver ; their other Hero-Gods, as particular and partial
benefactors, being worshipped variously. But this fixes them in their
high Antiquity. Again, the calf and ox are owned to be the peculiar
symbols of Osiris: but the GotpeN Car I have proved to be an
Egyptian symbol ; therefore Osiris was, at least, as old as Moses.
And again, our great Author owns,* that the king who invented
agriculture in Egypt, seems to have been worshipped by his subjects
in the ox or calf for this benefaction. Now the ox or calf was the
symbol of Osiris. But agriculture, we certainly know, was invented
before the time of Joseph, which will bring us to seek for Osiris 700
years higher than Sesac, who is our author’s ancient Osiris or
Sesostris of Egypt.
To proceed: Such were the blunders in the history of Osiris and
Sesostris,¢ of which Sir Isaac hath taken advantage, to prove them
to be one and the same. And it is certain, as was said before, that,
had not the sure records of Antiquity kept them separate, this jum-
bling of their actions into one another’s life had long ago incorporated
them; and left no room for Sir Isaac’s discovery: for the ancients
were fond of running many into one, as appears particularly in the
case of Bacchus, whose history we come now to consider.
II. For Sir Isaac farther strengthens the evidence of their identity
from Egyptian History, with the Grecian Mythology: in which
Baccuus is delivered to us as the same with Osiris: and Bacchus
being but two generations earlier than the Trojan war, the very age of
Sesostris, this, in his opinion, reduces all three to one.t
This identity of Bacchus and Osiris, Diodorus Siculus has very
accurately confuted.§ But to discover the general cause of this, and
all other mistaken identities, we must trace down the religion of
Greece from its original.
It is a certain truth, agreed upon by ancient as well as modern
writers, that civiLizED GREECE received its religion from Eeyrrt.
But the way in which this commerce was carried on is not so well
understood. It is generally supposed to have been done by adopting,
and worshipping the very Egyptian Gods themselves. But this is a
capital mistake. It was not till long after their first acquaintance
with Egypt, and instruction in their religious Rites, that they adopted
Egyptian Gods: which I shall now endeavour to shew.
In the barbarous ages of Greece their only Gods were those natural
Divinities, the heavenly Luminaries.|| But, on their first commerce
with Egypt for the arts of policy, they found there a new species of
* See note ZZZ, at the end of this book. t See note AAAA, at the end of this
book. 1 Page 191. § Lib. i. p. 14, || See ‘* Divine Legation,’’ vol. ii. p. 32.
ΒΕ OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 261
idolatry, the worship of DEAD MEN; which civilized Egypt had
invented ; and which, as they improved in policy, had almost worked
out their first natural Deities; the same with those of all other
uncivilized nations.* This new species, the Greeks eagerly embraced :
and beginning now to take the Egyptian nation for their model in
religious as well as in civil matters, they brought home this mode of
foreign worship, namely, DEAD MEN DEIFIED. Thus far is agreed
on all hands. The material question is, whether their object were
Egyptian hero-gods ; or whether, in imitation of that worship, they
made hero-gods of their own? The common opinion is that they
took the Egyptian. I suppose, on the contrary, that they must
needs make hero-gods of their own; and could not, at that time,
receive the other. My reason is this:
The greater celestial bodies were Deities in common, as their
influence sensibly extended over the whole habitable globe. But
hero-worship introduced the new idea of local tutelary Deities: and
this of necessity. For those Heroes were the distinguished bene-
factors of their own nation, at the expence, frequently, of their
neighbours: and, for such benefits, they were deified. Now several
causes concurred to make men teach and think, that the care and
providence of their Heroes, now become Gods, was still, as in life,
confined to their own dear Country: Such as the superior reverence
which rulers knew the People would pay to a God, whose Peculiar
they were supposed to be: for, when undistracted with other cares,
he would be supposed at full liberty to attend to the minutest
concerns of his own People: Such again, as the selfishness and pride
of the worshippers, who would be for ingrossing a God to them-
selves; and raising honour to their country from this imaginary
property. So that the opinion of local tutelary Deities became, at
length, one of the most general and most undisputed doctrines of
Paganism. It is delivered to us, for such, by Plato: yet, as the
origin of hero-gods from humanity was to be kept out of sight, ‘he
carefully disguises the foundation of it. The Gods (says he) for-
merly divided the whole earth amongst themselves by lot : not from
any contention or quarrel about their rights; for it is absurd to
suppose they did not know what was fit for every one’s peculiar care ;
or knowing this, that they should endeavour by violence to possess
themselves of one another's property: but all of them receiving in an
amicable manner, what fell to their share,t in this just method of
distribution, each resided on his own peculiar : which, having rendered
proper for our habitation, they lead and support us as shepherds do
* See “ὁ Divine Legation,” vol. i. p. 212. τὰ φίλων AayxdvovtTes—Serranus
, .
translates it—-‘¢ Deorum quisque prout hominum amore teneretur.’’ 1 understand it—
. ayy iY 1 Ἐ . . -
ΖΕ Τρ amicorum sortiti’””—i. 6. regions which belonged to gods who were in unity with
δ Θ᾽
one another.
262 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
their flocks and herds in a pasture.—Lvery God therefore having his
proper allotment, all his endeavours are employed to adorn and benefit
his own.* This was so flattering a notion, that, in after-times, the
Pagans carried it even into their Planet-worship: and each climate
was supposed to be under the proper protection of its own Star or
Constellation. So that the writer of The wisdom of Solomon seems to
make this the distinguishing mark of Paganism ; where praising the
God of Israel for his ancient mercies to that people, he says, Neither
is there any God but thou, that carest for ALL.+
Now, such a kind of tutelary God, the Egyptians would be so far
from offering to others, that they would be careful to keep him to
themselves. Hence the old practice of chaining down their Gods
(for hero-gods were worshipped by statues in human form) when
they imagined them disposed to ramble ; or to take a liking to any of
their neighbours. And as the Egyptians would be averse to lending,
so the Greeks would be as little inclined to borrow ; for they had now
a race of Heroes of their own; those godlike men, who had reduced
them from a savage to a civilized condition, and had given them this
very appetite ; the appetite to improve their policy by the assistance
of Egyptian wisdom. As little too would their own Lawgivers, who
brought that wisdom home to them, be disposed to offer them Egyp-
tian Gods ; as knowing how much stronger their reverence and adher-
ence would be to Gods made out of their own parents and fellow-
citizens. ‘But if this were the case, (and, in the course of the inquiry,
it will be proved from fact, as here from the reason of the thing) it
may be asked, What then was that ΚΕΙΙΘΊΟΝ which all agree the
Greeks borrowed of the Egyptians? I answer, the TRADE itself of
Hlero-worship ; or the custom of deifying their dead benefactors.
But again, if this were so, and that the Bacchus, Apollo, Mars, Jupiter,
&ec. first worshipped by the Greeks, were indeed Grecian Deities, it
will be then asked, how came their resemblance to the Egyptian to be
so great, as that later times should be generally deceived in thinking
them the same? This is a reasonable question, and will deserve a
particular discussion. There were several causes of this resemblance.
1. Nothing could be more simple than the riruax of the first
Planet-worship, as may be easily collected from the nature of that
idolatry. But Hero-worship necessarily introduced a great number of
complex Ceremonies. For, the commemorating the peculiar benefits
* Θεοὶ yap ἅπασαν γῆν «ποτὲ κατὰ τοὺς τόπους διελάγχανον, οὐ κατ᾽ ἔριν (οὐ γὰρ ἂν
ὀρθὸν ἔ ἔχοι λόγον, δεοὺς ἀγνοεῖν τὰ “αρέποντα ἑκάστοις αὑτῶν, οὐδ᾽ αὖ γινώσκοντας τὸ
μᾶλλον ἄλλοις τοροσῆκον, τοῦτο ἑτέρους αὑτοῖς δι᾽ ἐρίδων ἐπιχειρεῖν κτᾶσθαι) δίκης δὲ
κλήροις τὰ φίλων λαγχάνοντες κατῴκιζον τὰς Χώρας" καὶ κατοικίσαντες, οἷον νομεῖς
κτήματα καὶ ποίμνια καὶ δρέμματα ἑαυτῶν ἡμᾶς ἔτρεφον. --ἄλλοι μὲν οὖν κατ᾽ ἄλλους
τόπους κληρουχήσαντες Seay ἐκεῖνα ἐκόσμουν. —Vol. iii. p. 109, Ser. ed. { Οὔτε
ve Seds ἐστι WAhy σοῦ, ᾧ μέλει wept wdvTwv, ἵνα δείξῃς bre οὐκ ἀδίκως EKpivas.—
Cap. xii. 13,
SECT. V. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED, 263
received from the Hero-god, in his state of humanity, would occasion
many specific Rites; and the shadowing or concealing his original
and especially the blemishes in his moral character would necessitate
the use of allegorical. And what this last sort of Rites did not
sufficiently cover, the notion propagated amongst his worshippers (on
which was founded the rationale of their worship) was made to sup-
ply, viz. That the Demons or Heroes had, like men, their inordinate
virtues, passions and appetites. Plutarch in his tract Of the ceasing of .
the oracles has a remarkable passage to this purpose. ‘‘ There are in
Demons, as in men, a disparity in their virtues; and, like as in the
latter, a mixture of passion and imperfection. Of which, in some,
we find only the faint and obscure traces yet remain, as the dregs of
evanid matter; in others the vestiges are much stronger, and indeed,
indelible : and of this, we have certain marks and tokens dispersed up
and down, and preserved in the sacrifices, in the mysteries, and in the
ancient mythologic tales.”’* In like manner, the general memory of
the Hero’s descent from mortals, gave rise to the consultation of orA-
ΟΠ ΕΒ and adoration of STATUES in HUMAN FORM. Now, when Greece
borrowed of Egypt the superstition of Hero-worship, they would of
course borrow such of the Rites and practices as were peculiar to that
superstition ; and adapt them to their own Hero-gods, as best suited
every one’s character. For the truth of which we have the express
testimony of Herodotus, who tells us, that the HKygyptians were the
first authors of religious festivals, processions, and offerings ; and that
the Greeks learnt them of that people.t But this resemblance, even
without a studious application of Egyptian rites, must have arisen,
from the very practice itself of Hero-worship ; as appears from what
we have observed of the nature of those ceremonies which Hero-
worship necessarily introduced. To confirm this, we need only con-
sider the case of those hero-worshippers of the north and west, the
Gauls and Suevi; who did not, ike the Greeks, borrow this mode of
idolatry from Egypt ; being indebted for it to nothing but the cor-
ruption of our common nature. Now the Gods of those Barbarians,
and the Rites with which their Gods were adored, resembled the
religion of Greece and Rome so exactly, that these polite nations
‘thought the Gods of the Gauls and Suevi were the same with their
own; only worshipped under different names.t This was indeed a
gross mistake ; but natural to fall into: So great a resemblance have
Heroes of all times and places ever borne to one another; whether
* Εἰσὶ γὰρ ὡς ἐν ἀνθρώποις καὶ Δαίμοσιν ἀρετῆς διαφοραὶ, καὶ τοῦ ταθητικοῦ καὶ
ἀλόγου, τοῖς μὲν ἀσθενὲς καὶ ἀμαυρὸν ἔτι λείψανον, ὥσπερ πτσερίττωμα: τοῖς δὲ πσολὺ καὶ
δυσκατάσβεστον ἔνεστιν, ὧν ἴχνη καὶ σύμβολα wodrAaxod ϑυσίαι καὶ τελεταὶ καὶ μυθο-
λογίαι σώζουσι καὶ διαφυλάττουσιν ἐνδιεσπαρμένα. t Πανηγυρίας δὲ ἄρα καὶ wop-
πὰς καὶ τυροσαγωγὰς τ-αρῶτοι ἀνθρώπων Αἰγύπτιοί εἰσι οἱ τσοιησάμενοι" καὶ wapa τούτων
Ἕλληνες μεμαθήκασι.---Τὴν. ii, cap. 58. 1 See note BBBB, at the end of this book.
264 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
they were lawgivers, warriors, navigators, merchants, or artists. Nor
was their common rise from humanity, and their occupations in social
life, the only cause of this resemblance. There was another ; viz.
their several departments after they were become Gods: some presid-
ing over the elements, as earth, air, or water; others over the pas-
sions and pursuits of men, as love, war, trade, and the like. To this
common resemblance it was that at length almost every nation pre-
_tended, (as we see by Diodorus) that the Gods came originally from
them. Now if the Gods of these Barbarians, though different in
name, were for this resemblance, mistaken for the Gods of another
people, with whom they had no commerce ; where was the wonder
that the Grecian Gods, who had the same name with those of a peo-
ple with whom Greece held a perpetual commerce, should for the like
resemblance, be believed to be originally Egyptian ?
2. For, secondly, when the Greeks borrowed Egyptian Rites to
enrich the worship of their Gods, they borrowed Egyptian NAMES
of honour to adorn their persons. Thus, for instance, the name of
Bacchus, one of the appellations of Osiris, was given to the son of
Semele. Herodotus tells us, that these names they did certainly
borrow ; and we see by his account, that this was all which, in his
time, was pretended to be borrowed.* This observing historian, in
his account of the Pelasgi, further confirms this truth, by a very
curious piece of history. ‘In former times,” (says he) “ the
Pelasgi in their religious worship used to sacrifice of every thing
without distinction, to their Geds, as I was informed by the priests
at Dodona. ‘They gave neither xwme nor surname to any of their
Gods : for they had heard of no such practice. But their titles were
taken from what their worshippers conceived of their providence,
directing and ordering all things fitly and harmoniously. But after a
long course of time they heard of other Gods, and of their NAMEs,
which came from ἔσυρ, and in the last place of the name of Bac-
cHus. Some time after they consulted the Oracle of Dodona con-
cerning these Names; for this Oracle is supposed to be the oldest
of any in Greece ; and, at the time I am speaking of, the only one.
Of this Oracle therefore having asked advice, whether they should
admit the Names, which came from the Barbarians, into their reli-
gion ; they received for answer, that they should admit them. From
that time + therefore they sacrificed with specific multifarious Rites, in
which they honoured their Gods with these new appellations. And, from
“ Σχεδὸν δὲ καὶ wdvra τὰ OTYNOMATA τῶν Θεῶν EZ ΑἸΓΎΠΤΟΥ ἐλήλυθε ἐς
τὴν Ἑλλάδα. διό \ x > - U ¢g “ Spl “, Lj
ἢν Ἑλλάδα. διότι μὲν yap ex τῶν BapSdpwr ἥκει τσυνθανόμενος οὕτω εὑρίσκω ἔον. δοκέω
δ᾽ ὧν μάλιστα ἀπ᾿ Αἰγύπτου ἀπῖχθαι" 6, τι γὰρ δὴ μὴ Ποσειδεῶνος, καὶ Διοσκούρων (ὡς
καὶ wpdrepdy μοι ταῦτα εἴρηται) καὶ “Ἥρης, καὶ Ἱστίης, καὶ Θέμιος, καὶ Χαρίτων, καὶ
Νηρηΐδων, καὶ τῶν ἄλλων ϑεῶν, Αἰγυπτίοισι αἰείκοτε τὰ οὐνοματά ἐστι ἐν τῇ χώρῃ- λέγω
abet αὐτοὶ Αἰγύπτιοι. — Lib. ii, cap. 50. t+ See note CCCC, at the end of
this book.
SECT. V. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 265
the Pelasgi, the Greeks afterwards took up the custom. But the
original of each God, and whether they are all from eternity, and
what are their several kinds of natures, to say the truth, they neither
knew at that time, nor since. For Homer and Hestop—were those
who made a Theogony for the Greeks; gave SURNAMES to the Gods ;
adjusted their various and specific Rites and Attributes ; and designed
and delineated their several forms and figures.”’ *
From this remarkable passage we may deduce the following facts ;
which, besides the evidence to the matter in question, are very corro-
borative of our general explanation of Antiquity. 1. It appears
from hence, that the Greeks borrowed the names of the Egyptian
Gods,+ to decorate their own; receiving them, as Herodotus here
supposes, by the hands of the Pelasgians. 2. That they received.
nothing but the names. 3. That the humour of these ancient inha-
bitants of Greece was so far from disposing them to take Egyptian,
or Stranger-Gods, that they would not so much as venture on their
names till they had consulted the Oracle. 4. That the Religion of
names came in with Hero-worship or local tutelary Deities (to which
species of Gods xames were an honorary attribution) ; and unknown
to the worshippers of the natural Divinities, as the Pelasgians and all
other uncivilized people. 5. That this Religion of names was a thing
of much consequence in the Egyptian superstition, and even charac-
teristic of it; which the reader is desired to observe as of use to
explain some passages in the next section, concerning the propensity
of the Israelites to that superstition. 6. That one cause of that
ignorance, which, Herodotus here tells us, the Greeks ever laboured
under, concerning the original, nature, and species of their Gods, and
which, as now appears, we had not unjustly charged upon them,
when we ventured to say the same in several parts of this work ; one
cause, I say, was, that those zames which the Pelasgians had applied
to their new Hero-Gods, the Greeks, their successors, took and trans-
ferred to theirs. 7. And lastly, (which supports the general argu-
ment we are now upon) the true sense of the concluding words,
* Ἔθυον δὲ τσάντα wpdrepov οἱ Πελασγοὶ ϑεοῖσι ἐπευχόμενοι, ws ἐγὼ ἐν Δωδώνῃ οἶδα
ἀκούσας" ἐπωνυμίην δ᾽ οὐδ᾽ οὔνομα ἐποιεῦντο οὐδενὶ αὐτέων" ov γὰρ ἀκηκόεσάν κω. δεοὺς
δὲ ττυροσωνόμασάν σῴεας ἀπὸ τοῦ τοιούτου, ὅτι κόσμῳ ϑέντες τὰ τυάντα τορήγματα καὶ
πάσας νομὰς εἶχον" ἐπεί τε δὲ χρόνου τσολλοῦ διελθόντος, ἐπύθοντο ἐκ τῆς Αἰγύπτου
ἀπικόμενα τὰ οὐνόματα τῶν ϑεῶν τῶν ἄλλων, Διονύσου δὲ ὕστερον ττολλῷ ἐπύθοντο. καὶ
μετὰ χρόνον ἐχρηστηριάζοντο wept τῶν οὐνομάτων ἐν Δωδώνῃ" τὸ γὰρ δὴ μαντήϊον τοῦτο
νενόμιστο ἀρχαιότατον τῶν ἐν Ἕλλησι χρηστηρίων εἶναι: καὶ ἦν τὸν χρόνον τοῦτον
μοῦνον" ἐπεὶ ὧν ἐχρηστηριάζοντο ἐν τῇ Δωδώνῃ οἱ Πελασγοὶ εἰ ἀνέλωνται τὰ οὐνόματα
τὰ ἀπὸ τῶν βαρβάρων ἥκοντα, ἀνεῖλε τὸ μαντήϊον χρᾶσθαι. ἀπὸ μὲν δὴ τούτου τοῦ χρόνου
ἔθυον, τοῖσι οὐνόμασι τῶν ϑεῶν χρεώμενοι, wapa δὲ Πελασγῶν Ἕλληνες ἐξεδέξαντο
ὕστερον. Ἔνθεν δὲ ἐγένετο ἕκαστος τῶν ϑεῶν, εἴτε δ᾽ ἀεὶ ἦσαν waves ὁκοῖοί τέ τινες
τὰ εἴδεα, οὐκ ἠπιστέατο μέχρι οὗ Wpwhy τε καὶ χθὲς, ws εἰπεὶν λόγῳ. Ἡσίοδον γὰρ καὶ
Ὅμηρον-- οὗτοι δέ εἰσι of τσοιήσαντες ϑεογονίην Ἕλλησι, καὶ τοῖσι ϑεοῖσι TAS ἐπωνυμίας
δόντες, καὶ τιμάς τε καὶ τέχνας διελόντες, καὶ εἴδεα αὐτῶν onunvavtes.—Lib. ii. cap.
52, 53. + See note DDDD, at the end of this book.
266 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iy.
which has hitherto been grosly mistaken, lies open to us—Jor (says
Herodotus) Homer and Hesiod—were those who made a Theogony for
the Greeks ; gave surnames to the Gods ; adjusted their various and
specific attributes, and rites of worship ; and designed and delineated
their several forms and figures. What hath been commonly under-
stood by these words is, that in Herodotus’s opinion, the Greeks
knew little or nothing of what we call their classical Gods, till Homer
and Hesiod taught them how they were to be marshalled, and had
assigned their several departments. A sense not only confuted by
the poems of those two writers, who relate what they saw ESTAB-
LISHED in their own times, but contradicted by what went just
before, where the historian tells us that Melampus (whom Homer
himself places three generations before the Trojan war) first taught
the Greeks the name, the rites, and the mysteries of Bacchus ;* the
God last received (if we may believe the same historian) after the
Religion of names was come in fashion. And we have no reason to
doubt his evidence, when we see the several parts of it so well coin-
cide; for if Melampus first taught the Greeks the worship of Bac-
chus, this God must needs be the last received by them. But indeed,
the whole context excludes the common interpretation, and directs us
to one, very different. The Pelasgians (we are told) received the
RELIGION OF NAMES from the Barbarians [1. 6. the Egyptians] ; by
which, the Gods were divided into their several classes. This new
doctrine, the Pelasgians conveyed down to the Greeks. But (says
the historian) the original of each God, and whether they are all from
eternity, and what their several kinds and natures are, to say the
truth, they neither knew at that time, nor since. He then immedi-
ately subjoins the reason of their ignorance—For Homer and Hesiod
—were those who made a Theogony for the Greeks ; gave SURNAMES
to the Gods ; adjusted their various and specific rites and attributes ;
and designed and delineated their several forms and figures: and a
convincing reason it is; for Homer’s and Hesiod’s being the popular
and only authorised books of Theology amongst the Greeks, which
assign the names, the attributes, and the form to each God, and
their accounts being, at the same time, over-run with fables and fic-
tions, it was impossible even for the Greeks themselves to develop
the confusion, and emancipate themselves from that ignorance here
complained of, namely, of the true natures of their Gods: which
indeed, their Teachers seem to have known as little of as themselves.
For Homer when he speaks of Jupiter, sometimes represents him as
a God from eternity, at other times as only the head of the college
_ * Ἤδη ὧν δοκέει μοι Μελάμπους ὃ ᾿Αμυθέωνος τῆς ϑυσίης ταύτης οὐκ εἶναι ἀδαὴς,
ἀλλ᾽ ἔμπειρος, Ἕλλησι γὰρ δὴ Μελάμπους ἐστὶ 6 ἐξηγησάμενος τοῦ Διονύσου, τότε
οὔνομα, καὶ τὴν ϑυσίην, καὶ τὴν ττομπὴν τῶ paddod.—Cap. 49.
SECT. Vv. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 267
of their terrestrial Deities. This then was what Herodotus meant to
say ; who is not speaking of the inventions of Homer and Hesiod,
but of their AurHority. Whether they were the first who propa-
gated or delivered these things, was not the matter in question. Had
it been so, we know how Herodotus would have decided ; who, in
this very place, expressly tells us, who were the rrrsT; namely, the
Pelasgians ; who delivered them to the Greeks; where Homer and
Hesiod found them. However, on the common interpretation, gross
as it is, Sir Isaac Newton builds one of his strongest arguments in
favour of his new Chronology. To proceed :
3. The Greeks not only borrowed the names, but likewise the
symuoxs of the Egyptian Gods; and fitted them to theirown. A
very natural superstition, as appears by the practice of the Hebrews
in the wilderness ; who, in the absence of Moses, running back into
Egyptian idolatry, would needs worship the God of their Fathers
under an Egyptian Symbol ; and with Egyptian Rites likewise, and
the people sat down to eat and drink, and rose up to play. Now had
God, on this occasion, persisted in the severity of his justice, where
he tells Moses, that he would indeed give them the land of Canaan,
and drive out the inhabitants before them, because he had promised
Abraham so to do, yet that he would not honour them, as a select
People, with his peculiar protection: Had, I say, God thus cast them
off, and the people departed with their new Leader, the GoLpEeN
CALF, into Canaan; and there made it the visible representative of
the God of their Fathers, and worshiped it with Egyptian Rites ;
who can doubt but that the late posterity of this people, thus aban-
doned by God, and given up to make and believe a lye, would have
supposed that their Forefathers had worshiped Osiris, and not Jeho-
vah, under this golden calf? The case needs no application.
This then was the whole of what Greece borrowed from Egypt in
matter of religion, when it rrrsT learnt the mode of Hero-worship
from that superstitious people. But
4, It must be owned, that soon after, they did indeed adopt
STRANGER Gods. At first the occasion was rare, and the Worship
.particular and confined. Thus the Athenians labouring under a
destructive famine, and relieved by Egypt with corn, did, in gratitude
for that benefit, make Isis the patron-Goddess of their Mysteries.
Their Migrations were another cause of this adoption: for every
region having a local tutelary Deity, the new Colony thought them-
selves obliged to worship the God of that place in which they came to
settle. But, of this, more in another place.
However, in process of time, the Greeks naturalized all the greater
Gods of Egypt. For we are to observe that, as superstition grew in
bulk, the principle of InrERCOMMUNITY, arising from. the very
205 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
essence of Paganism, at length overspread all their National Religions,
so as to bring things round again. We observed, that those most
early Idol-gods, the Celestial luminaries, were common to all nations,
and that Hero-worship brought in the idea of local tutelary Deities :
now, the principle of 1nrERcomMuNITy at length broke down this
inclosure, and turned all their Gods again upon the Common,
‘“‘The grazed ox, and all her bleating Gods.” *
But to be a little more particular concerning these various revolu-
tions in the genius of Paganism. The first idolatry was Planetary :
and so long, their Gods were in common. But Hero-worship, by
bringing in local tutelary Deities, made their Gods peculiar. ΑΒ the
times grew polished, and the absurdity of MorTAL Gops became
better understood, the Managers of this superstition were obliged to
hide their origin from Earth, and to pretend they had ever been
Celestial. This soon wore out their peculiarity, and brought in again
the notion of their general providence: which, by means of an
increasing superstition, ended in an universal INTERCOMMUNITY. To
explain all these particulars, as they deserve, would require a volume,
And not much less perhaps might be collected from what hath been
occasionally said of them, in the course of this work. Only one
attendant circumstance in these revolutions, it may not be improper to
take notice of, as it greatly contributed to fix the later Greeks in their
mistake concerning the origin of their Hero-Gods. It was this: The
learned Egyptians, as we have observed, at length contrived: to hide
the deformity of their idolatry by pretending that the whole had a
reference to the onty Gov. Thus their various Brute-worship, they
said, was severally relative to the various attributes of the Diviniry.
The same kind of refinement they brought into their Hero-worship :
and each of their greater Gods they made significative, some way or
other, of the rrrst Cause. But to perfect this part of their symbo-
lical Theology, it was necessary to make large additions to the
Legends of those Gods. And thus the several parts of Isis’s history
became relative to the divine Nature. But Isis being now possessed
of all the attributes, which happened to be severally divided amongst
the various Grecian Goddesses, the Greeks began to think that these
were all originally derived from her. This was the established doc-
trine in the time of Apuleius: who makes [515 address herself to him
in these words: Hn assum—rerum natura parens—cujus numen unicum
multiformi specie, ritu vario, nomine multiyugo, totus veneratur orbis.
Me primigenii Phryges Pessinunticam nominant Deim matrem ; hine
Autochthones Attici Cecropiam Minervam ; illine fluctuantes Cyprii
patriam Venerem ; Cretes Sagittiferi Dictynnam Dianam ; Siculi tri-
* MILTON.
SECT, ν. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 969
lingues Stygiam Proserpinam; Eleusinit vetustam Deam Cererem ;
Junonem alii, alii Bellonam, alii Hecaten, Rhamnusiam alii Aigypti
ceremoniis me prorsus propriis percolentes appellant vero nomine
Is1pEmM.*
Osirrs too, becoming equally symbolical, made his fortune in the
same manner, as appears by this ancient epigram :
Ogygia me Baechum vocat,
Osinin A’gyptus putat,
Mysi Phanacen nominant,
Dionyson Indi existimant,
Romana Sacra Liberum,
Arabica gens Adoneum,
‘ Iucaniacus Pantheum,t
Thus have I explained the several causes which occasioned the later
Greeks to think their own Gods were originally Egyptian ; for under-
standing that the Rites, the Names, and the very Symbols of their
Gods were borrowed from thence, they concluded the same of the
Gods themselves. And with good appearance of reason, as they found
too that the ages immediately preceding theirs, had certainly adopted
Egyptian Gods ; which Gods had all the attributes of the Grecian.
Now when this opinion was once generally embraced, they would, of
course, invent a Legend for the Gods, conformable to the Egyptian
history of them. And thus we see the reason why they made their
Baccuvus but two generations earlier than the Trojan war, of which
age he was; and yet made him Osrris, the conqueror of India, which
he was not.{ But their more intelligent historians perceived the
absurdity ; and so, reasonably satisfied themselves in supposing a
double Bacchus: but being, as Herodotus observes, very ignorant of
the true origin of their Religion, it was a mere gratuitous solution :
which made it easy for Sir Isaac to evade it; by only supposing, in
his turn, that it was their wrong notion of the high antiquity of Egypt
which made them split one Bacchus into two. And yet in another
instance, he frankly enough allows of this ancient practice of the
communication of names.§ But he gives the fact reversed: for they
were the earlier Greeks who worshipped two Bacchus’s. And it was
late, as we find by Diodorus, ere they incorporated them into one.||
Now had the cause of their duality been what the great writer sup-
poses, the fact had been just contrary ; and earlier times had wor-
shiped one Bacchus, and the later, ἔσο. The truth of the case then
is this: when they first worshiped Hero-Gods, they had but one
* Metam. lib. xi. p. 378. + AUSONIUS, ep. XXX. t See note EKEE, at the
end of this book. § ‘The Phenicians, upon their first coming into Greece, gave the
name of Jao-pater, Jupiter, to every king.’’—“‘ Chron. of Ancient Kingdoms amended,”
p- 150. || Διμήτορα δ᾽ abtovy τσροσαγορευθῆναι λέγουσι, διὰ τὸ τσατρὸς μὲν ἑνὸς
ὑπάρξαι τοὺς δύο Διονύσους, μητέρων δὲ δυεῖν: κεκληρονομηκέναι δὲ τὸν νεώτερον τὰς τοῦ
wporyevertépov τσράξεις. διόπερ τοὺς ΜΕΤΑΓΕΝΕΣΤΕΡΟΥΣ ἀνθρώπους, ATNOOTN-
TAS μὲν τἀληθὲς, τσλανηθέντας δὲ διὰ τὴν ὁμωνυμίαν, ἕνα “γεγονέναι νομίσαι Διόνυσον.
— Lib. iv. p. 148,
270 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK lv.
Bacchus and one Hercules, &c. and these were Grecian: when they
afterwards borrowed the Egyptian Gods, they had two of each. And
this is not said at random ; for Herodotus * and Diodorus + expresly
tell us, that two Bacchus’s and two Hercules’s were worshiped by
different Rites, and as Gods of different original, the one Grecian,
the other Egyptian. And at length, for the causes explained under
the next head, the two of each were again reduced to one. For we
shall now see, that design as well as mistake contributed to confound
the Grecian Bacchus with the Egyptian.
III. For our illustrious Author makes another use of the Grecian
mythology, to support his system. He examines the genealogies of
their Gods and Heroes; and finds them to coincide exactly with
the time of Sesostris:{ A farther evidence of the truth of his
hypothesis.
There are but few cases in which one would seriously admit the
testimony of a Mythologist. Least of all, in settling of dates.
The most learned of the moderns complain greatly of them for con-
founding all time in their pretended relations of fact. The excellent
bishop STILLINGFLEET thus expresseth himself: MWe see those [Thu-
cydides and Plutarch, whose confession he had quoted] who were best
able to judge of the Greek Antiquities, can find no sure footing to
stand on in them; and what basis can we find for our faith, where they
could find so little for their knowledge? And those who have been
more daring and venturous than these persons mentioned, what a laby-
rinth have they run themselves into? How many confusions and con-
tradictions have they involved themselves in? sometimes writing the
passages of other countries for those of Greece, and at other times so
confounding times, persons, and places, that one might think they had
only a design upon the understandings of their readers, to make them
play at blind-man’s buff in searching for the kings of Greece.§ And
the candid and accurate bishop CUMBERLAND speaks so much to our
purpose, that I shall add his words to the foregoing: Their mythic .
writers confound and lose all the times of their Gods ; which advantage
divers Christians make use of against them: and this was a good argu-
ment ad hominem, as τέ is called, but is not sufficient to prove, that
* Kal δοκέουσι δέ μοι οὗτοι ὀρθότατα Ἑλλήνων πσοιέειν, οἱ διξὰ Ἡράκλεια ἱδρυσάμενοι
ἔκτηνται: καὶ τῷ μὲν, ὡς AOANATQ: ᾿Ολυμπίῳ δὲ ἐπωνυμίην, ϑύουσι: τῷ δ᾽ ἑτέρῳ, ὡς
“Ηρωϊ, ἐναγίζουσι.---ΠΈΚΟΡ. lib ii. cap. 44. t Μυθολογοῦσι δέ τινες καὶ ἕτερον
Διόνυσον γεγονέναι τπσολὺ τοῖς χρόνοις τυροτεροῦντα τούτου. φασὶ γὰρ ἐκ Διὸς καὶ
Περσεφόνης Διόνυσον γενέσθαι, τὸν ὑπό τινων Σαθδάζιον ὀνομαζόμενον. οὗ Thy τε γένεσιν,
καὶ τὰς ϑυσίας, καὶ τιμὰς ΝΥΎΚΤΕΡΙΝΑΣ καὶ ΚΡΥΦΙΑΣ πσαρεισάγουσι, διὰ τὴν
αἰσχύνην τὴν ἐκ τῆς συνουσίας ἐπακολουθοῦσαν.--- ΠΙΟΠΟΆυΒ, lib. iv. p. 148. These
nightly and secret Rites shew them to be Egyptian. As for what is said of the other
Bacchus’s being the son of Proserpine, this was only a faney of the Greeks, on observ-
ing the mysteries of Bacchus and those of Ceres or Isis to have a great resemblance :
but this was only occasioned by their being both Egyptian Rites. 1 Page 191, et
este of ‘the Chron. of Ancient Kingdoms amended.” § Orig. Sacr. p. 41, eighth
edit.
SECT. Ve. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 271
idolatry, and the heathen Gods, are of SO LATE AN ORIGINAL, as
some, both Heathen and Christians, have affirmed them to be.* Now
though, in answer to what Sir Isaac Newton brings from such writers,
it were enough to say, with those who have considered their character
before me, that they are so perplexed, contradictory, and infinitely
fabulous, that nothing certain can be gathered from their accounts,
for the regulation of ancient time; yet that they may never appear
again amongst witnesses of credit, or be heard in matters of fact, I
shall endeavour to shew, from what sources those accounts arose, from
which the low date of the Egyptian Gods is inferred : whence it will
appear that they are a heap of fictions, invented and contrived, as
usual, only for the support of greater.
1. The first source was the address of the EGYPTIAN PRIESTS, to
screen their Hero-worship from the inquisition of the curious. We
have observed, from a famous fable, invented by these men,+ to record
the danger which this superstition incurred, and from their art in evad-
ing that danger, that the original of their Hero-Gods was a subject
maliciously pursued by the Free enquirers of those times. For the
discredit attending this superstition was, that these Gops had been
MEN ; and the proof of their humanity was taken from their late
existence. Now what did these Masters in their trade do, to evade
this evidence? We have seen before what they did to obscure the
enquiry. Why, by an equal effort of their skill, they invented a set
of fables (one of which has been examined above) concerning these
Gods ; which brought their births even lower down than to the times
of their established worship. What they gained by this was con-
siderable: They threw a general confusion over the whole history of
these Gods: and in a short time made men as indisposed to give
credit to the o/d stories of them (from whence the dangerous truth of
their HUMANITY might be collected) as these xew fables, which it was
impossible they should believe, for the reason just now assigned.
Hence, the first source of the low dates of these Hero-Gods.
2. The second, was the extravagant vanity of the Greeks in pre-
tending, at length, to be original even to the Egyptians themselves.
For we are to observe, that there were three distinguished periods in
the Religion of civilized Greece; two of which we have described
already. The first was, when the Greeks borrowed Egyptian Rites
and Ceremonies to adorn their own Hero-gods: the second, when
they adopted the very Egyptian Gods: and the third, when, on the
contrary, they pretended that the Egyptians had adopted Theirs. On
their first acquaintance with Egypt, they were modest, and fairly
* Sanchoniatho, pp. 132, 133. + The fable I mean is that of Typhon’s perse-
eution of the Gods and their flight into Egypt; which the Greeks borrowed and fitted
up with their own names of the Gods.
972 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK iv.
=
allowed its superior Antiquity. But as they advanced in arts and
empire, they grew intoxicated with their good fortune ; and would now
contend with Egypt (become by this time as much fallen and
depressed in both) for the honour of priority ; and soon after (as was
no wonder when they had ventured so far), with all the rest of man-
kind.* And then it was, that having, before this time, thoroughly
confounded the Grecian and Egyptian Bacchus with design (a confu-
sion first occasioned by mistake) they invented many fables to counte-
nance their absurd pretensions. Hence their idle tale of Apis, the
son or grandson of Phoroneus, becoming Osrris; without any other
reason in the world than that the son of Phoroneus chanced to have
the same name with the symbol of Osiris. Hence, again, the fable of
Io, the daughter of Inachus, becoming Isis; for scarce so good a
reason; only an approaching similitude of names. Yet these two
wretched fables, Sir Isaac Newton (surprising as it is) hath drawn in
for the main supports of his hypothesis.t But as much credit as his
countenance hath given to them, he who can suppose Io to be stolen
out of Greece, carried into Egypt, and there made a Goddess, may as
well believe an European ship to be now busied in bringing hither an
Indian savage to be made a queen. /
But another story of the same stamp, carries its confutation along
with it, as Herodotus rightly observed.{ For, to bring Hercules, as
they had done Isis and Osiris, out of Greece into Egypt, in a manner
suitable to his character, they pretended that, when he had landed on
that inhospitable shore, and was led by the Natives, crowned with
garlands, to be offered up at the altar of Jupiter, he broke loose from
his leaders, and slaughtered all who were assembled for the Sacrifice ;
and in this rough manner, I suppose, taught them to abolish those
inhuman rites, and to worship their chastiser as a God: which would
seem to have been the first bringing in of club-law into Religion. But,
as Herodotus observes, the inventor of this fable hath laid his story so
ill together, that he hath only betrayed his own ignorance of Egyptian
Manners. For, from the most early time, the inhabitants of the Nile
were so far from offering up human victims, that they held it unlaw-
ful to sacrifice above three or four species of animals. But the
Egyptians owed them a good turn for this slander of human sacrifices ;
and indeed paid them with usury. For Herodotus tells us, the
Priests informed him, that when Menelaus went to Egypt to enquire
after Helen, and lay wind-bound in their ports, he cut up two chil-
dren of the natives, to divine by their entrails.§
* Λανθάνουσι δ᾽ αὑτοὺς τὰ τῶν Ἑλλήνων κατορθώματα, ἀφ᾽ ὧν μὴ ὅτι γε φιλοσοφία,
ἀλλὰ καὶ γένος ἀνθρώπων ἦρξε, Βαρθάροις wpoodmrovres.—DiOGENES LAERTIUS,
Proem, segm. 3. t Page 192, of his * Chronology.” t Λέγουσι δὲ τσυολλὰ
καὶ ἄλλα ἀνεπισκέπτως of Ἕλληνες ebhOns δὲ αὐτέων καὶ ὅδε ὃ μῦθός ἐστι, τὸν wept τοῦ
Ἡρακλέους λέγουσι: ὡς αὐτὸν ἀπικόμενον ἐς Αἴγυπτον, &e.—Lib. ii. cap. 45. § Λαξὼν
γὰρ δύο τσαιδία ἀνδρῶν ἐπιχωρίων, ἔντομά σφεα ἐποίησε.---Π ΈΠΟΡ. lib. ii. cap. 119.
SECT. v. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 973
This humour of priority was so rooted in the Greeks, that Diodorus
seems to insinuate, they always disputed it with the Egyptians.*—
And so far indeed is true, that it was one of their most early
vanities : + and though afterwards, on their more intimate acquaint-
ance with Egypt, it was in some degree corrected, yet it burst out
again, and lasted, as we see, even to the time of Diogenes Laertius.
But this is the pleasant part of the story; The Egyptians were not
content to complain, as well they might, that the Greeks had stolen
away their Gods and Heroes; but they would needs make reprisals on
them. Thus, as Diodorus tells us, when they charged the Greeks
with taking away their Isis, to aggravate the theft they pretended that
Athens itself was originally but an Egyptian Colony.t This was a
home stroke : but the Greeks as handsomely returned it ; by affirming
that one of the Egyptian pyramids was built by Rhodope, a Grecian
whore.§ This setting up one false claim to oppose another, was
in the very spirit of ancient Paganism.|| So again, the Egyptians
maintaining that civilized Greece was indebted for the mode of Hero-
worship to them ; did, in order to support a just claim, which wanted
none of these arts, pretend to Antiquity most extravagantly high.
The Greeks, not to be behind-hand with them, and to support a false
claim which did want these sort of arts, having pretended that the
Egyptians borrowed all from them, brought down the age of these dis-
puted Gods as much too /ow. Unluckily, the great Author, who saw
the unreasonable Antiquity of the one system, did not advert to the
unreasonable Novelty of the other.
But we are not to think the Greeks firm and steady in this natural
consequence of their unjust pretensions. Nothing is so inconstant as
falshood. When, therefore, on the issue, it was seen that all the
Records of former times contradicted this novelty ; and, consequently,
that their darling claim itself was likely to be in danger, they shifted
their support, and then contended, in imitation of the Egyptians, for
as extravagant an Antiquity.4]
IV. Hitherto Sir Isaac Newton was drawn in by Antiquity ; which
had sunk with him, and foundered in the treacherous soil of Mytho-
logy. But the greatest part of his reasoning, from these Genealogies,
stands upon an error of his own. ‘The age preceding the destruction
* Περὶ δὲ τῆς Tov βίου ἤγουν γένους ἀρχαιότητος ov μόνον ἀμφισϑθητοῦσιν Ἕλληνες
ἀλλὰ καὶ τσολλοὶ τῶν Βαρβάρων ἑαυτοὺς αὐτόχθονας A€yovTes.—P. 6. + See
*¢ Divine Legation,” book iv. sect. iii. p. 149, et seq. t Καὶ τοὺς ᾿Αθηναίους δέ
φασιν ἀποίκους εἶναι Σαϊτῶν τῶν ἐξ Αἰγύπτου.--- ΠΟ. δ᾽οῦτ. p. 17. § See note
FFFF, at the end of this book. || In the former part of this work where we have
shewn, that the Converts from Gentilism unhappily practised it even after they had pro-
fessed a Religion which condemns all the oblique arts of falshood, and unjust retaliation.
“ Πάντων δὴ wpdrov μνησθῶμεν, ὅτι τὸ κεφάλαιον Hy ἐννάκις ἔτη χίλια, ἀφ᾽ οὗ γεγονὼς
ἐμηνύθη ττόλεμος τοῖς δ᾽ ὑπὲρ Ἡρακλείας στήλας ἔξω κατοικοῦσι καὶ τοῖς ἐντὸς waow
by δεῖ νῦν διαπεραίνειν" τῶν μὲν οὖν ἥδε ἣ τσόλις ἄρχουσα καὶ τσυάντα τὸν τσόλεμον διαπο-
λεμήσασα ἐλέγετο.--- ῬΙ,ΑΤΟ, vol. iii. p. 108. BE.
VOL, II. Zt
274 ἶ THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
of Troy is full of the loves and intrigues of the greater Divinities : who
supplied that expedition from their own loins with Demi-Gods once
removed. Sir Isaac, who supposed, as indeed he well might from
physical observation, that the Gods left off getting children when they
died, concludes, from the mythologic account of their Offspring, that
they must needs have lived but two or three generations before the
war of Troy. But our great Philosopher took this thing a deal too
seriously. The truth is, he concerned himself no farther with the
fabulous history of ancient times than just served the purpose of his
system. Otherwise, he might have found, on the most cursory sur-
vey, that one of the essential attributes of a Pagan God was the get-
ting of Bastards: and that, for one he fairly had in life, his worship-
pers fathered an hundred upon him after his decease. This amorous
commerce between Heaven and Earth never ceased till near the latest
times of Paganism ; as we learn from the primitive Apologists ; who,
referring to their perpetual intrigues in mythologic story, rally the
idolaters, of their time, with great vivacity, on the decrepid old age
and sudden debility of their Gods.
It being then notorious that, in the later ages of Paganism, Earth
swarmed as thick with the progeny of Heaven, as in the early times
of that religion, Heaveh swarmed with the progeny of Earth, Sir
Isaac’s- calculation, from the time of the sons and grandsons of the
Gods, what must needs be their own, is altogether fallacious. But
as, in this inquiry, we have still attempted to account for the fables
of Antiquity, in order to detect their various impostures, and prevent
their future mischief, we shall now consider the original of those in
question.
1. The first cause of this doubly-spurious Offspring, was the contri-
vance of wives to hide their adultery ; of virgins to excuse their incon-
tinence ; and of parents to cover the dishonour of their House.*
The God bore the blame, or rather the Mortal reaped the glory ; and
Passion, as is usual, was advanced into Piety. Great men too,
employed it, (for then Great men had some regard for their Race and
Name) to conceal the ignominy of a low-born commerce. In a word,
both sexes soon learnt the sweets of a holy intrigue; where a pre-
tended converse with a God or Goddess preserved the reputation of
the weaker, and procured power and authority to the stronger sex.
Sometimes the pretended amour was mutually concerted between the
real parties: as that of Anchises and a Country wench; who, in
regard to his honour, was to pass for a Venus. So Homer: Ὁ
* See note GGGG, at the end of this book.
+t Δαρδανίων αὖτ᾽ ἦρχεν, eis wails ᾿Αγχίσαο,
Αἰνείας" τὸν ὑπ᾽ ᾿Αγχίσῃ τέκε δῖ᾽ ᾿Αφροδίτη,
Ἴδης ἐν κνημοῖσι, Yea βροτῷ εὐνηθεῖσα. ---ἴλ. B. verse 819.
Yet this is one of the instances Sir Isaac brings to prove the low age of the Goddess
Venus. See p. 191, of his “ΚΞ Chronology.”
SECT. Vv. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 7019)
“Divine A‘neas brings the Dardan race,
Anchises’ son by Venus’ stol’n embrace ;
Born in the shades of Ida’s secret grove,
A mortal mixing with the Queen of Love.’’—Mr. Pore.
And, in a much later age, the Wife of Philip of Macedon and her
Court-gallant. Sometimes again, one of the parties was deceived by
the mask of divinity which the other had impiously assumed, as seems
to have been the case of Astioché : *
“‘ Two valiant brothers rule th’ undaunted throng,
Ialmen and Ascalaphus the strong :
Sons of Astioche the heavenly fair,
Whose virgin charms subdw’d the God of war:
In Actor’s court, as she retir’d to rest,
The strength of Mars the blushing maid comprest.’’—Mr. Pore.
And of the priestess Rhea,
Quem Rhea Sacerdos
Furtivum parte sub luminis edidit auras,
Mista Deo Mulier.t+
And of Alemene the mother of Hercules. It was certainly the case of
the virtuous Paulina, in the reign of Tiberius: who, being made to
believe that the God Anubis was fallen in love with her, went to the
appointed assignation with a mind equally balanced by conjugal
chastity and superstition. The story is very curious, and told by
Josephus in all its cireumstances.t In short, if we may believe Ovid,
who was exquisitely skilled in the mythologic story, this was one of
the most common covers of lust and concupiscence. The pretended
nurse of Semele is made to caution her mistress against the addresses
of Jupiter, in the following manner :
Opto
Jupiter ut sit, ait ; Metuo tamen omnia. MULTI
NomINE DivyoRUM THALAMOS INIERE PUDICOS, ὃ
2. Another cause was the ambition of the pretenders themselves to
heavenly birth, in order to support their authority amongst their
barbarous subjects or followers. Thus we are told, that the two
Amazon queens, Marthesia and Lampeto, gave out that they were the
daughters of Mars, ne successibus deesset auctoritas (says the historian)
genitas se Marte predicabant.|| And thus Romulus and Remus
pretended to the same relation: But this matter is explained more
at large in the discourse on the ancient Lawgivers.4]
3. A third cause was the flattery of sycophants and corrupt Courtiers.
To this practice Clepolemus alludes, in his address to Sarpedon :
* Τῶν ἦρχ᾽ ᾿Ασκάλαφος καὶ Ἰάλμενος vies “Apnos,
Ods τέκεν ᾿Αστυόχη, δόμῳ ΓΑκτορος ᾿Αζείδαο,
Παρθένος ALAOTH, ὑπερώϊον εἰσαναδᾶσα,
“Apni κρατερῷ" ὁ δέ οἱ τταρελέξατο ΛΑ ΘΡΗ.---ἶλ. β. verse 512.
+ “ΞΕ ηοῖΐδ, lib. vii. verse 659. See Dionys. ΗΑΔΙΊΙΟΑΕΝ. Antig. Rom, lib. i. p. 62,
{ Aniiq. Jud. lib. xviii. cap. 3. See, for this general practice, HEROD. lib. i. cap. 181.
§ Metam. lib. iii. fab. 3. || Justin. Hist. lib. ii, cap. 4. 4“ “ Divine Lega-
tion,” lib. ii. sect. 2.
Ty 9
270 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
“ Know thy vain self, or let their flatt’ry move,
- Who style thee son of cloud-compelling Jove.
How far unlike those chiefs of race divine !
How vast the diff’rence of their deeds and thine !’? *—Mr. Pope.
4. A fourth cause was a mere figure of speech common in the
eastern phraseology: which, to express the qualities of the subject,
called a prudent and powerful monarch + the son of Jupiter ; a violent
and inhuman ravager,t or an expert and able seaman, the son of
Neptune ; ὃ a sharper, a banker, or a large trader, the son of Mer-
cury ; a cultivator of the fine arts, the son of Apollo; a great warrior,
the son of Mars ; a beautiful woman, the daughter of Venus; and a
good physician, the offspring of Aisculapius. Thus Homer,
“In thirty sail the sparkling waves divide,
Which Podalirius and Machaon guide.
To these his skill their Parent-God imparts,
Divine professors of the healing arts.” ||—-Mr. Pope.
And that the poet meant no more than that they were excellent in
their profession, appears from his giving to all the Egyptians the
same original, where, speaking of their superior eminence in the art
of physic, he says,
“‘ These drugs, so friendly to the joys of life,
Bright Helen learn’d from Thone’s imperial wife ;
Who sway’d the sceptre, where prolific Nile
With various simples clothes the fat’ned svil—
From Peon sprung, their patron God imparts
To all the Pharian race his healing arts.” {— Mr. FENTON.
5. ‘The last cause. I shall mention were the dotages of judicial
Astrology. But whether giving to each of their Gods a Star over
which to preside was the cause or effect of this folly, may be disputed ;
because, I believe, it was sometimes one, and sometimes the other.
* Ψευδόμενοι δέ σε φασὶ Διὸς γόνον αἰγιόχοιο
Εἶναι, ἐπεὶ τσολλὸν κείνων ἐπιδεύεαι ἀνδρῶν
Οἱ Διὸς ἐξεγένοντο ἐπὶ τοροτέρων ἀνθρώπων .---ἴλ. ε. verse 635.
+ The words of Callimachus, in his Hymn to Jupiter, are so apposite to our purpose,
that the learned reader will not think them quoted impertinently :
Αὐτίκα χαλκῆας μὲν ὑδείομεν Ἡφαιστοῖο,
Τευχηστὰς δ᾽ ᾿ΑρῆοΞ" ἐπακτῆρας δὲ χιτώνης
᾿Αρτέμιδος" Φοίξου δὲ. λύρης εὖ εἰδότας οἴμους.
Ἔκ δὲ Διὸς βασιλῆες" ἐπεὶ Διὸς οὐδὲν ἀνάκτων
@cidrepov.— Verse 76, et seq.
t “Prestantissimos virtute, prudentia, viribus, Jovis jfilios, poete appellaverunt, ut
/®acum, et Minoa, et Sarpedona: Ferocissimos et immanes et alienos ab omni huma-
nitate tanquam e mari genitos, Neptuni filios dixerunt, Cyclopa, et Cereyona, et Sey-
rona, et Lestrygonas.””-— A. GELLIUS, lib. xv. cap. 21. § Thus in the Argonautic
expedition Typhis the pilot, and his mate Ergynus, were called the sons of Neptune.
And when these died in the voyage, they were succeeded by dnceus and Huphemus ;
and both of these, we are told, were the sons of Neptune, likewise. I chose to give
the reader this instance, because, from this figure of speech, thus qualifying men any
way distinguished in the Argonautic times, Sir Isaac Newton infers the low age of the
Grecian Deities.
|| τῶν αὖθ᾽ ἡγείσθην ᾿Ασκληπιοῦ δύο waide,
Ἰητῆρ᾽ ἀγαθὼ, Ποδαλείριος ἠδὲ Μαχάων"
Τοῖς δὲ τριήκοντα γλαφυραὶ νέες eorixdwyTo.—IX. β. verse 731.
Ἵ ᾿Ιητρὺς δὲ ἕκαστος ἐπιστάμενος wep) τσάντων
᾿Ανθρώπων" ἢ γὰρ Παιήονός εἰσι γενέθλης.---Οδ. 5, verse 231.
ΒΈΘΥ OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 2977
Yet. it gave frequent occasion to call an extraordinary person the son
of that God or Goddess under whose planet he was born.
Thus have I endeavoured to discover and lay open the true causes
of all that confusion which goes under the name of the History of the
heroic ages. Those false facts, therefore, and the mistaken conclu-
sion drawn from them by Sir Isaac Newton to support the identity of
Osiris and Sesostris, being detected, general tradition, which vouches
for their real diversity, is reinstated in its credit: whose testimony
likewise, as I have gone along, I have not neglected occasionally to
support by divers corroborating circumstances.
I might indeed have taken a very different route through this
Land of Fables, to the confutation of his hypothesis; by opposing
adventure to adventure, and genealogy to genealogy; and have
formed upon them, as others have done before me, a system of
chronology directly opposite to our illustrious Author’s. But this,
instead of relieving the reader, would only have put him in mind of
the old man’s complaint ; Incertior sum multo quam dudum. I have
therefore attempted a way of greater certainty, in an explanation of
the greater principles and practices of ancient Superstition ; of which,
their mythologic history was the fruits: And by this it appears that
all these pretended Facts, on which Sir Isaac Newton supports his
hypothesis of the identity of Osiris and Sesosrris, are mere Fables,
invented to confound all times and eras, and therefore most unhappily
chosen for one of the means of regulating and reforming the ancient
Chronology.
Ill.
But although I could have given no reasonable account of these
mistaken facts, from which Sir Isaac Newton infers the identity, I was
still able to prove the falshood of that supposed identity, by the
consequences that follow from 10 : not only by those which our great
Author would not, but by those which he would, venture to admit.
Both of which directly contradict scrrprurE and the NATURE OF
THINGS. So that, as before I proved the error of his conclusion
from the falshood of his premisses ; I now begin at the other end,
and shall prove the falshood of his premisses from the error of his
conclusion.
I. I have, in the third and fourth sections of this book, shewn at
large, from sacred Scripture, illustrated and confirmed by profane
Antiquity, that Egypt was a polite and powerful Empire at the egres-
sion of the Israelites. This is alone sufiicient to overthrow Sir Isaac
Newton’s whole system. But to make the truth still more evident,
it may be proper to take a particular, though short, view of the
necessary consequences which follow from the supposed identity
of Osiris and Sesostris. These may be divided into two parts ;
278 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
such as our great author hath ventured to own ; and such as, for their
apparent falshood, he was obliged to pass over in silence.
To begin with the latter. Those very histories on which Sir Isaac
builds his identity, tell us that Osiris and his wife and sister Isis were
the professed patron and patroness of nascent arts, the very instru-
ments of husbandry being invented in their time; that he first taught
the culture of the vine;* and abolished the bad habit, his savage
Subjects had of eating one another:+ and that she taught them to
sow corn ;{ and gave them their first system of laws.§—But if Osiris
were Sesostris, all these fine discoveries were made but two genera-
tions before the Trojan war, and full five hundred years after the
egression of the Israelites from Egypt: And then what are we to
think of the Bible? But the gross absurdity of these things hindered
our Author from receiving them into the consequences of his new
system: yet these standing on the same authority with the conse-
quences, he hath thought fit to receive, he was obliged to pass them
over in silence. But though he be silent, we should not. On the
contrary, we must insist that he hath transgressed the plainest rules
of fair reasoning, which required him, either to receive the conse-
quences he hath rejected, or to reject those which he hath received ;
or lastly, to shew, that they stand upon a different authority. But
he will do nothing of this ; he picks and chuses as he likes best, and,
what is not for his purpose, he leaves without notice. Diodorus says,
that Osiris abolished the-custom of human sacrifices; that he built
the city of Thebes ; that he regulated the worship of the Gods; and
conquered many nations. These things Sir Isaac, who takes Osiris
for Sesostris, readily admits. The same Historian says, that this
Osiris first cultivated the vine ; restrained his Subjects from eating
one another; and found out the arts of life; that his wife Isis
invented agriculture, and gave the first law to the Egyptians ; but all
this, Sir Isaac tacitly rejects. Yet if one part of the Sicilian’s
account be of better authority than the rest, it is that, which says,
Isis invented agriculture : for he expressly tells us, that so it was
found written on a large column, in hieroglyphic characters, half
consumed by time, then standing in the eity of Nysa in Arabia : ||
* Εὑρετὴν δ᾽ αὐτὸν γενέσθαι φασὶ τῆς ἀμπέλου wep) τὴν Νύσαν, καὶ τὴν ἐργασίαν τοῦ
ταὐτης καρποῦ “προσεπινοήσαντα, τορῶτον οἴνῳ χρήσασθαι καὶ διδάξαι τοὺς ἄλλους
ἀνθρώπους τήν τε φυτείαν τῆς ἀμπέλου, καὶ τὴν χρῆσιν τοῦ οἴνου, καὶ τὴν συγκομιδὴν
αὐτοῦ καὶ τήρησιν .--- το». Sic. lib. i. p. 10. t Πρῶτον μὲν γὰρ τσαῦσαι τῆς ἀλλη-
λοφαγίας τὸ τῶν ἀνθρώπων yévos—Idem, p. 9. 1 Εὑρούσης μὲν Ἴσιδος τόν τε τοῦ
τουροῦ καὶ τῆς κριθῆς καρπὸν, (φυόμενον μὲν ὡς ἔτυχε κατὰ τὴν χώραν μετὰ τῆς ἄλλης
βοτάνης, ἀγνοούμενον δὲ ὑπὸ τῶν ἀνθρώπων) τοῦ δὲ ᾽Οσίριδος ἐπινοησαμένου τὴν τούτων
κατεργασίαν τῶν Kaprav.—ldem, ibid. § Θεῖναι δέ φασι καὶ νόμους τὴν “low, Kal?
οὺς ἀλλήλοις διδόναι τοὺς ἀνθρώπους τὸ δίκαιον καὶ τῆς ἀθέσμου βίας καὶ ὕθρεως watoac-
θαι, διὰ τὸν ἀπὸ τῆς τιμωρίας pdé6ov.—ldem, ibid. || Ἐγὼ Ἴσις εἰμὶ ἡ βασίλισσα
waons χώρας.--- Ἐγώ εἶμι γυνὴ καὶ ἀδελφὴ Ὀσίριδος βασιλέως. “Eye εἰμι ἣ τυρώτη
καρπὸν ἀνθρώποις evpovou.—lIdem, p. 16,
SECT. V. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 979
and, without his telling, we are well assured, that her mysteries had
very early brought the knowledge of the fact to all the neighbouring
nations.
II. Amongst the consequences which the great Author hath
thought fit to admit; some are these, That cstruments of war ;
horses for military service; animal food ; the exact distribution of
property ; alphabetic letters; and the well peopling of Egypt ; were
all the product of the Sesostrian age.
1. Vulcan, he says, who lived even to the times of dite Trojan war,
invented Armour, and was, on that account, deified by the Egyptians.
His words are these. He [Vulcan] reigned there [in Cyprus and
Byblus] ¢ill a very great age, living to the times of the Trojan war,
and becoming exceeding rich*—And for assisting the Egyptians with
armour, it is probable, that he was deified by his friends the Egyp-
tians, by the name of Baal-Canaan or Vulcan: for Vulcan was cele-
brated principally by the Egyptians, and was a king, according to
Homer, and reigned in Lemnos ; and Cinyras was an inventor of arts,
and found out copper in Cyprus, and the smith’s hammer, and anvil,
and tongs and laver ; and employed workmen in making armour, and
other things of brass and iron, and was the only king celebrated in
history for working in metals, and was king of Lemnos, and the hus-
band of Venus; all which are the characters of Vulcan: and the
Egyptians about the time of the death of Cinyras, viz. in the reign of
their king Amenophis, builé a very sumptuous temple at Memphis to
Tulean.+ Here we have a Hero, living till the time of the Trojan
war, not only the inventor of arms, but likewise of the very tools em-
ployed in making them. That this was our Author’s meaning, is
plain from what he tells us of the Egyptians fighting with clubs in
the time of Sesostris ; { which certainly was for want of better wea-
pons: and still plainer, from what he tells of Vulcan’s beingsmade a
God ; which, certainly, was for a NEwINvention. If I should now
shew, by a formal enumeration of particulars, how all here said, con-
tradicts the BIBLE, the reader would think me disposed to trifle with
him. Instead of this, I shall but just observe, how ill it agrees with
Homer: who seems, indeed, to make Vulcan the Patron-God of the
Armourers, but, at the same time, makes both him, and the invention,
the product of a much earlier age. From the poem of the Trojan war
it appears that military weapons had been then of tried use; and
Vulcan, and his wife Venus, Deities of long standing. Nor can it be
objected that the poet hath here given us the picture of his own
times. He was a stricter observer of decorum: as may be seen
amongst other instances, from a celebrated one taken notice of by the
critics, that though, in his days, Cavalry were common, yet he brings
* Page 225. + Pp. 224, 225. { Page 215.
B80 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv,
none to the siege of Troy, because those times had not yet learnt
their use. Nor was he less knowing than exact ; for he was pos-
sessed of the Songs and Poems of his ancestors; in which he found
all the particulars of that famous expedition.* Now, if military wea-
pons, at the time of the Trojan war, had been long in use amongst
the Greeks, it is hardly possible they should have been just invented
in Egypt.
2. Our author makes Sesostris’s conquest of Libya the occasion of
furnishing Egypt with Horses. After the conquest of Libya (says he)
by which Egypt was furnished with horses, and furnished Solomon and
his friends, he prepared a fleet, &.+ The illustrious Writer is here
speaking of the original of those civil advantages, for which ancient
Egypt was so much celebrated. He had before, and afterwards, told
us his thoughts of their astronomy, navigation, letters, names, and
weapons of war. We cannot therefore but understand what he here
says, of the Libyan horses, to mean, that the conquest of that country
was the first occasion of Egypt’s abounding in Horse. But this
directly contradicts holy Scripture, which assures us that they
abounded in Horse long before. Their pursuit of the Israelites is
thus deseribed,—And Pharaoh made ready his chariot, and took his
people with him. And he took six hundred chosen chariots, and all
the chariots of Egypt, and captains over every one of them.—The
Egyptians pursued after them (all the horses and chariots of Pharaoh
and his horsemen and his army.)—And the Egyptians pursued after
them to the midst of the sea, even all Pharaoh’s horses, his chariots
and his horsemen.t Sir Isaac§ seems to have been aware of this
evidence against him, and endeavours to turn it on the side of his
hypothesis. In the days of Mosss (says he) all the chariots of
Legypt, with which Pharaoh pursued Israel, WERE BUT SIX HUNDRED.
Hezod. xiv. 7. This is a strange mistake. The six hundred, men-
tioned in the place quoted, are expresly said to be the chosen chariots,
that is, the king’s guard; for over and above these, all the chariots
of Egypt, an indefinite number, were in the pursuit. Besides, the
number of horses is not to be estimated from the chariots, because
there was an army of horsemen likewise in this expedition.
However, by Sir Isaac’s own confession it appears, that Egypt
abounded with Horse much earlier than the time he here assigns. For
the vast number of Philistim Horse brought into the field, in the second
year of the reign of Saul, in an army consisting of thirty thousand
chariots and six thousand horsemen, came all, in our author’s opinion,
from Egypt. The Canaanites (says he) had their Horses from
Egypt ; and—from the great army of the Philistims against Saul, and
ad See note HHHH, at the end of this book. + Page 215. 1 Exod. xiv.
6, 4) 9, 28. § Page 167.
SECT. V. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 981
the great number of their Horses, I seem to gather that the shepherds
had newly relinquished Egypt, and joined them.*—Now if they had
such plenty of horse in the time of Saul, how was it that they were
first furnished from Libya in the time of Sesac?
But another circumstance in sacred History will shew us, that
Egypt, which supplied Canaan, abounded in Horse still much earlier.
In the law of Moses, we fiud this prohibition, personally directed to
their future King: he shall not multiply horses to himself, nor cause
the people to return to EGYPT, TO THE END THAT HE SHOULD MUL-
TIPLY HORSES: forasmuch as the Lord hath said unto you, Ye shall
henceforth return no more that way.t Now the reason, here given,
being to prevent all commerce with Egypt, we must conclude, if it
appear that Egypt, at this time, supplied other nations with horses,
that the law extended to their Judges as well as Kings. But they
did supply other nations. For we find the confederate Canaanites
(who, by Sir Isaac’s confession, had their horses from Egypt) warring
against Joshua, they and all their hosts with them, much people, even
as the sand that is upon the sea-shore in multitude, with Horses and
chariots very many.t The law therefore did certainly respect the
Judges. And the reasoning is confirmed by fact. For Joshua, when
he had defeated these confederate hosts, houghed their Horses and
burnt their chariots with fire,§ according to the commandment of the
Lord : observing it in the same rigorous manner in which it was
obeyed by their Kings, to whom the law was personally addressed :
For thus Ahab destroyed the horses and chariots of Benhadad.|| So
that I now conclude the other way from this Law, that a general
traffic with Egypt for Horses was very common in the times of Moses
and Joshua. Consequently Egypt was not furnished with Horses
from Libya in the time of Sir Isaac Newton’s Sesostris.
But it may give strength to this argument, as well as light to the
sacred Text, to inquire more particularly into the reasons of this
PROHIBITION ; which we shall find so weighty and various as to
appear worthy of its Author, and accommodated only to a Law of
divine original.
1. The first reason (which was expresly delivered with the Law)
is, properly, RELIGIous. He [the King], says the Law, shall not
multiply Horses to himself, nor cause the people to return to Egypt, to
the end that he should multiply Horses: forasmuch as the Lord hath
said unto you, Ye shall henceforth return no more that way ; i. 6. He
should not establish a body of Cavalry, because this could not be
effected without sending into Egypt, with which people the Lord-had
* Page 167. + Deut. xvii. 16. t Joshua xi. 4. § Verse 9.
|| 1 Kings xx. 21,
282 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
forbidden any communication, as, of all foreign commerce, that was
the most dangerous to true Religion.*
When Solomon had violated this Law, and multiplied Horses to
such excess that, we are told, he had forty thousand stalls of Horses
for his chariots, and twelve thousand Horsemen,t+ it was soon
attended with those fatal consequences which the Law had foretold.
For this wisest of Kings having likewise, in violation of another Law
of Moses, married Pharaoh’s daughter,t (the early fruits of this com-
merce) and then, by a repetition of the same crime, but a transgres-
sion of another law, had espoused more strange women ; ὃ they first
of all, in defiance of a fourth Law, persuaded him to build them idol
Temples for their use ; and afterwards, against a fifth Law, still more
fundamental, brought him to erect other Temples for his own.||
Now the original of all this mischief was the forbidden traffic with
Egypt for Horses: For thither, we are told, the agents of Solomon
were sent to mount his Cavalry. And Solomon gathered chariots and
horsemen: and he had a thousand and four hundred chariots, and
twelve thousand horsemen, which he placed in the chariot-cities, and
with the king at Jerusalem—And he had Horses brought out of
egypt, and linen-yarn : the king’s merchants received the linen-yarn
at a price. And they fetcht up and brought forth out of Egypt a
chariot for six hundred shekels of silver, and an Horse for an hundred
and fifty. Nay, this great King even turned factor for the neigh-
bouring monarchs. And so brought they out Horses for all the kings
of the Hittites, and for the kings of Syria by their means.** This
opprobrious commerce was kept up by his Successors ; and attended
with the same pernicious consequences. Isaiah, with his usual
majesty, denounces the mischiefs of this traffic; and foretels that one
of the good effects of leaving it, would be the forsaking their idol-
atries. Wo to them that go down to Egypt for help, and stay on
Horses and trust in chariots, because they are many; and in
HORSEMEN, Jecause they are very strong: but they look not unto the
holy one of Israel, neither seek the Lord.—For thus hath the Lord
spoken unto me: Like as the lion, and the young lion, roaring on his
prey, when a multitude of shepherds is called forth against him, he
will not be afraid of their voice, nor abate himself for the noise
of them: so shall the Lord of Hosts come down to fight for mount
Zion, and for the hill thereof—Turn ye unto him from whom the chil-
dren of Israel have deeply revolted. For in that day every man shall
east away his idols of silver, and his idols of gold, which your own
hands have made unto you for a sin.t+
; * See the next section. 1 Kings iv. 26. 11 Kings iii. 1. δ 1 Kings
sells \| Verses 7, 8. q 2 Chron, i. 16, 17. #8: Viersey 17.
tt Isaiah xxxi. 1, 4, 6, 7.
SECT. Vv. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 933
2. The second reason against multiplying Horses 1 take to have
been properly poxrricay. The Israelites, separated by Gop for his
peculiar People, under his government as King, must needs have been
designed for the proprietors of one certain country. Accordingly the
land of Canaan, the possession of the seven nations, was marked out
for their proper inheritance. Within these limits they were to be
confined ; it being foreign to the nature of their Institution to make
conquests, or to extend their dominion. But the expulsion of the
seven nations being, as we shall see presently, to be effected by the
extraordinary assistance of their KING, JEHOVAH, their successes
must, of course, be full and rapid. But nothing is so impatient of
bounds as a multitude flesht with easy victories: the projects of such
a people are always going on from conquest to conquest ; as appears
from the Mahometan Arabs, under the same circumstances, led out to
conquest by a false Prophet, as the Israelites by a ¢rue. Now to
defeat this so natural a disposition, in a nation not designed for
Empire, a Law is given against MULTIPLYING HORSES ; than which
nothing can be conceived more effectual. The Country that confined
them, was rocky and mountainous, and therefore unfit for the breed
and sustentation of horse. Telemachus is commended for giving this
reason for refusing the horses of Menelaus :
Haud male Telemachus, proles patientis Ulixei ;
Non est aptus equis Ithace locus, ut neque plunis
Porrectus spatiis, nec multe prodigus herba.*
Besides, when they had once gotten possession of these mountains,
they had little need of horse to preserve their conquest; as all
skilled in military matters very well understand.t The Israelites
therefore, had they been either wise or pious, would soon have found
that their true strength, as well political as religious, lay in Infantry :
As that of Egypt, for a contrary reason, was in their Cavalry. Hence
that people, who well understood their advantages, so industriously
propagated the breed of Horses, as the surest defence of their territo-
ries. There is a remarkable passage, in the history of these times, to
support what I here advance. When Benhadad, the gentile king of
Syria, whose forces consisted of chariots and horsemen, had warred
with ill success against the king of Israel, the Ministers, in a council
of war, delivered their advice to him in these terms: Their Gods are
Gods of the u1uus, therefore they were stronger than we: but let us
fight against them in the Puan, and surely we shall be stronger than
they.—And he hearkened unto their voice, and did so.t From this
passage I collect, 1. That the army of Israel, consisting all of
Infantry, had chosen the situation of the hills; and this with proper
* HORATIUS. + See note ILIJ, at the end of this book. { 1 Kings xx.
23, et seq.
284 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
military skill. 2. That their constant success in such a disposition of
their forces occasioned this advice of the Ministers of Benhadad.
These men, possessed with the general notion of local tutelary
Deities, finding the arms of Israel always successful on the hills, took
it for the more eminent manifestation of the power of their Gods.
Their Gods, say they, are Gods of the hills. Their superstition dic-
tated the first part of their advice; and their skill in war, the second,
—let us fight against them in the plain. The operations of the war
had been hitherto most absurd: they had attacked an army of
Infantry with one of Cavalry, on hills and in defiles. :
But this want of Horse (which kind of military force neither the
product of their country could well support, nor the defence of it
need) would effectually prevent any attempt of extending their domi-
nions either into the Lesser Asia, Mesopotamia, or Egypt. All which
neighbouring countries being stretched out into large and extended
plains, could not be safely invaded without a numerous Cavalry. In
this view, therefore, the wisdom of the Law can never be sufficiently
admired. -
3. But the third reason of the prohibition was evidently to afford a
lasting MANIFESTATION OF THAT EXTRAORDINARY PROVIDENCE by
which the Israelites were conducted, in taking possession of the land
of Canaan. I have shewn that, when once settled, they might very
well defend the possession without the help of Cavalry: But to con-
quer it without Cavalry, and from a warlike people abounding in -
Horse, was more than a raw unpractised Infantry could ever have per-
formed alone. No more need be said to convince military men of the
extreme difference of the two cases. To others it may be proper to
observe, ἐς
1. That in the invasion of a country, the invaded may chuse their
ground ; and as it is their interest to avoid coming to a decisive
action, so, being amidst their own native stores and provisions, they
have it in their power to decline it. On the contrary, the invader
must attack his enemies wherever he finds them posted. For, by
reason of the scantiness and uncertainty of supplies in an enemy’s
country, he has not, for the most part, time to draw them, by mili-
tary stratagems, from their advantages. We find this verified in the
history of Benhadad, mentioned above. He had invaded Israel ; but
this people disposing of their Infantry with soldier-like address, he
was forced to fight them on the Az//s, where only they were to be met
with. After many unsuccessful engagements, his Ministers proposed
a new plan of operation ; to attack the enemy in the plains. And
truly the advice was good: but how to put it in execution was the
question ; for they being the assailants, the Israelites were masters of
their ground. So that, after all, there was no other way of bringing
SECT. V. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 985
them into the plains but by beating them from the hills. And there
they must have stuck, till famine and desertion had ended the quar-
rel. In this exigence, their blasphemy against the God of Israel
enabled them to put their counsels, against him, in execution. They
fancied, according to the superstition of that time, and so gave out,
that he was God of the hills, but not of the valleys. His omnipotence
being thus disputed, He placed his people in the plains ; and sent his
Prophet to predict the coming vengeance on his enemies. And there
came a man of Gon, and spake unto the king of Israel, and said, Thus
saith the Lord, Because the Syrians have said, the Lord is God of the
hills, but he is not God of the valleys ; therefore will I deliver all this
great multitude into thine hand, and ye shall know that I am the
Lord.*
2. Secondly, we may observe, that the possessors of mountainous
regions may so dispose their Fortresses, with which they cover their
country, as to make an invader’s Cavalry absolutely useless ; and con-
sequently to have no occasion for any of their own. But the invaders
of such a place where Cavalry is in use, and consequently the
defences disposed in a contrary manner, so as best to favour the ope-
rations of Horse, the invaders, I say, go to certain destruction without
a body of Horse to support their Infantry, This then being the very
situation of affairs when the Israelites invaded Canaan, and conquered
it, (for till then they had not begun to transgress the Law against
Cavalry) I conclude that they must have been MIRACULOUSLY
assisted. The Arabians, in a like expedition, thought it so extraor-
dinary a thing to conquer without Horse, that Mahomet made it a
law, when this happened, for the spoils not to be divided according to
the stated rule, but for all to go to the Prophet himself, as a deodand
or a gift from God alone.t Yet Mahomet never pretended to make
his conquests without Horse, but used them on every occasion of need.
To return, we see then how little reason Sir Isaac Newton had for
saying that Sesostris’s conquest of Libya was the occasion of Egypt’s
being furnished with horse, so as to supply the neighbouring coun-
tries. But the instance was particularly ill chosen: for Sesostris,
whom he makes the author of this benefit to Egypt, did, by his filling
the country with canals, defeat the chief use and service of Cavalry ;
with which, till this time, Egypt had abounded; but which from
henceforth we hear no move of.t
* 1 Kings xx. 28. + Et id, quod concessit in predam Deus legato suo ex illis :
Non impulistis super illud ullos equos, neque camelos [i. e. non acquisistis illud ope
equorum aut camelorum] ; sed Deus prevalere facit legatos swos, super quem vult : nam
Deus est super omnem rem potens. — Surat. 59, Alcor. verse 6, t Νοστήσας δὲ 6
Σέσωστρις ἐς τὴν Αἴγυπτον, καὶ-τὰς διώρυχα: τὰς νῦν ἐοῦσας ἐν Αἰγύπτῳ, wdous οὗτοι
a ναγκαζόμενοι ὥρυσσον" ἐποίεόν τε οὐκ ἑκόντες Αἴγυπτον, τοπρὶν ἐοῦσαν ἱππϑσίμην, καὶ
ἁ μαξευομένην τσᾶσαν, ἐνδεᾶ τούτων" ἀπὸ γὰρ τούτου τοῦ χρόνου Αἴγυπτος ἐοῦσα wedias
τυᾶσα, ἄνιππος καὶ ἀναμάξευτος γέγονε.-- ΠΕΠΟΡΟΤῚ Historia, lib. ii. capal08.
286 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
3. Again, in consequence of the same system, our great author
seems to think that animal food was not customary amongst the
Egyptians till about this time. The Egyptians (says -he) originally
lived on the fruits of the earth, and fared hardly, and abstained frem
animals, and THEREFORE abominated shepherds: Menes [the third
from Sesostris] taught them to adorn their beds and tables with rich
Surniture and carpets, and brought in amongst them a sumptuous,
delicious, and voluptuous way of life.* Now, whoever brought in the
eating of flesh, and a voluptuous life, did it (as we are assured from
Scripture) before the time of Joseph. I have proved, in my account
of their Physicians as delivered in the Bible, that they were then a
luxurious people.t From the dream of Pharaoh’s baker, compared
with Joseph’s interpretation,t it appears, they eat animal food ; and,
from the story of Joseph’s entertainment of his brethren, it appears,
that their enmity to shepherds was not occasioned by these Hebrews’
eating animal food, which, Sir Isaac says, the Egyptians abstained
from. And he said to the ruler of his house, Bring these men home,
and suay, and make ready : for these men shall dine with me at noon.
And the man did as Joseph bade: and the man brought the men into
Joseph’s house—and they set on for him by himself, and for them by
themselves, and for the Egyptians, which did eat with him, by them-
selves, because the Egyptians might not eat bread with the Hebrews,
Sor that is an abomination to the Egyptians.—And he took and sent
messes unto them from before him. Here, we see the common provi-
sion for their entertainment was animal food. And no one can doubt
whether Joseph conformed to the Egyptian diet. He sat single out
of state, with regard to the Egyptians ; the Egyptians sat apart, with
regard to the Shepherds; and Both were supplied from the
Governor’s table, which was furnished from the Steward’s slaughter-
house. The truth of this is farther seen from the murmuring of the
Israelites in the wilderness, when they said, Would to God we had
died by the hand of the Lord in the land of Egypt, when we sat by
the FLESH-POTS, and when we did eat bread to the full.|| Now we
can scarce suppose the Egyptians would permit their slaves, whom
they kept in so hard oppression, to riot in flesh-pots, while, as Sir
Isaac supposes, they themselves fared hardly and abstained from
Animals.
4, Again, he supposes, that the exact division of the land of Egypt
* Page 241. + See p. 157, and following, of this volume. t ‘* And the
chief baker said unto Joseph, I also was in my dream, and behold I had three white
baskets on my head, and in the uppermost basket there was of all manner of BaKkE-
MEATS for Pharaoh, and the birds did eat them out of the basket.—And Joseph
answered and said—The three baskets are three days. Yet within three days shall
Pharaoh lift up thy head from off thee, and shall hang thee on a tree; and the birds
shall eat thy flesh from off thee.’’—Gen. xl. 16, et seq. § Gen. xliii. 16, 17, 32,
34. || Exod. xvi. 3.
SECT. V. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 987
into Property was first made in the time of Sesostris. Sesostris (says
he) upon his returning home, divided Egypt by measure amongst the
Egyptians ; and this gave a beginning to surveying and geometry.*
And in another place, he brings down the original of geometry still
lower ; even as late as Meeris, the fifth from Sesostris. Meris (says
he)—for preserving the division of Egypt into equal shares amongst
the soldiers—wrote a book of surveying, which gave a beginning to
geometry.+ Let the reader now consider, whether it be possible
to reconcile this with the following account of Joseph’s administration.
And Joseph bought all the land of Egypt for Pharaoh ; for the Egyp-
tians sold EVERY MAN HIS FIELD, because the famine prevailed over
them: so the land became Pharaoh’s. And as for the people, he
removed them to cities from one end of the borders of Egypt, even to
the other end thereof. Only the land of the Priests bought he not ;
Sor the Priests had a portion assigned them of Pharaoh, and did eat
their portion which Pharaoh gave them; therefore they sold not their
lands. Then Joseph said unto the people, Behold I have bought you
this day, and your land for Pharaoh : lo here is the seed for you, and
ye shall sow the land. And it shall come to pass, in the increase, that
you shall give the fifth part unto Pharaoh, and four parts shall be
your own, for seed of the field, and for your food, and for them of
your own housholds, and for food for your little ones. And Joseph
made it a law over the land of Egypt unto this day, that Pharaoh
should have the fifth part ; except the land of the Priests only, which
became not Pharaoh’s.t Were we have the description of a country
very exactly set out and settled in private property. It would afford
room for variety of reflexions: I shall confine myself to the following.
If private property had not been, at this time, established with the
utmost order and exactness ; what occasion had Joseph to recur to
that troublesome expedient of transplanting the People, reciprocally,
from one end of Egypt to the other? His purpose in it is evident:
it was to secure Pharaoh in his new property, by defeating the ill
effects of that fondness which people naturally have to an old paternal
inheritance. But what fondness have men for one spot, rather than
another, of lands lying in common, or but newly appropriated ?
Were the Egyptians at this time, as Sir Isaac Newton seems to sup-
pose, in the state of the unsettled Nomades, they would have gone
from one end of Egypt to the other, without Joseph’s sending ; and
without the least regret for any thing they had left behind.
But without weakening the great man’s conjecture by Scripture-
history, How does it appear from the simple fact of Sesostris’s
dividing the large champion country into square fields, by cross-cut
canals, that this was a dividing Egypt by measure, and giving a begin-
* Page 218. + Page 248. t Gen xlvii. 20, et seq.
288 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK ly.
ning to surveying and geometry ? If we examine the cause and the
effects of that improvement, we shall find that neither one nor the
other part of his conclusion can be deduced from it. The cause of
making these canals was evidently to drain the swampy marshes of
that vast extended level; and to render the whole labourable.* But
a work of this kind is never projected till a people begin to want
room. And they never want room till private property hath been
well established; and the necessaries of life, by the advancement of
civil arts, are become greatly increased. As to the effects; Ground,
once divided by such boundaries, was in no danger of a change of
land-marks ; and consequently had small occasion for future surveys.
So that had not the Egyptians found out geometry before this new
division, ’tis probable they had never found it out at all. The most
likely cause, therefore, to be assigned for this invention, was the
necessity of frequent surveys, while the annual overflowings of the
Nile were always obliterating such land-marks as were not, like those
cross-cut canals, wrought deep into the soil. But these put a total,
end to that inconvenience. Indeed, Herodotus seems to give it as his
opinion, that geometry had its rise from this improvement of Sesos-
tris.¢ But we are to remember what hath been said of the incredible
Antiquity which the ancient Greek writers, and particularly Aristotle, t
assigned to this Hero: the natural consequence of the Egyptians’
having confounded the ages and actions, though never the persons, of
Osiris and Sesostris.
5. The next inference this illustrious Writer makes from his system
is, that letters were unknown in Egypt till the time of David. When
the Edomites (says he) fled from David with their young hing Hadad
into Egypt, it is probable that they carried thither also the use of
letters: for leiters were then in use amongst the posterity of Abra-
ham—and there is no instance of letters, for writing down sounds,
being in use before the days of David in any other nation besides the
posterity of Abraham. The Egyptians ascribed this invention to Thoth
the secretary of Osiris ; and therefore letters began to be in use in
Egypt in the days of Thoth, that is, a little after the flight of the
Edomites from David, or about the time that Cadmus brought them
into Europe.§ It appears from the two stone-tables of the Law, and
from the engravings on Aaron’s breast-plate, that letters were in
common use amongst the Israelites at the time of their egression
from Egypt. Now supposing alphabetic writing to be amongst the
peculiar advantages of the chosen people, was it not more likely that
the Egyptians should learn it of them during their long abode in that
τω See note KKKK, at the end of this book. + Δοκέοι δέ μοι ἐνθεῦτεν γεωμετρίη
εὑρεθεῖσα, ἐς τὴν Ἑλλάδα ἐπανελθεῖν.---ΠΕκοΡοτυϑ, lib. ii. cap. 109. t See pp.
256—258. $ Page 209,
SECT. V. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 989
country, than from the fugitive Hdomites, if they had indeed carried thi-
ther (which however is a mere conjecture) the use of letters? But when
we consider that alphabetic writing was introduced amongst the chosen
people some time between the age of Jacob and that of Moses, it
seems most probable that they learnt it of the Egyptians. But, fora full
confutation of this fancy, and of the arguments that support it, I am
content to refer the reader to what I have occasionally observed, though
to other purposes, in my discourse of the Egyptian hieroglyphics.*
6. Lastly, he observes, that Egypt was so thinly peopled before
the birth of Moses, that Pharaoh said of the Israelites, ““ Behold the
people of the children of Israel are more and mightier than we :”’
and that to prevent their multiplying, and growing too strong, he
caused their male children to be drowned.t Yet this country, so
thinly peopled at the birth of Moses, was, we find from Scripture, so
vastly populous, by the time Moses was sent upon his mission, that it
could keep in slavery six hundred thousand men besides children ;{
at a time, when they were most powerfully instigated to recover their
liberty ; which yet, after all, they were unable to effect but by the
frequent desolation of the hand of Gop upon their insolent and cruel
masters. And is this to be reconciled with Sir Isaac’s notion of their
preceding thinness? But he likewise supports himself on Scripture.
Egypt was so thinly peopled—that Pharaoh said—Behold the people
of the children of Israel are more and mightier than we. Strange
interpretation! The Scripture relation of the matter is in these
words: And Pharaoh said unto his people, Behold the people of the
children of Israel are more and mightier than we. Come on, let us
deal wisely with them: lest they multiply, and it come to pass, that
when there falleth out any war, they join also unto our enemies, and
Jight against us, and so get them up out of the land. Therefore they did
set over them Taskmasters, to afflict them with their burdens.—But the
more they afflicted them, the more they grew and multiplied. By the
whole turn of this relation it appears, that the more and mightier
signify only more prolific and healthy. And that was in truth the
case. The Egyptians of this time, as we” have shewn,|| were very
luxurious: While the manners of the Israelites concurred with their
condition to render them hardy and fruitful, by an abstemious and
laborious course of life. On this account the king expresses his
fear. But of what? certainly not that they should subdue their
masters ; but that they should escape out of bondage : which, even
to the very moment of their egression, was the sole object of the
Egyptian’s fear.—Lest (says he) they multiply ; and it come to pass,
that, when there falleth out any war, they join also unto our enemies,
* See p. 172, et seq. + Page 186. 1 Exod. xii. 37. § Exod. i. 9,
et seq. || See p. 157, et seq.
VOL. II. υ
200 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
and fight against us, and sO GET THEM UP OUT OF THE LAND.
This was a reasonable apprehension: for Egypt was in every age
subject to the incursions of that fierce and barbarous people the
Arabians, on that very side which the Israelites inhabited: who, pos-
sessing their own District, unmixed with Egyptians, had the keys of the
country in their hands, to admit or exclude an invader at their plea-
sure. A circumstance which would make the smallest province
formidable to the most powerful kingdom. To prevent then so
probable a danger, their taskmasters are ordered to increase their
oppressions ; and they groan under them without power to resist, till
set free by the all-powerful hand of Gop.
Thus we see how Sir Isaac Newton’s system stands with regard to
SACRED ANTIQUITY. What is still worse, it is not only repugnant to
the Bible, but even to ITSELF.
III. We have observed, that, by the casual confounding of the
proper actions of Osiris and Sesostris with one another, each came to
be, at the same time, the INVENTOR, and the PERFECTER, of the
arts of life. This, which might have led our Author, the most pene-
trating of all writers, to the discovery of the ancient error in their
history, served only to confirm him in his own; as placing the inven-
tion of civil arts low enough for the support of his general Chrono-
logy. However, it is very certain, that the making their invention
and perfection the product of the same age is directly contrary to the
very NATURE OF THINGS. Which if any one doubt, let him examine
the general history of mankind ; where he will see that the advances,
from an emerging barbarity, through civil policy, to refined arts and
polished manners, when not given them, ready fitted to their hands,
by neighbouring nations forward to impart them, have been ever the
slow and gradual progress of many and successive ages. Yet these,
our illustrious Author (in consequence of the supposed identity of his
two Heroes) makes to spring up, to flourish, and to come to their
perfection, all within the compass of one single reign. Or rather,
which is still more intolerable, he makes this extraordinary age of
Sesostris to be distinguished from all others by an inseparable mixture
of savage and polished manners. Which is so unnatural, so incre-
dible, so impossible a circumstance, that, were there only this to
oppose against his system, it would be a sufficient demonstration of
its falshood.
To shew then, that Sir Isaac Newton, by fairly and honestly taking
in these consequences of his system, hath indeed subjected it to this
disgrace, I shall give two instances. The one taken from his account
of the state of War, the other of the state of Architecture, during
this period.
1. Our Author having made the Egyptian Hercules to be Sesostris,
SECT. y. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 991
is forced to own that the war in Libya was carried on with clubs.
After these things, he [Hercules or Sesostris] invaded Libya, and
Sought the Africans with clubs, and thence is painted with a club in
his hand. Were, the great Writer hath given us the very picture of
the Iroquosian or Huron Savages warring with a neighbouring tribe.
And without doubt intended it for such a representation ; as appears,
first, from his immediately adding these words of Hyginus: Afri et
Egyptii primum fustibus dimicaverunt, postea Belus Neptuni filius
gladio belligeratus est, unde bellum dictum est. p.215. For we are to
observe that the title of the chapter, in which these words are found,
is, quis quid invenerit :* and secondly, from his supposing Vulcan
(whom he makes to live at this time) the inventor of military wea-
pons. Yet this, according to the great Author, was after Sesostris’s
conquest of the Troglodytes and Ethiopians: it was after his Father’s
building a fleet on the Red sea, with which he coasted Arabia Felix ;
went into the Persian Gulph, and penetrated even into India: [pp. 214,
215.] and but a little before Sesostris’s great expedition for the con-
quest of the habitable world. At which time we see him set out with
the most splendid retinue of a Court, and the most dreadful appara-
tus of War ; we find him defeat great armies; subdue mighty king-
doms (amongst the rest Judea, where all kind of military arms
offensive and defensive had been in use for many ages) ; people large
cities ; and leave behind him many stately monuments of his power
and magnificence.
2. Thus again, Sir Isaac tells us, that Tosorthrus or A’sculapius,
an Egyptian of the time of Sesostris, discovered the art of building
with square stones.t Yet his contemporary, Sesostris, he tells us,
divided Egypt into 36 nomes or counties, and dug a canal from the
Nile, to the head city of every nome ; and with the earth dug out of it,
he caused the ground of the city to be raised higher, and built a temple
tn every city for the worship of the nome ; §c. p. 218. And soon after,
Amenophis, the third from him, built Memphis; and ordered the worship
of the Gods of Egypt ; and built a palace at Abydus, and the Memno-
nia at This and Susa, and the magnificent temple of Vulcan in Memphis.t
Now, in this odd mixture of barbarity and politeness, strength and
impotence, riches and poverty, there is such an inconsistency in the
character of ages, as shews it to be the mere invention of professed
fabulists, whose known talent it is to
“ Make former times shake hands with latter,
And that which was before come after ; ”’
though composed of tales so ill concerted, and contradictory, as shews,
* Fab. cclxxiv. +t The building with square stones (says he) being found out by
Tosorthrus, the Hsculapius of Egypt. Page 247, t See note LLLL, at the end
of this book.
υ 2
292 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
they wroté upon no consistent plan, but each as his own temporary
views and occasions required.
When I entered on a confutation of Sir Isaac Newton’s Egyptian
Chronology (for with that only I have here to do), I was willing for
the greater satisfaction of the reader to set his arguments for the
identity of Osiris and Sesostris, on which that Chronology was
founded, in the strongest and clearest light. On this account I took
them as I found them collected, ranged in order, and set together in
one view, with the greatest advantage of representation, by the very
worthy and learned Master of the Charter-house, in a professed
apology for our great Philosopher. But this liberty the learned
writer hath been pleased to criticise in the Latin edition* of the tracts
to which that apology was prefixed—‘ I am not ignorant” (says het)
“that the author of The Divine Legation supposing it, some how or
other, to concern Moses’s divine mission, to prove that Osiris was not
the same with Sesostris, hath lately turned all that is here said into
ridicule, by a comparison made between the fabulous ARTHUR and
Wiu1sAM the Norman; who, he says, may be made one by as good
reasons (though they have scarce any thing alike or in common with
one another) as those which we have brought to confound Osiris with
Sesostris: and on this point he draws out a disputation through
seventy pages and upwards; in which, however, he neither denies nor
confutes, but only laughs at what we have here said of Sesostris. It
is true indeed that some other of Newton’s assertions he does oppose ;
such as those concerning the late invention of arts, arms, and instru-
ments by some certain king; and in this part of the argument he gets
the better. For that these things were found out by the Egyptians
long before the age of Sesostris, holy Writ commands us to believe :
but whether found out by any of their kings, is not so certain.
However, these were matters we never touched upon, as relating
nothing to our purpose; nor do they yet induce us to recede from
that conclusion of the famous Newton, that Sesac was Sesostris,
Osiris, and Bacchus. But the cause being now brought before the
* De veris Annis Ὁ. N. Jesus Christi natali et emortuali Dissertationes due Chro-
nologice. + “Non nescimus nuperrime accidisse, ut Vir ingenio et eruditione
prestans, quum ratus sit ad divinum legationem Mosis demonstrandum aliquo modo
pertinere, ut probetur Osiris non esse idem cum Sesostri, omnia huc allata in lusum
jocumque verterit, instituta comparatione Arthuri illius fabulosi cum Wilhelmo Nor-
manno, quos «qué bonis rationibus in unum hominem conflari posse ait (quamvis nihil
fere habeant inter se commune aut simile) ac nos Osirin cum Sesostri confundimus. Et
de hac re disputationem in 70 paginas et ultra producit. In qua tamen hee nostra de
Sesostri neque negat, neque refellit, sed irridet. Alia:vero quedam Newtoni dicta de
sero inventis ab aliquo rege artibus, armis, instrumentis oppugnat, et ea quidem parte
cause vincit. Nam ut ista longe ante Sesostiis etatem apud Algyptios reperta sint,
Scriptura sacra jubet credere ; ab ullo unquam regum inventa esse haud ita certum.
Sed ea prius non attigimus, ut que nihil ad propositum nostrum attinent, neque nunc
nos movent, ut pedem retrahamus ab ista Cl. Newtoni conclusione Sesacum, Sesostrim,
Osirin et Bacchum fuisse. Lite jam contestata judicent eruditi.”’—In Dedic. pp. xii. xiii.
SECT. ν. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 293
Public, let the learned determine of it.’ Thus far this candid and
ingenuous writer.
He says, the-author of The Divine Legation supposes that it some
how or other concerns Moses’s divine mission to prove Osiris not the
same with Sesostris ; which seems to imply that this learned person
doth not see How it concerns it. And yet afterwards he owns, that
Scripture (meaning the writings of Moses) will not allow us to believe
with Sir Isaac, that the invention of arts, arms, and instruments, was
so late as the time of Sesostris. Now it follows (as I have shewn) by
certain consequence, that if Osiris and Sesostris were one and the
same, then the invention of arts was as late as the time of Sesostris.
But this contradicting Scripture or the writings of Moses, as the
learned person himself confesseth, the reader sees plainly, How τέ
concerns Moses’s mission to prove Osiris not the same with Sesostris.
The learned writer, speaking of the comparison I had made
between Arthur and William the Norman, says, they have scarce any
thing alike or in common with one another. (had brought together
thirteen circumstances (the very number which the learned writer
thinks sufficient to establish the identity of Osiris and Sesostris) in
which they perfectly agree. [am persuaded he does not suspect me
of falsifying their history. He must mean therefore, that ¢hirteen in
my comparison, prove nothing, which, in his, prove every thing.
He goes on,—in a disputation of seventy pages and upwards, the
author of The Divine Legation neither denies nor confutes, but only
laughs at what we have said of Sesostris. What is it the learned
writer hath said of Sesostris? Is it not this? That between his
history and that of Osiris there are many strokes of resemblance :
From whence he infers (with Sir Isaac) that these two Heroes were
one and the same. Now if he means, I have neither denied nor con-
futed this resemblance, he says true. J had no such design. It is
too well marked by Antiquity to be denied. Neither, let me add, did
I laugh at it. What I laughed at (if my bringing a similar case is to
be so called) was his inference from this resemblance, that therefore
Osiris and Sesostris were one and the same. But then too I did
more than lavgh : I both denied and confuted it. First I denied it,
by shewing that this resemblance might really be, though Osiris and
Sesostris were two different men, as appeared by an equal resemblance
in the actions of two different men, the British Arthur and William
the Norman. But as the general history of ancient Egypt would not
’ suffer us to believe all that the Greek writers have said of this resem-
blance, I then explained the causes which occasioned their mistaken
accounts of the two persons, from whence so perfect a resemblance
had arisen. Secondly, I confuted what the learned person had said
of Sesostris, by shewing, from the concurrent testimony of Antiquity, —
294 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
and from several internal arguments deducible from that testimony,
that Osiris and Sesostris were in fact two different persons, living im
two very distant ages.
The learned writer proceeds,—I¢ is true indeed that some other of
Newton’s assertions he does oppose ; such as those concerning the late
invention of arts, arms, and instruments ; and in this part of the argu-
ment he gets the better. But if I have the better here, it is past dis-
pute I overthrow the whole hypothesis of the identity of Osiris and
Sesostris. For, as to the resemblance, which Antiquity hath given
them, that, considered singly when the pretended late invention of
arts hath been proved a mistake, will indeed deserve only to be
laughed at. But were it, as Sir Isaac Newton endeavoured to prove,
that the invention of arts was no earlier than the time of Sesostris or
Sesac, there is then indeed an end of the ancient Osiris of Egypt ;
and the Hero, so much boasted of by that people, can be no other
than the Sesostris of this author. For the very foundation of the
existence of the ancient Osiris was his civilizing Egypt, and teaching
them the Arts of life: But if this were done by Sesostris, or in his
reign, then is HE the true Osiris of Egypt. As, on the contrary, were
the invention of arts as early as ScripTURE-HISTORY represents it,
then is Egypt to be believed, when she tells us that Osiris, their
Inventor of arts, was many ages earlier than Sesostris their Con-
queror: And consequently, all Sir Isaac Newton’s zdentity separates
and falls to pieces. In a word, take it which way you will, If Osiris
were the same as Sesostris, then must the invention of Arts (for all
Antiquity have concurred in giving that invention to Osiris) be as late
as the age of Sesostris, the Sesac of Newton: but this, ScripTuRE-
HISTORY will not suffer us to believe. If, on the other hand, Osiris
and Sesostris were not the same, then was the invention of Arts (and
for the same reason) much earlier than the age of Sesostris; as
indeed all mankind thought before the construction of this new Chro-
nology. These were the considerations which induced that Great
man, who so well understood the nature and force of evidence, to
employ all the sagacity of his wonderful talents in proving the inven-
tion of Arts to be about the age of his Sesostris or Sesac. And is it
possible he should have a follower who cannot see that he hath done
this? or the necessity he had of doing it? It will be said, perhaps,
“that Sir Isaac has, indeed, argued much for the low invention of
Arts: but had neither inforced it under the name of an argument, nor
stated it in the form here represented.” The objection would ill
become a follower of Newton, who knows that his Master’s method,
as well in these his critical as in his physical inquiries, was to form
the principal members of his demonstration with an unornamented
brevity, and leave the supplial’ of the small connecting parts to his
SECT. V. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 295
reader’s sagacity. Besides, in so obvious, so capital, so necessary an
argument for this ¢dentity, it had been a ridiculous distrust of com-
mon sense, after he had spent so much pains in endeavouring to
prove the low invention of Arts, to have ended his reasoning in this
formal way: “ And now, Reader, take notice that this is a conclusive,
and perhaps the only conclusive argument for the identity of Osiris
and Sesostris.” Lastly, let me observe, that the very reason which
induced Sir Isaac to be so large in the establishment of his point, the
low invention of Arts, induced me to be as large in the subversion of
it. And now some satisfactory account, I hope, is given of the
seventy long pages.
What follows is still more unaccountable—However these were
matters (says the learned writer, speaking of the invention of Arts)
we never touched upon, as relating nothing to our purpose. Here I
cannot but lament the learned writer’s ill fortune. There was but
this very circumstance in the book he would defend, which is essen-
tial to his purpose, and this he hath given up as nothing to his
purpose ; and more unlucky still, on a review of the argument, he
hath treated it as an error in his author, who took so much pains
about it; but yet as an error that doth not at all affect the point in
question. For, i
He concludes thus—wNor do they yet induce me to recede from that
conclusion of the famous Newton, that Sesac was Sesostris, Osiris and
Bacchus.—Sesac, as I said before, I have no concern with. And as
to Bacchus, it is agreed that this was only one of the names of Osiris,
The thing I undertook to prove was, that Osiris and Sesostris were
not the same person: but in doing this, I did not mean to say that
Osiris was not one of the names of Sesostris. This is a very different
thing: and the rather to be taken notice of, because I suspect a
quibble in the words of the learned writer, which would confound the
difference. Nor is my suspicion unreasonable. For I have met with
some of his most learned followers, who have ventured to say, that
Sir Isaac meant no more than that Sesostris was AN Osiris. But if
he meant no more, I would allow him to mean any thing ; and never
to have his meaning disputed. I, for my part, and so I suppose every
body else, understood him to mean, “That the old Osiris, famous,
amongst the Egyptians, for Legislation and the invention of the Arts
of life, was the very same man with Sesostris, whom these Egyptians
make to be a different man, of a later age, and famous for the
Conquest of the habitable world.” This was the proposition I under-
took to confute. Wherein I endeavoured to shew, ‘‘ that there was a
real Osiris, such as the Egyptians represented him, much earlier than
their real Sesostris.””. And now (to use this writer’s words) the cause
being brought before the public, let the learned determine of it. As to
206 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
the other point, that Sesostris went by the name of the earlier Hero,
this I not only allow, but contend for, as it lays open to us one of the
principal causes of that confusion in their stories, which hath pro-
duced a similitude of actions, whereon Sir Isaac Newton layeth the
foundation of their IDENTITY.
But if Sir Isaac Newton and his learned Advocate have paid too
little deference to Antiquity, there are, who, in a contrary extreme,
would pay a great deal too much. The learned Dr. Pococke, in his
book of travels, introduceth his discourse On the mythology of the
ancient Egyptians in this extraordinary manner: “ As the mythology,
or fabulous religion of the ancient Egyptians, may be looked on, in a
great measure, as the foundation of the heathen Religion in most
other parts ; so it may not be improper to give some account of the
origin of it, as it is delivered by the most ancient authors, which may
give some light both to the description of Egypt, and also to the
history of that country. We may suppose, that the Ancients were
the best judges of the nature of their Religion; and consequently,
that all interpretations of their Mythology, by MEN OF FRUITFUL
INVENTIONS, that have no sort of foundation in their writings, are
forced, and such as might never be intended by them. On the con-
trary, it is necessary to retrench several things the Ancients them-
selves seem to have invented, and grafted on true history; and, in
order to account for many things, the Genealogies and Alliances they
mention must in several respects be false or erroneous, and seem to
have been invented to accommodate the honours of the same Deities
to different persons, they were obliged to deify, who lived at different
times ; and so they were obliged to give them new names, invent
genealogies, and some different attributes.” *
He says, We may suppose that the ancients were the best judges of
the nature of their religion, and of their mythology. But the Ancients,
here spoken of, were not Egyptians, but Greeks ; and the Mythology
here spoken of was not Greek, but Egyptian: Therefore these
Ancients might well be mistaken about the nature of a Religion which
they borrowed from strangers; the principles of which, they tell us,
were always kept secreted from them. But this is not all; they in
fact were mistaken ; and by no means good judges of the nature of
their Religion, if we may believe one of the most authentic of these
Ancients, Heropotvus himself, where discoursing of the Greeks he
expresly says,—‘ But the origin of each God, and whether they are
all from eternity, and what is their several kinds or natures, to speak
the truth, they neither knew at that time nor since.”’ +
The learned Traveller goes on—and consEqueNntLy that all inter-
pretations of their Mythology by men of FRUITFUL INVENTIONS, that
* Pp. 221, 222. +t See above.
SECT. V. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 297
have no sort of foundation in their writings, are forced, and such as
might never be intended by them. This is indeed a TRUTH, but it is
nO CONSEQUENCE, and therefore not to the purpose. For, whether
the Ancients were, or were not, the best judges ; whether the Moderns
have, or have not, fruitful inventions, yet if their interpretations have
no sort of foundation in ancient writings, it is a great chance but they
are forced ; and as great, that the Ancients never intended what the
Moderns ascribe to them. However, he gets nothing by this hypo-
thetical proposition, unless it be the discredit of begging the question.
But the most extraordinary is his making it an additional reason
for leaving the Moderns and sticking to the Ancients, that the
Ancients seem to have invented and grafted on true history ; and, in
order (he says) to account for many things, the genealogies and
alliances they mention must in several respects be false or erroneous,
and seem to have been invented, §c. Now, if the Ancients were thus
mistaken, the Moderns sure may be excused in endeavouring to set
them right : To common sense therefore, this would seem to shew
the use of their interpretations. But this use is better understood
from our Author’s own success ; who, in this chapter concerning the
Egyptian mythology, has attempted to give us some knowledge of
Antiquity, without them. And here we find, the ancient account, to
which he so closely adheres, is not only fabulous by his own confes-
sion, but contradictory by his own representation ; a confused collec-
tion of errors and absurdities: that very condition of Antiquity which
forced the Moderns to have recourse to interpretations ; and occa-
sioned that variety whereon our author grounds his charge against
them. A charge however, in which his Ancients themselves will be
involved ; for they likewise had their interpretations ; and were (if
their variety would give it them) as fruitful at least, in their cnven-
tions. For instance, How discordant were they in their opinions
concerning the origin of ANIMAL worsHiP? Was our Author igno-
rant that so odd a superstition wanted explanation? By no means.
Yet for fear of incurring the censure of a fruitful invention, instead of
taking the fair solution of a modern Critic, or even any rational inter-
pretation of the ancient Mythologists, whom yet he professes to
follow, he contents himself with that wretched fable ‘‘ of Typhon’s
dividing the body of Osiris into twenty-six parts, and distributing
them to his accomplices ; which being afterwards found by Isis, and
delivered by her to distinct bodies of priests to be buried with great
secrecy, she enjoined them to pay divine honours to him, and to
consecrate some particular animal to his memory.” From this account
(says our author very gravely) we may see the reason why so many
sacred animals were worshipped in Egypt.* Again, the Greek account,
* Page 226.
298 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
in Diodorus, of Osiris’s expedition, has been shewn to be a heap of
impossible absurdities ; yet our author believes it all; and would
have believed as much more rather than have run the hazard of any
modern invention.
AND now, we presume, the minor of Sir Isaac Newton’s general
argument, that Osiris and Sesostris were the same, is intirely over-
thrown. For, 1. It hath been proved, that the premisses, he employs
in its support, do not infer it. 2. That the consequence of his con-
clusion from it contradicts sacred Scripture; and 3. That it disagrees
with the very nature of things.
So that our first proposition, That the Egy yptian learning celebrated
in Scripture, and the Egyptian superstition there condemned, were the
very Learning and Superstition represented by the Greek writers, as
the honour and opprobrium of that people, stands clear of all objection.
What that Learning and Superstition were, we have shewn very
largely, though occasionally, in the course of this inquiry ; whereby it
appears, that their Learning in general was consummate skill in c1viL
POLICY AND THE ARTS OF LEGISLATION; and their Superstition, the
WORSHIP OF DEAD MEN DEIFIED.
SECTION VI.
I come, at length, to my second proposition : which if, by this time,
the Reader should have forgotten, he may be easily excused. It is
this, That the Jewish people were extremely fond of Egyptian man-
ners, and did frequently fall into Egyptian superstitions : and that
many of the laws given to them by the ministry of Moses, were insti-
tuted, partly in compliance to their prejudices, and partly in nae
tion to those superstitions.
The first part of this proposition—the people's fondness for, and
frequent lapse into, Egyptian superstitions,—needs not many words
to evince. ‘The thing, as we shall see hereafter, being so natural in
itself ; and, as we shall now see, so fully recorded in holy Scripture.
The time was now come for the deliverance of the chosen People
from their Egyptian bondage: For now vice and IDOLATRY were
arrived at their height ; the former (as St. Paul tells us) by means of
the latter ; for as they did not like to retain God in their knowledge, God
gave them over to a reprobate mind, to do those things which are not
convenient ; being filled with all unrighteousness, §c.* The two most
populous regions at that time in the world were Canaan and Eaypr:
The first distinguished from all other by its violence and unnatural
crimes ; the latter by its superstitions and idolatries. It concerned
God’s moral government that a speedy check should be put to both ;
the inhabitants of these two places being now ripe for divine ven-
* Rom. i, 28.
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 299
geance. And as the instruments he employed to punish their present
enormities were designed for a barrier against future, the Israelites
went out of Egypt with a high hand, which desolated their haughty
tyrants ; and were led into the possession of the land of Canaan,
whose inhabitants they were utterly to exterminate. The dispensation
of this Providence appears admirable, both in the time and in the
modes of the punishment. Vic and 1poLaTrRy had now (as I said)
filled up their measure. Eaypr, the capital of false Religion, being
likewise the nursery of arts and sciences, was preserved from total
destruction for the sake of civil life and polished manners, which were
to derive their source from thence: But the CANAANITES were to be
utterly exterminated, to vindicate the honour of humanity, and to put
a stop to a spreading contagion which changed the reasonable Nature
into brutal.
Now it was that Gop, remembering his Covenant with Abraham,
was pleased to appoint his People, then groaning under their bond-
age, a Leader and Deliverer. But so great was their degeneracy,
and so sensible was Moses of its effects, in their ignorance of, or
alienation from the true Gop, that he would willingly have declined
the office: And when absolutely commanded to undertake it, he
desired however that Gov would let him know by what NAME he
would be called, when the people should ask the name of the Gon of
their fathers.—And Moses said unto Gov, Behold when I come unto
the children of Israel, and say unto them, The Gov of your fathers
hath sent me unto you; and they shall say unto me, WHAT IS HIS
Name? what shall I say unto them?* Here we see a people not
only lost to all knowledge of the Unrry (for the asking for a name
necessarily implied their opinion of a plurality), but likewise possessed
with the very spirit of Egyptian idolatry. The religion of NAMES, as
we have shewn,t was a matter of great consequence in Egypt. It
was one of their essential superstitions: it was one of their native
inventions: and the first of them which they communicated to the
Greeks. Thus when Hagar, the handmaid of Sarai, who was an
Egyptian woman, saw the angel of God in the wilderness, the text
tells us,t She called the name of the Lord that spake unto her, Eirot,
the God of vision, or the visible God: that is, according to the estab-
lished custom of Egypt, she gave him a name of honour : not merely
a name of distinction; for such, all nations had (who worshipped
local tutelary deities) before their communication with Egypt.§ But,
after that, (as appears from the place of Herodotus quoted above,
concerning the Pelasgi,) they decorated their Gods with distinguished
Titles, indicative of their specific office and attributes. A NAME was
* Exod. iii. 13. + Page 253, et seq. { Gen. xvi. 13. § See note
MMMM, at the end of this book.
900 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
so peculiar an adjunct to a local tutelary Deity, that we see by a
passage quoted by Lactantius from the spurious books of Trismegist
(which however abounded with Egyptian notions and superstitions),
that the one supreme God had no zame or title of distinction.*
Zachariah evidently alluding to these notions, when he prophesies of
the worship of the supreme God, unmixed with idolatry, says, In that
day shall there be one Lord, and wis NAME ONE;7+ that is, only
bearing the simple title of Lorp: and, as in the words of Lactantius
below, ae ne quis NOMEN ejus requireret, ANONYMON esse dizit ;
eo quod nominis PROPRIETATE non egeat, ob ipsam scilicet UNITATEM.
Out of indulgence therefore to this weakness, Gop was pleased to give
himself a Name. And God said unto Moses, 1 AM THAT 1 AM: And
he said, Thus shalt thou say unto the children of Israel, 1 am hath
sent me unto you.t Where we may observe (according to the con-
stant method of divine Wisdom, when it condescends to the prejudices
of men) how, in the very instance of indulgence to their superstition,
he gives a corrective of it.—The Religion of names arose from an
idolatrous polytheism ; and the NAME here given, implying eternity
and self-ewistence, directly opposeth that superstition.
This compliance with the Religion of names was a new indulgence
to the prejudices of this people, as is evident from the following
words: dnd Gop spake unto Moses, and said unto him, I am the
Lord : and I appeared unto Abraham, unto Isaac, and unto Jacob, by
the NAME oF Gop Atmicuty, but by my Name Jenovayn was I
not known to them.§ That is, as the Gop of Abraham, I before
condescended to have a Name of distinction: but now, in compliance
to another prejudice, I condescend to have a Name of honour.
This seems to be the true interpretation of this very difficult text,
about which the commentators are so much embarrassed. For the
word Jehovah, whose name is here said to be unknown to the
Patriarchs, frequently occurring in the book of Genesis, had fur-
nished Unbelievers with a pretext that the same person could not be
author of the two books of Genesis and Exodus. But Ignorance
and Scepticism, which set Infidelity on work, generally bring it to
shame. They mistook the true sense of the text. The assertion is
not, that the worp Jehovah was not used in the patriarchal lan-
guage; but that the name Jehovah, as a title of honour, (whereby
a new tdea was affixed to an old word) was unknown tothem. Thus,
* “Hie scripsit libros—in quibus majestatem summi ac singularis dei asserit, iisdem-
que nominibus appellat, quibus nos, Deum et ParRem. Ac ne quis NOMEN ejus requi-
reret ANQONYMON esse dixit; eo quod nominis proprietate non egeat, ob ipsam
scilicet unitatem, Ipsius hee verba sunt, 6 δὲ Θεὸς cis’ ὁ δὲ εἷς ὀνόματος ov wpoade-
era" ἔστι yap 6 dv ἀνώνυμος. Deo igitur nomen non est, quia solus est: nec opus est
proprio vocabulo, nisi cum discrimen exigit multitudo, ut unamquamque personam sua
nota et appellatione designes.”—Div. Inst. lib. i. cap. 6. + Zach. xiv. 9.
1 Exod. iii. 14. § Exod. vi, 3.
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 301
in a parallel instance, we say rightly, that the King’s suPREMACY was
unknown to the English Constitution till the time of Henry VIII.
though the word was in use, and even applied to the chief Magis-
trate, (indeed in a different and more simple sense) long before.
The common solution of this difficulty is as ridiculous as it is false.
You shall have it in the words of a very ingenious writer.—‘ The word
JrHovaH signifies the being unchangeable in his resolutions, and
consequently the being infinitely faithful in performing his promises.
In this sense the word is employed in the passage of Exodus now
under examination. So that when God says, by my name Jehovah
was I not known to them, this signifies—as one faithful to fullfil my
promise, was I not known to them.” ‘i. 6. [had not then full-
filled the promise which I had made to them, of bringing their pos-
terity out of Egypt, and giving them the land of Canaan.”’* By
which interpretation, the Almighty is made to tell the Israelites that
he was not known to their forefathers as the God who had redeemed
their posterity from Egypt, before they had any posterity to redeem.
A marvellous revelation, and, without doubt, much wanted. ΤῸ
return.
Moses however appears still unwilling to accept this Commission ;
and presumes to tell Gon, plainly, Behold they will not believe me,
nor hearken to my voice: for they will say, The Lord hath not
appeared unto thee.t But could this be said or thought by a People,
who, groaning in the bitterest servitude, had a message from Gop, of
a long promised deliverance, at the very time that, according to the
prediction, the promise was to be fulfilled, if they had kept him and
his dispensations in memory? When this objection is removed,
Moses hath yet another; and that is, his imability for the office of
an ORATOR. This too is answered. And when he is now driven
from all his subterfuges, he with much passion declines the whole
employment, and cries out, O my Gon, send I pray thee by the hand
of him whom thou wilt send.t This justly provokes Gon’s displea-
sure: and thereon, he finally complies. From all this backwardness,
(and the cause of it could be no other than what is here assigned ;
for Mosss, as appears by the former part of his history,§ was for-
ward and zealous enough to promote the welfare of his brethren)
we must needs conclude that he thought the recovery of this People
* <T] signifie U’etre immuable dans ses resolutions, et par consequent l’etre infiniment
fidelle duns ses promesses, et c’est dans cette acception que ce nom est emploié dans le
_ passage de I’Exode, que nous examinons. Qu’ainsi quand Dieu dit, Je ne lewr ai point
esté connu en mon nom de Jehovah, cela signifie, Je ne me suis point fait connoitre,
comme fidelle ἃ remplir mes promesses, c'est ἃ dire, JE N'Al PAS ENCORE REMPLI LA
PROMESSE, gui je leur avois faite, de retirer de l’ Egypte leur posterité, et de lui donner
la terre de Chanaan.”—M. AsrrRuc, Conjectures sur le Livre de la Genese, p. 305. He
says very truly, that, in this solution, he had no other part to perform, gue suivre
la foule des Commentaieurs tant Chretiens que Juifs, p. 301. +t Exod. iv. 1.
t Verse 13. § Exod. ii. 12.
302 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
from EGYPTIAN SUPERSTITIONS to be altogether desperate. And,
humanly speaking, he did not judge amiss; as may be seen from a
succinct account of their behaviour during the whole time Gop was
working this amazing Deliverance.
For now Moses and Aaron discharge their message; and having
confirmed it by signs and wonders, the People believed: but it was
such a belief, as men have of a new and unexpected matter, well
attested.—They bow the head too, and worship ;* but it appears to
be a thing they had not been lately accustomed to. And how little
true sense they had of Gop’s promises and visitation is seen from
their murmuring and desponding + when things did not immediately
succeed to their wishes; though Moses, as from God, had told them
before-hand, that Pharaoh would prove cruel and hard-hearted ; and
would defer their liberty to the very last distress.t And at length,
when that time came, and Gop had ordered them to purify them-
selves from all the idolatries of Eayrt, so prodigiously attached were
they to these follies, that they disobeyed his command even at the
very eve of their deliverance.§ A thing altogether incredible, but
that we have Gon’s own word for it, by the prophet Ezekiel: In the
day (says he) that I lifted up mine hand unto them to bring them forth
of the land of Egypt, into aland that I had spied for them flowing with
milk and honey, which is the glory of all lands: Then said I unto
them, Cast ye away every man the abominations of his eyes, and defile
not yourselves with the idols of Egypt: I am the Lord your Gop.
But they rebelled against me, and would not hearken unto me: they
did not every man cast away the abominations of their eyes, neither
did they forsake the idols of Egypt: Then I said, I will pour out my
Jury upon them, to accomplish my anger against them in the midst of
the land of Egypt. But I wrought for my name's sake, that it should
not be polluted before the heathen, amongst whom they were, in whose
sight I made myself known unto them, in bringing them forth out of
the land of Egypt. Wherefore I caused them to go forth out of the
land of Egypt, and brought them into the wilderness. ||
From all this it appears, that their Cry, by reason of their bond-
age, which came up unto Gov, was not for such a deliverance as was
promised to their forefathers, to be brought up out of Egypt ; but
for such a one as might enable them to live at ease, amongst their
flesh-pots, in it.
But now they are delivered: and, by a series of miracles per-
formed in their behalf, got quite clear of the power of Pharaoh.
Yet on every little distress, Let us return to Egypt, was still the ery.
Thus, immediately after their deliverance at the Red-Sea, on so com-
* Exod. iv. 31. + Exod. ν. 21. 1 Exod. iii. 19—21. § See note
NNNN, at the end of this book. || Ezek. xx. 6, et seq.
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 303
mon an accident, as meeting with Jdttter waters in their rout, they
were presently at their What shall we drink ?* And no sooner had
a miracle removed this distress, and they gotten into the barren wil-
derness, but they were, again, at their What shall we eat?+ Not
that indeed they feared to die either of hunger or of thirst ; for they
found the hand of Gop was still ready to supply their wants ; all
but their capital want, to return again into Eaypr; and these pre-
tences were only a less indecent cover to their designs: which yet,
on occasion, they were not ashamed to throw off, as where they say
to Moses, when frightened by the pursuit of the Egyptians at the
Red-Sea, Is not this the word that we did tell thee in Egypt, Let us
alone that we may serve the Egyptians.t And again, Would to Gon,
we had died by the hand of the Lord in the land of Egypt, when we
sat by the flesh-pots and did eat bread to the full.§ That is, in plain
terms, ‘“‘ Would we had died with our brethren the Egyptians.” For
they here allude to the destruction of the first-born, when the destroy-
ing angel (which was more than they deserved) passed over the
habitations of Israel.
But they have now both flesh and bread, when they cry out the
second time for water: and even while, again, at their Why hast thou
brought us up out of Egypt,|| a rock, less impenetrable than their
hearts, is made to pour out a stream so large that the water run down
like rivers: 41 yet all the effect it seemed to have upon them was only
to put them more in mind of the way of Egypt, and the watrrs of
Sion Ὁ
Nay even after their receiving the LAw, on their free and solemn
acceptance of Jehovah for their Gop and Κινα, and their being con-
secrated anew, as it were, for his peculiar People, Moses only hap-
pening to stay a little longer in the Mount than they expected, They
fairly took the occasion cf projecting a scheme, and, to say the truth,
no bad one, of returning back into Egypt. They went to Aaron,
and pretending they never hoped to see Moses again, desired another
Leader. But they would have one in the mode of Egypt; an Image,
or visible representative of Gop, to go before them.++ Aaron com-
plies, and makes them a GoLDEN Caxr, in conformity to the super-
stition of Egypt ; whose great God Osiris was worshiped under that
representation 77 and, for greater holiness too, out of the jewels of
the Egyptians. In this so horrid an impiety to the Gop of their
fathers, their secret drift,§§ if we may believe St. Stephen, was this ;
* Exod. xv. 24. + Exod. xvi. 2. t Exod. xiv. 12. § Exod. xvi. 3.
|| Exod. xvii. 3. 4 Psalm Ixxviii. 16. *® Jer. ii. 18. tt Exod. xxxii. 1.
tt Ὁ MOSKOS οὗτος, 6 ATIIS καλεόμενος.--- HERovoTUvS, lib. iii.cap.28. δὲ “To
whom our fathers would not obey, but thrust him from them, and in their hearts turned
back again into Egypt, saying unto Aaron, Make us Gods to go before us,” &c. (Acts
vii. 39, 40.)
904 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
they wanted to get back into Egypt; and while the Catr, so much
adored in that country, went before them, they could return with an
atonement and reconciliation in their hands. And doubtless their
worthy Mediator, being made all of sacred, Egyptian metal, would
have been consecrated in one of their temples, under the title of
OSIRIS REDVCTOR. But Moses’s sudden appearance broke all their
measures: and the ringleaders of the design were punished as they
deserved.
At length, after numberless follies and perversities, they are
brought, through Gon’s patience and long-suffering, to the end of all ©
their travels, to the promised place of rest, which is just opening to
receive them ; When, on the report of the cowardly explorers of the
Land, they relapse again into their old delirium, Wherefore hath the
Lord brought us unto this land, to fall by the sword, that our wives
and our children should be a prey ? were it not better for us to return
into Egypt ? And they said one to another, Let us make a captain,
and let us return into Egypt.* This so provoked the Almighty, that
he condemned that Generation to be worn away in the Wilderness.
How they spent their time there, the prophet Amos will inform us,
Have ye offered unto me (says Gop) any sacrifices and offerings in
the Wilderness, forty years, O house of Israel ? +
In a word, this unwillingness to leave Egypt, and this impatience
to return thither, are convincing proofs of their fondness for its cus-
toms and superstitions. When I consider this, I seem more inclined
than the generality even of sober Critics to excuse the false accounts
of the Pagan writers concerning the Exodus ; who concur in repre-
senting the Jews as expelled or forcibly driven out of Egypt; For so
indeed they were. The mistake was only about their driver. The
Pagans supposed him to,be the King of Egypt; when indeed it was
the Gop of Israel himself, by the ministry of Moses.
Let us view them next, in possession of the PROMISED LAND. A
land flowing with milk and honey, the glory of all lands. One would
expect now their longing after Egypt should have entirely ceased.
And so without doubt it would, had it arose only from the flesh-pots ;
but it had a deeper root; it was the spiritual luxury of Egypt, their
superstitions, with which the Israelites were so debauched. And
therefore no wonder they should still continue slaves to their appetite.
Thus the prophet Ezekiel, Neither Lert she her whoredoms brought
Jrom Egypt.t So that after all Gop’s mercies conferred upon them
in putting them in possession of the land of Canaan, Joshua is, at
last, forced to leave them with this fruitless admonition : Now there-
Sore fear the Lord, and serve him in sincerity and in truth; and Put
Away the Gods which your fathers served on the other side of the
* Num. xiv. 3, 4. + Amos vy, 25. 1 Ezek. xxiii. 8.
SECT, VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 305
flood and in Kayrr.* It is true, we are told that the people served
the Lord all the days of Joshua, and all the days of the elders that
outlived Joshua, who had seen all the great works of the Lord that he
did for Israel.+ But, out of sight out of mind. It is then added—
And there arose another generation after them, which knew not the
Lord, nor yet the works which he had done for Israel—And they for-
sook the Lord God of their fathers, which brought them out of the
land of Eyypt, and followed other Gods, of the Gods of the people
that were round about them.t And in this state they continued
throughout the whole administration of their Jupexs ; except, when,
from time to time, they were awakened into repentance by the seve-
rity of Gon’s judgments ; which yet were no sooner passed, than
they fell back again into their old lethargy, a forgetfulness of his
mercies.
Nor did their fondness for Egypt at all abate when they came under
the iron rod of their k1nGs ; the Magistrate they had so rebelliously
demanded ; and who, as they pretended, was to set all things right.
On the contrary, this folly grew still more inflamed; and instead of one
Caur they would have rwo. Which Ezekiel hints at, where he says,
Yet she MuuvieLieD her whoredoms in calling to remembrance the
days of her youth wherein she had played the harlot in Egypt.§
And so favourite a superstition were the Canves of Dan and Beth-el,
that they still kept their ground against all those general Reforma-
tions which divers of their better sort of Kings had made, to purge
the land of Israel from idolatries. It is true, their extreme fondness
for Egyptian superstition was not the only cause of this inveterate
adherence to their caLves. There were two others :
They flattered themselves that this specific idolatry was not altoge-
ther so gross an affront to the Gop of their fathers as many of the
rest. Other of their idolatries consisted in worshiping Strange
Gods in conjunction with the Gon of Israel; this of the CALVEs, only
in worshiping the Gop of Israel in an idolatrous manner: as appears
from the history of their erection. And Jeroboam || said in his heart,
Now shall the kingdom return to the house of David: if this people
go up to do sacrifice in the house of the Lord at Jerusalem, then shall
the heart of this people turn again unto their lord, even unto Reho-
boam King of Judah, and they shall kill me, and go again to Rehoboam
king of Judah. Whereupon the King took counsel, and made two
CALVES of gold, and said unto them, It is too much for you to go up
to Jerusalem, Behold thy Gods, O Israel, which brought thee up out of
the land of Egypt. And he set the one in Beth-el, and the other put
* Joshua xxiv. 14, 1 Judges ii. 7. t Verses 10, 12. § Ezek.
xxiii. 19. || It is to be observed of this Jeroboam, that he had sojourned in
Egypt, as a refugee, during the latter part of the reign of Solomon, (1 Kings xi. 40.)
VOL. ΤΙ. x
306 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
he in Dan.*—It is too much for you (says he) to go up to Jerusalem.
Who were the men disposed to go up? None surely but the worship-
pers of the Gop of Israel. Consequently the caves, here offered to
save them a journey, must needs be given as the representatives of
that God. And if these were so, then certainly the caur in Hored :
since, at their several consecrations, the very same proclamation was
made of all three: Behold thy Gons, O Israel, which brought thee up
out of the land of Egypt.
The other cause of the perpetual adherence of the Kingdom of
Israel to their GoLpeN Catves was their being erected for a preven-
tion of re-union with the Kingdom of Judah. If this people (says the
politic contriver) go up to do sacrifice in the house of the Lord at
Jerusalem, then shall the heart of this people turn again unto their
lord, even unto Rehoboam king of Judah. The succeeding kings,
therefore, we may be sure, were as careful in preserving them, as He
was in putting them up. So that, good or bad, the character com-
mon to them all was, that he departed not from the sins of Jeroboam
the son of Nebat, who made Israel to sin ; namely, in worshiping the
Calves in Dan and Beth-el. And those of them who appeared most
zealous for the Law of Gop, and utterly exterminated the idolatry of
Baal, yet connived at least, at this political worship of the cALVES.—
Thus Jehu destroyed Baal out of Israel. Howbeit from the sins of
Jeroboam the son of Nebat who made Israel to sin, Jehu departed not,
to wit, the golden CALVES that were in Beth-el, and that were in Dan.}
But the Israelites had now contracted all the fashionable habits of
Egypt. We are assured that it had been long peculiar to the Egyp-
tian superstition for every city of that empire to have its own tutelary
God, besides those which were worshipped in common: But now
Jeremiah tells us the people of Judah bore a part with them in this
extravagance: Where are thy Gods that thou hast made thee? Let
them arise, if they can save thee in the time of thy trouble: For
ACCORDING TO THE NUMBER OF THY CITIES, ARE THY Gops, Ὁ
Jupau.t
And by the time that the sins of this wretched People were ripe
for the punishment of their approaching Captivity, they had polluted
themselves with all kind of Eyyptian abominations : as appears from
the famous visions of EzeKiex, where their three capital idolatries
are so graphically described. The Prophet represents himself as
brought, in a vision, to Jerusalem: and, at the door of the inner gate
that looked towards the north, he saw the seat of the IMAGE OF
JEALOUSY which provoketh to jealousy.4 Here, by the noblest
stretch of an inspired imagination, he calls this seat of their idolatries,
* 1 Kings xii. 26, et seq. t 2 Kings x. 28, et seq. t Jer. ii. 28.
§ Ezek. viii. 3.
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 307
the seat of the image of Jealousy, whom he personifies, and the
more to catch the attention of this corrupt people, converts into an
Idol, tHE IMAGE OF JEALOUSY which provoketh to jealousy ; as if
he had said, God, in his wrath, hath given you one idol more, to
avenge himself of all the rest. After this sublime prelude, the pro-
phet proceeds to the various scenery of the inspired Vision.
I. The first of their capital idolatries is described in this manner :
And he brought me to the door of the court, and when I looked, behold
@ HOLE IN THE WALL. Then said he unto me, Son of man, diy now
in the wall ; and when I had digged in the wall, behold a poor. And
he said unto me, Go in, and behold the wicked abominations that they
do here. So I went in and saw, and behold EVERY FORM OF CREEP-
ING THINGS, AND ABOMINABLE BEASTS, and all the idols of the
house of Israel, POURTRAYED UPON THE WALL ROUND ABOUT.
And there stood before them seventy men of the ancients of the house
of Israel, and in the midst of them stood Jaazaniah the son of Sha-
phan, with every man his censer in his hand, and a thick cloud of
incense went up. Then said he unto me, Son of man, hast thou seen
what the ancients of the house of Israel do IN THE DARK, every man
in the CHAMBERS OF HIS IMAGERY? *
1. The first inference I draw from these words is, That the Super-
stition here described was Egyptian. ‘This appears from its object’s
being the Gods peculiar to Egypt, every form of creeping things and
abominable beasts ; which, in another place, the same prophet calls,
with great propriety and elegance, the abominations of the eyes of the
Israelites.+
2. The second inference is, That they contain a very lively and
circumstantial description of the so celebrated mMysTEeRtEesS oF [515
AND Ostris. For 1. The rites are represented as performed in a
secret subterraneous place. And when I looked, behold a noun in the
wall; Then said he unto me, Son of man, dig now in the wall ; and
when I had digged in the wall, behold a poor. And he said unto
me, Go in—Hast thou seen what the Ancients of the house of Israel
do in the park? ‘This secret place was, as the Prophet tells us, in
the Temple. And such kind of places, for this use, the Egyptians
had in their Temples, as we learn from a similitude of Plutarch’s :
Like the disposition (says he) and ordonance of their Temples ; which,
in one place, enlarge and extend themselves into long wings, and fair
and open isles; in another, sink into dark and secret subterranean
Vestries, like the Adyta of the Thebans ; 7 which Tacitus describes in
* Ezek. viii. 6, et seq. ustEzek. xx. 7,8. This shews brute-worship in Egypt
to have been vastly extensive at the Exo dus ; the time the prophet is here speaking of.
1 ‘Os—al τε τῶν Ναῶν διαθέσεις, πῇ μὲν ἀνειμένων εἰς wTepa καὶ δρόμους ὑπαιθρίους καὶ
καθαροὺς, wih δὲ κρυπτὰ καὶ σκότια κατὰ γῆς ἐχόντων στολιστήρια Θηβαίοις ἐοικότα καὶ
σηκοῖς. epi Ἴσιδ. καὶ Οσίρ. p. 639, Steph. ed.
xe,
908 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK iv.
these words— atque alibi angustie, et profunda altitudo, nullis
inquirentium spaciis penetrabilis.” * 2. These rites are celebrated by
the SanuEpRIM, or the elders of Israel : And there stood before them
seventy men of the ancients of the house of Israel. Now it hath
been shewn in the Account of the Mysrrerres, that none but princes,
rulers, and the wisest of the people, were admitted to their more
secret celebrations. 3. The paintings and imagery, on the walls of
this subterraneous apartment, answer exactly to the descriptions the
ancients have given us of the mystic cells of the Egyptians. +
Behold every form of creeping things and abominable beasts, and all
the idols of the house of Israel pourtrayed upon the wall round about.
So Ammianus Marcellinus—“ Sunt et syringes subterranei quidam et
flexuosi secessus, quos, ut fertur, periti rituum vetustorum—penitus
operosis digestos fodinis, per loca diversa struxerunt: δέ excisis
parietibus volucrum ferarumque genera multa sculpserunt, quas hiero-
glyphicas literas appellarunt.”t There is a famous antique monu-
ment, once a consecrated utensil in the rites of Isis and Osiris, and
now well known to the curious by the name of the Istac or Bempine
TABLE; on which (as appears by the order of the several comparti-
ments) is pourtrayed all the imagery that adorned the walls of the
Mystic Cell. Now if one were to describe the engravings on that
table, one could not find juster or more emphatic terms than those
which the Prophet here employs.
3. The third inference I would draw from this vision is, that the
Egyptian superstition was that to which the Israelites were more
particularly addicted. And thus much I gather from the following
words, Behold every form of creeping things and abominable beasts,
and ALL THE IDOLS OF THE HOUSE OF ISRAEL, pourtrayed upon
the wall round about. I have shewn this to be a description of an
Egyptian mystic cell: which certainly was adorned only with Egyp-
tian Gods: and yet those Gods are here called, by way of distinction,
all the idols of the house,of Israel: which seems plainly to infer this
People’s more particular addiction to them. But the words, house of
Israel, being used in a vision describing the idolatries of the house of
Judah, 1 take it for granted, that in this indefinite number of All the
idols of the house of Israel, were eminently included those two prime
idols of the house of Israel, the calves of Dan and Beth-el. And the
rather, for that I find the original Calves held a distinguished station
in the paintings of the Mystic Cell; as the reader may see by casting
his eye upon the Bembine Table. And this, by the way, will lead us
* Annales, lib, xi. cap. 62. + Thus described by a learned Antiquary : “ Adyta
Bgyptiorum, in quibus sacerdotes sacra operari, ritusque et ceremonias snas exercere
solebant, subterranea loca erant, singulari quodam artificio ita constructa, ut nihil non
maysteriosi in iis occurreret. Afuri ex omni parte pleni tum hicroglyphicis picturis,
twm sculpturis?’—K1iRCHER. t Lib, xxii. cap. 15.
7. 222
DUD ID
Z 2575.
ΚΠ ΠΡ ΠΧ XIII
ὴ
x]
: oe: WEE Ἦν 4 Oy la θυ ἢ =
SECT, VI. _ OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 309
to the reason of Jeroboam’s erecting two Calves. For they were, we
see, worshiped in pairs by the Egyptians, as representing Isis. and
Osiris. And what is remarkable, the Calves were male and female, as
appears from 2 Kings, c. x. ver. 29. compared with Hosea, c. x.
ver. 3. where in one place the masculine, and in the other the feminine
term is employed. But though the Egyptian Gods are thus, by way
of eminence, called the idols of the house of Israel, yet other idols they
had besides Egyptian ; and of those good store, as we shall now see.
For this prophetic vision is employed in describing the three
master-superstitions of this unhappy people, the Ecyprian, the
PHENICIAN, and the PERSIAN.
II. The Egyptian we have seen. The ΡΗΈΝΊΟΙΑΝ follows in these
words: 176 said also unto me, Turn thee yet again, and thou shalt see
greater abominations that they do. Then he brought me to the gate of
the Lord’s house which was towards the NortH, and behold there sat
WOMEN WEEPING For TamMMuz.*
Ill. The Persian superstition is next described in this manner :
Then he said unto me, [Hast thou seen this, O son of man? Turn thee
yeé again, and thou shalt see greater abominations than these. And
he brought me into the inner court of the Lord’s house, and behold at
the door of the temple of the Lord, between the porch and the altar,
were about five and twenty men with their backs towards the temple of
the Lord, and THEIR FACES TOWARDS THE EAST, AND THEY WOR-
SHIPED THE SUN TOWARDS THE EAST.
1. It is to be observed, that when the Prophet is bid to turn from
the Egyptian to the Phenician rites, he is then said to look towards
the north ; which was the situation of Phenicia with regard to Jeru-
salem: consequently, he before stood southward, the situation of
Egypt, with regard to the same place. And when, from thence, he is
bid to turn into the inner court of the Lord’s house, to see the
Persian rites, this was east, the situation of Persia. With such
exactness is the representation of the whole Vision conducted.
2. Again, as the mysterious rites of Egypt are said, agreeably to
their usage, to be held in secret, by their ELpERS AND RULERS
only: so the Phenician rites, for the same reason, are shewn as they
were celebrated by the Peorxe, in open day. And the Persian wor-
ship of the sun, which was performed by the Magi, is here said to be
observed by the Priests alone, five and twenty men with their faces
towards the east.
These three capital Superstitions, the Prophet, again, distinctly
objects to them, in a following chapter. Thou hast also committed
fornication with the UGxerians thy neighbours, great of flesh ; 1 and
* Ezek. viii. 13, et seq. t Verse 15, et seq. ft See note OOOO, at the
end of this book,
910 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
hast increased thy whoredoms to provoke me to anger. Thou hast
played the whore also with the Assyrians, because thou wast unsa-
tiable: yea thou hast played the harlot with them, and yet couldst
not be satisfied. Thou hast moreover multiplied thy fornication in the
land of Canaan unto Chaldea, and yet thou wast not satisfied here-
with.*
And when that miserable Remnant, who, on the taking of Jerusa-
lem by Nebuchadnezzar, had escaped the fate of their enslaved
countrymen, were promised safety and security, if they would stay in
Judea ; they said, No, but we will go into the land of Eeyrt, where we
shall see no war, nor hear the sound of the trumpet, nor have hunger
of bread, and there will we dwell.t
Thus we see what a surprizing fondness this infatuated people had
for Egypt, and how entirely they were seized and possessed with its
superstitions. Which the more I consider, the more I am confirmed
in the truth of Scripture-history (so opposite to Sir Isaac Newton’s
Egyptian Chronology), that Egypt was, at the egression of the
Israelites, a great and powerful empire. For nothing so much
attaches a people to any particular Constitution, or mode of Govern-
ment, as the high opinion of its power, wealth, and felicity; these
being ever supposed the joint product of its Rexigion and CIviL
Po.icy. )
IJ. Having thus proved the first part of the Proposition, That the
Jewish people were extremely fond of Egyptian manners, and did
Frequently fall into Egyptian superstitions, 1 come now to the second ;
That many of the Laws given to them by the ministry of Moses were
instituted partly in compliance to their prejudices, and ραν ἢ
sition to those and to the like superstitions. But to set what I have to
say in support of this second part of the Proposition in a.fair light, it
may be proper just to state and explain the ENps of the Ritual Law.
Its first and principal, was to guard the chosen people from the
contagion of IDOLATRY: a second, and very important end, was to
prepare them for the reception of the Mrsstau. The first required
that the Ritual Law should be onsEectTive to the Pagan superstitions ;
and the second, that it should be typicat of their great Deliverer.
Now the coincidencies of these two ends, not being sufficiently
adverted to, hath been the principal occasion of that obstinate aver-
sion to the truth here advanced, That much of the Ritual was given,
PARTLY in compliance to the People’s prejudices, and PARTLY in
opposition to Egyptian superstitions: These men thinking the fals-
hood of the Proposition sufficiently proved in shewing the Ritual to
be typical; as if the one end excluded the other: whereas we see
they were very consistent ; and hereafter shall see, that their con-
* Ezek. xvi. 26, et seq. t Jer. ΧΙ, 14,
SECT, VE. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 311
currency affords one of the noblest proofs of the divinity of its
original.
And now, to go on with our subject: The intelligent reader cannot
but perceive, that the giving a RITUAL in opposition to Egyptian
superstition, was a necessary consequence of the People’s propensity
towards it. For a people so prejudiced, and who were to be dealt
~ with as free and accountable Agents, could not possibly be kept
separate from other nations, and pure from foreign idolatries, any
otherwise than by giving them laws IN OPposiTION to those super-
stitions. But such being the corrupt state of man’s Will as ever to
revolt against what directly opposeth its prejudices, wise Governors,
when under the necessity of giving such laws, have, in order to break
and evade the force of human perversity, always intermixed them with
others which eluded the perversity, by flattering the prejudice ; where
the indulgence could not be so abused as to occasion the evil which
the laws of opposition were designed to prevent.* And in this
manner it was that our inspired Lawgiver acted with his people, if we
will believe Jesus himself, where, speaking of a certain positive
institution, he says, Moses for the HARDNESS OF YOUR HEARTS
wrote you this precept.+ Plainly intimating their manners to be such,
that, had not Moses indulged them in some things, they would have
revolted against all.t It follows therefore, that Moses’s giving Laws
to the Israelites, én compliance to these their prejudices, was a natural
and necessary consequence of Laws given in opposition to them.
Thus far from the nature of the thing.
Matter of fact confirms this reasoning. We find in the Law a
surprizing relation and resemblance between Jewish and Egyptian
rites, in circumstances both opposite and similar. But the learned
Spencer hath fully exhausted this subject, in his excellent work,
De legibus Hebreorum ritualibus et earum rationibus ; and thereby
done great service to divine revelation: For the RrruaL LAw, when
thus explained, is seen to be an Institution of the most beautiful and
sublime contrivance. Which, without its causrs, (no where to be
found but in the road of this theory) must lie for ever open to the
scorn and contempt of Libertines and Unbelievers. This noble work
is no other than a paraphrase and comment on the third part of a
famous treatise called More Nevochim, of the Rabbi Mosrs Maimon-
IDES: of whom only to say (as is his common Encomium) that he
was the first of the Rabbins who left off trifling, is a poor and
invidious commendation. Thither I refer the impartial reader ; rely-
ing on his justice to believe that I mean to charge myself with no
* See this reasoning inforced, and explained more at large in the proof of the next
proposition. + Mark x. 5; Matt. xix. 8. } This is still farther seen from
God’s being pleased to be considered hy them as a local tutelary Deity « which, when
we come to that point, we shall shew was the prevailing superstition of those times.
312 . THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
more of Spencer’s opinions than what directly tend to the proof of
this part of my Proposition, by shewing, That there is a great and
surprizing relation and resemblance between the Jewish and Egyptian
rites, in circumstances both opposite and similar.
I ask nothing unreasonable of the reader, when I desire him to
admit of this as proved; since the learned Herman Wirtstus in a
book professedly written to confute the hypothesis of Maimonides
and Spencer, confesses the fact in the fullest and amplest manner.*
What is it then (a stranger to Controversy would be apt to inquire)
which this learned man addresses himself, in a large quarto volume, to
confute? It is the plain and natural consequence of this resem-
blance, namely, That the Jewish Ritual was given partly in compliance
to the People’s prejudices, and partly in opposition to Egyptian super-
stitions ; the Proposition we undertake to prove. Witsius thinks,
or is rather willing to think, that the Egyptian Ritual was invented in
imitation of the Jewish. For the reader sees, that both sides are
agreed in this, That either the Jews borrowed from the Egyptians, or
the Egyptians from the Jews; so strong is the resemblance which
forces this confession from them.
Now, the only plausible support of Witsius’s party being a thing
taken for granted, viz. that the rites and customs of the Egyptians, as
delivered by the Greeks, were of much later original than these
writers assign to them; and my discourse on the ANTIQUITIES OF
Eeypr, in the preceding section, proving it to be entirely groundless ;
the latter part of the proposition, viz. That many of the laws given to
the Jews, by the ministry of Moses, were instituted partly in com-
pliance to their prejudices, and partly in opposition to Egyptian super-
stitions, is sufficiently proved.
But to let nothing that hath the appearance of an argument remain
unanswered, I shall, in as few words as may be, examine this opinion,
That the Egyptians borrowed from the Israelites ; regarding both
Nations in that very light in which holy Scripture hath placed them.
The periods then in which this must needs be supposed to have
happened, are one or other of these. . 1. The time of Abraham’s
residence in Egypt. 2.—ofJoseph’s government. 3.—of the slavery
* Ita auten commodissime me processurum ewistimo, δὲ primo longa exemplorum
inductione ex doctissimorum virorum mente, et eorum plerumque verbis, demonstravero,
MAGNAM ATQUE MIRANDAM PLANE CONVENIENTIAM IN RELIGIONIS NEGOTIO VETERES
INTER AGYPTIOS ATQUE HEBRHOS ESSE. Que cum fortuita esse non possit, necesse
est ut vel Agyptii sua ab Hebreis, vel ex adverso Hebrei sua ab Aigyptiis habeant. And
again: Porro, si, levato antiquitatis obscurioris velo, gentium omnium ritus oculis
vigitantibus intueamur, Aigyptios et Hebrzos, PRE OMNIBUS ALIIS moribus SIMILLIMOS
Suisse comperiemus. Neque hoe Kircherum fefellit, cujus hac sunt verba: Hebriei
tantam habent ad ritus, sacrilicia, cwerimonias, sacras disciplinas Algyptiormm afiinita-
tem, ut vel Agyptios hebraizantes, vel Hebraos agyptizantes fuisse, plane mihi persua-
deam.— Sed quid verbis opus est? in rem presentem veniamus, [Aegyptiaca, p. 4.] And
sv he goes on to transcribe, from Spencer and Marsham, all the eminent particulars of
that resemblance.
SECT. Vi. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 313
t
of his, and his brethren’s descendants: or, 4. Any indefinite time
after their egression from Egypt.
Now not to insist on the utter improbability of a potent nation’s
borrowing its religious Rites from a private Family, or from a People
they held in slavery; [ answer, that of these four periods, the three
first are beside the question. For the characteristic resemblance
insisted on, is that which we find between the Egyptian ritual, and
what is properly called mosarcaL. And let it not be said, that we
are unable to distinguish the Rites which were purely LEGAL from
such as were PATRIARCHAL:* for Moses, to add the greater force
and efficacy to the whole of his Institution, hath been careful te
record each specific Rite which was properly Patriarchal.
Thus, though Moses enjoined crrcumcrsion, he hath been careful
to record the patriarchal institution of it with all its cireumstances—
Moses gave unto you circumcision (not because it is of Moses, but of
the fathers) says Jesus.¢ So again, where he institutes the Jewish
sabbath of rest, he records the patriarchal observance of it, in these
words :—JIn six days the Lord made heaven and earth, Se. and rested
the seventh day, wherefore the Lord blessed the sabbath day and
hallowed it.t
The last period then only remains to be considered, namely, from
the Egression. Now at that time and from thence-forward, we say,
the Egyptians would not borrow of the Israelites, for these two plain
and convincing reasons. 1. They held the Israelites in the greatest
contempt, and abhorrence, as SHEPHERDS, SLAVES, and ENEMIES,
men who had brought a total devastation on their Country: and had
embraced a Religion whose Ritual daily treated the Gods of Aigypt
with the utmest ignominy and despite.§ But people never borrow
their religious Rites from those towards whom they stand in such
inveterate distance. 2. It was part of the Religion of the old Egyp-
tians to borrow from none: || most certainly, not from the Jews.
This is the account we have, of their natural disposition, from those
Ancients who have treated of their manners. While, on the other
hand, we are assured from infallible authority that the Israelites, of
the time of Moses, were in the very extreme of a contrary humour,
and were for BORROWING all they could lay their hands on. This is
so notorious, that I was surprised to find the learned Witsius attempt
* See note PPPP, at the end of this book. + Jobn vii. 22. And see note
QQQQ, at the end of this book. 1 Exod. xx. }l. And see note RRRR, at
the end of this book. § See Spencer, De Legibus Heb. Rit. vol. i. p. 296.
|| A gyptit detestari videntur quicquid ot γονεῖς οὐ wapédeitav, parentes non common-
strarunt.—Witsu Atgyptiaca, p. 6. Πατρίοισι δὲ χρεώμενοι νόμοισι. ἄλλον οὐδένα
ἐπιικκτέωνται.--- HERODOT. lib. ii. cap, 78. Ἑλληνικοῖσι δὲ νομαίοισι φεύγουσι χρᾶσθαι"
τὸ δὲ σύμπαν εἰπεῖν. μηδ ΑΛΛΩΝ MHAAMA MHAAMON ἀνθρώπων νομαίοισι. οἱ
μὲν νῦν ἄλλοι Αἰγύπτιοι οὕτω τοῦτο φυλάσσουσι.--- (ἀρ. 91.
“814 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
to prove, that the Egyptians were greatly inclined to borrowing : *
but much more surprised with his arguments; which are these.
1. Clemens Alex. says, that it was the custom of the Barbarians, and
particularly the Egyptians, to honour their legislators and benefactors
as Gods. 2. Diodorus Siculus confirms this account, where he says,
that the Egyptians were the most grateful of all mankind to their
benefactors. And 3. The same historian tells us, that when Egypt
was become a province to Persia, the Egyptians deified Darius, while
yet alive; which honour they never had done to any other king.t
—This is the whole of his evidence to prove the Egyptian genius so
greatly inclined to foreign Rites. Nor should I have exposed the
nakedness of this learned and honest man, either in this place or in
any other, but for the use which hath been made of his authority ; of
which more hereafter. But Witsius, and those in his way of think-
ing, when they talk of the Egyptians’ borrowing Hebrew rites, seem
to have entertained a wrong idea of that highly policied People. It
was not in ancient Egypt, as in ancient Greece, where every private
man, who had travelled for it, found himself at liberty to set up what
lying vanity he pleased. _ For in that wary Monarchy, Religion was in
the hand of the magistrate, and under the inspection of the Public:
so that no private novelties could be introduced, had the people been
as much disposed, as they were indeed averse, to innovations; and
that any public ones would be made, by rites borrowed from the
Hebrews, is, as we have shewn above, highly improbable.
Hitherto I have endeavoured to discredit this proposition, (that the
Egyptians borrowed of the Israelites) from the nature of the thing.
I shall now shew the falshood of it, from the infallible testimony of
Gop himself: who upbraiding the Israelites with their borrowing
idolatrous Rites of all their neighbours, expresses himself in this
manner, by the prophet Ezekiel: The contrary is in thee from other
* His words are these: Magna quidem laterum contentione reclamat Doctissimus
Spencerus, prorsusgue incredibile esse contendit, consideruto gentis utriusque genio, ut
ab Hebreis Aigyptii in suam tam multa religionem adsciverint. At quod ipsi incredibile
videtur, id miht, post alios eruditione atque judicio clarissimos, perquam probabile est :
ipso AEGYPTIORUM 1D SUADENTE GENIO. In co quippe prestantissimi Auctores
consentiunt, solitos fuisse A2gyptios maxima eos existimatione prosequi, quos sapi-
entia atque virtute excellentiores cernerent, et a quibus se ingentibus benefictis affectos
esse meminerant : adeo quidem ut ejusmodi mortales, non defunctos solum, sed et super-
stites, pro Diis haberent.—Lib. iii. cap, 12, p. 262. + ‘Clemens Alexandrinus
clarum esse dicit, Barbaros eximie semper honorasse suos legumlatores et preceptores
Deos ipsos appellantes.—\nter Barbaros autem maxime id prestiterunt Agyptii. Quin
etiam genus AAgyptium diligentissime illos in Deos retulit. Assentitur Diodorus ;
Ai yyptios denique supra cateros Mortales quicquid bene de ipsis meretur grata mente
prosequi affirmant.—Neque popularibus modo suis atque indigenis—sed Peregrinis—
Facit hue Darii Persarum regis exemplum, quod Diodori iterum verbis exponam. Tan-
dem Darius legibus Algyptiorum animum appulisse dicitur-—Nam cum Sacerdotibus
Aiygypti familiaritatem init, §c.—Propterea tantwm honoris consecutus est, ut superstes
adhuc Divi appellationem quod nulli regum aliorum contigit, promeruerit.”—Lib., iii.
cap. 12, p. 263.
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 315
Women, WHEREAS NONE FOLLOWETH THEE TO COMMIT WHORE-
poms: and in that thou givest a reward, and no reward is given to
thee, therefore thou art contrary.* The intelligent reader perceives
that the plain meaning of the metaphor is this, Ye Jews are contrary
to all other nations : you are fond of borrowing their Rites, while none
of them care to borrow yours. But this remarkable fact, had it not
been so expresly delivered, might easily have been collected from the
whole course of sacred history. The reason will be accounted for
hereafter. At present I shall only need to observe, that by the
words, Whereas none followeth thee to commit whoredoms, is not
meant, that no particular Gentile ever embraced the Jewish religion ;
but, that no Gentile people took in any of its Rites into their own
national Worship. That this is the true sense of the passage, appears
from hence, 1. The idolatry of the community of Israel is here
spoken of: and this, as will be shewn in the next book, did not con-
sist in renouncing the Religion of Moses, but in polluting it with
idolatrous mixtures. 2. The embracing the Jewish religion, and
renouncing idolatry, could not, in figurative propriety, be called
committing whoredom, though polluting the Jewish Rites, by taking
them into their own superstitions, gives elegance to the figure thus
applied.
The Reader, perhaps, may wonder how men can stand out against
such kind of evidence. It is not, I will assure him, from the abun-
dance of argument on the other side; or from their not seeing the
force on this ; but from a pious, and therefore very excusable, appre-
hension of danger to the Divinity of the Law, if it should be once
granted that any of the Ceremonial part was given in compliance to
the people’s prejudices. Of which imaginary danger lord Boling-
broke hath availed himself, to calumniate the Law, for a COMPLIANCE
too evident to be denied.
The apprehension therefore of this consequence being that which
makes Believers so unwilling to own, and Deists, against the very
genius of their infidelity, so ready to embrace an evident truth; I
seem to come in opportunely to set both parties night: while I shew,
in support of my THIRD PROPOSITION, that the consequence 15
groundless ; and that the fears and hopes, built upon this supposed
compliance, are vain and fantastic: which, I venture to predict, will
ever be the issne of such fears and hopés as arise only from the
Religionist’s honest adherence to common sense and to the word of
Grod.
ΠῚ
Our THIRD PROPOSITION 15, That Moses’s Egyptian learning, and
the Laws he instituted in compliance to the People’s prejudices, and in
* Ezek. xvi. 34.
910 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
opposition to Egyptian superstitions, are no reasonable objection to the
divinity of his mission.
The first part of the Proposition concerns Moses’s Fy gyptian wisdom.
Let us previously consider what that was. Moses (says the holy
martyr Stephen) waAS LEARNED IN ALL THE WISDOM OF THE
Eeyrrians, and mighty in words and deeds.* Now where the wis-
pom of a Nation is spoken of, that which is characteristic of the
Nation must needs be meant : where the wisdom of a particular man,
that which is peculiar to his quality and profession. St. Stephen, in
this place, speaks of both. In both, therefore, he must needs mean
CIVIL or POLITICAL wisdom; because, for that (as we have shewn)
the Egyptian nation was principally distinguished: and in that con-
sisted the eminence of character of one who had a royal adoption,
was bred up at court, and became at length the Leader and Lawgiver
of a numerous People. More than this,—St. Stephen is here speak-
ing of him under this public character, and therefore he must be
necessarily understood to mean, that Moses was consummate in the
science of Legislation. The words indeed are, au the learning of the
Egyptians. But every good logician knows, that where the thing
spoken of refers to some particular use (as here, Moses’s LEARNING,
to his conpuctTiNG the Israelites out of Egypt) the particle att does
not mean all of every kind, but all the parts of one kind. In this
restrained sense, it is frequently used in the sacred Writings. Thus
in the Gospel of St. John, Jesus says, When he, the spirit of truth, is
come, he will guide you into aux truth.+ But further, the concluding
part of the character,—and mighty in worvs and peEps, will not
easily suffer the foregoing part to admit of any other interpretation ;
ἣν δὲ δυνατὸς ἐν AOTOIS καὶ ἐν EPYOIS. This was the precise
character of the aNctENT CureF: who leading a free and willing
People, needed the arts of peace, such as PERSUASION and LAW-
MAKING, the AOTOI; and the arts of war, such as conpucT and
couRAGE, the EPIA in the text. Hence it is, that Jesus, who was
The prophet like unto Moses, the Legislator of the new covenant as
the other was of the o/d, and the Conductor of our spiritual warfare,
is characterised in the same words, δυνατὸς ἐν ΕΡΓΩ, καὶ AOTQ:
ἐναντίον τοῦ ΘΕΟΥ͂ καὶ παντὸς τοῦ Auxod.[—A prophet, mighty in
DEED and ΟΚΡ, before Gop and all the ββορι5. This wisdom,
therefore, in which Moses was said to be versed, we conclude, was the
τὸ πραγματικὸν τῆς φιλοσοφίας, in contradistinction to the τὸ
δεωρητικόν. Wence may be seen the impertinence of those long
inquiries, which, on occasion of these words, men have run into,
concerning the state of the speculative and mechanic arts of Egypt,
at this period.
*
Acts vii, 22. + John xvi. 13. t Luke xxiv. 19.
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. » ols
This being the wispom, for which Moses is here celebrated, the
Deist hastily concluded, that therefore the establishment of the Jewish
Policy was the sole contrivance of Moses himself ; We did not reflect,
that a fundamental truth (which he will not venture to dispute any
more than the Believer) stands very much in the way of his conclu-
sion; namely, That Gon, in the moral government of the world, never
does that in an extraordinary way which can be equally well effected
in an ordinary.
In the separation of the Israelites, a civil Policy and a national
Religion were to be established, and incorporated with one another,
by God himself. For that end, he appointed an under-agent, or
instrument: who, in this work of Legislation, was either to under-
stand the government of a People, and so, be capable of comprehend-
ing the general plan delivered to him by Gop, for the erection of this
extraordinary Policy: -or else he was not to understand the govern-
ment of a People, and so, God himself, in the execution of his plan,
was, at every step, to interfere, and direct the ignorance and inability
of his Agent. Now, as this perpetual interposition might be spared
by the choice of an able Leader, we conclude, on the maxim laid
down, that Gop would certainly employ such an one in the execution
of his purpose.
There was yet another, and that no slight expediency, in such a
Leader. The Israelites were a stubborn People, now first forming
into Civil government ; greatly licentious ; and the more so, for their
just coming out of a state of slavery. Had Moses therefore been so
unequal to his designation, as to need Gon’s direction at every turn
to set him right, he would soon have lost the authority requisite for
keeping an unruly multitude in awe ; and have sunk into such con-
tempt amongst them, as must have retarded their designed establish-
ment.
But it will be said, “if there wanted so able a Chief at the first
setting up of a THEOCRACY, there would still be the same want,
though not in an equal degree, during the whole continuance of that
divine form of government.” It is likely there would, because I find,
Gop did make a proper provision for it ; first in the erection of the
SCHOOLS OF THE PROPHETS: and afterwards, in the establishment
of the GREAT SANHEDRIM, which succeeded them. But sacred his-
tory mentioning these Schools of the prophets, and the assembly of the
Seventy elders, only occasionally, the accounts we have of both are
very short and imperfect. Which is the reason why interpreters, who
have not well weighed the causes of that occasional mention, have
suffered themselves to be greatly misled by the Rabbins.
I. The most particular account we have of the Schools of the pro-
phets is in the first book of Samuel, and on this occasion: David, in his
318 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
escape from the rage of Saul, fled to his protector, Samuel, who then
presided over a School of the prophets, at Naioth in Ramah.* When
this was told to Saul, he sent messengers in pursuit of him.t And,
on the ill success of their errand, went afterwards himself.t But as
it was the intent of the historian, in this mention of the Schools of the
_ Prophets, only to acquaint us with the effect they had on Saul and
his messengers, when the spirit of Gop came upon them, we have
only a partial view of these Collegiate bodies, that is, a view of them
while at their DEvorions only, and not at their srupres. For Saul
and his messengers coming when the Society was prophesying,§ or at
divine worship, the spirit of Gop fell upon them, and they prophesied
also. And thus the Chal. Par. understands prophesying, as did the
apostolic writers, who use the word in the same sense, of adoring
God, and singing praises unto him. For we may well suppose these
Societies began and ended all their daily studies with this holy
exercise.
But from hence, writers of contrary parties have fallen into the
same strange and absurd opinion ; while they imagined that, because
these Schools were indeed nurseries of the Prophets, that therefore
they were places of instruction for I dan’t know what kind of arr or
PROPHECY. Spinoza borrowed this senseless fancy from the Rabbins,
and hath delivered it down to his followers ; || from whence they con-
clude that PROPHECY was amongst the mechanic arts of the Hebrews.
But an inquirer of either common sense or common honesty would
have seen it was a College for the study of the Jewish Law only;
and, as such, naturally and properly, a seminary of Prophets. For
those who were most knowing as well as zealous in the Law, were
surely the most fit to convey Gop’s commands to his People.
This account of the nature of the Schools of the prophets helps to
shew us how it became a proverb in Israel, Is SauL ALSO AMONGST
THE PropHets? 4 which, I apprehend, has been commonly mis-
taken. The proverb was used to express a thing unlooked for and
unlikely. But surely the spirit of God falling occasionally on their
supreme Magistrate, at a time when it was so plentifully bestowed on
private men, could be no such unexpected matter to the people; who
knew too, that even Idolaters and Gentiles had partaken of it, while
concerned in matters which related to their Oeconomy. But more
than this, They could not be ignorant that the spirit of God had
usually made its abode with Saul; as appears from the following
words of the sacred historian, But the spirit of the Lord departed
Srom Saul, and an evil spirit from the Lord troubled him.** From all
* 1 Sam. xix. 18. + Verse 21. t Verse 23. § Verse 20. || See
note SSSS, at the end of this book. q 1 Sam. xix. 24. ** 1 Sam. xvi. 14.
—And see note TTTT, at the end of this book.
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 319
this I conclude that the people’s surprise, which occasioned this pro-
verb, was not because they heard the spirit of God had fallen upon
him: but a very different reason, which I shall now endeavour to
explain.
Sau, with many great qualities, both of a public man and a pri-
vate, and in no respect an unable Chief, was yet so poorly prejudiced
in favour of the human Policies of the neighbouring Nations, as to
become impiously cold and negligent in the support and advancement
of the Law or Gon; though raised to regal power from a low and
obscure condition, for this very purpose. He was, in a word, a mere
Politician, without the least zeal or love for the divine constitution of
his Country. This was his great, and no wonder it should prove his
unpardonable crime. For his folly had reduced things to that
extremity that either He must fall, or the Law. Now, this Pagan
turn of mind was no secret to the People. When, therefore, they
were told that he had sent frequent messengers to the supreme School
of the prophets, where zeal for the Law was so eminently professed ;
and had afterwards gone himself thither, and entered with divine rap-
tures and extasy into their devotions ; they received this extraordinary
news with all the wonder and amazement it deserved. And, in the
height of their surprise, they cried out, Is Saul also amongst the pro-
phets? 1. 6. Is Saul, who throughout his whole reign, hath so much
slighted and contemned the Law, and would conduct all his actions
by the mere rules of human Policy, is he at length become studious
of and zealous for the Law of God? And the miracle, of such a
change in a Politician, brought it into a proverb before the mistake
was found out.
This matter will receive farther light from what we are told, in the
same story, concerning Davip; a man of so opposite a character,
with regard to his sentiments of the Law, that it appears to have
been for this difference only that he was decreed by Gop to succeed
the other, in his kingdom. Now David, the story tells us, sojourned
for some time in this School.—So David fled and escaped, and came
to Samuel at Ramah, and told him all that Saul had done to him, and
HE AND SAMUEL WENT AND DWELT IN Naroru.* And here it
was, as we may reasonably conclude, that he so greatly cultivated and
improved his natural disposition of love and zeal for the Law, as to
merit that most glorious of all titles, ΤῊΣ MAN AFTER GOD'S OWN
HEART ; for, till now, his way of life had been very distant from
accomplishments of this nature ; his childhood and youth were spent
in the country ; and his early manhood in camps and courts.t But
it is of importance to the cause of truth to know, that this cHARAC-
TER was not given him for his PRIVATE morals, but his pusuic ; his
* 1 Sam. xix. 18. + See note UUUU, at the end of this book.
320 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
zeal for the advancement of the glory of the THrocracy. This is
seen from the first mention of him under this appellation, by Samuel,
who tells Saul—But now thy kingdom shall not continue.-—The Lord
hath sought him A MAN AFTER HIS OWN HEART, and the Lord hath
commanded him to be Captain over his people.* And again, God
himself says, I have chosen Jerusalem that my name might be there,
and have chosen Davin to be over my people Israel.t Here David’s
vicegerency, we see, is represented to be as necessary to the support
of the Oeconomy, as God’s peculiar residence in Jerusalem. Con-
formably to these ideas it was, that Hosea, prophesying of the restora-
tion of the Jews, makes the God of Israel and his Vicegerent
inseparable parts of the Oeconomy.—<dfterwards shall the children
of Israel return, and seek the Lorpv their Gov and Davin their
Kine ; { i. 6. they shall have the same zeal for the dispensation
which king David had; and on account of which they shall honour
his memory. Now if we would but seek for the reason of this pre-
eminence, in David’s pudlic, not in his private character, we should
see it afforded no occasion of scandal. His zeal for the Law was
constantly the same: as is manifest by this distinguishing cireum-
stance, that he never-fell into Idolatry. But the phrase itself, of @
man after God’s own heart, is best explained in the case of Samuel.
Ex the prophet was rejected, and Samuet put in his place just in
the same manner that Davip superseded Saux. On this occasion,
when God’s purpose was denounced to Eli, we find it expressed in
the same manner, dad I will raise me up a faithful priest, THAT
SHALL DO ACCORDING TO THAT WHICH IS IN MINE HEART.|{
What was then iz God’s heart (to speak in the language of humanity)
the context tells us, The establishment of his Dispensation. Thus, we
see, the man after God’s own heart, is the man who seconds God’s
views in the support of the Theocracy. No other virtue was here in
question. Though in an indefinite way of speaking, where the sub-
ject is only the general relation of man to God, no one can, indeed, be
ealled a man after God’s own heart, but he who uses his best endea-
vours to imitate Ged’s purity as far as miserable humanity will allow,
in the uniform practice of every virtue.
By this time, therefore, [ presume, the serious Reader will be dis-
posed to take for just what it is worth, that refined observation of
the noble author of the Characteristics, where he says, “It is not
possible, by the muse’s art, to make that royal Hero appear amiable
in human eyes, who found such favour in the eye of Heaven. Such
are mere human hearts, that they can hardly find the least sympathy
with that onrty one which had the character of being after the
* 1 Sam. xiii. ]4. + 2 Chron. vi. 6. 1 Hosea iii. 5. § See note
X XXX, at the end of this book. 1 Sam. ii. 35,
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 321
pattern of the Almighty.”*—His lordship seems willing to make any
thing the test of truth, but that only which has a claim to it, RIGHT
REASON. Sometimes this fest is RIDICULE; here, it is the ART OF
POETRY—t is not possible (says he) for the muse’s art to make that
royal Hero appear amiable in human eyes. Therefore, because
Davip was not a character to be managed by the Poet, for the Hero
of a fiction, he was not a fit instrument in the hands of God, to sup-
port a Theocracy : and having nothing amiable in the eyes of our
noble Critic, there could be nothing in him to make him acceptable
to his Maker. But when classical criticism goes beyond its bounds,
it is liable to be bewildered: as here. The noble Author assures us
that David was the only man characterised, to be AFTER Gop’s OWN
HEART, whereas we see the very same character is given of Samuel ;
and both honoured with this glorious appellation for the same reason.
II. As for the GREAT SANHEDRIM, it seems to have been established
after the failure of Prophecy. And concerning the members of this
body, the Rabbins tell us, there was a tradition, that they were
bound to be skilled in all sciences.t So far is certain, that they
extended their jurisdiction to the judging of doctrines and opinions,
as appears by their deputation to Jesus, to know by what authority
he did his great works. And as the address of our blessed Saviour
ou this occasion deserves well to be illustrated, I shall set down the
occurrence as it is recorded by St. Matthew :—‘‘ When he was come
into the temple, the chief priests and the elders of the people came
unto him as he was teaching, and said, By what authority dost thou
these things? And who gave thee this authority? And Jesus
answered and said unto them, I also will ask you one thing, which
if you tell me, I in like wise will tell you by what authority I do
these things. The baptism of John, whence was it ?* from heaven, or
of men? And they reasoned with themselves saying, If we shall say
from heaven, he will say unto us, Why did ye not then believe him?
But if we shall say of men, we fear the people : for all hold Johnas a
prophet. And they answered Jesus and said, We cannot tell. And he
said unto them, Neither tell [ you by what authority I do these
things.’t We are not to suppose this to be a captious evasion of a
question made by those whose authority he did not acknowledge.
On the contrary, it was a direct reply to an acknowledged jurisdiction,
(as Jesus was obedient to all the institutions of his country) con-
vincing them that the question needed not, even on the principles of
that jurisdiction, any precise answer. They sent to him to know the
authority on which he acted. He asks them whether they had yet
determined of John’s: they say, they had not. Then replies Jrsus,
* « Advice to an Author,” vol. i. sect. 3. 1 See Smitn’s “Select Discourses,’
p. 258. { Matt. xxi. 23, et seq.
VOL, 11. Y
322 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
“1 need not tell you my authority ; since the Sanhedrim’s not having
yet determined of John’s, shews such a determination unnecessary ;
or at least, since (both by John’s account and mine) he is represented
as the fore-runner of my mission, it is fit to begin with his preten-
sions first.” The address and reasoning of this reply are truly
divine.
The foregoing observations. concerning this method of divine wis-
dom, in the establishment 6f the Jewish Theocracy, will be much
supported, if we contrast it with that which Providence was pleased
to take in the propagation of Christianity.
The blessed Jesus came down to teach mankind a spiritual Reli-
gion, the object of each individual as such; and offered to their
acceptance on the sole force of its own evidence. The Propagators
of this religion had no need to be endowed with worldly authority
or learning ; for here was no Body of men to be conducted ; nor no
civil Policy or government to be erected or administered. Had
Jesus, on the contrary, made choice of the Great and Learned for
this employment, they had discredited their own success. It might
have been then objected, that the Gospel had made its way by the
aid of human power or sophistry. ΤῸ preserve, therefore, the splen-
dour of its evidence unsullied, the meanest and most illiterate of a
barbarous people were made choice of for the instruments of Gon’s
last great Revelation to mankind: armed with no other power but
of Miracles, and that only for the credence of their mission; and
with no other wisdom but of Truth, and that only to be proposed
freely to the understandings of Particulars. St. Paul, who had
fathomed the mysterious depths of divine wisdom under each Oeco-
nomy, was so penetrated with the view of this last Dispensation, that
he breaks out into this rapturous and triumphant exclamation, Where
is the Wise? Where is the Scribe? Where is the Disputer of this
world? Hath not God made foolish the wisdom of this world ?*
But further, Divine wisdom so wonderfully contrived, that the
inability and ignorance of the Propagators of Christianity were as
useful to the advancement of this Religion, as the authority and wis-
dom of the Leader of the Jews were for the establishment of theirs.
I shall only give one instance out of many which will occur to an
attentive reader of the Evangelic history.
When Jesus had chosen these mean and weak instruments of his
power, he suffered them to continue in their national prejudices
concerning his Character; the nature of his kingdom;*and the
extent of his jurisdiction ; as the sole human means of keeping them
attached to his service, not only during the course of their attendance
on his ministry, but for some time after his resurrection, and the
* 1 Cor. i. 20.
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 393
descent of the Holy Ghost upon them; that Power which was to
lead them into all truth ; but by just and equal steps. Let us see the
use of this, in the following circumstance: From the order of the
whole of Gon’s Dispensation to mankind, as laid down in Scripture,
we learn, that the offer of the Gospel was to be first fairly made to
the Jews; and then afterwards to the Gentiles. Now when, soon
after the ascension of our Lord, the Church was forced, by the per-
secution of the Synagogue, to leave Judea, and to disperse itself
through all the regions round about; had the Apostles, on this dis-
persion, been fully instructed in the design of Gop to call the Gen-
tiles into his church, resentment for their ill usage within Judea, and
the small prospect of better success amongst those who were without,
which they of Jerusalem had prejudiced against the Gospel, would
naturally have disposed them to turn immediately to the Gentiles.
By which means Gon’s purpose, without a supernatural force upon
their minds, had been defeated ; as so great a part of the Jews would
not have had the Gospel first preached unto them. But now pushed
on by this commodious prejudice, that the benefits “belonged properly
to the race of Abraham, they directly addressed themselves to their
brethren of the dispersion: where meeting with the same ill success,
their sense of the desperate condition of the house of Israel would
now begin to abate that prejudice in their favour. And then came
the time to enlighten them in this matter, without putting too great
a force upon their minds; which is not Gop’s way of acting with
free agents. Accordingly, his purpose of calling the Gentiles into
the Church was now clearly revealed to Perrer at Joppa; and a
proper subject, wherewith to begin this great work, was ready pro-
vided for him.
But though ignorance in the Propagator of a divine truth amongst
particulars may serve to these important ends, yet to shew still
plainer how pernicious this inability would be wherever a Society is
concerned, as in the establishment of the Jewish Religion, I shall
produce an occasional example even in the Christian.
For when now so great numbers of the Gentiles were converted to
Curist, that it became necessary to form them into a Church ; that
is, areligious Society ; which of course hath its Policy as well as the
Civil; so hurtful was ignorance in its governing members, that divers
of them, though graced with many gifts of the holy Spirit, caused
such disorders in their assemblies as required all the abilities of the
LEARNED ApostLe to reform and regulate. And then it was, and
for this purpose, that Paut, the proper Apostle of the Gentiles,* was,
in an extraordinary manner, called in, to conduct, by his learning and
* The gospel of the uncircumcision was committed unto me, as the gospel of the circum-
cision was unto Peter. (Gal. ii. 7.)
oO
Sa
924 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
abilities, and with the assistance of his companion Luxs, a learned
man also, this part of Gon’s purpose to its completion. The rest
were properly Apostles of the Jews ; which people having a religious
Society already formed, the converts from thence had a kind of rule
to go by, which served them for their present occasions ; and there-
fore these needed no great talents of parts or learning; nor had they
any. But a new Society was to be formed amongst the Gentile con-
verts ; and this required an able conductor; and such an one they
had in Paul. But will any one say that his learning afforded an
objection against the divinity of his mission? We conclude therefore,
that none can arise from the abilities, natural and acquired, of the
great Jewish Lawgiver. The point to be proved.
II. We come now to the second part of the Proposition, That the
Laws instituted in compliance to the People’s prejudices, and in oppo-
sition to Egyptian superstitions, are no reasonable objection to the
divinity of the Jewish Religion. That most of these Laws were given
in opposition to Egyptian superstitions, believers seem not unwilling
to allow; as apprehending no consequence from such a concession
that will give them trouble. The thing which startles them is the
Supposition that some of these Laws were given in compliance to the
Jewish prejudices ; because infidels have inforced this circumstance
to the discredit of Moses’s pretensions. ΤῸ satisfy believers there-
fore, I shall shew, “that the Laws in compliance were a consequence
of the Laws in opposition.” And to reconcile them to both sorts,
I shall attempt to prove, from the double consideration of their
NECESSITY and FiTNeEss, that the institution of such Laws is no
reasonable objection to the divinity of their original.
I. If Gop did indeed interfere in the concerns of this People, it
will, I suppose, be easily granted, that his purpose was to separate
them from the contagion of that universal idolatry, which had now
overspread the whole earth ; and to which, especially to the Eeyp-
TIAN, they were most inveterately prone.
There were two ways, in the hand of Gon, for effecting this sepa-
ration: either to overrule the Will; and this required only the exer-
cise of his power: or, by leaving the Will at liberty, to counterwork
the passions ; and this required the exercise of his wispoM.
Now, as all the declared purposes of this separation shew, that
Gop acted with the Israelites as MORAL AGENTS, we must needs
conclude, notwithstanding the peculiar favour by which they were
elected, and the extraordinary providence by which they were con-
ducted, that yet, amidst all this display and blaze of almighty Power,
the wiLL ever remained free and uncontrolled. This not only
appears from the nature of the thing, but from the whole history of
their reduction out of Egypt. To give only one instance: Moses
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 325
tells us, that Gop led the Israelites into the land of Canaan, not by
the direct way of the Philistines, lest the sight of danger, in an
expedition against a strong and warlike People, should make them
chtse to return to Egypt, and seek for refuge in their slavery: But
he led them about, by the way of the Wilderness, to inure them by
degrees to fatigue and hardships; the best foundation of military
prowess.* And when Gop, to punish them for their cowardice, on
the report of the faithless explorers of the land, had decreed that
that generation should be worn away in the Wilderness,t the wise
policy of this sentence was as conspicuous as the justice of it.
If then the Wills of this people were to be left free, and their
minds influenced only by working on their passions, it is evident, that
Gop, when he became their Lawgiver, would act by the same policy
in use amongst human Lawgivers for restraining the vicious inclina-
tions of the People. The same, I say, in kind, though differing
infinitely in degree. For all People, whether conducted on divine or
human measures, having the same nature, the same liberty of Will,
and the same terrestrial situation, must needs require the same mode
of guidance. And, in fact, we find the Jewish to be indeed consti-
tuted like other Civil governments, with regard to the integral parts
of a Political society.
According to all human conception therefore, we see no way left to
keep such a People, thus separated, free from the contagion of idol-
atry, but,
First, by severe penal Laws against idolaters ;
And, Secondly, by framing a multifarious Ritual, whose whole
direction, looking contrary to the forbidden superstitions, would, by
degrees, wear out the present fondness for them; and at length bring
on an habitual aversion to them. This is the way of wise Lawgivers ;
who, in order to keep the Will from revolting, forbear to do every
thing by direct force and fear of punishment ; but employ, where
they can, the gentler methods of restraint.
Thirdly, but as even in the practice of this gentler method, when
the passions and prejudices run high, a direct and professed opposi-
tion will be apt to irritate and inflame them; therefore it will be
further necessary, in order to break and elude their violence, to turn
men’s fondness for the forbidden practice into a harmless channel ;
and by indulging them in those customs, which they could not well
abuse to superstition, enable the more severe and opposite institutions
to perform their work. Such, for instance, might be the lighting up
of lamps in religious Worship : which practice, Clemens Alexandrinus
assures us, came first from the Egyptians: t nor would Witsius him-
* Exod. xiii. 17. + Num. xiii. xiv. t Αἰγύπτιοι λύχνους καίειν WPATOL
κατέδειξαν. -- Strom. lib. i. p. 306, edit. Colon. 1688, fol.
920 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
self venture to deny it.* But, for the same reason, we conclude
that the brazen serpent was no imitation of an Egyptian practice, as
Sir J. Marsham would persuade us; because we see how easily it
might, and did suffer abuse. Which conclusion, not only our prin-
ciple leads us to make, but matter of fact enables us to prove.t
Such a conduct therefore as this, where the Will is left free, appears
to be NECESSARY.
II. Let us see next whether it were Fit, that is, Whether it agreed
with the wisdom, dignity, and purity of Gop.
1. His wispom indeed is the Attribute peculiarly manifested in this
method of government; and certainly with as great lustre as we
should have seen his power, had it been his good pleasure to have
_ over-ruled the Will. To give an instance only in one particular, most
liable to the ridicule of unbelievers; I mean, in that part of the
Jewish Institute which concerns clean and unclean meats; and
descends to so low and minute a detail, that men, ignorant of the
nature and end of this regulation, have, on its apparent unfitness to
engage the concern of Gop, concluded against the divine original of
the Law. But would they reflect, that the purpose of separating one
People from the contagion of ‘universal idolatry, and this, in order to
facilitate a still greater good, was a design not unworthy the Governor
of the Universe, they would see this part of the Jewish Institution in
a different light: They would see the brightest marks of divine
wisdom in an injunction which took away the very grounds of all
commerce with foreign Nations. For those who can neither eat nor
drink together, are never likely to become intimate. This will open
to us the admirable method of divine Providence in Prrer’s vision.
The time was now come that the Apostle should be instructed in
Gon’s purpose of calling the Gentiles into the Church: At the hour
of repast, therefore, he had a scenical representation of all kind of
meats, clean and unclean; of which he was bid to take and eat
indifferently and without distinction.t The primary design of this
vision, as appears by the context, was to inform him that the partition-
wall was now broken down, and that the Gentiles were to be received
into the church of Curist. But besides its figurative meaning, it
had a literal ; and signified, that the distinction of MEATS, as well as
of MEN, was now to be abolished. And how necessary such an infor-
mation was, when he was about to go upon his mission to the
Gentiles, and was to conciliate their benevolence and good-will, I have
observed above. But although this was the principal cause of the
distinction of meats into clean and unclean, yet another was certainly
* 6 . κ ὅς, . *
Earum [lucernarum] prima ad religionem accensio, utrum Hebreis debeatur, an
Egyptiis, haud facile dixero.”’— A’ gyptiaca, p. 190. t See above. 1 Acts x.
10, et seq.
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. oot
for the preservation of health. This institution was of necessity to be
observed in the first case, to secure the great object of a separation :
and in the second case (which is no trivial mark of the wisdom of the
Institutor) it might be safely and commodiously observed. by a People
thus separated, who were consequently to be for ever confined within
the limits of one country. And here the absurdity of this part of
Mahometanism evidently betrays itself. Mahomet would needs imitate
the Law of Moses, as in other things, so in this the distinction of
meats, clean and unclean; without considering that in a Religion
formed for conquest, whose followers were to inhabit Regions of the
most different and contrary qualities, the food which in one climate
was hurtful or nutritive, in another changed its properties to their
contraries. But to shew still more clearly the difference between
Institutions formed at hazard, and those by divine appointment, we
may observe, that when Judaism arrived at its completion in Chris-
tianity, the followers of which were the inhabitants of all Climes, the
distinction between meats clean and unclean was abolished ; which, at
the same time, serving other great ends explained above, shew the
Dispensation (in the course of which these several changes of the
Oeconomy took place) to be really Divine.
2. As to the pigniry and Majesty of Gop, that, surely, does not
suffer, in his not interfering with his power, to force the Will, but
permitting it to be drawn and inclined by those cords of a man, his
natural motives. The dignity of any Being consists in observing a
conformity between his actions, and his quality, or station. Now it
pleased the Gop of heaven to take upon himself the office of supreme
Magistrate of the Jewish Republic. But it is (as we have shewn) the
part of a wise Magistrate to restrain a People, devoted to any pars
ticular superstition, by a Ritual directly opposite in the general to that
superstition ; and yet similar in such particular practices as could not
be abused or perverted: because compliance with the popular preju-
dices in things indifferent, naturally eludes the force of their propen-
sity to things evil. In this wise Policy, therefore, the dignity of the
Gop of heaven was not impaired.
3. Nor is his purrry any more affected by this supposed conduct.
The Rites, in question, are owned to be, in themselves, indifferent :
and good or evil only as they are directed to a true or false object.
If it be said ‘‘ that their carnal nature, or wearisome multiplicity,
or scrupulous observance, render them unworthy of the purity and
spiritual nature of Gop:” ΤῸ Believers, I reply, that this objection
holds equally against these Rites in whatever view they themselves are
wont to regard them :—To Unbelievers; that they forget, or do not
understand Gop’s primary end, in the institution of the Jewish
Ritual ; which was, to preserve the people from the contagion of these
328 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
idolatrous practices with which they were surrounded. But nothing
could be so effectual to this purpose, as such a Ritual. And since the
continual proneness of that People to idolatry hath been shewn to
arise from the inveterate prejudice of intercommunity of worship,
nothing could be so effectual as the extreme minuteness of their
Ritual.
If it be said, ‘ that the former abuse of these indulged Rites to an
abominable superstition had made them unfit to be employed in the
service of the Gop of purity: ” I reply, that there is nothing in the
nature of things, to make them unfit. That a material substance,
materially soiled, stained, and infected, is unfit to approach and be
joined to one of great cleanness and purity, is not to be denied. But
et us not mistake words for things; and draw a metaphysical con-
clusion from a metaphorical expression. The soil and stain, in the
case before us, is altogether figurative, that is, unreal. And in truth,
the very objection is taken from the command of this very Law, to
abstain from things polluted by idolatry: But we now understand,
that the reason of its so severely forbidding the use of some things
that had been abused to superstition, was the very same with its
indulging the use of others which had been equally abused ; namely,
to compass, by the best, though different yet concording means, that
one great end, the EXTIRPATION OF IDOLATRY. Notwithstanding
this, the Law concerning things polluted, like many other of the
Jewish observances, hath occasionally been adopted by different Sects
in the Christian church. Thus our Purrrans, who seem to have had
their name from the subject in debate, quarrelled with the established
use of the cross in baptism, the surplice, and the posture of commu-
nicating, because they had been abused to the support of popish
superstition.* I chuse this instance, that the Men whom I am
arguing against, may see the issue of their objection; and that They,
from whom the instance is taken, may be shewn the unreasonableness
of their separation ; as far at least as it was occasioned on account of
ceremonies.
Tf, lastly, it be said, ‘‘that these Rites, which once had been,
might be again, abused to superstition ; and were therefore unfit to be
employed in this new service ;”’ I reply, that this is a mistake. For,
1. We go on the supposition, that the Jews were indulged in no
practices capable of being so abused. 2. That though they might in
themselves be subject to abuse, yet they carried their corrective with
them: which was, first, their being intermixed with a vast number of
other Rites directly opposite to all idolatrous practice ; and, secondly,
their making part of a burdensome multifarious Worship, which would
keep the people so constantly employed, as to afford them neither
* See note YYYY, at the end of this book.
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 829
time nor occasion, from the cause in question, of falling into foreign
idolatries.
But how can I hope to be heard in defence of this conduct of the
Gop of Israel, when even the believing part of those whom I oppose
seem to pay so little attention to the reasoning of Jesus himself; who
has admirably illustrated and vindicated the wisdom of this conduct,
in the familiar parable of new cloth in old garments, and new wine in
old bottles : * which, though given in answer to a particular question,
was intended to instruct us in this general truth, That it is the way of
God to accommodate his Institutions to the state, the condition, and
contracted habits, of his creatures.
But as this notion hath been condemned “ ex cathedra;” + and the
yyptiaca of Herman Wrrsivus recommended to the clergy, as a
distinct and solid confutation of Spencer's book, de legibus Hebreorum
ritualibus ; 1 shall examine what that learned Foreigner hath to say
against it. All Witsius’ s reasoning on this point is to be found in
the fourteenth clinpter of his third book; which I shall endeavour to
pick out, and set in the fairest light.
1, His first argument is, “that it is a dishonouring of Gop, who
has the hearts of men in his power, and can turn them as he pleases,
to conceive of him as standing in need of the tricks of crafty Politi-
cians ; not but, he confesses, that Gop deals with men as reasonable
creatures, and attains his end by fit and adequate means ; and, in the
choice of these means, manifests a wisdom perfectly admirable.”
Yet, for all this, he says, “‘ we cannot, without the highest contumely,
presume to compare the sacred Policy of Heaven with the arts and
shifts of the beggarly politics of this world.’{ All I find here is
only misrepresentation. Spencer never compared the wisdom of
Gop, in the institution of the Jewish republic, to the tricks and shifts
of politicians ; but to their legitimate arts of Government, conducted
on the rules of strict morality. And if, as this writer owns, Gop
dealt with the Israelites as reasonable creatures, and attained his end
by fit and adequate means, he must needs use a wisdom the same in
* And he spake also a parable unto them, No man putteth a piece of a new garment
upon an old: if otherwise, then both the new maketh a rent, and the piece that was
taken out of the new, agreeth not with the old. And no man putteth new wine into old
bottles, else the new wine will burst the bottles, and be spilled, and the bottles shall
perish. (Luke v. 36.) + WaTERLAND’s “ Charge to the Clergy of Middlesex.”
1 “ Verum enimvero quantamcunque hee civilis prudentiz speciem habeant, preter Dei
verbum cuncta dicuntur, et humani commenta sunt ingenii, divini numinis majestate
haud satis digna. Nimirum cauti catique in seculo mortales Deum ex sua metiuntur
indole: arcanasque imperandi artes, et vaframenta politicorum, que vix terra probet,
celo locant. Quasi vero in populo sibi formando firmandoque iis astutiarum ambagibus
indigeat is, qui, mortalium corda in manu sua habens, ea, quorsum vult, flectit. Non
nego equidem Deum cum hominibus, uti cum creaturis rationalibus, agentem, media
adhibere iis persuadendis idonea, inque eorum mediorum delectu sapientiam ostendere
prorsus admirabilem. Attamen Dei sanctissima ista sapientia eum politicorum astibus
ac vafritie comparari sine insigni illius contumelia non potest.”—P. 282.
,.
330 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
kind, though vastly different in degree, with what we call human
policy. But indeed, he seems reconciled to the thing: it is the
name only which he dislikes. If his followers say otherwise, I desire
they would explain, in some intelligible manner, their idea of that
wisdom, in Gon’s civil government of a people, which is not founded
in the exercise of almighty power, and is yet different in kind from
what we call Policy.
2. His second argument is, ‘‘ That, as Gop erected a new Republic,
it was his will that it should appear new to the Israelites. Its struc-
ture was not to be patched up out of the rubbish of the Canaanitish
or Egyptian Rites, but was formed according to the model brought
down from heaven, and shewn to Moses in the Mount. Nor was it
left to the people to do the least thing in religious matters, on their
own head. All was determinately ordered, even to the most minute
circumstance ; which was so bound upon them, that they could not
do, or omit, any the least thing contrary to the Law, without becom-
ing liable to immediate punishment.”*—If, by this newness of the
Jewish Republic, be meant, that it was different in many fundamental
circumstances from all other civil policies, so as to vindicate itself to
its divine Author; I not only agree with him, but, which is more
than he and his recommender could do, have proved it. But this
sense makes nothing to the point in question. If by Newness be
meant, that it had nothing in common with any of the neighbouring
Institutions ; To make this credible, he should have proved that Gop
gave them new hearts, new natures, and a new world, along with
their new Government. There is the same ambiguity in what he says
of the appearance of newness to the Israelites. For it may signify
either that the Institution appeared so new as to be ‘seen to come
from Gop ; or that it appeared so new as not to resemble, in any of
its parts, the Institutions of men, The first is true, but not to the
purpose: the latter is to the purpose, but not true.—From the fact,
of the Law’s coming down entire from heaven, he concludes that
the genius and prejudices of the Israelites were not at all consulted :
From the same fact, I conclude, that they were consulted: which of
us has concluded right is left to the judgment of the public. Let me
only observe, That ignorant men may compose, and have composed
Laws in all things opposite to the bent and genius of a people ; and
they have been obeyed accordingly. But, when divine wisdom frames
* << Uti revera novam moliebatur rempublicam, ita et novam, qualis erat, videri eam
Israélitis voluit. Quippe cujus forma sive species, non ex rituum ruderibus Canaaniti-
corum aut Aigyptiacorum efficta, sed celitus delapsa, Mosi primum in sacro monstrata
monte erat, ut ad illud instar cuncta in Israéle componerentur. Neque permissum esse
populo voluit, ut in religionis negotio vel tantillum suo ageret arbitratu. Omnia deter-
minavit ipse, ad minutissimas usque circumstantias ; quibus ita eos alligavit, ut non
sine presentaneo vite discrimine quicquam vel omittere, vel aliter agere potuerint.””—
Pp. 282, 283.
SECT. VI. OF MOSES. DEMONSTRATED. 881
.
an Institution, we may be sure that no such solecism as that of
putting new wine into old bottles will ever be committed.—But the
people were not consulted even in the least thing that concerned reli-
gious matters. How is this to be reconciled with their free choice of
Gop for their King; and with his indulgence of their impious cla-
mours afterwards for a Vicegerent or another king? ‘This surely
concerned religious matters, and very capitally too, in a Policy where
both the Societies were perfectly incorporated.—But every thing was
determined even to the most minute circumstances, and to be observed
under the severest penalties. What this makes for his point, I see
not. But this I see, that, if indeed there were that indulgence in the
Law which I contend for, these two circumstances of minute prescrip-
tion, and severe penalties, must needs attend it: and for this plain
reason; Men, when indulged in their prejudices, are very apt to
transgress the bounds of that indulgence ; it is therefore necessary
that those bounds should be minutely marked out, and the transgres-
sion of them severely punished.
3. His third argument is—‘‘ That no religious Rites, formerly used
by the Israelites, on their own head, were, after the giving of the
law, PERMITTED, out of regard to habitude; but all things pRE-
SCRIBED and COMMANDED: and this so precisely, that it was unlawful
to deviate a finger’s breadth either to the right hand or to the left.’ *
—This indeed is an observation which I cannot reconcile to the
learned writer’s usual candour and ingenuity. He is writing against
Spencer’s system: and here he brings an argument against it, which
he saw in Spencer’s book had been brought against Grotius (who was
in that system), and which Spencer answers in defence of Grotius.
Therefore, as this answer will serve in defence of Spencer himself
against. Witsius, I shall give it at the bottom of the page.t For the
rest, I apprehend all the force of this third argument to le only in
* “ Nec ulli in religione ritus fuerunt, ab Israelitis olim sine numine usurpati, quibus
propter assuetudinem ut in posterum quoque uterentur lege lata permisit: sed pre-
scripta jussaque sunt omnia. Et quidem ita distincte, ut nec transversum digitum
dextrorsum aut sinistrorsum declinare fas fuerit. Deut. v.”—P. 283. + * Testium
meorum agmen claudit Grotius—Authoris verba sunt hee: Sicut fines sacrificiorum
diversi sunt,—ita et ritus, qui aut ab Hebreis ad alias gentes venere, aut, quod credibi-
lius est, a Syris et A2gyptiis usurpati, correcti sunt ab Hebreis, et ab aliis gentibus sine
ea emendatione usurpati. Hic in Grotium paulo animosius insurgit auctor nuperus:
nam hoe, ait 1116, cwm impietate et absurditate conjunctum est. Quid ita? Num enim,
respondet ille, Dewm sanctissima sua instituta, que ipse prolixe sancivit, et conscribi in
religiosam observationem, per inspirationem numinis sui, voluit, credemus ab idololatria
Syrorum et AAgyptiorum mutuo sumpsisse? Neque ea pro libitu Ebrei assumpserunt,
aut assumpta emendarunt, sed omnia et singula divinitus in lege prescripta sunt, et
juata ejus normam exactissime observari debuerunt. At opinio Grotii multo solidior
est, quam ut mucrone tam obtuso confodi possit. Non enim asserit ille, vel sanus quis-
piam, Hebreos ritum ullum a gentibus, pro libitu suo, sumpsisse, vel sumptum pro inge-
nio suo correxisse. Id unum sub locutione figurata, contendit Grotius, Deum nempe
ritus aliquos, usu veteri confirmatos (emendatos tamen, et ignem quasi purgatorium
passos) a gentibus accepisse, et Hebreis usurpandos tradidisse ; ne populus ille, rituum
ethnicorum amore preceps, ad cultum et superstitionem Gentilium rueret, ni more plu-
rimum veteri cultum prestare concederetur.”"— De Legibus Heb, rit, vol. ii. pp. 748, 749.
oo2 THE DIVINE LEGATION ROOK Iv.
-
a quibble on the equivocal use of the word PERMISSION, which sig-
nifies either a facit connivance, or legal allowance. Now Spencer
used the word in this latter sense.* But permission, in this sense,
is very consistent with every thing’s being expressly prescribed and
commanded in the law.
4. His fourth argument proceeds thus,—‘‘ But farther, God neither
permitted, nor commanded, that the Israelites should worship him
after the Pagan mode of worship. For it had been the same thing
to Gop not to be worshipped at all, as to be worshipped by Rites
used in the service of Demons. And Moses teaches us that the Laws
of God were very different from what Spencer imagined ; as appears
from Deut. xii. 30, 31, 32. and from Lev. xviii. 2, 3,4. Here the reason
given of forbidding the vanities of Egypt, is, that Jehovah, who
brought them out from amongst that people, will, from henceforth,
allow no farther communication with Egypt. Small appearance of
any indulgence. And hence indeed it is, that most of the ritual
Laws are directly levelled against the Egyptian, Zabian, and Canaan-
itish superstitions, as Maimonides confesseth.”+—As to what this
learned man says, that we may as well not worship Gop at all as
worship him by Rites which have been employed in Paganism, we
have already overturned the foundation of that fanatical assertion.
It is true, the argument labours a little in the hands of SpeENcER and
Marimonipes; while they suppose the Devil himself to be the princi-
pal Architect of Pagan Superstition: for to believe that Gop would
employ any Rites introduced by this evil Spirit is of somewhat
hard digestion. But that writer, who conceives them to be the
inventions of superstitious and designing men only, hath none of this
difficulty to encounter. As for the observation, that most of the ritual
Laws were levelled against idolatrous superstition, we are so far from
seeing any inconsistency between this truth and that other, “ that
some of those ritual Laws did indulge the people in such habituated
practices, as could not be abused to superstition,” that, on the con-
trary, we see a necessary connexion between them. For if severe
Laws were given to a people against superstitions, to which they
* See note ZZZZ, at the end of this book. + ©“ Porro nec permisit, nec jussit
Deus, ut eo se modo Israelite colerent, quo modo Deos suos colebant Gentiles; veritus
scilicet ne per veteres istas vanitates Demoni cultum deferrent, si minus Deo licuisset.
Nam et inanis ille metus erat: quum Deo propemodum perinde sit, sive quis Dzemoni
cultum deferat, sive per vanitates aliquas veteres Deo cultum deferre presumat. Et
longe aliter Deum instituisse Moses docet, Deut. xiii. 30, 31, 32: adde Levit. xviii. 2,
3,4. Andin’, Spencere, qua ratione ab Agyptiacis vanitatibus ad suorum observan-
tiam preceptorum Israélitas Deus avocet? Lo id facit nomine, quod ipse Jehova et
Deus ipsorum sit, qui ex Adgypto eos eripiens nihil posthac cum A‘gyptiorum vanitati-
bus commune habere voluit. Hoe profecto non est, id quod tu dicis, allicere eos per
umbratiles veterum Aigypti rituum reliquias. Atque hine factum est ut plurima Deus
legibus suis ritualibus inseruerit, Algyptioram, Zabiorum, Canaanzorum institutis ἐκ
Pein opposita—Cujus rei varia a nobis exempla. alibi allata sunt.’ —Pp. 283,
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 333
were violently bent, it would be very proper to indulge them in some
of their favourite habits, so far forth as safely they could be indulged,
in order to break the violence of the rest, and to give the body of
opposed Laws a fuller liberty of working their effect. And if they
had Laws likewise given them in indulgence, it would be necessary to
accompany such Laws with the most severe prohibitions of idolatrous
practice, and of the least deviation from a tittle of the Institute. In
a word, Laws in direct opposition, and Laws in conformity or com-
pliance, had equally, as we say, the same tendency, and jointly
concurred to promote the same end; namely, the preservation of the
Israelites from idolatry.*
5. His fifth argument runs thus.—‘‘ Indulgence was so far from
being the end of the Law, that the Ritual was given as a most heavy
yoke, to subdue and conquer the ferocity of that stiff-necked people,
Gal. iv. 1, 2, 3. Col. ii. 21.’’+—By this one would imagine, his adver-
saries had contended for such a kind of indulgence as arose out of
Gon’s fondness for a chosen People; when indeed, they suppose it to
be only such an indulgence as tended the more effectually and expedi-
tiously to subdue and conquer the ferocity of their savage tempers :
Quos optimus
Fallere et effugere est triumphus.
If, therefore, that were the END of the Law which Witsius himself
contends for, we may be assured that this indulgence was one of the
MEANS. But the principal and more general means being Laws in
direct opposition, this justified the character the Apostle gives of the
Jewish Ritual, in the two places urged against us.
6. His sixth argument is,—‘< That the intent of the Law was to
separate the Israelites, by a partition-wall, as it were, from all other
people; which, by its diversity, might set them at a distance from
idolaters, and create an aversion to idolatry.”’ {—As to the first effect”
of the diversity of the Jewish Law, the keeping the people distinct ;
if the learned writer would thereby insinuate (which is indeed to his
point) that this distinction could be kept up only while the Jews and
other nations had no similar Rites; it could never, even by the means
he himself prescribes, be long kept up at all. For if the Jews were
not indulged in the imitation of any Pagan Rites, the Pagans might
indulge themselves in the imitation of the Jewish: as indeed they are
supposed to have done in the practice of crscumciston: and so this
* See note AAAAA, at the end of this book. + ‘Id sibi primum in rituum
jussione propositumn habuit Deus, ut laboriosis istis exercitiis ferociam populi indomi-
tam, veluti difficillimo jugo, subigeret, Gal. iv. 1, 2, 33 Col. 11. 21.”—P. 286.
t ‘* Deinde hee quoque Dei in rituum jussione intentio fuit, ut eorum observantia,
veluti pariete intergerino, eos ἃ gentium communione longe semoveret, Eph. ii. 14, 15.
—Quum autem legem preceptorum in ritibus inimicitias Apostolus vocat, hoc inter
cetera innuit, fuisse eam symbolum atque instrumentum divisionis atque odii inter
Israélem et gentes.”— Pp. 287, 288.
334 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK 1Y.
partition-wall, if only built of this untempered mortar of Witsius’s
providing, would soon tumble of itself. But the very case here given
shews no necessity for ALL the laws to be in opposition, in order to
secure a separation; the Jews being as effectually separated from all
their neighbours when most of them used the rite of circumcision, as
when these Jews practised it without a rival. And the reason is this,
CIRCUMCISION was not given to Abraham and to his race as a mark
of distinction and separation from all other people, but, what its
constant use made it only fit for, a standing memorial of the covenant
between Gop and Abraham. And ye shall circumcise (says God) the
flesh of your foreskin, and it shall be a TOKEN OF THE COVENANT
between me and you, Gen. xvii. 11. But though it was not given as
a mark of separation, yet it effectually answered that purpose : for it
preserved the memory, or was the token, of a covenant, which neces-
sarily kept them separate and distinct from the rest of mankind. As
to the other effect of this diversity of the Jewish Law, namely the
creating aversion to the Rites of all other nations; in this, the
learned ate hath betrayed his ignorance of human nature. For we
always find a more inveterate hatred and aversion, between people of
different Religions where several things are alike, than where every
thing is diametrically opposite: of which a plain cause might be
found in the nature of man, whose heart is so much corrupted by his
passions. So that the retaining some innocent Egyptian practices, all
accompanied with their provisional opposites, would naturally make
the Jews more averse to Egypt, than if they had differed in every
individual circumstance.
7. His last argument concludes thus,—‘‘ The ceremonies of the
Jewish Ritual were types and shadows of heavenly things: It is
therefore highly improbable that Gop should chuse the impious and
diabolic Sacra of Egypt, and the mummery of Magic practices, for
the shadows of such holy and spiritual matters.” * Thus he ends, as
he began, with hard words and soft arguments. No one ever pre-
tended to say that such kinds of practices were suffered or imitated in
the Jewish Ritual. All the indulgence supposed, is of some harmless
Rite or innocent Ornament, such as the lighting up of Lamps, or
wearing a Linen garment. And let me ask, whether these things,
though done, as we suppose, in conformity to an Egyptian practice,
were more unfit to be made a type or shadow of heavenly things, than
the erection of an altar without steps; done, as they will allow, in
direct opposition to Pagan practice. But it will be shewn under the.
* “ Denique et hic cxrimoniarum scopus fuit, ut rerwm spiritualium figure atque
umbre essent, et exstaret in iis artificiosa pictwra Christi, ac gratie per ipsum impe-
trande— Non est autem probabile, Deum ex impiis A2gyptiorum ac diabolicis sacris, ex
veteribus vanitatibus, ex magic artis imitamentis, picturas fecisse rerum spiritualiam
atque celestium.’—P. 289.
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 935
next head, that the supposition that the Jewish Ritual was framed,
partly in compliance to the people’s prejudices, and partly in opposi-
tion to idolatrous superstitions, and, at the same time, typical of a
future Dispensation, tends greatly to raise and enlarge our ideas of
the divine Wisdom.
But it is strange, that such a writer as Wirstus (whatever we may
think of the admirers of his argument) should not see, that the cha-
racter given of the RITUAL LAW by God himself did not imply that it
had a mixture at least of no better stuff than Egyptian and other
Pagan practices.
Gop, by the prophet Ezextex, upbraiding the Israelites with their
perversity and disobedience, from the time of their going out of Egypt
to their entrance into the land of Canaan, speaks to them in this
manner.—
Ver. 1. “And it came to pass, in the seventh year, in the fifth
month, the tenth day of the month, that certain of the elders of Israel
came to inquire of the Lord, and sat before me.
2. “Then came the word of the Lord unto me saying :
3. “Son of man, speak unto the elders of Israel, and say unto
them, Thus saith the Lord God, Are ye come to inquire of me? as I
live, saith the Lord God, I will not be inquired of by you.
4. “Wilt thou judge them, son of man, wilt thou judge them?
cause them to know the abominations of their fathers :
5. ‘And say unto them, Thus saith the Lord God, in the day when
I chose Israel, and lifted up mine hand unto the seed of the house
of Jacob, and made myself known unto them in the land of Egypt,
when I lifted up mine hand unto them, saying I am the Lord your
God.
6. “In the day that I lifted up mine hand unto them to bring
them forth of the land of Egypt, into a land that I had espied
for them, flowing with milk and honey, which is the glory of all
lands :
7. “Then said I unto them, Cast ye away every man the abomina-
tions of his eyes, and defile not yourselves with the idols of Egypt: 1
am the Lord your God.
8. “ But they rebelled against me, and would not hearken unto me ;
they did not every man cast away the abominations of their eyes,
neither did they forsake the idols of Egypt: Then I said, I will pour
out my fury upon them, to accomplish my anger against them in the
midst of the land of Egypt.
9. “But I wrought for my name’s sake, that it should not be
polluted before the heathen, among whom they were, in whose sight
I made myself known unto them, in bringing them forth out of the
land of Egypt.
336 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK 1Y-
10. ‘ Wherefore I caused them to go forth out of the land of
Egypt, and brought them into the wilderness.
11. “And I gave them my statutes, and shewed them my judg-
ments, which if a man do, he shall even live in them.
; 12. “ Moreover also, I gave them my sabbaths, to be a sign between
me and them, that they might know that I am the Lord that sanc-
tify them.
13. ‘But the house of Israel rebelled against me in the wilder-
ness: they walked not in my statutes, and they despised my judg-
ments, which if a man do, he shall. even live in them; and my sab-
baths they greatly polluted: then I said I would pour out my fury
upon them in the wilderness to consume them.
14, “ But I wrought for my name’s sake, that it should not be
polluted before the heathen, in whose sight I brought them out.
15. “Yet also I lifted up my hand unto them in the wilderness,
that I would not bring them into the land which I had given them,
flowing with milk and honey, which is the glory of all lands:
16. “Because they despised my judgments, and walked not in my
statutes, but polluted my sabbaths: for their heart went after their
idols.
17. ‘Nevertheless, mine eye spared them from destroying them,
neither did I make an end of them in the wilderness.
18. “ But I said unto their children in the wilderness, Walk ye not
in the statutes of your fathers, neither observe their judgments, nor
defile yourselves with their idols.
19. “Tam the Lord your God; walk in my statutes, and keep my
judgments, and do them :
20. ‘And hallow iny sabbaths, and they shall be a sign between
me and you, that ye may know that I am the Lord your God.
21. “Notwithstanding the children rebelled against me: they
walked not in my statutes, neither kept my judgments to do them,
which if a man do, he shall even live in them ; they polluted my sab-
baths: then I said I would pour out my fury upon them, to accom-
plish my anger against them in the wilderness.
22. ‘* Nevertheless, I withdrew mine hand, and wrought for my
name’s sake, that it should not be polluted in the sight of the
heathen, in whose sight I brought them forth.
23. “1 lifted up mine hand unto them also in the wilderness, that
I would scatter them among the heathen, and disperse them through
the countries.
24. “Because they had not executed my judgments, but had
despised my statutes, and had polluted my sabbaths, and their eyes
were after their fathers’ idols.
25. “WHEREFORE I GAVE THEM ALSO STATUTES THAT WERE
-
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 337
NOT GOOD, AND JUDGMENTS WHEREBY THEY SHOULD NOT
LIVE.
26. “And I polluted them in their own gifts, in that they caused to
pass through the fire all that openeth the womb, that I might make
them desolate, to the end that they might know that Iam the Lord.” *
Could the Prophet have possibly given a plainer or more graphical
description of the character and genius of the RITUAL LAw, than in
those last words? Yet to suit it to theologic purposes, System-
makers have endeavoured, in their usual manner, fo interpret it away,
as if it only signified Gop’s suffering the Israelites to fall into idola-
try. Now if it were not indulged to these men to make use of any
arms they can catch hold of, one should be a little scandalized to find
that they had borrowed this forced interpretation from the Rassrns ;
who holding their Law to be perfect, and of eternal obligation, were
indeed much concerned to remove this opprobrium from it. Kimchi
is recorded for his dexterity in giving it this meaning: though done
with much more caution than the Chyistian writers who took it from
him. He supposed that the statutes not good were the Tributes
imposed on the Israelites while in subjection to their Pagan neigh-
bours. And this takes off something from the unnatural violence of
the expression, of GIVING STATUTES, when understood only to sig-
nify the permission of abusing their free-will, when they fell into
idolatry.
Now, because the right explanation and proper inforcement of this
famous passage will, besides its use in the present argument, serve for
many considerable purposes, in the sequel of this work, it may not
be time mis-spent to expose this spurious pilfered interpretation.
And, as the last inforcer of it, and the most, satisfied with his exploit,
the late Author of the Connexions between sacred and profane history,
takes the honour of it to himself, I shall examine his reasoning at
large.
Dr. Spencer, and (I suppose) every capable judge before him,
understood the statutes and judgments in the eleventh verse, to signify
the MoRAL law; and the statutes and judgments in the twenty-fifth
verse, to signify the riruaL. But Dr. Shuckford, who always takes
a singular pleasure in carping at that faithful Servant of Common-
sense, directs the defence of his borrowed novelty, against the great
Author of the Reasons of the Ritual Law, in the following manner.—
“‘The persons spoken of, who had the statutes given to them, which
were noé good, were not that generation of men to whom the whole
Low was given, but their children or posterity. To this posterity,
God made no additions to his laws ; the whole being completed in the
time of their forefathers. Therefore all he Gave to them of statutes
* Ezek. xx. 1—26, inclusive.
VOL. II. 4
338 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
not good was the pERMission of falling into the Pagan idolatries
round about.” * This, I believe, his followers will confess to be his
argument, though represented in fewer words, yet with greater force :
for a perplexed combination of needless repetitions, which fill two or
three large pages, have much weakened and obscured-his reasoning.
However it concludes in these very terms: “And thus it must be
undeniably plain, that the Prophet could not, by the statutes not' good,
mean any part of the Ritual law: for the whole Law was given to the
fathers of those whom the Prophet now speaks of; but these statutes
were not given to the fathers, but to the descendants. If we go on,
and compare the narrative of the Prophet with the history of the
Israelites, we shall see further, that the statutes and judgments not
good are so far from being any part of Moses’s law, that they were
not given earlier than the times of the Judges ; + 7. e. the Israelites
then fell into the idolatries, here called (as this learned interpreter
will have it) statutes and judgments GIVEN.
And now, to canvass a little this decisive argument—Tuus (says
he) ἐξέ must be undeniably plain—Thus ! that is, Grant him his pre-
misses, and the conclusion follows. Without doubt. But the whole
context shews that his premisses are false.
First then let it be observed, that the occasion of the Prophecy, in
the xxth chapter of Ezekiel, was this,—The Jews, by certain of their
Elders, had, as was usual in their distresses, recourse to the God of
Israel for direction ‘and assistance [ver. 1.1. On this we are informed
[ver. 3.], that the word of the Lord came to Ezekiel, bidding him tell
these Elders that Gop would not be inquired of by them: for that
their continued rebellions, from their coming out of Egypt, to that
time, had made them unworthy of his patronage and protection.
Their idolatries are then recapitulated, and divided into three periods.
The First, from Gop’s message to them while in Egypt, to their
entrance into the promised land.—Thus saith the Lord God, In the
day when I chose Israel, and lifted up mine hand unto the seed of
Jacob, and made myself known unto them in the land of Egypt, &e.
and so on, from the fifth to the twenty-sixth verse inclusively. The
SECOND period contains all the time from their taking possession of
the land of Canaan, to their present condition when this prophecy
was delivered.—Therefore, son of man, speak unto the house of Israel,
and say unto them, Thus saith the Lord God, Yet in this your fathers
have blasphemed me, in that they have committed a trespass against
me. For wHEN I HAD BROUGHT THEM INTO THE LAND, for the
_ which I lifted up mine hand to give it to them, then they saw every
high hill, &c. and so on, from the twenty-seventh to the thirty-second
verse inclusively. The TH1rp period concerns the iniquities, and the
“ “Connection,” vol.-v. pp. 159—161. + Idem, vol. v. p. 161.
SECT. VT. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 339
consequent punishment of the present generation, which had now
applied to him in their distresses.—ds I live, saith the Lord God,
surely with a mighty hand, and with a stretched out arm, and with
fury poured out, witu I RuLE over you, &c. And this is the
subject of what we find between the thirty-third and the forty-fourth
verse, inclusively.
This short, but exact analysis of the Prophecy, is more than suffi-
cient to overturn Dr. Shuckford’s system, founded on a distinction
between the fathers and the children in the eighteenth verse, (which
is within the first period) as if the fathers related to what happened
in the wilderness, and the children, to what happened under the
judges ; whereas common sense is sufficient to convince us, that the
whole is confined to the two generations, between the exodus from
Egypt and the entrance into Canaan.
But the confutation of a foolish system, dishonourable indeed to
Scripture, is the least of my concern. Such things will die of them-
selves. My point, in delivering the truths of Gop as they lie in his
Word, is to illustrate the amazing wisdom of that Dispensation to
which they belong. Let me observe therefore, as a matter of much ἡ
greater moment, that this distinction, which the text hath made
between the rarHeRS and the cHILDREN, in the first period, during
their abode in the wilderness, affords us a very noble instance of that
divine mercy which extends to thousands.
The Prophet thus represents the fact. When Gop brought his
chosen people out of Egypt, he gave them his statutes and shewed
them his judgments, which if a man do, he shall live in them. More-
over also he gave them his sabbaths, to be a sign between him and
them.* That is, he gave them the moral law of the Decalogue, in
which there was one positive institution,t and no more ; but this one,
absolutely necessary as the token of a covenant, to be a perpetual
memorial of it, and, by that means, to preserve them a select people,
unmixed with the nations. What followed so gracious and generous a
dispensation to the house of Israel? Why, they rebelled against him
in the wilderness: they walked not in his statutes, and they despised
his judgments, and his Sabbaths they greatly polluted.t On which,
he threatened to pour out his fury upon them in the wilderness, and
consume them.§ But, in regard to his own glory, lest the Heathen,
before whom he brought them out of Egypt, should blaspheme, he -
thought fit to spare them.|| Yet so far punished that generation, as
never to suffer them to come into the land of Canaan.{ Their
children he spared, that the race might not be consumed as he had
first threatened.** And hoping better things of them than of their
* Ezek. xx. 11, 12. + The Sabbath. 1 Ezek. xx. 13. § Ibid.
|| Verse 14. 4 Verses 15, 16, *® Verse 17. —
Z 2
940 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
Fathers, he said to them in the wilderness, Walk ye not in the statutes
of your fathers, neither observe their judgments, nor defile yourselves
with their idols. Walk in my statutes, and keep my judgments and
do them: and hallow my Sabbaths, and they shall be a sign between
me and you.* Here we see, the Children, or immediate progeny,
were again offered, as their sole rule of government, what had been
given to, and had been violated by their Fathers; namely, the moral
law of the Decalogue, and the positive institution of the Sabbath.
Well, and how did they behave themselves on this occasion? Just as
their fathers had done before them.—WNotwithstanding [the repetition
of this offered grace] the Children rebelled against me, they walked
not in my statutes, they polluted my Sabbaths.t—What followed ?
The same denunciation which had hung over the Fathers, utter
destruction in the wilderness.t However, mercy again prevails over
judgment ; and the same reason for which he spared their Fathers
inclines him to spare them ; lest his xame should be polluted in the
sight of the heathen.§ However due punishment attended their
transgressions, as it had done their Fathers’. Their Fathers left their
bones in the wilderness: but this perverse race being pardoned, as a
People, and still possessed of the privilege of a select and chosen
Nation, were neither to be scattered amongst the Heathen, nor to be
confined for ever in the wilderness: Almighty Wisdom therefore
ordained that their punishment should be such, as should continue
them, even against their Wills, a separated race, in possession of the
land of Canaan. What this punishment was, the following words
declare ;—Because they had not executed my judgments, but had
despised my statutes, and had polluted my Sabbaths, and their eyes
were after their fathers idols. Wherefore 1 GAVE THEM ALSO STA-
TUTES THAT WERE NOT GOOD, AND JUDGMENTS WHEREBY THEY
SHOULD NOT LIVE.|| That is, because they had violated my rirrst
system of laws, the DecaLocur, I added to them [I Gave THEM
ALSO, words which imply the giving as a supplement] my sECOND
system, the RITUAL LAW ; very aptly characterised (when set in
opposition to the MORAL LAW) by statutes that were not good, and
by judgments whereby they should not live.
What is here observed, opens to us the admirable reasons of both
punishments: and why there was a forbearance, or a second trial,
before the yoke of Ordinances was imposed. For we must never
forget, that the God of Israel transacted with his people according to
the mode of human Governors. Let this be kept in mind, and we
shall see the admirable progress of the Dispensation. God brought
the Fathers out of Egypt, to put them in possession of the land of
* Ezek. xx. 18—20,. t Verse 21. t Ibid. § Verse 22.
|| Verses 24, 25.
ΒΕΟΎ, Vi. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 341
Canaan. He gave them the mora Law to distinguish them for the
worshippers of the true God: And he gave them the positive Law
of the Sabbath to distinguish them for God’s peculiar people. These
Fathers proving perverse and rebellious, their punishment was death
in the wilderness, and exclusicn from that good land which was
reserved for their Children. But then these Children, in that very
Wilderness, the scene of their Fathers’ crime and calamity, fell into
the same transgressions. What was now to be done? It was plain,
so inveterate an evil could be only checked or subdued by the curb of
some severe Institution. A severe Institution was prepared; and the
RITUAL Law was established. For the first offence, the punishment
was personal: but when a repetition shewed it to be inbred, and, like
the Leprosy, sticking to the whole race, the punishment was properly
changed to national.
How clear, how coherent, is every thing, as here explained! How
consonant to reason! How full of divine wisdom! Yet, in defiance
of Scripture and Common-sense (which have a closer connexion than
the Enemies of religion suspect, or than the common advocates of it
dare venture to maintain) comes a Doctor, and tells us, that these
Children in the Wilderness of the time of Moses, were Children of the
land of Canaan in the time of the Judges; and that the statutes
given which were not good, were Pagan idolatries, not given, but
suffered ; indeed not suffered ; because severely, and almost always
immediately punished. é
What misled our Doctor (whose Connexions, by what we have seen,
appear to be little better than a chain of errors) seems to have been
this, The Ritual law was given during the life of the Fathers, and
soon after their transgression mentioned in the 13th verse of this
Propheey. So he could not conceive how the Prophet should mean
that this Law was given to the Children. But he did not consider,
that the proper punishment of the Fathers was extinction in the
wilderness: the proper punishment of the Children, who were re-
served to possess the holy land, was the infliction of the RITUAL
LAW.
The Doctor, however, notwithstanding all his complacency in this
his adopted system, yet appears conscious of its want of strength ; for
he owns that an objection may be made to it from the following words
of the Prophecy.— But I said unto their Children 1N THE WILDER-
ness, Walk ye not in the statutes of your Fathers—walk in my
statutes—and hallow my Sabbath.* And again, of these Children—
then I said I would pour out my fury upon them to accomplish mine
anger against them 1N THE WILDERNEsS.¢ And again,—ZI lifted up
my hand unto them also 1N THE WILDERNESS.{ ‘ Here” (says the
4 Ezek, xx. 18—20. + Verse 2]. t Verse 23.
942 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
learned Doctor) “the prophet may seem TO HINT, that God’s anger
against the Children was while they were in the wilderness.” *
May seem to hint! The Doctor must be immoderately fond of
precise expression when he esteems this to be no more than a hint or —
doubtful intimation.
But Mosgs having omitted to tell us, that these Children did
indeed play these pranks in the Wilderness, he will not take a later
Prophet’s word for it. 4s Moses (says the Doctor) wrote before
Ezekiel prophesied ; his prophecy could not alter facts. It will be
more than the Doctor deserves, if the Freethinker neglects to reply,
that both the Prophet and the Doctor here seem to hint ; the former,
that God’s anger against the Children was while they were in the
wilderness ; the latter, that Moses and Ezekiel contradict one ano-
ther. But to let this pass.—Prophecy, he says, could not alter facts ;
by which he means that Prophecy, any more than the author of
Prophecy, could not make that to be undone which was already done.
Who ever thought it could? But might not Ezekiel’s Prophecy
explain facts, and relate them too, which a former Prophet had
omitted? However Ezekiel is not the only one who informs us of
this fact. . Amos upbraids these sojourners ix the wilderness with a
still more general apostacy. ‘‘ Have ye offered unto me sacrifices and
offerings IN THE WILDERNESS forty years, O house of Israel? - But
ye have born the tabernacle of your Moloch and Chiun, your images,
the Star of your God, which ye made to yourselves.”+ Now if the
Israelites committed idolatry all the time they sojourned in the Wil-
derness, the crime necessarily included the Cu1LpREN with the
Fathers.
The Doctor’s second expedient to evade the determinate evidence
of the text is as ridiculous as the first is extravagant. The text says,
—TI will pour out my fury upon them to accomplish mine anger against
them IN THE WILDERNESS.—‘‘ These words, in the wilderness,”
(says the acute Expositor) “do not hint the place where the anger
was to be accomplished, but rather refer to anger, and suggest the
anger to be, as if we might almost say in English, the wILDERNESs-
ANGER.’ {—If the Doctor’s Rhetoric is to be enriched with this new
phrase, I think his Logic should not be denied the benefit of a like
acquisition, of which it will have frequent use, and that is, WILDER-
NESS-REASONING. And so much for this learned solution.
But the absurdity of supposing with these men, that the words,
1 gave them also statutes that were not good, and judgments whereby
they should not live, might signify, their taking (witheut giving) Baal
and Ashteroth for their Gods,§ is best exposed by the Prophet him-
self, as his words lie in the text. Consider then the case of these
*" Page 169, + Amos ν᾿ 25, 26, 1 Page 17]. § Page 163.
SECT. νι. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 343
Rebels. God’s first intention (as in the other case of their Fathers’
rebellion) is represented to be the renouncing them for his people,
and scattering them amongst the nations. Then I said I would pour
out my fury upon them to accomplish my anger against them in the
wilderness.* But his mercy prevails.—Wevertheless I withdrew mine
hand, and wrought for my names sake, that it should not be pol-
luted in the sight of the Heathen, in whose sight I brought them
Jorth.+ In these two verses, we see, that the punishment intended,
and the mercy shewn, are delivered in general; without the circum-
stances of the punishment, or the conditions of the mercy. The three
following verses, in the mode of the eastern composition, which delights
in repetition, informs us more particularly of these circumstances,
which were pispERSION, &c. and of these conditions, which were the
imposition οὗ a Ritual Law.—I lifted up my hand unto them also in
the wilderness, that I would scatreER THEM amongst the heathen,
and DISPERSE THEM through the countries; because they had not
executed my judgments, but had despised my statutes, and had pol-
luted my Sabbaths, and their eyes were ufter their Fathers’ idols.t
Here, the intended punishment is explained specifically, that is, with
its circumstances. —The mercy follows ; and the terms, on which it
was bestowed, are likewise explained.—Wherefore I gave them also
Statutes that were Not Goon, and Judgments whereby they should
ΝΟΥ LivE.§ And now the beggarly shifts of the new interpretation
appear in all their nakedness. Whatever is meant by statutes not
good, the end of giving them, we see, was to preserve them a pecu-
liar people to the Lord; for the punishment of dispersion was
remitted to them. But if by statutes not good be meant the per-
mitting them to fall into Idolatries, God is absurdly represented as
decreeing an end (the keeping his people separate) ; and at the same
time providing means to defeat it: For every lapse into idolatry was
a step to their dispersion and utter consumption, by absorbing them
into the Nations. We must needs conclude therefore, that, by sTa-
TUTES NOT GOOD is meant the RITUAL LAw, the only means of
attaining that end of mercy, The preserving them a separate people.
Who now can chuse but smile to hear our learned Expositor quot-
ing these words of the book of Judges,—T7he CuitpREN of Israel
did evil in the sight of the Lord, and followed other Gods of the
Gods of the people, that were round about them, and provoked the
Lord to anger, and served Baal and Ashteroth ; || and then gravely
adding,—‘“‘ So that here the scene opens which Ezekiel alludes to ;
and accordingly what Ezekiel mentions as the punishment of these
wickednesses began now to come upon them.” 4]
* Ezek. xx. 21. + Verse 22. t Verses 23, 24. δ Verse 25.
|| Judges ii. 11—13. + 4 Bagels:
914 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
However, it must be owned, that if words alone could shake the
solidity of the interpretation I have here given, these which imme-
diately follow the contested passage of statutes not good, would be
enough to alarm us—Adnd I polluted them (says the text) in their own
gifts, in that they caused to pass through the fire all that openeth
the womb, that I might make them desolate, to the end that they might
know that I am the Lord.* The common interpretation of which is
this, “41 permitted them to fall into that wicked inhumanity, whereby
they were polluted and contaminated, in making their Children to
pass through the fire to Moloch, in order to root them out and utterly
to destroy them.”
Dr. Spencer (who follows the general sense of the prophecy which
I have here explained and supported) appeared but too sensible how
much this text stood in his way.. He endeavours therefore to shew,
that ‘it relates to God’s rejecting the first-born of the Israelites
from the priesthood, and appointing the tribe of Levi to the sacred
office in their stead: ”’ and that, therefore, the verse should be ren-
dered thus, I pronounced them polluted in their gifts [i. e. unfit to
offer me any oblation], ix that I passed by all that openeth the womb
fi. 6. the first-born] ἐπ order to humble them that they might know
that I am the Lord. And this rendering may be the right, for any.
thing Dr. Shuckford has to oppose to the contrary; + the main of
which is, what has been already confuted, (or rather, what the very
terms, in which the assertion is advanced, do themselves confute)
namely, that the Children in the wilderness were not the immediate
issue of those who died in the wilderness, but a remote posterity. As
for his Hebrew criticism, that the word maas, and not nabar, would
probably have been used by the Prophet, if rejecting from the priest-
hood had been the sense intended by him,t} this is the slenderest of
all reasoning, even though it had been applied to a Rhetorician by
profession, and in a language very copious, and perfectly well under-
stood : How evanid is it therefore, when applied to a Prophet under
the impulse of inspiration, and speaking in the most scanty of all
languages ; the small knowledge of which is to be got from one sin-
gle volume of no large bulk, and conveyed in a mode of writing
subject to perpetual equivocations and ambiguities! From the mis-
chiefs of which, God in his good providence preserved us by the
Septuagint Translation, made while the Hebrew was a living language,
and afterwards authenticated by the recognition of the inspired writers
of the New ‘Testament.
Tlowever, the truth is, that this explanation of the learned Spencer
must appear forced, even though we had no better to oppose to it :
But when there is a better at hand, which not only takes off all the
* Ezek. xx. 26. + Pp. 168, 169. t Page 169.
SECT. VI. OF MOSZS DEMONSTRATED. 345
countenance which this 26th verse affords to Dr. Shuckford’s inter-
pretation of statutes not good, but so exactly quadrates with the
sense here given, that it completes and perfects the narrative, we shall
be no longer frighted with its formidable look.
To understand then what it aims at, we must consider the con-
text as it has been explained above. The 2lst and 22d verses (it
hath been shewn) contain God’s purposes of judgment and of mercy
in general. The 23d, 24th, and 25th, explain in what the intended
judgment would have consisted, and how the prevailing mercy was
qualified. The Israelites were to be pardoned ; but to be kept under,
by the yoke of a ritual Law, described only in general by the title
of statutes not good. The 26th verse opens the matter still further,
and explains the nature and genius of that yoke, together with its
effects, both salutary and baleful. The salutary, as it was a barrier
to idolatry, the most enormous species of which was that of causing
their children to pass through the fire to Moloch: the baleful, as it
brought on their desolation when they became deprived of the Tem-
ple-worship. But to be more particular.—J polluted them in their
own gifts. By gifts Τ understand that homage (universally expressed,
in the ancient world, by Rites of sacrifice) which a People owed to
their God. And how were these gifts polluted? By a multifarious
Ritual, which, being opposed to the idolatries of the Nations, was
prescribed in reference to those idolatries; and, consequently, was
incumbered with a thousand Ceremonies, respecting the choice of the
animal; the qualities and purifications of the Sacrificers ; and the
direction and efficacy of each specific Offering. This account of
their pollution, by such a Ritual, exactly answers to the character
given of that Ritual, [statutes not good, §c.] in the text in question.
Then follows the reason of God’s thus polluting them in their own
gifts—in that [or, because that] they caused to pass through the fire
all that openeth the womb—i. e. the polluting Ritual was imposed
aS ἃ PUNISHMENT FOR, as well as BARRIER TO their idolatries ;
characterised under this most enormous and horrid of them all, the
causing of their children to pass through the fire to Moloch. Then
follows the humiliating circumstance of this ritual yoke,—that I
might make them desolate, i. e. that they should, even from the
nature of that Ritual, be deprived, when they most wanted it, of
their nearest intercourse with their God and King. A real state of
desolation! To understand which, we are to consider, that at the
time this Prophecy was delivered, the Jews, by their accumulated
iniquities, were accelerating, what doubtless the Prophet had then in
his eye, their punishment of the seventy years Captivity. Now, by
the peculiar Constitution of the ritual Law, their Religion became,
as it were, local; it being unlawful to offer sacrifice but in the temple
845 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
of Jerusalem only. So that when they were led captive into a foreign
land, the most solemn and essential intercourse between God and
them (the morning and evening sacrifice) was entirely cut off: and
thus, by means of the ritual Law, they were emphatically said to be
made desolate. The verse concludes in telling us, for what end this
punishment was inflicted—that they might know that I am the Lord.
How would this appear from the premisses? Very evidently. For if,
while they were in Captivity, they were under an interdict, and their
Religion in a state of Suspension, and yet that they were to continue
God’s select people (for the scope of the whole Prophecy is to shew,
that, notwithstanding all their provocations, God still worked for his
name's sake), then, in order to be restored to their Religion, they
were to be reinstated in their own Land; which work, Prophecy
always describes as the utmost manifestation of God’s power. Their
redemption from the Assyrian captivity particularly, being frequently
compared, by the Prophets, to that of the Egyptian. From hence there-
fore all men might know and collect, that the God of Israel was the Lord.
This famous text then, we see, may be thus aptly paraphrased—
And I polluted them in their own gifts, in that they caused to pass
through the fire all that openeth the womb, that I might make them
desolate, to the end that they might know that I am the Lord; i. 6.
«1 loaded the religious Worship due to me, as their God and King,
with a number of operose Ceremonies, to punish their past, and to
oppose to their future, idolatries ; the most abominable of which was
their making their children to pass through the fire to Moloch: And
further, that I might have the Ceremonial Law always at hand as an
instrument for still more severe punishments, when the full measure
of their iniquities should bring them into Captivity in a strange land,
I so contrived, by the very constitution of their Religion, that it
should then remain under an interdict, and all stated intercourse be
cut off between me and them; From which evil, would necessarily
arise this advantage, an occasion to manifest my power to the Gen-
tiles, in bringing my People again, after a due time of penance, into
their own land.”
Here we see, the text, thus expounded, connects and compleats the
whole narrative, concerning the imposition of the ritual Law, and
its nature and consequences, from the 21st to the 26th verse inclu-
sively: and opens the history of it by due degrees, which the most
just and elegant compositions require. We are first informed of the
threatened judgment, and of the prevailing mercy in general :—we
are then told the specific nature of that judgment, and the cireum-
stance attending the accorded mercy ;—and lastly, the Prophet
explains the nature and genius of that attendant circumstance ; toge-
ther with its adverse as well as benignant effects.
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 217
I have now deprived the Connecter of all his arguments but
one, for this strange interpretation of statutes not good ; and that
one is, “That the worshipers of Baal and Ashteroth, in the book
of Judges, and the slaves to statutes not good in the prophet Eze-
kiel, having the common name of CuiLpREN, must needs be the
same individuals:”? But this I make a conscience of taking from
him.
Yet such confidence has the learned person in his goodly expo-
sition, that he concludes his reasoning against the obvious sense of
the Prophecy, in this extraordinary manner—‘“ Dr. Spencer imagined,
this text alone was sufficient to support his hypothesis: but I cannot
but think, if what has been offered be fairly considered, No HONEST
WRITER can ever cite it again for that purpose.’’*
What is Dr. Spencer’s hypothesis? Just this and no other, that
Moses gave the ritual Law to the Jews because of the hardness of their
hearts ;+ the very Hypothesis of Jesus Christ himself.
But the Connecrer thinks, that, 7f what he has offered be fairly
considered, NO HONEST WRITER can ever cite it again for that pur-
pose. This smells strong of the Bigot. One can hardly think one’s
self in the closet of a learned and sober Divine; but rather in some
wild Conventicle of Methodists or Hutchinsonians ; whose criticisms
are all Revelations: which, though you cannot embrace but at the
expence of COMMON SENSE, you are not allowed to question without
renouncing COMMON HONMSTY.
I have fairly considered (as the Connecter expects his Reader
should do) what he has offered against Dr. Spencer’s hypothesis ;
and if there be any truth in the conclusions of human reason, I think
a writer may go on very advantageously, as well as with a good con-
science, to defend that Hypothesis. How such a writer shall be
qualified by Bigots, is another point. Many an HONEST MAN, I am
persuaded, will still adhere to Dr. Shuckford’s hypothesis ; and with
the same good faith, with which he himself supported it : for though
his charity will not allow that title to those who dissent from him, yet
God forbid, that I should not give it to Him.
But it is now time to proceed to the third period of Tuts Prophecy.
For the principal design of this work is to vindicate and illustrate
sacred Scripture, though in my progress I be still obliged, from time to
time, to stop a little, while I remove the most material obstructions
which lie in my way.
This Prophecy hitherto contains a declaration of the various
punishments inflicted on the rebellious Israelites, from the time of
Moses’s mission, to the preaching of Ezekiel. We have shewn that
their punishment in the first period, was death in the wilderness :
* Page 167. + Matt. xix. 8.
943 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
their punishment in the second period, was the fastening on their
necks the yoke of the ritual Law.
Their punishment in the third period is now to be considered: and
we shall see that it consisted in rendering the yoke of the ritual Law
still more galling, by withdrawing from them that EXTRAORDINARY
PROVIDENCE, which once rewarded the studious observers of it, with
many temporal blessings. The punishment was dreadful: and such,
indeed, the Prophet describes it to have been. But we may be
assured, their crimes deserved it, as having risen in proportion with
it ; and this likewise, he tells us, was the case. Their idolatries were
at first, and so, for some time, they continued to be, the mixing
Pagan worship with the worship of the God of Israel. But though
they had so often smarted for this folly, they were yet so besotted
with the Gods of the nations, the stocks and stones of the high places,
that their last progress in impiety was the project of casting off the
God of Israel entirely, at least as their ruUTELAR God, and of mixing
themselves amongst the Nations. They had experienced, that the -
God of Israel was a JEALOUS Gop, who would not share his glory
with another ; and they hoped to avoid his wrath by renouncing their
Covenant with him, and leaving him at liberty to chuse another peo-
ple. To such a degree of impiety and madness was this devoted
Nation arrived, when Ezekiel prophesied at the eve of their approach-
ing Captivity. All this will be made plain, by what follows.
We have seen their behaviour in the tw@former periods ; in Eeyrt,
and in the WiLtpERNeEss. The third begins with a description of
their Manners when they had taken possession of the land of
CANAAN.
Ver. 27. “Son of man, speak unto the house of Israel, and say
unto them, Thus saith the Lord God, yet in this, your fathers have
blasphemed me, in that they have committed a trespass against me.
28. “ For when I had brought them into the land, for the which I
lifted up my hand to give it to them, then they saw every high
hill, and all the thick trees, and they offered there their sacrifices,
and there they presented the provocation of their offering.”
This was their continual practice, even to the delivery of this
Prophecy ; at which time, their enormities were come to the height,
we just mentioned ; to contrive in their hearts to renounce the God of
Israel, altogether. But being surrounded with calamities, and a
powerful enemy at their door, they were willing to procure a present
relief from him, whom they had so much offended ; though at this
very instant, they were projecting to offend still more. The singular
impudence of this conduct was, apparently, the immediate occasion of
this famous Prophecy ; as we shall now see.
Ver. 30. “* Wherefore say unto the house of Israel, Thus saith the
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 349
Lord God, Are ye polluted after the manner of your fathers? and
commit ye whoredoms after their abominations ?
31. “For when ye offer your gifts, when ye make your sons to
pass through the fire, ye pollute yourselves with all your idols EVEN
To THis pAy. And shall I be enquired of by you, O house of
Israel? As I live, saith the Lord God, I will not be enquired of
by you.”
That this recourse to the God of their Fathers was only a moment-
ary impulse, arising from their pressing necessities, is evident from
what immediately follows; the mention of that specific crime which
brought upon them the punishment annexed to the third period.—
Ver. 32. “AND THAT WHICH COMETH INTO YOUR MIND SHALL
NOT BE AT ALL, THAT YE SAY, WE WILL BE AS THE HEATHEN,
AS THE FAMILIES OF THE COUNTRIES, TO SERVE WOOD AND
STONE.
33. “As I live, saith the Lord God, Surely with a mighty hand,
and with a stretched out arm, AND WITH FURY POURED OUT, WILL
I RULE OVER YOU.
34. “Anp I WILL BRING YOU OUT FROM THE PEOPLE, AND
WILL GATHER YOU OUT OF THE COUNTRIES WHEREIN YE ARE
SCATTERED, with a mighty hand, and with a stretched out arm, AND
WITH FURY POURED OUT.
35. “ And I will bring. you into the WILDERNESS OF THE PEOPLE,
and there will 1 plead with you face to face.
36. ‘Like as I pleaded with your fathers in the wilderness of the
land of Egypt, so will I plead with you face to face.”
By all this it appears, that the Jews of this time were little anxious
to avoid their approaching Captivity, denounced and threatened by all
their Prophets. What they wanted was a light and easy servitude,
which might enable them to mingle with, and at last to be lost
amongst the Nations; like the Ten Tribes which had gone before
‘them. Against the vileness of these hopes is this part of the Pro-
phecy directed. God assures them, he will bring them out of the
Assyrian Captivity, as he had done out of the Eyyptian; but not in
mercy, as that deliverance was procured, but in judgment, and with
fury poured out. And as he had brought their Fathers into the
wilderness of the land of Egypt, so would he bring them into the
WILDERNESS OF THE PEOPLE, that is, the land of Canaan, which
they would find, on their return to it, was become desart and unin-
habited: and therefore elegantly called the wilderness of the people.
But what now was to be their reception, on their second possession of
the promised Land? a very differeut weleome from the first. God
indeed leads them here again with a mighty hand and a stretched out
arm ; and it was to take possession ; but not, as at first, of a land
350 THE DIVINE LEGATION ROOK IV,
flowing with milk and honey, but of a prison, a house of correction
where they were to pass under the rod, and to remain in bonds.
37. “AnD I wILL CAUSE you (says God) TO PASS UNDER THE
ROD, AND I WILL BRING YOU INTO THE BOND OF THE COVE-
NANT.”
Words which strongly and elegantly express subjection to a ritual
Law, after the extraordinary Providence, which so much alleviated the
yoke of it, was withdrawn: And we find it withdrawn soon after
their return from the Captivity.—But, the prophecy, carrying on the
comparison to the Egyptian deliverance, adds— ;
Ver. 38. “And I will purge out from amongst you, the Rebels,
and them that transgress against me: I will bring them forth out of
the country where they sojourn, and they shall not enter into the
land of Israel.”
These Rebels, like their Faruurs in the wilderness, were indeed to
be brought out of Captivity, but were never to enjoy the promised
Land; and the rest, like the CHILDREN in the wilderness, were
to have the yoke of the ritual Law still made more galling. And thus
the COMPARISON is compleated.
These were the three different punishments inflicted in these three
different periods. The first personaL; the second and the third,
NATIONAL; only the third made heavier than the second, in propor-
tion to their accumulated offences.
But as, in the height of God’s vengeance on the sins of this
wretched people, the distant prospect always terminated in a mercy ;
So, with a mercy, and a promise of better times, the whole of this
prophetic Scene is closed; in order that the Nation to which it is
addressed, should, however criminal they were, not be left in an utter
state of desperation, but be afforded some shadow of repose, in the
prospect of future peace and tranquillity. For now, turning again to
these temporary Inquirers after God, the Prophecy addresses them, in
this manner,
Ver. 39. ** As for you, O house of Israel, thus saith the Lord God,
Go ye, serve ye every one his idols, and hereafter also, if ye will not
hearken unto me: But pollute you my holy name no more with your
gifts, and with your idols.”
As much as to say, Go on no longer in this divided worship ; halt
no more between two opinions ; if Baal be your God, serve him; if
the God of Israel, then serve him only. The reason follows. .
Ver. 40—43. “ For in mine holy mountain—there shall all the
house of Israel—serve me. There will I accept them, and there will I
require your offerings—with all your holy things—and there shall ye
remember your ways, and all your doings wherein ye have been defiled,
AND YE SHALL LOTHE YOURSELVES IN YOUR OWN SIGHT.”’—1i. 6.
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 351
“For then, a new order of things shall commence. My people, after
their return from the Captivity, shall be as averse to idolatry, as till
then they were prone and disposed to it: and the memory of their
former follies shall make them lothe themselves in their own sight.”
And this, indeed, was the fact, as we learn by their whole history,
from their restoration to their own Land, quite down to the present
hour.
The idea of mercy is naturally attached to that of repentance and ~
reformation ; and with mercy the Prophecy concludes.
Ver. 44. “ And ye shall know that I am the Lord when I have
wrought with you for my name’s sake; not according to your wicked
ways, nor according to your corrupt doings, O ye house of Israel, saith
the Lord God.”
The Reader hath now a full explanation of the whole Prophecy :
whereby he may understand how justly it hath acquired its eminent
celebrity. Its general subject being no less than the Fate and For-
tunes of the Jewish Republic; of which the several parts are so
important, so judiciously chosen, so elegantly disposed, and so nobly
enounced, that we see the divinity of the original in every step we
take.
But to return to the peculiar purpose of this Comment. Which is
given to shew, that God himself has delivered the ritual Law of the
Jews, under the character of Statutes that were not good, and Judg-
ments whereby they should not live.*
The use I would make of it against Witsrus, with whom I have
been concerned, is to shew, that if such be the genius of the ritual
Law, it is no wonder it should have, in its composition, an alloy of
no better materials, than Egyptian and other Pagan Ceremonies ;
cleansed indeed and refined from their immoralities and superstitions :
And conversely, that a composition of such an alloy was very aptly
characterised by Statutes not good, and Judgments whereby they could
not live.
Thus having before seen what little force there was in Witsius’s
arguments, and now understanding how little reason he had to be so
tenacious of his opinion ; the reader may think he scarce merited the
distinction of being recommended to a learned Body as the very
bulwark of the faith, in this matter. But let what will become of his
arguments, he deserves honour for a much better thing than orthodox
disputation: I mean, for an honest turn of mind, averse to imputing
odious designs to his adversaries, or dangerous consequences to their
opinions.+
On the whole then, we conclude, both against Derisr and
* See note BBBBB, at the end of this book. + See note CCCCC, at the end
of this book.
352 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
BreieveRr, that the Ritual Law’s being made in reference to Egyp-
tian superstition is no reasonable objection to the divinity τὰ its
original.
But the Deist may object, “ That though indeed, when the Israel-
ites were once deeply infected with that superstition, such a ritual
might be necessary to stop and cure a growing evil; yet as the
remedy was so multiplex, burdensome, and slavish, and therefore not
in itself eligible, how happened it, that Gop, who had this family
under his immediate and peculiar care, should suffer them to contract
an infection which required so incenvenient and impure a remedy?”
I have been so accustomed to find the strongest objections of infi-
delity end in the stronger recommendation of revealed Religion, that
I have never been backward, either to produce what they have said,
when they write their best, or to imagine what they would say, if
they knew how to write better. To this therefore I reply, That the
promise Gop had made to Abraham, to give his posterity the land of
Canaan, could not be performed till that Family was grown strong
enough to take and keep possession of it. In the mean time, there-
fore, they were necessitated to reside amongst idolaters. And we
have seen, although they resided unmixed, how violent a propensity
they ever had to join themselves to the Gentile Nations, and to prac-
tise their Manners. Gop, therefore, in his infinite wisdom brought
them into Egypt, and kept them there during this period; the only
place where they could remain, for so long a time, safe and uncon-
founded with the natives; the ancient Egyptians being, by numerous
institutions, forbidden all fellowship with strangers; and bearing,
besides, a particular aversion to the profession* of this Family. Thus
we see, that the natural disposition of the Israclites, which, in Egypt,
occasioned their superstitions ; and, in consequence, the necessity of
a burthensome Ritual, would, in any other Country, have absorbed
them in Gentilism, and confounded them with Idolaters. From this
objection, therefore, nothing comes but a new occasion to adore the
footsteps of eternal Wisdom in his Dispensations to his chosen People.
ΠΙ.
The last proposition is, That the very circumstances of Moses’s
Egyptian learning, and the Laws instituted in compliance to the peo-
ples prejudices, and in opposition to Egyptian superstitions, are a
strong confirmation of the divinity of his mission.
Eeyrrt was the great School of legislation for the rest of Mankind.
And so revered were her oracular dictates, that foreign Lawgivers,
who went thither for instruction, never ventured to deviate from those
fundamental principles of Government which she prescribed. In
* The profession of Shepherds.
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 353
RELIGION, particularly, which always made a part of civil Policy,
they so closely adhered to Egyptian maxims, that Posterity, as we
have seen, were deceived into an opinion that the Greek Lawgivers
had received their very Gods from thence.
What therefore must we think had been the case of a Native of
Egypt ; bred up from his infancy in Egyptian wisdom, and, at length,
become a member of their Legislative body? would such a man, when
going to frame a civil Policy and Religion (though we suppose
nothing of that natural affection, which the best and wisest men have
ever borne for their own country-institutions), be at all inclined to
deviate from its fundamental principles of Government ?
Yet here we have in Moses, according to our Adversaries’ account
of him, a mere human Lawgiver, come fresh out of the Schools of
Egypt, to reduce a turbulent People into Society, acting on funda-
mental Principles of Religion and Policy directly opposite to all the
maxims of Egyptian Wisdom.
One of the chief of which, in the RELIGIOUS PoLIcy of Egypt,
was, That the government of the World had, by the supreme Ruler of
the universe, been committed into the hands of subordinate, local,
tutelary Deities ; amongst whom the several Regions of the earth were
shared out and divided : that these were the true and proper objects
of all public and popular Religion; and that the knowledge of the
ONE TRUE God, the Creator of all things, was highly dangerous to be
communicated to the People; but was to be secreted, and shut up in
their mysTeRIEs; and in them, to be revealed only occasionally, and
to a few; and those few, the wise, the learned, and ruling part of
mankind.* Now, in plain defiance and contempt of this most vene-
rable Principle, our Egyptian Lawgiver rejects these doctrines of
inferior Deities, as impostures, and lying vanities ; and. boldly and
openly preaches up to the People, the belief of the onE TRUE Gop,
the Creator, as the sole object of the Religion of all mankind.+
Another fundamental maxim, the RELIGious PoLicy of Egypt,
was to propagate, by every kind of method, the doctrine of A FUTURE
STATE OF REWARDS AND PUNISHMENTS; as the necessary support
of all Religion and Government. Here again, our Lawgiver (no
Deist can tell whyt) forsakes all his own principles ; intentionally
rejects a support, which was as really beneficial to mankind, in all his
interests, as the other notion, of inferior Deities, was but thought to
be ; intirely omits to mention it in his Institutes of Law and Reli-
gion ; and is studiously silent in all those particulars which lead to the
propagation of it.§ But of this, more at large, in a future volume.
* See an account of these MystTERIEs in the first volume. { See note DDDDD,
at the end of this book. { See ‘* View of Lord Bolingbroke’s Philosophy,’’
letter iv. § See note EEEER, at the end of this book.
VOL. II. A A
904 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
Again, it was of the crvi~ poxicy of Egypt to prefer an hereditary
despotic Monarchy to all other forms of Government: Moses, on the
contrary, erects a THrocracy on the free choice of the people ; to be
administered Aristocratically.
Add to all this, that his deviation from the Policy of Egypt was
encountering the strongest prejudices of his People; who were vio-
lently carried away to all the customs and superstitions of that
Policy.
And now let an ingenuous Deist weigh these instances, with many
more that will easily occur to him, and then fairly tell us his senti-
ments. Let him try, if he can think it was at all likely, that Moses,
a mere human Lawgiver, a Native of Egypt, and learned in all its
political Wisdom, should, in the formation of a Civil policy, for such
a People as he undertook to govern, act directly contrary to all the
fundamental principles in which he had been instructed ?
I. To this perhaps it may be said,—‘‘ That Moses well understood
the folly and falshood of inferior Gops :—that he did not believe the
doctrine of a future state of rewards and punishments ;—that he was
too honest to employ fraud :—that his love to his People made him
indisposed to an hereditary despotic Monarchy ;—and that the theo-
logic principles of Egypt led him to the invention of a THrocracy.”
To all this, I answer,
1. As to his seeing the falshood of inferior Gods.—So did many
other of the old Lawgivers, instructed in Egyptian policy ; yet being
taught to think Polytheism useful to Society, they did not, for all
that, the less cultivate their abominable idolatry.
2. As to his not believing a future state, and his honesty in not
teaching what he did not believe-—Such Objectors forget that they have
already made him a fraudulent impostor, in his pretension to a divine
employment. Now if the end of civil Government made him fraudu-
lent in that instance, it would hardly suffer him to be scrupulous in
this ; even allowing the extravagance of this fancy, that he did not
believe a future state ; because, as hath been proved at large,* the
propagation of this doctrine is, and was always believed to be, the
firmest support of civil government : But of this more at large, here-
after.
3. With regard to his concern for the happiness of his people ;—I1
will readily allow this to be very consistent with Heroic or Legislative
fraud. But this happiness the ancient Lawgivers thought best pro-
cured by the Egyptian mode of Government. And indeed they had
EXPERIENCE, the best guide in public matters. For the excellent
education which the Egyptians gave their Kings, in training them up
to the love of the Public, and high veneration for the Laws, prevented
* See the first volume.
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 355
the usual abuse of power ; and gave to that people the longest and
most uninterrupted course of prosperity that any Nation ever
enjoyed.* It is no wonder, therefore, that this should make
MONARCHY (as it did) the first favourite form of Government, in all
places civilized by the aid of Egypt.
4. But, the theologic principles of Egypt led Moses to the invention
of a THrocracy.—Without doubt those principles, as we shall see
hereafter, occasioned its easy reception amongst the Hebrews. But
there is one circumstance in the case that shews its invention must
have been of Gop, and not of Moses. For the ground of its easy
reception was the notion of local tutelary Deities. But this notion,
Moses, in preaching up the doctrine of the one true Gop, entirely
took away. This, indeed, on a supposition of a Divine LeGarion,
has all the marks of admirable wisdom; but supposing it to be
Moses’s own contrivance, we see nothing but inconsistency and
absurdity. He forms a design, and then defeats it; he gives with
one hand, and he takes away with the other.
II. But it may be farther objected,—‘“ That, as it was the inten-
tion of Moses to separate these people from all others, he, therefore,
gave them those cross and opposite institutions, as a barrier to all
communication.” ΤῸ this I answer,
1. That were it indeed Gon, and not Moses, who projected this
SEPARATION, the reason would be good. Because the immediate end
of Gon’s separation was twofold, to keep them unmixed; and to
secure them from idolatry: and such end could not be effected but
by opposing those fundamental principles of Egypt, with the doctrine
of one Gop, and the institution of a THrocracy. But then this,
which would be a good reason, will become a very bad objection.
Our Deist is to be held to the question. He regards Moses as a mere
human Lawgiver. But the sole end which such a one could propose
by a separation, was to preserve his people pure and unmixed. Now
this could be effected only by laws which kept them at home, and
discouraged and prevented all foreign commerce: and these, by the
same means, bringing on general poverty, there would be small danger
of their being much frequented, while they laboured under that con-
tagious malady. This we know was the case of Sparta. It was their
Lawgiver’s chief aim to keep them distinct and unmixed. But did he
do this by institutions which crossed the fundamental principles of
the Religion and Policy of Greece? By no means. They were all of
them the same. The method he gmployed was only to frame such
Laws as discouraged commerce and foreign intercourse. And these
proved effectual. I the rather instance in the Spartan, than in any
other Government, because the end, which Moses and Lycurgus pur-
* See note FFFFF, at the end of this book.
29 9
a Ae
396 THE DIVINE LEGATION - BOOK IV.
sued in common, (though for different purposes) of keeping their
people separate, occasioned such a likeness in several parts of the two
Institutions, as was, in my opinion, the real origin of that tradition
mentioned in the first book of Maccabees, That there was a Family-
relation between the two People. :
2. But, secondly, as it is very true, that the mere intention of
keeping a people separate and unmixed (which is all a human Law-
giver could have in view) would occasion Laws in opposition to the
customs of those people with whom, from their vicinity to, or fond-
ness for, they were in most danger of being confounded ; so, when I
insisted on those Anti-Egyptian institutions, which I gave as a certain
proof of Moses’s Divine Legation, I did not reckon, in my account,
any of that vast number of ritual and municipal laws, which,
Manetho confesses, were given principally in opposition to Egyptian
customs.* This a mere separation would require: But this is a very
different thing from the opposition to FUNDAMENTALS, here insisted
on; which a mere separation did not in the least require.
III. But it may be still further urged, “ That resentment for ill
usage might dispose Moses to obliterate the memory of the place they
came from, by a Policy contrary to the fundamental Institutions of
Egypt.’ Here again our objecting Deist: will forget himself. 1. He
hath urged a conrormity in the Law to Egyptian Rites ; and this,
in order to discredit Moses’s Divine Legation : and we have allowed
him his fact. Whatever it was therefore that engaged Moses to his
general OPPOSITION, it could not be resentment: for that had cer-
tainly prevented all kind of conformity or similitude.
2. But, secondly, such effects of civil resentment, the natural man-
ners of men will never suffer us to suppose. We have in ancient
history many accounts of the settlement of new Colonies, forced
injuriously from home by their fellow-citizens. But we never find
that this imbittered them against their Country-institutions. On the
contrary, their close adherence to their native customs, notwithstand-
ing all personal wrongs, has in every age enabled learned men to find
out their original, by strong characteristic marks of relation to the
mother city. And the reason is evident: INNATE LOVE OF ONE’S
COUNTRY, whose attractive power, contrary to that of natural bodies,
is strongest at a distance; and INVETERATE MANNERS which stick
closest in distress ; (the usual state of all new Colonies) are qualities
infinitely too strong to give way to resentment against particular men
for personal injuries. τ
“Ὁ δὲ ττρῶτον μὲν αὐτοῖς νόμον ἔθετο, μήτε παροσκυνεῖν ϑεούς, μήτε τῶν μάλιστα ἐν
Αἰγύπτῳ ϑεμιστευομένων ἱερῶν ζώων ἀπέχεσθαι μηδενὸς, ττάντα Te ϑύειν καὶ ἀναλοῦν"
συνάπτεσθαι δὲ μηδενὶ wAhy τῶν συνωμοσμένων. τοιαῦτα δὲ νομοθετήσας καὶ τσλεῖστα
ἄλλα, μάλιστα τοῖς Αἰγυπτίοις ἐθισμοῖς evayTiovueva.—Apud JosePHUM Contra Apion.
lib. i. pp. 460, 461, Haverch. ed.
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 307
It is not indeed unlikely but that some certain specific Law or
custom, which did, or was imagined to contribute to their disgrace
and expulsion, might, out of resentment, be reprobated by the new
Colony. And this is the utmost that the history of mankind will
suffer us to suppose.
On the whole, therefore, I conclude that Mosrs’s Eaypr1an
LEARNING IS A STRONG CONFIRMATION OF THE DIVINITY OF HIS
MISSION,
The second part of the proposition is no less evident, That the
laws instituted in compliance to the people's prejudices, and in oppost- |
tion to Egyptian superstitions, support the same truth with equal
strength. Had Moses’s Mission been only pretended, his conduct, as
a wise Lawgiver, had doubtless been very different. His business had
been then only to support a false pretence to inspiration. Let us
see how he managed. He pretended to receive the whole frame of a
national Institution from Gon; and to have had the pattern of all its
parts brought him down from Heaven, to the Mount. But when this
came to be promulged, it was seen that, the CEREMONIAL LAW
being politically instituted, partly in compliance to the people’s preju-
dices, and partly in opposition to Egyptian superstitions, several of
its Rites had a reference to the Pagan superstitions in vogue. This,
as we see, from the objection of the ignorant in these times, might have
been an objection in those. And as an Impostor could not but have
foreseen the objection, his fears of a discovery would have made him
decline so hazardous a system, and cautiously avoid every thing that
looked like an imitation. It is true, that, on enquiry, this unfolds a
scene of admirable and superior wisdom: but it is such as an
Impostor could never have projected; or at least would never have
ventured to leave to the mercy of popular judgment. We conclude,
therefore, that this conduct is a clear proof that Moses actually
received the Institution from Gop. Nor does this in anywise contra-
dict what we have so much insisted on above, That a mere human
Lawgiver, or even an inspired one, acting with free agents, is necessi-
tated to comply with the passions of the People ; a compliance which
would necessarily induce such a relation to Egypt as we find in the
ritual Law: for we must remember too what hath been likewise
shewn, that the ends of a divine and human Lawgiver, both using the
common means of a SEPARATION, are vastly different ; the latter-only
aiming to keep the people unmixed ; the former, to keep them pure
from idolatry. Now, in both cases, where the People are dealt with
as free agents, some compliance to their prejudices will be necessary.
But as, in the Institution of a human Lawgiver pretending only to
inspiration, such comphance in the Rrruau would be subject to the
danger here spoken of ; and as compliance in the FUNDAMENTALS,
308 _ THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
such as the object of Worship, a future State, and mode of civil
Government, would not be so subject; and, at the same time, would
win most forcibly on a prejudiced people, to the promoting the
Legislator’s end; we must needs conclude that these would be the
things he would comply with and espouse. On the other hand, as a
divine Lawgiver could not comply in these things; and as a Rirvat,
like the Mosaic, was the only means left of gaining his end; we must
conclude that a divine Lawgiver would make his compliance on that side.
1. Let me only add one corollary to our BELIEVING ADVERSA-
. RIES, as a farther support of this part of the proposition ; ‘ That
allowing the Ritual-law to be generally instituted in reference to
Egyptian and other neighbouring Superstitions, the divine wisdom
of the contrivance will be seen in redoubled lustre.” One reason, as
we have seen above, of the opposition to the notion of such a refer-
ence is, that the RITUAL LAW WAS TYPICAL, not only of things
relating to that Dispensation, but to the Evangelical. . This then they
take for granted; and, as will be shewn hereafter, with good reason.
Now an Institution of a body of Rites, particularly and minutely
levelled against, and referring to, the idolatrous practices of those
ages; and, at the same time, as minutely typical, not only of all the
remarkable transactions under that Dispensation, but hkewise of all
the great and constituent parts of a future one, to arise in a distant
age, and of a genius directly opposite, must needs give an attentive
considerer the most amazing idea of divine wisdom.* And this I beg
leave to offer to the consideration of the unprejudiced Reader, as
another strong INTERNAL ARGUMENT THAT THE RITUAL LAW WAS
NOT OF MERE HUMAN CONTRIVANCE.
2. Let me add another corollary to the UNBELIEVING Jews. We
have seen at large how expedient it was for the Jews of the first ages,
that the Ritual or ceremonial Law should be directed against the
several idolatries of those ages. It was as expedient for the Jews of
the later ages that this Law should be ryprcau hkewise. For had it
not been typical, God would have given a Law whose reason would
have ceased many ages before the Theocracy was abolished: and so
have afforded a plausible occasion to the Jews for changing or abro-
gating them, on their own. head.
* Hear what the learned Spencer says on this occasion: ‘‘ Atque hac in re Deus
sapientiz suze specimen egregium edidit, et illi non absimile quod in mundo frequenter
observamus: in eo enim, notante Verulamio, dum natura aliud agit, providentia aliud
elicit ; nam frondibus quas natura, consuetudinem suam retinens, parit, utitur providen-
tia ad cceli injurias a fructu tenello propulsandas. Pari modo, cum Hebrzorum natio,
consuetudinem suam exuere nescia, ritus antiquos impense desideraret, Deus eorum
desiderio se morigerum prebebat; sed eorum ruditate et impotentia puerili ad fines
egregios et sapientia sua dignos utebatur. Sie enim ritus antiquos populo indultos,
circumstantiis quibusdam demptis aut additis, immutavit, ut rerum ceelestium schema
representarent, oculis purgatioribus facile percipiendum ; adeo ut Deus puerilibus Israeli-
farum studiis obsequens, divina promovyeret.’’—-De Legthus Heb. Rit. p. 218.
SECT. VI. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 359
3. Let me add a third corollary to the UNBELIEVING GENTILES.
The Law’s being fypical obviates their foolish argument against Reve-
lation, that the abolition of the Mosaic religion and the establishment
of the Christian in its stead, impeaches the wisdom of God, as imply-
ing change and inconstancy in his acting ; for by his making the Law
typical, the two religions are scen to be the two parts of one and the
same design.
The great Maimonides, who first * explained the causes of the
Jewish Ritual in any reasonable manner (and who, to observe it by
the way, saw nothing in the Law but temporal sanctions), was so
struck with the splendour of divinity, which this hght reflected back
upon the law, that in the entry on his subject he breaks out into this
triumphant boast, EA TIBI EXPLICABO UT PLANE NON AMPLIUS
DUBITARE QUEAS ET DIFFERENTIAM HABEAS QUA DISCERNERE
POSSIS INTER ORDINATIONES LEGUM CONDITARUM AB HOMINIBUS
ET INTER ORDINATIONES LEGIS DIVINE,
Thus the Reader sees what may be gained by fairly and boldly
submitting to the force of evidence. Such a manifestation of the
divinity of the Law, arising out of the Deist’s own principles, as is
sufficient to cover him with confusion !
And what is it, we lose? Nothing sure very great or excellent.
The imaginary honour of being original in certain Rites (considered in
themselves) indifferent ; and becoming good or bad by comparison, or
by the authority which enjoins them, and by the object to which they
are directed.
The Deist indeed pretends that, in the things borrowed from
Egypt, the first principles of Law and Morality, and the very tritest
customs of civil life, are to be included. The extravagance of this
fancy hath been exposed elsewhere.t But as it is a species of folly
all parties are apt to give into, it may not be amiss to consider this
matter of TRADUCTIVE CUSTOMS a little more particularly.
There is nothing obstructs our discoveries in Antiquity (as far as
concerns the noblest end of this study, the knowledge of mankind)
so much as that false, though undisputed Principle, that the general
customs of men, whether civil or religious, (in which a common like-
ness connects, as in a chain, the Manners of its inhabitants, through-
out the whole globe) are traductive from one another. When, in
truth, the origin of this general similitude is from the sameness of
one common Nature, improved by reason, or debased by superstition.
But when a custom, whose meaning lies not upon the surface, but
requires a profounder search, is the subject of inquiry, it is much
easier to tell us that the users borrowed it from such or such a people,
* In his More Nevoch. pars iiiimAnd see note GGGGG, at the end of this book.
t Vol. i. book ii.
900 THE DIVINE LEGATION OF MOSES. BOOK IV.
than rightly to inform us, what common principle of REASON or
SUPERSTITION gave birth to it in both.
How many able writers have employed their time and learning to
prove that Christian Rome borrowed their superstitions from the
Pagan city! They have indeed shewn an exact and surprising like-
ness in a great variety of instances. But the conclusion from thence,
that, therefore, the Catholic borrowed from the Heathen, as plausible
as it may seem, is, I think, a very great mistake ; which the followers
of this hypothesis might have understood without the assistance of
the principle here laid down: since the rise of the superstitious cus-
toms in question were many ages later than the conversion of that
imperial city to the Christian Faith : consequently, at the time of their
introduction, there were no PAGAN prejudices which required such
a compliance from the ruling Clergy. For this, but principally for
the general reason here advanced, I am rather induced to believe, that
the very same spirit of superstition, operating in equal circumstances,
made both Papists and Pagans truly originals.
But does this take off from the just reproach which the Reformed
have cast upon the Church of Rome, for the practice of such Rites,
and encouragement of such Superstitions ? Surely not; but rather
strongly fixes it. In the former case, the rulers of that Church had
been guilty of a base compliance with the infirmities of their new
converts: in the latter, the poison of superstition is seen to have
infected the very vitals of its Hierarchy.*
But then, truth will fare almost as ill when a right, as when a
wrong principle, is pushed to an extravagance. Thus, as it would be
ridiculous to deny, that the Roman laws of the Twelve Tables were
derived from the Greeks ; because we have a circumstantial history of
their traduction : so it would be equally foolish not to own, that a
great part of the Jewish ritual was composed in reference to the super-
stitions of Egypt ; because their long abode in the country had made
the Israelites extravagantly fond of Egyptian customs: but to think
(as some Deists seem to have done) that they borrowed from thence
their common principles of morality, and the legal provisions for the
support of such principles,f is, whether we consider the Israelites
under a divine or human direction, a thing equally absurd ; and such
an absurdity as betrays the grossest ignorance of human nature, and
the history of mankind.
And thus much concerning the anriauiry of Egypt, and its
EFFECTS on the Divine Legation of Moses.
* See note HHHHH, at the end of this book. + See MARSHAM.
NOTES
ON
THE FOURTH BOOK.
P. 141. A. Dr. Prieavx, in his learned Connevions, has indeed told us
a very entertaining story of ZoroastRES: whom, of an early Lawgiver of
the Bactrians, Dr. Hyde had made a late false prophet of the Persians, and
the preacher-up of one God in the public religion ; which doctrine, how-
ever, this learned man supposes to be stolen from the Jews. But the truth
is, the whole is a pure fable; contradicts all learned antiquity ; and is
supported only by the ignorant and romantic relations of late Persian
writers under the Califes ; who make Zoroastres contemporary with Darius
Hystaspis, and servant to one of the Jewish prophets; yet, in another fit
of lying, they place him as early as Moses; they eyen say he was Abra-
ham ; nay, they stick not to make him one of the builders of Babel. It
may be thought strange how such crude imaginations, however cooked up,
could be deemed serviceable to Revelation, when they may be so easily
turned against it ; for all falshood is naturally on the side of unbelief. I
have long indeed looked when some minute philosopher would settle upon
this corrupted place, and give it the infidel taint. And just as I thought,
it happened. One of them having grounded upon this absurd whimsy the
impious slander of the Jews having received from the followers of Zoroastres,
during the captivity, juster notions of God and his providence than they had
before.—See The Moral Philosopher, vol. i. and vol. ii. p. 144. Another of
these Philosophers makes as good an use of his Indian Bracmanes, and their
Vedam and Ezourvedam ; for this Vedam is their Bible, as the Zend or
Zendavesta is the Bible of the fire worshipers in Persia, and both of them
apparent forgeries since the time of Mahomet to oppose to the Alcoran.
Yet Mr. Voltaire says, of his Κειμήλιον, the Hzourvedam, that it is appa-
rently older than the conquests of Alexander, because the rivers, towns,
and countries, are called by their old names, before they were new christ-
ened by the Greeks. —“ Cet ancien Commentaire du Vedam me parait ecrit
avant les conquétes d’ Alexandre, car on n’y trouve aucun des noms que les
vainqueurs Grecs imposerent aux fleuves, aux villes, aux contrees.” Addi-
tions ἃ Hist. Generale, p. 23, 24. Which is just as wise, as it would be
to observe, that the Sarazin and Turkish annals were written before the
conquests of Alexander, because we find in them none of the names which
the Greeks imposed on the rivers, the cities, and the countries, which they
conquered in the Lesser Asia, but their ancient names, by which they were
knewn from the earliest times. It never came into the Poet’s head that
the Indians and Arabians might be exactly of the same humour, to restore
the native names to the places from which the Greeks had driven them.
P. 141, Β. μόνῳ δὲ τῶν ‘ESpaiov γένει τὴν ἘΠΟΠΤΕΙΑΝ ἀνατεθεῖσθαι
τῆς ΘΕΩΡΙΑΣ τοῦ τῶν ὅλων ποιητοῦ καὶ AHMIOYPL'OY Θεοῦ, καὶ τῆς εἰς
362 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
ἀυτὸν ἀληθοῦς εὐσεξείας. Prep. Evang. 1. i. c. ix. p. 20. As the imaginary
interest of religion engaged Dr. Prideaux to espouse the Persian tale of
Zoroastres ; so the same motive induced those excellent persons, Stilling-
fleet, Cudworth, and Newton, to take the affirmative in the general question,
whether the one true God had ever been publicly worshiped out of Judea,
between the introduction of general idolatry, and the birth of Christ. As
this determination of the general question is no less injurious to Revelation
than the particular of Zoroastres, we may be assured no less advantage
would be taken of it. Lord Bolingbroke saw to what use it might be
applied, and has therefore enforced it to the discredit of Judaism : indeed,
with his usual address, by entangling it in a contradiction. But those
other venerable names will make it necessary hereafter to examine both the
one and the other question at large.
P. 147. C. See Shuckford’s Sacred and profane history of the world
connected, vol. ii. edit. 2. p. 317—327. Our countryman Gale, in the like
manner, is for deriving all arts and sciences, without exception, front the
Jews—“ Arithmetic,” he says, “it is evident, had its foundation from God
himself ; for the first computation of time is made by God, Gen. i. 5, &e.
And as for navigation, though some ascribe it to the Phenicians ; yet it is
manifest the first idea thereof was taken from Noah’s ark. It is as plain
that geography traduced its first lines from the Mosaic description of the
several plantations of Noah’s posterity.’—Court of the Gentiles, part i.
p- 18. “Who would not think but the learned man, and learned he really
was in good truth, was disposed to banter us, had he not given so sad a
proof of his being in earnest as the writing three bulky volumes to support
these wonderful ‘discover! ies ?
P. 147. D. See Canon Chron. Secul. v. tit. Circumcisio. I decline enter-
ing into this controversy for two reasons: 1. Because, which way soever
the question be decided, the truth of the Mosaic account will be nothing
affected by it ; for the Scripture no where says, that Abraham was the first
man, circumcised ; nor is the prior use of this rite amongst men, any argu-
ment against God’s enjoining him to observe it. The pious bishop Cum-
berland little thought he was disserving religion, when he followed an
interpretation of the fragment of Sanchoniatho, which led him to conclude
[ Remarks on Sanchon.’s Pheen. Hist. p. 150.] that whole nations had prac-
tised circumcision before Abraham: but I quote this great man, not for the
weight of his opinion in a matter so unconcerning, but as an example of
that candour of mind and integrity of heart, without which the pursuit of
truth is a vainer employment than the pursuit of butterflies. A less able
and a less ingenuous man, with not a tenth part of this noble writer’s
invention, would have had a thousand tricks and fetches to reconcile the
first institution of this rite in Abraham to the high antiquity he had given
to Cronus. Another example of a contrary conduct, ina writer of equal
account, will shew us how much this ingenuity is to be esteemed in men
of learning. The excellent Dr. Hammond, misled by the party-prejudices
of his time, had persuaded himself to believe, that the prophecies of the
Apocalypse related only to the first ages of the Christian Church ; and that
the book was written, not, as Ireneus supposed, about the end of Domitian’s
reign, but, as Epiphanius affirmed, in Claudius Cesar’s. To this, there
were two objections ; First, that then the prophecy, which, on Hammond’s
system, related to the destruction of Jerusalem, would be of an event past :
while the prophecy speaks of it as a thing future. To this he replies, That
it was customary with the Prophets to speak of things past as of things to
come. So fay was well. But then the second objection is, That if this
NOTES. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 363
were the time of writing the Revelations, Antipas, who is said, ¢. ii. ver.
13. to have been martyred, was yet alive. No matter for that, it was cus-
tomary with the Prophets, as he tells us on the other hand, to speak of things
to come as of things past. And all this within the compass of two pages.
2. The other reason for my not entering into this matter is, because it is
not my intention to examine (except occasionally) any particular question
of this kind. This hath been done already. What I propose is to prove
in general, that many of the positive institutions of the Hebrews were
enjoined in opposition to the idolatrous customs of the Egyptians ; and that
some bearing a conformity to those customs, and not liable to be abused to
superstition, were indulged to them, in wise compliance with the prejudices
which long use and habit are accustomed to induce.
P.151. E. The recovery of exhausted fertility by compost, seems not
to have been a very early invention. For though Homer describes Laertes
in his rural occupations as busied in this part of agriculture ; yet Hesiod,
in a professed and detailed poem on the subject, never once mentions the
method of dunging land.—Not that I regard this circumstance as any sure
proof to determine the question of Hesiod’s priority in point of time. It
may be well accounted for, by supposing, that they described particular
places in the state they were then found, some more and some less advanced
in the arts of civil life.
P. 153. F. Here let me observe, that this representation of the high
and flourishing state of Egypt, in these early times, greatly recommends
the truth of the Samaritan chronology, and shews how much it is to be
preferred to the Hebrew. See the learned and judicious M. Leonarp in his
Observations sur V antiquité des Hieroglyphes scientifiques, p. 339, 24 vol.
P. 153. G. The various disasters to which determined disputants are
obnoxious from their own proper tempers, would make no unentertaining
part of literary history. A learned writer undertaking to confute the
Egyptian pretensions to their high antiquity, thinks it proper first to shew,
that they did indeed pretend to it. And this, it must be owned, he does
effectually enough. His words are these: “ Et profecto, ab aNTIQUISSIMIS
TEMPORIBUS hac vanitate infecti erant : dicebat enim, ipso Isaize tempore,
purpuratorum quisque Pharaoni se esse filiwm regum antiquissimorum.”—
Spicilegia antig. Egypt. Sc. autore Gul. Jameson. Now, could any thing
be more unlucky? The author only meant to introduce his system by
this flourish ; and in introducing it, he confutes it. For can there be a
better evidence of the high antiquity of any people than that they claimed
it from the most ancient times? from times long preceding that general
vanity of a high antiquity, which had infected the nations, and prompted
them to support their claims against one another, by forged evidence and
unphilosophic reasoning? Not to say, that this high antiquity is acknow-
ledged by the Prophet also: the force of whose exultation depends on the
truth of it. For what reason was there to insist so much on the power and
wisdom of God in destroying the counsel of Egypt, if Pharaoh and his
Counsellors, only pretended to be, but were not, wise ; nor yet, the sons
of ancient kings ?
P. 155. H. Cheremon, who, as we are told by Josephus, wrote the his-
tory of Egypt, calls Moses and Joseph scribes ; and Joseph a sacred scribe,
ἡγεῖσθαι δ᾽ αὐτῶν γραμματέας Μωῦσήν re καὶ ἸΩΣΗΠΟΝ᾽ καὶ τοῦτον TEPO-
ΓΡΑΜΜΑΤΒΑ, cont. Ap. lib. i. Τὸ is true, the historian has confounded
times, in making Joseph contemporary with Moses: but this was a com-
mon mistake amongst the Pagans. Justin the epitomizer of Trogus Pom-
peius calls Moses the son of Joseph—/ilius ejus | Joseph | Moses fuit, quem
904 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
preter paterne scientie hereditatem, &c., lib. xxxvi. cap. 2. Those learned
men therefore are mistaken, who, for this reason, would have it that
Cheremon, by Joseph, meant Joshua. Besides, the superior title here
given to Joseph shews plainly we are to understand the patriarch, and not
the companion of Moses: for though it appears from Scripture that Joseph
and Moses were related to, and educated by the Egyptian Priesthood, yet
we have not the least reason to think that Joshua had ever any concern
with them ; being held with the rest of his brethren in a state of servitude,
remote from the benefit of that education, which a singular accident had
bestowed upon Moses.
P. 156. I. Hence we may collect, how ill-grounded that opinion is of
Eupolemus and other authors, ancient and modern, who imagine, that
Abraham first taught the Egyptians astrology. And indeed the contending
for this original of the sciences seems to contradict another argument much
in use amongst Divines, and deservedly so ; which answers the objection
of infidels against the authority of the Bible, from several inaccuracies
in science to be met with in sacred history, by observing it was not
God’s purpose, in revealing himself to mankind, to instruct them in the
sciences.
P. 156. K. Εὔδοξον μὲν οὖν Χονούφεώς φησι Μεμφίτου διακοῦσαι: “Σόλωνα
δὲ, Σόγχιτος Saizov’ ΠΥΘΑΓΌΡΑΝ δὲ, Οἰνούφεως ἩΛΙΟΥΠΟΔΙΤΟΥ. Plut.
de Is. et Osir. p. 632. Steph. ed. Here we see, each sage went for that
science he was disposed to cultivate, to its proper Mart: for not only
Pythagoras studied astronomy at Heliopolis, where it was professed with
the greatest celebrity ; but Eudoxus learnt his geometry at Memphis,
whose Priests were the most profound mathematicians ; and Solon was
instructed in civil wisdom at Sais, whose patron deity being Minerva (as
we are told by Herodotus and Strabo) shews that politicks was there in
most request: and this doubtless was the reason why Pythagoras, who,
during his long abode in Egypt, went through all their schools, chose
Minerva for the patroness of his legislation. See Div. Leg. vol. i. book ii.
sect. 2, 3.
P. 157. L. I cannot forbear on this occasion to commend the ingenuous
temper of another learned writer, far gone in the same system: who, haying
said all he could think of to discredit the antiquity and wisdom of Egypt,
concludes in this manner.—“ Tandem queres, in qua doctrina Agyptiorum
propter quam tantopere celebrati erant in épsis Scripturis, viz. 1 Reg. ὁ. iv.
com. 30. et vil. actorwm, com. 22, Respondeo, non nego magnos Philosophos,
Geometras, et Mupicos, et aliarum artium peritos fuisse in Egypto, tempore
Mosis, et postea quoque, Sed sensim et gradatim illa doctrina exolevit, ut
omnino nihil aut parum ejus permanserit.”—G. Jameson, Spicilegia Antiq.
fEgypt. p. 400, 1.—You will ask now, What is become of his system ?
No matter. He is true to a better thing, the sacred Texr: for the sake of
which he took up the system; and for the sake of which, upon better
information, he lays it down again: and, like an honest man, sticks to his
Bible at all hazards.
P. 164. M. Diodorus Siculus, lib. i. says, that Melampus was in the
number of those civilizers of Greece, who went, to fit themselves for that
employment, into Egypt: and, as Orpheus proceeded thence a legislator
and philosopher ; so Melampus, whose bent lay another way, commenced
physician and diviner ; those two arts being, as we have said, professed toge-
ther in Egypt. Apollodorus says, he was the first who cured diseases by
medicinal potions. τὴν διὰ φαρμακῶν καὶ καθαρμῶν ϑεραπείαν wparos εὑρηκώς.
—Meaning the first among the Greeks. As this Greek went to Egypt to
NOTES. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 26
ὧι
be instructed in his craft, so we meet with an Egyptian who went to
practise the very same trade in Greece ;
“Ams γὰρ ἐλθὼν ἐκ wépas Ναυπακτείας,
IATPOMANTIS MAIS ANOAAQNOS, χθόνα
Thvd ἐκκαθαίρει κνωδάλων βροτοφθόρων.
A®sch. Inet. p. 316. Stanl. ed.
As to what is said of his being the son of Apollo, we must understand it
in the sense of Homer, where he speaks of the Egyptian physicians in
general :
IHTPOS δὲ ἕκαστος ἐπιστάμενος wep) wavTwy
᾿Ανθρώπων: ἢ γὰρ TAIHONOS ΕΙΣΙ TENEOAHS.
Ῥ. 172. N. Nothing can be more unjust or absurd than the accusation
of Joseph’s making the free monarchy of Egypt despotic : for allowing it
did indeed at this time suffer such a revolution, who is to be esteemed the
author of it but Pharaoh himself? Joseph indeed was prime minister ;
but it does not appear that his master was of that tribe of lazy monarchs,
who intrust their sceptre to the hands of their servants. Moses describes
him as active, vigilant, jealous of his authority, anxious for his country,
and little indulgent to his officers of state. But the terms in which he
invests Joseph in his office, shew that office to be purely ministerial ; how
shalt be over my house, and according to thy word shall all my people be ruled,
ONLY IN THE THRONE WILL I BE GREATER THAN THOU. [Gen. xli. 40. ]
i. e. thou shalt administer justice, but I will reserve to myself the preroga-
tive of giving law. It is highly reasonable therefore, when we find, in so
concise a history as the Mosaick, Joseph bidding the people give their
money, their cattle, and their lands for bread, to suppose that he only deli-
vered to them the words of Pharaoh, who would supply their wants on
no other conditions.
P.173. O. This is the general sentiment of Antiquity ; and as generally
embraced by modern writers. Kircher makes it the foundation of his
Theatrum Hieroglyphicum, and so consequently hath written a large volume
full of the most visionary interpretations. The great principle, he goes
upon, as he himself tells us, is this :— Hieroglyphica AXgyptiorum doc-
trina nihil aliud est, quam Arcana de Deo, divinisque Ideis, Angelis,
Demonibus, cxterisque mundanarum potestatum classibus ordinibusque
scientia, Saxis potissimtm insculpta.” Oedipus Aigyptiacus, tom. ili. p. 4.
Dr. Wilkins follows the received opinion in the general division of his
subject, in his Essay towards a real Character: For speaking of notes for
secrecy, such (says he) were the Egyptian hieroglyphics.—Yet he adds, with
his usual penetration,—ét seems to me questionable whether the Egyptians did
not at first use their hieroglyphics as a mere shift for the want of letters, as
was done by the Mexicans, p. 12.—And this was all his subject led him to
say of the Egyptian Hieroglyphics. Servius had gone further, and asserted
the priority of hieroglyphics without a doubt. “ Annus enim secundum
Mgyptios indicabatur, ante inventas literas, picto dracone caudam suam
mordente.” Apud Virg. Ain. 1. v. ver. 85. :
Ῥ. 176. P. The ship and pilot, bearing this signification, would, of
course, be much used in the descriptions of their mysteries, in which, as
we have shewn, the knowledge of the Governor of the universe was part of
the ἀπόῤῥητα : and so we find it more than once delineated in the Bembine
Table. Kircher, according to custom, makes it full of sublime know-
ledge ; but the plain truth is no more than this above.—Tacitus, speaking
of the religion of the Suevians, says they worshipped Isis ; he could not
366 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOQK IV.
conceive how this came about, only the figure of a galley, under which
image she was fepresented, shewed that the worship was imported from
abroad. ‘ Pars Suevorum et Isrpr sacrificat : unde causa et origo pere-
grino sacro, parum comperi, nis? quod signum ipsum, in modum Lisurnx
figuratum, docet advectam religionem.” De Morib. Germ. ὁ. ix. The
latter part of which period Mr. Gordon has thus translated, wnless the figure
of her image formed like a galley shewed, Sc. But nisi quod does not signify
unless, as implying any doubt, but saving only. So the same author, De
Mor. Ger. c. xxv. “ Occidere solent non disciplina et severitate, sed
impetu et ira, ut inimicum, 2s? quod impune.”’ ‘Tacitus could tell no
more of the original than this, that the worship of Isis was imported,
because her image was made in the figure of a galley. In this he was
positive : but for all this, not the less mistaken. It was indeed imported ;
but the galley was no mark of that original. Strabo tells us, in his fourth
book, that, in an island near Britain, they performed the same mysterious
rites to Ceres and Proserpine as were used in Samothrace. Ceres and Isis
were the same. The Phenician seamen, without doubt, brought them
thither, as likewise to the Suevians inhabiting the coasts of the German
ocean. The governor of the universe was taught in these mysteries. Isis
was represented by the later Egyptians to be the governor of the universe,
as we have seen before, in a discourse on the metamorphosis of Apuleius.
But the governor of the universe was delineated, in their hieroglyphics, by
a ship and pilot. ence, amongst the Suevians, Isis was worshipped under
the form of a galley, and not because her religion was of foreign growth :
And so amongst the Romans, which Tacitus did not advert to. For in the
calendarium rusticum amongst the inscriptions of Gruter, in the month of
March, an Egyptian holyday is marked under the title of Isrp1s Navrerum.
The ceremonies on this holyday are described in Apuleius Met. 1. ii—It
was a festival of very high antiquity amongst the Egyptians ; and seems to
be alluded to in these words of the Prophet Isaiah :— Wo to the land sha-
dowing with wings—that sendeth ambassadors by the sea even im VESSELS OF
BULRUSHES wpon the waters, saying, Go ye swift messengers, Sc. chap. xviii.
γΟΣΟ 1... 2.
Ῥ. 177. Q. The original is, καὶ τῶν λοιπῶν διετύπωσεν τοὺς ἱεροὺς τῶν
στοιχείων χαρακτῆρας. There is a small fault in this reading ; it should be
τούς TE ἱεροὺς, with the conjunction: The corruption helped to mislead
Cumberland, who translates,—and formed the sacred characters of the other
elements [p. 38. of his Sanchoniatho’s Phenician history] ; which looks as if
the learned prelate understood by στοιχείων, the elements of nature ; Calum
or Ouranos having (as he supposed) been mentioned before, as delineated or
engraved by Taautus: but =TOIXEION signifies the elements of hierogly-
phic writing, and λοιπῶν refers not to that, but to ϑεῶν just above ; which
further appears from what follows—rois δὲ λοιποῖς Seots ; otherwise, only
Dagon is left, for these words, τοῖς λοιποῖς Sects to be applied to.—Sancho-
niatho had said that Taautus represented the gods in a new invented hiero-
glyphic character ; and then goes on to tell us that he invented other
hieroglyphic characters, whether by figures or marks; for I apprehend
that ἱεροὺς τῶν στοιχείων χαρακτῆρας principally designs that part of hiero-
glyphic writing which was by marks, not figures: for without doubt, at
first,* the Egyptians used the same method as the Mexicans, who, we are
told, expressed in their hieroglyphic writing, those things which had form,
_* This Eusrarnivs intimates in these words, speaking of the most ancient Egyptian
hieroglyphics,—Zédid τινα ἱερογλυφοῦντες, καὶ λοιποὺς δὴ χαρακτῆρας εἰς σημασίαν ὧν
, 3 3 a
λέγειν €6ovAovto.— In Iliad. vi. verse 168.
NOTES, OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 267
by figures ; others by arbitrary marks. See p. 175, note (+). But we
shall see, that when the Egyptians employed this writing for the vehicle of
their secrets, they then invented the forms of things to express abstract
ideas. However, that this is the meaning of στοιχείων is further evident
from this place of Eusebius, where he speaks of a quotation of Philo’s,
from a work of Sanchoniatho, concerning the Phenician elements, Φοινίκων
στοιχείων ; which work, as appears by his account of the quotation, treated
of the nature of several animals, But we have shewn how much the
study of natural history contributed to the composition of hieroglyphic
characters.
Ῥ. 177. R. At the time this account was first given to the public, the
learned Dr. Richard Pococke coming fresh from Egypt, thought it ineum-
bent on him to contradict that Egyptian learning which was only con-
ceived at home. But as, by a common practice of prudent men, he had
not mentioned me by name, it was thought I had no right to reply. Let
the reader judge of one, by the other.—This learned and indeed candid
writer, in his book of travels, has a chapter, On the ancient hieroglyphics
of Egypt ; in which he expresseth himself as follows.—* If hieroglyphical
figures stood for words or sounds that signified certain things, the power of
hieroglyphics seems to be the same as of a number of letters composing
such a sound, that by agreement was made to signify such a thing. For
hieroglyphics, as words, seem to have stood for sounds, and sounds signify
things ; as for instance, it might have been agreed that the figure of a cro-
codile might stand for the sound that meant what we call malice: the
children of the priests were early taught that the figure of a crocodile stood
for such a sound, and, if they did not know the meaning of the sound, it
would certainly stand with them for a sound; though, as the sound, it
signified also a quality or thing ; and they might afterwards be taught the
meaning of this sound; as words are only sounds, which sounds we agree
shall signify such and such things ; so that, to children, words only stand
for sounds, which relate to such things as they know nothing of ; and, in
this sense, we say children learn many things like parrots, what they do
not understand, and their memories are exercised only about sounds, till
they are instructed in the meaning of the words. This I thought it might
be proper to observe, AS SOME SAY HIEROGLYPHICS STOOD FOR THINGS AND
NoT FOR worps,—if sounds articulated in a certain manner are words.
And though it may be said, that in this case, when different nations of
different languages agree on common characters, that stand for certain
things they agree on, that then such figures stand for things: this will be
allowed ; but then they stand for sounds too, that is, the sounds in each
language that signify such things: and, as observed before, to children,
who know nothing of the several things they stand for, to them they are
only marks that express such and such sounds: so that these figures stand
not for things alone, but as words, for sounds and things.” *
The design of this passage, the reader sees, is to oppose the principle I
went upon, in explaining the nature of Egyptian hieroglyphics, that they
stood for things, and not for words. But that is all one sees ; for the learned
writer’s expression conforming to his ideas, will not suffer us to do more
than guess at the proof which he advances: it looks, however, like this,—
That hieroglyphics cannot be said to stand for things only ; because things
being denoted by words or sounds ; and hieroglyphics exciting the idea of
sounds (which are the notes of things) as well as the idea of the things
themselves, hieroglyphics stand both for sounds and things.—This seems to
* Pp. 228, 229, of a book intituled, “A Description of the East,” Ke.
368 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
be the argument put into common English. But, for fear of mistaking
him, let us confine ourselves to his own words.
If hieroglyphical figures (says he) stood for words or sounds that signified
certain things, the power of hieroglyphics seems to be the same as of a number
of letters composing such a sound that by agreement was made to signify such
a thing. Without doubt, if hieroglyphics stood for sounds, they were of
the nature of words, which stand for sounds. But this is only an hypo-
thetical proposition; let us see therefore how he addresses himself to
prove it.—for hieroglyphics, as worps, seem to have stood for sounds, and
sounds signify things ; as for instance, it micur have been agreed that the
Jigure of a crocodile miaut stand for the same sound that meant what we call
malice. The propriety of the expression is suited to the force of the rea-
soning. 1. Instead of saying, but hieroglyphics, the learned writer says,
for hieroglyphics ; which not expressing an illation, but implying a reason,
obscures the argument he would illustrate. 2. He says, Hieroglyphics, as
words, seem to have stood for sounds. Just before, he said, hieroglyphics
stood for words or sounds. Here they are as words, or like words, and seem
to stand ror sound. What are we to take them for? are words sound ?
or, do they stand for sound? He has given us our choice. But we go
on. 3. For, he corroborates this seeming truth by an instance, in which
the possibility of its standing for a sound is made a proof of its so doing.
Jt micur (says he) have been agreed that the figure of a crocodile micutr
stand, &c.
But he is less-diffident in what follows. The children of the priests
were early taught that the figure of a crocodile stood for such a sound, and
if they did not know the meaning of the sound, it would certainly stand
with them for a sound. This indeed is an anecdote: but where did he
learn that the children, before they could decipher the sounds of their own
language, were taught hieroglyphics? ’Till now, hieroglyphics, when got
into exclusive hands, were understood to be reserved for those instructed in
high and mysterious science. But let us suppose that they were taught to
children amongst their first elements : yet even then, as we shall see from
the nature of the thing, they could never stand as marks for words or
sounds. Whena child is taught the power of letters, he learns that the
letters, which compose one word, malice, for instance, express the sound ;
which, naturally arising from a combination of the several powers of each
letter, shews him that the letters stand for such a sound or word. But
when he is taught that the figure or picture of a crocodile signifies malice,
he as naturally and necessarily conceives (though he knows not the mean-
ing of the word) that it stands for some thing, signified by that word, and
not for a sownd :. because there is no natural connexion between jigure and
a sound, as there is between figure and a thing. And the only reason why
the word malice intervenes, in this connexion, is because of the necessity of
the use of words to distinguish things, and rank them into sorts. But the
veriest child could never be so simple as to conceive that, when he was
told the figure of a beast with four short legs and a long tail signified
malice, that it signified the sound of malice: any more than if he were told
it signified a crocodile, that it signified the sownd of the word crocodile.
The truth is, the ignorant often mistake words for things, but never, things
for words: that is, they frequently mistake the name of a thing for
its nature ; and rest contented in the knowledge which that gives them :
Like him who, on the sight of a pictured elephant, inquiring what the
creature was, on his being answered, that it was the great Czar, asked no
further, but went away well satisfied in his acquaintance with that illus-
NOTES. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 869
tiious Stranger. Yet I apprehend he did not understand his informer to
mean that it signified only the sound of that word. Perhaps the learned
writer will object, that the cases are different; that the elephant was a
mere picture,and the crocodile a sign or mark. But I have shewn at large
that the ancient Egyptian hieroglyphics were at first mere pictures ; and
that all the alteration they received, in becoming marks, was only the
having their general use of conveying knowledge rendered more extensive
and expeditious, more mysterious and profound ; while they still continued
to be the marks of things.
To proceed ; our author considers next what he apprehends may be
thought an objection to his opinion. And though (says he) ἐξ may be said
that, in this case, where different nations of different languages agree on
common characters, that stand for certain things they agree on, that then such
Jigures stand for things. To which he answers, This will be allowed ; but
then they stand for sounds too, that is, the sounds in each language that
signify such things. We who can grant so much, and without injury to
his system, need be under no fear of ever giving his adversary advantages.
He may, if he pleases, say next, when disputing about the colour of an
object,—that it is black, will be allowed ; but then it is white too. Fora
mark for things can no more be a mark for sounds, than black can be
white. The reason is the same in both cases; one quality or property
excludes the other: thus, if hieroglyphic marks stand for things, and are
used as common characters by various nations differing in speech and lan-
guage, they cannot stand for sownds ; because these men express the same
thing by different sounds; unless, to remove this difficulty, he will go
farther, and say, not, as he did before, that one hieroglyphic word (to use
his own language) stood for one sound, but, that it stands for an hundred.
Again: if hieroglyphic marks stand for sounds, they cannot stand for
things: not those things which are not signified by such sounds ; this he
himself will allow: nor yet, I affirm, for those which are thus signified ;
because it is the sound which stands for the thing signified by the sound,
and not the hieroglyphic mark. But all this mistake proceeded from
another, namely, that worps stand both for sounds and things, which we
now come to. For he concludes thus, So that these figures (viz. hiero-
glyuphics) stand not for things alone, but, as worvs, for sounds and things.
An unhappy illustration! which has all the defects, both in point of
meaning and expression, that a proposition can well have. For, if by
words, be meant articulated sounds, then the expression labours in the sense,
as affirming, that sounds stand for sounds. And that he meant so is
possible, because in the beginning of the passage quoted, he uses words
for articulate sounds.—Hieroglyphics, says he, stood for words or sounds.
But if, by words, he meant letters, (and that he might mean so is possible
likewise, for he presently afterwards uses words in that sense too—/Hiero-
glyphics, as words, says he, seem to stand for sounds) then the proposition
is only false: the plain truth being this, letters stand for sounds only ;
which sounds they naturally produce ; as sounds arbitrarily denote things.
But to bea little more particular ; as in this distinction lies the judg-
ment which is to be made, if ever it be rightly made, of the contro-
versy between us. All this confusion of counter-reasoning proceeds, as we
observed before, First, from not reflecting that letters, which stand for
words, have not, and hieroglyphies, which stand for things, once had not,
an arbitrary, but a natural designation. For, as the powers of letters
naturally produce words or sounds, so the figures of hieroglyphics natu-
rally signify things: either more simply, by representation, or more
VOL. Il. BB
370 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
artificially by analogy : Secondly, from his not considering, that as we
cannot think nor converse about things either accurately or intelligibly
without words, so their intervention becomes necessary in explaining the
marks of things. But therefore, to make hieroglyphics the marks of
sounds, because sounds accompany things, would be as absurd as to make
letters the marks of things, because things accompany sounds. And who,
before our author, would say that letters signified things as well as sounds ?
unless he had a mind to confound all meaning. If he chose to instruct, or
even to be understood, he would say, that letters naturally produced
sounds or words ; and that words arbitrarily denoted things: and had our
author spoken the same intelligible language, and told us that hiero-
glyphics naturally expressed things, and that things were arbitrarily
denoted by words, he would indeed have spared both of us the present
trouble ; but then he had said nothing new. As it is, I cannot but
suspect that this learned writer, though he had been in Egypt, yet found
his hzeroglyphics at home, and mistook these for the Egyptian. No other
agreeing with his description of picture characters standing for sownds, but
that foolish kind of rebus-writing called by the polite vulgar, hiereglyphics,
the childish amusement of the illiterate ; in which, indeed, the figures
stand only for sounds ; sounds, divested of sense as well as things. Nor is
Dr. Pococke the only polite writer who has fallen into this ridiculous
mistake. See a paper called Toe Wortp, N° XXIV.
P. 183. S. It may not be improper, in this place, just to take notice of
one of the strangest fancies, that ever got possession of the pericranium of
an Antiquary. It is this, that the Chinese borrowed their real characters
or hieroglyphic marks from the Egyptians. The author of it expresses his
conceit in this manner.—“ Linguam autem primitivam et barbaram vel
puram, vel saltem parum immutatam, et politam gyptiorum consue-
tudine, retinere poterant [Sinenses, | et solum hoc sibi ab ipsis DERTVARE,
ET ADOPTARE SCRIBENDI GENUS, ratione habita non ad linguam Aigyptiacam,
sed unice ad ideas his Characteribus expressas, quos et sermonis sui nativi,
immo etiam et lingue sue syllabis separatim sumptis eodem tempore
applicaverunt.” De Inser. Ligyptiaca Epist. p. 53. Authore Turbervil.
Needham.
From what hath been observed of the nature and origin of a REAL CHa-
RACTER in general, supported by what the Chinese tell us of the very
high antiquity of theirs, it is impossible to fix upon any period of time
when the Egyptians (whether invited, or simply enabled by their improve-
ments in navigation and commerce to penetrate into China) could find this
highly policied people without a real character. -
The question then will be, What possible inducements the Chinese
could have to exchange their real characters for the Egyptian? Benefit
by this change they could receive none, because one real character is just as
good as another: And men at their ease, are rarely disposed to change
native for foreign, but with the prospect of some advantage. To this
it may be said, “that one alphabetic character likewise is just as good as
another: and yet nothing has been more common than for one nation to
change its own alphabet for the alphabet of another.’ An instance,
without doubt, very apposite. ‘lo change the shapes of four and twenty
letters is but a morning’s work ; and I suppose a small share of civility
and complaisance might go thus far, between neighbours. But to throw
away a million of old marks, and to have a million of new to learn, is an
amusement of quite another nature. I apprehend, that such a proposal
(had the Egyptians made it, with an offer of all their learning along with
a
NOTES. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 371
it) would have much alarmed the indolent unenterprising temper of the
Chinese. But the Critic seems to think, that an old character, like an old
coat, would be willingly exchanged for a new one. Alas! Time and
Antiquity, which make such havock with the muddy vestures of decay, give
a new gloss, as well as a stronger texture, to the spiritual cloathing ot ideas.
And if their old characters were like any old coat, it must be such a one as
Settle wore in Elysium ; which, as the Poet sings, had, together with its
owner, received a new lustre in this its state of beatification :
“ All as the Vest, appear’d the Wearer’s frame,
Old in new state, another yet the same.”
The truth is, the Chinese, who have preserved specimens of all the
various revolutions in their veal characters, have the highest veneration for
the most ancient. Now is it possible to conceive that a people, thus cir-
cumstanced and disposed, should part with their native characters, the gift
of their Demy-gods and Heroes, to receive others, of the same sort, from
strangers : recommendable for no advantage which their own did not pos-
sess, and partaking of all the inconveniencies to which their own were
subject. Had the Egyptians indeed offered them an anpnaper (which,
were they disposed to be so communicative, we know, they had it in their
power to do, at what time soever it can be reasonably supposed they first
visited the coasts of China), the offer had been humane, and, without
doubt, the benefit had been gratefully accepted. But that the Egyptians
did nothing of all this, appears from the Chinese being without an ALPHA-
BET to this very day. And yet I am persuaded, it was the confounding of
these two things, one of which was practicable and useful, the other useless
and impracticable, I mean the communication of an Alphabet, which was
common in the ancient world ; and the communication of a real Character,
which was never heard of till now,—I say, it was the confounding of these
two things that gave birth to this strange conceit. And then the similitude
of shape between the Egyptian and the Chinese marks, was thought to
compleat the discovery. The Letter-writer did not seem to reflect, that the
shapes of real characters, after great improvements made in them by a long
course of time, such as the Egyptian and the Chinese, must needs have a
great resemblance, whether the characters were formed by ANALoGy or
tnstiruTion. In the first case, nature made the resemblance, as being the
common archetype to both nations. In the latter, necessity, for only
straight and crooked lines being employed to form these marks, there must
needs arise from a combination of such lines infinitely varied, a striking
resemblance between the real characters of two people, though most distant
in genius and situation. But the folly, which such Conjecturers are apt to
fall into, is, that, if the forms of the marks be alike, the powers must be
alike also.
What is here said will enable us likewise to appreciate another ingenious
contrivance of one M/, de Guignes of the Academy Royal of Inscriptions, &e.
to get to the same discovery. Upon a supposition of the truth of what I
had laid down, that the first Egyptian alphabet was taken from their hiero-
glyphic characters,* this Academician fell to work, to ANALYSE, as he terms
“ΓΜ, Warburton avoit pensé que le premier Alphabet avoit emprunté ses elemens
des Hieroglyphes mémes ; et M. I’ Abbé Barthelemy avoit mis cette excellente théorie
dans un plus grand jour, en plagant sur une colonne diverses lettres Kgyptiennes, en
correspondance avec les Hieroglyphes qui les avoient produits. On pouvoit donc pre-
sumer que les Egyptiens avoient communiqué aux Chinois les cavacteres que je venois
de decouvrir, mais qwils les regardoient eux-mémes alors comme des signes Hierogly-
phiques, et non comme des lettres proprement dites.’’—De Τ᾿ Origine des Chinois,
pp. 63, 64.
oe THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
it, the Chinese characters ; when, to his great surprise, he found, that their
contents were only a certain number of terrers belonging to the Oriental
Alphabets, packed up, as it were, for carriage: which, when taken out,
developed, and put in order, formed an Egyptian or Phenician word, that
expressed the idea for which the Chinese real Character stood, as its Repre-
sentatives. How precarious, and of how little solidity this fanciful
Analysis is, may be understood by all who have seen these Chinese marks
and Oriental alphabets ; both of which consist of the same straight and curve
lines variously combined ; so that it cannot be otherwise but that in every
Chinese mark should be found, that is, easily imagined, a composition of
any alphabetic letters which the profound Decipherer stands in need of.
But the pleasantry of the conceit lies here, that though the Chinese have
alphabetic characters (which this ingenious Author has, with great asto-
nishment, now first discovered) yet they themselves know nothing of the
matter, as he at the same time has assured us.*
I might likewise insist upon this scheme’s labouring under the same
absurdity with M. Needham’s. For though when M. de Guignes speaks of
that part of the Chinese real character whose marks are symbolic, or formed
upon analogy, pp. 71, 72. he is willing to have it believed (what his title-
page enounces), that China was inhabited by an Egyptian Colony, which
carried along with them the Hieroglyphics they now use: yet where he
examines that other part, consisting of arbitrary marks, or marks by insti-
tution, p. 64 et seq. he supposes them, as we see above, communicated to
the Chinese by the Egyptians. On pouvoit done presumer (says he) que les
Eguptiens avoient communiqué aux Chinois les caractéres que je venois de
decowvrir.
To conclude, the learned world abounds with discoveries of this kind.
They have all one common Original ; the old inveterate error, that a simili-
tude of customs and manners, amongst the various tribes of mankind most
remote from one another, must needs arise from some communication.
Whereas human nature, without any other help, will, in the same circum-
stances, always exhibit the same appearances.
P. 183. T. “ L’AlphabethEthiopien est seul de tous ceux que l’on connoit
qui tient encore des Hieroglyphes.” Fourmont, Reflexions Crit. sur les
Hist. des Anc. Peuples, tom. sec. p. 501. Kircher illustrates this matter in
his account of the Coptic alphabet. But as on his system every thing that
relates to Egypt is a mystery, the shapes and names of the letters of their
alphabet we may expect to find full of profound wisdom: yet, methinks,
nothing could be more natural, than for a people long used to hieroglyphic
characters, to employ the most celebrated of them, when they invented an
alphabet, in forming the letters of it: and if the Chinese, who yet want an
alphabet, were now to make one, it is not to be doubted but they would
use the most venerable of their characteristic marks for the letters of it.
However, let us hear Kircher for the fact’s sake :—“ Ita Aigyptiis natura
comparatum fuit, ut quemadmodum nihil in omnibus eorum institutis sine
mysterio peragebatur, ita et in lingua communi, uti ex alphabeto eorun-
dem, mysteriosa literarum institutione ita concinnato, ut nulla feré in
eodem litera reconditorum sacramentorum non undiquaque plena reperire-
tur, patet. De primevis Zgyptiorum literis varie diversorum sunt opini-
κ « Les caracteres Chinoises dans l’etat ou nous les avons ἃ present, constituent trois
sortes de caracteres ; I'iipistolique ou ALFHABETIQUE, le hieroglyphique et le symbo-
lique; c’est un nouveau rapport des plus singuliers avee Egypte, gui n’a point eté
connu jusque a present, QUE LES CHINOIS EUXMEMES IGNORENT, et qui me jette
dans le plus grand étonnement, un examen attentif—me I’a fait connoitre,” &c.—Mem.
de Lit. tom. xxix. p. 15.
NOTES. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 373
ones. Omnes tamen in hoc consentiunt, plerasque ex sacrorum animalium
forma, incessu, aliarumque corporis partium sitibus et symmetrio desumptas.
Ita Demetrius Phalereus, qui septem vocales assignans, septem Diis conse-
cratas, ait, ceteras ex animalium forma desumptas. Eusebius adstruit
idem.” — Theatr. Hierogl. p. 42. tom. iii. of his Qidip. Aqypt. As for this
fancy, mentioned by Demetrius Phalereus, it had a very different original
from what Kircher supposes ; being only an enigmatic intimation of the
different natures of vowels and consonants. The latter being brute sounds
without the aid of the former, by which they are as it were animated.
P. 184. U. The very learned and illustrious author of a work intituled,
Recueil @ Antiquités Egyptiennes, Etrusques, Grecques et Romaines, vol. i.
M. the Count Caytus, after having confuted the idle conjectures of certain
learned men concerning the contents of a sepulchral linen, marked over
with Egyptian alphabetic characters, proceeds thus :—“Il me semble
qu’on tireroit de plus grands avantages de ce monument, si au lieu de
s’obstiner a percer ces ténébres, on tachoit de remonter par son moyen a
Porigine de l’écriture, et d’en suivre le developpement et les progres: si
Von cherchoit enfin a connoitre la forme des anciennes lettres, et le pays ou
Yon acommencé a les employer. Ces questions et tant d’autres semblables
ne pourront jamais étre eclaircies par les temoignages des auteurs Grees et
Latins. Souvent peu instruits des antiquités de leur pays, ils n’ont fait
que recueillir des traditions incertaines, et multiplier des doutes, auxquels
en prefereroit volontiers l’ignorance la plus profonde : ¢’est aux monumens
qu’on doit recourir. Quand ils parleront clairement, il faudra bien que les
anciens auteurs s’accordent avec eux. Avant le commencement de ce siécle
on ne connoissoit point l’ecriture courante des Egyptiens, et plusieurs criti-
ques la confondoient tantot avec celle des anciens Hebreux, et tantot avec les
hieroglyphes ; mais depuis cette epoque il nous est venu plusieurs fragmens,
qui ont fixé nos idées ; et il faut espérer que de nouvelles recherches nous en
procureront un plus grand nombre. Conservons avec soin des restes si pré-
cieux, et tachons de les mettre en ceuvre, en suivant exemple de celui des
modernes, qui a repandu les plus grandes lumieres sur la question de l’anti-
quité des lettres. M. Warburton a detruit erreur οἱ l’on etoit que les prétres
Egyptiens avoient inventé les hieroglyphes pour cacher leur science : il a dis-
tingué trois epoques principales dans l’art de se communiquer les idées par
ecrit : sous la premiere, l’ecriture n’etoit qu’une simple representation des
objets, une veritable peinture ; sous la seconde, elle ne consistoit qu’en hiero-
glyphes, c’est-a-dire, en une peinture abrégée, qui, par exemple, au lieu de
representer un objet entier, n’en representoit qu’une partie, un rapport, ὅτε,
Enfin sous la troisieme epoque, les hieroglyphes altérés dans leurs traits
devinrent les élémens d’une écriture courante: M. Warburton auroit pu
mettre cette excellente theorie a portée de tout le monde, en placant dans
une premiére colomne une suite @hieroglyphes, et dans une seconde les
lettres qui en sont dérivées ; mais sans doute que les bornes qwil s’etoit
prescrites ne lui ont pas permis d’entrer dans ce detail. Quoi qu'il soit,
tous ceux qui recherchent l’origine des arts et des connoissances humaines,
peuvent verifier le systéme du scavant Anglois, et se convaincre que les
lettres Egyptiennes ne sont que des hieroglyphes deguisés. Nous avons
assez de secours pour entreprendre cet examin. Les recueils des anti-
quaires offrent plusieurs monumens Egyptiens chargés @’hieroglyphes :
et la seule bande de toile que Von publie ici [ Pl. N° 21, 22, 23, 24, 25.]
suffroit pour donner une idée de l’écriture courante—de s’assurer que
Valphabet de la langue Egyptienne emanoit des hieroglyphes, il suffira
(avoir une assez grande quantité des lettres isolées, et de comparer avec les
274 ὃ THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
figures représentées sur les monumens Egyptiens. Or je puis assirer que —
Yon appercevra entr’elles la liaison la plus intime, et les rapports les plus
sensibles ; et pour s’en convaincre, on n’a qu’a jetter les yeux sur le N° 1.
dela XXVI. planche. J’y ai fait graver sur une premiere colomne une
suite @hieroglyphes tirés la plupart des obelisques, et dans une colomne cor-
respondante, les lettres Egyptiennes qui viennent de ces hieroglyphes. On
trouvera, par exemple, que le premier hieroglyphe representant une barque,
a produit un element d’ecriture, dont la valeur a pti varier, suivant les
points ou les traits dont il etoit affeeté : que le troisieme hieroglyphe, qu’on
croit étre ’image d’une porte, en perdant son arrondissement a formé la
lettre qui lui est paralléle ; que la figure @’homme ou d’animal accroupie
au N° 4. est devenue une lettre qui ne conserve que les linéamens du sym-
bole original ; enfin que le serpent figuré si souvent sur les monumens
Egyptiens, N° 19. s’est changé en un caractére qui retrace encore aux yeux
les sinuosités de ce reptile. On trouvera aussi que les autres hieroglyphes,
tels que le 2. le 5. le 6. le 11. le 13, &e. ont passé dans l’ecriture courante,
sans €éprouver le moindre changement. Au reste, ce n’est ici que le leger
essai d’une operation qui pourroit étre poussée plus loin, et dans laquelle
on appercevroit peut-étre des rapports différens de ceux que j’ai établis
entre certaines lettres Egyptiennes prouve visiblement leur origine ; et
plus il est approfondi, plus il sert a confirmer le sentiment de M. Warbur-
ton,” p. 69. Thus far this learned person. I have borrowed the scheme
he refers to, and the reader will find it marked, plate VII.
P. 184. X. Mr. Voltaire, in a discourse intituled, Nouveau plan de
l’Histoire de ?Esprit humain, speaking of the Chinese printing, which is
an impression from a solid block, and not by moveable types, says they
have not adopted the latter method, owt of attachment to their old usages.—
“On sait que cette Imprimerie est une gravure sur des planches de bois.
L’Art de graver les caracteres mobiles et de fonte, beaucoup supérieure a
la leur, ’a@ point encore été adopté par eux, TANT ILS SONT ATTACHES A LEURS
ANCIENS USAGES.” Now I desire to know of M. Voltaire, how it was possible
for them to adopt the method of a Font of types or moveable characters,
unless they had an alphabet. That they had no such, M. Voltaire very
well knew, as he gives us to understand, in the same place. “L’art de
faire connoitre ses idées par l’ecriture, qui devroit n’étre qu’une methode
trés simple, est chez eux ce qu’ils ont de plus difficile ; chaque mot a des
caractéres differens : un savant a la Chine est celui qui connoit le plus de
ces caractéres, et quelques uns sont arrivés ἃ la vieillesse avant que de
savoir bien écrire.’” Would not Caslon or Baskerville be finely employed
to make a font of letters for this people, who have so many millions of real
characters? But this historian of men and manners goes on in the same
rambling incoherent manner, and so he can but discredit the Jewish history
he cares little for the rest.—‘ Qui leur donne une superiorité reconnue sur
tous ceux qui rapportent l’origine des autres nations, e’est qu’on n’y voit
aucun prodige, aucune prediction, aucune méme de ces fourberies politiques
que nous attribuons aux Fondateurs des autres Etats, excepté peut-étre ce
qu’on a imputé a Fou, d@’avoir fait accroire qu’il avoit vi ses Loix ecrites
sur le dos d’un serpent ailé. Cette imputation méme fait voir qu’on con-
naissait Pecriture avant Foi. Enfin, ce n’est pas ἃ nous, au bout de notre
Occident, ἃ contester les archives d’une nation qui etait toute policée quand
nous n’etions que des Sauvages.”—First, China has the advantage of the
western world, because the Founders of its religious policy employed
neither Miracles nor Prophecies, nor the Founders of its civil policy state
tricks and cheats, like other Leaders. And yet he is forced, before the
ῥ.
G»
v:
“SIO}}9'T. soupdaps oro
iss Ye ἔπ Σ pam Si
: oa nm KK ΠΩ; TAA WX el ‘
* τέ Al ma U5, vohV Uw wl Gorn ν ἣν ik πα.
Be eg ee
a
ac
τι
δν-
Ἔξ
a
O
NOTES. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 375
words are well out of his mouth, to own that Fok pretended to have seen
his laws written upon the back of a winged Serpent : and one can hardly
think that Fohi now gotten into so good a train would stop there.
Secondly, By this, however, the historian gains (and he bids us observe it) a
very early date for writing amongst the Chinese, whereas in truth they have
no writing in the sense the historian gives to the word, even at this day :
and as for Hieroglyphic Characters, all nations had them from the most
early times, and as soon as men began to associate. Thirdly, We barbari-
ans of yesterday must not pretend, he says, to contradict the records of this
ancient nation. And why not, I pray, when superior Science has enabled
this upstart people of the West to detect the falsehood of the Records of
Egypt, a nation which pretended to as high antiquity as the Chinese? This
they have done, and, I suppose, to the good liking of our historian, if ever he
has heard of the names of Scaliger and Petavius, of Usher and Marsham.
P.184. Y. ᾿Αλλὰ γὰρ οὐ μόνον Αἰγυπτίων of λογικώτατοι, wpos δὲ, καὶ
τῶν ἄλλων βαρξάρων, ὅσοι φιλοσοφίας ὠρέχθησαν, τὸ συμξολικὸν εἶδος
ἐζήλωσαν: φασὶ γοῦν καὶ ᾿Ιδανθούραν τῶν SKYOQN βασιλέα, Sec. Clem.
Alex. Strom. 1. v. p. ὅ07. Thus this learned Father; who being in the
general prejudice that hieroglyphics were a late art, invented by philo-
sophic men, to secrete their knowledge, expresses himself accordingly,
ὅσοι φιλοσοφίας ὠρέχθησαν : and yet, methinks, the story he tells of the
Scythian king might have directed him to another original—Eustathius
says the same thing: Of δέ ye παλαιοὶ, ὁποῖόν τι καὶ of Αἰγύπτιοι ἐποίουν,
ζώδιά twa ἱερογλυφοῦντες καὶ λοιποὺς δὲ χαρακτῆρας εἰς σημασίαν ὧν λέγειν
ἐξούλοντο, οὕτω καὶ αὐτοὶ καθὰ καὶ τῶν τινες ὕστερον Σκυθῶν, ἐσήμαινον ἃ
ἤθελον εἴδωλά τινα καὶ πολυειδῆ γράμματα ἕέσματα eyypaporres.—In Miad.
vi. ver. 168.
P.185. Z. In judging only from the nature of things, and without the
surer light of Revelation, one should be apt to embrace the opinion of
Diodorus Siculus [lib. ii.], and Vitruvius [lib. ii. cap. 1.1, that the first
Men lived, for some time, in woods and caves, after the manner of beasts,
uttering only confused and indistinct noises ; till associating for mutual
assistance, they came, by degrees, to use articulate sounds, mutually
agreed upon, for the arbitrary signs or marks of those ideas in the mind
of the speaker, which he wanted to communicate to the hearer. Hence
the diversity of languages ; for it is confessed on all hands, that speech is
not innate. This is so natural an account of the original of language, and
so unquestioned by Antiquity, that Gregory Nyssen Ladver. Eunomium,
lib. xii.] a father of the church, and Richard Simon [ Hist. Crit. du Vieux
Test. lib. i. cap. 14 et 15, lib. iii. cap. 21,] a priest of the Oratory, have both
endeayoured to support this hypothesis: and yet, methinks, they should
have known better ; Scripture plainly informing us, that Janguage had a
different original. This was just the case of Sacririces. It is very easy
to conceive, that one sort arose naturally from the sense of gratitude to our
Divine Benefactor, and the other from a sense of our demerit towards him
(as will be shewn hereafter); yet it is certain they were of divine appoint-
ment. In this indeed the two cases differ ; language, I believe, had, for
its sole original, divine instruction; whereas sacrifices amongst many
people were certainly of human invention, and underived from tradition.
But to return to the subject of language. It is strange, as I say, that these
learned men should not have been better informed. We see, by Scripture,
that God instructed the first man, in religion. And can we believe, he
would not at the same time teach him /angwage, so necessary to support
the intercourse between man and his Maker? For Quietism is a thing of
376 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK 2V.
modern growth ; this, with Mysticism of all kinds, is the issue of that
wantonness which makes favoured man grow tired of his two great bless-
ings, REASON and LANGUAGE.—If it be said, Man might gain language by
“the use of reason, I reply, so might he gain religion likewise: and that
much easier and sooner. Again, when God created man, he made woman
for his companion and associate ; but the only means of enjoying this
benefit is the use of speech. Can we think that God would leave them to
themselves, to get out of the forlorn condition of brutality as they could ?
But there is more than a probable support for this opinion. If I am not
much mistaken, we have the express testimony of Moszs, that God did
indeed teach men language: It is where he tells us, that God brought every
beast of the field, and every fowl of the air, unto Adam, to see what he would
call them: and whatsoever Adam called every living creature, that was the
name thereof. And Adam gave names to all cattle, and to the fowl of the air,
and to every beast of the field. Gen. ii. 19, 20. Here, by a common figure of
speech, instead of directly relating the fact, that God taught men language,
the historian represents it, by shewing God in the act of doing it, in a
particular mode of information ; and that, the most apposite we can con-
ceive, namely, elementary instruction ; in the giving names to substances ;
such as those with which Adam was to be most conversant, and which
therefore had need of being distinguished each by its proper name : How
familiar an image do these words convey of a learner of his rudiments ?—
And God brought every beast, ὅτο. to Adam to sex what he would call them.
In a word, the prophet’s manner of relating this important fact, has, in my
opinion, an uncommon elegance. But men of warm imaginations over-
looked this obvious and natural meaning to ramble after forced and mys-
terious senses, such as this, that Adam gave to every creature @ name
expressive of its nature. From which fantastic interpretation, all the wild
visions of Hutchinson, and his cabalistie followers, seem to have arisen.
Nor are the Freethinkers much behind them in absurdities, ‘ Some,”
says Tindal, “ would be almost apt to imagine that the author of the book
of Genesis thought that words had ideas naturally fixed to them, and not
by consent ; otherwise, say they, how can we account for his supposing
that God brought all animals before Adam, as soon as he was created, to
give them names ; and that whatsoever Adam called every living creature,
that was the name thereof?” [Christianity as old as the Creation, 8vo. ed.
Ρ. 228.] But though Moses thought no such thing, I can tell him of one
who did: a very ancient writer, and frequently quoted by the men of this
tribe to confront with Moses, I mean Heroporus ; who not’ only thought
this, but thought still more absurdly, that Jdeas had words naturally
affixed to them. See the famous tale of Psammetichus and his two boys,
lib. ii. How would these men have rejoiced to catch Moses at the same
advantage !—To conclude. From what hath been said, it appears, that
God taught man, language : yet we cannot reasonably suppose it to be any
other than what served his present use : after this, he was able of himself to
improve and enlarge it, as his future occasions should require: conse-
quently the first language must needs be very poor and narrow.
P. 186. AA. “How many commands did God give his Prophets,
which, if taken according to the letter, seem unworthy of God, as making
them act like madmen or idiots? As for instance, the prophet Isaiah
walked for three years together naked for a sign; Jeremiah is commanded
to carry his girdle as far as Euphrates,—to make bands and yokes, &¢e.—
Ezekiel is commanded to draw Jerusalem on a tile, &c. &e.” [ Tindal’s
Christianity as old as the Creation, p. 229.| The prophet Jeremiah (says a
NOTES. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 377
learned writer) 7s ordered to buy a girdle, &c.—He is also sent about with
yokes—Ezekiel besieges a pan-tile—He. shaves his head and beard.—No
reasonable man can believe these actions were really performed. See Disserta-
tion on the History and Character of Balaam.
P. 186. BB. “ Quemadmodum autem vidit in visionibus [Propheta]
quod jussus fuerit [ Ezech. cap. vili. | fodere in pariete, ut intrare et videre
posset, quid intus faciant, quod foderit, per foramen ingressus fuerit, et
viderit id quod vidit ; ita quoque id quod dictum est ad eum, L¢ tu sume
tibi laterem, &c. [ Ezech. cap. iv.] quod item alibi ei dictum legitur, Vova-
culam hane tonsoriam cape tibi, [ Ezech. cap. v.] ita, inquam, ista omnia in
visione prophetie facta sunt, ac vidit, vel visum fuit ipsi, se ista opera
facere, qu ipsi precipiebantur. Absit enim ut Deus prophetas suos stultis
vel ebriis similes reddat, eosque stultorum aut furiosorum actiones facere
jubeat.” More Nev. p. ii. cap. 46. But here the author’s reasoning is
defective,—because what Ezekiel saw in the chambers of imagery in his
eighth chapter was in vision, therefore his delineation of the plan of the
siege, and the shaving his beard, in the fourth and fifth chapters, were like-
wise in vision. But to make this illation logical, it is necessary that the
circumstance in the eighth, and the circumstances in the fourth and fifth,
be shewn to be specifically the same ; but examine them, and we shall find
them very different: that in the eighth was to shew the Prophet the
excessive idolatry of Jerusalem, by a sight of the very idolatry itself ;
those in the fourth and fifth, were to convey the will of God, by the Pro-
phet to the people, in a symbolic action. Now in the first case, as we have
shewn above, the information was properly by vision, and fully answered
the purpose, namely, the Prophet’s information ; but, in the after, a vision
had been improper ; for a vision to the prophet was of itself no information
to the people.
P. 188. CC. The general moral, which is of great importance, and is
inculeated with all imaginable force, is that weak and worthless men are
ever most forward to thrust themselves into power; while the wise and
good decline rule, and prize their native ease and freedom above all the
equipage and trappings of grandeur. The vanity of base men in power is
taught in the fifteenth verse, and the ridicule of that vanity is inimitably
marked out in those circumstances ; where the bramble is made to bid his
new subjects, who wanted no shadow, to come and put their trust in his,
who had none ; and that, in case of disobedience, he would send out from
himself ὦ fire that should devour the cedars of Lebanon, whenas the fire
of brambles, and such like trash, was short and momentary even to a pro-
verb, amongst the Easterns.—Tinpat, speaking of the necessity of the appli-
cation of reason to scripture, in order to a right understanding of those
passages in the Old Testament, where God speaks, or is spoken of, after the
manner of men, as being jealous, angry, repentant, reposing, &c. (Modes
of expression very apposite, where the subject is God’s moral government
of the world ; very necessary, where it is his civil government of a parti-
cular people.) Tindal, I say, brings this in, amongst his instances.— Wine,
that cheareth god and man ; as if Jotham had meant God, the governor of
the universe ; when all, who can read antiquity, must see his meaning to
be, that wine cheareth hero-gods and common men. For Jotham is here
speaking to an idolatrous city, which ran a whoring after Baalim, and
made Baalberith their god; a god sprung from amongst men, as may be
partly collected from his name, as well as from divers other circumstances
of the story. But our critic, who could not see the sense, it is certain, saw
nothing of the beauty of the expression ; which contains one of the finest
378 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
strokes of ridicule in the whole apologue, so much abounding with them ;
and insinuates to the Shechemites the vanity and pitiful original of their
idolatrous gods, who were thought to be, or really had been, refreshed with
wine. Hesiod tells us, in a similar expression, that the vengeance of the
fates pursued the crimes of gods and men :
Air ANAPON τε ΘΕΩ͂Ν τε wapaibaclas ἐφέπουσαι,
Οὐδέποτε λήγουσι Sead δεινοῖο χόλοιο,
Πρίν y ἀπὸ τῷ δώωσι κακὴν ὕπιν ὅστις ἁμάρτῃ.---ΘῈ Ο Γ΄. ver. 220.
P. 188. DD. Judges ix. 7. Corns, the author of the Scheme of
literal Prophecy considered, speaking of Dean Sherlock’s interpretation of
Gen. ili. 15, says—“ What the Dean just now said is nothing but an argu-
ment from the pretended absurdity of the literal sense, that supposes the
most plain matter of fact to be fable, or parable, or allegory ; though it be
suited to the notions of the Ancients, who thought that beasts had, in the
Jirst ages of the world, the use of speech, agreeable to what is related in the
Bible of Balaam’s ass, and told after a simple historical manner, like all the
relations in the Old Testament, wherein there is nothing savours of adle-
gory, and every thing is plainly and simply exposed.” p. 234. By this it
appears that Mr. Collins thought that fable, parable, and allegory, were the
same mode of speech, whereas they are very different modes. <A fable was
a story familiarly told, without any pretended foundation of fact, with
design to persuade the hearers of some truth in question ; a parable was
the same kind of story, more obscurely delivered ; and an allegory was the
relation of a real fact, delivered in symbolic terms: Of this kind was the
story of the Fan: a real fact, told allegorically. According to Mr. Col-_
lins, it is a fable to be understood literally, because ἐξ was suited to the
notions of the ancients, who thought that beasts had, in the first ages of the
world, the use of speech. By the Ancients he must mean, if he means any
thing to the purpose, those of the Mosaic age: and this will be news.
His authority is, in truth, an authentic one! It is Balaam’s ass.—Agree-
able, says he, to what is related in the Bible of Balaam’s ass, and told after
a simple historical manner. Now the Bible, to which he so confidently
appeals, expressly tells us, that Balaam had the gift of prophecy ; that an
angel intervened ; and that God Almighty opened the ass’s mouth. But
however he is pleased to conceal the matter, he had a much better proof
that the Ancients thought beasts had the use of speech in the first ages of the
world than Balaam’s ass ; and that was Esor’s Fasies. And this might
have led him rather to the story of Jotham, so plainly and simply exposed,
that, had not only the serpent, but the tree of knowledge likewise spoken, he
could have given a good account of the matter, by Jotham’s fable ; told
after a simple historical manner, like all the relations in the Old Testament.
A great improvement, believe me, this, to his discovery,—that the ancients
thought not only that beasts, but that trees spoke in the first ages of the world.
The Ancients! an’ please you. It is true, they delighted in fabulous
traditions. But what then? they had always the sense to give a sufficient
cause to every effect. They never represented things out of nature, but
when placed there by some God, who had nature in his power. Even
Homer, the father of fables, when he makes the horses of Achilles speak,
or feel human passions, thinks it not enough to represent them as stimu-
lated by a God, without informing us, that they themselves were of a
ccelestial and immortal race.
P. 190. EE. This account shews how ridiculously the critics were
employed in seeking out the inventor of the Apologue; they might as
well have sought for the inventor of the Metaphor, and carried their
NOTES. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 379
researches still further, and with Sancho Pancha inquired after the inventor
of eating and drinking.
P. 191. FF. Καὶ ἐν Αἰγύπτῳ μὲν τοῖς ἱερεῦσι συνῆν, καὶ τὴν σοφίαν
ἐξέμαθε, καὶ τῶν Αἰγυπτίων φωνὴν. Τραμμάτων δὲ τρισσὰς διαφορὰς, ἘΠΙῚΣ -
ΤΟΛΟΓΡΑΦΙΚΩΝ τε, καὶ TEPOTAY®IKON, καὶ SYMBOAIKQN: τῶν μὲν
κοινολογουμένων κατὰ μίμησιν, τῶν δὲ ἀλληγορουμένων κατά τινας αἰνιγμούς.
De Vita Pythagore, cap. xi. et xii. p. 15. Ed. Kusteri. Holstenius trans-
lates τῶν μὲν κοινολογουμένων κατὰ μίμησιν, τῶν δὲ ἀλληγορουμένων κατά
τινας αἰνιγμοὺς, in this manner :—“ Quorum illud propriam Θὲ communem
loquendi consuetudinem imitatur; reliqua per allegorias sub quibusdam
enigmatum involucris sensum exprimunt.” By which, it seems, he under-
stood, τῶν μὲν κοινολογουμένων κατὰ μίμησιν to be an explanation of the
nature of epistolary writing ; and τῶν δὲ ἀλληγορουμένων κατά τινας αἰνιγ-
μοὺς, of the nature both of hieroglyphic and symbolic ; whereas the first
words are an explanation of hieroglyphic writing, and the second only of
symbolic. For Porphyry having named three kinds of writing, the first
common to all people; the two other peculiar, at that time, to the Egyp-
tians; when he comes to speak of their natures, he judiciously omits
explaining the epistolary, which all the world knew, and confines his
discourse to the hieroglyphic and symbolic. But was it, as Holstenius
thought, that he explained the nature of the epistolary in the words
τῶν μὲν κοινολογουμένων, Sc. then has he entirely omitted the proper
hieroglyphic (for the τῶν δὲ ἀλληγορουμένων, Fc. relates only to the sym-
bolic); which had been an unpardonable fault. But that this is Hol-
stenius’s mistake is further seen by the next passage from Clemens
Alexandrinus : for what Porphyry calls hieroglyphical and symbolical,
Clemens calls hieroglyphical ; using hieroglyphical as a generic term,
which Porphyry used as a specific. Clemens, I say, giving an account
of the nature of hieroglyphic writing, tells us it was of two sorts ; the
one, KYPIOAOTEITAI KATA ΜΙΜΗΣΙΝ, directly and simply imitates the
thing intended to be represented ; by this he meant the proper hieroglyphic
(which Porphyry, in his enumeration of the kinds, distinguishes from
the symbolic); and what is more, Porphyry seems to have borrowed
his expression of τῶν μὲν κοινολογουμένων κατὰ μίμησιν, from Clemens’s
κυριολογεῖται κατὰ μίμησιν, by which this latter evidently means to express
the nature of the proper hieroglyphic. Besides, Clemens, who gives the
nature of epistolary writing, with the same judgement that Porphyry
omitted giving it, describes it in a very different manner, and with great
propriety, thus, ἧς ἡ μέν ἐστι διὰ τῶν τσρώτων ZTOIXEIQN KYPIOAOTIKH.
Yet a learned writer, supported by the authority of Holstenius, which
served his purpose in an argument for the low antiquity of Egypt, would
persuade us that Porphyry did not mean by the expression kowodoyovpeva
κατὰ μίμησιν, that the characters he spoke of imitated the forms or figures of the
things intended by them ; ¥or that was not the μίμησις which the ancient writers
ascribed to tnvters. [Sacr. and Prof. Hist. of the World connect. vol. ii. p.
296.] This argument is a Petitio Principit ; which supposes Porphyry to be
here describing epistolary writing. On this supposition the writer says,
that the imitation of the forms or figures of things is not the μίμησις the
ancient writers ascribed to letters. Certainly it is not. But Porphyry is
not speaking of the letters, but of hieroglyphic figures: therefore, μίμησις
does here, and may any where, mean (because it is the literal sense of the
word) imitation of the figure of things. However, let us consider his
criticism on this word, though it makes so little to his purpose :—Socrates
in Plato says, it seems, 6 διὰ τῶν συλλαξῶν τε καὶ γραμμάτων THY οὐσίαν τῶν
880 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOR Iv.
wpayparav ATIOMIMOYMENOS: and the ancients, the learned writer tells
us, were exceeding philosophical in their accounts of both words and letters :
when a word or sound was thought fully to express, according to their notions,
the thing which it was designed to be the name of, then they called it the
εἰκὼν, or picture of that thing. The ancients were, without doubt, wonder-
fully profound ; if we will believe Kircher and his school: but if a plain
man may be heard, all the mystery of μίμησις and εἰκὼν was simply this :
Alphabetic letters, as we have observed, sprung from hieroglyphic charac-
ters ; and even received their form from thence. Now the ancients, as
was very natural, when they spoke of the power of letters, and of words
composed of letters, frequently transferred the terms μίμησις and εἰκὼν,
to these, which properly belonged to hieroglyphic characters: a plain
proof of this is the very word ἀπομιμέομαι, quoted by the learned writer
from Plato; which literally signifies, to imitate from an exemplar, but
figuratively, to express, at large: So mAdoya originally signified any
thing formed and fashioned by art ; traductively, a similitude in speech,
nay, the musical modulation of the voice. There is a remarkable passage
in Plutarch’s discourse of the Pythian prophetess no longer rendering her
prophecies in verse; where the word wddcpa is generally thought to be
used in the first of these traductive senses, but I think it must be under-
stood in the second: speaking of the ancient manner of delivering the
oracles, he says,—ov« ἀνήδυντον, οὐδὲ λιτὴν, ἀλλ᾽ ἐν μέτρῳ καὶ ὄγκῳ καὶ
ΠΛΑΣΜΑΤῚ καὶ μεταφοραῖς ὀνομάτων, καὶ μετ᾽ αὐλοῦ. Mr. Le Clere, [De
Prophetia, p. 18, tom. iv. Comm. in V. T.] translates the latter part thus,
“pedibus vincta, tumida, quesitis οὐ tralatitiis verbis constantia, et cum
tibia pronunciata.” But πλάσματι signifies here, not guwsitis verbis, but
that modulation of the voice which we may call placida conformatio, and
is opposed to ὄγκῳ, a contrary modulation of the voice, which may be
called gravis conformatio. These two were used in the theatre (to which
the matter is compared) in a kind of recitative on the flute: so that what
Plutarch would say, is this, that the ancient oracles were not only deli-
vered in verse, and ina pompous figurative style, but were sung likewise
to the flute. To ὄγκῳ and wAdopate he opposed ἀνήδυντον, in the sense of
untunable; and to μεταφοραῖς ὀνομάτων he opposed λιτὴν, plain, simple.
Plutarch uses wAdoya again in the sense of conformatio, where speaking of
the elocution of Pericles, he calls it TAASMA φωνῆς ἀθόρυξον, a composed
modulation of voice. But Quintilian employs it in the very sense in ques-
tion, to express ὦ soft and delicate modulation of voice. “ Sit autem impri-
mis lectio virilis et cum suavitate quadain gravis, et non quidem prose
similis, quia carmen est, et se poete canere testantur. Non tamen in can-
ticum dissoluta, nec PLASMATE (ut nunc a plerisque fit) effoeminata.” 1. i.
9. 14. Hence again, in another traduction, plasma was used to signify a
certain medicine, that speakers in public took to render their voice soft and
harmonious :
“ Sede leges celsa, diguido cum plasmate guttur
Mobile conlueris ”—Pers. Sat. i. 17.
Turnebus, not attending to this progressive change in the sense of words,
and taking his signification of plasma from the passage of Quintilian, sup-
posed that plasma, in this place of the poet, signifies not a medicament,
but a soft and delicate modulation of the voice.— Est cim molli et tenera
fictaque vocula poema eliquaverit udo gutture. Est enim plasma, ut alio
loco docui, cum vox est tenera et mollis.” On the other hand, Lubin, who
had taken his signification of plasma from this place, will needs have the
same word in the passage quoted above from Quintilian to signify not a
NOTES. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 2881
soft and delicate modulation of the voice, but a medicament. ‘ Turnebi
hujus loci explicatio, 1. xxviii. ὁ. 26. Adversar. mihi non placet, et hoc
Quintiliani loco refutatur.’’? Comment. in Pers.
P. 192. GG. Kar οἰκειότητα μετάγοντες καὶ μετατιθέντες. That is, as 1
understand it, representing one thing by another, which other hath qualities
bearing relation or analogy to the thing represented.
‘P. 192. HH. ᾿Αναγράφουσι διὰ τῶν avayhipov. The Latin translator
keeps close to his original, anaglyphicis describunt ; and Stanley, [ Lives of
Phil. p. 350, ed. 3d. ] they write by anaglyphics: as if this was a new species
of writing, now first mentioned by Clemens, and to be added to the other
three: whereas, I suppose, it was Clemens’s intention only to tell us that
tropical symbols were chiefly to be met with on their stone monuments,
engraven in relief: which was true.
P. 192. 11. Αὐτίκα οἱ wap Αἰγυπτίοις παιδευόμενοι τορῶτον μὲν wavToy
τῶν Αἰγυπτίων γραμμάτων μέθοδον ἐκμανθάνουσι, τὴν ἘΠΙΣΤΟΛΟΓΡΑΦΙΚΗΝ
καλουμένην" δευτέραν δὲ, τὴν ΤΕΡΑΤΙΚΗΝ, 7 χρῶνται οἱ ἱερογραμματεῖς" ὕστά-
τὴν δὲ καὶ τελευταίαν, τὴν ΤΕΡΟΓΛΥΦΙΚΗΝ, ἧς ἡ μέν ἐστι διὰ τῶν τορώτων
στοιχείων κυριολογική᾽ ἡ δὲ συμξολική᾽ τῆς δὲ συμξολικῆς ἡ μὲν κυριολογεῖται
κατὰ μίμησιν ἡ δ᾽ ὥσπερ τροπικῶς γράφεται ἡ δὲ ἄντικρυς ἀλληγορεῖται κατά
τινας αἰνιγμούς. Ἥλιον γοῦν γράψαι βουλόμενοι, κύκλον ποιοῦσι Σελήνην
δὲ, σχῆμα μηνοειδὲς, κατὰ τὸ κυριολογούμενον εἶδος" τροπικῶς δὲ, κατ᾽ οἶκει-
ὄτητα μετάγοντες καὶ μετατιθέντες, τὰ δ᾽ ἐξαλλάττοντες" τὰ δὲ, πολλαχῶς
μετασχηματίζοντες, χαράττουσιν᾽ τοῦς γοῦν τῶν βασιλέων ἐπαίνους ϑεολογου-
μένοις μύθοις παραδιδόντες, ἀναγράφουσι διὰ τῶν ἀναγλύφων᾽ τοῦ δὲ κατὰ
τοὺς αἰνίγμους, τρίτου εἴδους, δεῖγμα ἔστω τόδε τὰ μὲν γὰρ τῶν ἄλλων ἄστρων,
διὰ τὴν πορείαν τὴν λοξὴν, ὄφεων σώμασιν ἀπείκαζον᾽ τὸν δὲ Ἥλιον, τῷ τοῦ
κανθάρου" ἐπειδὴ κυκλοτερὲς ἐκ τῆς βοείης ὄνθου σχῆμα σλασάμενος, ἀντιπρόσ-
ὡπὸς κυλίῳδει. Strom. lib. v. p. 555, 556, Ed. Morell.—ijs ἡ μέν ἐστι διὰ
TOY πρώτων στοιχείων κυριολογική. ἡ δὲ, συμξολική, the Latin translator
turns thus, Cujus una quidem est per prima elementa κυριολογικὴ, id est,
proprie loquens ; altera vero symbolica, id est, per signa significans. This is
so faithfully translated, that it preserves the very ambiguity of the ori-
ginal, and leaves us still to guess at the author’s division. Marsham takes
it just wrong ; and so does his nephew Stanley : the first of these learned
men quotes and translates the passage thus: Triplex erat apud Algyptios
characterum ratio, ᾿Ἐπιστολογραφικὴ, ad scribendas epistolas apta, sive vul-
garis ; ‘leparixn, qua utuntur ‘lepoypapparets, qui de rebus sacris scribunt ; et
Ἱερογλυφικὴ, sacra sculptura ; Husus duce sunt species, Kupiodoytkn, proprie
loquens per prima elementa, et Συμξολικὴ, per signa [Can. Chron. p. 88,
Franeq. Ed.] The second thus,—the last and most. perfect, hieroglyphical :
WHEREOF one 7s curiologic, the other symbolic. [Lives of Phil. p. 329,
3d. ed.| By this interpretation, the learned Father is, 1. made to enume-
rate three kinds of writing, but to explain only the last, namely /iero-
glyphics ; 2. which is worse, he is made to say one kind of hieroglyphics
was by letters of an alphabet ; for that is the meaning of διὰ τῶν wparev
στοιχείων : 3. which is still worse, he is made to divide hieroglyphics into
two sorts, cwriologic and symbolic ; and symbolic into three sorts, curiologic,
tropical, and allegorical ; which makes the prior division into curiologic
and symbolic, inaccurate and absurd ; and spreads a general confusion over
the whole passage. Their mistake seems to have arisen from supposing
μεθόδου ἱερογλυφικῆς (the immediate antecedent) was understood at ἧς ἡ μέν
ἐστι; whereas it was the more remote antecedent, μεθόδου Αἰγυπτίων ypap-
μάτων : and what made them suppose this, was, I presume, the author’s
expressing the common plain way of writing by letters of an alphabet, and
382 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK lv.
the common plain way of imitating by figures (two very different things)
by the same words, κυριολογικὴ and κυριολογεῖται ; not considering that
διὰ τῶν τρώτων στοιχείων, joined to the adjective, signified writing by
letters ; and, κατὰ μίμησιν, joined to the verb, signified writing by figures.
In a word then, the plain and easy meaning of Clemens is this,—‘ The
Egyptian method of writing was epistolic, sacerdotal, and hieroglyphical ;
of this method, the epistolic and sacerdotal were by letters of an alphabet ;
the hieroglyphical, by symbols: symbols were of three kinds, curiologic,
tropical, and allegorical.”
P,.192. KK. This was indeed a very logical conclusion from the
opinion that hieroglyphics were invented to hide mysteries ; but the high
improbability of the fact should have led them, one would think, to the
falshood of the premisses. That the Egyptians had Jetters before they had
hieroglyphics, seems to me as extravagant as that they danced before they
could walk ; and, I believe, will seem so to all who consider the first part of
this dissertation. However, a modern writer has taken up that opinion :
and tells us in plain terms, that the hiereglyphical way of writing was not the
most ancient way of writing in Egypt ; | Connect. of the Sacr. and Prof.
“οί. vol. i. p. 230, and again to the same purpose, vol. ii. 293, 294. |
partly, I presume, as it favoured the hypothesis of the low antiquity of
Egypt ; and partly, perhaps, in compliment to that consequential notion,
that not only all arts and sciences came from the Hebrews, but all the
vehicles of knowledge likewise ; whence, particularly, the author of the
Court of the Gentiles derives hieroglyphics. The greatest pieces of the
Jewish wisdom, says My. Gale, were couched under the cover of symbols and
types ; whence the Egyptians and other nations borrowed their hieroglyphic
and symbolic wisdom. [Part i. p. 77.] But on what ground does the
author of the Connection build, in support of his opinion? On this, that
letters are very ancient ; in which, without doubt, he is right: but surely
not so ancient as he would have them. However, the Argument he uses is
certainly a very perverse one: There is one consideration more, says he,
which makes it very probable that the use of Lerrers came from Noah, and
out of the first world, and that is the account which the Chinese give of their
LETTERS. They assert their first emperor, whom they name Fohy, to be the
inventor of them; before Fohy they have no records, and their Fohy and
Noah were the same person. [ Vol. i. p. 236.] Now it unluckily happens
that the Chinese are without Lerrers, even to this day. Nor are we, for
all this, to think our author ignorant of the nature of the Chinese charac-
ters, for he tells us soon after, that the Chinese have no notion of alphabetical
letters, but make use of characters to express their meaning. Their characters
are not designed to express words, for they are used by several neighbouring
nations who differ in language. [p. 244.| Thus the learned writer, before
he was aware, in endeavouring to prove Jeffers of higher antiquity than
hieroglyphics, hath proved just the contrary ; even that hieroglyphical cha-
racters, not letters, were the writing so early as his Noah: For the Chinese
characters are properly hieroglyphics, that is, marks for things, not words ;
and hieroglyphics they are called by all the missionaries from whom we
have the most authentic accounts of China. But had their characters been
indeed Jetters, as our author, in this place, by mistake supposed them, yet
still his argument would have had no weight ; and I will beg leave to tell
him why : The Chinese characters in use at present are very modern in
comparison of the monarchy. The missionaries tell us (as may be seen
by the quotations given above) that the Chinese character hath undergone
several changes ; that their first way of writing was, like the Mexican, by
NOTES. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 329
picture ; that they then abbreviated it in the manner of the most ancient
Egyptian hieroglyphics; and at length brought it, by many gradual
improvements, to its present contracted form : yet a real character or hiero-
glyphic the Chinese writing still is; and so is likely to continue.
P. 194. LL. <A late curious Voyager, who had examined the larger
PYRAMIDS with great exactness, and found no hieroglyphics inscribed upon
them, either without or within, concludes, rather too hastily, that they
were built before the usé of hieroglyphic writing in Egypt ; and from
thence insinuates another conclusion, in favour of the absurd hypothesis
here confuted, that hieroglyphics were not the first species of writing known
in Egypt; and, consequently, did not come from picture-writing, but from
alphabetic marks ; a foolish error, which betrays great ignorance in the
natural progress of human knowledge. “Si je suppose” (says Captain
Norden) “que les Pyramides, méme les dernieres, ont été elevées avant
que l’on efit Vusage des hieroglyphes, je ne l’avance sans fondement. Qui
pourroit se persuader, que les Egyptiens eussent laissé ces superbes monu-
mens, sans la moindre inscription hieroglyphique, eux, qui, comme on
Vobserve de toutes parts, prodigueoient les hieroglyphes sur tous les edifices
de quelque consideration? Or on n’en appercoit aucun, ni au dedans, ni au
dehors, des pyramides, pas méme sur les ruines des temples de la seconde et
de la troisieme pyramide : n’est ce pas une preuve que l’origine des pyra-
mides précéde celle des hieroglyphes, que l’on regarde neanmoins comme les
premiers caracteres dont ‘on ait usé en Egypte?”—Vovage d Egypte, 8me
partie, p. 75.
The curious voyager not only satisfies himself in accounting for the want
of hieroglyphic characters on the Pyramids, by their being built before the
invention of such characters, but seems to value himself upon a discovery
resulting from it, that Hieroglyphics were not the first sort of writing in
Egypt. But there is a greater difficulty in this matter than he was
aware of.
Τὸ hath been proved at large, that marks for things, by a kind of picture-
writing, were the first rude effort of every people upon earth, to convey
and perpetuate their intelligence and conceptions to one another, as soon
as they began to associate into tribes and nations. The Monuments in
question are a proof that the erectors of them had advanced in the arts of
civil life. No one then, who understands what Society is, can doubt but
that the Egyptians had then a method of conveying their thoughts at a
distance, by visible marks: and no one, acquainted with the slow progress
of human inventions, can imagine that alphabetic writing was the first
effort towards this conveyance. Hence arises the difficulty.
But this observation of the curious voyager, which furnishes the di-
culty, supplies the solution. Suppose only the Pyramids to be erected in
the interval between the inventions of cwriologic and tropical hieroglyphics,
that is, between their natural and more artificial state, and the difficulty
vanishes : For in their natural state, they would be only used out of neces-
sity; and not for ornament, luxury, or decoration. So that it is no wonder
we do not find them on the pyramips in pompous and flattering inscriptions
like those on the oBELIsKs.
His observation Norden, indeed, gives as a proof of the high antiquity of
the pyramids; and very justly. But his drawings furnish us with another
argument in support of this truth, which he himself seems not to have
considered. It is this, that the general idea of Egyptian architecture was
entirely taken from the pyramips: which nothing sure but the high
veneration for them, increased by their remote antiquity, could possibly
/
384. -THE DIVINE LEGATIOGN BOOK IV.
have occasioned ; since the figure of these sepulchral monuments, so well
adapted to triumph over time, is the most inconvenient that can possibly
be imagined for habitable structures, whether public or private; and
exceedingly grotesque, in all others. And yet we see, from the ancient
ruins of Egypt, of which this diligent and exact Traveller has given us so
fine drawings, that all their buildings, without exception, were raised on
the idea and genius of the Pyramids. We are surprised to find not only
their ports, their door-steads [See plates cix.—exviii.] but even the very
walls of their temples, [ Pl. cxlvii—viiii—cli—cliv.] nay, of their
towns, narrowing upwards and inclining inwards, in the manner of a modern
fortification. [ Pl. xcix.—cxv.—cxxxviii. |—But to return to the solution
given above: It may be said, perhaps, “‘ Allow the pyramids to have been
erected in the interval between the invention of curiologic and tropical hiero-
glyphics. What hindered the Egyptians from scribbling over these bulky
monuments with their first rude essays, as other barbarous nations have
done upon their rocks? of which we find specimens enough in Scandinavia,
North-East Tartary, and elsewhere.” Indeed I know of nothing but
custom that hindered them; that sovereign Mistress of the worlds who
only is of force to control and conquer Nature : And that Custom did
effectually hinder them, is very plain, from our finding no specimens of
any of their first rude hieroglyphic paintings; though, from them, their
improved hieroglyphics received their birth. Nor did they want, any
more than other Barbarians, their isolated rocks for this purpose: they had
them very commodiously bordering on the Nile, and in view of all
passengers. And on these, it is remarkable, they have inscribed their
improved hieroglyphics, though we see no remains of any the earlier and
ruder efforts of picture-writing.
But the modesty and reserve of this curious Traveller, and his deference
to learned Antiquity, deserves commendation. He is not of the number of
those who expect more faith from their Reader than they commonly find,
or venture to entertain him with discoveries which he did not expect. For
the learned reader acquiesces in Antiquity ; the sensible reader prefers the
evidence of a contemporary writer to the conjectures of a modern traveller :
yet such is the general humour of our Voyagers, that they think they do
nothing, if they do not rectify the errors of Antiquity. I have an inge-
nious measurer of the Pyramids in my eye, and one of the latest too [ Dr.
Shaw ], who, in the passion for saying something new, assures us, that the
opinion of their being sepuLcHREs is an old inveterate mistake: that they
are indeed no other than Temptes, for religious worship. ΤῸ soften so
rugged a paradox, he says, there was no universal consent amongst the
Ancients concerning the use or purpose for which these Pyramids were
designed. And was there any universal consent amongst them that snow
was white? But would this save the modesty or understanding of him
who should affirm, after a certain ancient Philosopher, that it was black ?
And yet such a one would have the advantage of our Traveller ; who
would be hard put to it to produce any Ancient, whether Philosopher or
otherwise, who said the Pyramids were Temples. But if the positive and
agreeing testimony of all the old writers extant may be called universal con-
sent, it certainly is not wanting. Herodotus, Diodorus Siculus, Strabo,
Pliny, Tacitus, &c. all assure us that the Pyramids were Sepulchres. Nay,
Diodorus, to put the matter out of doubt, informs us, that the sacred com-
mentaries of their Priests said so. But our Traveller supposed this uni-
versal consent to be shaken at least by Pliny, who tells us, they were built
Sor ostentation, and to keep an idle people in employment. As if this inti-
NOTES, OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 385
mated that, in Pliny’s opinion, they were not Sepulchres! Suppose I
should say the great Arch at Blenheim was built for ostentation ; and if not
to set an idle people to work, yet at least to make them stare: Does this
contradict the universal consent of its being a Bridge, though as much too
large for the water that runs under it, as the Pyramids were for the bodies
contained in them? Ina word, Pliny is not speaking of the wse to which
the buildings were applied, but of the motives for their erection.
P.197. MM. Against this,a late furious writer objects—“ But is it
credible that the polite and learned priests of Egypt would use a method
to hide and secrete their knowledge, which the more rude and barbarous
nations employed to publish and divulge theirs? Or can you conceive that
a curious and studied refinement of so knowing and enlightened a people
as the Egyptians should be one and the very same thing with a rude and
simple invention of those nations which were most barbarous and unci-
vilized?” Jackson’s Chronol. vol. ili. p. 357.
I answer by another question—Is it credible that the polite and learned
orators and historians of Greece and Rome should, out of choice, use a
method [FIGURATIVE EXPRESSION | to perfect their eloquence, which the first
rude and barbarous nations employed out of necessity, and which rude and
barbarous nations still employ, for want of intellectual ideas, and more
abstract terms? Or can you conceive, that a curious and studied refinement
of dress, in so knowing and enlightened a people as the present French,
should be one and the same thing with the rude and simple invention of
leathern garments to cover nakedness amongst the Laplanders, a people
most barbarous and uncivilized? But if it displeases our Chronologist, that
so enlightened and refined a people as the Egyptians should pride them-
selves in the rude and simple invention of barbarians: what will he say to
find, that the most savage people upon earth go a step beyond the most
polished in the delicacy and luxury of speech? Yet this is the case of the
Greenlanders, or the missionary Egede deceives us. The women (says he)
have a dialect different from the men, making use of the softest letters at the
ends of words, instead of the hard ones. Hist. of Greenland, p. 160.
P. 197. NN. This hieroglyphic likewise signified the earth, for the
first rude mortals imagined, that that which sustained them was the Deity
which gave them being. So Hesiod, who took his notions of the earth
from the Egyptians, describes her after their paintings; TAI EYPY-
=TEPNOS, which the figure of the Diana multimammia well explains. But
Shakspeare, who, as Mr. Pope finely observes, had immediately from nature
what the two Greek poets, Homer and Hesiod, received through Egyptian
strainers, paints this famous hieroglyphic with much more life and spirit !
“Common Mother thou!
Whose womb unmeasurable aud INFINITE BREAST
Teems and feeds all.”’
That Hesiod had there the Egyptian Goddess in his mind, is plain from
the character he gives of her in the words subjoined,
πάντων ἕδος ἀσφαλὲς αἰεὶ
᾿Αθανάτων,
for the earth was the first habitation of those Gods which Greece borrowed
of the Egyptians: from whence, as the poet insinuates, they were trans-
ferred into heaven :
Γαῖα δέ τοι ττρῶτον μὲν ἐγείνατο ἶσον ἑαυτῇ
Οὐρανὸν ἀστερόενθ᾽, ἵνα μιν wepl wavTa καλύπτοι,
“Opp εἴη μακάρεσσι ϑεοῖς ἕδος ἀσφαλὲς αἴει.
VOR: 11- cc
386 THE DIVINE LEGATION ROOK IV.
P. 199. OO. A very curious specimen of this hasty delineation of the
outlines of the figures (which gave birth to the running-hand character we
are here speaking of ) the reader will find in Kircher, p. 350, of his (Ἰαΐρ.
Aigypt. tom, iii. where he has given the characters on the Florentine
obelisk, which, though dignified by that name, is only a late mimic in
miniature of the superb monuments so intitled. See plate vill.
P. 199. PP. The account which a missionary jesuit gives us of the
several sorts of writing amongst the Chinese will illustrate this matter :—
Parmi ces caracteres il y en a de plusieurs sortes. Les premiers ne sont
presque plus d’usage, et on ne les conserve que pour faire honneur a Vanti-
guité. Les seconds beaucoup moins anciens n’ont place que dans les inscrip-
tions publiques: quand on en a besoin, on consulte les livres, et ἃ la faveur
des dictionnaires il est facile de les dechiffrer. Les troisiemes, beaucoup plus
requliers et plus beaux, servent dans Vimpression et méme dans Vl ecriture
ordinaire. Neanmoins comme les traits en sont bien formez, il faut un temps
considerable pour les écrire ; c’est pour cela qu’on a trouvé une quatrieme
espece d’ecriture, dont les traits plus liez et moins distinguez les uns des
autres, donnent la facilité d’ecrire plus viste—ces trois derniers caracteres
ont entre eux beaucoup de ressemblance, et respondent assez a nos lettres
capitales, aux lettres d’impression, e ἃ Vecriture ordinaire—Nouveaux
Memoires sur Vetat present de la Chine, parle P. L. Le Comte, tom. i.
Amst. 1698, p. 258, 259. And here let me just take notice of a ridiculous
mistake into which the equivocation of the word Note (a term signifying
as well short-hand characters, as hieroglyphical) drew a certain learned
grammarian: who in a letter to his friend [Gloss. Ant. Rom. p. 414. ed.
1781] undertaking to give the original of short-hand characters, rejects the
account of the ancients (which makes them a Roman invention) to fetch
them from the Barbarians ; and will have them to be indeed the same as
the Jgnorabiles Litere of the Egyptians (mentioned by Apuleius) and the
present Chinese characters ; that is, real héeroglyphics. But had he consi-
dered, that the notes of short-hand were marks for words, and the notes
of hieroglyphics marks for things, he would have seen that they had no
manner of relation to one another, but were of different original, and
employed to different ends: He thinks, however, he has found a support
for his notion in St. Jerom ; who, he says, tells us somewhere or other,
that they came from the Barbarians: Restant adhuc Norm, que cum ex
Barbarorum puto ortu nate sint, rationem amisere. But without searching
for the place, and recurring to the context, we may safely pronounce, that
St. Jerom meant here by nora, not the notes of short-hand, but hiero-
glyphic notes ; by his saying of them rationem amisere ; which was not
true of short-hand notes, but very true of hieroglyphical.
P. 201. QQ. To this, perhaps, it may be objected that literary writing
had the name of epistolary, rather for its being afterwards employed in
such kind of compositions ; because Clemens Alexandrinus says, That
Atossa the Persian empress was the first that wrote epistles ; and Tatian,
where he gives a list of some Inventors, expresses himself, from Hella-
nicus the historian, in this manner, Ἐπιστολὰς SYNTASSEIN ἐξεῦρεν ἡ
Περσῶν wore ἡγησαμένη γυνὴ, καθάπερ φησὶν Ἑλλάνικος, "Atoooa δὲ ὄνομα
αὐτῇ jv. But to this it may be replied, that the supposition of literary
writing’s having the name of epistolary from any later application of alpha-
betic letters to this sort of composition, is very precarious: for it may be
asked, why rather a name from epistles than from any nobler sort of
composition, in which we must needs conclude letters had been employed,
before the use of epistles, if epistles were so lately invented? But the
‘ NOTES. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 3927
truth is, if by συντάσσειν, which word Clemens likewise uses, we are to
understand the composing, and not the artificial closing and sealing up of
the tablets in which the Ancients wrote their epistles (the more natural
sense of the word, and an invention more to the genius of a court lady) we
must needs say the whole story of Atossa’s invention is a very idle one, and
worth only the attention of such triflers as the writers Of the invention of
things ; from whence Tatian and Clemens had it: they might as well
have enquired after the inventors of speech : writing epistles being as early
as the occasions of communicating the thoughts at a distance ; that is, as
early as human commerce. We find in the 77. ζ΄. ver. 169. Bellerophon
carrying an epistle from Pretus to Iobates. “ No,” says a great Critic, [see
p- 539, of the Dissertation upon Phalaris | “this was no epistle, as Pliny
rightly remarks, but codicelii ; and Homer himself calls it πίναξ wrukrés.””
I do not comprehend the force of the learned person’s argument; the point
between him and his noble adversary was concerning the thing, not the
name ; but Pliny’s observation, and his own, is concerning the name, not
the thing. Let what Bellerophon carried be πίναξ ττυκτὸς, small leaves of
wood covered with waz, and writien upon by a pen of metal, yet was it
essentially an epistle, if Cicero’s definition of an epistle be a true one: Hoc
est, says he, Epistole proprium, ut is ad quem scribitur, de tis rebus quas
ignorant, certior fiat. Why Pliny said, this πίναξ ττυκτὸς was not an
epistle, but a codicil, was because small leaves of wood covered with wax,
when written on, were called by his countrymen codicil/i ; and a missive-
paper, epistola: that this was his meaning appears from the account he
gives of the pretended paper epistle of Sarpedon mentioned as a great rarity
by Licinius Mucianus. [See the Dissert. mentioned above. ]
P. 201. RR. By sonos vocis Cicero means words: It was impossible he
could ever conceive that brute and inarticulate sounds were almost infinite.
—See what is said on this matter below.
Long before this addition was made to the discourse on Hieroglyphic
writing, one of the ablest Philosophers of this age, M. l’Abbé de Condillac,
in his Essai sur Porigine des connoissances humaines, had the candour to
say, that I had perfectly well discovered the progress by which men
arrived to the invention of letters. ‘‘ Cette section [De L’ecriture],” says
he, “ étoit presque achevée, quand |’Essai sur les Hieroglyphes traduit de
PAnglois de M. Warburton me tomba entre les mains : Ouvrage ot l’esprit
philosophique et Verudition régnent egalement, &c. mes propres reflexions
m’avoient aussi conduit a remarquer que l’écriture n’avoit d’abord été qu’
une simple peinture: mais je n’avois point encore tenté de découvrir par
quels progres on étoit arrive a l’invention des lettres, et il me paroissoit
difficile d’y reussir. La chose a été parfaitement executée par M. Warbur-
ton, p. 178, sec. partie.’”—My own countrymen have been less candid : and
to them the above addition is owing.
P, 204. SS. Τὸ σερὶ τῶν ἐν Βαξυλῶνι ἱερῶν γραμμάτων. περὶ τῶν ἐν
Μερόῃ ἱερῶν γραμμάτων. In Vit. Democr. Segm. xlix. lib. 9. But Reine-
sius and Menage, not apprehending there was any sacred mysterious writ-
ing out of Egypt and its confines, will have the Babylon here mentioned
to be Babylon in Egypt ; but they should have reflected how unlikely it
was, if Democritus had chosen to write of the sacred letters of the Eqyp-
tians, that he should denominate his discourse from a place not at all cele-
brated for their use, when there were so many other that these characters
had rendered famous.
P. 207. TT. I have the pleasure to find, that so sensible a writer as
the celebrated Mr. Astruc, in his Conjectures sur la Genese, has espoused
2 c-2
988 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
this opinion, that alphabetic writing was in use amongst the Egyptians
before the time of Moses: He has likewise adopted the arguments here
employed in support of it, as well as this whole theory of hieroglyphic
writing.
P. 207. UU. Exod. xxviii. 21.. And the stones shall be with the names
of the children of Israel, twelve, according to their names ; LIKE THE ENGRAY-
INGS OF A SIGNET, every one with his name shall they be, according to the
twelve tribes. And again, ver. 36. And thou shalt make a Plate of pure
gold, and grave upon it, like the engravings of a signet, HoLinEss TO THE
Lorp. Had letters been invented by Moses, and unknown till then to the
Israelites, would he not naturally have said, when he directed the work-
men to engrave names and sentences on stones and gold,—and in these
engravings you shall employ the alphabetic characters which I have now
invented and taught you the use of 2 On the contrary, he gives them a
very different direction ; he refers them to a model in familiar use,—/ike
the engravings of a signet. For the ancient people of the East engraved
names and sentences on their seals, just as the Mahometan princes do at
present.—Mr. Fleuri with great ingenuity confesses the high perfection of
the arts at this time amongst the Israelites. “Ils scavoient tailler et
graver les pierres precieuses. Ils etoient Menuisiers, Tapissieurs, Brodeurs
et Parfumeurs. Entre ces arts, il y en a deux que j’admire principale-
ment : la taille des pierreries, et la fonte des figures, telles qu’étoient les
Chérubins de l’Arche et le Veau d’or. Ceux qui ont tant soit peu con-
noissance des arts, scavent combien il faut d’artifices et de machines pour
ces ouvrages. Si des-lors on les avoit trouvées, on avoit déja bien raffiné,
méme dans les arts qui ne servent qu’a l’ornement; et si lon avoit
quelque secret pour faire les mémes choses plus facilement, c’étoit encore
une plus grande perfection, ce qui soit dit en passant, pour montrer que
cette antiquité si eloignée n’etoit pas grossiére et ignorante, comme plu-
sieurs s’imaginent.” Meurs des Israelites, sect. 9.
P. 207. XX. A certain anonymous writer, quoted by Crinitus from
an ancient MS, in his de honesta disciplina, is of this opinion. But I
quote him chiefly for his pacific disposition to accommodate and compro-
mise matters, by giving every nation its share in the glory of the inven-
tion ; not, I mean, of the alphabetic powers, but of the various alphabetic
characters :
“Moses primus Hebraicas exaravit literas ;
Mente Pheenices sagaci condiderunt Atticas ;
Quas Latini scriptitamus, edidit Nicostrata ;
Abraham Syras, et idem repperit Chaildaicas ;
{sis arte non minore, protulit Avgyptiacas :
Gulfila promsit Getarum, quas videmus, literas.”
Ῥ, 213. YY. ‘Les Iroquois, comme les Lacedemoniens, veulent un
discours vif et concis ; leur Style est cependant figuré, et tout metaphorique.”
Meurs des Sauvages Ameriquains comparées aux Meeurs des premiers Temps,
par Lafitau, tom. i. p. 580, 4to. And of the various languages of all
the people on that great continent in general, he expresseth himself thus,
“La plipart de ces Peuples Occidentaux, quoiqu’avec des Langues tres
differentes, ont cependant ἃ peu pres la méme genie, la méme facon de
penser, et les meme tours pour s’exprimer ;” tom. ii. p. 481. Condamine
gives pretty much the same account of the Savages of South America.
Speaking of their languages he says, “ plusieurs sont energiques et suscep-
tibles d’eloquence,” &c. p. 54. which can mean no other than that their
terms are highly figurative. But this is the universal genius of the lan-
NOTES. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 889
guage of Barbarians. Zgede, in his History of Greenland, says, the Lan-
guage is very rich of words and sense ; and of such ENERGY, that one is often
at a loss, and puzzled to render it in Danish, p. 165. This energy is
apparently what the French Missionary calls tout metaphorique. Quinti-
lian, speaking of metaphors, says, “ Qua quidem cum ita est ab ipsa nobis
concessa natura, ut indocti quoque ac non sentientes ea frequenter utan-
tur,” lib. viii. 6. 6. which shews, by the way, that Quintilian did not
apprehend their true cause or original.—By all this may be seen how much
M. Bullet mistakes the matter, where, in his Memoires sur la langue
Celtique, he says, “ Dans les pays chauds une imagination ardente decouvre
aisement ‘la plus petite ressemblance qu’une chose peut avoir avee une
autre. lle voit @abord, par exemple, la report qui se trouve entre un
homme cruel et une béte feroce ; et pour faire connoitre qu’ elle appercoit
cette ressemblance elle donne a cet homme le nom de Tigre. Vola l’ori-
gine du langage figuré et metaphorique. Dans les pays froides, ο Vimagina-
tion n’a pas une vivacité pareille, on se sert de terms propres pour exprimer
chaque chose, ou appelle tout par son nom.” Vol. i. p.6, But we find the
fact to be just otherwise.
P. 213. ZZ. Κατὰ δὲ τὰς ὁμιλίας βραχυλόγοι, καὶ αἰνιγματίαι, καὶ τὰ
πολλὰ αἰνιττόμενοι συνεκδοχικῶς" πολλὰ δὲ λέγοντες ἐν vrepFodais.—p. 213.
This being the nature and genius common to all the barbarous nations
upon earth, I am almost tempted to believe Geofry of Monmouth, when he
says, that he translated his worthy history of Britain from the Welch ; of
which, his original, he gives this character,—Phallerata verba et ampullose
dictiones. If this was not so, one can hardly tell why he should mention
a circumstance that neither recommended his copy nor his original. But
the character of the ballads of the old Welch Bards fully supports Diodo-
rus’s account of the style of the ancient Gauls.
P. 214. AAA. But the important use to which the very learned the
Abbé de Condillac has employed all that has been here said on this matter,
may be seen in his excellent Essay on the origin of human Knowledge,
Part ii. which treats of Language.
P. 214. BBB. ΠῚ males an objector to the figurative style argue
thus,—* Antiquissimum quemque maxime secundum naturam Ἰππετες
contendunt ; mox Poetis similiores extitisse, etiamsi parcius, simili tamen
ratione, falsa et impropria virtutes ducentes.’”” On which he observes—
“ἐ qua in disputatione non nihil veri est.”—It is true, there is something of
truth in it, and indeed, not much; for though the polishers of human
speech did, as the objector says, turn the improprieties of speech into orna-
ment, it is utterly false that the most ancient speakers used only simple
and proper terms.
P. 217. CCC. So I thought: and so it has been generally thought.
But M. de Beausobre, in his Histoire de Manichée, lib. iv. cap. 4. has made
it probable, that the heretics had no hand in these Adbrazas, but that they
are altogether Pagan.
P. 217. DDD. This charm, which the Arabs called Talisman or Tsali-
mam, the later Greeks, when they had borrowed the superstition, called
STOIXEIA ; which shews of what house they supposed it to have come ;
στοιχεῖα being, as we have observed, the technical Greek name for hiero-
glyphic characters.
P. 217. EEE. The same error has made the half-paganized Marsilius
Ficinus fall into the idle conceit, that the Golden Calf was only a Talis-
man :—* Hebrei quoque” (says he) “in Aigypto nutriti, struere vitulum
aureum didicerant, ut eorundem astrologi putant, ad aucupandum veneris
͵
200 THE DIVINE LEGATION ‘ BOOK IV.
luneque favorem, contra Scorpionis atque Martis influxum Judezis infes-
tum.”—De Vita Celit. Com. 1. iii. e. 13.
P. 218. FFF. This Discourse on the Eeyptian Hirroeiypatcs. hath
had the same fortune abroad, that the Discourse on the Boox or Jos hath
had at home: Like this, it hath been the occasion of much waste paper,
and violation of common sense. For the Discourse on the Hieroglyphics
having been well translated and well received in France, both the sabject
and the author became known enough to invite all gentlemen scholars, better
able to entertain the Public, to oblige us with their ingenious conjectures ;
and many a French pen, even to that of a captain of grenadiers, hath been
drawn, to shew that the nature of Hieroglyphics is yet as unknown as
ever. A nameless dissertator, sur ?Ecriture Hieroglyphique, (who chuses
to write, as he himself very truly says, in his title-page,—swb luce maligna )
assures us, that Hieroglyphics were not a species of writing to convey intel-
ligence to the reader, but a mere ornament upon stone, to entertain the eye
of the spectator: So there is an end of the sussrecr. The learned captain,
who wheels ina larger circle, and takes in all the wisdom of Egypt,
laments with much humanity, the superficiality and ignorance of all who
have gone before him, and their utter incapacity of getting to the source
of things: So there is an end of the aurHor. Indeed, the Journalist who
recommends this important work to the public seems to have his doubts
as to this point.—“N’est ce pas s’avancer un peu trop” (says he), “ et
peut-on dire que MarsHam pour la Chronologie et l’Histoire, M. Warsur-
ΤῸΝ pour les Hieroglyphes, et d’autres scavans ayent negligé de consulter
les sources ?”
To say the truth, these wonderful investigators of the learning of ancient
Egypt, by the mere dint of modern ingenuity, had provocation enough to
fall upon this unlucky Discourse, which no sooner appeared amongst them
in the fine translation of a very learned French lawyer, than the celebrated
writers of the Journal des Scavans, of March, 1744, and of Trevoux of
July, in the same year, announced it to the public in these terms, “II
regne” (says the first) “ une si belle analogie dans le systeme de Mr. War-
burton, et toutes ses parties tiennent les unes aux autres par un lien si
naturel, qu’on est porté a croire que lorigine, et les progrés de l’ecriture et
du language ont été tels qu’il les a decrits. Le public doit avoir bien de
Pobligation au Traducteur de lui avoir fait connoitre un Ouvrage si
curieux.”—‘ M. Warburton ” (says the other) “n’a pu sans une erudition
profonde, une lecture murement digerée et des reflexions infinies traiter
avec tant de precision, de justesse et de netteté, un sujet de lui méme si
difficile 4 mettre en ceuvre. Les plus savans hommes se sont laissé seduire
sur l’origine des Hieroglyphes ; et la plupart ont regardé un effet du peu
experience des Egyptiens comme un refinement de la plus mysterieuse
sagesse. C’est cette erreur que M. Warburton s’applique particulierement
a detruire dans la premiere partie. I] le fait de la maniere la plus naturelle.
Ce n’est point un systeme fondé suR DES IMAGINATIONS VAGUES. Ses rai-
sonnemens, ses preuves, sont appuiées sur des Fairs, sur la NATURE des
choses, et sur LES PRINCIPES LES PLUS LUMINEUX DU SENS COMMUN.” f
P. 219. GGG. Amongst the rest, the author of Sacred and Profane
History connected ; who says: “ We have no reason to think that these
hieroglyphics [namely, what we call the cwréologic] were so ancient as the
first letters :” This is his first answer to the opinion that hieroglyphics
were more ancient. His second is in these words: “They would have
been a very imperfect character ; many, nay most occurrences, would be
represented by them but by halves,” vol. ii. p. 295. Now this to me
NOTES. . OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 391
appears a very good argument why Aieroglyphics were indeed the first rude
effort towards recording the human conceptions; and still, a better, why
they could not be the second, when men had already found out the more
compleat method of alphabetic letters.
P. 220. HHH. What hath been said above of the reason why Lgypt
alone continued their hieroglyphic characters after the invention of Jetters,
and why all other nations thenceforward left them off, will give an easy
solution to what a curious traveller seems to think matter of some wonder,
namely, that “the symbolic learning was the only part of Egyptian wis-
dom not translated into Greece.” [Dr. Shaw's Travels, p. 391.|—But if
this learned man meant not hieroglyphic characters, but only the mode of
Egyptian wisdom employed therein, he raises a wonder out of his own
mistake : that mode was translated into Greece with the rest ; for the pre-
cepts of Pythagoras were a fantastic kind of translation of hieroglyphic
pictures into verbal propositions; and on that account, doubtless, called
SYMBOLS :--- Μάλιστα (says Plutarch) δὲ οὗτος [ὁ Πυθαγόρας] ὡς ἔοικε, Sav-
μασθεὶς καὶ ϑαυμάσας τοὺς ἄνδρας, ἀπεμιμήσατο τὸ συμξολικὸν αὐτῶν καὶ
μυστηριῶδες, ἀναμίξας αἰνίγμασι τὰ δόγματα: τῶν γὰρ καλουμένων γραμμάτων
ἱερογλυφικῶν οὐθὲν ἀπολείπει τὰ τστολλὰ τῶν Πυθαγορικῶν τταραγγελμάτων, οἷόν
ἐστι τὸ Μὴ ἐσθίειν ἐπὶ δίφρου, μηδ᾽ ἐπὶ χοίνικος καθῆσθαι, μηδὲ φοίνικα φυτέυ-
εἰν, μηδὲ wdp μαχαίρῃ σκαλεύειν ἐν οἰκίᾳ. De Is. et Os. Ρ- 632. Edit. Steph.
8vo. Αὐτίκα τῆς Bapbapov (says Clemens Alex.) φιλοσοφίας, wavy σφόδρα
ἐπικεκρυμμένης ἥρτηται τὰ ἸΤυθαγόρια ΣΎΜΒΟΛΑ. wapaivee γοῦν ὁ Σάμιος
χελιδόνα ἐν οἰκίᾳ μὴ ἔχειν, τουτέστι, λάλον καὶ ψίθυρον καὶ τρόγλωσσον
ἄνθρωπον, &c. Strom. lib. ν. p. 558. Edit. Colon. 1688, fol.
P. 221. Ill. The reader may now see how inconsiderately the learned
W. Baxter pronounced upon the matter when he said, “ The ἵερα γράμματα
of the Egyptians were note sacre borrowed from the Onirocritics, and
therefore divine.” [App. to his Gloss. Antiqg. Rom. pag. 414,] Nor does
the more judicious Mr. Daubuz conclude less erroneously, when he sup-
poses that both onzrocritic and hieroglyphics stood upon one common foun-
dation. But he was misled by Kircher, and certain late Greek writers,
who pretended that the ancient Egyptians had I can’t tell what notion of
a close union between visible bodies in heaven, the invisible deities, and
this inferior world, by such a concatenation from the highest to the lowest,
that the affections of the higher link reached the lower throughout the
whole chain ; for that the intellectual world is so exact a copy and idea of
the visible, that nothing is done in the visible, but what is decreed before
and exemplified in the intellectual. [Prelim. Discourse to his Comm. on
the Reveations.] This was the senseless jargon of Jamblichus, Por-
phyry, Proclus, and the rest of that fanatic tribe of Pythagorean-Platonists ;
and this they obtruded on the world for old Egyptian wisdom ; the vanity
of which pretence has been confuted in the first volume. It is “hard to say
whether these Enthusiasts believed themselves, there is such an equal
mixture of folly and knavery in all their writings: however, it is certain,
Kircher believed them.
Ρ. 222, KKK. But hieroglyphic writing, as we have observed, not only
furnished rules of interpretation for their Onirocritics, but figures of speech
for their Orators. ‘So Isaiah expresseth the king of Assyria’s invasion of
Judea by the stretching out of his wines, to fill the breadth of the land : *
And afterwards, prophesying against Egypt and Ethiopia, he says, Wo to
the land shadowing with winas.t Most of the interpreters, indeed, explain
* Tsai, viii 8. + Isai. xviii. 1.
902 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
wings to signify the sails of their vessels on the Nile : but the expression
evidently means, in general, the over-shadowing with a mighty power: of
which wings in hieroglyphic language were the emblem.
P. 222. LLL. Thus Suidas on the word STOIXEIA’ ai εἰκόνες καὶ δια-
πλάσεις τῶν ὀνείρων αἱ δί ὀλίγου ἢ πολλοῦ χρόνου τὴν ἔκξασιν ἔχουσαι.
Artemidorus tells us this was the technical word for the phantasms in
dreams : "Ονειρός ἐστι, κίνησις ἢ σλάσις ψυχῆς τσολυσχήμων᾽ σημαντικὴ τῶν
ἐσομένων ἀγαθῶν ἢ κακῶν τούτου δὲ οὕτως ἔχοντος, ὅσα μὲν ἀποξήσεται
μεταξὺ χρόνου διελθόντος, ἢ ττολλοῦ, ἢ ὀλίγου, ταῦτα wavta δὲ’ εἰκόνων ἰδίων
φυσικῶν τῶν καὶ ΣΤΟΙΧΕΙΩΝ καλουμένων, ττροαγορεύει ἡ ψυχὴ τὸν μεταξὺ
χρόνον νομίζουσα ἡμᾶς δύνασθαι λογισμῷ διδασκομένους τὰ ἐσόμενα μαθεῖν.
Oneir. lib. i. cap. 2. And in his fourth book he begins a chapter which
he entitles περὶ STOIXEION in this manner: Περὶ δὲ τῶν STOIXEION
wpos τοὺς ἐπιφθόνως εἰρῆσθαι δοκοῦντας, οὗτος ὁ λόγος ἁρμόσει, ὅπως ἔχης
ἀποκρίνασθαι καὶ αὐτὸς, καὶ μὴ ἐξαπατηθῆς ὑπὸ τῶν Drelova λεγόντων εἶναι.
cap. 3.
P. 222. MMM. But the learned Daubuz, in consequence of his trusting
to the fanatic notion of the late Greek philosophers, supposes that hiero-
glyphic marks were called ΣΤοιχεῖα, because the first composers of them
used the heavenly bodies to represent the notions of their minds, there being,
according to them, a mystic sympathetic union and analogy between heavenly
and earthly things ; consequently that Στοιχεῖα, in this use, signifies the
host of heaven: That it may do so, according to the genius of the Greek
tongue, he endeavours to prove by its coming from στείχω, which is a
military term, and signifies to,march in order. [p. 10. of the Prel. Disc.]
But this learned man should on this occasion have remembered his own
quotation from the excellent Quintilian, p. 54. that analogy is not founded
upon reason, but example. Non ratione nititur analogia, sed exemplo; nec
lex est loquendi, sed observatio: ut ipsam analogiam nulla res alia fecerit,
quam consuetudo. Inst. lib. i. cap. 10.
P. 222. NNN. Here perhaps I shall be told, with the candour I have
commonly experienced, that I have applied the history of Pharaoh’s dream
in illustrating the old Pagan method of onirocritic for no other purpose
than to discredit Joseph’s prophetic interpretation of it: Therefore, though
this matter be explained afterwards at large, 1 must here inform the reader,
of what every one will be content to know, except such as these, who
never think but to suspect and never suspect but to accuse, that when Gop
pleases to deal with men by his ministers, he generally condescends to treat
them according to their infirmities ; a method which hath all the marks of
highest wisdom as well as goodness. Phantasms in dreams were supersti-
tiously thought to be symbolical: Gop, therefore, when it was his good ἡ
pleasure to send dreams to Pharaoh, made the foundation of them two well-
known symbols ; and this, doubtless, in order to engage the dreamer’s more
serious attention: But then to confound the Egyptian Onirocritics, these
dreams were so circumstanced with matters foreign to the principles of
their art, that there was need of a truly divine Interpreter to decipher
them.
P. 223. OOO. But if you will believe a late writer, Animal-worship
was so far from coming from Hieroglyphics, that Hieroglyphics came out
of Animal-worship. This is an unexpected change of the scene ; but, for
our comfort, it is only the forced consequence of a false hypothesis, which
will be well considered in its place: “The hieroglyphical inscriptions of
the Egyptians” (says he) “are pretty full of the figures of birds, fishes,
beasts, and men, with a few letters sometimes between them; and this
NOTES. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 893
alone is sufficient to Aint to us, that they could not come into use before the
animals, represented in inscriptions of this sort, were become by allegory
and mythology capable of expressing various things by their having been
variously used in the ceremonies of their religion.” Connect. of the Sacred
and Profane History, vol. ii. p. 294. But if this were the case, How came
these animals to be so capable of expressing by allegory and mythology ? or
in other words, How came they to be the objects of worship? Weare yet
to seek ; and it must be more than a Aint that can supply us with a reason.
Ῥ, 226. PPP. As unanswerable a proof as this appears to be, that the
living Animal was not yet worshiped in Egypt, (for if it were, what occa-
sion for this trouble and expence?) yet a learned German, so oddly are
men’s heads sometimes framed, brings this circumstance to prove that the
living Animal was at this time worshiped in Egypt.—‘ Eadem historia
Mosaica cultus vivorum animalium in Agypto, vestigia alia non inficienda,
tum sepe alias, tum vero omnium clarissime in virULO AUREO nobis offert.”’
Jablonski, Pantheon Zgyptiorum Prolegom. p. 85.
P. 228. QQQ. Sirs, in the eastern languages, signified a swallow ; under
whose form, as this fable says, Isis concealed herself: and ΒΌΒΑΒΤΕ, which
signifies a cat, was the Egyptian name of Diana, who lay hid under that
shape. Hence the learned Bochart supposes, in his usual way, that the
original of this fable was only an equivoque of some Greek story-teller,
whose countrymen delighted in the marvellous. But 1. The fable was not
of Greek invention, if we may believe Diodorus and Lucian ; the latter of
whom, speaking of the Egyptian account of it, says, ταῦτα yap ἀμέλει ἐν
τοῖς ἀδύτοις ἀπόκειται γραφέντα, πρὶν ἢ πρὸ ἐτῶν μυρίων, de sacrificiis.
2. This only places the difficulty a step backward, without removing it :
For one might ask, How came the Egyptian name of Diana to signify a
cat ; or the word Sis or Isis to signify a swallow? Can any other good
reason be given, but that these Goddesses were expressed by such symbols
in hieroglyphic writing? Agreeably to this, Horapollo tells us [lib. i.
cap. 7. | that the hieroglyphic for the soul was a hawk, which in the Egyptian
tongue was called Baieth, a word compounded of Bai and Eth, the first of
which signified, in that language, the sow; the other the heart: for
according to the Egyptians the heart was the enclosure of the soul. But if
this were the case, what we have given above seems the more natural
original of the story.
P, 230, RRR. Lpsi, qui irridentur, Zgyptii, nullam beluam, nisi ob ali-
quam utilitatem, quam ex ea caperent, consecraverunt.—Ita concludam tamen
beluas a Barbaris propter beneficium consecratas. Nat. Deor. 1. i. ὁ. 36.
This, in the person of Cotta the academic. How ill it agrees with what the
same Cotta says afterwards, I have shewn above : “ Omne feré genus Bestia-
rum Aigyptii consecraverunt.” lib. ili. cap. 15. Now this being a fact,
and the other but a speculation, we see the reason has no weight. The
wonder is that Tully should not see it. But the notion was plausible, and
antiquity seemed enamoured of it. When Plutarch [Js. οὐ Os.] had
said, the Jews worshiped swine ; not content with this simple calumny,
he invents a reason for it ; and takes up this which lay so commodious for
these occasions ; namely, gratitude to that animal for having taught men
to plow the ground.
P. 280. SSS. <A passage in Eusebius strongly confirms our opinion of
the origin of brute-worship ; and, consequently, accounts for the adoration
paid to noxious animals : Ὃ δὲ αὐτὸς πάλιν wepl τῶν Φοινίκων στοιχείων ἐκ
τῶν Σαγχουνιαθῶνος μεταδαλὼν, Séa ὁποῖά φησι περὶ τῶν ἑρπυστικῶν καὶ ἰοξό-
Nov θηρίων, ἃ δὴ χρῆσιν μὲν ἀγαθὴν ἀνθρώποις οὐδεμίαν συντελεῖ, φθορὰν δὲ καὶ
394 THE DIVINE LEGATION ’ BOOK IV.
λύμην ols ἂν τὸν δυσαλθὴ καὶ χαλεπὸν ἰὸν ἐγχρίμψειεν ἀπεργάζεται " γράφει de
καὶ ταῦτα wpos λέξιν ὧδέ Was λέγων Τὴν μὲν οὖν τοῦ Δράκοντος φύσιν καὶ τῶν
ἤοφεων αὐτὸς ἐξεθείασεν ὁ Τάαυτος, καὶ per αὐτὸν αὖθις Φοίνικές τε καὶ Αἰγύπ-
rit. [ Pr. Evang. lib. 1. cap. 10.1 Consider again what he [Philo] says in
his translation of Sanchoniatho’s discourse of the Phoenician elements, con-
cerning certain reptiles and other venomous animals, which not only bring
no benefit to man, but convey certain mischief and destruction on whomsoever
they shed their deadly venom. These are his very words. Taautus therefore
consecrated the species of dragons and serpents, and the Phoenicians and
Egyptians followed him in this superstition. The quotation from Philo
then goes on to shew, from the nature of the serpent-kind, why it was
made a symbol of the Divinity. The discourse of Sanchoniathon here
mentioned, as translated by Philo, was part of a larger work, which he
wrote concerning the Pheenician and Egyptian wisdom and learning, and
treated of hieroglyphic characters, as appears from the title of Φοινίκων
STOIXEION, which latter word I have shewn to be the technical term for
hieroglyphics : hut how a digression concerning the consecration of noxious
animals should come into this discourse, unless the author understood Aie-
roglyphics to be the origin of brute-worship, is dificult to conceive.
P. 234. TTT. And it is remarkable that this, which was done to hide
the ignominy of vulgar Paganism, the advocates of the Church of Rome
have lately revived to hide the ignominy of vulgar Popery, in their saint-
worship : nothing having been of late more fashionable amongst the French
Philologists than the contending against that most established doctrine of
early Antiquity, that the greater Gods of Paganism were all dead men
deified. “Il soit aisé de prouver” (says one of them) “que, de tous les
Dieux du Paganisme, Hercule, Castor et Pollux sont les seuls qui aient
eté veritablement des hommes.” Hist. del Academie Royale des Inscript.
Sc. tom. xxiii. p. 17.
P. 235. UUU. Winckelman, in his Histoire de ? Art chez les Anciens,
vol. i. p. 97, says 1am mistaken, in supposing it to be made at Rome.
And that this is an opinion I have adopted without any foundation—“ il
ne paroit avoir adopté cette opinion, destituée de fondement, que parce
qu’elle cadre avec son systeme.” That I told my opinion, because it qua-
drated with my system, is certain. But that it is not without foundation
he might have understood by the very hint I gave of the devotees of Isis in
Rome. These were very numerous, and had the liberty of celebrating
their own country rites. And when they had this, it would be hard upon
them not to permit a Roman Artificer to make them one of the proper
implements of their worship, and decent furniture for their temple. The
Jews at the same time had the like indulgence in Rome, and without
doubt made the like use of it in directing Roman workmen to make them
utensils like these, once employed in their Temple worship. Now should
one of these chance to fall into the hands of an antiquarian of the size of
Winckelman, he would say they could never have been made at Rome,
but at Jerusalem, for that they were entirely different from the stile of the
Roman school. And this wise remark Winckelman makes with regard to
the Bembine Table—“les Hieroglyphes qui s’y trouvent, et qu’on ne voit
sur aucun ouvrage imité par les Romains, en prouvent l’antiquité et refutent
@avance tous les sentimens qui pourroient y étre contraires.” But after
all how does he know but that the Romans might be at one time as fond
of Egyptian Hieroglyphics as we in England (whom he says have neither
art nor taste) have lately been of Chinese filigrane ? Would he therefore,
because there is certainly as wide a difference between the Chinese and the
NOTES. — OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 395
English stile as there was between the Egyptian and the Roman, deprive
us of a fashion which we have been at so much pains to make our own?
They seem to have been fond enough of Hieroglyphics when they were at
so much cost and labour of transporting to Rome the gigantic Obelisques
covered all over with them. And though the grandees procured these for
their bulk, and not for their literature, the common people might mistake,
and grow fond of these overbearing strangers, for the sake of their imputed
learning, which they might take upon trust, and be ready to transcribe
into smaller volumes, such as the Bembine Table. In a word, the good
man, with all the advantage of eye-sight—“ je n’ai parlé,” says he, “ que de ce
que j’ai vu”—has not been able to distinguish between works which a Roman
artificer was employed to make for a Barbarian customer, and those he
made according to his own fancy, or on Grecian rules, to please the more
elegant taste of his own countrymen.
P. 240. XXX. To this I shall be bold to add one or two more: For
though Antiquity be full and clear in this matter, yet lest it should be
said, that as the Greeks talk of things done long before their time, it might
very well be that, for the credit of the God, tradition would pretend a
very early deification, how short soever, in reality, of the age of the hero ;
lest this, I say, should be objected, I shall give an instance or two of the
fact from contemporary evidence. God speaking by the Prophet to the
king of Tyre says: Thine heart is lifted up, and thou hast said, I am a God,
I sit in the seat of God in the midst of the seas ; yet thou art aman and not
God.— Wilt thou yet say before him that slayeth thee, I am a God ? but thou
shalt be a man and no God, in the hand of him that slayeth thee, Kizek. xxviii.
2—9. This I understand to denote a real worship paid to the living king
of Tyre, by his idolatrous subjects: it is not unlikely but he afterwards
became one of the Greek Neptunes. The Rabbins seem to have under-
stood the text in this sense, when, as Jerom observes, they made him to
have lived a thousand years. For the Egyptians taught (whose ceremo-
nial of the apotheosis was followed by the rest of the nations) that their
first God-Kings reigned a thousand or twelve hundred years a-piece.
Μυθολογοῦσι (says Diodorus) δὲ καὶ τῶν YeGv τοὺς ἀρχαιοτάτους βασιλεῦσαι
πλείω τῶν χιλίων καὶ διακοσίων ἐτῶν.---Ε. 15. We have already taken
notice of Odin and his early consecration. But Tacitus assures us, it
was a general custom amongst the Northern Barbarians to deify without
loss of time: and this not in jest, like their contemporary Romans. For
speaking of the German nations he says: Ha virgo [Velleda] nationis
Bructere late imperitabat: Vutrre apud Germanos Mor, quo plerasque
feminarum fatidicas, et augescente superstitione, arbitrentur pxas, lib. iv.
hist. And again of the same heroine: Vidimus pivo Vespasiano Velle-
dam, dix apud plerosque Numtnis Loco habitam. Sed et olim Auriniam,
et complures alias venerati sunt, NON ADULATIONE NEC TANQUAM FACERENT
pEAs. Here the historian hints at the mock deifications in Rome, and
insinuates, that these in Germany were of another nature, and believed
in good earnest.
P. 245. YYY. This paradox, as we say, is advanced in defiance of
Antiquity. The Mysteries, in their secret communications, taught that
ALL THE NATIONAL GODS WERE DEAD MEN DEIFIED. Of this we are assured
by the express testimony of the most learned ancients, both Gentile and
Christian ; Cicero, Julius Firmicus, Plutarch, Eusebius, Clemens Alex-
andrinus, Cyprian, and St. Austin. See the first volume of the Divine
Legation. And will this author pretend to say, that the institutors of the
Mysteries did not know the true original of their national Gods? But we
396 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
have much more than their bare testimony; almost every rite in the
ancient worship of these Gods declared them to be DEAD MoRTALS: such as
the solemn mournings and lamentations with which they began their
celebrations ; the custom of never coming to worship empty-handed, but
with a present, as was the Eastern use when they approached their
princes ; the building sumptuous houses for their Gods, and setting meat
before them for their refreshment; with a number of other domestic
usages, too tedious to dwell upon. Thus the clearest facts and most cre-
ditable testimony concur to support this notorious truth ; a truth, which
they who most eagerly defended Paganism, and they who most maliciously
undermined it ; as well the ministers of the Mysteries, as Euhemerus and
his followers, equally allowed. On what then is this author’s paradox
supported? On the common foundation of most modern philologic sys-
tems, ETYMOLOGIEsS; which, like fungous excrescencies, spring up from
old Hebrew roots, mythologically cultivated. To be let into this new
method of improving barren sense, we are to understand, that in the ancient
oriental tongues the few premitive words must needs bear many different sig-
nifications ; and the numerous derivatives be infinitely equivocal. Hence
any thing may be made of Greek proper names, by turning them to Oriental
sounds, so as to suit every system, past, present, and tocome. ΤῸ render
this familiar to the reader by example: M. Pluche’s system is, that the
Gentile Gods came from Agriculture: All he wants then, is to pick out
(consonant to the Greek proper names) Hebrew words which signify a
plow, tillage, or ears of corn ; and so his business is done. Another comes,
let it be Fourmont, and he brings news, that the Greek Gods were Moses
or Abraham ; and the same ductile sounds produce, from the same pri-
mitive words, a chief, a leader, or a true believer ; and then, to use his
words, Mier qwil s’agisse ict du seul Abraham, c’est étre aveugle d’esprit et
d’un aveuglement irremediable. A third and fourth appear upon the scene,
suppose them, Le Clere and Bannier; who, prompted by the learned
Bochart, say, that the Greek Gods were only Phenician voyagers; and
then, from the same ready sources, flow navigation, ships, and negociators.
And when any one is ata loss in this game of crambo, which can never
happen but by being duller than ordinary, the kindred dialects of the
Chaldee and Arabic lie always ready to make up their deficiencies. To
give an instance of all this in the case of poor distressed Ostris, whom
hostile Critics have driven from his family and friends, and reduced toa
mere vagabond upon earth. M. Pluche derives his name from Ochos#-erets,
domaine dela terre ; Mr. Fourmont from Hoscheiri, habitant de Seir, the
dwelling of Esau, who is his Osiris ; and Vossius from Sicher or Stor, one
of the scripture names for the Nile. I have heard of an old humourist, and a
great dealer in etymologies, who boasted, That he not only knew whence
Words came, but whither they were going. And indeed, on any system-
maker’s telling me his Scheme, I will undertake to shew whither all his
old words are going: for in strict propriety of speech they cannot be said
to be coming from, but going to some old Hebrew root.—There are certain
follies (of which this seems to be in the number) whose ridicule strikes so
strongly, that it is felt even by those who are most subject to commit
them. Who that has read M. Huet’s Demonstratio Evangelica, would have
expected to see him satirise, with so much spirit, the very nonsense with
which his own learned book abounds? “ Le veritable usage de la connois-
sance des langues étant perdu, l’abus y a succédé. On s’en est servi pour
ETYMOLOGISER—on veut trouver dans l’Hebreu et ses dialectes le source de
tous les mots et de toutes les langues, toutes les barbares et étranges
NOTES. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 397
qu’elles puissent étre—Se presente-t-il un nom de quelque Roi d’Ecosse ou
de Norvége, on se met aux champs avec ses conjectures ; on en va chercher
Yorigine dans la Palestine. A-t-on de la peine a l’y rencontrer? On passe
en Babylone. Nes’y trouve-il point, ’Arabie n’est pas loin: et en un besoin
méme on pousseroit jusqu’en Ethiopie, plutot que de se trouver court
@errymotocies: et ’on bat tant de pais qwil est impossible enfin qu’on ne
trouve un mot qui ait quelque convenance de lettres et de son avec celui,
dont on cherche l’origine-—Par cet art on trouve dans ?Hebreu ou ses
dialectes, Yorigine des noms du Roi Artur, et tous les Chevaliers de la
Table ronde ; de Charlemagne, et des douze pairs de France ; et méme en
un besoin de tous les Yneas du Perou. Par cet art, un Allemand que j’ai
connu, prouvoit que Priam avoit été le méme qu’Abraham ; et Atneas le
méme que Jonas.”—Lettre au Bochart. Onsuch subjects as these, how-
ever, this trifling can do no great harm. But when, by a strange fatality
of the times, it is transferred from matters of profane Antiquity, to such
important questions as the redemption of mankind, and faith in the Mes-
siah, we are ready to execrate a Caballistic madness which exposes our
holy religion to the scorn and derision of every unbeliever, whose bad prin-
ciples have not yet deprived him of all remains of common sense.
P. 260. ZZZ. As Sir Isaac’s own words seem so much to shake his
system, I shall quote them at length: “The lower part of Egypt being
yearly overflowed by the Nile, was scarce inhabited before the invention
of corn, which made it useful: and the king, who by this invention first
peopled it and reigned over it, perhaps the king of the city Mesir, where
Memphis was afterwards built, seems to have been worshiped by his sub-
jects after death, in the ox or calf, for this benefaction,” p. 197, 198.
P. 260. AAAA. Lapprehend such mistakes were pretty general in the
traditional accounts of nations, concerning their early times. Garcillasso’s
history of the Yncas affords us just such another instance. ‘Ils pretend-
ent” (says the French translator) “qu’un de leur Rois fut un grand
Legislateur. Us disent de plus, qu’il fut un excellent capitaine, qui conquit
un grand nombre de Provinces et de Royaumes. Mais pour le tirer de ce
Labyrinte, ils attribuent au premier Ynea tous ces choses, tant pour ce qui
est de leurs Loix, que du fondement de leur Empire.” Vol. i. p. 150.
P. 263. BBBB. Julius Cesar had so little doubt of this matter, that
speaking of the Gauls, he says, Dewm maximée Mercurium colunt—Post hunce,
Apollinem et Martem et Jovem et Minervam. De his eandem fere, quam
relique gentes, habent opinionem. De Bell. Gall. 1. vi. sect. 15. The reason
he gives is, that the several Gods of Gaul had attributes correspondent to
those of Greece and Rome. Hence he, and most other writers, concluded
them to be the same. So Tacitus observes of the Germans, that they wor-
shiped Mercury, Hercules, and Mars, “‘ deorum maxime Mercurium
eolunt—Herculem ac Martem concessis animalibus placant.” [De Mor. Ger.
c. ix.] and speaking of the Aéstii, a nation of the Suevians, he says, they
worshiped the mother of the Gods.—Ergo jam dextro Suevici maris littore
Aistiorum gentes adluuntur : quibus ritus habitusque Suevorum, lingua Bri-
tannice propior. Matrem Detm venerantur. [6. 45.] But this Mother of
the Gods was, as we learn from the ancient Northern Chronicles, an idol
peculiar to those people, called Solotta Babba, or the golden woman. Yet as
she most resembled the Mother of the Gods, she is called so by Tacitus
without any hesitation: who yet, in another place, speaking of the worship
paid to Castor and Pollux amongst this people, gives us to understand by his
expression that no more was meant than that the Germans had a couple of
Gods whose attributes and relation to one another bore a resemblance to the
908 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
Greek and Roman Dioscuri. “ Presidet sacerdos muliebri ornatu, sed Deos>
interpretatione Romana, Castorem Pollueemque memorant.” [¢. 43.] But
what greatly confirms our opinion is, that, when these people were converted
from Paganism to the Christian faith, their Convertists, who had the best
opportunities ‘and fittest occasion to enquire thoroughly into the state of
their superstition, found neither Greek nor Roman Gods amongst them ;
but Idols of their own growth only. And though, indeed, the vulgar herd
of Antiquarians, misled by the Classic writers, are wont to speak after
them, in this matter, yet the most learned investigators of the history of
this people expressly affirm the contrary. Of whom I need only mention the
celebrated Saxo Grammaticus, who says, “ Eos quia nostris colebantur non
esse quos Romanorum vetustissimi Jovem Mercuriumque dixere, vel quibus
Greci Latiumque plenum superstitionis obsequium exsolverunt, ex ipsa
liquidd feriarum appellatione colligitur.” Hist. Dan. 1. vi. But Tacitus
has recorded a circumstance which fully evinces the mistake of this sup-
posed identity. For when he had told us that the Germans worshiped
Mercury, Hercules, Mars, &c. he immediately adds, that they did not
worship their Gods in Temples, nor under a Human figure. “ Ceterum nee
cohibere parietibus deos, neque in ullam humani oris speciem assimilare ex
magnitudine ccelestium arbitrantur.” [¢. ix.] I quote the words for the
fact. The reason seems to be a conjecture of his own. Now if the Ger-
mans had borrowed their Mercury, Hercules, and Mars, from Greece and
Rome, they probably would have worshiped them in Temples; most
certainly, under a Human form. And, what is strangest of all, Tacitus
himself afterwards, in the case of the Naharvali, seems to be sensible of
this; for having told us that they worshiped two young Brother-Gods,
which the Romans conjectured to be Castor and Pollux, he makes the fol-
lowing observation, as seeming to dissent from them. “ Nulla smwuzacra,
nullum peregrine superstitionis vestigium,” ὁ. xliii.
A celebrated French author, M. Freret, has borrowed and adopted this
system. He holds with me, that the Gods of these Barbarians were not the
same with the Greek and Roman Gods ; and that the mistake arose from
the resemblance between their attributes, which he shews, in the manner I
have done (and I suppose from the observations I had made) must needs be
alike. “Chaque Dieu dans toute religion Polytheiste avoit son district, ses
occupations, son caractere, ὅθ. Le partage avoit été réglé sur les passions
et sur les besoins des hommes: et comme leurs passions et leurs besoins
sont les mémes par tout, les départemens des Dieux barbares avoient neces-
sairement du rapport avec ceux des divinités de la Gréce. 1] falloit par
tout une intelligence qui gouvernat le ciel, et qui lancat le tonnerre. Il en
falloit @autres pour gouverner les élémens, pour présider ala guerre, au
commerce, a la paix, ὅς La conformité des emplois entrainoit une res-
semblance @attributs: et ¢’étoit sur ce fondement, que les Grees et les
Romains donnoient les noms de leurs Dieux aux divinités des Bar-
bares.” —Voiez MW. de la Bleterie, ses remarques sur la Germanie de Tacit.
Ρ. 1365.
In conclusion ; the learned reader will remark, that this isa species of
that general conformity which I had observed is commonly ascribed to
imitation, when in truth its source is in our common nature, and the similar
circumstances in which the partakers of it are generally found. Here again
I have the pleasure of finding this M. Freret agree with me in this general
principle, as before in the particular system of polytheism here advanced.
“Tl seroit utile, dit M. Freret, de rassembler les conformités qui se trouvent
entre des nations qu’on sait n’avoir jamais eu de commerce ensemble. Ces
NOTES. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 399
exemples pourroient rendre les critiques un peu moins hardis ἃ supposer
qu’une nation a emprunté certains opinions et certains coutumes d’une autre
nation, dont elle étoit séparée par une tres- grande distance, et avee qui l’on
ne voit point qu’elle ait jamais eu la moindre communication.” See 77. de
la Bleterie, p. 168. and compare it with what I had said many years before
at the end of the last section of this [Vth Book. When I reflect upon the
honours of this kind, which several writers of this Awmane nation have done
me in silence, it puts me in mind of what Muret says of Macrobius on the
like occasion,—“ ut appareat eum factitasse eandem artem, quam plerique
hoe seculo faciunt, qui ita humani a se nihil alienum putant, ut alienis
eque utantur ac suis.”
P. 264. CCCC. It is remarkable, that though Herodotus tells us, these
Pelasgians, before their knowledge or admission of the Egyptian names,
sacrificed to their Gods, [Ἔθυον δὲ wavta wpérepor οἵδε Πελασγοὶ |, yet when
they had admitted these names, he gives the matter of sacrificing as one
change which this admission had introduced ; from that time, says he, they
sacrificed [ ἀπὸ μὲν δὴ τούτου τοῦ χρόνου ἔθυον]. A passage in Julius Cesar
will explain this difficulty : After he had given an account of the Gods of
the Gauls, who, living under a civil policy, worshiped Hero-gods ; he
goes on to those of the uncivilized Germans, which, he tells us, were only
the celestial Luminaries and Elements. Deorwm numero eos solos ducunt,
quos cernunt, et quorum opibus aperte juvantur ; Solem et Vulcanum et
Lunam. Reliquos ne fama quidem acceperunt. De Bell. Gall. 1. vi. sect. 19.
The very Gods, as we observed, of all the uncivilized idolaters upon earth,
Now of these Barbarians he adds, Negue Druides habent, qui rebus divinis
preesint ; neque Sacririciis stuDENT. ‘They were not nice and exact in the
matter of sacrificing: and no wonder, for he tells us, they had no Priests.
Now Herodotus, speaking of his Barbarians, informs us of the same thing,
though in other words, and on a different occasion. They sacrificed, says
he, every thing without distinction; this was the neque sacrificits student of
Cesar. But when they came to use the names of the Egyptian Gods, then
ἔθυον, they sacrificed, i.e. made a study of it, had a large Ritual concerning
it, and no longer sacrificed without distinction. For these names being
expressive of each God’s peculiar nature, qualities, and dispositions, soon
introduced a distinction of sacrifices, according to the imaginary agreement
or disagreement between the subject and the object.
P. 265. DDDD. This communication of names (from whence the men we
are arguing against inferred, that the Grecian Gods were originally Egyp-
tian) made another party, such as Bochart, Huet, and Fourmont, conclude
they were originally Jewish. Thus the last of these writers in one place
says, Par tout ce discours il est clair, que les Romains, les Grecs, les Phry-
giens, les Thraces, les Getes, les autres Scythes, et en general tous les peuples
Guerriers ont adoré Mars sans le connoitre, et que c’etoit un Dieu originaire-
ment Phenicien, comme les autres grands Dieux. | Refi. Crit. vol. i. p. 103.]
And in another place, AZais en voila assez sur ce Dieu ou Heros, qui, comme
Von voit, avoit été fort illustre SANS ETRE CoNNU. [p. 156.] For, according
to these Critics, a pagan Hero was never known till his pedigree had been
traced up into the Holy family.
P. 269. EEEE. But, besides the Greek and Egyptian, there was cer-
tainly an Indian Baccuus: whose existence and history the learned Mr.
Shuckford has well disembarrassed. I shall quote his words, and this with
more pleasure than I have yet done on most occasions. “There have been
several pers ns called by the name of Bacchus ; at least one in India, one
in @gypt, and one in Greece ; but we must not confound them one with the
400 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
other, especially when we have remarkable hints by which we may suffh-
ciently distinguish them. For, 1. The Indian Bacchus was the first and
most ancient of all that bore that name. 2. He was the first that pressed
the grape and made wine. 3. He lived in these parts before there were any
cities in India. 4. They say he was twice born, and that he was nourished
in the thigh of Jupiter. These are the particulars which the Heathen
writers give us of the Indian Bacchus; and from all these hints it must
unquestionably appear that he was Noau, and no other. Noah being the
first man in the post-diluvian world, lived early enough to be the most
ancient Bacchus; and Noah, according to Moses, was the first that made
wine. Noah lived in those parts as soon as he came out of the ark, earlier
than there were any cities built in India; and as to the last circumstance
of Bacchus being twice born, and brought forth out of the thigh of Jupiter,
Diodorus gives us an unexpected light into the true meaning of this
tradition ; he says, that Bacchus was said to be twice born, because in Deuca-
lion’s flood he was thought to have perished with the rest of the world, but Gov
brought him again as by a second nativity into the sight of men, and they say,
mythologically, that he came out of the thigh of Jupiter.’ Connection, vol. ii.
p- 49, 50.
P. 273. FFFF. Τὴν δὴ μετεξέτεροι φασὶ Ἑλλήνων “Podamos ἑταίρης
γυναικὸς εἶναι. Herod. |. ii. ο. 154. Their handle for this was a story the
Egyptian priests told of their king Cheops, the great builder of Pyramids,
That, having exhausted his revenues, he raised a new fund for his expences
by the prostitution of his pauenreR: By which the priests, in their
figurative way of recording matters, only meant, as I suppose, that he
prostituted Justice. This interpretation is much confirmed by the cha-
racter they give of his son Mycerinus, δίκας δέ oft ττάντων βασιλήων δικαι-
οτάτας κρίνειν. [See Herod. 1. ii. ο. 126, 129.] However the Greeks
took it literally.
P. 274. GGGG. Plutarch, in Theseus, tells us, that when the daughter
of Pitheus bore Theseus of Adgeus, her father gave out that the infant was
begot by Neptune.
P. 280. HHHH. That Homer collected his materials from the old
Songs and Poems of his predecessors, I conclude from this circumstance ;
In those things wherein he might be instructed by the records of poesy,
we find him calling upon the Musss to inform him: But when he relates
what happened amongst the Gods, which he could only learn by poetical
inspiration, he goes boldly into his story, without invoking the MJuses,
at all. Thus when he speaks of the squabbles between Jupiter, and his
wife Juno, he tells them with as little preparation as if they had been
his next door neighbours. But when he comes to give a catalogue of the
Grecian forces which went to the siege of Troy, the likeliest of all subjects
to be found in the old poems of his Ancestors, he invocates the Muses
in the most solemn and pompous manner: which therefore I understand as
only a more figurative intimation (to give the greater authority to what
followed), that he took his account from authentic records, and not from
uncertain tradition. And these old poems being, in his time, held sacred, as
supposed to be written by a kind of divine impulse, an invocation to them,
under the name of the Goddesses, who were said to have inspired them, was
an extreme natural and easy figure :
Ἔσπετε νῦν μοι, Μοῦσαι, ὀλύμπια δώματ᾽ ἔχουσαι"
Ὑμεῖς yap Seal ἐστε, wapeoré Te, ἴστε τε WayTaA,
Ἡμεῖς δὲ κλέος οἷον ἀκούομεν, οὐδέ τι ἴδμεν:
Οἵτινες iyyeuoves—tIA. β. ver. 484,
NOTES. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 401
“¢ Say, Virgins, seated round the throne divine,
All-knowing Goddesses ! immortal nine !
Since Earth’s wide regions, Heaven’s unmeasured height,
And Hell’s abyss hide nothing from your sight,
We wretched mortals lost in doubt below,
But guess by rumour, and but boast we know,
Oh, say what Heroes.’’—Mr. Pore.
Which, put into a plain dress, is no more than this, That as the old records of
the poets had preserved a very circumstantial account of the forces warring
before Troy, he chose rather to fetch his accounts from thence than from uncer-
tain and confused tradition.
This observation will help to explain another particular in Homer, and as
remarkable ; namely, his so frequently telling us, as he is describing
persons or things, that they bore one name amongst the Gods, and another
amongst Mortals. Which, we may now collect, means no more than that,
in those old poems, they were called differently from what they were in the
time of Homer. ‘Thus speaking of Titan he says,
"Ox Ἑκατόγχειρον καλέσασ᾽ ἐς μακρὸν “OAuutroy,
“Ov Βριάρεων καλέουσι Θεοὶ, ἄνδρες δέ τε τυάντες
Αἰγαίων᾽.-- Ιλ. a. ver. 402.
“* Then call’d by thee, the monster Titan came,
Whom Gods, Briareus, men “geon name.’’—Mr. Pore.
So again,
Ἔστι δέ τις τυροπάροιθε τσόλεως αἰπεῖα κολώνη,
Ἔν wedi ἀπάνευθε, weplipouos ἔνθα καὶ ἔνθα:
Τὴν ἦτοι ἄνδρες Βατίειαν κικλήσκουσιν,
᾿Αθάνατοι δέ τε σῆμα τσολυσκάρθμοιο Μυρίννης. IA. β. ver. 811.
“ς Amidst the plain in sight of Ilion stands
A rising mount, the work of human hands,
This for Myrinné’s Tomb th’ immortals know,
Tho’ called Bateia in the world below.’”’—Mr. Pore,
And again,
ἔΑντα δ᾽ ἄρ᾽ Ἡφαίστοιο μέγας wotauds βαθυδίνης,
Ὃν Ξάνθον καλέουσι Seol, ἄνδρες δὲ Σκάμανδρον. IA. v. ver. 73.
“ With fiery Vulcan last in battle stands
The sacred flood that rolls on golden sands ;
Xanthus his name with those of heav'nly Lirth,
But call’d Scamander by the sons of earth.’-—Mr. Pore.
Now supposing these names were not taken by Homer from the old poems,
no reasonable account can be given for his so particular an information
of this circumstance. But allow them to be taken thence, and the reason
is evident. It was to remind the reader, from time to time, that he still
kept their own venerable records in his eye ; which would give weight and
authority to what he delivered. The old names are called by Homer, the
Names used by the immortals, on these three accounts: 1. As they were the
names employed in the old sacred poems. 2. As they were in use in
the first heroic ages. And 3. As they were of barbarous and Egyptian
original ; from whence came the mythologic history of the Gods. Two
lines of the pretended Chaldaic oracles, collected by Patricius, explain this
whole matter well, as they shew the great reverence of the Ancients for the
Religion of Names :
᾿Ονόματα βάρβαρα μήποτ᾽ ἀλλάξῃς,
Εἰσὶ γὰρ ὀνόματα wap ἑκάστοις δεόσδοτα.
Never change barbarous Names ; for every nation hath Names which it
received from God.
P. 283. IIIT. The late bishop Sherlock supposed, that “the divine
original of the Law might be inferred from this prohibition of the use of
VOL. IT. DD
402 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
Cavalry: for that nothing but a divine command could have prevailed
with Moses to forbid the princes of his country the uses of Horses and Chariots
for their defence.” [Ath Dissert. p. 329. Ed. 4.] But I chuse not to insist
on this, as the use of Cavalry could not be necessary for their defence after
they were in possession of the country.
P. 288. KKKK. Τὸ is true Diodorus supposes, the principal reason was
to cover and secure the flat country from hostile incursions : τὸ δὲ μέγιστον,
πρὸς Tas τῶν πολεμίων ἐφόδους ὀχυρὰν καὶ δυσέμξολον ἐποίησε τὴν χώραν,
p- 36. But sure he hath chosen a very unlikely time for such a provision.
The return of Sesostris from the conquest of the habitable world would
hardly have been attended with apprehensions of any evil of this kind.
P. 291. LLLL. The reader may not be displeased to see Homer’s ideas
of this matter: who supposes the science of architecture to be arrived at
great perfection in the time of the Trojan war. For speaking of the habi-
tation of Paris (whom, as his great translator rightly observes, Homer
makes to be ὦ bel-esprit and a fine genius) he describes it in this manner :
Ἕκτωρ δὲ τυρὸς δώματ᾽ ᾿Αλεξάνδροιο βεβήκει
KAAA, τά ῥ᾽ αὐτὸς ἔτευξε σὺν ἀνδράσιν, οἱ τότ᾽ ΑΡΊΙΣΤΟῚΙ
Ἦσαν ἐνὶ Τροίῃ ἐριθώλακι TEKTONE® ἄνδρες,
Οἵ οἱ ἐποίησαν ΘΑΛΑΜΟΝ, καὶ ΔΩ͂ΜΑ, καὶ ΑΥ̓ΛΗΝ..---ἴλ. ¢ 518.
Here, we see a magnificent palace, built by profest architects, with all its
suits of apartments ; as different from the description of Hector’s dwelling,
as the character of the masters from one another ; of which last he only
says, it was a commodious habitation.
Aida δ᾽ ἔπειθ᾽ ἵκανε δόμους EY NAIETAONTAS
“Extopos.— Ibid. 497.
P. 299. MMMM. Inthe history of the acts of Hezekiah, king of Judah,
it is said, that, “He removed the high places, and brake the images, and
cut down the groves, and brake in pieces the brasen serpent that Moses had
made: for unto those days the children of Israel did burn incense to it :
and he called it Newusuran.” [2 Kings xviii. 4.] The historian’s care to
record the name which the king gave to the brasen serpent, when he passed
sentence upon it, will appear odd to those who do not reflect upon what
hath been said, about the superstition of NAMEs. But that will shew us the
propriety of the observation. This idol, like the rest, had doubtless its
name of honour, alluding to its sanative attributes. Good Hezekiah, there-
fore, in contempt of its title of deification, called it Nenusuran, which sig-
nifies A THING OF BRAss. And it was not out of season either to nickname
it then, or to convey the mockery to posterity: For the name of a demo-
lished God, like the shade of a deceased Hero, still walked about, and was
ready to prompt men to mischief.
P. 302. NNNN. A learned writer [Mr. Fourmont—Reflezions Cri-
tiques sur les Histoires des anciens Peuples| hath followed a system which
very well accounts for this unconquerable propensity to Egyptian supersti-
tions. He supposeth that the Egyptian, and consequently the Jewish
idolatry, consisted in the worship of the dead Patriarchs, Abraham, Isaac,
and Jacob, &c. The mischief is, that this should have the common luck
of so many other learned Systems, to have all Antiquity obstinately bent
against it. Not more so, however, than its Author is against Antiquity,
as the reader may see by the instance I am about to give him. Mr. Four-
mont, in consequence of his system, having taken it into his head, that
Cronos, in Sanchoniatho, was ABRAHAM ; notwithstanding that fragment tells
us, that Cronos rebelled against his father, and cut off his privities ; buried
his brother alive, and murdered his own son and daughter ; that he was an
NOTES. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 403
idolater ; and a propagator of idolatry, by consecrating several of his own
family ; that he gave away the kingdom of Athens to the Goddess Athena ;
and the kingdom of Egypt to the God Taaut ; notwithstanding all this, so
foreign and inconsistent with the history of Abraham, yet, because the
same fragment says, that Cronos, in the time of a plague, sacrificed his
only son to appease the shade of his murdered father; and circumcised
himself and his whole army ; on the strength of this, and two or three cold,
fanciful etymologies, this great Critic cries out, Mier qi’il s’agisse ici du
seul Abraham, ec est tre AVEUGLE D’ESPRIT, ET ΟἿΌΝ AVEUGLEMENT IRREME-
DIABLE. Liv. ii. sect. 3, ὁ. 3.
P. 309. OOOO. Fornication, adultery, whoredom, are the constant
figures under which the Holy Spirit represents the idolatries of the Israel-
ites : consequently, by this character of the Lgyptians being great of flesh,
and in another place, their flesh was as the flesh of asses, and their issue like
the issue of horses, Ezek. xxiii. 20. we are given to understand that Egypt
was the grand origin and incentive of idolatry, and the propagator of it
amongst the rest of mankind: which greatly confirms our general position
concerning the antiquity of this Empire.
P. 313. PPPP. Yet this evasive reasoning a systematic writer, who
has therefore often fallen in our way, would seem to insinuate in an argu-
ment designed to make short work with Spencer’s learned volumes. His
words are these—“It is remarkable that some learned writers, and Dr.
Spencer in particular, have imagined, that the resemblance between the
ancient Heathen Religions, and the ancient Religion which was instituted by
Gop, was in many respects so great, that they thought that Gop was pleased
to institute the one in imitation of the other. This conclusion is indeed a
very wrong one, and it is the grand mistake which runs through all the
works of the very learned author last nentioned.” ‘The ancient Heathen
Religions do indeed in many particulars agree with the institutions and
appointments of that Religion, which was appointed to Abraham and to his
Family, and which was afterwards revived by Moses; not that these were
derived from those of the Heathen nations, but much more evidently the
Heathen religions were copied from them; for there is, I think, ΟΝῈ
OBSERVATION, which, as far as I have had opportunity to apply it, will fully
answer every particular that Dr. Spencer has offered, and that is this; He
is able to produce no one ceremony or usage, practised both dz the religion
of Abraham or Moses, and in that of the Heathen nations, but that it may
be proved, that it was used by Abraham or Moses, or by some other of the
true worshippers of Gop earlier than by any of the Heathen nations,’
Sacred and Prof. Hist. Connected, vol. i. 2d ed. p. 316, 517. This writer,
we see, seems here to suppose a palpable falshood ; which is, that there is
an impalpable difference between the Mosaic and Patriarchal Religions.
But this was not the principal reason of my quoting so long a passage. It
was to consider his ONE OBSERVATION, which is to do such wonders. Now
I cannot find that it amounts to any more than this ; That the Bible, in
which is contained the account of the Jewish Religion, is a much older
book than any other that pretends to give account of the national Religions
of Paganism. But how this discredits Dr. Spencer’s opinion I cannot
understand. I can easily see indeed the advantage this learned writer
would have had over it, had there been any ancient books which delivered
the origin of Gentile religions in the same circumstantial manner that the
Bible delivers this of the Jewish ; and that, on a proper application of this
ONE OBSERVATION, it appeared that Dr. Spencer, with all his labour, was
able to produce no one ceremony or usage practised both in true and false
2 ἢ 2
404 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
religion, but that it might be proved it was used first in the true. But as
things stand at present, what is it this learned writer would be at? The
Bible is, by far, the oldest book in the world. It records the history of a
Religion given by Gop to a people who had been long held in a state of
slavery by a great and powerful empire. The ancient historians, in their
accounts of the religious rites and manners of that monarchy, deliver many
which have a surprising relation to the Jewish ritual ; and these rites,
these manners, were, they tell us, as old as the monarchy. Thus stands
the evidence on the present state of things. So that it appears, if, by ἐξ
may be proved, the learned writer means to confine his proof to contem-
porary evidence, he only tells us what the reader knew before, wiz. That
the Bible is the oldest book in the world. But if, by ἐξ may be proved, he
means proved by such arguments as the nature of the thing will admit,
then he tells us what the reader knows now to be false. Sir Isaac Newton
hath given us much the same kind of paralogism in his account of the
original letters. There ts no instance, says he, of letters for writing down
sounds being in use before the days of David in any other nation besides the
posterity of Abraham. [Chron. p. 209.] So that what hath been said above
in answer to the other will serve equally against this. I would only remark,
that the learned writer seems to have borrowed his oNE OBSERVATION from a
chapter of Witsius’s Agyptiaca, thus intitled, Nullius Historict sufficienté
Testimonio probari posse, ea que in Religione laudabilia sunt apud Algyptios,
quam apud Hebreos antiquiora fuisse, lib. iii. c. 1. to which, what I have here
said is, I think, a full answer.—The learned writer will forgive me, if, before
I leave this passage, I take notice of an expression which seems to reflect on
that good man, and sincere believer, Dr. Spencer; but I suppose not
designedly, because it seems a mere inaccuracy. The words are these :
they thought [i. 6. Dr. Spencer and others] that Gop was pleased to institute
the ope in imitation of the others. Now this neither Dr. Spencer nor any
believer ever thought. They might indeed suppose that he znstetuted one
in reference to the other, i. e. that part of its Rites were in direct opposition
to the customs of the idolaters ; and part, out of regard to the people’s pre-
judices, in conformity to such of their customs as could not be abused to
superstition. But this isa very different thing from énstituting one religion
in imitation of another. As no believer could suppose Gop did this; so
neither, I will add, could any unbeliever. For this opinion, That the
Jewish religion was instituted in imitation of the Heathen, is what induces
the unbeliever to conclude, that Gop was not its author.
P. 313. QQQQ. The parenthesis seems odd enough. It may not there-
fore be unseasonable to explain the admirable reasoning of our divine
Master on this occasion. Jesus, being charged by the Jews as a trans-
gressor of the law of Moses, for having cured a man on the sabbath-day,
thus expostulates with his accusers. ‘‘ Moses therefore gave unto you
circumcision, not because it is of Moses, but of the Fathers, [οὐχ ὅτι ἐκ τοῦ
Μωσέως, ἀλλ᾽ ἐκ τῶν πατέρων] and ye on the sabbath-day circumcise a
man. If aman on the sabbath-day receive circumcision, that the law of
Moses should not be broken, are ye angry at me, because I have made a
man every whit whole on the sabbath-day?” That is, “ Moses enjoined
you to observe the Rite of Circumcision, and to perform it on the eighth
day : but if this day happen to be on the sabbath, you interrupt its holy
rest by performing the Rite upon this day, because you will not break the
law of Moses, which marked out a day certain for this work of charity.
Are you therefore angry at me for performing a work of equal charity on
the sabbath-day? But you will ask, why was it so ordered by the Law,
NOTES. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 405
that either the precept for Circumcision, or that for the sabbatical-rest,
must needs be frequently transgressed? I answer, that though Moses, as 1
said, gave you Circumcision, yet the Rite was not originally of Moses, but
of the Fathers. Now the Fathers enjoined it to be performed on the eighth
day ; Moses enjoined the seventh day should be a day of rest; conse-
quently the day of rest and the day of Circumcision must needs frequently
fall together. Moses found Circumcision instituted by a previous covenant
which his law could not disannul.* But had he originally instituted both,
*tis probable he would have contrived that the two Laws should not have
interfered.”—This I take to be the sense of that very important paren-
thesis, not because it is of Moses, but of the Fathers.
P. 313. RRRR. No one ever yet mistook Circumcision for a natural
duty ; while it has been esteemed a kind of impiety to deny the sabbath to
be in that number. There are two circumstances attending this latter
institution, which have misled the Sabbatarians in judging of its nature.
1. The first is, that which this positive institution and a natural duty
holdin common, namely, the setting apart a certain portion of our time for
the service of Religion.—Natural reason tells us, that that Being, who gave
us all, requires a constant expression of our gratitude for the blessings he
has bestowed, which cannot be paid without some expence of time: and
this time must first be set apart before it can be used. But things of very
different natures, may hold some things in common.
2. The second circumstance is this, that Moses, the better to impress
upon the minds of his People the observance of the sabbath, acquaints
them with the early institution of it; that it was enjoined by God himself,
on his finishing the work of creation. But these Sabbatarians do not con-
sider, that it is not the time when a command was given, nor even the
author who gave it, that discover the class to which it belongs, but its
nature as discoverable by human reason. And the sabbath is as much a
positive institution when given by God to Adam and his posterity, as when
given by Moses, the messenger of God, to the Israelites and to their pos-
terity. To judge otherwise, is reducing all God’s commands to one and the
same species.
Having thus far cleared the way, I proceed to shew that the Jewish
sabbath is a mere positive institution,
1. From the account the Prophet Ezekiel gives of it—Moreover also I
gave them my ΒΑΒΒΑΤΗ, to be a siGn between me and them.t A sign of what?
A sign of a covenant. And so was circumcision called by God himself—
And ye shall circumeise the flesh of your fore-skin, and it shall be a TOKEN
[or sign] oF THE COVENANT between me and you.{ Now nothing but a Rite
by institution of a postrive Law could serve for a 8207) or token of a cove-
nant between God and a particular selected People ; for besides it’s use for
a remembrance of the covenant, it was to serve them as a partition-wall to
separate them from other nations: And this a Rite by positive institution
might well do, though used before by some other people, or even borrowed
from them. But a natural duty has no capacity of being thus employed :
because a practice observed by a// nations would obliterate every tract of a
sign or token of a covenant made with one. Indeed, where the Covenant
is with the whole race of mankind, and so, the sign of the covenant is to
serve only for a remembrance, there, the sign may be either a moral duty or
a natural phenomenon. This latter was the case in Gop’s promise or cove-
nant, not to destroy the earth any more by water. Here the Almighty,
with equal marks of wisdom, made a natural and beautiful phenomenon,
* See Gal. iii. 17. + Ezek. xx, 12. t Gen. xvii. 1].
406 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV.
seen over the whole habitable earth, the token of that covenant. -And Gop
said, This is the TOKEN OF THE COVENANT. J do ser my bow in the cloud,
and it shall be for a token of a Covenant between me and the earth, Gen. ix.
12,13. Yet it is wonderful to consider how this matter has been mistaken.
Perhaps the word se¢ did not a little contribute to it : the expression being
understood absolutely ; when it should have been taken in the relative
sense, of set for a token. And in this sense, and only in this sense, the
bow was then First set in a cloud. However, Dr. Burnet of the Charter-
house, who had a visionary theory to support, which made it necessary for
him to maintain that the phenomenon of the Rain-bow did not exist before
the flood, endeavours to countenance that fancy from the passage above, by
such a kind of reasoning as this, “‘ That, had there been a Rain-bow before
the flood, it could not have been properly used as a token of Gon’s Covenant,
that he would no more drown the earth, because, being a common appear-
ance, it would give no extraordinary assurance of security.” And to this
reasoning Tindal, the author of Christianity as old as the Creation, alludes.
Perhaps (says he) the not knowing the natural cause of the rain-bow, occa-
sioned that account we have in Genesis of its institution, page 228, 229. Its
institution! 'The expression is excellent. Gopn’s appointing the rain-bow
to be a token or memorial, for perpetual generations, of his covenant with
mankind, is called, his institution of the rain-bow. But ill expression is the
homage to nonsense, for the privilege of Freethinking. However, his
words shew, he took it for granted that Moses represents Gop as then First
setting his bow in the clouds. And it is the reasoning which we are at pre-
sent concerned with. Now this, we say, is founded in gross ignorance of
the nature of s¢mple compacts and promises: in which, the only security for
performance is the known good faith of the Promiser. But, in the case
before us, the most novel or most supernatural appearance could add
nothing to their assurance, which arose from the evidence of Gon’s veracity.
As, on the contrary, had the children of Noah been ignorant of this attri-
bute of the Deity, such an extraordinary phenomenon could have given no
assurance at all. For what then served the rain-bow? For the wise
purpose so well expressed by the sacred writer, for THE TOKEN OF THE
covENANT. That is, for a memorial or remembrance of it throughout all
generations. A method of universal practice in the contracts of all civilized
nations. Indeed, had this remnant of the human race been made acquainted
with Gon’s Covenant or promise by a third person, and in a common way,
there had then been occasion to accompany it with some extraordinary or
supernatural appearance. But for what? Not to give credit to Gon’s
veracity ; but to the veracity of the messenger who brought his Will.
Now Gop revealed this promise émmediately to the children of Noah. But
here lies the mistake : Our Deists have put themselves in the place of those
Patriarchs, when a much lower belonged to them ; and, the promise being
revealed to them only by a third hand, and in a common way, they refuse
to believe it, because not accompanied with a miracle. In the mean time
they forget the condition of the Patriarchs when this covenant was made
with them ; filled with terror and astonishment at the past, and with the
most disquieting apprehensions of a future Deluge, they needed some
superior assurance to allay their fears. Had not that been the case, a
particular Covenant had not been made with them ; and had their posterity
all along continued in the same condition, we may certainly conclude, from
the uniformity of Gov’s dealings with mankind, that he would, from time
to time, have renewed this Covenant, in the way it was first given ; or have
secured the truth of the tradition by a supernatural appearance. But those
ΝΌΤΕΒ. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 407
fears soon wore out: and Posterity, in a little time, became no more con-
cerned in this particular promise, than in all the other instances of divine
goodness to mankind. But Moses, as this great philosopher concludes, had
‘no knowledge of the natural cause of the rain-bow. It may be so: because I
know of no use that knowledge would have been to his Mission. But he
was acquainted with the moral cause, and the effects too, of COVENANTS,
which was more to the purpose of his office and character ; and which this
freethinking Docror or taws should not have been so ignorant of.
2. But secondly, if the Jewish Prophets cannot convince our Sabbata-
rians, that the Mosaic day of rest was @ positive institution ; yet methinks
the express words of Jesus might, who told the Sabbatarians of that time,
the Pharisees, That the Sabbath was made for man, and not man for the
Sabbath. Mark ii. 27. Now were the observation of the Sabbath a natural
duty, it is certain, man was made for the Sabbath, the end of. his creation
being for the observance of the Moran Law,—the worship of the Deity,
Temperance and Justice: nor can we by natural light conceive any other
end. On the contrary, all positive institutions were made for man, for the
better direction of his conduct in certain situations of life ; the observance
of which is therefore to be regulated on the end for which they were insti-
tuted: for (contrary to the nature of moral duties) the observance of them
may, in some circumstances, become hurtful to man, for whose benefit they
were instituted ; and whenever this is the case, God and nature grant a
dispensation.
3. Thirdly, the primitive Christians, on the authority of this plain decla-
ration of their blessed Master, treated the Sabbath as a positive Law, by
changing the day dedicated to the service of Religion from the seventh to
the first day, and thus abolished one positive Law, THE SaBBatu instituted
in memory of the Creation, and, by the authority of the Church, erected
another, properly called rue Lorp’s pay, in memory of the Redemption.
P. 318. SSSS. The author of the Grounds and Reasons of the Christian
Religion says—“* They [the Pagans] learnt the art [divination ] in schools,
or under discipline, as the Jews did prophesying in the Schools and Colleges
of the Prophets. [For which Wheatly’s Schools of the Prophets is quoted ]
where the learned Dodwell says, the candidates for prophecy were taught
the rules of divination practised by the Pagans, who were skilled therein,
and in possession of the art long before them.” P. 28,
P. 318. TTTT. Dr. Mead, in his Wedica Sacra, cap. iii. p. 25. observes
that what is said of the spirit of the Lord is not to be understood literally.
He did not reflect that the Vicegerent of the Theocracy is here spoken οἵ,
Otherwise, surely, he could not but acknowledge that if there was any
such thing as the sprrir or THE Lorp existing in that administration, it
must needs reside in the supreme Magistrate.
P. 319. UUUU. There is a difficulty in the history of David, in
which ΞΡΙΝΟΖΑ much exults, as it supports him in his impious undertaking
on Sacred Scripture. It is this, in the xvith chapter of the first book of
Samuel, we find David sent for to Court, to sooth Saul’s melancholy with
his harp. On his arrival, he gave so much satisfaction, that the distem-
pered Monarch sent to his father to desire he might stand before him, ver.
22. that is, remain in his service. David hath leave ; and becomes Saul’s
Armour-bearer, [ver.21.] Yet in the very next chapter, viz. the xviith
(which relates an incursion of the Philistines, and the defiance of Goliah),
when David goes to Saul for leave to accept the challenge, neither the
king, nor the captain of his host, know any thing of their champion or of
his lineage. This is the difficulty, and a great one it is. But it would
408 * THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
soon become none, in the usual way Critics have of removing difficulties,
which is by supposing, that whatever occasions them is an interpolation ;
and some blind manuscript is always at hand to support the blinder Cri-
ticism. But had more time been employed in the study of the nature of
Scripture History, and somewhat less in collations of manuscripts, those
would have found a nearer way to the wood, who now cannot see wood for
trees. In a word, the true solution seems to be this: David’s adventure
with Goliah was prior in time to his solacing Saul with his music. Which |
latter story is given by way of anticipation in chap. xvi. but very properly
and naturally. For there the historian having related at large how Gop
had rejected Saul, and anointed David, goes on, as it was a matter of high-
est moment in a RELIGIOUS HIsToRY, to inform us of the effects both of one
and the other; though we are not to suppose them the instantaneous
effects. The effect. of Saul’s rejection was, he tells us, the departure of
Gon’s spirit from him, and his being troubled with an evil spirit [ver.
14.]: this leads him, naturally, to speak of the effect of David’s election,
namely, his being endowed with many divine graces; for Saul’s malady
was only to be alleviated by David’s skill on the harp. When the histo-
rian had, in this very judicious manner, anticipated the story, he returns
from the 14th to the 28d verse of the xvith chapter, to the order of time,
in the beginning of the xviith chapter. So that the true chronology of
this part of David’s life stands thus: He is anointed by Samuel—he car-
ries provisions to his brethren, incamped against the Philistines, in the
valley of Elah—he fights and overcomes Goliah—is received into the
king’s court—contracts a friendship with Jonathan—incurs Saul’s jealousy
—retires home to his father—is, after some time, sent for back to court, to
sooth Saul’s melancholy with his harp—proves successful, and is made his
armour-bearer—and, again, excites Saul’s jealousy, who endeavours to
smite him with his javelin. This whole history is to be found between
the first verse of the xvith, and the tenth of the xviiith chapter. Within
this, is the anticipation above-mentioned, beginning at the fourteenth verse
of the xvith chapter, and ending at the twenty-third verse. Which anti-
cipated history, in order of time, comes in between the 9th and 10th verses
of the xviiith chapter, where, indeed, the breach is apparent. For in the
9th verse it is said, And Saul eyed David from that day forward. He had
just begun, as the text tells us, to entertain a jealousy of David from the
women’s saying in their songs, Saul hath slain his thousands, and David his
ten thousands.—“ From that day forward Saul eyed David,’ i. e. watched
over his conduct. Yet, in the very next verse, it says, And zt came to pass
on the Morrow, that the evil spirit from Gov came upon Saul—And David
played with his hand—And Saul cast the javelin. This could never be on
the morrow of that day on which he first began to entertain a jealousy ; for
the text says, from that day forward he began to watch over his conduct, to
find whether his jealousy was well grounded. Here then is the breach,
between which, in order of time, comes in the relation of the evil spirit’s
falling upon Saul ; his sending for David from his father’s house, &c. For
when Saul began first, on account of the songs of the women, to grow
jealous of David, and to watch his behaviour, David, uneasy in his situ-
ation, asked leave to retire; which we may suppose was easily granted.
He is sent for again to court: Saul again grows jealous: but the cause, we
are now told, was different: And Saul was afraid of David, Because the
Lord was witn wim, and was DEPARTED FROM Sauvt, ver. 12. This plainly
shews, that the departing of Gon’s spirit from Saul was after the conquest
of Goliah : consequently, that all between ver. 14 and 28 of the xvith
NOTES. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 409
chapter is an anticipation, and, in order of time, comes in between ver.
9 and 10 of the xviiith chapter, where there is a great breach discoverable
by the disjointed parts of distant time. Thus the main difficulty is mas-
tered. But there is another near as stubborn, which this solution likewise
removes. When David is recommended by the courtiers for the cure of
Saul’s disorder, he is represented as a mighty valiant man, aman of war
and prudent in matters, and that the Lord was with him, chap. xvi. 18. ἢ, e.
a soldier well versed in affairs, and successful in his undertakings. <Ac-
cordingly he is sent for ; and preferred to a place which required valour,
strength, and experience ; he is made Saul’s armour-bearer. Yet when
afterwards, according to the common chronology, he comes to fight Goliah,
he proves a raw unexperienced stripling, unused to arms, and unable to
bear them ; and, as such, déspised by the Giant. I will not mispend the
reader’s time, in reckoning up the strange and forced senses the critics
have put upon these two passages, to make them consistent ; but only
observe, that this reformation of the chronology renders all clear and easy.
David had vanquished the Philistine; was become a favourite of the
people ; and, on that account, the object of Saul’s jealousy ; to avoid the
ill effects of which, he prudently retired. During this recess, Saul was
seized with his disorder. His servants supposed it might be alleviated by
music ; Saul consents to the remedy, and orders an artist to be sought for.
They were acquainted with David’s skill on the harp, and likewise with
Saul’s indisposition towards him. It was a delicate point, which required
address ; and therefore they recommend him in this artful manner— The son
of Jesse is cunning in playing, and a mighty valiant man, and a man of war,
and prudent in matters, and a comely person :—That is, “as you must have
one constantly in attendance, both at court, and in your military expeditions,
to be always at hand on occasion, the son of Jesse will become both sta-
tions well: he will strengthen your camp, and adorn your court ; for he
is a tried soldier, and of a graceful presence. You have nothing to fear
from his ambition, for you saw with what prudence he went into volun-
tary banishment, when his popularity had incurred your displeasure.””—
Accordingly Saul is prevailed on: David is sent for, and succeeds with his
music. This dissipates all former umbrage; and, as one that was to be
ever in attendance, he is made his armour-bearer. This sunshine continued, —
till David’s great successes again awakened Saul’s jealousy ; and then the
lifted javelin was, as usual, to strike off all court-payments. Thus we see
how these difficulties are cleared up, and what light is thrown upon the
whole history by the supposition of an anticipation in the latter part of the
xvith chapter, an anticipation the most natural, proper, and necessary for
the purpose of the historian. The only reason I can conceive of its lying
so long unobserved is, that, in the xviith chapter, ver. 15. it is said, But
David went, and returned from Saul, to feed his father’s sheep at Beth-lehem.
Now this being when the Israelites were encamped in Elah against the
Philistines, and after the relation of his going to court to sooth Saul’s
troubled spirit with his music, seems to fix the date of his standing before
Saul in quality of musician in the order of time in which it is related,
But the words, David went and returned from Saul, seem not to be rightly
understood: they do not mean, David left Saul’s Court where he had
resided, but that he left Saul’s Camp to which he had been summoned.
The case was this: A sudden invasion of the Philistines had penetrated
to Shochoh, which belonged to Judah. Now on such occasions, there always
went out a general summons for all able to bear arms, to meet at an
appointed rendezvous; where a choice being made of those most fit for
410 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK IV,
service, the rest were sent back again to their several homes. To sucha
rendezvous, all the tribes at this time assembled. Amongst the men of
Beth-lehem, came Jesse and his eight sons ; the three eldest were enrolled
into the troops, and the rest sent home again. But of these, David is
only particularly named ; as the history related particularly to him. Mow
David was the son of that Ephrathite of Bethlehem-Judah, whose name was
Jesse, and he had eight sons: and the man went amongst men for an old man
in the days of Saul. And the three eldest sons of Jesse went and followed
Saul to the battlek—And David was the youngest, and the three eldest followed
Saul. But David went, and returned from Saul, to feed his father’s sheep at
Beth-lehem, i. e. he was dismissed by the captains of the host, as too young
for service. And in these sentiments, we find, they continued, when he
returned with a message from his father to the camp.—I have only to add,
that this way of anticipation is very frequent with this sacred historian.—
In the xviiith chapter, ver. 11. it is said, And Saul cast the javelin ; for
he said, I will smite David even to the wall with it: and David avoided
out of his presence Twick. But one of these times relates to a second cast-
ing of the javelin, a considerable time after the first, here spoken of, which
is recorded in chap. xix. 10. So again the historian telling us in the xth
chapter, how Saul, when he was first anointed by Samuel, prophesied
amongst the Prophets, says, And it came to pass, when all that knew him
beforetime saw, that behold, he prophesied among the prophets ; then the peo-
ple said one to another, What is this that is come unto the son of Kish? 75
Saul also among the prophets ?—Therefore it became a proverb, Is Saul also
among the prophets ? ver. 11,12. But it is evident, that the original of the
proverb, was his second prophesying amongst the prophets at Naioth, -
recorded chap. xix. both for the reasons given above, and for these: 1. Saul
was not at this time known to the people; and, 2. The original of the pro-
verb is said to arise from this second prophesying, ver. 24. Therefore the
account of the proverb in the xth chapter is given by way of anticipation.
P. 320. XXXX. <A malignant and very dull buffoon, who appears to
have had little idea of this matter, and less inclination to be better
instructed, lately published a large and virulent invective against the per-
sonal character of Davip; his pretended provocation was as extraordi-
nary; it was a pulpit parallel; of which he ironically complains, as
injurious to a modern character of great name, who is complimented with
a likeness to the King of Israek. He was answered as he deserved.—But,
if Divines think they can manage infidel cavils by the aid of sums and
systems, instead of studying to acquaint themselves with the nature and
genius of the Jewish dispensation, as it lies in the Bible, unbelievers will
have little to apprehend, how bad soever be the cause which a low vanity
has put them upon supporting.
P. 328. YYYY. There were no sort of men more averse to the system
here defended of Jewish customs borrowed from Egypt, than those Puri-
tans. Yet when they could serve a turn by adopting it, they made no
seruple of so doing. Thus, in order to disgrace the swrplice, they venture
to say, in the Declaration of the Ministers of London, published 1566, That
the surplice, or white linen garment, came from-the Ecyprtans into the Jewish
church.
P. 332. ZZZZ. For, with regard to every thing's being exactly pre-
scribed ; from which direction it was not lawful to make the least deviation,
Spencer acknowledges this as fully as Witsius himself. ‘“ Nihil enim
cultum divinum spectans verbis obscuris aut incerti sensus a Mose tradi-
tum, nil ceco vel precipiti zelo, nihil prurienti Judeorum ingenio, vel
NOTES. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 411
nature humane rerum novarum in sacris avide, relictum fuit. Nempe
lex de minimis plerisque curavit. Ipsi arce annuli, &c.” De Leg. Rit,
Heb. 1. i. c. 10. sect. 5. And it is remarkable, that he employs this very
circumstance, with great weight as well as ingenuity, to inforce the oppo-
site conclusion ; namely, that God admitted some rites in use amongst the
Gentile nations in compliance to the people’s prejudices :—“‘ Ipse ritus
Mosaicos instituendi modus huic sententie non parum presidii prebet.
Deus enim non tantum eorum materiam, sed et locum, tempus, ipsum
etiam corporis situm quandoque quo prestari debebant, aliasque minoris
not circumstantias, accurate prescripsit. Et postquam Deus minimas
quasque circumstantias rituum singulorum tradidisset, precepto cautum
est, Deut. iv. 2, ne quid e ceremoniis nempe vetitis iis adderetur ; aut
quicquam e ceremoniis nempe preceptis adimeretur. Nemo vero qui
judicio valet, opinari potest Deum horum rituum minutias accurate adeo
prescripsisse, ex ullo quo ipse eorum amore vel desiderio tangebatur. A
ratione multo minus abest, gentium et Hebreorum ritus haud paucos (si
materiam eorum vel substantiam spectemus) proximam inter se simili-
tudinem et affinitatem habuisse, rnEoquE lege curatum fuisse, ne eodem
modo peragerentur, sed ut circumstantiis quibusdam peculiaribus et a Deo
prescriptis ab invicem discernerentur. Nam Israélite ritus suos omnes e
Dei prescripto peragentes, se in Jehove [non dei alicujus ethnici 1 honorem
sacra sua prestare testarentur; et ratio temporum exegit, ut cultus Deo
prestitus quandam ἰδιότητα retineret, nec ad ritus gentium nimis accedere,
vel ab iis plusquam par erat abire videretur. Mosis etate res in loco tam
lubrico et ancipiti site sunt, quod summa tantum sapientia limites eos
definire norat, quos ultra citrave non potuit consistere Dei veri cultus.”
Lib. iii. cap. 2. sect. 1.
P. 338. AAAAA. I cannot therefore agree with Mr. Whiston in the
high value he sets upon a passage of Manetho—This (says he) és a very
valuable testimony of Manetho’s, that the laws of Osarsiph or Moses were not
in compliance with, but in opposition to, the customs of the Egyptians.
Translat. of Josephus, p. 993. However, though this fairy treasure vanish,
it is some comfort that we do not want it.
P. 351. BBBBB. That very able interpreter of Scripture, father Hou-
bigant, understands these words of the Prophet as spoken of the Jewish
Law. “Itaque in preceptis non bonis intelligende veniunt ejusmodi leges
que ad poenam proposite erant, non ad mercedem; quales erant leges de
suppliciis, de aquis ab uxore suspecte pudicitie bibendis, de leprosis ab
hominum ccetu arcendis, et aliee quedam, que ab irato Legislatore proficisci
videbantur.” Jn loc. This learned person was too well versed in the style
of Scripture, in the subject of the Prophecy, and in the history of the Jews,
to imagine, when God speaks in the character of Legislator, of giving Statutes
and Judgments, that he meant the general permission of divine Providence
to suffer a people to fall into a number of senseless and idolatrous practices.
Indeed, a little to soften the character given of Statutes not good, he sup-
poses they were thus qualified on account of their being penal Laws: and
50 makes what I understand to be a representation of the moral genius of
the ritual Law in general, only the physical quality of some particular
Rites. But the very words of the Prophecy evince that a body of laws
was meant ; and the character of the Speaker shews, that the subject is of
moral, not of physical good and evil.
P. 351. CCCCC. Speaking of Marsuam and Spencer, he says: “In
omnium nune fere eruditorum manibus versatur Nobilissimi Viri Johannis
Marshami Canon Curonicus. Opus quantivis pretii; quod uti Authori
412 THE DIVINE LEGATION ' BOOK Iv.
~
suo multa lectione, accurata meditatione, plurimisque lucubrationibus
stetit, ita Lectori per salebrosos obscurissime Antiquitatis recessus viam
non paullo faciliorem expeditioremque effecit. Sed ut in humanis rebus
nihil omni ex parte beatum esse solet, ita nec pulcherrimo huie corpori
suos deesse nevos videas—Eandem sententiam magno nuper animo atque
apparatu tuitus est Johannes Spencerus in Dissertatione de Urim et Thum-
mim. Ubi ita vir doctissimus instituit, Sc—Multa a viris doctissimis
congesta sunt, quibus huic sue assertioni fidem faciant. Ea autem quum
plurimum recondite contineant eruditionis, non videntur Clarissimi Au-
thores sua laude, uti nec studiosi lectores jucunditate atque utilitate, que
exinde percipi potest, fraudandi esse. Super omnibus denique ἐπίκρισιν
meam subjungam, eo argumentorum robore quod suscepti negotii ratio
patitur firmandam. Nequaquam ea mente ut doctissimorum virorum
laboribus detraham ; sed ut me et Lectores meos in investiganda veritate
exerceam, si forte detur curva corrigere et egregio inspersos abstergere
corpore nevos,” p.1—4. This candour was the more extraordinary, as
Sir J. Marsham had given but too many marks of disaffection to revealed
Religion. And though that great and good man Dr. Spencer was entirely
free from all reasonable suspicion of this kind ; yet, it must be owned, that
too intent on a favourite argument, he was apt to express himself somewhat
crudely. He had a bright and vigorous imagination, which, now and
then, got the better of his judgment; and the integrity of his heart made
him careless in giving it the reins ; sometimes in a dangerous road. ‘Thus,
for instance, in his fine discourse concerning Prodigies, speaking of a certain
quality in the soul, which, as he says, makes it greatly impressive to the
persuasion of parallels, equalities, similitudes, in the frame and government
of the world, he goes on in this strange manner: “ This general temper of
thé soul easily inclines it to believe great and mighty changes in states,
usher’d with the solemnity of some mighty and analogous changes in
nature, and that all terrible evils are prefac’d or attended with some prodi-
gious and amazing alterations in the creation—Hence, perhaps, it is that
we generally find great troubles and judgments on earth described, espe-
cially by persons ecstatical, Prophets and Poets (whose speeches usually
rather follow the easy sense of the soul than the rigid truth of things) by
all the examples of horror and confusion in the frame of the creation.
The prophet David describes Gon’s going out to judgment thus,” Se. p.
71, 72, 2d ed. Dr. Spencer seems to have been misled in this philosophic
solution by a greater Master, who, however, talks still more grosly of
what he seems to have understood as little. ‘‘In matters of faith and reli-
gion” (says lord Verulam) “we raise our imagination above our reason :
which is the cause why Religion sought ever access to the mind by
similitudes, types, parables, visions, dreams.” Adv. of learning, Ὁ. 2d.
The serious christian reader cannot but be offended at this injurious repre-
sentation of the holy Prophets. Such remarks as these are altogether
unworthy these two excellent men. It is false in fact that Prophetic
figures were enthusiastic or fantastic visions raised by, and then represented
to, the imagination. I have shewn that the images, which the Prophets
employed, composed the common phraseology of their times; and were
employed by them because this figurative language was well understood,
and still better relished by the People. [See p. 185, of this vol. |—But is it
therefore fitting that such writers should be treated, by every dirty scrib-—
bler, as Libertines, Deists, and secret propagators of Infidelity, for inadver-
tencies, which a man like the candid Witsius would only call nevi in
pulcherrimo corpore ?
NOTES. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 413
P. 353. DDDDD. Let me here observe how this very circumstance in
Moses’s conduct, acquits him of all suspicion of that kind of rraup so
much in use amongst the best human Lawgivers of Antiquity. The
Mosaic Dispensation had been treated by our Freethinkers with great
liberties. It was therefore offered by the late learned and ingenious Dr.
Middleton, as a means to rescue it from theingontempt, and to solve the
difficulties which attend it, without hurting the authority whereon it
stands, to suppose SOME DEGREE OF FICTION in certain cases, in the Mosaic
writings. And this he endeavoured to make credible, from the practice of
the ancient Lawgivers. Now I think this supposition neither true nor
probable. 1. If we consider what it was that induced the ancient Law-
givers to employ fiction, we shall find it arose, in part, from their false
pretences to a divine Mission ; and, in part, from the imaginary necessity
of propagating Polytheism. As to the first, Moses’s pretensions to a
divine mission are here allowed. And it is notorious that he preached up
the one true Gop, the Creator, in opposition to all kinds of Polytheism.
No occasion therefore remained for the use of fiction. And we can hardly
think he would employ it without occasion. What we have then to shew
is, that the only cause why the ancient sages employed fiction (besides the
support of a false mission) was to hide the absurdities of Polytheism.
This indeed hath been already done for other purposes, in several places of
this Work: So that I shall here confine myself to one single proof.
Macrobius assures us, that the ancient sages did not admit the fabulous in
all their disputations ; but in those only which related to the soux, to the
HEAVENLY BODIES, and to the Hrro-Gops. ‘“Sciendum est tamen non in
omnem disputationem philosophos admittere fabulosa vel licita, sed his uti
solent cum vel de anima, vel de AERIS ATHERIISVE POTESTATIBUS, vel de
CETERIS Dis loquuntur.” [in Somn. Scip. 1. i. 6. 2.] On the contrary,
when they discoursed of the Frrst causE, then every thing was delivered
exactly agreeable to the truth. ‘* Ceterum cum ad sUMMUM ET PRINCIPEM
omNtum Drum—tractatus se audet attollere—ninm, FABULOsUM penitus
attingunt.”’ [zd. 2b.] The reason of their using fictéon or fable, in treating
of their false Gods, was to hide the absurdities attendant on their Wor-
ship; a Worship thought to be necessary. Hence, as hath been shewn
elsewhere, [ vol. ii. of the Div. Leg. b. iii. sect. 6,] they were led from the
absurdity and the necessity together, to conclude that utility, and not truth,
was the end of Religion ; and from another mistake there mentioned, that
utility and truth do not coincide. From these two principles necessarily
arose a third, that it was expedient and lawful to deceive for the Public good.
And, on this last, was founded the practice of fiction above mentioned.
Now the whole Religion of Moses being established on that very doctrine,
in the handling of which the ancient Sages neither needed nor used fiction ;
and at the same time directly opposing that very superstition, for the sake
of which, the fiction was employed; we conclude, with certainty, that
Moses employed No DEGREE OF FicTION in the composition or in the pro-
pagation of the Jewish Religion. But 2. That which he had no occasion
to use, we think it impossible he should use, if his pretensions were (as is
here allowed) real. We have, indeed, in order to display the wisdom
of Gon’s Dispensation, endeavoured to shew that he employed, in the con-
trivance of it, all those arts (though in an infinitely more perfect degree)
which human Lawgivers are wont to use, in the legitimate exercise of civil
Government: for that, without forcing the Will, no other method was
sufficient to accomplish the end designed. But this, we presume, is as
different from fiction as truth is from falshood. Thus far, we think, Gon,
414 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK 1Γ.
in his dispensations to men, would chuse to do, rather than to force the
Will. But could we suppose a People, favoured with a divine Revelation,
so absurdly circumstanced as to be incapable of being worked upon by
common means, without the use of some degree of fiction, we should then
conclude Gop would rather chuse miraculously to overrule the Will:
because we conceive divine @evelation with human fiction to be a mixture of
things utterly incompatible ; that there can be no alliance between Gop
and Belial ; nor any union between the Spirit of Truth, and the Father of
Lies.
P. 358. EEEEE. “Suppose” (says Dr. Stebbing) “a Deist should
alledge that the Israelites learned this doctrine in Egypt where Moses him-
self also might have learnt it, How would you prove the contrary?” Exami-
nation, p. 33, 84.
Should a Deist allege this, as making any thing against my argument,
or for his own cause, I should say he knew as little either of one or the
other as Dr. Stebbing himself does: For my argument being addressed to
the Deist, supposes that Moses and the Israelites might have learnt the
doctrine in Egypt; and on that supposition, defies them to find a reason,
exclusive of the eatraordinary Providence, why Moses did not make so
useful and necessary a doctrine (in favour of which his People were much
prejudiced) the Sanction of his Laws. Their acquaintance with the doc-
trine in Egypt, I supposed: This acquaintance my argument required me
to suppose: and yet this Answerer of my Book knew so little of its
contents, as to ask, How I wounp PROVE THE conTRARY? If the learned
Doctor had any pertinent drift in this question, you can discover it only by
supposing him to go upon this ridiculous assumption, that what the Jews
once learned they could never either wnlearn or forget, and therefore if
they had learned the doctrine of a future state in Egypt, they could not be
so ignorant of it as, I say, they were. But to clear up his conceptions in
this matter he may have recourse, if he pleases, to the latter division of the
fifth section of the fifth Book, of the Divine Legation.
P. 355. FFFFF. This was the character it bore even so late as the
time of Jeremiah, who tells us, that the rebellious Israelites, frightened at
the power of the king of Babylon, refused to stay any longer in Judea,
saying, No, but we will go into the land of Egypt, where we shall see no war,
nor hear the sound of the trumpet, nor have hunger of bread, and there will
we dwell. chap. xlii. 14.
P. 359. GGGGG. This famous book (as is the fortune of all which
bring new proofs for Revelation in a new way) hath undergone many
heavy censures both from Jews and Christians. Those blame him for
attempting to assign reasons for the Ceremonial ordinances; These for
explaining Scripture on the principles of Aristotle. But both, as usual,
expose their own ignorance and prevention. In this work, the excellent
author studied the real honour of Gop, together with the good of those
to whom his discourse was addressed. And because its end and design
appears to be little understood, and depends on a curious piece of history,
neglected by his editors and translators, I shall give the Reader a short
account of it. In the first flourishing times of the Saracene Empire, (as
we learn from William of Paris in his book De Legibus) a great number
of Jews, devoting themselves to the study of the Aristotelian philosophy,
(then cultivated by the Arabs with a kind of scientific fanaticism) and
thereby contracting not only an inquisitive but a disputatious habit, set
themselves to examine into the REASONS OF THE JEWISH LAWS; which
being unable to discover, they too hastily concluded them to be useless,
NOTES. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 415
absurd, and of human invention ; and so apostatized, in great numbers,
from the Religion of their Fathers.—‘ Postquam autem Chaldiis sive
Babyloniis et genti Arabum commixti sunt, et miscuerunt se studiis eorum
et philosophie ; et secuti sunt opiniones philosophorum ; nescientes legis
sue credulitates et Abrahe fidem contra disputationes eorum et rationes
defendere: hine est quod facti sunt in lege erronei, et in fide ipsius
Abrahe heretici ; maxime postquam regnum Saracenorum diffusum est
super habitationem eorum, Exinde enim eternitatem mundi et alios
Aristotelis errores secuti sunt multi eorum. Hincque pauci veri Judei
(hoc est, qui non in parte aliqua credulitatis sue Saraceni sunt, aut
Aristotelicis consentientes erroribus) in. terra Saracenorum inveniuntur,
de his qui inter philosophos commorantur. Dedit enim occasionem
non levem apostasic hujusmodi ea que videtur multorum mandatorum
absurditas vel inutilitas: dum enim apparet in eis absurditas et inutilitas,
nulla autem preceptionis aut inhibitionis earum ratio, nulla observanti-
arum utilitas, non est mirum si ab eis receditur : sed tanquam onera super-
vacanea projiciuntur.” fol. 18. In these times and under this Empire, our
Author wrote. So that nothing could be more useful than to shew his
apostatizing brethren that the Scriprures might be defended, nay, even
explained on the principles of Aristrorne, and that the precepts of the
CEREMONIAL Law were founded in the highest reasonableness and conve-
nience—Maimonides, where, in his preface, he gives his reasons for writing
this discourse, plainly hints at that apostasy—Vertiginosos vero quod atti-
net, quorum cerebrum est pollutum et vanis futilibusque ac falsis opinionibus
repletum, quique sibi imaginantur se magnos esse PHILOSOPHOS, ac theologos,
tllos scio fugituros a multis, contra multa etiam objectiones moturos.—Deus
vero benedictus novit, quantoperé timuerim conscribere ea, que explicare et
consignare volut in hoc libro. Nam quia talia sunt de quibus nullus ex gente
nostra in hac captivitate quicquam scripsit hactenus, qua ratione primus ego
prodire in hac palestra audeo? Verum suffultus sum duobus principiis ;
primo, quod de istius modi negotio dictum sit, Tempus est faciendi Domino:
IRRITAM FECERUNT LEGEM TUAM, Sc. secundo, eo quod sapientes nostri dicunt,
Omnia opera tua fiant ad gloriam Dei.
P. 360. HHHHH. The learned author of the elegant and useful Letter
from Rome has here taken to himself what was meant in general of the
numerous writers on the same subject ; and so has done it the honour of a
confutation, in a postscript to the last edition of that Letter. But the same
friendly considerations which induced him to end the postscript with
declaring his unwillingness to enter further into controversy with me,
disposed me not to enter into it at all. This, and neither any neglect of
him, nor any force I apprehended in his arguments, kept me silent. How-
ever, I owe so much both to myself and the public, as to take notice of a
misrepresentation of my argument; and a change of the question in dis-
pute between us: without which notice the controversy (as I agree to
leave it where it is) can scarce be fairly estimated.—* A paragraph in Mr.
Warburton’s Divine Legation of Moses obliges me” (says Dr. Middleton)
“to detain the reader a little longer, in order to obviate the prejudices
which the authority of so celebrated a writer may probably inject, to the
disadvantage of my argument.—I am at a loss to conceive what could move
my learned friend to pass so severe a censure upon an argument which has
hitherto been espoused by all protestants ; admitted by many papists ; and
evaded rather than contradicted by any. But whatever was his motive,
which, I persuade myself, was no unfriendly one, he will certainly pardon
me, if, pursuing the full conviction of my mind, I attempt to defend an
410 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Iv.
established principle, confirmed by strong and numerous facts, against an
opinion wholly new and strange to me; and which, if it can be supposed
to have any force, overthrows the whole credit and use of my present
work.—He allows that the writers, who have undertaken to deduce the
rites of popery from paganism, have shewn an exact and surprising likeness
between them in a great variety of instances. This” (says he) “one would.
think, is allowing every thing that the cause demands: it is every thing,
I dare say, that those writers desire.” * That it is every thing those writers
desire, I can easily believe, since I see, my learned friend himself hath consi-
dered these two assertions, 1. The religion of the present Romans derived from
that of their Heathen ancestors ; and, 2. An exact conformity, or uniformity
rather of worship between popery and paganism: He hath considered them,
I say, as convertible propositions: for, undertaking, as. his title-page
informs us, to prove the religion of the present Romans derived from that
of their Heathen ancestors ; and having gone through his arguments, he
econcludes them in these words, “ But it is high time for me to conclude,
being persuaded, if I do not flatter myself too much, that I have suff-
ciently made good WHAT I FIRST UNDERTOOK TO PROVE, an exact con-
formity, or uniformity rather, of. worship between popery and pagan-
ism.” t But what he undertook to prove, we see, was, The religion of the
present Romans derived from their Heathen ancestors: That I have there-
fore, as my learned friend observes, allowed every thing those writers desire,
is very likely. But then whether I have allowed every thing that the cause
demands, is another question: which I think can never be determined in
the affirmative, till it be shewn that no other probable cause can be
assigned of this exact conformity between Papists and Pagans, but a borrow-
ing or derivation from one to the other. And I guess, that now this is
never likely to be done, since I myself have actually assigned another
probable cause, namely, the same spirit of superstition operating in the like
circumstances.
But this justly celebrated writer: goes on—“ This question according to
his [the author of The Divine Legation] notion is not to be decided by
facts, but by a principle of a different kind, @ superior knowledge of human
nature.” {+ Here I am forced to complain of a want of candour, a want
not natural to my learned friend. For, whence is it, I would ask, that he
collects, that, according to my notion, this question is not to be decided by
Facts, but a superior knowledge of human nature? From any thing I have
said? Or from any thing I have omitted to say? Surely, not from any
thing I have said (though he seems to insinuate so much by putting the
words ὦ superior knowledge of human nature in Italic characters as they are
called) because I leave him in possession of his facts, and give them all the
validity he desires; which he himself observes; and, from thence, as we
see, endeavours to draw some advantage to his hypothesis :—Nor from any
thing I have omitted to say ; for, in this short paragraph where I deliver
my opinion, and, by reason of its evidence, offer but one single argument
in its support, that argument arises from a Fact, viz. that the superstitious
customs in question were many ages later than the conversion of the imperial
city to the Christian faith: whence I conclude, that the ruling Churchmen
could have no motive in borrowing from Pagan customs, either as those
customs were then fashionable in themselves, or respectable for the num-
ber or quality of their followers. And what makes this the more extra-
ordinary is, that my learned friend himself immediately afterwards quotes
these words ; and then tells the reader, that my argument consists of an
* Postscript, p. 228. + Letter, p. 224. { Postscript, p. 228.
NOTES. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 417
HISTORICAL FACT, and of a consequence deduced from it. It appears there-
fore, that, according to my notion, the question és to be decided by facts,
and not by a superior knowledge of human nature. Yet I must confess I
then thought, and do so still, that a superior knowledge of human nature
would do no harm, as it might enable men to judge better of facts than we
find they are generally accustomed to do. But will this excuse a candid
representer for saying, that the guestion, according to my notion, was not to be
decided by facts, but a superior knowledge of human nature? However, to
do my learned friend all justice, I must needs say, that, as if these were
only words of course, that is, words of controversy, he goes on, through
the body of his postscript, to invalidate my argument from fact ; and we
hear no more of a superior knowledge of human nature than in this place
where it was brought in to be laughed at.
As to the argument, it must even shift for itself. It has done more
mischief already than I was aware of: and forced my learned friend to
extend his charge from the modern to the ancient church of Rome. For my
argument, from the low birth of the superstitions in question, coming
against his hypothesis, after he had once and again declared the purpose of
his letter to be the exposing of the Heathenish idolatry and superstition
of the present church of Rome; he was obliged, in support of that hypo-
thesis, to shew that even the early ages of the church were not free from
the infection. Which hath now quite shifted the subject with the scene,
and will make the argument of his piece from henceforth to run thus,
The religion of the present Romans derived from their early Christian
ancestors ; and theirs, from the neighbouring Pagans. To speak freely, my
reasoning (which was an argument ad hominem, and, as such, I thought,
would have been reverenced) reduced the learned writer to this dilemma ;
either to allow the fact, and give up his hypothesis ; or to deny the faet,
and change his question. And he has chosen the latter as the lesser
evil. As to the fact; that the Churches of the first ages might do
that on their own heads, which Moses did upon authority, i. e. indulge
their Pagan converts with such of their customs as could not be easily
abused to superstition, may be safely acknowledged. My learned friend
has produced a few instances of such indulgence, which the censure of
some of the more scrupulous of those times hath brought to our know-
ledge. But the great farraginous body of Popish rites and ceremonies, the
subject of my learned friend’s Letter from Rome, had surely a different
original. They were brought into the Church when Paganism was in
part abhorred and in part forgotten; and when the same spirit of sordid
superstition which had overspread the Gentil: world, had now deeply
infected the Christian.
VOL, 11, EE
THE
DIVINE LEGATION OF MOSES
DEMONSTRATED.
BOOK V.
SECTION I.
HavinG now examined the cuaracter of the Jewish People, and
the TALENTS of their Lawgiver, I come next to consider the NATURE
of that Policy, which by his ministry was introduced amongst them.
For in these two enquiries I hope to lay a strong and lasting founda-
tion for the support of the third general proposition, That the doc-
trine of a future state of rewards and punishments is not to be found
in, nor did make part of the Mosaic Dispensation.
We find amongst this people a Policy differing from all the Institu-
tions of mankind; in which the two Societies, civil and religious,
were perfectly incorporated, with Gop ALMIGHTY, AS A TEMPORAL
Governor, at the head of both.
The peculiar administration attending so singular a frame of Govern-
ment hath always kept it from the knowledge of superficial observers.
Christian writers, by considering Judaism as a Religious policy only,
or a Church ; and Deists, as a Civil policy only, or a State; have run
into infinite mistakes concerning the reason, the nature, and the end
of its laws and institutions. And, on so partial a view of it, no won-
der that neither have done justice to this amazing (iconomy. Let
us suppose, the famous picture of the female centaur by Zeuxis, where
two different Natures were so admirably incorporated, that the passage
from one to the other, as Lucian tells us,* became insensible ; let us,
I say, suppose this picture to have been placed before two com-
petent judges, yet in such different points of view, that the one could
see only the brutal, the other the human part; would not the first
have thought it a beautiful horse, and the second, as beautiful a
* τὴν ϑήλειαν δὲ ἵππου ye τῆς καλλίστης, οἷαι μάλιστα al Θετταλαί εἰσιν, ἀδμῆτες,
ἔτι καὶ ἄδατοι: τὸ δ᾽ ἄνω ἡμίτομον, γυναικὸς, πσάγκαλον,--- καὶ ἡ μίξις δὲ, καὶ ἡ ἁρμογὴ
τῶν σωμάτων, καθὸ συνάπτεται καὶ συνδεῖται τῷ γυναικείῳ τὸ ἱππικὸν, ἠρέμα, καὶ οὐκ
ἀθρόως μεταβαίνουσα, καὶ ἐκ τσροσαγωγῆς τρεπομένη, λανθάνει τὴν ὄψιν ἐκ ϑατέρου, εἰς
τὸ ἕτερον ὑπαγομένη.--- Ζοιωνῖδ, cap. vi. tom. i. p. $43, edit, Reitzii, Amst. 4to, 1748.
THE DIVINE LEGATION OF MOSES. 419
woman ; and would not each have given the creature supposed to be
represented such functions as he judged proper to the species in
which he ranked it? But would not both of them have been mis-
taken ; and would not a sight of the whole have taught them to rec-
tify their wrong judgments? as well knowing that the functions of
such a compounded animal, whenever it existed, must be very dif-
ferent from those of either of the other, singly and alone. From such
partial judges of the Law therefore, little assistance is to be expected
towards the discovery of its true nature.
Much less are we to expect from the Jewish Doctors: who, though
they still keep sheltered, as it were, in the ruins of this august and
awful Fabric ; yet patch it up with the same barbarity of taste, and
impotence of science, that the present Greeks are wont to hide them-
selves amongst the mouldering monuments of Attic power and polite-
ness. Who, as our travellers inform us, take a beggarly pride in
keeping up their claim to these wonders of their Ancestors’ magnifi-
cence, by white-washing the Parian marble with chalk, and incrusting
the porphyry and granate with tiles and potsherds.
But least of all shall we receive light from the fantastic visions of
our English Cocceians ; ** who have sublimed the crude nonsense of
the Cabalists, so long buried in the dull amusement of picking Mys-
teries out of letters, into a more spiritual kind of folly ; a quintes-
sence well defecated from all the impurities of sense and meaning.
Therefore, to understand the nature of the Jewish Giconomy, we
must begin with this truth, to which every page of the five books of
Moses is ready to bear witness, That the separation of the Israelites |
was in order to preserve the doctrine of the unity, amidst un idola-
tfrous and polytheistic World. The necessity of this provision shall
be shewn at large hereafter.} At present we only desire the Deist
would be so civil as to suppose there might possibly be a sufficient
cause.
But now, because it is equally true, that this separation was fulfill-
ing the promise made to Asrawam their Father; these men have ἡ
taken occasion to represent it as made for the sake of a FAVOURITE
peopLe.t And then again, supposing such a partial distinction to
be inconsistent with the divine ἀμ σιρ μία, have ventured to arraign
the Law itself of imposture.
But this representation of the fact is both unjust and absurd.
They cannot deny but it might be Gop’s purpose, at least, that it
became his goodness, to preserve the doctrine of the uniry amidst an
idolatrous world. But this (we know by the event) could never be
effected but by a separation of one part from the rest. Nor could
* The followers of Hutchinson. + In the ninth book. 1 See the first
volume of ‘the Divine Legation.”
420 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK V.
such a separation be made any otherwise than by bringing that part
under Gop’s peculiar protection: The consequence of which were
GREAT TEMPORAL BLESSINGS. Now as some one People must needs
be selected for this purpose, it seems most agreeable to our ideas of
divine Wisdom, which commonly effects many ends by the same
means, to make the Glessings attendant on such a selection, the reward
of some high exalted virtue in the progenitors of the chosen People.
But therefore to object that they were chosen as FAVOURITES, is both
unjust and absurd. The separation was made for the sake of Man-
kind in general ; though one People became the honoured instrument,
in reward of their Forefathers’ virtues. And this is the language of
those very Scriptures which, as they pretend, furnish the objection.
Where God, by the Prophet Ezekiel, promises to restore the Israel-
ites, after a short dispersion through the Countries, to their own land,
he declares this to be the end of their separation: ‘Therefore say
unto the house of Israel, Thus saith the Lorp Gop, I po NoT THIS
FOR YOUR SAKES, O HOUSE OF ISRAEL, BUT FOR MINE HOLY
NAME’S SAKE, which ye have profaned among the heathen, whither
ye went. And I will sanctify my great name which was profaned
amongst the heathen, which ye have profaned in the midst of
them ; and the heathen shall know that I am the Lorp, saith
the Lorp Gop, when I shall be sanctified in you before their
eyes.” * What Gop himself says of the prope, St. Paul
says of their Law: ‘ Wherefore then serveth the Law? Ir was
ADDED BECAUSE OF TRANSGRESSIONS; till the seed should come,
to whom the promise was made.” + It was added, says the Apostle.
To what? To the patriarchal Religion of the uniry.{ To what
end? Because of transgressions, i.e. the transgressions of polytheism
and idolatry ; into which, the rest of mankind were already absorbed,
and the Jews at that time, hastening apace; and from which, there
was no other means of restraining them, than by this ADDITION; an
addition that kept them separate from all others, and preserved the
doctrine of the Unriry till the coming of the promised seed.
But another thing offends the Deists: they cannot understand, let
the end of this choice be what it would, why Gop should prefer so
perverse and sottish a People, to all others. One reason hath been
given already ; that it was for the sake of their Forefathers, and to ful-
fill the promise made to the Patriarchs. But others are not wanting;
and those very agreeable to the ideas we have of infinite Wisdom ;
such, for instance, as this, That the EXTRAORDINARY PROVIDENCE,
by which they were blessed and protected, might become the
more visible and illustrious. For had they been endowed with the
* Ezek. xxxvi. 22, 23, + Gal. iii. 19. t See note A, at the end of this
book.
SECT. I. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 421
shining qualities of the more polished nations, the effects of that pro-
vidence might have been ascribed to their own power or wisdom.
Their impotence and inability, when left to themselves, is finely
represented in the Prophet Ezekiel, by the similitude of the vine-tree :
Son of man, what is the vine-tree more than any tree, or than a
branch which is amongst the trees of the forest ? Shall wood be taken
thereof to do any work ? or will men take a pin of it to hang any
vessel thereon ?—Therefore thus saith the Lord God, As the vine-tree
amongst the trees of the forest,’ §c.* For as the vine, which, with
cultivation and support, is the most valuable of all trees, becomes the
most worthless, when left neglected in its own natural state: so the
Jews, who made so superior a figure under the particular protection
of Gop, when, for their sins, that protection was withdrawn, became
the weakest and most contemptible of all tributary nations.
The Poet Vorrairr indeed has had a different revelation. ‘ The
pride of every individual amongst the Jews” (says he) ‘is interested
in believing, that it was not their DETESTABLE POLICY, their igno-
rance in the arts, and their unpoliteness, which destroyed them ; but
that it is Gon’s anger which yet pursues them for their idolatries.”’ +
This DETESTABLE POLicy (for so, with the free insolence of impiety,
characteristic of these times, he calls the MOSAIC INSTITUTION) was
a principle of independency : this ignorance in the arts prevented the
entrance of luxury; and this wnpoliteness hindered the practice of it.
And yet parsimony, frugality, and a spirit of liberty, which naturally
preserve other States, all tended, in the ideas of this wonderful Politi-
cian, to destroy the Jewish. Egypt was long lost for want of a spirit
of independency ; Greek sunk by its knowledge in the arts ; and Rome
was ruined by its politeness: yet Judeea suffered for the want of all
these causes of destruction. Is not this more than a thousand topical
arguments, to prove, that they were ruined by nothing but by their
idolatries, which brought down Gon’s vengeance upon them? But any
contrivance will serve a Poet, any argument will satisfy a Freethinker,
to keep a Gop and his providence at a distance. And that the Pro.
PLE were aS DETESTABLE as their Poticy, the same Poet, the virtu-
ous Voltaire assures us—‘‘ We do not find” (says he) ‘throughout
the whole annals of the Hesrew PEOPLE one generous action.
They are utter strangers both to hospitality, to beneficence, and to
clemency. Their sovereign-good is the practice of Usury, with all
but their own nation. And this disposition, the principle of all
baseness, is so inrooted in their hearts, that Usury is the constant
object of the figures they employ in that species of eloquence which
* Ezek. xv. 2, 3,6. + L’orgueil de chaque Juif est intéressé a croire que ce n’est
point sa DETESTABLE POLITIQUE, son ignorance des arts, sa grossiereté, qui l’a perdu ;
mais que c’est la colere de Dieu qui le punit.”—Rem. ir. sur les Pensées de Pascal.
422 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK V.
is peculiar to them. Their glory is to lay waste with fire and sword,
such paltry villages as they were just able to storm: They cut the
throats of the old men and children, and reserve from slaughter only
the marriageable virgins. They assassinate their masters when they are
slaves. They are incapable of pardoning when they conquer. THEY
ARE THE FOES OF ALL MANKIND.” *
Such is the strong colouring of our MoRAL PAINTER. He has
dipt his pencil in sulphur to delineate with horns and tails, these
chosen instruments of God’s vengeance on a devoted Nation, overrun
with UNNATURAL LusT and brutish Idolatry ; for to their destruc-
tion, the murders, the rapine, and the violations here charged upon
the Hebrew People, allude. For the rest, it is so much below all
criticism, that one is almost ashamed to touch upon it. Otherwise,
we might observe, that, in his rage, he hath confounded the character
of the ancient Hesprews with that of the modern Jews, two people
as much unlike as the ancient Franks to modern Frenchmen.—We
might be merry with the nonsense, of Usury’s being the object of their
Jigures of eloquence ; which yet is not more ridiculous in the thought
than absurd in the expression: his meaning, I suppose, being, that
their figures of eloquence are formed from, and alluded to, the cir-
cumstances attending their practice of Usury.
But the affair grows more serious, as we proceed with our General
Historian ; and we shall find that this unhappy People, however they
may stand with their God. certainly, at present, for some reason or
other, lye under the Poe?’s curse. And from his uncommon know-
ledge of their Usury and their eloquence, I should suspect, he had
lately been transacting some money-matters with them, and had been
not only out-witted but out-talked too into the bargain.
As to their HATRED OF ALL MANKIND, (the chopping-block of
infidelity) we have it over again, and more at large, in another place.
*“ You are” (says he to his reader) “struck with that hatred and con-
tempt, which all people have always entertained for the Jewish
Nation. It is the unavoidable consequence of THEIR LEGISLATION ;
which reduced things to the necessity, that either the Jews must
enslave the whole world, or that they, in their turn, must be crushed
and destroyed. Ir was coMMANDED THEM to hold all other People
in abhorrence, and to think themselves polluted if they had eat in the
* “On ne voit dans toutes les Annales du peuple Hebreu aucune action généreuse.
Ils ne connaissent ni |’ hospitalité, ni la liberalité, ni la clémence. Leur souverain
bonheur est d’exercer I’usure avec les étrangers; et cet esprit de l’usure, principe de
toute lacheté, est tellement enraciné dans leurs ceurs, que c’est l’object continuel des
figures, qu’ils employent dans l’espece d’eloquence, qui leur est propre. Leur gloire est
de mettre ἃ feu et A sang les petits villages, dont ils peuvent s’emparer. Ils égorgent
les vieillards et les enfans; ils ne réservent que les filles nubiles; ils assassinent leurs
Maitres quand ils sont esclaves; ils ne savent jamais pardonner quand ils sont Vain-
al ILS SONT LES ENNEMIS DU GENRE HUMAIN.’’—Addit. ἃ I Hist. Generale,
p- 30.
SECT. f. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 425
same dish which belonged to a man of another religion. By THE
VERY LAW ITSELF, they at length found themselves the natural
enemies of THE WHOLE RACE OF MANKIND.” *
I believe it will not be easy to find, even in the dirtiest sink of
Freethinking, so much falshood, absurdity, and malice heaped toge-
ther in so few words. He says, There was an inevitable necessity,
arising from the very genius of the Law itself, either that this people
should enslave the whole world, or that they, in their turn, should be
erushed and destroyed.
It might be thought unreasonable to expect that a Poet should read
his Bible: but one might be allowed to suppose that he had heard at
least of its general contents. If he ever had, could lie, unmasked,
and in the face of the sun, have said, ‘‘ That the Mosaic LAW
directed or encouraged the Jewish people to attempt extensive con-
quests?”’ That very Law, which not only assigned a peculiar and
narrow district for the abode of its followers; but, by a number of
Institutions, actually confined them within those limits: Such as the
stated division of the land to each Tribe ; the prohibition of the use
of horses; the distinction of meats into clean and unclean; the
yearly visit of each individual to Jerusalem, with many others. The
Poet, who appears throughout his whole history to be a much better
Mussulman than a Christian, was surely, when he said this, in some
pious meditation on the ALcoraNn; which indeed, by the imevitable
consequence of its Legislation, must either set the Saracens upon
enslaving all mankind, or all mankind on extirpating so pernicious a
crew of miscreants.
But the Jews, he tells us, were COMMANDED fo hold all other
People in abhorrence. If he had said, to hold their IDOLATRIES in
abhorrence, he had said ¢rue ; but that was saying nothing. To tell
the world that the Jews were commanded to hold the Persons of
Idolaters in abhorrence, was done like a Poet.
But when he goes on to say, that The Jews found, BY THE VERY
CONSTITUTION OF THE LAw ITSELF, that they were the NATURAL
ENEMIES Of all mankind, this was not like a Poet, being indeed a
transgression of the PROBABLE; for by the constitution of the Law
itself, every Jew that could read, found all mankind to be his
BRETHREN. For Moses, to prevent any such estrangement, which
some other parts of his Institution, if abused, might occasion, was
careful to acquaint the chosen Family with the origin of the human
* <¢Vous étes frappés de cette haine et de ce mepris que toutes les nations ont tou-
jours eu pour la Nation Juive. C’est la suite inevitable de LEUR LEGISLATION ; il
falloit, ou que ce Peuple subjuguat tont, ou 40] fit ecrasé. 11 lui fut ordonné d’avoir
les nations en horreur, et de se croire souillés s’ils avaient mangé dans un plat, qui etit
appartenu A un homme d’une autre Loi—ils se trouvéerent PAR LEUR LOI MEME enfin
Ennemis naturels du GENRE HUMAIN.”—<ddd. ἃ I’ Hist. Generale, p. 174.
424 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK V.
race,‘and of their descent from one man and woman; and, in order
to impress this salutary truth more strongly on their minds, he draws
out an exact genealogy from Adam, not only of the direct line which
was to inhabit the land of Judea, but of all the collateral branches
by which the whole earth was peopled.
So that were our Poet to turn Lawgiver, (which he might as well
do, as GENERAL HISTORIAN) and sit down to contrive a method by
which brotherly love and affection might be best established amongst
the sons of men, one might defy him, with all his poetical or histo-
rical invention, to hit upon any more efficacious than that which
Moses has here employed. St. Paul, when he would enlarge the
affections of the Athenians (to whom all other nations, as well as the
Jews, were become BARBARIANS) to that extent which Christian
benevolence requires, employed no other topic than this, that Gop
HAD MADE OF ONE BLOOD ALL NATIONS OF MEN: and from
thence inferred, that they all stand in the relation of BRETHREN to
one another. ἱ
But it may be asked, What are we then to think of that oprum
HUMANI GENERIS, with which the ancient Pagans charged the Jews ?
I have shewn, in the first volume of this work, that there was not
the least shadow from fact to support this calumny ; and that it was
merely an imaginary consequence, which they drew from the others’
declared hate and abhorrence of the Idols of Paganism, and firm
adherence to the sole worship of the one true God. But besides this
original, the Principles and Doctrine, there was another, the Rites
and Ceremonies of the Mosaic Religion; either of them sufficient
alone to perpetuate this wretched calumny amongst ignorant and
prejudiced men, That the Doctrine was worthy of its original, the
enemies of Revelation confess ; That the establishment of the Cere-
monies, as they were necessary to support the Doctrine, were of no
less importance, I shall now shew our Poet.
To separate one people from all others, in order, to preserve the
doctrine of the Unity, was a just purpose.
No separation could be made but by a ceremonial Law.
No ceremonial Law could be established for this purpose, but
what must make the Gentiles be esteemed unclean by the separated
People.
The consequence of an estimated wncleanness, must be the avoiding
it with horror: which, when observed by their enemies, would be
maliciously represented to arise from this imaginary odium humani
generis, What idea then must we needs entertain, I will not say of
the Religion, but of the common honesty of a modern Writer, who,
without the least knowledge of the Jewish Nation or their Policy, can
repeat an old exploded calumny with the assurance of one who had
SECT, I. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 425
discovered a newly acknowledged truth? But the Pagans were
decent when compared to this rude Libertine. They never had the
insolence to say, that this pretended hate of all mankind was com-
MANDED BY THE LAW ITSELF. They had more sense as well as
modesty. They reverenced the great Jewish Lawgiver, who, they
saw, by his account of the origin of the human race, had laid the
strongest foundation amongst his people of brotherly love to all men.
A foundation, which not one of the most celebrated Lawgivers of
Antiquity had either the wit to enforce, or the sagacity to discover.
Well, but if the Jews were indeed that DETESTABLE People which
the Poet Voltaire represents them to be, they were properly fitted
however with a Law, which, he assures us, was full as DETESTABLE.
What pity is it that he did not know just so much of his Bible
however, as might serve to give some small countenance at least to
his impieties!] We might then have had the Prophet to support the
Poet, where, speaking in the name of God, he says,— I gave them
Statutes that were not good, and Judgments whereby they should not
live.* But to leave this to his maturer projects; and go on with
him, in his pious design of eradicating this devoted People; for he
assures us, we see, that unless they be rooted out, their DETESTABLE
POLICY will set them upon enslaving all mankind.
He hath shewn the Peor.e to be detestable, and their Law to be
detestable ; and well has he provided for the reception of both, a
most detestable country. You may, if you please, suppose all this
done in vindication of the good providence of the God of Israel ; for a
People so bad, certainly deserved neither a better Government nor Habi-
tation. No, he had a nobler end than this ; it was to give the lye to
the Legate of the God of Israel, who promised to them in his Mas-
ter’s name, 4 land flowing with milk and honey, the glory of all lands.
Having gotten Moses at this advantage, by the assistance of Servetus
and his followers, (for he always speaks from good authority) he
draws this delightful picture of the Hoty Lanp.—“ All of it which
is situated towards the south, consists of DESERTS OF SALT SANDS
on the side of the Mediterranean and Egypt; and of HorRRID
MOUNTAINS all the way to Esiongaber, towards the Red-Sea. These
sands, and these rocks, at present possessed by a few straggling
Arabian Robbers, were the ancient patrimony of the Jews.” +
Now admitting this account ,to be true: 1. In the first place, we
may inform our Poet, that, from the face of a country lying desert,
there is no safe judgment to be made of the degree of its fertility
* Ezekiel. See book iv. sect. vi. p. 335, δέ seq. + “Tout ce qui est situé vers
le midi consiste en desertes de sables salés du coté de la Mediterranée et de I’ Egypte,
et en montagnes affreuses jusqu’ ἃ Esiongaber vers la Mer Rouge. Ces sables et ces
rochers, habités aujourd’hui par quelques Arabes Voleurs, sont l’ancienne patrie des
Juifs.”’—ddd, a i’ Hist. Generale, p. 83.
420 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Vv.
when well cultivated ; especially of such a one as is here described,
consisting of rugged mountains and sandy plains, which, without
culture, indeed, produce nothing, but which, by human industry in a
happy climate, may be made to vie with soils naturally the most
prolific. 2. It appears from the vast numbers which this country
actually sustained, in the most flourishing times of the Theocracy,
that it well answered the character their Lawgiver had bestowed upon
it, of a land flowing with milk and honey. 3. The Israelites, when
they took possession of it, certainly found it to come up to the cha-
racter which Moses had given them, of a place where they should
find great and goodly Cities which they had not builded, houses full of
good things which they had not filled, wells digged which they had not
digged, and vineyards and olive trees which they had not planted.*
If, I say, they had not found it so, we should soon have heard of it,
from the most turbulent and dissatisfied people upon earth. And it
was no wonder they found it in this condition, since they had wrested
it from the hands of a very numerous and luxurious People, who had
carried arts and arms to some height, when they, in any sense,
could be said to have Cities fenced up to Heaven. But the Poet has a
solution of this difficulty ; for to the Israclites, just got out of their
forty years captivity in the Wilderness, this miserable country must
needs appear a paradise, in comparison of the Deserts of Param and
Cadish Barnea.t Now it is very certain, that no Desert thereabout,
could be more horrid or forbidding than that of Judea, as the Poet
has here drawn the landscape. But does he think they had quite
forgot the fertile plains of Egypt all this time? And if they compared
the promised Inheritance to the Wilderness on the one hand, would
they not be as apt to compare it to Egypt on the other? And what
Judea gained by the first, it would lose by the second. But he will
say, that Generation which came out of Egypt, fell in the Wilderness.
What if they did? they left their fondness for its flesh-pots behind
them, as we are sufficiently informed from the excessive attachment
of their posterity for Egyptian luxury of every kind. 4. But let us
admit his account of the sterility of the promised Land, and then see
how the pretensions of the Mosaic Mission will stand. We will
consider this sterility in either view, as corrigible, or as incorrigible.
If corrigible, we cannot conceive a properer region for answering the
ENDS of Providence, as Moses has delivered them unto us, with regard
to this People. The first great blessing bestowed on mankind, was to
be particularly exemplified in the posterity of Abraham, which was to
be like the sand on the sea-shore for multitude: and yet they were to
be confined within the narrow limits of a single district : so that some
* Deut. vi.—viii. + “Ce pais fut pour eux une terre delicieuse en comparaison
des Déserts de Param et de Cades-Barné.”—Add. ἃ 1 Hist. Generale, p. 83.
SECT. 1. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 427
proportionate provision was to be made for its numerous Inhabitants.
Affluence by commerce they could not have; for the purpose of their
separation required, that Idolaters should no more be permitted to
come and pollute them, than that they should go amongst Idolaters to
be polluted by them: And accordingly, a sufficient care was taken,
in the framing of their Laws, to hinder this communication at either
end. Thus the advantages from commerce being quite cut off, they
had only agriculture to have recourse to, for subsistance of their mul-
titudes. And the natural sterility of the land would force them upon
every invention to improve it. And artificial culture produces an
abundance, which unassisted nature can never give to the most fruitful
soil and most benignant climate. Add to this, that a People thus
sequestered, would, without such constant attention to the art, and
application to the labour, which the meliorating of a backward soil
requires, soon degenerate into barbarous and savage manners; the first
product of which has been always seen to be a total oblivion of a God.
But if we are to suppose what the Poet would seem to insinuate, in
discredit of the Dispensation, that the soil of Judea was absolutely
incorrigible ; a more convincing proof cannot be given of that EXTRA-
ORDINARY PRoviDENCE which Moses promised to them. So that if
the corrigibility of a bad soil perfectly agreed with the enp of the
Dispensation, which was a separation, the cncorrigibility of it was as
well fitted to the MEAN, which was an extraordinary Providence. For
the fact, that Judea did support those vast multitudes, beg unques-
tionable, and the natural incapacity of the country so to do being
allowed, nothing remains but that we must recur to that extraordinary
Providence, which not only was promised, but was the natural conse-
quence of a Theocratic form of government. But I am inclined to
keep between the two contrary suppositions, and take up the premisses
of the one, and the conclusion of the other: to hold that the sterility
of Judea was very corrigible ; but that all possible culture would be
inadequate to the vast numbers which it sustained, and that therefore
its natural produce was still further multiphed by an extraordinary
blessing upon the land.
To support this system, we may observe, that this extraordinary
assistance was bestowed more eminently, because more wanted, while
the Israelites remained in the Wilderness. Mosrs, whose word will
yet go as far as our General Historian’s, says, that when God took
Jacob up, to give him his Law, he found him indeed in a desert Land,
and in the waste howling wilderness ; but it was no longer such, when
now God had the leading of him. ‘“ He led him about,” [1. e. while
he was preparing him for the conquest of the promised Land] ‘ He
instructed him,” (i. 6. by the Law, which he there gave him] ‘“ He
kept him as the apple of his eye,” [1. e. he preserved him there by his
428 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK V.
extraordinary Providence ;] the effects of which he describes in the
next words,— He made him ride on the high places of the earth,”
[i. e. he made the Wilderness to equal, in its produce, the best culti-
vated places] “that he might eat the increase of the fields; and he
made him to suck honey out of the Rock, and oil out of the flinty
Rock: Butter of kine, and milk of sheep, with fat of lambs, and rams
of the breed of Bashan”’ [i. 6. as large as that breed] ‘and goats, with
the fat of kidneys of wheat,” [i. e. the flour of wheat] ‘and thou
didst drink the pure blood of the Grape.”
That this was no fairy-scene, appears from the effects. —“ Jeshurun
waxed fat, and kicked: thou art waxen fat, thou art grown thick,
thou art covered with fatness; then he forsook God which made him,
and lightly esteemed the Rock of his salvation,” &c.* This severe
reproof of Moses certainly did not put the Israelites in an humour, to
take the wonders in the foregoing account on his word, had the facts
he appeals to been the least equivocal.
On the whole, we can form no conception how God could have
chosen a People, and assigned them a land to inhabit, more proper for
the display of his almighty Power, than the People of Israel and the
land of Judea. As to the People, the Propuer in his Parable of the
Vine-tree, informs us, that they were naturally, the weakest and most
contemptible of all nations: and as to the land, the Port, in his
great Fable, which he calls a General History, assures us, that Judea
was the vilest and most barren of all countries. Yet somehow or
other this chosen People became the Instructors of mankind, in the
noblest office of humanity, the science of true Theology: and the
promised Land, while made subservient to the worship of one God,
was changed, from its native sterility, to a region flowing with milk
and honey ; and, by reason of the incredible numbers which it sus-
tained, deservedly entitled the GLORY OF ALL LANDS.
This is the state of things which Scriprure lays before us. And
I have never yet seen those strong reasons, from the schools of Infi-
delity, that should induce a man, bred up in any school at all, to pre-
fer their logic to the plain facts of the Sacred Historians.
I have used their testimony to expose one, who, indeed, renounces
their authority : but in this I am not conscious of having transgressed
any rule of fair reasoning. The Freethinker laments that there is no
contemporary Historian remaining, to confront with the Jewish Law-
giver, and detect his impostures. However, he takes heart, and boldly
engages his credit to confute him from his own history. This is a fair
attempt. But he prevaricates on the very first onset. The Sacred
History, besides the many civil facts which it contains, has many of a
miraculous nature. Of these, our Freethinker will allow the first only
* Deut. xxxii. 10, et seq.
SECT. IT. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 429
to be brought in evidence. And then bravely attacks his adversary,
who has now one hand tied behind him: for the civil and the miraculous
facts, in the Jewish Dispensation, have the same, nay, a nearer relation
to each other, than the two hands of the same body ; for these may be
used singly and independently, though to disadvantage ; whereas the
civil and the miraculous facts can neither be understood nor accounted
for, but on the individual inspection of both. This is confessed by
one who, as clear-sighted as he was, certainly did not see the* conse-
quence of what he so liberally acknowledged. <‘‘ The miracles in the
Bible” (says his philosophic Lordship) “are not like those in Livy,
detached pieces, that do not disturb the civil History, which goes on
very well without them. But the miracles of the Jewish Historian are
intimately connected with all the civil affairs, and make a necessary
and inseparable part. The whole history is founded in them; it con-
sists of little else; and if it were not an history of them, it would be a
history of nothing.’’+
From all this, I assume that where an Unbeliever, a Philosopher if
you will, (for the Poet Voltaire makes them convertible terms) pretends
to shew the falshood of Moses’s mission from Moses’s own history of
it ; he who undertakes to confute his reasoning, argues fairly when he
confutes it upon facts recorded in that history, whether they be of the
miraculous or of the civil kind: since the two sorts are so inseparably
connected, that they must always be taken together, to make the
history understood, or the facts which it contains intelligible.
SECTION II.
ALLOWING it then, to have been Gon’s purpose to perpetuate the
knowledge of himself amidst an idolatrous World, by the means of a
separated People ; let us see how this design was brought about, when
the Family, he had chosen, was now become numerous enough to sup-
port itself under a separation ; and Idolatry, which was grown to its
most gigantic stature, t was now to be repressed.
The Israelites were, at this time, groaning under the yoke of Egypt;
whither the all-wise providence of God had conducted them, while
they were yet few in number, and in danger of mixing and con-
founding themselves with the rest of the Nations. In this distress,
one of their own brethren is sent to them with a message from Gop,
by the name and character of the Gop or THEIR FATHERS, whose
virtues Gop had promised to reward with distinguished blessings on
their Posterity. The message, accompanied with signs and wonders,
denounced their speedy deliverance from Egyptian bondage, and their
certain possession of the land of Canaan, the scene of all the promised
* See the “ View of Lord Bolingbroke’s Philosophy,” vol. vi. p. 732, of the quarto
edition. + BoLincBroke’s * Posthumous Works,” vol. iii. p. 279. t See
note B, at the end of this book.
430 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK γ΄.
blessings. The People hearken, and are delivered. They depart from
Egypt ; and in the third month from their departure, come to Mount
Sinai. Here Gop first tells them by their Leader, Mosss, that, if they
would obey his voice indeed, and keep his Covenant, then they should be
@ PECULIAR TREASURE f0 him above all people, for that the WHOLE
EARTH was his.* Where we see an example of what hath been
observed above, that whenever an Institution was given to this People,
in compliance with the notions they had imbibed in Egypt, a correc-
tive was always joined with it to prevent the abuse. Thus God having
here told them, that if they would obey his voice they should be his
peculiar treasure above all people, (speaking in the character of a tutelary
God ;) to prevent this compliance from falling into abuse, as the divi-
sion of the several regions of the earth to several celestial rulers was
inseparably connected with the idea of a tutelary Deity, he adds, as a
reason for making this People his Peculiar, a circumstance destructive
of that pagan notion of tutelary Gods—for that the WHOLE EARTH
was his. Well. The people consent ;+ and God delivers the Covenant
to them, in the words of the two Tables.t
But this promise, of their being received for Gov’s peculiar treasure,
could be visibly performed no otherwise than by their separation from
the rest of mankind. As on the other hand, their separation could
not have been effected without this visible protection. And this,
Moses observes in his intercession for the people: For wherein shall it~
be known here, that I and thy people have found grace in thy sight ?
Ts it not in that thou Gorst ΨΙΤΗ us? So shall we be SEPARATED, I and
thy people, from all the people that are upon the face of the earth.§
The better, therefore, to secure this separation, Gop proposes to them
to become their Kine. And, for reasons that will be explained anon,
condescends to receive the Magistracy, on their free choice.—And ye
shall be unto me a kingdom of priests,\| and an holy nation.—And all
the people answered together and said, All that the Lord hath spoken
we will do.4| Gop then delivers them a Digest of their civil and reli-
gious Laws, and settles the whole Constitution both of Church and State.
Thus the Almighty becoming their Kine, in as real a sense as he was
their Gop, the republic of the Israelites was properly a THEOCRACY ;
in which the two Societies, civil and religious, were of course intirely ,
incorporated. A thing neither attended to nor understood. The
name indeed is of familiar use: but how little men mean by it, is seen
from hence, that those who, out of form, are accustomed to call it a
Theocracy, yet, in their reasonings about it, consider it as a mere Aristo-
cracy under the Judges; and as a mere Monarchy under the Kings:
* Exod. xix. 5. + Verse 8. t Exod. xx. § Exod. xxxiii. 16.
\| For where God is King, every subject is, in some sense or other, a priest; because
in that case, civil obedience must have in it the nature of religious ministration.
4] Exod. xix. 6—8.
SECT, Il. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 481
whereas, in truth, it was neither one nor the other, but a real and
proper THEOCRACY, under both.
Thus was this famous SEPARATION made. But it will be asked,
Why in so extraordinary a way? A way, in which the sagacious Deist
can discover nothing but the marks of the Legislator’s fraud, and the
People’s superstition.—As to what a mere human Lawgiver could gain
by such a project, will be seen hereafter. At present, it will be suffi-
cient, for the removal of these suspicions, to shew, that a THEOCRACY
WAS NECESSARY, as the separation could not be effected any other way.
It appears, from what hath been shewn above, that the Israelites
had ever a violent propensity to mix with the neighbouring Nations,
and to devote themselves to the practices of idolatry: this would
naturally, and did, in fact, absorb large portions of them. And the
sole human means which preserved the remainder, was the severity of
their civil Laws against idolatry.* Such Laws therefore were neces-
sary to support a separation. But penal Laws, inforced by the ordi-
nary Magistrate, for matters of opinion, are manifestly unjust. Some
way therefore was to be contrived to render these Laws equitable.
For we are not to suppose Gop would ordain any thing that should
violate the rule of natural justice. Now these penal Laws are equita-
ble only in a Theocracy : therefore was a THEOCRACY NECESSARY.
That the punishment of opinions, by civil Laws, under a THEO-
cRACY, is agreeable to the rules of natural justice, I shall now endea-
vour to prove.
Unbelievers and intolerant Christians have both tried to make their
advantage of this part of the Mosaic institution. The one using it as
an argument against the divinity of the Jewish Religion, on presump-
tion that such Laws are contrary to natural equity; and the other
bringing it to defend their intolerant principles by the example of
Heaven itself. But they are both equally deceived by their ignorance
of the nature of a Theocracy : which, rightly understood, clears the
Jewish Law from an embarrassing objection, and leaves the rights of
mankind inviolate.
Mr. Bayle, in an excellent treatise for Toleration, when he comes
to examine the arguments of the Intolerants, takes notice of that
which they bring from the example in question. ‘‘The fourth objec-
tion”’ (says he) “‘ may arise from hence, that the Law of Moses gives
® < Tf there be found amongst you, within any of thy gates which the Lorp thy Gop
giveth thee, man or woman that hath wrought wickedness in the sight of the Lorn thy
Gop in transgressing his covenant, and hath gone and served other Gods, and wor-
shipped them, either the sun, or the moon, or any of the host of*heaven, which I have
not commanded ; and it be told thee, and thou hast heard of it, and inquired diligently,
and behold it be true, and the thing certain, that such abomination is wrought in Israel ;
hen shalt thou bring forth that man or that woman (which have committed that wicked
hing) unto thy gates, even that man or that woman, and shalt stone them with stones
ll they die.” (Deut, xvii. 2—5.)
450 “ THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK V.
no toleration to idolaters, and false prophets, whom it punishes with
death ; and from what the Prophet Elijah did to the Priests of Baal,
whom he ordered to be destroyed without mercy. From whence it
follows, that all the reasons I have employed, in the first part of this
commentary, prove nothing, because they prove too much; namely,
that the literal sense of the Law of Moses, as far as relates to the
punishment of opinions, would be impious and abominable. There-
fore, since Gop could, without violating the eternal order of things,
command the Jews to put false prophets to death, it follows, evi-
dently, that he could, under the Gospel also, command orthodox
believers to inflict the same punishment upon heretics. wit:
“1 am not, if I rightly know myself, of that temper of mind, so
thoroughly corrupted by the contagion of Controversy, as to treat this
objection with an air of haughtiness and contempt; as is the way
when men find themselves incapable of answering to the purpose.
I ingenuously own the objection to be strong; and that it seems to
be a mark of Gon’s sovereign pleasure, that we should not arrive at
certainty in any thing, seeing he hath given exceptions in his holy
word to almost all the common notices of reason. Nay I know some
who have no greater difficulties to hinder their believing that Gop
was the author of the Laws of Moses, and of all those Revelations
that occasioned so much slaughter and devastation, than this very
matter of intolerance, so contrary to our clearest ideas of natural
equity.” *
Whether Mr. Bayle himself was one of these backward believers, as
by some of his expressions he gives us reason to suspect, is not
material. That he dwelt with pleasure on this circumstance, as
favouring his beloved scepticism, is too evident. But sure he went a
little too far when he said, Gov’s word contains exceptions to almost
all the common notices of reason.t 1 hope to shew, before I have
done with Infidelity, that 10 contains exceptions to none.t Our excel-
lent countryman Mr. Locke, who wrote about this time on the same
subject, and with that force and precision which is the character of all
his writings, was more reasonable and modest in his account of this
matter. ds to the case (says he) of the Israelites in the Jewish Com-
monwealth, who being initiated into the Mosaical rites, and made citi-
zens of the commonwealth, did afterwards apostatize from the worship
of the Gov of Israel; these were proceeded against as traitors and
rebels, guilty of no less than high treason. For the commonwealth of
“ “ Voions presentement cette iv. objection. On la peut tirer de ce que la loi du
Moise,” &c.—Commentaire Philosophique, part ii. chap. 4. } ‘‘ Par les excep-
tions qu'il a mises dans sa parole a presque toutes les notions communes de la raison.”
{ [In the fourth edition of 1765, the two following sentences occur :— But the solution
of the difficulty was above his strength, had he been ever so willing to reconcile Scrip-
ture to Reason. Judea was a terra incognita to this great Adventurer.” For the omis-
sion of them in the editions of 1788 and 1811, I can assign no reason.—J. N.]
SECT. 11. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 433
the Jews, different, in that, from all others, was an absolute Turo-
CRACY; nor was there, nor could there be, any difference between the
Commenwcalth and the Church. The Laws established there concern-
ing the worship of the one invisible Deity were the civil Laws of that
people, and a part of their political Government, in which Gov himself
was the Legislator.* This he said ; but it being all he said,
I shall endeavour to support his solution by such other reasoning
as occurs to me. It will be necessary then to observe, that Gop, in
his infinite wisdom, was pleased to stand in two arbitrary relations
towards the Jewish People, besides that natural one, in which he
stood towards them and the rest of mankind in common. The first
was that of a tutelary Deity, gentilitial and local ; the Gop of Abra-
ham, Isaac, and Jacob, who was to bring their posterity into the land
of Canaan, and to protect them there, as his peculiar People. The
second was that of supreme Magistrate and Lawgiver. And in both
these relations he was pleased to refer it to the people’s free choice,
whether or no they would receive him for their Gop and Kine. For
a tutelary Deity was supposed by the Ancients to be as much matter
of election as a civil Magistrate. The People, therefore, thus solemnly
accepting him, these necessary consequences followed from the HorEs
CONTRACT.
I. First, that as the national Gop and civil Magistrate of the Jews
centered in one and the same object, their civil Policy and Religion
must be intimately united and incorporated ;+ consequently, their
religion had, and very reasonably, A PUBLIC PART, whose subject was
the Society as such: though this part, in the national pagan Reli-
gions, which had it likewise, was extremely absurd, as hath been
shewn more at large in the first volume.t
II. Secondly, as the two Societies were thoroughly incorporated,
they could not be distinguished ; but must stand or fall together.
Consequently the direction of all their civil Laws must be for the
equal preservation of both. Therefore, as the renouncing him for
King was the throwing him off as God; and as the renouncing him
for God was the throwing him off as King; idolatry, which was the
rejecting him as Gop, was properly the ‘“‘crimen leesee majestatis ;” and
so justly punishable by the civil Laws. But there was this manifest
difference in these two cases, as to the effects. The renouncing Gop
as civil Magistrate might be remedied without a total dissolution of
the Constitution; not so, the renouncing him as tutelary Gop:
because, though he might, and did § appoint a deputy, in his office of
* < Letter concerning Toleration,”’ p. 37, ed. 1689. + Such a kind of union and
incorporation was most absurdly affected by Manomet in imitation of the Jewish
GEconemy; whence, as might be expected, it appears that neither he nor his assistants
understood any thing of its true nature. 1 See ** Divine Legation,” book ii. sect. i. vol. i.
p.17l,etseg. ὃ The kings of Jsrae/ and Judah being, as we shall shew, indeed no other.
VOL. II. FF
454 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK V.
KiNG, amongst the Jewish tribes; yet he would have no substitute,
as Gop, amongst the pagan Deities. Therefore, in necessity as well
as of right, idolatry was punishable by the civil Laws of a THEo-
CRACY; it being the greatest crime that could be committed against
the State, as tending, by unavoidable consequence, to dissolve the
Constitution. For the one Gop being the supreme Magistrate, it
subsisted in the worship of that Gop alone. Idolatry, therefore, as
the renunciation of one Gop alone, was in a strict philosophic, as well
as legal sense, the crime of lese-majesty. Let us observe farther, that
as, by such INCORPORATION, religious matters came under civil con-
sideration, so likewise civil matters came under the religious. This is
what Josephus would say, where, in his second book against Apion,
speaking of the Jewish Theocracy, he tells us that Moses did not
make Religion a part of Virtue, but Virtue a part of Religion.*
The meaning is, that, as in all human Societies, obedience to the Law
is moral Virtue ; under a TuEocracy, it is Religion.
III. The punishment of Idolatry, by Law, had this farther cireum-
stance of equity, that it was punishing the rebellion of those who had
chosen the Government under which they lived, when freely proposed
to them. Hence, in the Law against idolatry, the crime is, with
great propriety, called the TRANSGRESSION OF THE COVENANT.
Thus we see, the Law in question stands clear of the cavils of
Infidels, and the abuse of Intolerants.t
But to this, the defender of the common rights of subjects may be
apt to object, ‘that these penal laws were unjust, because no contract
to give up the rights of conscience can be binding.”’
To which I reply, with a plain and decisive fact, That none of all
the idolatrous worship the Jews ever fell into, from the time of giving
the Law to the total dissolution of the Republic, was MATTER OF
CONSCIENCE ; but always of convenience ; such as procuring some
temporal good, which they wantonly affected, or averting some tem-
poral evil, which they servilely feared. The truth of which appears
from hence, that, in the midst of all their idolatries, the Gop of their
Fathers, as we shall see, was ever owned to be the Creator and first
Cause of all things ; and the Religion taught by Moses, to be a Reve-
lation from heaven.
But it may be asked, What if their commission of idolatry had, at
any time, proved matter of conscience ; i. 6. such an action as they
thought they were obliged in duty to perform ?
I reply, the question would have weight, had the Law in dispute
* Αἴτιον δ᾽ ὅτι καὶ τῷ τρόπῳ τῆς νομοθεσίας τυρὸς τὸ χρήσιμον wayTwy ἀεὶ τσολὺ
διήνεγκεν" οὐ γὰρ μέρος τῆς ἀρετῆς ἐποίησε τὴν εὐσέξειαν, ἀλλὰ ταύτης τὰ μέρη τἄλλα
συνεῖδε καὶ κατέστησε: λέγω δὲ τὴν δικαιοσύνην, τὴν καρτερίαν, τὴν σωφροσύνην, τὴν
τῶν τσολιτῶν τσρὸς ἀλλήλους ἐν ἅπασι συμφωνίαν.--- P. 488, Havercampi ed. t Deut.
xvii. 2. 1 See note C, at the end of this book.
SECT. If. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 435
been of human institution. But as it was given by Gop, who knows
the future equally with the past and present, and saw the case would
not happen, it is altogether impertinent. The Question, indeed,
points out to us, the danger and absurdity in any human legislature
to make penal Laws for restraining the exercise of Religion, on any
pretence whatsoever.
Thus it is seen, that a separation, so necessary to preserve the
Unity, could not have been supported without PENAL LAws against
idolatry ; and, at the same time, seen that such penal laws can never
be equitably instituted but under a Theocracy. The consequence 15,
that A THEOCRACY WAS NECESSARY.
But this form of Government was highly convenient likewise. The
Israelites, on their leaving Egypt, were sunk into the lowest practices
of idolatry. To recover them, therefore, by the discipline of a separa-
tion, it was necessary that the idea of Gon and his attributes should
be impressed upon them in the most sensible manner. But this could
not be done, commodiously, under his character of Gop of the Uni-
verse : under his character of Kine of Israel it well might. Hence it
is, we find him in the Old Testament so frequently represented with
affections analogous to human passions. The Civil relation, in which
he stood to these people, made such a representation natural; the
grossness of their conceptions made the representation necessary ; and
the guarded manner in which it was always qualified, prevented it
from being mischievous. Hence, another instance of the wisdom of
this conomy; and of the folly of Spinoza, and others, who would
conclude from it, that Moses and the Prophets had themselves gross
conceptions of the Deity. Nor should the indiscretion of those
Divines pass uncensured, who have taught that Gop, in the Old Tes-
tament, looks on man with a less gracious and benign aspect, than in
the New. An error, which at one time gave birth to the most absurd
and monstrous of the ancient heresies; and hath at all times fur-
nished a handle to infidelity.* But Gop, whenever he represents
himself under the idea of Lord of the Universe, makes one uniform
revelation of his nature, throughout all his Dispensations, as gracious
and full of compassion ; as good to ALL, and whose tender mercies are
OVER ALL HIS WORKS: yet condescending to become the tutelary
God, and civil Magistrate of the Jews, it cannot but be, that he
should be considered as having his peculiar inspection attached to this.
People, and as punishing their transgressions with severity.
These appear to me the true reasons of the Theocratie form of
government. With such admirable wisdom was the Jewish Economy
* It must be owned (says Tyndal) that the same spirit (I dare not call it a spirit of
cruelty) does not alike prevail throughout the Old Testament: the nearer we come to the
times of the Gospel, the milder it appeared.—‘ Christianity as old as the Creation,”
p. 241. See too Lorp BoLincBROKE’s “ Posthumous Works” throughout.
ον 2
486 _ THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK V.
adapted, to effect the ends it had in view! Yet, notwithstanding the
splendour of divinity which shines through every part of this Theo-
cratic form, Mr. Foster, a dissenting preacher, tells us roundly, that
it is all an idle dream; and that he will undertake to defend the
Law, which punishes idolatry with death, “ not on dark and imagi-
nary, but on clear and solid principles ; I therefore add,” (says he)
“supposing the THEocratic form of government amongst the Jews
to be a point incontestable, it seems scarce capable of affording a full
and satisfactory answer to the objection raised against the Hebrew
Law for devoting idolaters to death. For when the people of Israel,
fond of novelty, and of imitating the customs of other nations, were
stubbornly and inflexibly resolved, notwithstanding all the remon-
strances of the Prophet Samuel to the contrary, to have a visible and
mortal King ; God upon this occasion declared, that they had rejected
him that he should not reign over them: and as his former political
reign is founded on a supposed compact between the Almighty Sove-
reign and his people, that original compact being now solemnly
renounced on the part of the people, there must of course be a disso-
lution or end of the Theocracy.” *
He begins with calling the Theocracy a dark principle. And yet,
the account he gives of it shews, that he did not find it dark; and,
what was worse, could not, with all his endeavours, make it so. He
calls it imaginary ; and yet the very History he quotes to prove its
short duration, shews, even by his own proof, it was not imaginary,
but real.
Indeed, if that civil Government, which is founded on ORIGINAL
COMPACT, were dissolvable at pleasure, that is, as soon as one of the
contracting parties was grown weary of it (which this Decider on
Government and Laws expressly says it is), then Government, on its
most legitimate foundation, would be the most dark and imaginary of
all things. When the Parliament rose up in arms against Charles I.
they wanted just such a Preacher as this (and yet they had many
precious ones), to assure them, that their renouncing the King’s
Authority had fairly dissolved the Monarchy, and brought it to a
lawful end. For the Leaders of that body, it is plain, knew nothing
of this secret, and were therefore at a great deal of pains to prove,
and at last could hardly get themselves believed, that Charles -himself
had broken the original Compact. But unless this Compact stands
upon a different footing from all other compacts in the world, we
may safely pronounce, that a bargain or agreement, which has been
made between two parties, can never be dissolved but by the consent
of both of them; or by a fundamental misdemeanour in one; if the
other party chuses to exact the forfeiture. Now, in the case of the
* “ Sermons," vol, iii. pp. 373, 374.
SECT. 11. ΟΕ MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 437
Jews under Samuel, there was a renunciation, it is true, on the part
of the People, or, in plainer English, a REBELLION. But Gon did
not give way to it; he would not (as on the principles of civil justice
he might) exact the forfeiture ; which was, the withdrawing his pro-
tection. All this will be proved at large in its place. The Theocracy,
therefore, still continued under their Kings ; which were indeed no
other than the anointed, or the Viceroys of Gop.—Such is our
Preacher’s success in attempting to shew Mr. Locke’s principle to be
dark and imaginary. Let us see next whether he has better fortune
in proving his own to be clear and solid.
Now his way of justifying the Law, which punished idolatry with
death, without the aid of the theocratic principle, is this.—“ As the
end for which the civil constitution of the Jews was formed, viz. to
prevent their being over-run with idolatry, (which, as it prevailed
amongst the neighbouring nations, corrupted their internal sense of
the difference of good and evil, and banished humanity and decency,
and many of the most considerable and important of the social vir-
tues, by introducing shameful impurities and human sacrifices, quite
detestable to nature) as the end, I say, for which the civil constitution
of the Jews was formed, appears, when thus explained, and abstracted
from all consideration merely religious, to be wise and gracious in
itself ; and as the judicial Laws in that scheme of Government were
admirably adapted to subserve and advance this wise and gracious
end ; it necessarily follows, that idolatry, which would have frustrated
the whole design of the Constitution, and have entirely dissolved and
destroyed it, must, upon the same reasons that are allowed to be just
in all other Policies, have deserved capital punishment.’’ *
Here we see our Preacher approves himself just as skilful in the
end of Civil-government, as he did before, in its nature and essence.
He appears not to know (what he might have seen proved in the first
volume of this work) that civil Society must have one particular,
distinct, and appropriated end; and that this end can be no other
than secnrity to the temporal liberty and property of man ; because
(as is there shewn) all other ends may be attained without civil
Society. This then is the only proper end of Government. Yet our
Preacher falls into that exploded conceit, which makes any attainable
end, so it be a good one, the legitimate business of civil Society, as
such : which confounds this Society with all others, there being no
way to keep the Civil distinct but by assigning it an end peculiar to
itself. But his subject happening to be the Jewish government, it
secured his reasoning from the glare of the absurdity. And his false
and fallacious account of the end of its institution, with which he intro-
* Pp. 375, 376.
~
438 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK V.
duces his reasoning, gave a certain plausibility to the nonsense which
followed. It is in these words, The end for which the civil constitu-
tion was formed, was to prevent their being over-run with idolatry.
Now, by civil constitution, a fair reasoner should mean (where the
question is concerning the efficacy of a mere civil Government, in
contradistinction to the Religious) the civil constitution of the Jews
as it was so distinguished. But, in this sense, the end of the civil
constitution of the Jews was the same with all other, namely, security
to men’s temporal liberty and property. It is true, if by their civil
constitution, he meant both civil and religious, which here indeed was
incorporated, and went under the common name of LAw; then indeed
its end was to prevent idolatry ; but then this is giving up the point,
because that incorporation was the consequence of the Theocratie
form of Government, or, to speak more properly, it was the THEO-
cracy itself. Thus he comes round again to the place on which he
had turned his back; and, before he knows where he is, establishes
the very doctrine he would confute. In a word, our Preacher was
got out of his depth; and here I shall leave him to sink or swim;
only observing, that this great advocate of religious liberty has done
his best (though certainly without design) to support a principle the
most plausible of any that Persecutors for opinions can catch hold on,
to justify their iniquitous practice ; namely, that civil government was
ordained for the procuring all the good of all kinds, which it is even
accidentally capable of advancing. And to make sure work, he
employs that adulterate gloss, which They so artfully put upon their
wicked practice ; viz. that it is for the support of morality : for who
is so purblind that he cannot spy immoralities lurking in all heretical
opinions? And thus it is that our Preacher defends civil Government,
in punishing opinions: The idolatry of the neighbouring nations (says
he) corrupted their internal sense of the difference of good and evil,
and banished humanity and decency, and many of the most considera-
ble and important of the social virtues. A reason constantly in the
mouths, whatever hath been in the hearts of Persecutors, from St.
Austin to St. Dominic.*
Eb.
We come, in the next place, to shew, that this THrocracy, as it
Was NECESSARY, so it would have an easy reception ; being founded
on the flattering notion, at that time universally entertained, of
TUTELARY DEITIES, Gentilitial and Local. Thus, to carry on his
great purpose, the Almighty very early represented himself to this
chosen race, as a Gentilitial Deity, The Gop of Abraham, Isaac, and
Jacob :+ Afterwards, when he preferred Judea to all other countries
* See note D, at the end of this book. + See Jer. x. 16, and li. 19.
SECT. I. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 439
for his personal residence (on this account called wis LAND),* he
came under their idea of a Local Deity: which notion was an estab-
lished principle in the Gentile world, as we have shewn above, from
Plato. It was originally Ecyprran ; and founded in an opinion that
the earth was at first divided by its Creator, amongst a number of
inferior and subordinate Divinities. The Septuagint translators appear
to have understood the following passage, in the song of Moses, as
alluding to this opinion ;—When the Most High divided to the
nations their inheritance, when he separated the sons of Adam, he set
the bounds of the people ACCORDING TO THE NUMBER OF THE
CHILDREN OF ISRAEL. For the Lord’s portion is his people: Jacob
is the lot of his inheritance :+ For, instead of, according to the num-
ber of the children of Israel (which if they found in the text, they
understood no more than later critics) they wrote κατὰ ἀριθμὸν
᾿Αγγέλων Θεοῦ, ACCORDING TO THE NUMBER OF THE ANGELS OF
Gop. Which at least is intelligible, as referring to that old notion,
original to the country where this translation was made. And Justin
Martyr tells us,t that in the beginning, Gop had committed the
government of the world to angels, who, abusing their trust, were
degraded from their regency. But whether he learnt it from this
translation, or took it from a worse place, I shall not pretend to
determine.
The Land, thus selected by Gop for his personal residence, he
bestows upon his chosen People. Behold (says he) the land of
Canaan which I give unto the children of Israel for a possession.§
This too was according to the common notions of those times. Thus
Jephthah, who appears to have been half paganized by a bad educa-
tion, speaks to the King of the Ammonites, Wilt not thou possess that
which Chemosh thy Gov giveth thee to possess? So, whomsoever the
Lord our Gop shall drive out from before us, them will we possess. ||
It was no wonder, therefore, when Gop was thus pleased, for the
wise ends of his providence, to be considered, by a prejudiced people,
in this character, that all the pagan nations round about should
regard the Gop or IsRAEL no otherwise than as a local tutelary
Deity ; too apt, by their common prejudices, to see him only under
that idea. Thus he is called the Gop of the Land,4]—the Gop of the
Hills,** §c. Aid it is expressly said, that they spoke against the Gop
of Jerusalem, as against the Gods of the people of the earth, which
were the work of the hands of man.t+ By which is meant, that they
treated him as a local tutelary Deity, of a confined and bounded
power: for it was not the old pagan way to speak against one
* Ley. xxv. 23; Deut. xi. 12; Psalm x. 16: Isai. xiv. 25; Jer. ii. 7; xvi. 18; Ezek.
xxxv. 10; xxxvi. ἘΣ 20; xxxviii. 16; Wisd. of Sol. xii. He iT Dent. Sty Sys
1 Apologets i. § Deut. EXxii. 49. || Judges xi. 24. q 2 Kings xvii.
26; xviii. 33, et seq. ** |] Kings xx. 23. ++ 2 Chron. xxxii. 19.
440 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK ¥.
another’s Gods, in discredit of their Divinity: and this circumscribed
dominion was esteemed, by them, no discredit to it: But, by the
Jews, the worshipers of the true Gop, it was justly held to be the
greatest. Therefore, to call the Goo of Israel the God of the hills,
and not of the plain, was speaking against him.
For, here again we must observe, that when Gop, agreeably to the
whole method of this Dispensation, takes advantage of, or indulges
his people in, any habituated notion or custom, he always interweaves
some characteristic note of difference, to mark the institution for his
own. Thus in this indulgence of their prejudices concerning a tute-
lary Gop,
1. He first institutes, upon it, a Theocracy ; a practice just the
reverse of Paganism: for there Kings became Gods; whereas here
Gop condescended to become King.*
2. Secondly, he forbids all kind of community or intercourse
between the Gop of Israel and the Gods of the Nations, either by
joining their worship to his, or so much as owning their Divinity.
Thus were the Israelites distinguished from all other people im the
most effectual manner ; for, as we have often had occasion to observe,
there was a general intercommunity amongst the Gods of paganism :
They acknowledged one another’s pretensions; they borrowed one
another’s titles ; and, at length, entered into a kind of partnership of
Worship. All the Pagan nations, we see, owned the Gon of Israel for
a tutelary Deity.t But His followers were not permitted to be so
ecomplaisant. There was to be no fellowship between Gop and Belial ;
though a good understanding always subsisted between Belial and
Dagon.
But, amidst a vast number of characteristic circumstances proving
the origin of the Mosaic reEx1er10n to have been different from that
of every other nation, there is none more illustrious than this, That
the Mosaic religion was built upon a former, namely, the Parri-
ARCHAL: whereas the various Religions of the Pagan world were all
unrelated to, and independent of, any other.t
And yet the famous Author of The grounds and reasons of the
Christian Religion hath been hardy enough to employ one whole
chapter to prove, that this method of introducing Christianity into the
world, by building and grounding it on the Old Testament, is agreeable
to the common method of introducing new Revelations, whether real or
PRETENDED, or any chayes in religion; and also the nature of
things.§ “ For if” (says he) ‘‘ we consider the various revolutions
ud changes in religion, whereof we have any tolerable history, in
heir beginning, we shall find them, for the most part, to be grafted
ὺ See note ὦ at the end of this book. + 2 Kings xviii. 25; Jer. iv. 2, 3,
} See vol. i, boos i. § ‘* Grounds and Reasons,” ὥς. p. 20.
SECT. 11. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 441
on some old stock, or founded on some preceding revelations, which
they were either to supply, or fulfil, or retrieve from corrupt glosses,
innovations, and traditions, with which by time they were incum-
bered : and this, which MAY SEEM MATTER OF SURPRISE TO THOSE,
WHO DO NOT REFLECT on the changeable nature of all things, hath
happened ; though the old revelations, far from intending any change,
ingraftment, or new dispensation, did for the most part declare they
were to last for ever, and did forbid all alterations and innovations,
they being the last dispensation intended.”’ ἢ
Here are two things asserted: 1. That the building new Religions
and new Revelations upon old was agreeable to the common method
of the ancient world. 2. That it was agreeable to the nature of
things. These are discoveries one would little have expected.
I. Let us first examine his Facrs.—But to judge truly of their
force, we must remember, that the observation is made to discredit
what Believers call true Revelation, by shewing that all false Religions
have taken the same method of propagation.
1. His first point is, That this method was agreeable to the common
practice of the ancient world. Would not one expect now an instance
of some confessedly false Religion, between the time of ABRAHAM and
Curist, which pretended to be built on some preceding Revelation ?
Without doubt : If it were only for this, that there is no other way
of proving the proposition. Besides, to say the truth, such an
instance would be well worth attending to, for its extreme curiosity.
But he could not give the reader what was not to be had: and there-
fore he endeavours to make up this deficiency of fact, by shewing,
1. That the Jewrsu Religion, like the CurisT1An, pretended to be
built on a preceding. ‘‘ Thus the mission of Moses to the Israelites”
(says he) “‘ supposed a former revelation of God (who from the begin-
ning seems to have been constantly giving a succession of dispensa-
tions and revelations) to their ancestors; and many of the religious
precepts of Moses were borrowed, or had an agreement with the reli-
gious rites of the heathens, with whom the Israelites had correspond-
ence, and particularly with the religious rites of the Egyptians, (who
upon that account seem confounded with the Israelites by some
pagans, as both their religious rites were equally, and at the same
time, prohibited by others) to whose religious rites the Israelites seem
to have been Conformists during their abode in Egypt.”+ Go thy
way, for a good Reasoner!—To prove that false revelations had the
same pretensions of dependency on a preceding, as the true have had,
he shews that all the true had these pretensions. But this is but half
the atchievement. The best part is still behind. °Tis a rarity; a
blunder ingrafted on a sophism. He was not content to say that
* Page 21. + Page 22.
442 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK V.
Moses founded his Religion on the Patriarchal : He must needs go on,
—And many of the religious precepts of Moses were borrowed, or had
an agreement with the religious rites of the Heathens, with whom the
Israelites had correspondence, and particularly with the religious Rites
of the Egyptians. Now, how it comes to pass that Moses’s borrowing
from the religious Rites of the Egyptians, whose religion he formally
condemned of falshood, should be metamorphosed into an example
of one Religion’s being founded upon, or receiving its authority from,
another, I confess, I cannot comprehend. If he were not at the head
of the Frrrruinxers, I should suspect some small confusion in his
ideas : and that this great Reasoner was unable to distinguish between,
a Religion’s supporting itself on one preceding, which is acknowledged
to be true: and a Religion’s complying, for the sake of inveterate pre-
judices, with some innocent practices of another religion, which it was
erected to overthrow, as false.
2. He shews next, that those false religions which came arTER the
Jewish and the Christian, and are confessed to mimick their peculi-
arities, pretended to be built on preceding revelations.—‘‘ The mission
of Zoroaster to the Persians supposed the religion of the Magians ;
which had been, for many ages past, the antient national religion of
the Medes as well as Persians. The mission of Mahomet supposed
Christianity; as that did, Judaism.” * This is still better. The
design of his general observation, That it was the common method for
new revelations to be built and grounded on preceding revelations,
was to shew that the revelations, which we call true, imitated the
false. And he proves it,—by shewing that the false imitated the
true. That Mahomet’s did so, is agreed on all hands. And those
bewildered men who would have us credit the story of a /ate Zoroas-
ter, do, and must suppose that he borrowed from Judaism. But the
truth is, the whole is an idle tale, invented by Persian writers under
the early Califs. However, though the Zoroaster of Hyde and Pri-
deaux be a mere phantom, yet the Religion called by his name, was a
real thing, and started up in the first ages of Mahometism, with a
Bible to support its credit, in imitation of, and to oppose to, the
Alcoran. But this neat device unluckily detects the whole imposture :
For in the Age of Mahomet, and in the time of the first Commenta-
tors on the Alcoran, the Persians were esteemed by them as Idolaters,
and without a Bible; (and they had good Opportunity, by their con-
stant commerce thither, to be well informed:) Which is agreeable to
every thing that the earlier and the later Greek Writers unanimously
deliver of the Persian Religion. But that, on the appearance of
Mahometanism, the Persians should do what the Greeks did on the
first appearance of Christianity, refine their old idolatrous worship,
* Page 23.
SECT, 11. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 443
till they brought it to what Hyde and Prideaux observe it is at this
day, amongst the remainder of the Magian sect in Persia and India,
is nothing strange. The wonder is, that these learned men should
have swallowed so gross a cheat, on the testimony of later Mahometan
Writers; who had so many motives to support it, and so slender
abilities to detect it; whose propensity to fabling is so great as even
to discredit any truth that rests on their authority ; and whose
talents in the art of lying are so little proportioned to their inclination
to exercise it, that they never fail of defeating their own impositions.
This argument, therefore, was in all respects worthy the Author of
The Grounds and Reasons of the Christian Religion.
3. Lastly, he tells us, that ‘‘the Siamese and Brachmans both pre-
tend that they have had a succession of incarnate deities amongst
them, who at due distances of time have brought new Revelations
from heaven; each succeeding one depending on the former; and
that religion is to be conveyed on, in that way, for ever.’’ *—He pro-
mised to prove a succession of Religions in the ancient world, the
later founded and depending on the preceding: And he proves—a
succession of incarnate deities, talked of amongst the MODERN pagans
of India and Siam; and, from this succession concludes for a succes-
sion of DEPENDING Rexicions, of which they have no kind of
notion. Nor are these extravagancies, which their priests do indeed
talk of, any other than late inventions of their priests, to oppose to
Mahometan and Christian Missionaries. But a succession of incarnate
deities was so arch a ridicule on the mysteries of our holy faith, that
it was to be brought in at any rate. But now the joke is over, let
me tell him, he need not have gone so far for it. Were not Ccelus,
Saturn, Jupiter, Mars, &c. a succession of incarnate deities ? yet were
any of the Religions, which had those Gods for their author or object,
FOUNDED Or DEPENDENT on (though they succeeded to) one ano-
ther? Here again, our sagacious Freethinker was at a fault; and,
with all his logic, could not distinguish between one Religion’s being
built upon another, and one Religion’s simply succeeding another.
11. He comes next to the NATURE OF THINGS. The reader has
seen how short he falls of his reckoning from fact: But let him
fairly make up his accounts, and we shall not differ with him about
his way of payment ; but willingly receive his deficiencies of Fact, in
Reason.—“ If we consider” (says he) ‘the nature of things, we
shall find that it must be difficult, if not impossible, to introduce
amongst men (who in all civilized countries are bred up in the belief
of some revealed religion) a revealed religion wholly new, or such as
has no reference to a preceding one: for that would be to combat all
men in too many respects, and not to proceed on a sufficient number
* Page 23.
444 THE DIVINE LEGATION - BOOK Vv.
of principles necessary to be assented to by those, on whom the first
impressions of a new religion are proposed to be made.” *
Here his head was full of the theologic ideas of modern times ;
where one Religion is maintained and propagated on the destruction
of all the rest. And that indeed would be combating all men in too
many respects, without good evidence in the Religion thus proposed.
But had he had the least knowledge of Antiquity, he would have
known that the Gentile religions of those times were founded on
different principles, and propagated on different practices. Not
one of those numerous Religions ever pretended to accuse another of
falshood ; and therefore was never itself in danger of being so
accused. They very amicably owned one another’s pretensions; and
all that a new Religion claimed, was to be let into partnership with
the rest, whose common practice was to trade in shares.¢ Yet,
according to this great Philosopher, i¢ was difficult, if not impossible
—it was combating all men in too many respects—It was not proceed-
ing on a sufficient number of principles necessary to be assented to, Sc.
But he can make Men, as well as Religions, change their natures
when he wants them for some glorious mischief. It is his more usual
way, and so it is of all his fellows, to make the People (the gross
body of mankind) run headlong into Religion, without the least
inquiry after evidence. But here we are told it is very difficult, if not
impossible, to induce them to think well of a Religion which hath not
the most plausible evidence for its support: That the not giving them
this, is not proceeding on a sufficient number of principles, but com-
bating all men in too muny respects, δ.
And this is all we can get out of him, FROM THE NATURE OF
THINGS. But as he has raised a curiosity which he knew not how to
gratify, I shall endeavour to supply his ignorance; and from this
nature of things, shew the reader, 1. How the Religions of Moses
and JESUS must NECESSARILY SUPPOSE a dependency on some pre-
ceding. 2. How the ancient Religions of paganism must NECES-
SARILY NOT SUPPOSE any such dependency; and 3. How it came to
pass, that more modern impostors, risen since the coming of Chris-
tianity, imitated the true, rather than the false Religions of ancient
times, in this pretence to dependency.
I. The Parriarcuat, the Jewisu, and the Curist1An Religions,
all professed to come from the only one Gop, the Creator of all
things. Now as the whole race of mankind must be the common
object of its Creator’s care, all his Revelations, even those given only
to a part, must needs be thought ultimately directed to the interest of
the whole : consequently every later Revelation must suppose the
TRUTH of the preceding. Again, when several successive Revelations
* Pp. 23; 24. + See the first volume, book ii. vol. i. p. 36), et seq.
SECT. IT. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 445
are given by him, some less, some more extensive, we must conclude
them to be the parts of ONE ENTIRE DISPENSATION ; which, for rea-
sons best known to infinite Wisdom, are gradually enlarged and
opened: consequently every later must not only suppose the TRUTH
of every preceding Revelation, but likewise their mutual RELATION
and DEPENDENCY. Hence we see, there may be weighty reasons,
why God, from the beginning, should have been constantly giving a
succession of Dispensations and Revelations ; * as this Author, with a
lewd sneer, seems to take a pleasure in observing. If therefore,
what we call the true Revelation came from Gop, these Religions
must needs be, and profess to be, dependent on one another.
IT. Let us see next how the case stood in the ancient Pagan
world. Their pretended Revelations were not from the onE Gop;
but all from local tutelary Deities ; each of which was supposed to
be employed in the care of his οὐ" Country or People, and uncon-
cerned in every Other’s department. Consequently, between earlier
and later Revelations of this kind, there could be no more dependency,
than there was opposition: But each stood on its own foundation,
single, unrelated, and original.
1Π. But when, by the propagation of the Gospel, the knowledge
of the ONLY ONE Gop was spread abroad over the whole earth, and
the absurdities of Polytheism fully understood by the people, an
Impostor, who would now obtrude a new Religion on the world,
must of necessity pretend to have received it from that only one God.
But the probability of his giving a Revelation now, being seen greatly
to depend on his having given one before, our Impostor would be
forced to own the truth of those preceding Religions, which professed
to come from that Gop. And as the credit of the new Religion was
best advanced by its being thought a finishing part of an incomplete
Dispensation, he would, at the same time, bottom it on the preceding.
Besides, as an Impostor must needs want that necessary mark of a
divine Mission, the power of Miracles, he could cover the want no
otherwise than by a pretended relation to a Religion which had well
established itself by Miracles. And thus, in fact, Manomert framed
the idea of his imposture. He pretended his new Religion was the
completion of Christianity, as Christianity was the completion of
Judaism ; for that the world not being to be won by the mild and
gentle invitations of Jesus, was) now to be’ compelled to enter in by
Mahomet. And so again, to complete the imitation, this last and
greatest Prophet, as his followers believe him to be, is pretended to
be foretold in the New Testament, as the Messiah was in the Old.
Thus this notable observation, from whence the Author of the
Grounds and Reasons of the Christian Religion endeavoured to deduce
* Page 22,
4406 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK V.
so discrediting a likeness between all false religion, and what we
believers hold to be the ¢rwe, comes, we see, just to nothing. -
But he has yet another flagrant mark of likeness, in reserve : And
thus he goes on, from discovery to discovery.—In building thus upon
PROPHECY (says he) as a principle, Jesus and his Apostles had the
concurrence of all sects of Religion amongst the Pagans. Is it possi-
ble? Yes. For the Pagans universally built their Religion on
DIVINATION.* As much as to say, the people of Amsterdam, in
building their town-house upon piles, had (in the mode of laying a
foundation) the concurrence of all the cities in England; who built
theirs upon stone, or clay, or gravel. In the Jewish writings there
are Prophecies of a future and more perfect Dispensation ; which,
Jesus claiming to belong to Η15, his Religion was properly built upon
PROPHECIES. The Heathens made Gods of their dead benefactors, and
then consulted them at their shrines, as Oracles; they inspected the
entrails of beasts ; they observed the flight of birds; they interpreted
dreams and uncommon pheenomena ; and all these things they called
DIVINATION. But what likeness is there between these things and
Prophecies, the Prophecies on which Jesus founded his Religion?
Just as much as there is between TRuTH and what these men call
FREE-THINKING. But he has found a device to bring them related.
᾿ΤῚΒ a master-piece ; and the Reader shall not be robbed of it. They
[the Pagans,] says he, learnt that art [Divination] in schools, or
under discipline, as the Jews did prophesying in the schools and col-
leges of the Prophets; where, the learned Dodwell says, the candi-
dates for prophecy were taught the rules of divination practised by
the Pagans, who were skilled therein, and in possession of the art long
before them.t This idle whimsy of the learned Dodwell concerning
the schools of the Prophets has been exposed, as it deserves,
already.t But for the sake of so extraordinary an argument (an
impiety, grafted on its proper stock an absurdity), it deserves to be
admitted, though it be but fora moment. The reasoning then stands
thus : Divination was an art learnt in the schools; so was one kind
of Prophecy, or the Jewish art of Divination: those who learnt this
Jewish-art of divination were taught the rules of pagan divination :
THEREFORE pagan divination and ANOTHER kind of Prophecy, such
as foretold the coming of the Messiah, were things of the same kind.
Incomparable reasoner! and deservedly placed at the head of modern
Free-thinking! But his learning is equal to his sense, and his pre-
misses just as true as his conclusion: The Pagans universally built
their Religion on divination. 1 believe there are few school-boys, who
would not laugh at his blunder, and tell him it was just otherwise,
; oe and Reasons,” &c. pp. 27, 28. + See vol. ii. book iv. sect. 6.
id.
SECT. Il. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 447
that the Pagans universally built divination on their Religion. All
that was ever built on divination was now and then a Shrine or a
Temple. To return:
Π|.
But these prejudices, concerning local tutelary Deities, which made
the introduction of a Theocracy so easy, occasioned as easy a defec-
tion from the Laws of it.
1. For these tutelary Deities owning one another’s pretensions,
there was always a friendly intercourse of mutual honours, though
not always of mutual worship. For at first, each God was supposed
to be so taken up with his own people, as to have little leisure or
inclination to attend to the concerns of others.—Now this prejudice
was the first source of the Jewish idolatry.
2. But the pretensions of these Gods being thus reciprocally
acknowledged: and Some, by the fortunate circumstances of their
followers, being risen into superior fame, the Rites used in their Wor-
ship were eagerly affected. And this was the second source of the
Israelites’ idolatry ; exemplified in the erection of the GOLDEN CALF,
and their fondness for all Egyptian superstitions in general.
3. But of these tutelary deities there being two sorts, GENTILI-
TIAL and LocAL; the one ambulatory, and the other stationed ; the
latter were fixed to their posts, as a kind of hezr-loom, which they who
conquered and possessed the country were obliged to maintain in
their accustomed honours. And whatever gentilitial Gods a People
might bring with them, yet the local God was to have a necessary
share in the religious Worship of the new Comers. Nay it was
thought impiety, even in foreigners, while they sojourned only in a
strange Country, not to sacrifice to the Gods of the place. Thus
Sophocles makes Antigone say to her father, that a stranger should
both venerate and abhor those things which are venerated and
abhorred in the city where he resides.* Celsus gives the reason of
so much complaisance.—“ Because” (says he) ‘‘the several parts of the
world were, from the beginning, distributed to several powers, each of
which has his peculiar allotment and residence.” + And those who
were loth to leave their paternal Gods when they sought new settle-
ments, at least held themselves obliged to worship them with the
Rites, and according to the usages of the Country they came to inhe-
* τόλμα, ξεῖνος
Ἐπὶ ξείνης, ὦ τλᾶμον, ὅ, τι
Καὶ τυόλις τέτροφεν ἄφιλον
᾿Αποστυγεῖν καὶ τὸ φίλον σέβεσθαι.---(αΐρ. Colon. act. i.
+ ᾿Αλλὰ καὶ ὅτι, ὡς εἰκὸς, τὰ μέρη τῆς γῆς ἐξ ἀρχῆς ἄλλα ἄλλοις ἐποπταῖς νενεμημένα
καὶ κατά τινας ἐπικρατείας διειλημμένα, ταύτῃ καὶ διοικεῖται. καὶ δὴ τὰ wap ἑκάστοις
ὀρθῶς ἂν ττράττοιτο ταύτῃ δρώμενα, Orn ἐκείνοις φίλον, τσαραλύειν δὲ οὐχ ὅσιον εἶναι τὰ
ἐξ ἀρχῆς κατὰ τόπους vevoutoueva.—ORIGENES Contra Celsum, lib. v. p. 247. See the
passage, from Plato, pp. 230, 231.
448 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK V.
bit. Against this more qualified principle of Paganism, Moses
thought fit to caution his People, in the following words: When the
Lord thy Gop shall cut off the nations from before thee, whither thou
goest to possess them, and thou succeedest them and dwellest in their
land ; take heed to thyself that thou be not snared by following them,
after that they be destroyed from before thee, and that thou ENQUIRE
NOT AFTER THEIR Gops, saying, HOW did these nations serve their
Gods ! even so witu I vo likewise.* But the adoption of these
new Gops, as well as of their Rites, was so general, that David |
makes his being unjustly driven into an idolatrous land, the same
thing as being forced to serve idolatrous Gods. For thus he expostu-
lates with his persecutor, ‘‘ Now therefore I pray thee let my lord the
king hear the words of his servant: If the Lord have stirred thee up
against me, let him accept an offering: but if they be the children of
men, cursed be they before the Lord; for they have driven me out
this day from abiding in the inheritance of the Lord, saying, Go
SERVE OTHER Gops.’ + ‘To the same principle Jeremiah likewise
alludes, in the following words, Therefore will I cast you out of this
land, into a land that ye know not, neither ye nor your fathers: and
THERE SHALL YE SERVE OTHER Gops day and night, where I will
not shew you favour.t By which is not meant that they should be
Jorced, any otherwise than by the superstitious dread of divine ven-
geance for a slighted worship: for at this time civil restraint in
matters of religion was very rare.
But the imaginary vengeance which the tutelary Gop was supposed
to take on those, who, inhabiting his Land, yet slighted his Worship,
was at length really taken on the Idolatrous Cutheans, when they
came to cultivate the land of Israel. For the Almighty having, in
condescension to the prejudices of the Israelites, assumed the title of
a TUTELARY LOCAL Gop, and chosen Judea for his peculiar regency ;
it appeared but fit that he should discharge, in good earnest, the
imaginary function of those tutelary Gops, in order to distinguish
himself from the lying Vanities of that infatuated age. Therefore
when so great a portion of his Chosen people had been led captive,
and a mixed rabble of Eastern idolaters were put into their place, he
sent plagues amongst them for their profanation of the holy Land.
Which calamity their own principles easily enabled them to account
for. The story is told in these words: ‘‘And the king of Assyria
brought men from Babylon, and from Cuthah, and from Ava, and
from Hamath, and from Sepharvaim, and placed them in the cities of
Samaria, instead of the children of Israel ; and they possessed Sama-
ria, and dwelt in the cities thereof. And so it was, at the beginning
of their dwelling there, that they feared not the Lord; therefore the
* Deut. xii. 29, 30. + 1 Sam. xxvi, 19, t Jer, xvi. 13.
SECT. 11. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 449
Lord sent lions amongst them which slew some of them. Wherefore
they spake to the king of Assyria, saying, The nations which thou
hast removed, and placed in the cities of Samaria, KNOW NOT THE
MANNER OF THE GOD OF THE LAND: therefore he hath sent
lions amongst them ; and behold they slay them, because they know not
the manner of the God of the land. Then the king of Assyria com-
manded, saying, Carry thither one of the Priests—and let him teach
them the manner of the God of the land.—Then one of the Priests
came and dwelt in Bethel, and taught them how they should fear the
Lord. Howbeit every nation made Gods of their own—every nation
in their cities wherein they dwelt.—NSo these nations feared the
Lord, and served their graven images, both their children and their
children’s children, as did their fathers, so do they unto this day.” *
But least this account of the miraculous interposition should be
misunderstood as an encouragement of the notion of local Gods, or
of tntercommunity of worship, rather than a vindication of the sanctity
of that Country, which was consecrated to the God of Israel, the
sacred Historian goes on to acquaint us with the perverse influence
this judgment had on the new inhabitants, so contrary to the divine
intention. ‘They feared the Lord, and served their own Gods after
the manner of the nations, whom they carried away from thence.
Unto this day, they do after the former manners: they fear not the
Lord, neither do they after their statutes, or after their ordinances, or
after the Law and Commandment which the Lord commanded
the children of Jacob whom he named [5.86]. Ὁ They feared the
Lord, and served their own Gods; that is, they feared the vengeance
impending on the exclusion of the Worship of the God of Israel.
But they feared not the Lord, neither did after their Statutes. That
is, they transgressed the Commandment which they found so fre-
quently repeated in the Pentateuch, of joining no other Worship fo
that of the God of Israel.
And this was the true reason why the Kings of Persia and Syria
(when Judea afterwards became a province to them) so frequently
appointed sacrifices to be offered to the God of the land, at Jerusalem,
in behalf of themselves and families. Nor was the practice disused
when the Jews fell under the Roman yoke ; both Julius Czesar and
Augustus making the same provision for the felicity of the Empire.
Hence therefore the ¢hird source of the Jewish idolatries. It was
this superstitious reverence to local Deities within their own depart-
ments, which made them so devoted, while in Egypt, to the Gods of
that Country ; and when in possession of their own land, to the
tutelary Gods of Canaan.
But this intercommunity of Worship, seein by the migration of
* 2 Kings xvii. 24, et seq. + Verses 33, 34,
ViGL.. If; GG
450 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK V.
People and Colonies from one country to another, grew more general;
as those migrations became more frequent. *Till at length the fre-
quency, aided by many other concurrent causes (occasionally taken
notice of in several places of this work), made the intercommunity uni-
versal. And this was the /as¢ source of Jewish idolatries. This drew
them into the service of every God they heard of; or from whom
they fancied any special good might be obtained ; especially the Gods
of all great and powerful Nations. These prejudices of opinion,
joined to those of practice which they had learnt in Egypt, were the
true causes of their so frequent lapse into idolatry.
From all this it appears, that their defection from the Gop of
Israel, wicked and abominable as it was, did not however consist in
the rejecting him as a false God, or in renouncing the Law of Moses
as a false Religion ; but only, in joining foreign Worship and idola-
trous Ceremonies to the Ritual of the true Gop. Their bias to the
idolatries of Egypt was inveterate custom; their inclination for the
idolatries of Canaan was a prevailing principle that the tutelary God
of the place should be worshiped by its inhabitants; and their
motive for all other idolatries, a vain expectation of good from the
guardian Gods of famous and happy Nations.
These were all inflamed by that common stimulation of a debauched
People, the luxurious and immoral rites of Paganism ; for it is to be
observed that these defections generally happened amidst the abuses
of prosperity. There is a remarkable passage in the Book of Joshua
which sets this matter in a very clear light. The Israelites having
lapsed into idolatry, Joshua drew together their Heads and Rulers at
Shechem, in order to a reformation. And the topic, he insists upon
for this purpose, is not, that the God of Israel was the only true God,
the Maker of all things; but that he was the family-God of the race
of Abraham, for which he had done so great things. And this he
prosecutes from the 2d verse of the xxiv. chap. to the 13th. His
conclusion from all this is, ‘‘ Now therefore fear the Lord, and serve
him in sincerity, and in truth, and put away the Gods which your
Fathers served on the other side of the flood and in Egypt.”* How-
ever (continues he) at least make your choice, and either serve the Lord,
or serve the Gods of other People. <‘‘ dnd the people answered, God
forbid we should forsake the Lord to serve other Gods :+ for we
acknowledge him to be that God who has done so great things for us.”
To this Joshua replies, “ Ye cannot serve the Lord; for he is an
holy God: he is a jealous God, he will not forgive your transgres-
sions, nor your sins.’ t From all this, it appears, that the point
debated between Joshua and his People, was not whether the Israelites
should return to God, whom they had rejected and forsaken ; but
* Joshua xxiv. 14. t+ Verses 16, 17. t Verse 19.
SECT. 11. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 451
whether they should serve him oNnty, or, as Joshua expresses it,
serve him in sincerity and in truth. For on their exclaiming against
the impiety of rejecting God,— God forbid, we should forsake the
Lord ; we will still serve him;” meaning along with the other
Gods,—their Leader replies, Ye cannot serve the Lord, for he is an
HOLY God : he is a sEALOUS God. i.e. As a holy God, he will not
be served with the lewd and polluted Rites of the Nations; and as a
jealous God, he will not suffer you to serve Idols of wood and stone,
with his Rites. The consequence is, You must serve him alone, and
only with that worship which he himself hath appointed.
That this was the whole of their Idolatry, is farther seen from the
accounts which the holy Prophets give us of it, in their reproofs and
expostulations.
ἸΒΑΙΑῊ says, To what purpose is the multitude of your Sacrifices
unto me, saith the Lord: Iam full of the Burnt-offerings of Rams,
and the Fat of fed Beasts,* &c. ΤῸ whom are these words addressed ἢ
To those who, besides their numerous Immoralities, there reckoned
up at large, delighted in idolatrous worship in Groves and high
Places. For the Denunciation is thus continued: They shall be
ashamed of the Oaks which ye have desired, and ye shall be con-
founded for the GARDENS that ye have chosen.t He describes them
again in this manner: A People that provoketh me to Anger conti-
nually τὸ MY FACE, that sacrificeth in Gardens, and burneth Incense
upon Altars of Brick.t Yet, at the same time, these men gloried so
much in being the peculiar People of the Lord, that they said, Stand
by thyself, come not near to me, for I am holier than thou.§
JEREMIAH draws them in the very same colours: Though they
say, The Lord liveth, surely they swear falsly,\| 1. e. vainly, idola-
trously. Why? The Reason is given soon after; they swore like-
wise by their idols: How shall I pardon thee for this? thy Children
have forsaken me, and SWORN BY THEM THAT ARE NO GODs.4
Again, Will ye steal, murder, and commit adultery, and SwEAR
FALSLY and BURN INCENSE UNTO Baat, and walk after other Gods
that ye know not [1. 6. strange Gods] ; and come and STAND BEFORE
ME IN THIS HOUSE, which is called by my name, and say, We are
delivered to do all these abominations ?** And in another place we find
them thus expostulating with the Prophet,— Wherefore hath the Lord
pronounced all this Evil against us ? or what is our Iniquity, or what
is our Sin that we have committed against the Lord our Gon? ΤΊ and
the Prophet answering them in this manner,—Jecause your Fathers
have forsaken me, saith the Lord, and walked after other Gods, and
have served them, and have worshiped them, and have forsaken me,
Selsate ie 1}: + Verse 29. 1 Isai. Ixv. 3. § Verse 5. || Jer. v. 2.
4 Verse 7. *e Jer. vil. 9.10. tt Jer. xvi. 10.
2G 2
452 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK V.
and have not kept my Law: And ye have done worse than your
Fathers.* But is it possible they could be so exceeding stupid or
impudent as to talk at this rate, had they ever renounced the REtt-
GION, or the Gon of their Forefathers 7
EzExiE1, likewise, shews plainly that their idolatries consisted in
polluting the Religion of Moses with foreign worship: ‘‘ Son of man,
these men have set up their idols in their heart, and put the stumbling-
block of their iniquity before their Face: SHALL] BE INQUIRED OF at
all by them? Therefore speak unto them, and say unto them, Thus
saith the Lord Gop, Every man of the house of Israel that putteth
up his idols in his heart, and putteth the stumbling-block of iniquity
before his face, and cometh to the Prophet, Τ the Lord will answer
him that cometh according to the multitude of his idols,” &e.+
And again: As for you, O house of Israel, Thus saith the Lord God,
Go ye, serve ye every one his idols, and hereafter also, if ye will not
hearken unto me: but eoLtuTE ye My Hory Name No MORE
with your gifts and with your idols,t i. e. with gifts offered up to me
with idolatrous Rites. In another place he giveth a terrible instance
of this horrid mixture: ‘They have committed adultery, and blood
is in their hands, and with their idols have they committed adultery,
and have also caused their sons, whom they bare unto me, to pass for
them through the fire to devour them. Moreover this they have done
unto me: THEY HAVE DEFILED MY SANCTUARY IN THE SAME DAY,
and have profaned my Sabbaths. For when they had slain their
Children to their idols, then THEY CAME THE SAME DAY INTO MY
SANCTUARY to profane it; and lo, thus have they done in the midst
of mine house.” § These, and innumerable other passages in the
Prophets to the same purpose, evidently shew, that this defection from
the God of Israel consisted not in a rejection of Him, or of his Law.
This appears still more evident from the following considerations :
1. That, in the course of their idolatries, they abused the memo-
rials of their own Dispensation to superstitious Worship. Such as
the Brazen Serpent of Moses ; to which, in the time of their kings,
they paid divine honours.|| And I am much mistaken if the monu-
ment of Twelve stones, taken out of Jordan, and pitched in Gilgal for
a memorial of their miraculous passage,4] was not equally abused.
What induces me to think so, is the following passage of Isatan:
*“Draw near hither, ye sons of the sorceress, the seed of the adul-
terer and the whore. Against whom do you sport yourselves ?—
enflaming yourselves with idols under every green tree, slaying the
children in the valleys under the clifts of the rocks? AMONG THE
SMOOTH STONES OF THE STREAM IS THY PORTION ; they, they are
* Jer. xvi. 11, 12. + Ezek. xiv. 3, 4. t Ezek. xx. 39. § Ezek.
xxiii. 37 —39. || 2 Kings xviii. 4. 4 Joshua iv. 3, 20—22.
SECT. 11. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 453
thy lot: EVEN TO THEM HAST THOU FOURED A DRINK-OFFERING, thou
hast offered a meat-offering. Should I receive comfort in these ?”’*
2. The Israelites were most prone to idolatry in PROSPEROUS
TIMES; and generally returned to the God of their fathers in
ADVERSITY, as appears from their whole history. Against this impo-
tence of mind they were more than once cautioned, before they
entered into the Land of Blessings, that they might afterwards be
left without excuse. ‘And it shall be” (says Moses) ‘when the
Lord thy Gop shall have brought thee into the land which he sware
unto thy fathers, to Abraham, to Isaac, and to Jacob, to give thee
great and goodly cities which thou buildedst not, and houses full of all
good things which thou filledst not, and wells digged which thou
diggedst not, vine-yards and olive-trees which thou plantedst not,
when thou shalt have eaten and be full; then beware lest thou forget
the Lord which brought thee forth out of the Land of Egypt from the
house of bondage. ‘Thou shalt fear the Lord thy Gop and serve him,
and shalt swear by his name. Ye shall not go after other Gods, of
the Gods of the people which are round about you.”’+ However
Moses himself lived to see an example of this perversity, while they
remained in the Wilderness : But Jeshurun (says he) waxed fat, and
kicked : Thou art waxed fat, thou art grown thick, thou art covered
with fatness ; then he forsook God which made him, and lightly
esteemed the Rock of his Salvation.t And the Prophet Hosea as-
sures us, that the Day of prosperity was the constant season of their
idolatry : Israel is an empty vine, he bringeth forth fruit unto himself :
ACCORDING TO THE MULTITUDE OF HIS FRUIT, HE HATH IN-
CREASED THE ALTARS; ACCORDING TO THE GOODNESS OF HIS
LAND THEY HAVE MADE GOODLY IMAGES.§ And again: decording
to their pasture so were they filled ; THEY WERE FILLED, AND
THEIR HEART WAS EXALTED: therefore have they forgotten me.||
This, therefore, is a clear proof that their defection from the God of
Israel was not any doubt of his goodness or his power, but a wanton
abuse of his blessings. Had they questioned the truth of the Law,
their behaviour had been naturally otherwise: they would have
adhered to it in times of prosperity ; and would have left it in adver-
sity and trouble. This the Deists would do well to consider.
3. The terms, in which God’s warnings against this defection are
expressed, plainly shew that their lapse into Idolatry was no rejection
of him: he will have no FELLOWsHIP OF COMMUNION with false
Gods. The names employed to design their idolatries are ADULTERY
and wHoREDOM. And God’s resentment of their defection is perpe-
tually expressed by the same metaphor: which shows that his right
* Isai. ἵν]. 3, et seq. + Deut. vi. 10, et seq.3 viii. 11, et seq. { Deut.
xxxii. 15. § Hosea x. l, || Hosea xiii. 6.
454 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK V.
over them was still acknowledged, just as an adulterous wife owns the
husband’s right, amidst all her pollutions with strangers. Where we
may observe, that though their idolatry is so constantly styled
ADULTERY, yet that of the Pagans never is; though it is very often
called wHorEDOM. ‘The reason of this distinction is plainly intimated
in the following words of Ezekiel: “How weak is thine heart, saith
the Lord God, seeing thou dost all these things, the work of an impe-
rious whorish woman? In that thou buildest thine eminent place in
the head of every way, and makest thine high place in every street,
and hast NOT BEEN AS AN HARLOT (in that thou scornest hire), but
AS A WIFE that committeth apuLTERY, which taketh strangers in-
stead of her husband.”* The Jews had entered into a covenant with
God, which had made them his Peculiar: and when they had violated
their plighted faith, they stood in that relation to him which an
ADULTRESS does to her injured husband. The Gentiles, on the con-
trary, had entered into no exclusive engagements with their Gods,
but the practice of intercommunity had prostituted them, as a common
HARLOT, to all comers.
Thus much, however, must be confessed, that though the very worst
of their idolatry consisted only in mixing foreign Worship with their
own; yet, in their mad attention to those abominable things, God’s
Worship was often so extremely neglected, that He says, by the Pro-
phet, They have forsaken me, the fountain of living waters, just as the
Saint-worshippers in the Church of Rome forsake God, when in their
private devotions the Vulgar think only of their tutelary Saints.
The several principal parts, therefore, of the Israelitish idolatry
were these,
1. Worshiping the true Gop under an image, such as the golden
Calves, 1 Kings xii. 28.
2. Worshiping him in Places forbidden, as in Groves, 2 Kings
xvili, 22, Is. xxxvi. 7.
3. And by idolatrous Rites, such as cutting themselves with knives,
Jer. xli. 5.
4. By profaning the house of Gop with idolatrous images, Jer.
xxx. 34,
5. By worshiping the true Gono and Idols together.
6. And lastly, by worshiping idols alone, Jer. ii. 13. Yet by
what follows, ver. 35, it appears, that even this was not a total apos-
tacy from God.
If the Reader would know what use I intend to make of this
account of the: Jewish idolatry, to the main Question of my Work, I
must crave his patience till we come to the last Volume. If he would
know what other use may be made of it, he may consider what hath
* Ezek. xvi. 30—32.
SECT. 11. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 455
been said above; and be farther pleased to observe, that it obviates
the objection of a sort of men equally unskilled in sacred and profane
Antiquity (of whom more by and by), who, from this circumstance of
the perpetual defection of the Jews into idolatry, would conclude that
the Dispensation of Gop to them could never have been so illustrious
as their history hath represented it. The strength of which objection
rests on these two suppositions, that their idolatry consisted in renounc-
ing the Law of Moses: And renouncing it as dissatisfied of its truth.
Both which suppositions we have shewn to be false: the neglect of
the law, during their most idolatrous practice, being no other than
their preferring impure novel Rites (which most strongly engage the
attention of a superstitious people) to old ones, whose sanctity has no
carnal allurements. As to its original from Gop, they never enter-
tained the least doubt concerning it; or that the Gop of Israel was
the Creator of the Universe: They had been better instructed.—Thus
saith the Lord, the HOLY ONE OF ISRAEL and HIS MAKER.*—As
much as to say, the tutelary God of Israel is the Creator of the Uni-
verse: Indeed, in the period just preceding their captivity, when the
extraordinary providence was gradually withdrawing from them (a
matter to be considered hereafter more at large), they began to
entertain suspicions of Gon’s farther regard to them, as his chosen peo-
ple. But that nothing of this ever contributed to their idolatry is plain
from what we have shewn above, of its being a wanton defection in
the midst of peace, prosperity, and abundance (the confessed effects of
the extraordinary providence*of the God of Israel), and of their
constantly returning to him in times of difficulty and distress.
It is true, that this state of the case, which removes the infidel
objection, at the same time discovers a most enormous perversity in
that People; who, although convinced of the truth of a Religion for-
bidding all intercommunity, was for ever running astray after foreign
Worship. However, would we but transport ourselves into these
times, and remember what hath been said of that great principle of
INTERCOMMUNITY OF worRsHIP; and how early and deeply the
Jews had imbibed all the essential superstitions of Paganism; we
should not only abate of our wonder, but see good cause to make large
allowances to this unhappy People.
But there is another circumstance in this affair too remarkable to be
passed by in silence. As fond as the Jews were of borrowing their
Neighbours’ Gods, we do not find, by any hints in ancient history,
either profane or sacred, that their Neighbours were disposed to bor-
row theirs. Nay, we are assured by Holy Writ, that they did not.
Gop, by the Prophet Ezekiel, addressing himself to the Jews, speaks
on this wise :—dnd the contrary is in thee from other women in thy
“Tsare xlva ll
450 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK V.
WHOREDOMS, WHEREAS NONE FOLLOWETH THEE TO COMMIT
WHOREDOMS: and in that thou givest a reward, and no reward is
gwen to thee ; therefore thou art contrary.* J have shewn, elsewhere,
that, by this, is meant, that no Gentile nation borrowed the Jewish
Rites of Worship, to join them to their own. For as to Proselytes, or
particular men converted to the service of the true God, we find a
prodigious number in the days of David and Solomon.+ So again, in
the Prophet Jeremiah, HATH A NATION CHANGED THEIR Gops,
WHICH ARE YET NO Gops? But my people have changed their
glory for that which doth not profit; t 7. e. Hath any of the nations
brought in the God of Israel into the number of their false Gods, as
the Israelites have brought in theirs to stand in fellowship with the
true? For that the Nations frequently changed their tutelary Gods,
or one Idol for another, is too notorious to need any proof.
This then is remarkable. The two principal reasons of the con-
trariety, I suppose, were these :
1. It was a thing well known to all the neighbouring Nations, that
the God of Israel had an abhorrence of all community or alliance with
the Gods of the Gentiles. This unsociable temper would deter those
people (who all held him as a tutelary Deity of great power) from ever
bringing him into the fellowship of their country Gods. For, after
such declarations, they could not suppose his company would prove
very propitious. And in truth, they had a single instance of his ill
neighbourhood, much to their cost ; which brings me to the second
reason.
2. The devastation he brought upon the Philistines, while the ark
rested in their quarters. For they having taken it from the Israelites
in battle, carried it, as another Palladium,§ to Ashdod, and placed
it in the temple of their God Dagon; who passed two so bad nights
with his new Guest, that on the second morning he was found pared
away to his fishy stump :|| And this disaster was followed with a
desolating pestilence. The people of Ashdod, who hitherto had in-
tended to keep the Ark-as one of their Idol-protectors, now declare ἐξ
should not abide with them, for that the hand of the Gop o¥ ISRAEL
was sore upon them, and upon Dagon their God. They sent it there-
fore to Gath, another of their cities ; and these having carried it about
in a religious procession, it made the same havock amongst them.** It
was then removed a third time, with an intent to send it to Ekron;
but the men of that city, terrified with the two preceding calamities,
refused to receive it, saying they had brought the Ark of the God of
Israel, to slay them and their people.t+ At length the Philistines by
* Ezek. xvi. 34. + 2 Chron. ii. 17. t Jer. τ᾿. 1, § See note F,
at the end of this book. || 1 Sam. v. 4, 5. 4“ Verse 7. **« Verse 9.
tt Verse 10.
SECT. I, OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. ABT
sad experience were brought to understand, that it was the best course
to send it back to its owners: which they did with great honour; with
gifts and trespass-offerings, to appease the offended Divinity.* And
from this time we hear no more of any attempts amongst the Gentile
Nations to join the Jewish Worship to their own. They considered
the God of Israel as a tutelary Deity, absolutely UNsocIABLE ; who
would have nothing to do with any but his own People, or with such
Particulars as would worship him alone ; and therefore, in this respect,
different from all other tutelary Gods; each of which was willing to
live in community with all the rest. This, the historian Josephus
understood to be their sentiment, when he makes the Midianitish
women address the young men of Israel in the following manner: Nor
ought you to be blamed for honouring those Gods which belong to the
Country where you sojourn.t Besides, our Gods are COMMON TO ALL
THE NATIONS, yours to NONE OF THEM.{
And thus the matter rested, till occasion requiring that God should
vindicate his property in that Country which he had chosen for his
peculiar residence, as a tutelary Deity. He then drove the Pagan
inhabitants of Samaria into his worship, just as he had driven the
Philistines from it: and, in both cases, hath afforded to his servants
the most illustrious proofs of divine wisdom, in his manner of con-
ducting this wonderful (Economy to its completion.
But from this circumstance of the inability of the Law to prevent
the Israelites from falling thus frequently into idolatry, a noble Wri-
ter§ has thought fit to ground a charge of imposture against the Law-
giver. It would therefore look like prevarication to let so fair an
opportunity pass by without vindicating the Truth from his misrepre-
sentations ; especially when the nature and causes of that idolatry,
as here explained, tend so directly to expose all his pompous
sophistry.
“One of the most conceivable perfections of a law is” (says his
Lordship), “that it be made with such a foresight of all possible
accidents, and with such provisions for the due execution of it in all
cases, that the law may be effectual to govern and direct these acci-
dents, instead of lying at the mercy of them. Such a law would pro-
duce its effect, by a certain moral necessity resulting from itself, and
not by the help of any particular conjuncture. We are able to form
some general notions of laws thus perfect; but to make them, is
above humanity.—To apply these reflections to the Law of Moses—
We cannot read the Bible without being convinced, that no law ever
* 1 Sam. vi. 3. + See what hath been said above concerning this imaginary
obligation. 1 Μέμψαιτο δ᾽ οὐδεὶς, εἰ γῆς εἰς ἣν ἀφῖχθε τοὺς ἰδίους αὐτῆς Θεοὺς
τοροτρέποισθε' καὶ ταῦτα, τῶν μὲν ἡμετέρων κοινῶν ὄντων wpds ἅπαντας. τοῦ δ᾽ ὑμετέρου
wpos μηδένα τοιούτου Tuyxdvovtos.—Anliq. Jud, lib. iv. cap. vi. sect. 8. § Lord
Bolingbroke.
458 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK V.
operated so weak and uncertain an effect as the Law of Moses did.
Far from prevailing against accidents and conjunctures, the least was
sufficient to interrupt the course and to defeat the designs of it ; to
make that people not only neglect the Law, but cease to acknowledge
the Legislator. To prevent this, was the first of these designs; and
if the second was, as it was, no doubt, and as it is the design or pre-
tence of all laws, to secure the happiness of the people, THIS DESIGN
WAS DEFEATED AS FULLY AS THE OTHER; for the whole history of
this people is one continued series of infractions of the Law, and of
national calamities. So that this law, considered as the particular
law of this nation, has proved more ineffectual than any other law
perhaps that can be quoted. If this be ascribed to the hardness of
heart and obstinacy of the people, in order to save the honour of the
Law, this honour will be little saved, and its divinity ill maintained.
This excuse may be admitted in the case of any human law; but we
speak here of a law supposed to be dictated by divine Wisdom, which
ought, and which would have been able, if it had been such, to keep,
in a state of submission to it, and of national prosperity, even ἃ.
people rebellious and obstinate enough to break through any other.
If it be said the Law became ineffectual by the fault of those who
governed the people, their Judges and their Kings, let it be remem-
bered that their Judges and their Kings were of Gon’s appointment,
for the most part at least; that he himself is said to have been their
King during several ages; that his presence remained amongst them,
even after they had deposed him; and that the High Priest consulted
him, on any emergency, by the Urim and Thummim. Occasional
miracles were wrought to inforce the Law; but this was a standing
miracle, that might serve both to explain and inforce it, by the
wisdom and authority of the Legislator, as often as immediate
recourse to him was necessary. Can it be denied that the most
imperfect system of human laws would have been rendered effectual
by such means as these?” *
I. The sum of his Lordship’s reasoning amounts to this, “that the
Jewish Law being ordained for a certain end, it betrays its imposture
by never being able to attain that end. For, first, if infinite Wisdom
framed the Law, it must be most perfect; and it is essential to the
perfection of a mean, for a Law is nothing but a mean, that it attain
its end. Secondly, if infinite Power administered it, that Power must
have rendered even the most imperfect system effectual to its purpose.”
Thus, we see, his argument, when reduced to order, divides itself
into these two branches; Considerations drawn, first, from the
Wisdom, and, then, from the Power of the Deity, to discredit his
workmanship.
* Lorp BouincBRoke’s ‘* Works,” vol. iii. pp. 292— 294, άϊο. ed.
SECT. 1. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 459
1. We will take him at his best, with the improvement of order ;
and first examine his conclusions from the circumstance of infinite
Wisdom’s framing the Law.
Let us admit then for a moment, that his representation of the end
of the Law is exact; and that his assertion of its never gaining its
end, is true: I answer, that this objection to the divine original of
the Jewiso Law holds equally against the divine original of that
Law of Nature, called the Morat Law. Now his Lordship pretends
to believe that the Moral Law came from Gop: nay, that He was so
entirely the Author and Creator of it, that if he had so pleased, he
might have made it essentially different from what it is. But yet the
experience of all ages hath shewn, that this Law prevailed still less
against accidents and conjunctures than the Mosaic. For if the Jews
were always transgressing their Law till the Captivity, yet after that
disaster they as scrupulously adhered to it; and in that attachment
have continued ever since: whereas, from the day the Moran Law
was first given to mankind, to this present hour, the least accident
was sufficient to interrupt the course, and to defeat the designs of τέ.
How happened it, therefore, that this acknowledged Law of Gop did
not govern and direct accidents, instead of lying at the mercy of them ?
Was it less perfect in its kind than the Mosaic? Who will pretend
to say That, who believes the Moral Law came directly from Gop,
and was delivered intimately to Man, for the service of the whole
Species ; while the Jewish Law came less directly from him, as being
conveyed through the ministry of Moses, for the sole use of the
Jewish People ?
To these questions his Lordship would be ready to answer, ‘‘ That
it is necessary for the subjects of a moral law to be endowed with free
Will: That free Will may be abused; and that such abuses may
render the most perfect system of Laws ineffectual.” But this answer
turns upon his Lordship, when applied to the defence of the Mosaic
Law ; and turns with redoubled force.
We see then how much he was mistaken in concluding, that, be-
cause perfection in its kind is one of the essential qualities of a divine
Law, therefore such a law must of necessity produce its effect. His
best reason for this fancy is, that he is able to form some general
notions of Laws thus perfect. Which is no more than telling us (not-
withstanding his parade of insinuated ability), that he is able to con-
ceive how the Will may be controlled, and how Man may be trans-
formed into a Machine. It is true, he owns, that this fact, viz.
to make laws thus perfect, is above humanity. It is so; and let me
add, as much below the Divinity; whose glory it is to draw his
reasonable creatures with the cords of a man. A Law then, which
produces its effects by a certain necessity, must do it by a necessity
400 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK V,
which is physical, and not moral ; it being the quality of physical, not
of moral necessity, that its effects cannot possibly be defeated.
Thus, we see, all there is of truth in his Lordship’s assertion, of its
being essential to the perfection of a mean that it attain its end,
amounts only to this, A capacity in such a mean to attain its end,
naturally and of itself. And this, we say, was the condition of the
Mosaic Law; whatever might be the actual success.
The qualities of a Law capable of producing its effect, are to be
sought for ἃ priori, as the Schools speak, and not ἃ posteriori: And
if here we find intrinsic marks of excellence in the particular Laws ;
of consummate wisdom in the general Frame and Constitution of
them; and can likewise discover those accidents, which, at some
periods of the Dispensation, hindered the effect; we have done all
that human reason can require, to vindicate this divine Law, from his
Lordship’s imputations of imposture.
To, treat this matter as it deserves, would require a volume, though
not so large as his Lordship’s. But a few words will suffice to give
the reader a general idea of the truth. And a general idea will be
sufficient to shew the futility of the objection.
The admirable provision made by the Jewish Law for preventing
idolatry, may be seen in the following instances.
1. That each specific Rite had a natural tendency to oppose, or to
elude, the strong propensity to idolatrous Worship, by turning certain
Pagan observances, with which the people were besotted, upon a
proper object.—Hence that conrormiry between Jewish and Pagan
Ceremonies, which so vainly alarms, and so vainly flatters, both the
friends and enemies of Revelation.
2. That by their multiplicity, and the frequent returns of their
celebration, they kept the People constantly busied and employed ; so
as to afford small time or leisure for the running into the forbidden
superstitions of Paganism.
3. That the immediate benefits which followed the punctual ob-
servance of the Law had a natural tendency to keep them attached
to it.
4. But lastly, and above all, that the admirable coincidency between
the Institute of Law, and the Administration of Government (whereby
the Magistrate was enabled to punish idolatry with death, without
violating the rights of mankind), went as far towards the actual pre-
vention of idolatrous Worship, as, according to human conceptions,
Civii Law, whether of human or divine original, could possibly go.
And resting the matter here, I suppose, one might safely defy his
Lordship, with all his legislative talents, and his vain boast of them,
to form any general notions of a law more perfect.
But this reasoning on the natural efficacy of the Mosaic Law, by
SECT, IL. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 461
its innate virtue, to prevent and to restrain Idolatry, which it did not
at all times, in fact, prevent and restrain, will be further supported by
this consideration: That the circumstance which, from time to time,
occasioned a defection from the Law, was neither an indisposition to
its establishment ; nor any incoherence in its general Frame and Con-
stitution; nor aversion to any particular part, nor yet a debility or
weakness in its Sanctions. The sole cause of the defection was an
inveterate prejudice, exterior and foreign to the Law. The Israelites,
in their house of bondage, had been brought up in the principles of
LOCAL AND TUTELARY DEITIES and INTERCOMMUNITY OF WOR-
SHIP; principles often referred to, on various occasions, in the course
of this work, for the illustration of the most important truths. In
these Principles, they saw the whole race of mankind agree: and,
from the Practice of them, in the worship of tutelar Deities, they
thought they saw a world of good ready to arise. But not only the
hope of good, but the fear of evil drew them still more strongly into
this road of folly. Their Egyptian education had early impressed
that bugbear-notion of a set of local Deities, who expected their dues
of all who came to inhabit the country which they had honoured with
their protection ; * and severely resented the neglect of payment on
all new comers. ‘This will easily account for the frequent defections
of the Israelites in the divided service of the Gods of Canaan.—But it
is difficult for men fixed down to the impressions of modern manners,
to let themselves into distant times; or to feel the force of motives
whose operations they have never experienced: Therefore, to convince
such men that the early Jewish defections were not owing to any
want of force or virtue in the Law, but to the exterior violence of an
universal prejudice, it may be proper to observe, that, from the Baby-
lonian Captivity to this very time, the Jews have been as averse to
Idolatry under every form and fashion of it, as before they were pro-
pense unto it. If it be asked, what it was that occasioned so mighty
a change? I answer, It was in part, the severity of that punishment
which they had felt ; and in part, the abatement of that foolish pre-
judice which they had favoured, of INTERCOMMUNITY OF WORSHIP:
This, though still as general as ever in the Pagan world, had yet lost
greatly of its force amongst the Jews, since they became acquainted
with the principles of Gentile Philosophy ; the sounder parts of which
being found conformable to the reasonable doctrines of their Religion,
were applied by them to the use of explaining the Law. An use which
this Philosophy was never put to in the place of its birth, on account
of the absurdities of Pagan worship; for this kept the principles of
Philosophy and the practices of Religion at too great a distance to have
* See what has been said on this matter just above, in the case of the Cutkeans,
inhabiting Samaria.
465 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Y.
any influence on one another. Such was the advantage the followers
of the Jewish Law reaped from the Greek Philosophy ; an advantage
peculiar to them ; and which made some amends for the many super-
stitions of another kind, which the mixing Philosophy with Religion
introduced into the practice of the Law: superstitions which depraved,
and at length totally destroyed the noble simplicity of its nature and
genius.—But I anticipate a subject for which 1 shall find a much fitter
place.
At length then we see, that the Law of Moses was, indeed, such a
one as his Lordship would require in a LAW OF DIVINE ORIGINAL,
namely, that ἐέ produced its effect, if not by a physical necessity
which bears down all obstruction before it, yet by a moral, which
constantly kept operating when no foreign impediment stood in the
way! So false is his Lordship’s assertions, that the WHOLE history
of this people is one continued series of infractions of the Law. Τῇ, by
the whole he means (as his argument requires he should mean) the
whole both of their sacred and merely civil history; and, by one con-
tinued series of infractions of the Law, their lapses into Idolatry ;
it is the grossest misrepresentation: the far greater part of their
duration as a distinct People was free from idolatry ; and an authentic
account of this freedom is recorded in their Annals, But if by their
whole history, he means (as his cause might necessitate him to mean)
only the sacred books; and, by their infraction of the Law, only
transgressions in lesser matters, it is illusory and impertinent.
2. We have seen the force of his Lordship’s conclusion from the cir-
cumstance—of infinite Wisdom’s framing the Law : We come next to
the other circumstance, from which he deduceth the same conclusion,
namely infinite Powers administring the Law.
«Let it be remembered” (says his Lordship) “ that Gop himself
is said to have been their King during several ages ; that his presence
remained amongst them, even after they had deposed him; and that
the High Priest consulted him, on any emergency, by the Urim and
Thummim. OccCASIONAL MIRACLES were wrought to inforce the
Law; but this was a standing miracle that might serve both to
explain and inforce it, by the wisdom and authority of the Legislator,
as often as immediate recourse to him was necessary. Can it be
denied that the most imperfect system of human Laws would have been
rendered effectual by such means as these?”
This bad reasoning seems to be urged with much good faith, con-
trary to his Lordship’s usual custom; and arises from his ignorance
of a Theocratic administration,.as the nature of the administration
may be collected from the common principles of the Law of Nature
and Nations.
Let us consider the affair dispassionately. God, in giving laws to
SECT, II. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 463
his chosen people, was pleased, more humano, to assume the title of
King, and to administer their civil affairs by a Theocratic mode of
Government. Every step in this establishment evinces, that it was
his purpose to interfere no otherwise than in conformity to that poli-
tical assumption. He proceeded on the most equitable grounds of
civil Government: he became their King by free choice. It must
needs therefore be his purpose to confine himself to such powers
of legislation, as human Governors are able to exert; though he
extended the powers of administration far beyond the limits of
humanity. His Lordship’s ignorance of so reasonable a distinction
occasioned all this pompous Fallacy. He found in the Mosaic Dis-
pensation OCCASIONAL MIRACLES pretended: and he imagined that,
consistently with this pretence, Miracles ought to operate through-
out, rather than that the end of the Law should be defeated. But, I
presume, Gop could not, conformably to his purpose of erecting a
THEOCRACY, and administring it MORE HUMANO, exert miraculous
powers in Jegislating, though he very well might, and actually did
exert them, in governing : because, in legislation, a miracle, that is,
a supernatural force added to the Laws, to make them constantly
obeyed, could not be employed without putting a force upon the Will ;
by which God’s Laws would indeed produce their effect, but it would
be by the destruction of the subject of them. The case was different
in administring the Laws made: here God was to act miraculously ;
often out of wise choice, to manifest the nature of the Government,
and the reality of his regal character ; sometimes out of necessity, for
the carrying on of that Government on the Sanctions by which it was
to be dispensed : and all this he might do without the least force
upon the Will.
This is sufficient to expose the futility of his Lordship’s conclusion
from the circumstance of infinite Powers administring the Law ; it
being essential to the Law, that infinite Power administring it,
should restrain itself within such bounds as left the Will perfectly
free. But infinite Power, restrained within such bounds, might
sometimes meet with unsurmountable obstructions in the course of
its direction, under a Theocracy administered more humano.
II. We have seen how weak his Lordship’s reasoning is in itself :
Let us now see how much weaker he makes it by ill management ;
till at length it comes out a good argument against his own
objection.
«The Law of Moses” (says his Lordship) ‘ was so far from pre-
vailing over accidents and conjunctures, that the least was sufficient
to interrupt the course and defeat the design of it, to make that peo-
ple not only neglect the Law, BuT CEASE TO ACKNOWLEDGE THE
Lecistator. To prevent this, was the first of these designs : and
464 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK V.
if the second was (as it was, no doubt) and as it is the design or pre-
tence of all Laws, to secure the happiness of the people, THIS DESIGN
WAS DEFEATED AS FULLY AS THE OTHER: for the whole history
of this people is one continued series of INFRACTIONS OF THE Law,
AND OF NATIONAL CALAMITIES.”
To pass by that vulgar mistake (which has been sufficiently
exposed above) that the Jews ever ceased to acknowledge their Legis-
lator ; let me observe it to his Lordship’s credit, that he appears to
have understood so much at least of the Mosaic Institution, as to
see that the first end of it was peculiar to itself; and that that
which is common to all civil Communities was but the second end of
This.
’ But is it not strange, when he saw so far into the nature of the
Jewish Constitution, that he should not see that this second end was
entirely dependent on what he himself makes the principal ; namely,
to preserve the Israelites from idolatry ; but should argue against the
divinity of the Law, as if these ends were independent one of another ;
and that one might be obtained without the other? For, to aggra-
vate the imbecility of the Law, he informs us in the passage last
quoted, “‘ that it was not only unable to gain its first end, but its
second likewise: that the one design was defeated as fully as the
other ; that the people were not only idolaters in spiritual matters, but
poor, miserable, and calamitous in their civil interests.” Strange !
that he could not see, or would not acknowledge, that the Law
denounces their happiness and misery as citizens, in exact proportion
to their adherence to, or their defection from, that Law ; when he
saw and confessed (what their Hisrory records), that this was their
invariable fortune. The whole history of this people (says his Lord-
ship) is one continued series of infractions of the Law, and of national
calamities. Now if the whole frame of the Mosaic Law was so com-
posed, as to do that by positive institute which the moral Law does
by natural, viz. reward the obedient, and punish the disobedient (and it
certainly was so composed, if a continued series of infractions was fol-
lowed by a continued series of calamities), we must needs conclude that
we have here the strongest proof of that divine Wisdom in the Constitu-
tion, which this great modern Law-giver pretends to seek, but assures
us he is not able to find; and yet, at the same time, brings this
convincing circumstance of the ¢ruth of the Law ;—This design (says
he) was defeated as fully as the other. Here his rhetoric, as usual,
got the better of his reasoning: Not content to say,—the whole his-
tory of this People is one continued series of infractions of the Law,—
he will needs add by way of exaggeration—AND OF NATIONAL
cALAMITIES. Which has so perverse an influence on the argument
as to undo all he had been labouring to bring about, by discovering a
SECT. If OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 465
connexion between infractions and calamities, which has all the
marks of a divine contrivance.
Had it been the declared design of their Law-giver to separate the
two ends, and to form such an (Economy as that the People under it
might be flourishing in peace and affluence, while they were Idolaters
in Religion ; or, on the other hand, true Worshippers and, at the
same time, calamitous Citizens; then to find them neither religious
nor prosperous, under a Law which pretended to procure truth with-
out temporal felicity, or to establish peace and prosperity in the
midst of error; this indeed (without taking in the perversity of such
a System) would have fully discredited the pretended original. But
when, in this Law, truth and happiness, error and misery, are
declared to have an inseparable connexion; the freethinking Polli-
tician, who shews from history that this connexion was constant and
invariable, is intrapped by the retorsion of nature and reason, to
prove against himself the Divinity of that Institute he labours to
discredit.
Still further : When, on reading the history of this extraordinary
People, we find (as Josephus well expresses it) that, in proportion to
the neglect of the Law, easy things became unsurmountable, and all
their undertakings, how just soever, ended in incurable calamities,* we
cannot but acknowledge the divine direction in every stage of such a
Dispensation. For, to comprehend the whole of the Historian’s
meaning, we must remember, that there were some Laws given pur-
posely to manifest the divinity of their original: such as that against
multiplying horses; which, when it was trangressed, easy things
became unsurmountable; and that which most facilitates a victory, a
strong body of Cavalry intermixed with Foot, proved amongst the
Israelites a certain means of their defeat. So again, when they
transgressed the Law which commanded all the males to go annually
to the temple, the historian tells us, their most just undertakings
ended in incurable calamities ; and sure nothing could be more just
than to defend their borders from invaders ; yet they were sure to be
most infested with them when they thought themselves best secured :
. that is, while their males were at home, when they should have been
worshiping at the Temple.
Ili. But it is now time to come a little closer to his Lordship. He
has been all along arguing on a FALSE FACT, which his ignorance of
the nature of the Jewish Separation hindered him from seeing.
He understood, indeed, that this extraordinary (economy had, for
its primary end, something very different from all other civil Policies ;
* Kal? ὅσον δ᾽ ἂν ἀποστῶσι τῆς τούτων ἀκριβοῦς ἐπιμελείας, ἄπορα μὲν γίνεται τὰ
ποόριμα, τρέπεται δ᾽ εἰς συμφορὰς ἀνηκέστους, 8, τι wor ἂν ὡς ἀγαθὸν δρᾷν σπουδάσωσιν.
—Antig. vol. i. p. 4.
VOL, 16’. H Η͂
4686 THE DIVINE LEGATION ἢ ROOK V.
and that that which was the first (indeed the only end), in others,
was but the secondary, end in this. Yet this primary end he saw so
obscurely, as not to be able to make it out. He supposed it was to
keep the Israelites from idolatry ; whereas it was TO PRESERVE THE
MEMORY OF THE ONE GOD IN AN IDOLATROUS WORLD, till the
coming of Christ: To seep the Israelites from idolatry, was but the
mean to this end. Thus has our political Architect ‘‘ mistaken the
scaffold for the pile,” as his harmonious friend expresses it. And the
mistake is the more gross, as the notion of the ultimate end’s being
to keep the Israelites from idolatry y, 15. founded in that vain fancy of
Jewish pride, that their Fathers were selected as the favourites of
God, out of his fondness for the race of Abraham.
Under this rectified idea therefore let us consider the truth of his
Lordship’s assertion, That no Law ever operated so weak and uncer-
tain an effect as the Law of Moses did ; far from prevailing against
accidents and conjunctures, the least was sufficient to interrupt the
course, and to defeat the designs of it.
Now if we keep the true end of the Law in view, we shall see, on
the contrary, that it prevailed constantly and uniformly, without the
least interruption, against the most violent accidents, and in the most
unfavourable conjunctures ; those 1 mean, which happened when their
propensity to the practice of idolatry, and their prejudice for the
principle of intercommunity, were at the height: for amidst all
the disorders consequent thereto, they still preserved the knowledge
of the true God, and performed the rites ordained by the Law. And
the very calamities which followed the infraction of the Law, of
which the neighbouring Nations occasionally partook, were sufficient
to alarm these latter, when most at ease, amidst the imaginary pro-
tection of their tutelary Gods, and to awaken them to the awful sense
of a Berne different, as well as superior to their National Protectors.
Which shews, that the Law still operated its effect, strongly and con-
_stantly; and still prevailed against accidents and conjunctures, which
it governed and directed, instead of lying at the mercy of them. But
as it is very probable that the frequent transgressions, which those
accidents and conjunctures occasioned, would in time have defeated
the end of the Law, the transgressors were punished by a seventy-
years-captivity ; the extraordinary circumstances of which made such
an impression on their haughty masters as brought them to confess
that the God of Israel was the true God ; and was so severely felt by
them, that they had an utter aversion and abhorrence of Idolatry, or
the worship of false Gods, ever after. So that from thence to the
coming of Christ, a course of many ages, they adhered, though tribu-
tary and persecuted, and (what has still greater force than Persecu-
tion, if not thoroughly administered) despised and ridiculed by the
SECT, I. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 467
two greatest Empires of the world, the Greek and Roman; and
though surrounded with the pomp and splendour of Pagan idolatries,
recommended by the fashion of Courts, and the plausible glosses of
Philosophers, they adhered, I say strictly, and even superstitiously, te
the letter of that Law, which allowed of no other Gods besides the
God of Israel. Now if this was not gaining its end, we must seek for
other modes of speech, and other conceptions of things, when we rea-
son upon Government and Laws.
Yet this was not all. For the Law not only gained its end, in
delivering down the Religion of the rRuE Gop into the hands of the
REDEEMER OF MANKIND; who soon spread it throughout the
whole Roman Empire; but even after it had done its destined work,
the vigour of the Mosaic Revelation still working at the root, enabled
a bold Impostor to extend the principle of the unrry still wider,
till it had embraced the remotest regions of the habitable World :
So that, at this day, almost all the Natives of the vast regions of
higher Asia, whether Gentiles, Christians, or Mahometans, are the
professed worshipers of the ONE ONLY Gop. How much the
extension of the principle of the Unity has been owing to this Cause,
under the permission and direction of that Providence, which is ever
producing good out of evil, is known to all who are acquainted with
the present state of the Eastern world.
The reason why I ascribe so much of this good, to the lasting
efficacy of the Mosaic Law, is this: Mahumet was born and brought
up an Idolater, and inhabited an idolatrous Country ; so that had he
seen no more of true Religion than in the superstitious practice of the
Greek Church, at that time over-run with saint and image-worship,
it is odds but that, when he set up for a Prophet, he might have
made Idolatry the basis of his new Religion: But getting acquainted
with the Jews and their Scriptures, he came to understand the folly
of Gentilism and the corruptions of Christianity ; and by this means
was enabled to preach up the doctrine of the onE Gop, in its purity
and integrity. It is again remarkable, that to guard and secure this
doctrine, which He made the fundamental principle of Ishmaelitism,
he brought into his Imposture many of those provisions which Moses
had put in practice to prevent the contagion of idolatry.
But the great Man with whom we have to do, is so secure of his
fact, namely that the Law was perpetually defeated, and never gained
its end, that he supposes his Adversaries, the Divrnes, are ready
to confess it; and will only endeavour to elude his inference by
throwing the ill success of its operations on the hardness of the Peo-
ples hearts and the impiety of their Governors.* And this affords
him fresh occasion of triumph.
* Pp. 293, 294.
Dd jet) Wy
403 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK V.
I will not be positive that this species of Divines is intirely of his
own invention, and that this their apology for Moses is altogether as
imaginary as their famous ConrepERACy * against God; because I
know by experience that there are of these Divines, who, in support
of their passions and prejudices, are always ready (as I have amply
experienced) to admit what Scripture opposes, and to oppose what it
admits, in almost every page. But the best Apologies of such men
are never worth a defence, and indeed are rarely capable of any.
To conclude: Such as these here exposed, are all the reasonings of
his Lordship’s bulky volumes: And no wonder ; when a writer, how-
ever able in other matters, will needs dictate in a Science of which he
did not possess so much as the first principles.
SECTION III.
Havine thus shewn the nature of this THEocracy, and the attend-
ant circumstances of its erection ; our next enquiry will be concerning
its DURATION.
Most writers suppose it to have ended with the JupGzs ; but scarce
any bring it lower than the carriviry. On the contrary, I hold
that, in strict truth and propriety, it ended not ’till the coming of ©
Curist. ω
I. That it ended not with the Judges, appears evident for these
reasons :
1. Though indeed the People’s purpose, in their clamours for a
King, was to live under a Gentile Monarchy like their idolatrous
neighbours (for so it is represented by God himself, in his reproof of
their impiety) ; + yet in compassion to their blindness, he, in this
instance, as in many others, indulged their prejudices, without expos-
ing them to the fatal consequence of their project : which, if complied
with, in the sense they formed it, had been the withdrawing of his
extraordinary protection from them, at a time when they could not
support themselves without it. He therefore gave them a King ; but
such an one as was only his viceroy or Deputy ; and who, on that
account, was not left to the People’s election, as he left his own
Regality ; but was chosen by himself: the only difference between
God’s appointment of the Judges and of Saul being this, that They
were chosen by internal impulse; He, by Lots, or external desig-
nation. .
2. This king had an unlimited executive power ; as God’s Viceroy
must needs have.
3. He had no /egislative power : which a Viceroy could not possibly
have.
4. He was placed and displaced by God at pleasure: of which, as
* Vol. v. pp. 305—307, 393. + 1 Sam. viii. 7.
SECT. 111. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 469
Viceroy, we see the perfect fitness ; but as Sovereign by the people’s
choice, one cannot easily account for; because God did not chuse to
supersede the natural Rights of his People, as appears by his leaving
it, at first, to their own option whether they would have God himself
for their King.
5. The very same punishment was ordained for cursing the King
as for blaspheming God, namely, stoning to death: and the reason is
intimated in these words of Abishai to David, Shall not Shimei be put
to death for this, because he cursed the Lorv’s ANOINTED? * This
was the common title of the Kings of Israel and Judah, and plainly
denoted their office of Viceroyalty: Improperly, and superstitiously
transferred, in these later ages, to Christian Kings and Princes.
From this further circumstance, a Viceroyalty is necessarily infer-
red: The throne and kingdom of Judea is all along expresly declared
to be God’s throne and God’s kingdom. ‘Thus, in the first book of
Chronicles, it is said that So/omon sat on the THRONE OF THE LORD,
as King, instead of David his father.t And the queen of Sheba,
who visited Solomon, to be instructed in his wisdom, and doubtless
had been informed by him of the true nature of his kingdom, compli-
ments him in these words: Blessed be the Lord thy God, which
delighted in thee to set thee on HIS THRONE, TO BE KING FOR THE
Lorp Tuy Gov.{ In like manner Abijah speaks to the house of
Israel, on their defection from Rehoboam: And now ye think to
withstand the KINGDOM OF THE LorpD in the hands of the sons of
David. And to the same purpose, Nehemiah: Nezther have our
kings, our princes, our priests, nor our fathers, kept thy law, nor heark-
ened unto thy commandments, and thy testimonies wherewith thou
didst testify against them. For they have not served thee in THEIR
K1INGDOM.|| The sense, I think, requires that the Septuagint reading
should be here preferred, which says EN BASIAEIAs SOY, τν THy
Kinepom. And this the Syriac and Arabic versions follow. As
Judea is always called his kingdom, so he is always called the King of
the Jews. Thus the Psalmist: Thine Altars, O Lord of Hosts, my
Kine, and my God.| And again: Let Israel rejoice in him that
made him: let the children of Zion be joyful in their Kine.** And
thus the Prophet Jeremiah: The Kino, whose name is the Lord of
Hosts.4-+
7. The penal Laws against idolatry were still in force during their
Kings, and put in execution by their best rulers, and even by men
inspired. Which, alone, is a demonstration of the subsistence of the
THrocracy; because such laws are absolutely unjust under every
other form of Government.
* 2 Sam. xix. 21. + 1 Chron. xxix. 23. 12 Chron. ix. 8. § 2 Chron.
xiii, 8. || Neh. ix. 35. q Psalm Ixxxiv, 3. ** Psalm cxlix, 2.
tt Jer. li. 57.
470 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK V.
As to the title of King given to these Rulers, this will have small
weight with those who reflect that Moses likewise, who was surely no
more than God’s deputy, is called King: Moses commanded us a Law ;
even the inheritance of the congregation of Jacob. And he was Kine
in Jeshurun, when the heads of the people, and the tribes of Israel
were gathered together.* ;
Let us now see what the celebrated M. Le Clerc says in defence of
the contrary opinion, which supposeth the THrocracy to have ended
with the Judges. Father Simon of the Oratory had said, that the
republic of the Hebrews never acknowledged any other CHiEF than
God alone, who continued to govern in that quality, even during the |
time in which it was subject to Kings.t This was enough to make
his learned adversary take the other side of the question ; who being
piqued at Simon’s contemptuous slight of his offered assistance in
the project for a new Polyglott, revenged himself upon him in those
heentious 7 Letters, intitled, Sentimens de quelques Theologiens de
Hollande, where his only business is to pick a quarrel. He therefore
maintains against Simon, That the theocracy ceased on establishing
the throne in the race of David.§ What he hath of argument to
support this opinion is but little; and may be summed up in the
following observation, That God did not PERSONALLY interfere with
his directions, nor discharge the functions of a Magistrate after the
establishment of the Kings as he had done before.|| But this, instead
of proving the abolition of the Theocracy, only shews that it was
administered by a Viceroy. For in what consists the office of a
Viceroy but to discharge the functions of his Principal? He had
been a cipher, had God still governed immediately as before. Mr. Le
Clere could see that God acted by the ministry of the Judges.§ If
then the Theocratic function could be discharged by deputation, why
might it not be done by Kings as well as Judges? The difference, if
any, 1s only from less to more, and from occasional to constant. No,
says our Critic, the cession was in consequence of his own declaration
to Samuel: For they have not rejected thee, but they have REJECTED
* Deut. xxxiii. 4, 5, + ‘La Republique des Hebreux differe en cela de tous
les autres états du monde, qu’elle n’a jamais reconnu pour chef que Dien seul, quia
eontinué de la gouverner en cette qualité dans les tems mémes, qu’elle a été sotimise ἃ
des rois.”— Histoire Crit. de Vieux Test. p. 15, ed. Rotterd. 1685. 1 See note G,
at the end of this book. § ‘Il paroit au contraire par l’Ecriture, que Dieu n’a
gouverné la republique des’ Hebreux, en qualité de chef politique, que pendant qu’ils
n’avoient point des rois, et peut-étre au commencement que les rois furent etablis, avant
que la famille de David fut affermie sur le tréne de Israel.””—Sentimens, &c. Ὁ. 78.
|| ‘* Pendant tout ce temps-la, Dieu fit les fonctions de roi, Il jugeoit des affaires—il
repondoit par l’oracle—il regloit la marche de l’armée—il envoyoit méme quelquefois un
ange—On n’étoit obligé d’obeir aveuglement, qu’aux seuls ordres de Dieu. Mais lors
qwil y eut des rois en Israél, et que le royaume fut attaché a la famille de David, les
rois furent maitres absolus, et Dieu cessa de faire leurs fonctions.”—Pp. 78, 79.
{] ‘‘ Au lieu qu’auparavant Dieu lui-méme la faisoit, par le ministere des Juges, qu'il
suscitoit de temps en temps au milieu d’Israél.”— Defense des Sentimens, p. 121.
SECT, IIL, OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 471]
ME, that I should not reign over them.* This only declares the sense
God had of their mutinous request ; but does not at all imply that he
gave way to it. For who, from the like words (which express so
natural a resentment of an open defection) would infer in the case of
any other monarch, that he thereupon stepped down from his throne,
and suffered an usurper to seize his place? This, we see, was poor
reasoning. But, luckily for his reputation, he had an Adversary who
reasoned worse.—However Simon saw thus much into Le Clerc’s
cavil, as to reply, That all he had said was quite beside the purpose,
Sor that the thing to be proved was, that, after the establishment of
the Kings, God was no longer the civil Chief.t On which Le Clerc
thus insults him: As much as to say, that in order to prove God was
no longer Chief of the Hebrews after the election of a King, it is
beside the purpose to shew, he never afterwards discharged the func-
tions of a Chief of the republic. It is thus this great Genius happily
unravels matters, and discovers, in an instant, what is, and what ts not
to the purpose.t Whether Simon indeed knew why Le Clere’s objec-
tion was nothing to the purpose, is to be left to God and his own
conscience, for he gives us no reasons for the censure he passes on it :
but that it was indeed nothing to the purpose, is most evident, if this
proposition be true, ‘‘ That a King does not cease to be King, when
he puts in a Viceroy, who executes the regal office by deputation.”
Le Clere returns to the charge in his Defense of the Sentiments :—
“The Israelites did not reject God as Protector, but as civil Chief,
as I observed before. They would have a King who should determine
sovereignly, and command their armies. Which, before this, God
himself did by the ministry of the Judges, whom he raised up, from
time to time, from the midst of Israel. In this sense we must
understand absolutely the words of God, in Samuel, that I should not
reign over them.’§ It is indeed strange, that, after writing two
books, he should still insist on so foolish a paralogism,|| That God’s
* © C’est pour cela que Dieu dit 4 Samuel, lors qu’ Israél voulut avoir un rot pour le
Juger ἃ la maniére de toutes les nations : ce n'est pas toi qwils ont rejetté, mais moi,
afin que je ne regne point sur eux. 1 Sam. viii. 7.” { ‘*Je passe sous silence le
long diseours de Mr. le Clere touchant le pouvoir de Dieu sur les Israelites avant
letablissement des rois, d’ou il pretend prouver que Dieu pendant tout ce temps-la fit la
fonction de roi. Tout cela est hors de propos, puis qu'il s’agit de prouver, qu’apres ces
temps-la Dieu n’a plus été leur chef: et c’est ce qu’on ne prouvera jamais.”—Reponse
aux Sentimens de quelques Theol. de Hol. p. 55. 1 “C’est a dire, que pour prouver
que Dieu n’a pas été chef des Hebreux, apres l’election des rois, il est hors de propos de
prouver 4111] n’a plus fait les fonctions de chef de la republique. C’est ainsi que ce
grand genie debrouille heureusement les matieres, et découvre d’abord ce qui est hors de
propos, de ce qui ne l’est pas.” —Defense des Sentimens, p. 120. § “ Les Israel-
ites ne rejetterent pas Dieu comme protecteur, mais comme chef politique, ainsi que
je Vai marqué. [15 vonlurent un roi qui les jugeat souverainement, et qui commandat
leurs armées, au lieu qu’auparavant Dieu lui-méme le faisoit, par le ministere des juges,
qu il suscitoit de temps en temps au milieu d’Israel.—En ce sens il faut entendre abso-
lument les paroles de Dieu dans Samuel, afin que je ne regne point sur eux.”—P. 121.
|| However, foolish as it is, the Reader hath seen, how a late Sermonizer has borrowed
it, and how little force he has added to it.
472 . THE DIVINE LEGATION _ BOOK Y.
giving up his office of civil Chief, was a necessary consequence of the
People’s demanding it. For, that they did demand it, I acknowledge.
Let us consider then this whole matter a little more attentively.
Samuel (and 1 desire the Deists would take notice of it) had now,
by a wise and painful direction of affairs, restored the purity of
Religion, and rescued his Nation from the power of the Philistines,
and their other hostile neighbours ; against whom they were utterly
unable to make head when he entered upon the public Administra-
tion. At this very time, the People, debauched, as usual, by power
and prosperity, took the pretence of the corrupt conduct of the
Prophet’s two sons,* to go-in a tumultuary manner, and demand a
King. But the secret spring of their rebellion was the ambition of
their leaders ; who could live no longer without the splendour of ἃ
regal Court and Houshold; Give ΜῈ (say they, as the Prophet
Hosea interprets their insolent demand) A KING AND PRINCES ;}
where every one of them might shine a distinguished Officer of State.
They could get nothing when their affairs led them to their Judges’
poor residence, in the Schools of the Prophets, but the Girr of the
Holy Spirit ;t which a Courtier, I presume, would not prize even at.
the rate Simon Magus held it, of a paultry piece of money.—This it
was, and this only, that made their demand criminal. For the
chusing Regal rather than Aristocratic Viceroys was a thing plainly
indulged to them by the Law of Moses, in the following admonition :
When thou art come into the land which the Lord thy God giveth thee,
and shalt possess it, and shalt dwell therein, and shalt say, I will set
a Kine over me, like as the nations that are about me: Thou shalt in
any wise set him King over thee, whom the Lorv THY GoD SHALL
CHUSE: one from amongst thy Brethren shalt thou set King over thee :
Thou mayest not set a Stranger over thee which is not thy brother.§
‘The plain meaning of which caution is, that they should take care,
when they demanded a King, that they thought of none other than
such a King who was to be Gov’s Deputy. As therefore Court-
ambition only was in the wicked view of the Ringleaders of these.
malecontents, and no foolish fears for the State, or hopes of bettering
the public Administration ; it is evident to all acquainted with the
genius of this Time and People, that compliance with their demand
must have ended in the utter destruction of the Mosaic RELIGION as
well as Law. But it was Gop’s purpose to keep them SEPARATE, in
order to preserve the memory of himself amidst an idolatrous World.
And this not being to be done but by the preservation of their
Religion and Law, we must needs conclude that he would not give
way to their rebellious demand.
“ 1 Sam. viii. 5; xii. 12. + Hosea xiii. 10.
- t 1 Sam. x. 10; xix.
§ Peut. xvii. 14, 15,
SECT, ὙΠ OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 473
And what we are brought to conclude from the reason of the thing,
the history of this transaction clearly enough confirms. For it having
now informed us how Gop consented to give this People a King ;
To shew us, that he had not cast off the Government, but only trans-
ferred the immediate Administration to a Deputy, and consequently,
that their King was his Viceroy ; it tells us next, how He was pleased
to bring them to repentance in an extraordinary way ; the gracious
method he commonly employed when he intended to pardon. Samuel
assembled the People ;* and to convince them of their crime in
demanding a King, called down the present vengeance of their
offended Gon in a storm of thunder and rain at the time of wheat-
harvest.+ This sudden desolation brings them to a sense of their
guilt, and they implore mercy and forgiveness: ‘‘ And all the People
said unto Samuel, Pray for thy servants unto the Lord thy God, that
we die not; for we have added unto all our sins this evil, to ask us a
King. And Samuel said unto the People, fear not: (ye have done all
this wickedness: yet turn not aside from following the Lord, but
serve the Lord with all your heart; and turn ye not aside: for then
should you go after vain things, which cannot profit nor deliver, for
they are vain:) For the Lord will not forsake his People, for his
great Name’s sake: because it hath pleased the Lord to make you his
People.’t Here, we see, they repent, are pardoned, and received
again into Grace, as appears by the concluding promise, that the
Theocratic form should be continued. They are ready to give up
their King, and yet a regal character is instituted. The plain conclu-
sion from all this is, that their King was given, and, now at least,
received as GOD'S DEPUTY.
But Father Simon is at length provoked into a Reason, and that,
to say the truth, no weak one. God, he observes, kept the election
of their King in his own hands.§ But this, Le Clere says, proves
nothing. How so? Because, according to this reasoning, we should
be obliged to say that God oftener discharged the functions of civil
Chief in the idolatrous realm of the ten Tribes than in that of Judah :
for that was elective, this, hereditary.|| And what if we do? Where
will be the harm of it? The two kingdoms made up but one Com-
monwealth ; of which God, as Head, governed by two Viceroys. And
* 1 Sam. xii. t+ Verses 17, 18. t Verses 19, et seq. § “Rt
une preuve méme qu'il ne cessoit pas d’étre leur chef par cette election, c’est qu'il s’en
rend le maitre.”—Reponse aux Sentimens, p. 55. || “* Pour ce que dit M. Simon,
que Dieu se rend maitre de election des Rois, il ne s’ensuit nullement qu’il continuat
aétre pour cela chef politique de la republique d’Israél; puisque si cela étoit, il
faudroit dire que Dieu faisoit beaucoup plus souvent les fonctions de chef de Vetat dans
le royaume Idolatre des dix tribes, que dans celui de Juda. Car ce derniere royaume
étoit hereditaire, et étoit possedé par la maison de David, sans qu'il fut besoin d’aucune
election, au lieu quwil le fit plusieurs elections dans celui des dix tribes.’’—Defense des
Sentimens, pp. 121, 122.
474 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK ν.
if he oftener acted immediately in the kingdom of Israel, there was a
plain reason for it; Its inhabitants were more given to idolatrous
worship ; and needed more the frequency of an extraordinary restraint.
And, in effect, we find he did interfere greatly in other instances, as
well as in the election of their Kings.
In truth, F. Simon seemed to see as little into the force of the
observation (that God reserved the choice of their King to himself)
when he urgéd it, as M. Le Clere did, when he despised it: yet it is
strongly conclusive for the continuation of the Theocracy. For had
the visible King which the Israelites demanded been granted to them, -
that is, a King in his own right, sovereign, and at the head of a new
Constitution, or indeed, any other than a Viceroy to the Krne of the
Theocracy, the choice of him would have been reserved to the People.
It was a natural right; and more than that, a right which God did
not think fit to take from them, when he first accepted the regal
office for himself. But if the People have, by natural Law, a right to
chuse their own King, that King hath, by civil Law, a prerogative to
chuse his own Deputy. When we see him therefore exercise this
prerogative, we may be assured that the King chosen was no other
than his Deputy, as Soverrren of the Theocracy. But to return to
the two Combatants.—Here the Dispute ended ; and for farther satis-
faction, Le Clerc refers us to a book of Spencer’s, written professedly
upon this very subject.* It is his tract De Theocratia Judaica.
What is to be found there, besides the arguments which Le Clere has
borrowed from it, and which have been considered already, I shall
now with some reluctance inform the Reader.
This treatise is by no means in the number of those on which Spen-
cer raised his reputation. He goes on a wrong hypothesis; he uses weak
arguments ; and he is confused and inconsistent in his assertions.
1. He thinks the Theocracy was established by degrees,+ and
abrogated by degrees.t A conceit highly absurd, as Gop was the
Lawgiver, and Supreme Magistrate of the Jews.—He thinks the
first step to its introduction was their protection at the Red Sea ;§
and the first step to its abolition, their demand of a King:|| That it
was still more impaired when Saul and David got possession of the
* “Tl n’est pas necessaire que je m’arréte d’avantage A cela, aprés ce qu’en a dit le
savant Spencer dans un traité qu’il a fait expres sur cette matiere. Lib. i. de Legg.
Heb. Ritual.” — Defense des Sentimens, p- 122. +’ Neminem in sacris literis vel
mediocriter versatum latere potest Theocratiam in ipso rerum Israeliticarum exordio
aliquatenus obtinuisse, ad ἀκμὴν autem non nisi gradatim et post legem in Sinai datam
pervenisse.”—Vol. i. p. 239. 1 “Cum autem regiminis hujus, non simul et semel,
sed per gradus quosdam, jacturam fecerint, placet hic veritatis fugientis vestigia grada-
tim premere.”—Idem, ibid. § “ Gradum primum ad potestatem regiam obtinendam
fecisse videtur Deus, cum gentem Israeliticam insigni illo potentie et bonitatis sue
documento (Aigyptiorum in Mari Rubro submersione) sibi devinxisset.”—Idem, ibid.
|| ** Primo itaque ad certum affirmo, quod Israelite, regem sibi dari postulantes, gradum
primum ad imperii hujus desideratissimi ruinam fecisse videantur.”—Idem, ibid.
SECT. 111. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 475
throne :* That it approached much nearer to its end when it became
hereditary, under Salomon: + and yet, for all this, he confesses that
some obscure footsteps of it remained even to the time of Carist.ft
2. In his reasoning for the abolition of the TuEocracy, instead of
employing the general principles of civil Policy, which were the only
means of coming to the truth, he insists much on the disuse of Urim
and Thummim, §c. which Le Clere borrowed from him; and which
hath been already considered. He brings the despotic power of the
Kings,§ as another argument ; which, | think, proves just the con-
trary. For if so be, that these Kings were the Viceroys of God,
whose power was despotic, their power must be despotic too, i. e.
independent on all but the Soverrien. Not so, if they were
Monarchs in their own right.
3. Though, as we observed, Spencer, in the second section of his
fourth chapter, supposes a gradual decay of the Theocracy ; and that
even some obscure footsteps of it remained to the time of Curist ;
yet, in the following section, he, all the way, argues upon the suppo-
sition of an absolute and entire abrogation|| by the establishment of
the Kings. To proceed.
II. That this Theocracy, the administration of which lay, as it were,
in abeyance during the Captivity, was again exercised after the return
from it, is evident from the express declaration of the Almighty, by
the Prophet Haggai: Yet now be strong, O Zerubbabel, saith the Lord,
and be strong, O Joshua, Son of Josedech the High Priest, and be
strong, all ye People of the Land, saith the Lord, and work: for I
am with you, saith the Lord of Hosts ; AccoRDING TO THE WorRD
THAT I COVENANTED WITH YOU WHEN YOU CAME OUT oF EeypT,
so My SPIRIT REMAINETH AMONGST You: fear ye not.** What
was that Covenant ? That Israel should be his People, and He, their
God and King. ‘Therefore it cannot barely mean, that he would be
their God, and they should be his People ; for this was but part of the
Covenant. Nor can it mean that they should be conducted by an
extraordinary providence, as at their coming out of Egypt, and during
the first periods of the Theocracy ; for this was but the effects of the
Covenant : and besides, we know that that dispensation of Providence
soon ceased after the Re-establishment. The meaning therefore must
be, that he would still continue their Kine as well as God. Yet at
* “Dei regimen multo magis imminutum est, cum Deus Saulem et Davidem ad
rerum arbitrium evocasset.”—P. 240. + ‘‘Salomone rerum potito, Theocratia
multo vicinior ἀφανισμῷ non immerito censeatur.” t ‘* Judi Theocratize
veteris indicia et vestigia quedam obscuriora, ad extrema usque politi sue tempora
retinuere—ipso Domini nostri seculo, Hierosolyma civitas magni regis audiit.””—Ibid.
§ ἐς Adeo ut hine constet, eos se pro regibus gessisse, et potestatem arbitrariam exer-
euisse.’’—Ihbid. || ““ Regiminis hujus mutati vel abrogati causa principalis—De
regiminis hujus abrogati effectu vel eventu breviter disserendum est,” &c.—Pp, 241 -
248, 4 See note Η, at the end of this book. ** Haggai ii. 4, ὃ.
476 . THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK V.
the same time, when this Theooracy was restored, it was both fit on
account of its own dignity, and necessary for the People’s assurance,
that it should be attended with some unusual display of divine favour.
Accordingly, Prophets were raised up; and an extraordimary Provi-
dence for some short time administered, as appears from many places
in those Prophets.*
III. That the Theocracy continued even to the coming of Curist,
may be seen from hence.—
1. Whenever it was abrogated, it must needs be done in the same
solemn manner in which it was established ; so that the one might be
as well known as the other: because it was of the highest importance
to a people so strictly bound to obedience, not to be mistaken con-
cerning the power under which they lived. Natural equity requires
this formality as a necessary concomitant in the imposing and abrogat-
ing of all civil laws and institutions whatsoever. Now the Theocracy
having never been thus abolished till the coming of Christ, we conclude
that it continued to subsist till that time.
2. Nor indeed, could it have been abolished without dissolving the
whole frame of the Republic; since all the Laws of it, whether as to
their equity, force, or fitness, as well as the whole Ritual of Worship,
respected, and referred to God as civil Governour. But neither by the
declaration of any Prophet, nor by the act of any good King, did the
Institution suffer the least change in any of its parts, from the time of
its establishment by Moses to its dissolution by Jesus Curist, either
by addition, correction, or abrogation. Consequently, the Theocracy
was existing throughout that whole period: Nothing being more absurd
than to suppose that national Laws, all made in reference to the form
of Government, should remain unvariable, while the Government itself
was changed. For what the Author of the Epistle to the Hebrews
says of the Prixst (in a Constitution where the two Societies were
incorporated) must be equally true of the Kinc.—Tue PriestHoop
BEING CHANGED, THERE IS MADE ALSO, OF NECESSITY, A CHANGE
OF THE Law.t And now it was that Jesus, the ΜΈΒΒΙΑΗ, who is
here spoken of as making this change, in quality of Prirst, made
it likewise in quality of Kina. For, as we learn from the history of
his Ministry, he came as Heir of Gop, to succeed immediately without
any interregnum, in his Father’s kingdom: Gop having DELIVERED
up to his Son the kingdom, of which the Father was, till then, in
possession. And this change in the Government, from the ¢emporal
Theocracy of Gop the Father, to the spiritual Kingdom of Gop the
Son, was made in the same solemn and authentic manner in which that
Theocracy was introduced. Gop raised up from amongst his chosen
People, a Prophet like unto Moses, who exercised the Legislatwe power,
* Haggai i. 6—11 ; ii, 16—19; Zech. viii. 12; Mal. iii. 10, 11. + Heb. vii- 12.
SECT. II. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 477
like Moses ; and assumed the Regal power, like Gop. He gave a New
Law to be administered in a NEW Ki1nGpom, and confirmed the divinity
of the Dispensation by the most stupendous miracles. Thus, we find,
-the Theocracy did indeed subsist till the coming of Christ.
And this ABoLiTIon of it by the Son of Gop, I take to be the true
completion of that famous propHEcy of Jacob, of which so much
hath been written and disputed. Tur Sceprre SHALL NOT DEPART
FROM JUDAH, NOR A LAWGIVER FROM BETWEEN HIS FEET, UN-
TIL SHILOH COME,* i. 6. the THrocracy shall continue over the
Jews} until Christ come to take possession of his Father’s Kingdom :
For there never was any Lawgiver,t in Judah, but Gop by the minis-
try of Moses, until the coming of his Son.
Jesus the Messiau, the best interpreter of the Oracles of Gon, of
which he himself is the capital subject, and for whose sake the chain
of Prophecies was so early drawn out, and extended to such a length,
seems to have paraphrased and explained the words of Jacob concern-
ing the departure of the Sceptre from Judah, by his declaration
-recorded in St. Matthew, Tar PropHets AND THE LAW PROPHE-
SIED TILL JOHN,§ i. 6. “the Mosaic Law, and the Theocratic
Government by which it was dispensed, continued in Being till the
approach of this harbinger of Christ, John the Baptist ; but was then
superseded by the promulgation of a new Law and the establishment
of a new Kingdom.”
But as this interpretation is so different from the common, and
understands the Prophecy as foretelling that the Jewish nation should
not be bereft of Sovereign Power, by falling under a foreign Yoke, till
the Advent of the Mess1ran, the Reader will excuse me, if I detain
him a little longer on so important a subject.
The common notion of the Sceptre of Judah, is explained three dif-
ferent ways, each of which has its particular Followers.
1. Some suppose the Sceptre of Judah to signify the SOVEREIGNTY
OF THE JEwisH NATION at large.
2. Others again suppose it to signify the SOVEREIGNTY OF THE
TRIBE OF JUDAH.
3. And a third sort contend that it signifies not a sovereign or regal,
but a TRIBAL SCEPTRE only.
In the Sense of a Sovereignty in the Jewish people at large, which
is the most general interpretation, and, in my Opinion, the most natu-
ral of the three (as the whole People were long denominated from that
* Gen..xlix. 10. + Who took their Name from the Tribe of Judah ; the rest
being incorporated in that Tribe, or extinguished in Captivity. 1 Mhhokek, Legis-
lator, aut Legis interpres. But the first is its original and proper Signification. And
thus Isaiah [chap. xxxiii. 22.] “‘The Lord is our Judge, the Lord is our LAWGIVER
[ Mhhokekenou}, the Lord is our King, he will save us.” Where the word Mhhokek is
used in its proper Signification of Lawgiver ; the other Sense of Dispenser or Inter-
preter of the Law being contained in the titles of Judge and King. § Matt. xi. 13.
478 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK V.
tribe), the pretended Prophecy was not only never fulfilled, but has
been directly falsified ; because long before the coming of Shiloh, or of
Christ, the Sceptre or Sovereignty in the Jewish people was departed.
During the Babylonian and Persian Captivity, and while afterwards
they continued in a tributary dependence on the Greeks, they could,
in no reasonable sense, be said to have retained their Sceptre, their
Sovereignty, or independent Rule. But it may be replied, “that the
Prophecy by departure, meant a final departure ; and in these instances
it was but temporary: for Cyrus restored the Sceptre to them; and
when it was again lost in the Grecian Empire, the Maccaser recovered
it for them.” Though this be allowed, yet we must still confess, that
the Romans, who under Pompey reduced Judea to a dependent Pro-
vince, effectually overthrew the Prophecy. Pompey took Jerusalem ;
and left to Hyrcanus, the last of the Asmonean family, only the office
of High-Priest. From this time, to the birth of Christ, it was ever in
dependence on the Romans, who disposed of all things at their plea-
sure. The Senate gave the Government of Judzea to Antipater; and
then to Herod his Son, under the title of King. And Archelaus, on
the Death of his Father, did not dare to take possession of this subject-
kingdom, till he had obtained leave of Augustus; who afterwards, on
complaint of the Jews against him, banished him into the West, where
he died. Now the precarious Rule of a dependent Monarch could no
more be called a Sceptre (which, in the figurative mode of all Jan-
guages, signifies Sovereignty) than the condition of the Jews could be
said to be sovereign, when this Archelaus was deposed, and Coponius
a Roman Knight made procurator of Judea, at that time which the
supporters of this interpretation fix for the Departure of the Sceptre.
I reckon for nothing another objection which has been made to the
common interpretation, “‘ That after the return from the Captivity, the
Jews were, from time to time, under a form of Government resembling
rather the Aristocratic than the Monarchic ;”’ because the Scepére, or
Sovereignty, belongs equally to all those Forms. This then makes no
more against the common interpretation, than the other, I am now
going to mention, makes for it, namely, that the Senate of Rome gave
the Government of Judeea to Herod under the title of Kine; since the
dependent rule of this Roitelet was as certainly the departure of a Scep-
tre, as a Sovereignty under an aristocratic Government was the con-
zinuance of it.
The learned Father Tournemine was so embarrassed with these
difficulties, that in a dissertation on the Sceptre of Judah, he endea-
vours to shew, that the proof of the predicted birth of Christ from
this Prophecy arises not from the departure of the Sceptre, but from
its re-establishment under the Messiah.* Which thesis (as the intelli-
* Journal de Trevoux, Mars 1705, et Feb, 1721.
SECT. 111. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 479
gent reader may observe) fairly put him in the road ; and, had it been
pursued, would have led him to the sense I am here endeavouring to
establish.
The second branch of the common interpretation is, That by the
Sceptre is signified a civil sovereignty in the tribe of Judah. This, in
my opinion, has still less of stability than the other. It supposes that
the Sceptre, or the supreme rule of the Jewish People, remained in
natives of that Tribe, from the time of David to the coming of Christ.
But Petavius hath shewn, that from the giving of the Prophecy to the
time of David (a Space of above six hundred Years), there was but one
or two Rulers descended from the Tribe of Judah: And that from the
death of Sedecias to the birth of Christ (a space of near the same
number of years) all the Rulers of the Jewish People were of other
Tribes; the Asmonean princes particularly being all of the tribe of
Levi.* The Abbé de Houteville, who, at a very easy rate, hath
obtained the reputation of an able defender of Revelation,+ hath indeed
invented a curious expedient to evade this difficulty. His system is,
that the rulers of the tribe of Levi (and so I suppose of the rest) exer-
cised this Sovereignty by leave, or deputation from the tribe of Judah.
To such wretched shifts are learned men reduced, when they have
reversed the order of things, and made Truth to wait upon their Sys-
tems ; instead of making their Systems subservient to Truth.
These two senses (by one or other of which the common interpre-
tation hath been long supported) being found on a stricter scrutiny,
to be intenable, men cast about for a third: and a happy one it was
thought to be, which contrived, that Sceptre should signify a domestic,
not a civil rule; a TRIBAL, not a SOVEREIGN Sceptre; and of which,
they say, Jupau, at the giving of the Prophecy, was already pos-
sessed. This expedient, the learned Dr. Sherlock, Bishop of London,
has honoured with his support and protection.{
It would be want of respect to so eminent a Person, to pass over
this refinement with the same slight notice that has been given to the
other two. I shall therefore do myself the honour to consider his
Lordship’s reasoning more at large.
His Lordship’s first argument in support of a ¢ribal Sceptre is—
That the Sceptre’s not DEPARTING from Judah shews plainly that
« ¢ At complures antiquorum recentiorumque qui in illa Jacobi sententia Judam
peculiari de tribu intellexerunt, id sibi Patriarcham voluisse credunt, ex stirpe ac proge-
nie Jude filii ipsius perpetuo Judzis prefuturum aliquem eorumque fore principem,
donec Christus adveniat. Sed in hujus reddenda dicti ratione multum zstuant, siquidem
vetustatis omni teste memoria refelluntur, que non solum ante Davidem unum alterumye
duntaxat ex illa tribu rexisse populum ostendit, annis circiter 675 ab edita prophetia ;
sed etiam post Sedecive necem, occasumque Urbis et Templi, ad Christum usque, de alia
quam Jude stixpe duces extitisse annis 588; etenim Machabzos constat ex Levitica
et Sacerdotali progenie descendere.”— Ration. Temporum, pars ii. lib. iii. cap. 16.
+ See his book, intituled, Religion preuvée par les Faits. 1 “Use and Intent of
Prophecy,” dissert. iii. 5th edit. 1749,
480 THE DIVINE LEGATION - "BOOK Vs
Judah had a Sceptre when the prophecy was given.—‘ Is there any
sense’’ (says his Lordship) ‘‘in saying that a thing shall not depart,
which never was yet in possession? The prophecy is not a grant of
the Sceptre, but a confirmation of it. Now a confirmation of nothing
is nothing: And, to make it something, the possession of the thing
confirmed must be supposed. I know not by what rules of language
or grammar, these words can be construed into a grant of the Sceptre.
And though so many writers and interpreters have followed this sense,
yet I do not remember to have seen one passage or parallel expression
from the Scripture, or any other author, produced to justify the
interpretation.” *
Is there any Sense (his Lordship asks) in saying a thing shall not
DEPART which never was yet in possession? Yes certainly, a very
good one, in a Prorpuecy, where the subject is not of a present but
of a future possession ; and where the Holy Spirit is wont to call the
things that are not, as though they were. The Subject is a Sceptre,
which could in no sense, not even in the sense of a ¢ribal sceptre, be
in possession of Judah before he became a Zride. His Lordship,
indeed, supposes he became a Tribe immediately after the death of
Jacob.—This power in the hands of the Tribes took place immediately
upon the death of Jacob.t But if it did? Was not that accession
as properly future, as if it had been a thousand years after? Judah
then, at the time of this Prophecy, not being in possession of his
Sceptre, a confirmation of nothing is nothing, ὅσο. so that all the
absurdities here imagined stick to his Lordship’s Aira of the Sceptre,
as well as to the common one.’ But let us suppose that Jacob’s
Prophecy and death were individual; and then see how he proves his
assertion, that Judah and the Rest became Tribes immediately on the
death of Jacob. His proof is a little extraordinary—When Moses and
Aaron led them into the Wilderness (says his Lordship) we hear of
the Expers of the people, and the Ruters of the congregation.t
His assertion is, that the ¢ribal sceptre sprung up from the ashes of
Jacob; and his proof, that it arose and flourished in the Wilderness.
This is indeed the truth; it was a Native of that place; as may be
fairly presumed from the occasion which the Israelites had of a tribal
rule (namely, to fit them for the warfare they were now about to
undertake), and as may be fairly proved from the first chapter of the
book of Numbers—“ And the Lord spake unto Moses in the wilder-
ness of Sinai: Take ye the sum of all the congregation of the
Children of Israel, after their families, by the house of their Fathers—
all that are able to go forth to war in Israel; Thou and Aaron shall
number them with their armies. And with you, there SHALL BE A
* “Use and Intent of Prophecy,” dissert. iii. 5th edit. 1749, pp. 326, 327.
t Page 323. t Ibid.
.
SECT. ΠῚ. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 48L
Man of every tribe; every one Heap or THE HOUSE of his Fathers—
and they assembled all the congregation; and they declared their
pedigrees, after their families, by the house of their Fathers—These
were those which were numbered: and the Princes or ΙΒΠΑΕῚ,
BEING TWELVE MEN, EACH ONE WAS FOR THE HOUSE OF HIS
Faruers. And the Children of Israel shall pitch their tents, every
man by his own camp, and every man by his own standard, through-
out their Hosts—And the Children of Israel did according to all the
Lord commanded them.’ * Then follows the order of the Tribes in
their tents.t Now, surely, this detailed account of these ¢ribal
Sceptres hath all the marks of a new Institution.
The Bishop’s hypothesis therefore is without foundation: the
Sceptre was something in reversion. Indeed the particular words, as
well as the general nature of Prophecy, declare the subject to be of
things future.—‘‘ And Jacob called to his sons, and said, Gather
yourselves together that I may tell you what shall befall you IN THE
LAsT pAys.”’t The Bishop owns, that most of the Interpreters, from
these words, take it for granted, and it ts the common notion, that the
Sceptre was not to be settled in Judah's family till some ages after the
death of Jacob.§ 1 think they had not reason so to do. How does
his Lordship prove they had? In this manner. ‘‘The observation,
when rightly applied, is right. And if the continuance of the Sceptre
of Judah be, as I suppose, the thing foretold, it extends to the very
last days of the Jewish State ; and in this respect the interpretation
is justified :”’ || 7. 6. if you will agree that futurity refers to the con-
tinuance, and not to the establishment of the Sceptre, his Lordship
will shew you, how well he can evade this objection. But though we
were inclined to be thus complaisant, the book of Numbers would not
suffer us: which informs us (we see) that even the tribal Sceptre was
established long after the death of Jacob. But to go no farther than
the Prophecy. If each Tribe had a Sceptre then existing, how hap-
pened it that Judah’s is only named, by way of CONFIRMATION, as
his Lordship will have it. For, by way of Grant, we find Dan too
had a Sceptre—Dan suai judge his People as one of the Tribes [or
Scertres| of Israel. But then Dan’s is a reversionary Sceptre; and
such a one destroys all his Lordship has been erecting.
To proceed—The Prophecy (says the Bishop) ts not a@ GRANT of a
sceptre, but @ CONFIRMATION. ‘The Prophecy itself plainly intimates
the contrary. Jacob having told his sons that he would inform them
of what should befall them in the last days, when he comes to Judah,
he says, Thy Father's Children shall bow down before thee.{ This,
* Num. i. 4, 5, 18, 44, 52, 54. + Num. ii. + Gen. xlix. 1. ἃ (ὁ Use and
Intent of Prophecy,” dissert. iii. 5th edit. 1749, p. 326. || Page 327. 4 Gen.
xlix. 8.
VOL. II. ΠῚ
482 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK V.
if it was any thing, was the promise of a future Sceptre; and conse-
quently it was the grant.
The Bishop goes on—Now a confirmation of nothing is nothing.
Without doubt. But he supposes (what I have shewn to be a
mistake), that there was no grant. If there were a grant, then the
confirmation of it was the confirmation of something. He seems to
be apprehensive of so obvious an answer, for he immediately adds—
I know not by what rules of language or grammar these words can be
construed into a GRANT of the Sceptre. By the plainest rule in the
world ; that of common sense, the first and capital rule in every Art as
well as grammar. For if Jacob made a declaration concerning some
future prerogative, as the words—Thy father’s Children shall bow
down before thee—prove he did; and that this was the first time that
Judah heard of it, as the words—I will tell you what shall befall you
in the last days—prove it was; What can this Prophecy be but the
GRANT of a Sceptre ? :
“ΤΠ ΟΡῊ so many writers and interpreters ” (says the Bishop) “ have
followed this sense, yet I do not remember to have seen one passage
or parallel expression from the Scripture or any other writer produced
to justify the interpretation.” As for any other Writers than those
of Scripture, I know of none who have prophesied : and the language
of prophecy hath peculiarities unknown to other Compositions. But
a Scripture-writer 1 am able to produce; and the same who has
recorded this Prophecy of Jacob.—On Abraham’s departure out of
Haran, he being then seventy-five years of age, the Lord, as Moses
tells us, appeared unto him and said—Unto thy serv will I give this
Land.* Was this now a grant, or a confirmation only of Sep?
‘* A confirmation only,” says his Lordship: “ All the grant contained in
these words is the grant of the Lanp: and this shews”’ (will he say)
“that the Seed was now existing: for a non-entity is incapable of
receiving any grant or donation: besides, a confirmation of nothing is
nothing, and so on.’’—Notwithstanding all this, it so happens that
Abraham had then xo Seed.
Here now is a parallel expression, which holds ἃ fortiort. For if it
be a little anomalous to talk of a thing’s departing which was never
yet in possession, it seems to be much more absurd to talk of giving
to persons who were never yet in Being. Besides, the promise of
Rule actually accompanies the promise of its duration: but the
express promise of Seed does not accompany the promise of a pro-
vision for it: I suppose the reason of this difference of expression in
the two places is, because to get a Son is a much commoner case
than to get a Sceptre. F
His Lordship having thus shewn, that Judah’s Sceptre was a
* ‘Gene χίϊ. ἥἧ.
SECT. III. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 483
Sceptre in possession, he will prove next, that it was not a civil, but a
tribal Sceptre; which did not stretch its sovereignty over a whole
nation, but was confined to the ceconomic rule of the single tribe of
Judah.—“ Another thing supposed ”’ (says he) ‘‘by most interpreters is,
that the Sceptre, here mentioned, is an emblem of Dominion over all
the tribes of Jacob. But how can that be? Had not Jacob settled a
sceptre in every tribe? as is evident, ver. 16. Dan shall judge his
people as one of the sceptres of Israel. Suppose a Father has divided
his estate amongst twelve Sons, and should say of one of them, The
Estate shall not depart from John, for many ages ; could you possibly
suppose him to mean more than the share of the Estate given to
John? Could you understand him to mean that all the estate, the
twelve shares, should come to John and continue in his family? The
case is the same here. ‘Twelve Princes are created; Of one of them
Jacob says, the Sceptre shall not depart from him until Shiloh come.
Is it not plain then, that the Sceptres are distinguished here; and
that it is foretold of one, that it shall long outlast the rest ?—conse-
quently the Sceptre here is an emblem of Authority IN AND OVER
ONE TRIBE ONLY.” *
His Lordship’s reasoning, on which he grounds his parallel, stands
thus—Judah’s sceptre was the same with Dan’s: now Dan’s was a
tribal Sceptre; therefore Judah’s. But the very words of the Pro-
phecy shew that the Sceptres were specifically different. Of Dan it is
said, he shall judge his People as ONE OF THE TRIBES OR SCEPTRES
or IsrarL. Here is a tribal Sceptre marked out in express and
proper terms. But of Judah’s Sceptre it is said, Toy FaTHER’s
CHILDREN SHALL BOW DOWN BEFORE THEE. Who were these
Children but the eleven tribes? So that here a civil and a sovereign
Sceptre is as properly and expresly marked out for Judah, as before,
a tribal one for Dan. ‘This shall judge his own tribe; but the other
shall, with his own tribe, judge the rest also. And yet if you will
rely on his Lordship’s Authority, he has a case in point; and he
assures us ‘‘ that Judah’s grant is the same as that of a Father’s to his
Son John, who when he had divided his estate amongst his twelve Sons
should say of John’s part, that it should not depart for many ages.”
He tells us next, “ that the sense of the word μασιν πὶ will fellow
the fate of the word Sceptre.” + In this, I perfectly agree with him.
And therefore as his sense of the word Sceptre is found to be erro-
neous, his sense of the word Lawgiver must fall with it.
All that follows has nothing to do with the question of a tribal.
Sceptre till we come to page 344. From thence to 350, he endea-
vours to take advantage of the hypothesis, to shew that this tribat
* “Use and Intent of Prophecy,’’ dissert. iii. 5th edit. 1749, pp. 328, 329.
ἡ Page 329.
21 2
454 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK VY.
Sceptre never departed from Judah till the coming of Christ: And
here he had an easy task. But unluckily confounding economic with
civil Rule, he embarasses himself as much, to make out the completion
of the Prophecy, as the supporters of the other two branches of the
common interpretation are wont to do.—As where he talks of the
Jews in Babylon ordering all matters relating to their own c1viL and
ECCLESIASTICAL Affairs.*—Their coming back to their own Country
as a People and a nation GOVERNED BY THEIR OWN LAwS—though
never SO FREE A PEOPLE as they had been formerly. They lived
under subjection to the Persian Monarch, and under the empire of the
Greeks and Romans.t—The Evangelists shew that they lived under
their OwN Laws, and EXECUTED JUDGMENT amongst themselves.t—
Had the exercise of supiciaL AurHority amongst themselves.§
Thus, like the Successors of Peter, who enlarged his Rock into a
Citadel, his Lordship at last lengthens his tribal Sceptre into a sove-
reign. But if here he extends it over a People and Nation, he con-
tracts it as much by and by; and we see it shrink up into a mere
philosophical or Stoical Regality. His Lordship undertakes to prove
that the Jews were a Free peopte, from their own consciousness of
their free condition. When our Saviour (says the Bishop) tells the
Jews “The truth shall make you free ;” they reply, ‘“‘ We are Abra-
ham’s Children, and were never in bondage to any man.” || This his
Lordship urges as a proof of their Civil freedom. But if the Jews,
who expected a carnal Messiah to lead real armies against their ene-
mies, could suppose that Jesus made them an offer of sending Truth
in person, to execute this commission for them, their stupidity must
have exceeded every thing we have been told of it, by their Enemies.
To be plain with his Lordship, the subject here debated, between
Jesus and his Adversaries, is most foreign from his Lordship’s purpose.
Our blessed Saviour is here addressing himself to the PHARISEES, a
rank of men not ignorant of the Greek philosophy (though greatly
mistaking its use when they brought so much of it into the Law),
and therefore, with a Stoical dignity, he tells them—the truth shall
set you free. They answer him in the same tone, We are Abraham’s
Children, and were never in bondage to any man. That is, “Our
principles are of divine extraction, and we never suffered ourselves to
be inslaved to human decisions.” Surely (says his Lordship) they
had not forgot their Captivity in Babylon. Forgot! Why, Jesus had
said nothing to put them in mind of it. The question is not about
their freedom from Babylon, but from Error.—Much less (says he)
could they be ignorant of the power of the Romans over them at that
time, and yet we see they account themselves free. And why should
* “Use and Intent of Prophecy,” dissert. iii. 5th edit. 1749, p. 345. + Page 347.
1 Page 349. § Page 350, || Page 349.
SECT. 11. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 485
they not, when the Question between Jesus and them was only who
should make them so, He or AsprAnAM. Strange! that his Lord-
ship’s own account of their civil condition under the power of the
Romans should not have brought him to see, that the subject in hand
was only of their moral Condition. Stranger still! that his solution
of this difficulty should not have led him to discover that it was but
imaginary—they were free (says his Lordship) for they lived by their
own Laws, and executed judgment amongst themselves.—Had he added
—but, at the precarious nod of an arbitrary Tyrant—it would doubt-
less have given great force to his observation: For, about this time,
Coponius, a Roman Knight, was named Procurator of Judea. Nay,
even the precarious privilege of punishing capitally was now taken
from them: They had a pagan Governor: and Justice was adminis-
tered, not by their own Forms of Law, but by the Roman. An
admirable character of civil Freedom !
His Lordship seems to be no happier in answering others’ objec-
tions, than in urging his own proofs. ‘‘ You will say” (continues
he) “why did not Jacob foretell also the continuance of the Sceptre
of Benjamin? For the tribe of Benjamin run the same fortune with
that of Judah: they went together into captivity: they returned
home together ; and were both in Being when Shiloh came.” *
Upon my word, a shrewd objection. Let us see how his Lordship
quits his hands of it. His first answer is,—That from the division of
the Kingdom after the death of Solomon, the tribe of Benjamin and
the remnant of Israel, that is, part of all the other tribes, ADHERED
TO JUDAH AS THEIR HEAD.
Here his Lordship seems fairly to have given up the Cause; his
answer proving, in so many words, that Judah’s Sceptre was not
tribal, but civil. Let us examine it step by step. Benjamin and the
remnants of all the other tribes adhered to Judah as their head.
Now such an adherence can be no other than an acknowledge-
ment of a Civil Sceptre in Judah. Yet his Lordship gives this as a
reason why the continuance of Judah’s Sceptre is foretold, and not
Benjamin’s. Therefore the Sceptre, whose continuance is foretold,
was a civil, not a tribal, Sceptre, even on his own principles. [{ this
needed a support, the words of the Prophecy afford it amply: his
Lordship says, that Benjamin and the remnants of all the other tribes
adhered to Judah as their HEAD; and this adherence, Jacob foretells
—Thy Father's children shall FALL Down before thee.
Supposing therefore that this Sceptre of Judah were of the civil
kind, his Lordship, it must be owned, has given a very satisfactory
reason why Benjamin’s ¢rida/ sceptre was not mentioned. But if
«ἐς Use and Intent of Prophecy,” dissert. iii. 5th edit. 1749, p. 355. + Pp. 355,
356.
486 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Vv.
both were tribal Sceptres, the continuance of Benjamin’s had as good
a claim to the Prophet’s notice (for any thing the Bishop has shewn
to the contrary) as Judah’s. Since, as Tribes, they both continued to
exist, and to exist distinct.
His second answer to the Objection seems as little satisfactory as
the first-—Though the continuance of the Sceptre of Benjamin is not
foretold, yet the continuance of the tribe or prorLE of Benjamin ἐδ
distinctly foretold.* Would you desire a more conclusive argument
against his own notion of a tribal Sceptre? If this prophetic Sceptre
of Judah was a ewil one, there is a very good reason why the con-
tinuance of the people, and not of the Sceptre of Benjamin, should be
foretold; because what Judah and Benjamin had in common was
their continuing to exist as distinct tribes; the Sceptre being peculiar
to the first: But if a tribal Sceptre be the subject of the Prophecy
concerning Judah, then no possible reason can be assigned why the
eontinuance of Benjamin’s Sceptre should not be honoured with the
divine notice as well as Judah’s; since his Lordship assures us—they
both run the same fortune ; they went together into captivity ; they
returned together to Judea; and were both in being when Shiloh
eame. And while a 7γιδο continues distinct, a tribal Sceptre conti-
nues with it ; just as the head of a family exists so long as there is a
family to govern.
All this considered, his Lordship in my humble opinion had done
well not to load himself with more than he had occasion to carry :
especially as he had so little to answer for, in the success of this
hypothesis ; for he tells us at the end of his Dissertation, that he
has nothing more to add, but to acquaint the reader that the interpre-
tation of Jacob’s Prophecy now advanced, was not a mere invention of
his own ; that it was, as to the main point, the same with that which
is the fourth in Hurtivus, and by him rejected, but for such reasons
as had been fully obviated in this dissertation.—That it was the same
which Junius and TREMELLIUS, and our own learned Countryman,
Arinsworta, had espoused; and which not many years ago was
revived and improved by Mr. Joncourt.t
Now, from what hath been said it appears, that of all the three
branches, into which the common interpretation spreads, though they
be equally weak, the last betrays its weakness most. But, what is of
principal consideration, it is, of all the three, least suitable to the
Dignity or PropHecy; the whole body of which has a perpetual
reference to one or other of the great parts of the Dispensation of
Grace. Now the first branch refers with suitable dignity to a whole
People at large: the second to the same People under the Govern-
* “Use and Intent of Prophecy,” dissert. iii. 5th edit. 1749, p. 356. t Page 558.
SECT. Τ]ὶ. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 487
ment of one certain line: while the third concerns only the fortunes
of a single Tribe, and under a Family-idea.
The common interpretation therefore being shewn so very excep-
tionable in all its branches, what remains for us to conclude but that
the true and real meaning of the Sceptre of Judah is that THEOCRA-
TIC GOVERNMENT which God, by the vicegerency of Judges, Kings,
and Rulers, exercised over the Jewish nation? We have shewn from
various considerations of weight, that this THEocracy, which was
instituted by the ministry of Moses, continued over that people till
the coming of Shiloh or Christ; rHat Propnet like unto Moses
whom God had promised to raise up. And to support what hath
been urged from reason, to illustrate this important truth, we have
here a Prophetic declaration enouncing the same thing,—the sceptre
shall not depart from Judah till Shiloh come: Shiloh is Christ. Now
Christ is not the Successor of those VicEGERENTS of the Jewish
State, but of God himself, the Kine of the Jews. The Sceptre
therefore which descends to him, through the hands of those vicege-
rents, is not merely a civiL, but a THEOCRATIC Sceptre. This, at
the same time, explains the Evangelic doctrine of Curist’s Kine-
DOM, arising out of the Theocracy or Kingdom of God. Hence the
distinction in that famous declaration of Christ, so much abused to
factious and party purposes, that His KinGpom was NoT OF THIS
wor_p: The Theocracy which was administered over the Jews only,
and in a carnal manner, was a Kingdom of this world: but when
transferred to Shiloh, and extended over all mankind, and adminis-
tered in a spiritual manner, it became a Kingdom not of this world.
And the making the Sceptre of Judah neither Tribal, nor MERELY
Civil, but properly Theocratic, clears the Prophecy from those insu-
perable difficulties which render all the other interpretations hurtful
or dishonourable to the Prophetic system in general.
These are the superior advantages of the sense I have here endea-
voured to establish. Nor are these all the advantages. The Prophecy
is seen to embrace a much nobler object than was imagined. It was
supposed to relate only to the fortunes of the Jewish Oeconomy, and
we find it extends itself to the whole Dispensation of Grace. It was con-
sidered but as a simple Propuecy, while it had the dignity of a Revewa-
TION. It was mistaken for the species, when it is indeed, of the genus.
But to all this an Answerer may reply. 1. “ That, as we admit the
‘Tueocracy to be a Kingdom of this World, the same objection will
lie as well against the CONTINUANCE or duration of a Theocratic
Sceptre as of a mere Civil one.” But here we must distinguish,
The Theocracy was indeed carnal in its administration, but in its
original it was Divine. Therefore, as where the subject is of the
continuance of a mere civil Sceptre, we cannot but understand’ the
488 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK V.
continuance of its administration, because the administration is inse--
parable from the existence ; so where the subject is of the continuance
of a Theceratic Sceptre, we must understand that continuance to con-
sist in its remaining unrevoked, since what is of divine original exists,
independently of its being actually administered ; it exists till it be for-
mally abrogated. This difference is evident from the nature of things.
Forms of Government ordained by Men cease when Men no longer
administer them ; because, in the non-administration of them, they
are naturally supposed to revoke what they had ordained: But men’s
ceasing to administer (whether by choice or force) a Form of Govern-
ment given by God, does not (on any rules of logic or ideas of nature)
imply God’s revocation of that form of Government.
Again, we must remember what has been said of the effect and
consequence of a Turocracy. It not only united, but incorporated
the two Societies, civil and religious, into One. And this incorpo-
rated body of the Jewish State went by the name of THE Law.
Now under that part of the Law which more intimately regarded
Religion, the Jews always lived Free till the publication of the
Gospel ; though the other part of it, regarding the sovereign admi-
nistration of civil policy and justice, they had lost from the time of
Pompey. For a power precariously enjoyed, and ready to be abo-
lished at the nod of a Conqueror, can never be called Sovereign
(which implies the being free and independent) without the worst
abuse of words, which is, the quibbling upon them. So that a
Sovereignty in this Theocracy was still administered to the last,
though in part. However this partial exercise was consentaneous to
the system on which this Theocracy was dispensed ; its Administra-
tion being ordained to have a gradual decline. The Jews, for their
transgressions, being first of all deprived of that natural effect of
Theocratic rule, the extraordinary providence : and then, for their incor-
rigible manners, further punished by an infringement of their civil
sovereignty : but still the Theocracy, as to that more essential, the
Religious part, remained unhurt till the coming of Christ: And let it be
observed, that it was this part in particular which was to be assigned
over to him, from the Father. Thus, as I said before, this is not so
properly a prediction of human events, as a revelation concerning the
course of God’s Dispensation.
2. Secondly, it hath been objected that ‘‘ according to the sense
here put upon the Sceptre, it should have been said—the Sceptre
shall not depart from πον ΑΗ instead of Jupan.” But such
Objectors do not advert, that the Theocracy was administered by
Vicegerents of Jupan. And this likewise will account for the
expression of a Lawgiver between his feet.
3. Lastly, it may be said, “That by this interpretation of the
SECT. IV. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 489
Sceptre of Judah we deprive the Prophecy of one principal part of
the information it was supposed to give, namely, the rrm« of Christ’s
advent, which the common interpretation is supposed to fix exactly.”
To this I answer, that Religion loses nothing by this change, since
there are so many other Prophecies which point out the ¢ime with
infinitely more precision. On the other hand, Religion gains much
by it, in evading a number of objections, which had stigmatized the
supposed Prediction with apparent marks of falshood.
Thus we see this noble Prophecy, concerning the transfer of the
Kingdom of Gop, to Curist, contains a matter of much greater
dignity in itself, and of much greater moment for the support of
CuRIsTIANITy, than could arise from the perplexed question about
the reign of the Asmonean Princes, or the Continuance of the power
of life and death amongst a tributary People. For, in predicting the
Abolition of the Law, it supplies us with a new and excellent Argu-
ment for the Conversion of the Jewish People, fatally persuaded of its
eternal obligation.
The Reasons of my being so particular concerning the duration of
the THEOCRACY are various, and will be seen as occasion offers.
Only the reader may here take notice, that it was necessary for the
present purpose, to shew its continuance throughout the whole dura-
tion of the Republic, in order to vindicate the justice of those Laws
all along in force, for the punishment of idolatrous Worship.
SECTION IV.
Tuus far as to the nature and duration of the Mosaic Republic.
Let us now see what PECULIAR CONSEQUENCES necessarily attended
the administration of a rHrocratic form of Government.
One necessary consequence was an EXTRAORDINARY PROVIDENCE.
For the affairs of a People under a Theocracy, being administered by
God as King; and his peculiar and immediate administration of
human affairs being what we call an extraordinary Providence ; it
follows that an extraordinary Providence must needs be exercised over
such a People. My meaning is, that if the Jews were indeed under a
Theocracy, they were indeed under an extraordinary Providence: And
if a Theocracy was only pretended, yet an extraordinary Providence
must necessarily be pretended likewise. In a word, they must be
either both true or both false, but still inseparable, in reality or idea.
Nor does this at all contradict (as was suggested by Doctor SyKes
even after he had seen his suggestion confuted) what I observe con-
cerning the gradual decay and total extinction of the extraordinary
Providence, while the Theocracy yet existed. For when I say an
extraordinary Providence was one necessary consequence of a Theo-
eracy, 1 can only mean that it was so in its original constitution, and
490 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK τ.
in the order and nature of things: not that in this, which was matter
of compact, the contravening acts of one Party might not make a
separation. For, as this extraordinary Providence was (besides its
being a mode of administration arising out of a Theocracy) a reward
for obedience, it became liable to forfeiture by disobedience, though
subjection to the Government still continued. I beg leave to illustrate
this position both by a foreign and a domestic instance. The rari in
the Roman State were such who, for their crimes, were deprived of
the right of Citizens: Yet these delinquents were obliged to pay the
public taxes. At home, a voice in the supreme Council of the king-
dom is the necessary consequence of an English Barony ; yet they
may be separated by a judicial Sentence; and actually have been so
separated ; as we may see in the two famous cases of Lord Verulam,
and the Earl of Middlesex, in the reign of James the First ; who were
both deprived of their seats in the House of Lords, and yet held their
Baronies, with all the other rights pertaining to them. Thus a
punishment of this kind was inflicted on the rebellious Israelites :
they were deprived of the extraordinary Providence : and were yet
held subject to the Theocracy, as appears from the Sentence pro-
nounced upon them, by the mouth of the Prophet Ezekiel :—*“ Ye
polluted yourselves with your idols even unto this day: and shall I
be enquired of by you, O house of Israel? As I live, saith the Lord
God, I will not be enquired of by you. And that which cometh into
your mind shall not be at all, that ye say, We will be as the Heathen,
as the Families of the Countries to serve Wood and Stone. As I live,
saith the Lord, with a mighty Hand, and with a stretched out Arm,
and with Fury poured out, will I rule over you. And I will bring you
out from the People, and will gather you out of the Countries wherein
ye are scattered, with a mighty Hand, and with a stretched out Arm,
and with Fury poured out. And I will bring you into the Wilderness
of the People, and there will I plead with you Face to Face. Like as
I pleaded with your Fathers in the Wilderness of the Land of Egypt,
so will I plead with you, saith the Lord. And I will cause you to
pass under the Rod. And TI will bring you into the Bonn oF THE
Covenant.” Chap. xx. ver. 31—37. It is here we see denounced,
that the extraordinary Providence should be withdrawn ; or, in Scrip-
ture phrase, that God would not be enquired of by them; That they
should remain in this condition, which their Fathers had occasionally
felt in the wilderness, when the extraordinary Providence, for their
signal disobedience, was, from time to time, suspended: And yet,
that, though they strove to disperse themselves amongst the People
round about, and projected iz their minds to be as the heathen, and
the families of the Countries to serve wood and stone, they should still
be under the government of a Tuxocracy; Which, when adminis-
SECT. IV. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 491
tered without an extraordinary Providence, the blessing naturally
attendant on it, was, and was justly called, ΤῊΣ Rop anp Bonp oF
THE COVENANT.
But now if you will believe a Professor of Divinity and a no less
eminent dealer in Laws, the case grows worse and worse, and, from a
contradiction in my system, it becomes a contradiction in God’s.
For thus Dr. Rurnerrortn descants upon the matter: “As the
Law was gradually deprived of its Sanction, the Obligation of it grew
continually weaker, till at last, after the people were returned from
the Captivity, it must have ceased to oblige them at all. For what-
ever may be the case of God’s MorAt Law, yet most certainly, as he
withdraws the Sanctions of his positive ones, he takes off something
from their obligation ; and when he has wholly withdrawn the pro-
mise of reward and the threatening of punishment, THOSE Laws
OBLIGE NO LONGER.”’* To this Determination of the learned Pro-
fessor, concerning ΟΒΙΙΘΑΤΙΟΝ, I have nothing to oppose but the
Determination of Gov himself: who, by the mouth of one of his
Prophets, declares, That the Laws shall still oblige, though the Sanc-
tion be withdrawn. ‘Ye pollute yourselves with your idols,” &e.—
as the reader may find it transcribed just above. Here God declares
he would withdraw that extraordinary Providence which naturally —
attended a Turocracy—I will not be enquired of by you. Yet do
not’’ (says he) ‘‘deceive yourselves in an expectation that, because
for your crimes I withdraw this sanction of my Law, the Law will
oblige no longer,—and that which cometh into your mind shall not be
at all, that ye say we will be as the heathen: For, in order to the
bringing about my own great purposes, I will still continue you a
select and sequestered people—I will bring you out from the people,
and will gather you out from the Countries wherein you are scattered.
And will still rule over you by my Law ; now, in my wrath, as before
in my mercy. With fury poured out I will rule over you, and bring
you into the bond of the Covenant.”
I suppose the thing that led our Doctor into this rash judgment,
That when the sanctions of a positive law are withdrawn, the obliga-
tion to the law ceases, was his totally misunderstanding the principles
of the best writers on the Law of Nature: Not by their fault, I dare
assure the Reader.—The Law of Nature is written in the heart; but
by Whom, is the question. And a question of much importance ;
for if not written by a competent Obliger it is no Law, to bind us.
The enquirers therefore into this matter had no other way of coming
to the Author of the Law but by considering the effects which the
observance or inobservance of it would have on mankind. And they
found that the observance tended to the benefit of all, the inobser-
* Page 329.
402 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK V.
vance to their destruction. They concluded therefore that it must
needs have been given by God, as a Law to mankind; and these
effects of its observance or inobservance they called the sanction.
Hence it appears that the knowledge of our obligation to the Law of
nature arises from the knowledge of the sanction. And, this sanction
away, we had not been obliged, because we could never have disco-
vered any real ground of obligation.
But the positive Law of the Jews was written in stone by the finger
of God, in a visible manner; in which the senses of the People were
appealed to, for the truth of the transaction. Here the knowledge of
their obligation did not arise from their knowledge of the sanction,
but from quite another thing, namely, the immediate knowledge they
had by their senses, that God, their sovereign Lord and Master, gave
them the Law. To inforce which, a sanction indeed was added; but
a sanction that added nothing to the obligation, nor consequently
that took from it, when it was withdrawn.
This is a plain and clear state of the case. Yet so miserably has
our Professor mistaken it, that for want of seeing on what principle
it was which the writers on the Law of Nature proceeded, when they
supposed obligation to depend on the sanction, he hath, of a particular
case, made a general maxim: and in applying that maxim, he hath
turned every thing topsy turvy, and given us just the reverse of the
medal. He supposes the taking the sanction from the moral Law
might not destroy the obligation (which it certainly would)—whatso-
ever, says he, might be the cause of God’s moral Laws ; and that
taking away the sanction from his positive Law would destroy the
obligation (which it certainly would not).
“What might further mislead our Professor (for the more such men
read the less they understand) is the attribute the Roman Lawyers
give to such civil Laws as are made without a penal sanction. These
they are wont to call, Leges imperfecte: And our great Civilian
might believe that this assigned imperfection had a reference to the
obligation they imposed, whereas it refers to the efficacy they were
able to work. He should have known at least this first principle of
Law, That it is the AurHority of the Lawgiver, not the Sancrion
he annexes to his Law, which makes it, I will not say, OPERATE
properly (for this is nothing to the purpose), but makes it oBLIGE
really, which is only to the purpose. In a word, I know of nobody
but Hosses, besides this Doctor, who pretended to teach that the
obligation to Laws depended upon their sanction: and this he did,
because he derived all right and wrong from the Civil Magistrate :
which, for aught I know, our learned Professor may do likewise, as
only mistaking right and wrong {by a blunder like to the foregoing)
for good and evil. Yet hath this grave man written most enormously
SECT. Iv. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 493
both on Laws and Moraus: And is indeed a great Writer, just as
the mighty Giant, Leon Gawer, was a great Builder; of whom the
Monk of Chester so sweetly sings :
“The Founder of this City, as saith Polychronicon,
Was Leon Gawer, a mighty strong Giant,
Which builded Caves and DUNGEONS many a one:
No goodly Building, ne proper, ne pleasant.”
But our business at present is not with the actual administration
of an extraordinary Providence, but with the Scripture representation
of such an administration. And this the sacred history of the Jews
attests in one uniform unvaried manner ; as well by recording many
instances of it in particular, as by constantly referring to it in general.
I. The first is in the History of Miracues. For an equal Provi-
dence being, by the nature of man’s situation and affairs, necessarily
administered partly by ordinary and partly by extraordinary means,
these latter produce what we call Miracles, the subject of the sacred
Writers their more peculiar regard. But I apprehend it would be
thought presuming too much on the reader’s patience, to expect his
attention, while I set myself formally to prove that many miracles are
related in the sacred history of the Israelites.
The simpler sort of Deists fairly confess that the Bible records the
working of many Miracles, as appears even from the free names they
give to those accounts. But there are refiners in Infidelity, such as
Sprnoza and his mimic ToLanp; who acknowledge many of the
facts recorded, but deny them to have been miraculous. These
are to our purpose, and an Appeal to the common sense of Mankind
is a sufficient answer to them all. And surely I should have done no
more, had they not attempted to draw in to their Party much
honester Men than themselves. For such, therefore, even charity
requires us to attempt some kind of defense.
The infamous Spinoza would persuade us that Josernus himself
was as backward in the belief of Miracles as any modern Pagan what-
soever. The handle, for his calumny, is* that Writer’s relation of
* “ Scriptura de natura in genere quibusdam in locis affirmat eam fixum atque immu-
tabilem ordinem servare.—Philosophus prterea in suo Eccl. clarissime docet nihil novi
in natura contingere.—Hee igitur in Scriptura expresse docentur, at nullibi, quod in
natura aliquid contingat, quod ipsius legibus repugnet, aut quod ex iis nequeat sequi,
adeoque neque etiam Scripture affingendum.— Ex quibus evidentissime sequitur mira-
cula res naturales fuisse.—Attamen—de his unicuique, prout sibi melius esse sentiet,
ad Dei cultum et religionem integro animo suscipiendum, liberum est existimare. Quod
etiam JOSEPHUS SENTIT; sic enim in conclusione /. 2. Antig. scribit, Nudlus vero dis-
credat verbo miraculi, si antiquis hominibus et malitia privatis via salutis liquet per
mare facta, sive voluntate Dei, sive sponte revelata: dum et eis, qui cumin Alexandro
rege Macedonie fuerunt olim, et antiquitus a resistentibus Pamphylicum mare divisum
sit, et cum aliud iter non esset, transitum prebuit tis, volente Deo, per ewnm Persarum
destruere principatum ; et hoc confitentur omnes, qui actus Alexandri scripserunt ; DE
HIS ITAQUE, SICUT PLACUERIT CUILIBET, EXIJSTIMET. Hee sunt verba Josephi,
ejusque DE FIDE MIRACULORUM JubiciuM.”—Tract. Theologico- Pol. cap. vi. de Mira-
culis, pp. 81, 82.
494 " THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK Y.
the passage of the Red-sea; which he compares to Alexander’s
through the Pamphylian, and which concludes with ‘saying that every
Man may believe of it as he pleases. No unusual way with this
Historian of introducing or ending a miraculous Adventure. This
hath indeed so libertine an air, that it hath betrayed some Believers
into the same false judgment concerning Josephus; as if he afforded
only a political or philosophical belief to these things; and gave a
latitude to those of his own Religion, to think as they should see
cause. .
But here lies the difficulty ; the Historian is every now and then
putting on a very different aspect, and talking like a most determined
Believer. Many are the places where he expresses the fullest and
firmest assent to the Divinity of the Mosaic Religion, and to the
Truth of the sacred Volumes. To mention only one or two, from a
Book so known, and in a point so notorious. The following words
of his Introduction (where he cannot possibly be considered as
a translator, or relator only of what he found in the sacred books,
from which he composed his history) these, I say, shew in how dif-
ferent a light he regarded Moses from all other Lawgivers: “ And
now I earnestly intreat all who take these Volumes in hand, to apply
themselves with their whole faculties to the contemplation of the
Divine Nature, and then turn to our LAwGiver, and see whether he
has not made a representation of that Nature entirely worthy of it;
always assigning such Actions to Gop, as become his excellence, and
preserving the high subject clear from any impure mixture of Fase.
Though if we consider the distance and antiquity of the Time he
wrote in, we cannot but understand he was at full liberty to invent
and falsify at pleasure. For he lived full two thousand years ago.—
A distance of Time to which even the Poets dared not to carry up
the birth of their Gods, the actions of their Heroes, or the establish-
ment of their Laws.” * Here, we see, the Historian expresly
declares that Moses in his writings employed xo degree of fiction,
so common in the practice of other ancient Lawgivers.
And how ¢ru/y divine he supposed the Law, appears from his
observing, in the same place, that, while the Jews religiously observed
its Precepts, all things went well and prosperously ; but that, when-
ever they transgressed, then nothing but disasters followed. And
lest any one should pretend, he meant no more than that national
* Ἤδη τοίνυν τοὺς ἐντευξομένους τοῖς βιθλίοις τταρακαλῶ τὴν γνώμην Θεῷ wpooca-
νέχειν, καὶ δοκιμάζειν τὸν ἡμέτερον Νομοθέτην, εἰ τῆν τε φύσιν αὐτοῦ ἀξίως κατενόησε,
καὶ τῇ δυνάμει wpemovoas ἀεὶ τὰς τσράξεις ἀντέθηκε, waons καθαρὸν τὸν wep) αὐτοῦ
φυλάξας λόγον τῆς wap ἄλλοις αἰσχήμονος μυθολογίας" καίτοιγε, ὅσον ἐπὶ μήκει χρόνον
καὶ ππαλαιότητι, τολλὴν ἔχων ἄδειαν ψευδῶν τολασμάτων. γέγονεν γὰρ wpd ἐτῶν
δισχιλίων.--- ἐφ᾽ ὕσον τ΄λῆθος αἰῶνος οὐδ᾽ αὐτῶν οἱ womtal τὰς γενέσεις τῶν Θεῶν,
ΕἼΤΕ τὰς τῶν ἀνθρώπων wpdtes, ἢ τοὺς νόμους ἀνενεγκεῖν ἐτόλμησαν.--- }. i-
pp. 3, 4.
ΒΕΟΤ. ΙΓ. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 495
happiness was the natural consequence of adhering to the Laws of
their Country; or that those Laws, being founded on Just and
Right, God (whose general Providence it is agreed he acknowledged)
would reward the virtuous observers, whatever were the original of
such Laws; lest, I say, this should be pretended, he adds, that these
disasters followed whenever they transgressed the Law, though in
pursuit of things just and good. His words are these: “ Upon the
whole, what the Reader of this History may chiefly learn from it is
this: That those who obsequiously study the Will of God, and reve-
rence his well established Laws, pass their lives in incredible prospe-
rity ; Happiness, the reward from God, ever attending their obedience.
But in proportion to their neglect of these Laws, easy things become
unsurmountable, and all their undertakings, how justly soever directed,
end in incurable calamities.” * . In which words, I take it for
granted, he had the case of Saul particularly in his view. Again, so
full was his persuasion of the Divinity of the Law, that he extols the
Jews for suffering Ptolemy, the son of Lagus, to take thai City by
storm on the seventh day, rather than violate the Saddatic rest.
Agatharchides (says he) thinks this scruple worthy of contempt and
laughter. But those who weigh it without prejudice, will see some-
thing truly great, and deserving of the highest commendations, in thus
always preferring their Piety towards God, and adherence to his
Law, before their own safety, or even the freedom of their Country.t
These passages, we see, have all the marks of a very zealous
Believer. And what makes the greatest difficulty of all, is, that the
very places in which the Historian uses such offensive latitude of
expression are those where he employs his utmost endeavours to shew
the real Divinity of his Religion ; of which these Miracles are pro-
duced as evidence; an evidence he studiously seeks, and seems to
dwell upon with pleasure.
This varying aspect, therefore, so indifferently assumed, creates
all the embarass. But would men only do in this case what they
ought to do in all, when they pass their judgment on an ancient
writing, that is, consider the Hud, and Time, and Genius of the
Writer, together with the Character of those to whom the work is
addressed ; they would find Josephus to be indeed a steady Follower
of the Law, and a firm Believer of its miraculous establishment ; and,
~ Td σύνολον δὲ μάλιστά τις ἂν ἐκ ταύτης μάθοι τῆς ἱστορίας, ἐθελήσας αὐτὴν διελθεῖν,
ὅτι μὲν τοῖς Θεοῦ γνώμῃ κατακολουθοῦσι, καὶ τὰ καλῶς νομοθετηθέντα μὴ τολμῶσι Wapa-
δαίνειν, τϑάντα κατορθοῦται τέρα ττίστεως, καὶ γέρας εὐδαιμονίας πρόκειται wapa Θεοῦ:
καθ᾽ ὅσον δ᾽ ἂν αποστῶσι τῆς τοῦτων ἀκριβοῦς ἐπιμελείας, ἄπορα μὲν γίνεται τὰ τσόριμα,
τρέπεται δ᾽ es συμφορὰς ἀνηκέστους, ὅ, τι ποτ᾽ ἂν, ὡς ἀγαθὸν, δρᾷν orovddowow.—
Vol. i. pp. 8, + Τοῦτο μὲν ᾿Αγαθαρχίδῃ καταγέλωτος ἄξιον δοκεῖ" τοῖς δὲ μὴ
μετὰ Rese ἐξετάζουσι φαίνεται μέγα καὶ τσολλῶν ἄξιον ἐγκωμίων, εἰ καὶ σωτηρίας
καὶ τσατρίδος ἄνθρωποί τινες νόμων φυλακὴν καὶ τὴν wpds Θεὸν εὐσέθειαν ἀεὶ τοροτιμῶσιν.
—Vol. ii. p. 468.
498 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK ν.
at the same time, discover the easy solution of all those untoward
appearances which have brought his Religion into question.
The case, with our Historian, stood thus: His Country was now
in great distress ; its Constitution overturned, and his Brethren in
apparent danger of utter Extirpation. Calamities arising as much from
the ill-will which the Heathens had entertained of their Religion *
for its unsociable nature, as for their own turbulent and rebellious
Carriage. This ill-will had been much increased by their superior
Aversion to Christianity, considered by them as a Sect of Judaism ;
which had carried its insociability as far, and its pretensions much
farther : so far as to insist on the necessity of all Men’s submitting to
its dominion, and renouncing their own Country Religions as the
Impostures of Politicians, or the Inventions of evil Demons. ‘This
put the Heathen world into a flame, and produced those mad and
wicked Persecutions that attended the first Propagation of the Chris-
tian Faith.¢ Such was the unfriendly state of things, when Josephus
underto@an Apology for his Nation, in the Hisrory or 115 ANTI-
qauities. Now as their conquerors’ aversion to them, arose from the
supposition that their Religion required the belief and obedience of
all Mankind (for they had, as we observed, confounded Judaism with
Christianity), to wipe off this invidious imputation, we must con-
clude, would be ever in the Author’s thoughts. So that when the
course of his History leads him to speak of the effects of Gop’s
extraordinary Providence in his conduct of this People, he sometimes
adds to his relation of a miraculous adventure, but in this every Man
may believe as he pleases. A declaration merely to this effect: ‘‘ The
Jewish Religion was given by Gop for the use of his chosen People,
therefore the Gentiles might believe as they pleased. The Jews did
not pretend they should leave their own Country Religion to embrace
theirs: {| That in this they were different from the Christian Sect,
which required all Mankind to follow the Faith of a crucified Saviour
under pain of total destruction. But that yet they were not
so unhospitable, but that they received with open arms all who were
willing to worship one God the Creator of the Universe.” || Thus we
see how it came to pass (which was the main difficulty), that the
places where he gives such a latitude of Belief, are those very places
where he most labours to prove the Divinity of his Religion.
But this solution clears up all difficulties, and shews the Historian’s
great consistency, as well as artful address, throughout the whole
work. Josephus professes the most awful regard to the sacred
Volumes ; and yet, at the same time, takes such liberties of going
* See note I, at the end of this book. + See the first volume, book i. t See
note K, at the end of this book. § See note L, at the end of this book. || Καὶ
τοῦτο μόνον εἶναι κοινὸν, εἰ βούλονται, wpds αὐτοὺς καὶ τσᾶσιν ἀνθρώποις, ἀφικνουμένοις
εἰς τὸ ἱερὸν σέθειν τὸν Oedy.—Vol. i. p 556.
SECT. IV. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 497
from their authority, that it provoked the honest resentment of a late
excellent Writer * to the following asperities: ‘Nec levis sit suspicie
illum Hebraice non scivisse, cum multis indiciis linguze ejus imperi-
tiam prodat. Quivis certe, cui vel mica salis est, sentiat illum Histo-
rias Sacras pro arbitrio- interpolasse, demendo, addendo, immutando,
ut Antiquitates suas ad Lectorum Greecorum et Romanorum palatum
accommodaret.” But this license, though surely to be condemned,
was however something more legitimate and sober than is generally
supposed ; his deviation from Scripture being in those places only,
where an exact adherence to it would have increased that general
aversion to his Nation, whose effects were at that time so much to be
dreaded, either as exposing the perverse nature of the People, or the
unsociable genius of their Religion. To give an instance or two of
each :
1. The murmuring of the Israelites, for bread and flesh in the
Wilderness, is represented in Scripture, and justly, as an act of
horrid ingratitude towards God. Yet Josephus makes Moses own
they had reason for their complaints.t And in the execrable beha-
viour of the Men of Gibeah to the Levite and his wife, though Scrip-
ture expresly says they attempted a more unnatural crime than
adultery, yet the Historian passes this over in silence, and makes all
the personal outrage attempted, as well as committed, to be offered to
the woman.§ The Reader will now easily account for what Mr.
Whiston could uot, his Author’s omission of the story of the golden
Calf.|| For this was so amazing a perversity, at that juncture, that
it must have made the very Pagans themselves ashamed of their
Jewish brethren in idolatry.
2. Again, we are told in Scripture, that when the Cutheans, or Sama-
ritans, heard that the Jews, who were returned from the Captivity, were
rebuilding the Temple, they came and desired to be partners in the
work, and joint Worshipers of the God for whom it was erected ; to
which the Jews gave this round reply : You have nothing to do with us,
to build un House unto our God, but we ourselves together will build
unto the Lord God of Israel, as King Cyrus the King of Persia hath com-
manded us.| And Nehemiah, on the same occasion, gave them a still
rougher answer: The God of Heaven he will prosper us, therefore we
his Servants will arise and build : but you have no Portion, nor Right,
nor Memorial in Jerusalem.** This was a tender place: it was touch-
ing upon the very sore, in an express declaration of the Unsociable-
ness complained of, The story therefore, we may be sure, was to be
softened before the Gentiles were to be intrusted with it. Accord-
* Bisnor Hare. + Exod. xvi. t Παθεῖν δ᾽ οὐκ ἀλόγως αὐτοὺς διὰ Thy
ἀνάγκην τοῦτο voulcas.—Antig. Jud. lib. iii. cap. i. § 5. § Ant. Jud. lib. v.
cap. ii. § 8 Π See note M, at the end of this book. q Ezra iv. 3.
** Neh. ii. 20.
VOL. ΤΙ, K K
408 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK V.
ingly, Josephus makes them speak in these obliging terms: That they
could not possibly admit them as partners in the work ; for that the
command to build the Temple was directed to them first by Cyrus, and
now by Darius: That indeed they were at liberty to worship along
with them: and that this was the only Community, in religious mat-
ters, that they could enter into with them, and which they would do
with as many of the rest of Mankind, as were willing to come up to
the Temple to adore the God of Heaven.* The reason the Scripture
Jews give for the refusal of the offer to be joint partners with them
in their work and worship is, that it was a Temple built in the Land
of Israel, and to the honour of the God of Israel. The reason
Josephus’s Jews give for their refusal is obedience to the King of Per-
sia: else, as for community of worship, they were very ready to receive
them.
And now was not that a wise + project which proposed reforming
the sacred Text by the Writings of Josephus ?
But this Explanation will enable us to conclude with certainty
against that spurious passage concerning Curist. I think I have
already offered one demonstrative argument against it.— And I sup-
pose, the many marks of forgery are so glaring, that most men would
be willing to give it up, were Josephus’s silence on so extraordinary
an occasion but easy to be accounted for. Now we have so far laid
open his conduct as to see, that the preaching up of CurisT was an
affair he would studiously decline. His great point, as we observed,
was to reconcile the Gentiles to his countrymen. But the Pagan
aversion was greatly increased by the new Sect.of Christians, sprung,
as was well known, from the Country of Judea. It was therefore
utterly destructive of his purpose to shew, as he must have done, in
giving them an account of Curist, the close connexion between the
two Religions. Of all dangerous subjects, therefore, Josephus would be
careful to avoid this.§ So that (certain as I am of the Writer’s pur-
pose, and not ignorant of the liberty he took with the sacred Records,
when it served his ends, of adding and omitting at pleasure) I should
have been as much surprised to have found the History of Jesus in
his Works as others are to be told that it is not there. This too will
equally well account for his omission of Herod’s slaughter of the Chil-
* Ἔφασαν, τῆς μὲν οἰκοδομίας αὐτοὺς ἀδύνατον εἶναι κοινωνεῖν, αὐτῶν τοροσταχθέντων
κατασκεύασαι τὸν ναὺν, wpdTepoy μὲν ὑπὸ Κύρου, νῦν δὲ ὑπὸ Δαρείου" τοροσκυνεῖν δὲ
αὐτοῖς ἐφιέναι. καὶ τοῦτο μόνον εἶναι κοινὸν, εἰ βούλονται, τυρὸς αὐτοὺς καὶ τσᾶσιν ἀνθρώ-
ποις, ἀφικνουμένοις εἰς τὸ ἱερὸν σέβειν τὸν Oedv.— Vol. i. p. 556. + Mr. Wuis-
TON’S. t See vol. i. § “La plus forte preuve qu’on ait, pour soutenir que
le passage en question, ot il est parlé de Jesus CuRIst, est de Joseph, c'est qu’il n’est
pas croyable, qu’il n’ait rien dit de Jesus Curist. Photius fournit une réponse a ce
raisonnement, en parlant de Juste de Tiberide, qui a ecrit l’Histoire des Juifs en Grec,
et qui vivoit du tems de Joseph, avec qui il a et de grands demelez. Juste de Tiberide,
dit Photius n’a point parlé de Jesus CHRIsT parce qu’il etoit Juif de Nation et de Reli-
gion.” —P. Simon, Bibl. Crit. vol. ii. p. 41.
SECT. IV, OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 499
dren at Bethlehem, which Scaliger so much wondered at; * which
Collins so much triumphed in; + and for the sake of which, our
Whitby seemed ready to give up the truth of the story.t
Thus did this excellent Writer out of extreme love to his Country
(the most pardonable however of all human frailties) make too free
with Truth and Scripture; though most zealously attached to the
Religion of his Forefathers: as those Men generally are who love their
Country best. And a Jew he strictly was, of a very different Stamp
too, from that poor paltry Mimic οὗ the Greek Sophists, Philo.§
Of whom his Master Plato would have said, what Josephus tells us
Aristotle did say, of one of his Jewish Acquaintance, A GREEK HE
WAS, AND NOT IN SPEECH ONLY, BUT IN SOUL LIKEWISE. ||
I judged it of importance to set this matter in a true light:
Because many, I supposed, would think it a fair prejudice against the
Divinity of the Mosaic Religion, had a person so eminent amongst
his Countrymen while the Republic was yet existing, and of so learned
an age; so conversant in the Jewish Records, and so skilled in the
best Grecian Literature ; had such a one afforded only a political or
philosophic Faith to the sacred Volumes. But then it will follow on
the other hand, that the sincere Belief of one, so circumstanced, will
be as fair a prejudice in its favour.
Not that I am over fond of this kind of evidence, in matters where
every one is obliged to judge for himself; and consequently, where
every one, on a due application to the subject, is capable of judging.
Much less would I lay great weight on the opinions of Men out of
their own Profession, however eminent in any other. What is it to
Truth, for instance, what a Courtier judges of a Church ; a Politician
of Conscience; or a Geometer, grown grey in Demonstration, of
moral Evidence? ΤῸ go on:
Miractes, therefore, as they are recorded to be continued
through so large a period of this Republic, I give for one proof that
the Scriptures have represented the Israelites as living under an
extraordinary Providence. I say, as they are recorded to be so con-
tinued : For when miracles are only given at the first propagation of
a Religion (as of the Christian), they are to be no otherwise esteemed
of, than as the Credentials of a new Revelation: These being like the
Cloud which conducted the Israelites in their journeyings in the wil-
derness ; the other like the same Cloud which abode upon the Mercy-
seat: These like the Manna rained down from heaven only for a pre-
* Animad, in Chron. Eusebii. + ‘Scheme of literal Prophecy considered.”
t “Comment. on the New Testament.” § Philo, in his life of Moses, brings in
the Egyptian Priests reasoning on the Platonic principles, concerning the soul that
informed Moses’s body ; which is altogether as well judged, as if a modern Writer of
the Life of Ptolemy the Astronomer should bring him in explaining Sir Isaac Newton’s
Principia. ! Ἑλληνικὸς ἣν, οὐ τῇ διαλέκτῳ μόνον, ἀλλὰ καὶ TH VY X He.
2k 2
500 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK ¥.
sent subsistence; the other like the same Manna preserved uncor-
rupted in the Ark, to be a testimony to future ages.
II. This extraordinary Providence is represented as administered ;
1. Over the State in general. 2. Over private Men in particular.
And such a representation we should expect to find from the nature
of the Republic; because, as an extraordinary Providence over the
STATE necessarily follows God’s being their TUTELARY DEITY; so an
extraordinary Providence to PARTICULARS follows as necessarily from
his being their supPREME MaGisTRATE.*
As to this Providence over the State, it would be absurd to quote
particular texts, when the whole BrsBxe is one continued history of it.
Only it may not be amiss to observe, that from a passage in Ezekiel,
where Gop says, Because that Moab and Seir do say, BEHOLD THE
HOUSE OF JUDAH IS LIKE UNTO ALL THE HEATHEN,T it appears
the Jews had boasted, and the Gentiles, till then, had acknowledged,
that they were under an extraordinary Providence. As this therefore
is so plain, I shall not hazard the obscuring it by many words: but
go on to shew, that Scripture represents this Providence as adminis-
tered likewise to Particulars.
In the Dedication of the first Temple, Sotomon addresses his
Prayer to Gop, that the Covenant between him and the People might
remain for ever firm and inviolate, and the old (economy be still con-
tinued. And after having enumerated divers parts of it, he proceeds
in this manner: ‘‘ When the heaven is shut up, and there is no rain,
because they have sinned against thee ; yet if they pray towards this
Place, and confess thy name, and turn from their sin when thou dost
afflict them ; Then hear thou from heaven, and forgive the sin of thy
Servants and of thy Peopre Isrart, when thou hast taught them
the good way wherein they should walk; and send rain upon the
Land which thou hast given unto thy People for an inheritance. If
there be dearth in the Land, if there be pestilence, if there be blast-
ing or mildew, locusts or caterpillers ; if their enemies besiege them
in the cities of their Land ; whatsoever sore, or whatsoever sickness
there be: Then what prayer, or what supplication shall be made of
any Man, or of all thy Peopie Israrx, when EVERY ONE shall know
his own sore, and his own grief, and shall spread forth his hands in this
house : then hear thou from heaven, and forgive, and RENDER UNTO
EVERY Maw according unto all his ways, whose heart thou know-
est.” { Solomon in this petition, which, with respect to the given Cove-
nant, we might properly call a Petition oF RIGHTS, speaks the lan-
guage of one who extended the temporal sanctions of the Law to
PARTICULARS and INDIVIDUALS. For he desires God, according to
* See note N, at the end of this book. + Ezek. xxv. 8. t 2 Chron. vi. 26
—30. See also note O, at the end of this book.
SECT. IV. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. a01
the terms of the Covenant, to render unto every man according to all
his ways. But when is it that he prays for the exertion of this extra-
ordinary providence to particulars? At the very time when it is
administring to the state in general.—If there be dearth in the land,
if there be pestilence, if there be blasting or mildew, locusts or cater-
pillers, if their enemies besiege them, &c. The necessary consequence
is, that as sure as Solomon believed an extraordinary Providence exer-
cised to the State in general, so surely did he believe it exercised to
individuals in particular. The Psalmist bears his testimony to the
same (Economy: I have been young (says he) and now am old: yet
have I not seen the Righteous forsaken, nor his seed begging their
bread.* God himself declares it, by the Prophet Isaiah: Say ye to
the Righteous that it shall be well with him: for they shall eat the
fruit of their doings. Wo unto the Wicked, it shall be ill with him :
for the reward of his hands shall be given him.t And again: He that
walketh righteously and speaketh uprightly, &c. he shall dwell on high :
his place of defence shall be the munitions of rocks, bread shall be given
him, his waters shall be sure.t And we learn, from a parabolical
command in Ezekiel, how exactly these promises were fulfilled : “ And
the Lord said unto him, Go through the midst of the city, through
the midst of Jerusalem, and set a mark upon the foreheads of the
men that sigh, and that cry for all the abominations that be done in
the midst thereof. And to others he said in mine hearing, Go ye
after him through the city, and smite: let not your eye spare, nei-
ther have ye pity. Slay utterly old and young, both maids and little
children, and women ; det come not near any man upon whom is the
mark ; and begin at my Sanctuary,” &c.§ The same Prophet in
another place, alluding to Abraham’s intercession for Sodom, declares
from God, that when his judgments come out against the land of
Judea, the Righteous, found in it, should save only themselves ;
which plainly shews a providence extending to particulars—‘ Son of
man, when the Jand sinneth against me by trespassing grievously,
then will I stretch out mine hand upon it, and will break the staff of
the bread thereof, and will send famine upon it, and will cut off man
and beast from it. Though these three men, Noah, Daniel, and Job,
were in it, they should deliver but their own souls by their righteous-
ness, saith the Lord God.” Ch. xiv. 13, 14. But Gop, by the Pro-
phet Amos, describes this administration of Providence in the fullest
manner: “Also I have withholden the rain from you, when there were
yet three months to the harvest ; and I caused it to rain upon one
city, and caused it not to rain upon another city: one piece was
rained upon, and the piece whereupon it rained not, withered. So
two or three cities wandered unto one city to drink water; but they
* Psalm xxxvii. 25. See also note P, at the end of this book. + Isai. iii. 10, 11.
{ Isai. xxxiii. 15, 16. § Ezek. ix. 4—6. See also note Q, at the end of this book,
502 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK V.
were not satisfied: yet have ye not returned unto me, saith the Lord.
I have smitten you with blasting and mildew,” &c.* And again:
Lo, I will command, and I will sift the house of Israel amongst all
Nations, like as corn is sifted in a sieve, yet shall not the least grain
fall upon the earth.
These declarations of God’s providence are so exactly correspondent
to Solomon’s petition ; that they seem as it were the Friar to it.
Thus we see the Law, as well by its express declarations as by its
essential nature and genius, extended its sanctions of temporal rewards
and punishments as well to Particulars as to the General. And as in
civil Government, universal practice shews the necessity of a more exact
dispensation of punishment than of reward, so we may observe from
the passages last quoted, that the Mosaic Law had the same atten-
tion; which occasioned the Wise Man to say, Behold the Righteous
shall be recompensed in the Earth: MucH MORE the Wicked and the
Sinner.§
The inspired writers of the New Trstamenr give evidence to this
dispensation of Providence under the Otp. The Author of the Epistle
to the Hebrews argues from it as a thing well known and generally
allowed: For if the Word spoken by Angels was stedfast, and EVERY
TRANSGRESSION AND DISOBEDIENCE RECEIVED A JUST RECOM-
PENCE OF REWARD, how shall we escape if we neglect so great
salvation ? ||
’ St. Paul, in his Epistle to the Romans, speaking of the advantages
which Christianity had over Judaism, says: Therefore being justified
by faith, we have peace with God through our Lord Jesus Christ. By
whom also we have access by Faith into his Grace, wherein we stand,
and rejoice in hope of the glory of God. And not only so, but ΜῈ
GLORY IN TRIBULATION ALSO, knowing that Tribulation worketh pa-
tience, §c.4 Here St. Paul, opposing the advantages which the Gen-
tile Converts had by Farrn, to those which the Jews, in contempt to
the Gentiles, gloried to have by the Law, adds, in order to shew those
advantages in their highest superiority, that the Christian Gentiles
could glory even in that which was the very opprobrium of the Jews,
namely, ¢ribulation. For the sanction of the Jewish Law being tem-
poral rewards and punishments, administered by an equal providence ;
Tribulation was a punishment for crimes, and, consequently, an high
opprobrium.** But the followers of Christ, who were taught, that we
must through much TRIBULATION enter into the kingdom of God,++ had
the same reason to glory in the roughness of the road, as the ancient
Agonistz had in the toils which procured them the victory. This is
urged with great address. But the Critics, not taking the Apostle’s
* Amos iv. 7—11. + Amos ix. 9. 1 See note R, at the end of this book.
§ Prov. xi. 3]. \| Heb. ii. 2, 3. 7 Rom vy, 1, et seq. ** See note 8,
at the end of this book. ++ Acts xiv. 22.
SECT. ἃν. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 503
meaning, have supposed, in their usual way, that he here broke in upon
his argument, with an idea foreign to the point in hand.
This will help us to explain an odd remark of the excellent Maimo-
nides : That their wise men talked of a thing which was NOT TO BE
FOUND in the Law, namely, that which some of them call the Cuas-
TISEMENTS OF Love, by which they meant that TRIBULATIONS might
befall a man without any precedent sin,* and only in order to multiply
his reward. And that this was the very opinion of the Sect called
Muatzal, of which, or in favour of which opinion, there is not one single
word to be found in the Law.+ This seems to have perplexed our
Rabbi; and with cause. He lived when his countrymen were under a
common providence, and had the doctrine of a future state of rewards
and punishments, which, he took for granted, was always in the Jew-
ish Cconomy. These things disabled him from seeing that—Nno
CHASTISEMENTS OF Love was a necessary consequence of temporal
rewards and punishments administered by an equal providence: And
likewise that when this sanction ceased, and a future state was known,
then CHASTISEMENTS OF LOVE became a necessary consequence.
But if by the Law, Maimonides did (as the Jews frequently do)
include the writings of the Prophets, then he was very much mistaken
in saying there is not one word in it concerning the chastisements
of love. For Zechariah, prophesying of a New Dispensation, describes
this sort of chastisements in very express terms: ‘And I will bring
the third part through the fire, and will refine them as silver is refined,
and will try them as gold is tried: and they shall call on my name,
and I will hear them.” So admirably do all the parts of God’s grand
(Economy support one another.
We have seen what testimonies their coeval writers afford of an
extraordinary Providence. But we must not suppose the Jews always
held the same language. The difference is great between the early
and later Jews, even during the existence of the Republic. Take an
instance from the Psalmist, and the writer of Ecclesiasticus. The
former says, I have been young, and now am old, yet have I not seen
the Righteous forsaken, nor his Seed begging their bread.t The latter
—Took at the GENERATIONS OF OLD, and see; Did ever any trust
in the Lord and was confounded? Or did any abide in his Fear and
was forsaken? Or whom did he ever despise that called upon him? §
* This explanation was necessary; for, another kind of chastisements of Love there
was in the Law, namely, paternal chastisements. Thus Moses: Thou shalt also con-
sider in thine heart, that as a man chasteneth his son, so the Lord thy God chasteneth
thee. (Deut. viii. 5.) + ** Unum tamen occurrit in verbis sapientum nostrorum,
quod NON INVENITUR IN LEGE; id nempe, quod quidam eorum dicunt CASTIGATIONES
AMORIS. Juxta hance enim sententiam possunt TRIBULATIONES alicui evenire sine
precedente peccato, sed ut multiplicetur ejus Remuneratio. Atque hee ipsissima est
sententia Sectz Muatzali, de qua, aut pro qua, ne verbulum quidem in Lege reperitur.”
—More Nevoch. Buxtorfii, p. 381. 1 Psalm xxxvii. 20, § Eeclus. ii. 10, &e.
504 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK V.
The Psalmist, living under an extraordinary Providence, appeals to his
own times ; the Author of Ecclesiasticus living when it was long ceased,
appeals to former times. But as we have been told, that this talk of
# particular Providence is only an Eastern Hyperbole, im which every
thing is ascribed to God, I think it not improper to take notice here
of one singular circumstance in favour of the Reporters.
We may observe, then, that the spirit of Gentilism was always
uniform; and, throughout its whole duration, had ever the same
unvaried pretensions to divine Intercourse, supported by the same
sort of Oracles and Divinations. But amongst the Jews matters were
on another footing. After their perfect settlement, on their return
from Captivity (when we know, from the course and progress of God’s
(Economy, that the extraordinary Providence was to cease), we hear
no more of their pretences to it, though they now adhered more strictly
than ever to the Religion of their forefathers. They made no claim,
as we see by the excellent Writer of the first Book of Maccabees, either
to Prophets, Oracles, or extraordinary Dispensations. When they
write unto the Lacedemonians, for the renewal of their Alliance, they
tell them, at the same time, that they need it not, FOR THAT THEY
HAVE THE HOLY Books or Scripture IN THEIR Hanps TO
COMFORT THEM.* Language very different from their forefathers’,
when God was wont to send immediate help from the Sanctuary.
How ingenuously does the same Historian relate the misfortune of
Bethsura, caused by the observance of the Sabbatic Year?+ A misfor-
tune of which we have no instance before the Captivity ; and therefore
a plain evidence that the extraordinary Providence was indeed with-
drawn. Besides, if we consider the nature of the Religion, the genius
of the People, and the circumstances of the Time, we shall find, they
all concurred to favour the continuance of a pretension to an extraor-
dinary Providence, had it been only a pretension.
1. The Mosaic Religion, like the Pagan, had a public part, and
therefore the Jews might, with the greatest ease, have still carried on
the Superstition of Oracles, had their Oracles been indeed a superstition ;
especially as they were now become so closely attached to their Religion.
For when did ever Greece or Italy confess that their Oracles were
become dumé, till the Consulters had generally forsaken them, and the
whole frame of their Religion was falling to pieces? Besides, the
practice of this superstition had been as easy as it was commodious;
for the Oracular Voice was wont to come from the Mercy-Seat behind
the Veil.
2. The genius of the People too would have contributed to the conti-
nuance of this claim. For, some how or other, it was become their char-
acter to require a Sign;t and though, now, really superstitious, yet the
* 1 Macc. xii. 9. t+ 1 Mace. vi. 49. t.1 Cor, i, 22.
SECT. IV. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 505
humour spent itself rather in telling lyes of former times,* than in
inventing any of their own. ‘This, on a supposition of the human
invention of their Law, is altogether unaccountable. But take the
matter as we find it in their sacred Books, and no thing is more easy.
For if they had indeed been long accustomed to a miraculous Dispen-
sation, they would, ever after, be strongly disposed fo require a Sign ;
but it would be only such a Sign as bore the evident marks of a
Divinity ; which not being to be had in human inventions, they would
be kept safe from delusions, and made sensible of the difference of
times : And such was, in fact, their case.
3. Add to all this, that the time of the Maccabees was the season of
Enthusiasm, when that airy Spirit is at its height ; after the national
Genius, long sunk by oppression, begins to rise and recover itself to a
vindication of public Liberty. And of this we have a signal instance
in the person of Judas Maccabeus himself; who, in ,imitation of
Gideon, would set upon an army of twenty thousand foot and two
thousand horse, with only eight hundred straggling desperadoes ;
which rash and fanatic attempt was followed with the fortune that
might, at this time, have been expected.t—In such a season too, artful
Leaders are most disposed to support themselves by inspirations ; have
‘most need of them; and are thought, by the People, most worthy to
receive them.
There is the same difference between the Writers of the New Testa-
ment and of the Old, as between the Writers of the several ages of the
Old. The Apostles (who worked Miracles as well as Moses and the
Prophets) represent the followers of Curist as under the same common
Providence with the rest of mankind: Unlike in this, to the first propa-
gators of the Law, who always declared the Israelites to be under an
extraordinary Providence.
From all this I conclude, that as amidst the concurrence of so many
favourable circumstances, no such claim was made ; but that, contrary
» to the universal practice of all false Religions, the Jews saw and owned
a great change in the Divine (Economy, that therefore their former
pretensions to the peculiar protection of Heaven were TRUE.
But it hath been objected, that the early sacred Writers themselves
frequently speak of the inequality of Providence to Particulars :{ and
in such a manner as Men living under a common Providence are accus-
tomed to speak. It is very true that these Writers do now and then
give intimations of this inequality. And therefore, though we shall
hereafter prove an extraordinary Providence to have been actually
. * See note T, at the end of this book. + 1 Mace. ix. 6. 1 “ Asaph de Dei
providentia dubitavit, et fere a vera via deflexisset—Salomon etiam, cujus tempore res
Judzorum in summo vigore erant, suspicatur omnia casu contingere—Denique omnibus
fere prophetis hoc ipsum valde obscurum fuit, nempe, quomodo ordo nature et hominum
eventus cum conceptu quem de providentia Dei formaverant, possent convenire.”—
Spinoz® Theologico- Pol. pp. 73, 74.
506 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK V.
administered, in which, not only this objection will be seen to drop
of itself, but the particular passages, on which it is founded, will be
distinctly considered ; yet, for the Reader’s satisfaction, it may not be
amiss to shew here, that these representations of inequality are very
consistent with that before given of the extraordinary Providence, We
say, therefore,
I. That when the Sacred Writers speak of the inequalities of Provi-
dence, and the unfit distribution of things, they often mean that state
of it amongst their Pagan neighbours, and not in Judea: As particu-
larly in the Book of Psalms and Ecclesiastes.* P
II. We sometimes find Men complaining of inequalities in events,
which were indeed the effects of a most equal Providence. Such as
the punishment of Posterity for the crimes of their Forefathers ; and
of Subjects for their Kings. Of the first, the Prophet Ezekiel gives
us an instance in the People’s case: What mean ye, that you use this
Proverb concerning the Land of Israel, saying, The Fathers have eaten
sour grapes, and the Children’s teeth are set on edge? +—Of the
second, David gives it in his own; not duly attending to the justice
of this proceeding, where he says, But these Sheep, what have they
done? t And that he was sometimes too hasty in judging of these
matters appears from his own confession: Behold, these are the
ungodly, who prosper in the world, they increase in riches.—When I
thought to know this, it was too painful for me : until I went into the
Sanctuary of God ; then understood I their end. Surely thou didst
set them in slippery places : thou castedst them down into destruction.
—So foolish was I, and ignorant: I was as a beast before thee.§
That is, I understood not the course of thy justice, till I had con-
sidered the way in which an equal Providence must necessarily be
administered under a Theocracy, and the consequences of such an
Administration. For,
III. Even admitting the reality of an equal Providence to Particu-
lars in the Hebrew State, the administration of it must needs be
attended with such circumstances as sometimes to occasion those
observations of inequality. For 1. it appears from the reason of the
thing, that this administration did not begin to be exerted in particu-
lar cases till the civil Laws of the Republic had failed of their effi-
cacy. ‘Thus where any crime, as for instance disobedience to Parents,
was public, it became the object of the civil Tribunal, and is accord-
ingly ordered to be punished by the Judge.|| But when private and
secret, then it became the object of Divine vengeance.4{ Now the
consequence of this was, that when the Laws were remissly or cor-
ruptly administered, good and ἐϊΐ would sometimes happen unequally
* See Appendix. + Ezek. xviii. 2. t 2 Sam. xxiv. 17. § Psalm
xxiii. 12 —22. \| Exod. xxi. 15, 17. 4. Deut. xxvii. 16; Prov. xxx. 17.
SECT. Iv. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 507
tomen. For we are not to suppose that Providence, in this case,
generally, interfered till the corrupt administration itself, when ripe
for vengeance, had been first punished. 2. In this extraordinary
administration, one part of the wicked was sometimes suffered as a
scourge to the other. 3. The extraordinary Providence to the State
might sometimes clash with that to Particulars, as in the plague for
numbering the people. 4. Sometimes the extraordinary Providence
was suspended for a season, to bring on a national repentance: But
at the same time this suspension was publicly denounced.* And a
very severe punishment it was, as leaving a State which had not the
sanction of a future state of rewards and punishments in a very dis-
consolate condition. And this was what occasioned the complaints
of the impatient Jews, after they had been so long accustomed to an
extraordinary administration.+
IV. But the general and full solution of the difficulty is this, The
common cause of these complaints arose from the GRADUAL WITH-
DRAWING the extraordinary Providence. Under the Judges it was
perfectly equal. And during that period of the Theocracy, it is
remarkable that we hear of no complaints. When the people had
rebelliously demanded a king, and their folly was so far complied
with, that God suffered the Theocracy to be administered by a Vice-
roy, there was then, as was fitting, a great abatement in the vigour of
this extraordinary Providence; partly in natural consequence, God
being now farther removed from the immediate administration ; and
partly in punishment of their rebellion. And soon after this it is
that we first find them beginning to make their observations and
complaints of inequality. From hence to the time of the Captivity,
the extraordinary Providence kept gradually decaying, till on their
full re-establishment, it intirely ceased.t For what great reasons,
besides punishment for their crimes ; and what consequences it had
on the religious sentiments of the People, will be occasionally
explained as we go along.
But now, let it be observed, that though I have here accounted for
the appearances of an unequal Providence, yet this is ew abundanti ;
the very nature of my general argument evincing, that there must
needs have been an equal Providence actually administered: for a
People in society, without both a future State and an equal Provi-
dence, could have no belief in the moral government of God: And
under such circumstances, it hath been shewn, that they could not
long subsist, but must fall back again into all the confusion of a
savage state. We must conclude therefore, that what appearances
soever there may be of inequality in the administration of Providence,
* Tsar. 11. δ: ix.) 2/5, Ixiv. 7: + Isai. v. 19; Jer. xvii. 15; Amos v. 18;
Zeph. i. 12; Mal. ii. 17. 1 See note U, at the end of thiz book.
508 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK V.
in the early times of the Jewish Theocracy, they are but appear-
ances: that is, nothing which can really affect such a mode of admi-
nistration.* The Adversaries therefore of the Divine Legation, such of
them, I mean, who profess themselves Believers, should consider that,
while they oppose the reality of an extraordinary Providence over the
Jewish people, they are weakening the evidence for the miracles
recorded in the Old Testament. But this is the least of their care.
One of them, with an assurance that hath something in it of a pro-
digy, affirms, ‘‘ that the Providence administered under the Law was
exactly the same kind with that administered under the Gospel.” +
How this could be the case without impeaching the veracity of God
himself, as not making good his repeated engagements, this man
would do well to consider before he becomes the scorn and contempt
of Unbelievers. But as such sort of men bear worse the disgrace of
folly than impiety, I shall consider this Portent on its ridiculous side
only.
Temporal rewards and punishments administered by the hand of
God, followed, as a consequence, from the Jewish Government’s being
Theocratical ; and an extraordinary Providence followed, as a conse-
quence, from the dispensation of temporal rewards and punishments.
Yet here we have a Regius Professor of Divinity affirming, That both
temporal Sanctions and an extraordinary Providence are administered
under the Gospel in the very same manner they formerly were under
the Law. In which it is difficult to determine what most to admire ;
his modesty or his wit. For if it does honour to his wit to maintain
conclusions destitute of their premisses, it as strongly recommends
his modesty to contradict the whole tenour of the New Testament.
But there is neither end nor measure to party-bigotry. Faustus, the
Manichean, contended that the Jews and Christians got the doctrine
of the one only God from the Gentiles. Is this a wilder fancy than
what many modern Divines have asserted, that the Gentiles got the
doctrine of future rewards and punishment from the Law of Moses?
Or are either of these more extravagant than the folly I am going to
expose, namely, That the temporal sanctions of the Law are transferred
into the GospeL? Now, if you should ask whether the Gospel
claimed to be a Theocracy ; I suppose at first, they would say zo ;
till they found the advantage you get over them by this answer.
And then I make no doubt, they would as readily say, yes. For
what should hinder them? Does the Gospel disclaim, in stronger
terms, its being a rEmMporRAL Kinepom, when Christ says, his hing-
dom was not of this world, than it disclaims TEMPORAL SANCTIONS,
when it says, Yea, and all that will live godly in Jesus Christ shall
suffer persecution,t or than it disclaims an extraordinary providence
* See note X, at the end of this book. + Dr. RuTHERFORTH. 12 Tim. iii. 12.
SECT. Iv. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 509
where it declares that the Jews had the promise of the life that now
is, and the Christians of that which is to come ? *
But not to stretch our conjectures to the lengths these men are dis-
posed to go; let us consider how far they have already gone. They
say the temporal sanctions of the Law are transferred into the Gospel :
and they prove it by these two notable texts.
The first is of St. Paux, ‘ Children, obey your parents in all things :
for this is right. Honour thy Father and thy Mother (which is the
first commandment with promise) that it may be well with thee, and
thou mayest live long on the earth.” + All that I here find ¢rans-
Jerred, from the Law to the Gospel, are the words of the fifth Com-
mandment. For the Apostle having said, Children, obey your parents
in the Lord: for this is right ; he supports his exhortation by a quo-
tation from the Decalogue ; just as any modern preacher, but This,
_ would do, without ever dreaming of temporal sanctions in the Gospel ;
the observation the Apostle makes upon it being in these words—
which is the first commandment with promise ; as much as to say,
«You may see, from this circumstance, how very acceptable the per-
formance of this duty is, to God:” The only inference which com-
mon sense authorises us to draw from it being what, in another place,
he thus expresses,—Godliness [or the observance of God’s commands]
is profitable unto all things, having the promise of the life that now is
[under the Law] and of that which is to come [under the GosPEL].
The other colour for this clandestine transfer of temporal sanctions,
is from St. Perer: ‘Who is he that will harm you, if you be
followers of that which is good?” { So says the Apostle ; and so
too said his Master ; to whose words Peter alludes, Fear» not them
which kill the body : but rather fear him which is able to destroy body
and soul in hell.§ But as if the Apostle had it in his thoughts to
guard against this absurd vision of temporal sanctions, he immediately
subjoins,—‘“ But, and if ye sufier for righteousness sake, happy
are ye.”
Our Doctor having so well made out this point, we need not won-
der at his confidence, when he assures us, that there is full as good
evidence of an extraordinary providence under the Christian Dispensa-
tion as under the Jewish. This though the language of Toland, Tin-
dal, Collins, and the whole tribe of Free-thinkers, yet comes so unex-
pected from a Regius Professor of Divinity, that we should be very
careful not to mistake his meaning.
If, by full as good, he would insinuate that an extraordinary pro-
vidence was administered under both Dispensations, I shall be in pain for
his intellects: if he would insinuate, that an extraordinary providence
was administered in neither, I shall be in pain for his Professorship.
* 1 Tim. iv. 8. ¢ Eph, vi. 2, 3. t 1 Peter iii. 13. § Matt. x. 28.
510 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK V.
But he is in pain for nothing; as the reader may perceive by his
manner of supporting this impertinent paradox. His proofs follow
with equal ease and force.—I say unto you, that if two of you shall
agree on earth, as touching any thing that they shall ask, it shall be
done for them of my Father which is in Heaven.*—And every one
that hath forsaken houses, or brethren, or sisters, or father, or mother,
or wife, or children, or lands, for my name’s sake, shall receive an
hundredfold, and shall inherit everlasting life-+—Take therefore no
thought saying, What shall we eat? or what shall we drink? or’
wherewithal shall we be cloathed ? for your heavenly Father knoweth
that you have need of all these things. But seek ye first the Kingdom
of God and his righteousness, and all these things shall be added unto
you.t And again, If ye ask any thing in my name, I will give it.§
—‘*No more, my most wise Friend! Thou hast my wonder ; that’s
enough. My understanding shall come after; ” said, once on a time,
a plain good man to a profound philosopher like this.
Now not to repeat again the illogical bravado of taking and sup-
porting a conclusion divorced from its premisses ; such as is the con-
tending for temporal sanctions and an extraordinary providence where
there was no Theocracy, from whence they could be derived ; we
have here a Professor of Divinity who has his elements of Scripture-
interpretation yet to learn. The first rule of which is, 1. “That all
does not signify all simply, but all of one kind; and, of what kind,
the context must direct us to determine.’ When therefore, the
members of Christ’s spiritual Kingdom are promised they shall obtain
all they ask, this al/ must needs be confined to things spiritual. Now
when here we find those, who are bid to leave their temporal posses-
sions and propagate the Gospel, have the promise of a hundredfold,
are we to seek for the performance, in Palestine, or in a better Coun-
try? || Again, Where under the Law, we read of temporal Promises,
we read likewise that they were fulfilled. Where, under the GosPEt,
we read that those who, for the sake of Christ, forsake houses, or
brethren, or sisters, or father or mother, or wife or children, or lands,
shall receive an hundredfold ; What are we there to look for? For
the good things of this world, which this sharp-sighted Doctor is so
eager and intent to find ?—Now admit there might be no great incon-
venience in receiving a hundred houses for one; would not a hundred
wives a little embarras his Professorship? And as to the house and
land—Where did he learn that this was literally fulfilled, even to
those who had the best title to them if they were literally promised, I
mean the ArostLEs, yet these we always meet on foot ; strangers
upon earth ; and without either house or home. He, who then passed
“ Matt. xviii. 19. t+ Matt. xix. 29. t Matt. vi. 31, et seq. § John
xiv. 14. || Heb. xi. 16,
SECT. Iv. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. ἘΠῚ
for ἃ learned Apostle, once at Rome, indeed, got a warm house over
his head ; yet let us not forget that it was but a Aired one. Here,
in this Capital of the World, he received all who came to him. But
_ though a good Divine, as times then went, he never rose to a Regius
Professorship.
2. The second elementary rule of interpretation is, “ That all the pro-
mises of extraordinary blessings, made to the first propagators of the
Gospel, are not to be understood as extending to their successors of
all Ages, or to the Church in general.” ΤῸ apply this likewise to the
thing in question. If it should be admitted that great temporal bless-
ings were promised to the first disciples of Christ, it will not follow
that their successors had a claim to them, any more than they had to
their spiritual gifts and graces, such as the power of working miracles,
prophesying, speaking with tongues, &c. Because as divine Wisdom
saw these latter to be necessary for the discharge of their peculiar
function ; so divine Goodness might be graciously pleased to bestow the
Other on them, as the reward of their abundant Faith, and superior
Courage in the day of trial, when the Powers of this world were bent
on their destruction. But this (blessed be God) is neither the learned
Professor’s case, nor mine. The worst that has befallen me in the
defence of Religion, is only the railings of the Vile and Impotent :
and the worst that is likely to befal him is only the ridicule of all the
rest. Happy had it been for himself and much happier for his
hearers, had our Professor’s modesty disposed him rather to seek
instruction from those who have gone before, than to impart it to
those who are to come after. Hooker has so admirably exposed this
very specific folly which our Doctor has run into, of arguing against
his senses, in making the Dispensation of Providence under the Mosaic
and Christian GAconomies to be the same, that I cannot do him better
service than to transcribe the words of that divine ornament of the
English Priesthood.—*“ Shall we then hereupon ARGUE EVEN AGAINST
OUR OWN EXPERIENCE AND KNOWLEDGE? Shall we seek to per-
suade men that, of necessity, it is with us as it was with them, that
because God is ours, in all respects as much as theirs, therefore, either
no such way of direction hath been at any time, or if it have been, it
doth still continue in the Church? or if the same do not continue,
that yet it must be, at the least, supplied by some such means as
pleaseth us to account of equal force? A more dutiful and religious
way for us, were to admire the Wisdom of God which shineth in the
beautiful variety of things, but most in the manifold and yet harmo-
nious dissimilitude of those ways, whereby his Church upon earth is
guided from age to age throughout all the generations of men.” *
But this was one of the charitable expedients employed to set me
* “ Keclesiastical Polity,” book. iii. sect. 10.
512 THE DIVINE LEGATION BOOK V.
right, and to prevent the disgrace of scribling much to no purpose.
However, as in a work of this nature, which partakes so much of the
History of the human mind, I may be allowed occasionally, and as it
falls in my way, to give as well, examples of its more uncommon
degrees of depravity and folly, as of its improvements and excellencies,
I shall go on. My constant friend Dr. Stebbing proceeds another
way to work, but all for the same good end. He desires me and my
reader to consider, ‘‘ what it was that Moses undertook ; and what
was the true end of his Mission. It was to carry the children of
Israel out of Egypt, and put them in possession of the Land of
Canaan, in execution of the Covenant made with Abraham. The work
in the very NATURE of it required the administration of an extraor-
dinary Providence; of which it OUGHT THEREFORE TO BE PRE-
SUMED that Moses had both the assurance and experience : otherwise
he would have engaged in a very MAD undertaking, and the people
would have been as map in following him. THis SHORT HINT
POINTS OUT THE TRUE INTERNAL EVIDENCE οὗ Moses’s Divine
Legation, and this evidence has no sort of dependence upon the belief
or disbelief of the doctrine of a future state. For supposing (what
is the truth) that the Israelites did believe it; what could this belief
effect? It might carry them to Heaven, and would do so if they
made a proper use of it, but it could not put them in possession of
the Land of Canaan. Mr. Warburton therefore has plainly mistaken
his point.”
This intimation of my mistake is kind: and I should have taken
his Aint, as short as it is, but for the following reasons :
1. This Aint would serve the Mufti full as well, to prove the Divine
Legation af Mahomet : for thus we may suppose he would argue :-—
““ Mahomet’s work was not like Moses’s, the subdual of a small tract
of Country, possessed by seven Tribes or Nations, with a force of
some hundred thousand followers; but the conquest of almost all
Asia, with a handful of Banditti. Now this work, says the learned
Mahometan, in the very nature of it, required the administration of an
extraordinary providence, of which ττ OUGHT THEREFORE TO BE
PRESUMED, that Mahomet had both the assurance and experience ;
otherwise he would have engaged in a very mad undertaking, and the
people would have been as mad in following him.”
Thus hath the learned Doctor taught the Mufti how to reason.
The worst of it is, that I, for whom the kindness was principally
intended, cannot profit by it, the argument lying exposed to so terrible
a retortion. To this the Doctor replies, that the cases are widely
different : and that T myself allow them to be different, for that I
hold, the Legation of Moses to be a true one; and the Legation of
Mahomet, an imposture.—‘* Risum teneatis, Amici!”
SECT. Iv. OF MOSES DEMONSTRATED. 513
But there is another reason why I can make nothing of this
gracious hint. It is because I proposed to prove (and not, as he
says I ought to have done, TO PRESUME upon) the Divinity of Moses’s
mission, by an internal argument. Indeed he tells me, that if I be
for proving, he has pointed out such a one to me. He says so, ’tis
true : but in so saying, he only shews his ignorance of what is meant
by an INTERNAL ARGUMENT. An internal argument is such a one
as takes for its medium some notorious Fact, or circumstance, in the
frame and constitution of a Religion, not in contest ; and from thence,
by necessary consequence, deduces the truth of a fact supported by
testimony which is in contest. Thus, from the notorious Fact of the
omission of a future State in Moses’s institution of Law and Religion,
I deduce his Divine Legation.
But the learned Artist himself seems conscious that the ware he
would put into my hands is indeed no better than a counterfeit piece
of trumpery; and so far from being an infernal argument, that it is
no argument at all: For he tells us, Ir OUGHT THEREFORE TO BE
PRESUMED, that Moses had both the assurance and experience that
God governed the Israelites by an extraordinary Providence.
But what follows is such unaccountable jargon !—For supposing the
Israelites did believe a future State, what would this belief effect ? It
might carry them to Heaven, but it could not put them in possession of
the land of Canaan. This looks as if the learned Doctor had sup-
posed that, from the truth of this assertion, That no civil Society
under a common Providence could subsist without a future state, 1 had
inferred, that, with a future state, Society would be able to work
wonders.—What efficacy a future state hath, whether little or much,
affects not my argument any otherwise than by the oblique tendency
it hath to support the reasoning: and I urged it thus ;—‘‘ Had not
the Jews been under an extraordinary Providence, at that period when
Moses led them out to take possession of the land of Canaan, they
were most unfit to bear the want of the doctrine of a future state :”
Which observation I supported by the case of Odin’s followers, and
Mahomet’s ; who, in the same circumstances of making conquests,
and seeking new habitations, had this Doctrine sedulously inculeated
to them, by their respective Leaders. And the histories of both these
Nations inform us, that nothing so much contributed to the rapidity
of their successes as the enthusiasm which that Doctrine inspired.
And yet, to be sure, the Doctor never said a livelier’ thing, who is
celebrated for saying many, than when he asked,—What could this
belief effect? It might carry them to Heaven; but it could not put
them in possession of the Land of Canaan. Now unlucekily, like most
of these witty things, when too nearly inspected, we find it to be just
the reverse of the truth. .The J6elief could never carry them to
VOL. 11. ΤΙ Ὑὶ
ἡ
514 DIVINE LEGATION OF MOSES. BOOK V.
Heaven, and yet was abundantly sufficient, under such a Jeader as
Moses, to put them in possession of the land of Canaan. The Ara-
bians’ belief of a future state could never, in the opinion at least of
our orthodox Doctor, carry them to Heaven; yet he must allow it
enabled them to take and keep possession of a great part of Europe
and Asia. But the Doctor’s head was running on the efficacy of the
Christian Faith, when he talked of belief carrying men to heaven.—
Yet who knows, but when he gave the early Jews the knowledge of
a future state, he gave them the Christian faith imto the bargain ?
END OF VOL. 11.
- PRINTED BY JAMES NICHULS, HOXTON-SQUARE,
νγ΄
DATE DUE
i
-
Angin
aT τ
“δι
ee
al
»
an
PRINTED INU S.A
GAYLORO
esti
STAT Peer br Pema)
Sef
+ ig
ty τς
< £4 sas
Shs} kk
SPEER py CE
ες,{,4 » ote
ἐκ εὐ τὸς te
ΣΡ CX
Sef SSE LEE eS
66656829)
nea
φρο een
eA
rye
AAA
senna
RAKE
x
<f
τ(ξ «{ς
. ae
tage ie
RX.
CREASE,
WA,
AES
(
ie Satake
(Se ΨΨΦΏΤΗ
43 <8
Sore:
sche
.
«(
ears
Pb RE ier
et Ak
4 Sahat.
AER ty
ΟΝ
S485:
ΣΤῚΣ
ἀν
αὖ
ti
aoe
SEARS,
CX
ever!
t
ee irs
NS
Cay
Lyrae Sax
ote
ᾧ
ἀν τος
Pu cespure wears
ah “a
Bow aw ere
rar
Vee kan RK
τ Or τ
re
Se
ΓΝ
τ ον Ὁ
"α :
ΟΝ,